Critical Cyberculture Studies
David Silver and Adrienne Massanariaye ty
‘egiocene
Utne ono Clg in Ptaton De
onitgaaincati
scaatanaantenna
suerte
=cae
Reasicciaatie,
* anand aan han S pe
Somatiga caer
peaciter se
sitting eho gs Ses
Contents
rear: Dees of Fs: PsibleDajectoriesof
Inver Sie
‘See fns
tioducton: Wher nternet Satie!
Dani Se
Fisding the Field
‘Te Historiography of Cybereare
Toth Sere
Clara Dilfeence, Theo and joe Stes
‘Ais of Maal Reelin
‘a Nake
Howe We Hasame Posi From Cysts to
Game Studies
‘po ara
Intent Sti in Ties of Teor
Dav Sir nd Ae Marc
Catching the Wer: Coesiderng Cyeraltue,
‘eehnoealte and Hecwonic Consumption
Wendy bon
Cybersture Stain An Aaisciinay
Approach veson 3.0),
Maken rk
8
o36 Lan eaeamene
he Food Bad Wing Cont, 19 arable a Mpnerclonb
Tnktwe in,
2 This qutaion i fm the ahold venom of Mic Kin "The
cpsenpace Dac n The Dal Dayo Pe Lonel Cab,
MMT Res opi
2. Lar hargag fe pith Cee ae somone ele wot «singe
author bok on te bjt fee and pers hl hve the
"Tiguan fo tested veo of Cameron Daley Vi
tal Sas Areatng Race in erp Ret Digi Care 9 i
“end london: Bl 2),
Bi Camm, 30, "Vial Ski: rilting Re in beripa"n Reding
Dial Cal eld by Dei endo Londor ace
le Steve "Who Bd Wig” Php ant etre 083 04-80.
‘Gli Pcl zoe. Aa Bare apg Pie! Cle Bnd te Ct Line
(kei A Belinp Perf Ver Unery Fe
Sonal, eer soo "The Append Subject Bac aod ity Digi
“use in Rae in Cepce eed ys Nant, ah Kalo
{Giana 7-5 New ere Roeder.
Hein, Mie! gn “The eps Die a The Dili ea
"yer Leen, ge amiga BT Bes.
Sons Steve wah Goer 2: Rtg Compr edited Cmmanton
(nt Conmay Patna CA Se
Phlnuply al Larne sexe to At he Was te Fourth Bed
‘Wing Conte 8 opt frisle thnk cai!
echin
Sv Dati 0. "Looking Hahvads. Looking Foran Cercle Sad
‘E 90-s00 In Shales Renting Maia Sas fore Di A
died by Dv Gaunt, so ond Al
‘hows Neal wa 998. Penpais, Gapisand Drms Towed eid
‘Thy of hes dhe Sie fn OU Clandon P
‘ed, Dri te. Rdg Dial Cur London: Make
"Wallan Burry and aoe ayaa Sse There Epa
fe Say Ma Bel
Chapters
How We Became Postdigital
From CyberStudies to Game Studies
Espen Aarseth
In the yn of his wing, 005 the number of trasore print on ll
on chips wl ave exceed the numberof characters piste on per
‘orldide By now, al of our public and personal medi have become
ror ores digital The eng of exitereat and wonder about al things
Cyber tt characterized the spo hms been replaeed by faaiarity and
Usuesas-osd. Hall, Wed newspapers hare started to make rater
than oe money wile paper based wepupers ae Riding i hard oe
ult ne ears fom the younger enero (Berthses 203) To he
Calta esac, he once mpi sod exote burl (ermember
‘Mondo 200) bat been sabsamed by mnntea clare, an eer
‘couse Binal ready tobe integrated it the teadtoal research di
Courses, We canallge home rae
But even if eyecare ial ove (andall ove the place, some aes
sve emerged that anno be soared by tration estore of sade
(One such ld the clue gene of digi gaming. Not gute et, not
quite len’ culture not ite, e should sy, ot omy, mass mel,
{ee are pong trough reainance tht promise to rode ther:
‘Stand most vated cultura irae we have yetsen.
