Prologue
The guitar works of Manuel M. Ponce were created over a 25 year period which started in
1923 and concluded with his death in 1948. During all these years Ponce composed six
sonatas, three variation groups, two suites, twenty four preludes in all major and minor keys,
an étude, two sonatinas, another six preludes, a sonata with harpsichord, a concerto with
orchestra and several pieces.
Alll these works came to enrich the guitar repertoire of this century and are marked by an
eclectic artistic approach that comprises several styles. Thus the works composed betwee:
1923 and 1927 bear, more or less, the influence of French impressionism, save the five songs,
transcribed by Ponce himself, that have a very Mexican character. This period was followed
by a neoclassic one that lasted a couple of years with the creation of two sonatas, one in the
classic style and another with Schubert's influence, as well as a suite in the baroque style,
written at the request of Segovia. This tendency was interrupted by the composition of the 24
preludes and the étude, between the fall of 1929 and the following spring; continuing with the
last sonata, where a procedure dating from the beginning of polyphony was deployed by using
in the first two movements the melody of a Paganini sonata, in the manner of a cantus firmus
but with a chromatic language within the romantic style. The sonatina bears a Spanish
influence, required by Segovia, and in the Folia variations, one of the leading guitar works of
the 20th century, several idioms and influences appear. During a single year, beginning in
December of 1930, there is a return to the neoclassic style, with the creation of another suite
and several pieces, all in the. baroque style, until finally, starting in 1932, with the second
sonatina written as a homage to Térrega, Ponce reaches his last period influenced again by
9impressionism, but by then within a more chromatic approach.
In all this output we find a concern towards the formal aspect, and so the proper
employment of the great forms, within guitar music, makes Ponce a true innovator since no
one, before or after him, had written six sonatas for the instrument, nor variations of the scope
of the ones written on the Folia theme.
‘The interest and the inclination towards research into Manuel M. Ponce’s music, were
awakened in me by Alirio Diaz when we met in Martinique in November of 1975 during the
Suite’. Alirio
guitar festival organized by Jean Pierre Jumez in which I played the ‘We
suggested that, since I was living in Mexico, I should check the Ponce manuscripts and see
what they were really like. At the beginning of 1976 I visited Ponce's house for the first time
and met his heir, the pianist Carlos Vazquez, who gave me access to the Ponce archive. I
started by writing the thematic catalogue of a copybook containing several guitar works and
there eventually found most of the 24 preludes which I started copying and that I published, a
few years later, with Tecla Editions in London.
Whenever a text is transmitted, or communicated by any means, a variation may occur
because occasionally editors, copyists, or even performers, are not careful enough with the
source itself. By omitting certain items, by trying to correct something that is considered
wrong, or perhaps by not knowing the style and context in which a text was originally written,
alterations may be introduced, as has happened many times with biblical texts. Because of
this, the critical work on a given text consists in detecting these changes in order to restore it,
whenever possible, to its original form, and in some cases to reconstruct something that does
not exist anymore. Also a text may be accepted in good faith and by getting used to it, in spite
of its lack of authenticity, it may often be preferred to the authentic and true version because
of the familiarity that has been established. Alll this is applicable to the case of Ponce, which is
why I have tried to make known the original version of his guitar works, which explains why
when playing his music one feels, sooner or later, that something is missing, that something is
not right and in the end one finds out that his original conception was changed.
Since Andrés Segovia prompted the composition of most of Ponce’s guitar music and was
its main editor and popularizer, one could think that this edition might be a sort of critique or
attack of his work, but this is not the case since Segovia was the result of an era and education,
Victorian up to a point, having remained enmeshed in the values and attitudes of the XIX
century. He also lacked a truly academic background, which he managed to overcome by his
own effort and discipline, though not completely. Besides, he was an idealist who took on
himself the redemption of the guitar, as a personal crusade, and engaged in making the music
of Ponce known to the world.
11He was also a human being and as such was not infallible; he could therefore be prone to
the influences that affect human beings and as we sometimes are motivated by unconscious
drives, he denied his origins and developed a phobia against flamenco. This can be
documented in his own words in Christopher Newpen’s Segovia en la Alhambra (Allegro Films,
1977) in which he admits when narrating that episode that his first guitar teacher was a
flamenco tocaor:
Suddenly, a poor flamenco tocaor came home, his first rough rasgueado frightened me and I
fell back; but when he scratched in his guitar some falsetas, according to him of soleares, those
melodic fragments entered through all the pores of my body; I felt so moved that I even now
remember it. The poor man asked: would you like co learn how to play? I motioned my head
upside down with joy; my uncle agreed. And two months later I had absorbed everything that
the poor tocaor knew, which was very little. As my uncle saw my skill, he used to say to his
friends: rather than learn this lad remembers.
