Professional Documents
Culture Documents
M4 Research Design Critique Report REV (6) SPR 2016
M4 Research Design Critique Report REV (6) SPR 2016
Milton Algood
M4 RESEARCH DESIGN 2
The scenario where I would use an experimental design would be to see how fifth
grade math anxiety impacts student learning and behavior. One way that I would counter
internal validity is by selecting at random which classes are a part of the control and
experiment than are needed may help minimize the threat of internal validity as well,
amongst other methods. Based on the scenario, using a quasi-experimental design would
be more feasible. The reasoning for this is because the researcher will have control of
which classes and grades will partake in this study. Using a true-experimental approach,
researchers often use. The first design is call Convergent Parallel Design. Through this
design, the researcher goes out and collects different kinds of data that are needed to
answer specific research questions. This data can either be qualitative or quantitative
data depending on what is necessary for the study. When the data is being gathered, there
is no priority given to one category over the other, all data is prioritized equally. Finally,
once all data is collected, the process of analyzing the data commences. The data is
looked at one by one; both types of data (qualitative and quantitative) are eventually
mixed to get an overall idea of the data. The second design is called Sequential Design.
While the first design focuses on the equal priority of qualitative and quantitative data,
sequential data does not. Sequential data simply focuses on the collection and analysis of
qualitative data that is Once quantitative data is gathered, the researcher then switches
their focus on the collection of qualitative data. Once gathered, the analysis of the
M4 RESEARCH DESIGN 3
qualitative data commences, and the researcher attempts to make connections. The
reasoning for the qualitative data being gathered, collected, and analyzed is to help make
sense of the quantitative data. The last research design is called Explanatory Sequential
Design. When it comes to the Explanatory Sequential Design, this design prioritizes the
gathering of information for qualitative data. After the qualitative data has been
analyzed, it switches its focus to the collection of quantitative data. This mixed-methods
design uses qualitative data as a basis for its research then uses quantitative research to
build upon the previous qualitative data. One reason for choosing a mixed-methods
approach is that sometimes research questions may need both qualitative and quantitative
data to be answered. Another reason is the fact that it can give clarity to an explanation
to something that only used one methodology. (Mertler 2016). Finally, it is more
look at a few different characteristics. In action research, the researcher attempts to find
any issues, obstacles, etc., that the researcher can attempt to fix. This kind of research
aims to help educators help each other develop strategies to overcome these obstacles.
Through this research method, educators usually want to improve and better themselves
to grow as educators. When it comes to formal research, the research done is not done by
reviewed academic journals tend to use formal research. A researcher may choose action
over formal because a teacher identifies an issue in their classroom, analyzes the solution,
and tries to come up with solutions while analyzing data. This reasoning also promotes
M4 RESEARCH DESIGN 4
self-reflection with what these educators do. Finally, the last reason is that it makes
whatever issue the teacher is trying to fix changeable. Therefore, the educator is able to
improve in whatever aspect of their classroom they are not content with.
Article Summary
In November 2014, Sarah E. Ruff and Dr. Susan R. Boes of the University of
West Georgia investigated how the low math achievement is a recurring weakness in
many students. Math anxiety is a persistent and significant theme to math avoidance and
low achievement. Causes for math anxiety include social, cognitive, and academic
factors. Interventions to reduce math anxiety are limited as as they exclude the expert
effectiveness of a school counseling small group intervention to reduce math anxiety and
increase achievement in fifth grade participants is presented. There were three research
1) How does math anxiety negatively impact math achievement in 5th grade
students?
2) How can PSCs reduce math anxiety and reverse the negative effects on math
achievement?
3) How can the results from the intervention be used to make improvements in
first country to put a man on the moon, the United States educational system wanted to
reform education and increase math and science achievement among children in america
M4 RESEARCH DESIGN 5
compared to those in other countries. Even after winning the race to the moon in 1969,
mathematic achievement. The american students scored below the international average
countries and 17 countries scored higher on average than the U.S. students.
provided a snapshot of the condition of education in the U.S. based on the results from its
2011 national study. Students in 4th, 8th, and 12th grade were assessed in reading,
mathematics, and social studies. Eighty two percent of the elementary students that were
tested reached only partial mastery of math knowledge and skills fundamental for
Numerous research studies have been conducted to pin-point the reasons for the
gaps in mathematical achievement for American Students. The causes are wide ranging.
It is difficult to single out a particular cause for low achievement for American students,
This action research was defined as a study conducted by a PSC within the school
participants responded to the intervention. This ARS addressed how PSC skills in
M4 RESEARCH DESIGN 6
method design was used to identify the nature and degree of problems in math
achievement for fifth grade students by find out what are their attitudes and beliefs about
math.
RQ 1 was confirmed from previous research collecting data about the negative
attitudes and beliefs young students have towards math. The Math Anxiety Scale for
Children was administered to all fifth grade students. This survey contained 22 items
related to math that students rated on a 4 point Likert scale. Fourteen students were
math anxiety and increase achievement. Fifth grade teachers were asked to participate in
interviews about group effectiveness. The teachers taught math to one or more
participants daily. Quantitative data is were scores were analyzed using descriptive
statistics to compare percentage changes in participants' scores after the intervention. All
qualitative data were analyzed using grounded theory. The goals of grounded theory are
to code qualitative responses and classify into emerging themes. Attention was paid to
themes that correlated with the literature connecting math anxiety and low math
achievement.
increase and 23% of the MASC scores remained the same. To examine the impact of the
M4 RESEARCH DESIGN 7
intervention on math achievement, the winter and spring fifth grade math benchmark
scores were compared. Analysis of basic math computation skills displayed that 84% of
participants increased their second score 8% decreased the score, and 8% had the same
score. Results revealed 58% of participants had the same MCAP score. One participant
was absent and did not participate in the second benchmark administration. After
identifying the themes theme frequency and after small group intervention was charted
and translated into numerical percentages. Student responses before the small group
intervention determined 52% displayed stress and frustration with math, 18% displayed
negative self-talk and avoidance behavior, 14% displayed positive attitudes toward math.
The authors suggested that in the future, the PSC should consider timing of the
small group interventions. Changing the time of the small group was suggested by three
teacher participants. Before or after school scheduled group times could allow for less
interruption of classroom instruction and longer periods for group intervention. The
teachers suggested that school year schedule should also be considered as student feelings
about the upcoming spring test administration may have been stressful.
References
Ruff, S., & Boes, S. (2014). The Sum of All Fears: The Effects of Math Anxiety on Math
Achievement in Fifth Grade Students and the Implications for School Counselors
M4 RESEARCH DESIGN 8
assessed reached only partial mastery of math knowledge and skills fundamental for