‘The Rise and Fall of Digital Stuies
‘The preicament of dita stds canbe character by the paradox of
suctflen, aia 19 Groucho Man's membenbip parade The mote
‘masse and popula the Bes objet Dearne, the les he need frech ueatment or atenion. Hee i an example of « more advanced
‘se From the leo, the bang ld af ists comping (hi
tian ung computers methods sah 4 tie tnd datbaes)
had international conferences anda worldwide organization, 3b well
‘epional and national ones. The eld pil rev, bt soedenty topped
srwring and in 199 the yeu confrence had wo be canceled becase of
Tusk of expected parscipton, What had happened? Did this man ta
the historian abe of computing was meray fda bobble that bust
slong wih the inated new economy"? Not atl.
The Bld of iors computing wes formed so tate pcionre
could havea place to meet. change ies, and vesve meet for thir
Scholl output Inthe bepaning, hey ad bean few and ar etwea 0|
‘tmade seseoorgantetheneles in pei ire group. Ba ese
tual the inseam history conferences and junels opened =p and
‘welcomed the empater ase iteriane other ruin vent ad pub
Tatons, Computes histrigraphy was no longer viewed ith
ference or suspicion. Aad so the sel Interest group oesed 8
‘method an ecology rather than context, wasn lange neces.
(One wonders i the fd of pbertaes or digtel studs (sch
fies even eit within Mentifiabe bounces toy) may nol experience
the sane rie and fly pethaps within these ites ye A ree
{he international Imemet research organization (Asoxition of Internet
esearches—AIR, perhaps the ges and most vse bec
seach comma, sa highly sce, growing movement with parte
pus fom ge mime of isipinesinclasingcommuniaton snd
‘edi studs, lw, ppcology. ethnography, pli scent, andl
fui to mame asa Fen. 8) the look a things ae ing ry we
But even 5, there seems tobe an element of dowbt about the ope of
{he fl: The canerence CEP menos “dig art" atopic that gue
orthogonal to the Internet, and ako i mentions something cl the
"the Pos-Inere Age" Pecaps AIR tl become the API, nan emp
‘0 say caren? Alay, scaly succes technologies lke SMS 2
panding the AR brton beyond the Inter a sich, Bring caine dos
‘ot equal Began the Inte, and nee di For example, ae a
sone i, computer magazines publed srtles aboot email ito
‘mention ofthe fern Aad stil today. in that mest onie of lone
‘Societies. Fan, oalne meane mobi phones, no the Inn, wih el
‘wey fe people haven tht owes hee
But what happens when the difience between doing “Internevontine
How WeDeame Rtn 9
sees and ding "esearch! becomes hard to set When, Web base
tewmpapes ace simp clled newspaper, and etre bas become i
trate! Or when 1V is completly digtze’ td tranemitd ia gel
etek? We may not be loling store than en to Seen yea ahead
tee probabl ls Wil the ietraeto ven theese see a
scope when ready its akg wt
‘Mos aly hii» gnerton! hing Young antenured chlare ne
to get copa for he work and band together across ciples But
‘eho happens when they gt tenure? When the eybergeneation becomes
Szpareatchas? AS in the case ofthe computing historian it seems
Uy ha cyberscies a that oie wil ra ot of ear, oboe Easy
eft 3 berlin aloes the pace, so wl eybestis
be asindted inn the ald dscns Cyeretnographywilbecome eth
ogeaphycyeraw vl become and ybermedia wil Become media.
Te ofcourse of limited ae nc har to proc what eat wil
Iappen-A bese question perhaps, Wil any part of eerste survive
jot er he ensimlation int the mother cline?
Games Reisareh—sor Disciplines or One?
‘One candidate for such longvity i the sty of vdeo and computer
nme Gncesngy reed oa gal gamer hut for no goed was)
“Te scdy of gues as ong Bat that only pth st two oF
thee years have games bee he objet ofa breed and incesing ate tion
from 2 marke of dines Gost he the fern), There are ead fie
independent snd interdsipinry rach radions that cove some a
pectot pane:
+ Game Theor, branch of mathematic snd esnomi that act
relly about games st al but about mang sequel decisions in
petitive suston with intel knowledge
+ Phy Reseich,«traddon foeved on understanding chitren’ pay
ih concbutions fom ethnography pechlogy. and pedapeics
+ Gaming snd Simlton, an experental eld that pores anda
se fr en ering tutions eat as eptne
+ Board Game Ste, the histori study of baad games and their
elton+ ThePhisopy of Spore the eadyof physical gamer—sometne
theoretical companion outs tle: programs,
‘Thess independet tans have very ferent sols and means ad i=
zor no iteration with o een avarenes of obe soother In ation,
thee inerdplinarynatre me then volnerbl a lopsisend vn
ya Nant camper pert
‘Aa nov, ener emputer game studies Ike the oer game dines
vi ide or ao regard for peeviou and neighboring floss and with et
sober set of estar agendas. This putea emerging gone reveath
{e's perhaps even wider and enre disparate than the oe four com
bio yeti seams aleay set become more developed an (hopeful)
aly more departed than they aze However whit i computer
tm rsa and can i become one fell Sine comptes ges oe
‘malations hatin principle eam conan any clement of (popula) clue
tr reat tht» gate designer cantante i ery ile perhaps
hoting, that coud no, someon finds wap into tee aren, omy
beach roel eo medial heraldry Ako, ney al exitig fs of
seech ar eleva, or can be made séevaat rough thir perspectives,
methods or objects fsa. The it practical endless.
‘fe yeas ago the Humanities dean st Teva niersy bought af
loa ge developers toa meeting wit the prove to dca» ponie
sw undead program fr gare developers. So, what cores did
‘hey thik would be ot uel Medea ior ad ent mythology?
once edt image what stem eld in yon anes (he
‘Univesity of Bergen) coal nt be applied to game veserch, ne cold
‘nly come up with one ume, dent, Of curve when? mention
this atte games conteeac in Tampece it 200, there a a deni inthe
dice who protested! So any sadenic aldo dpe cia probly
bebrout bear
“The problem, then, becomes one of eaberece Are we aking of oe
anu the sume fl Already these ae ours ae sontrences even
‘ius sabpars a he game fel some fort onthe ei some on
Aewlopment, nd someon elturl and aoe isis, So can we ve
tame tis asa monolithic separate fl Probably et Bat there ses
to bean exallenopporsnity fora interiscipline or for sew elated
viable sbfis tha cover vious main pect, nach a howe atone
cle
‘he Case for Game Souies
We many subsets of bert suchas the study of dig at or of
‘lterature, can apd should easy be studied in its "mother dpins™
(the Ar History or Engl o Leta department), game ties does
hot hae sich a mother ld w fll back a could ie film sud,
be ace a part of media suds, But thee are song reasons wy this
ight not be good ies The mow compen of thee that gam,
Clie fle nots meduun but a road category of seen that ext
sro sed and they ae capable of sing ferent mei Take ches
‘tan be payed onin or against = machine or on Boal or by post
fad or the heads of to blinded expert players. Between Tee
to BerQues (EQ), theresa at gap inal relevant dimensions techno
legal sci, aesthetic, conte economical and soon. Tes
‘and BQ ae fr fom being the ame medium, and to group ther
tether io the same mem sedis probaby ot going t reveal an
{hing interesting Games ae not medi they do we mdi bt ny
feretonee
"The problem alo arises when we try to dine games or “computer
ames issu a bron eld htt right jut be too Brosdto conte
1 esningfl practicable aademie area, One teategy would be to 1
‘bay fom gues in genera nd lok more coherent evel, sch at
‘wit Une eewhere termed games in vital exvconments (Aare
200) ht ames take ple in seve ind a ital word alle
‘ido dice games, computer or not. Here we do get the oben that
oocompuetized games ike Monopaly and Dungeons & Dragons also
fall ander our ceisition, bat that i nly a problem if we iat tht he
“gia” is en overriding eegoy, whic bot an abitary aod wecboo
osyftshzing thing te de As weno know, the onneloffie distinction
isnot very good one.
“The sty of gare in virtual environments then, becomes tetasve
approche a phenoaenon tat could not be subsumed by an umnbrea
{cpline,becste gums have none I might sl be to optimistic to
sssume ta this Wil happen, buta the moment it more Uy han
notes given ll the programs and eve, nthe United Sates, de
‘ted vocational school, ie ell Sail School of Gane Design and De
‘elope in Horde or DigPes Insitute of Techology in Washington
Stare, tat have emerged inthe past few years Granted mort of the
have ery prac snd technic fc, bt ke any other nate—
‘entertainment industry thre wl als be oom for theoreti and “con
‘ent ried ie.
Games as Cjbercuure
‘oe me ak the cs hat the sty fg gto oud ery
el besa new core eld hat ares fom he athe of yberclare sidi,
Haein
* Games computer games and online computer gai) ibn ca:
‘urs, sesthetes and ecology ia ew wy.
+ Games display all te signs of eyborgnes (Dat nineties wor) and
identity experi
+ Games Ie BvesQuest are vast commenity experiments, «Kind of
stant gure society infasrotre that ecblgues oe soci en
nd networks,
+ Games encourage ser atviy and creas an aver the orp:
ete tht proce th
+ Gamer ae a ew mode of sonumuniation (nt seve modes)
wih networking space, and simulation a caren
+ Games are sed bythe rast to make ola and ata ate
rent eg. act games, BosMiched Jadoo/Bin Laden games,
ven peel eampaign ae)
+ Games area semi ps erat, lb clu
‘Tosum up the probably not one cnc commonly ascribed to
cbereulr tht cold aot be ound inthe pring sc, This inate
thatthe world of campus games is 3 pret tet be for ebectre
studies. tops, ie, ll be Ue din which certs ha he
strongest resonance and the Ings dominance
Toward a Game Seuies Department
1, a have suggested bee, “ges in vital envionment” vale
empire foc for ur net scholly dn aril ewe conan
drum of how to come up with 2 good disciplinary or methodologic
ioe ame eal
approach Are we going analyte plays, the aesthetic spect, othe
telnology? Should we oo athe ell nduty of are ete sc
‘spec neil, our cole af fous willbe prdeerne by or back
{pounds and by our uthodlogiel preiencey whichis mt esctly &
‘atonal interested way toes 2 dpe
“There ace three main peepectie (or virl-worl gee componcats)
‘hat rey lend thenseer 10 "potptal” game sues Rl the
tpmeply the rules oe sructre of the game, snd Be gamewer. Thee
fhzee components tend to attract fest methodological and dp
ary approach:
+ Game ply: sociology ethnology, phology, pedagogy (player
sod)
+ Game structure game desig, economics computer seen 8e-
sign sue")
+ Game-word ar ete, history, cuktrredi stad, (ia
‘elect property ight) Caesbets)
‘As we cam Se jst ere” focus Hh dhs eal a8 ent a date disci
lines al quit diferent Sut might Be possible to contain chem al ina
‘epartmatl sacra 0 et then be pat of he same thing pro
sr tanga the cove empiri fcat main stable. Hower fer
Ent game ences wel a eention wand lend theses to deze
“omponents the ose of thi tre ronged approach would depend
Gn the empitie tlance Some gees sch at srtey gone, ae cee
-ote ineestng om avlessritve pepe; ier, suchas adver.
tre games ae moa teresting fom a gunse- word pela of vew and
wo such a macvelymltipayer one games are mos interesting in
tems of game-play an player interaction
“As ales ambiouallerateony ane or wv of he emponentlper
sects coud be ued but his might crete an imbulance het shouldbe
Componsted by an explo dliiteton ofthe Geld Ie bard under
Stand games without knowledge of how they ate costae, and ii
Ihde construc them without an undranding of how they ze pled
‘Abslansd combination ofthese thre ements cere elt might be
‘ard to achiew nae plies unercy sting
"We might alo beable wo lun om he mises made in ober ek,
‘Tere ate otber dicipies tht combine usr, design/productio, andseat perpetves, most atl lea tudes and architect
“The lessons they have lered concern the combination oF thee ab