Later on in the same video, before playing two Ponce pieces, he explains his resistance
towards flamenco in these terms:
It proved a herculean effort to change the idea my countrymen had about the guitar, being
considered only suitable to accompany songs and flamenco dancers in taverns with a prodigal
abundance of wine and female commerce.
To confirm this and to demonstrate how fallen was the image of the guitar, he also
recounts that one morning when the maid brought breakfast into his room and saw Segovia
practicing on his guitar she exclaimed: “Oh young man, so early and so happy!”
Segovia exerted a great influence on Ponce and that was only natural since the virtuosi,
during the first half of the century, always had a great charisma and their opinions were
considered next to infallible, Ponce succumbed to many of the suggestions made by Segovia
but sometimes when he did not agree with them he kept silent or made the required changes
but did not include them in his manuscripts, perhaps thinking that some day they would be
played in the way he had conceived them. Some people may think that the final result was
better after Segovia’s intervention. However, the interpreter’s point of view had always the
coloring of the great success expected and at times the subtlety of Ponce’s music had to be
transformed into something louder and more brilliant to obtain the public’s approval, as is the
case with the rasgueados that he liked to add. In some other cases the changes were to
facilitate the performance of a difficult passage; nevertheless, the crave for speed resulted in
rhythmical alterations, especially with the rhythmic figure of dotted eighth and sixteenth,
13ct value,
because the faster this is played the more difficult it gets to render it with the exa
being changed at times into a triplet or two uneven eighth notes.
The tempi asked by Ponce were not very fast and so the allegro was mostly shaded by adding
indications such as moderato, non troppo, serioso, espressivo, piacevole, semplice, etc.
Undoubtedly this was part and parcel of his unobstrusive character in which introversion and
reflection predominated, producing a tranquil and restrained personality that did not need
expansive outbursts to attract attention. These qualities are to be found in all his music which
shows a perfect balance between affection, expression and reflection. Alll this is evident in his
guitar music, managing to express what captivated him the first time he listened to Segovia in
his Mexican debut and that he shares with us in the review that he wrote for El Universal of 6
May 1923:
egovia is to experience a sensation of
Listening to the notes of the guitar played by Andrés
intimacy and homely wellbeing; it is the evoking of remote and soft emotions wrapped in the
mysterious enchantment of past things; it is opening the spirit to reverie and
living some
wonderful moments within an ambiance of pure art that the great Spanish artist knows how to
recreate.
Ponce's output comprised almost all musical forms and even in his orchestral works there
-y and refinement that appears in most of his
prevails the atmosphere of introspection, intima
works. His activity was not limited to composition and he was a brilliant pianist as well, with
technical resources that he worked on with Martin Krause in Berlin; these can be noticed in
the score of his piano and orchestra concerto, performed splendidly by the composer himself
for its premiere, as was confirmed by the reviews. He also taught piano and composition and
was director of the Conservatorio Nacional ile Miisica as well as of the Facultad de Miisica of the
| activity was his research and
University of Mexico. Another important aspect of his music
compilation of popular music as well as the creation and inclusion of these themes in many of
his works, being considered the initiator of the nationalistic movement in Mexican music.
Most of his guitar manuscripts have heen preserved in his archive, only missing the ones
that were kept by Segovia and that were lost during his pilgrimage from one continent to the
other, or because of national and personal disasters like the Spanish Civil War, or simple
robbery. This is the case of the first four sonatas, the Weiss suite, the Folfa variations and
several pieces that will be mentioned throughout the present text. At the beginning I
intended to publish only the solo guitar music but as the concerto has a lot of important
changes, not only in the soloist part but in the orchestration too, I finally decided to include
the guitar part and at the end, in an appendix, the reduction of the orchestra fragment that
15was suppressed. That is not the case with the guitar and harpsichord sonata, published like the
concerto by Peer International Corporation, revised and fingered by Carlos Vazquez and
Manuel Lopez Ramos, whose text was respected and only the metronome markings, which do
not appear in the original manuscript, were added.
Finally, | would like to acknowledge the assistance and help provided by Alitio Diaz,
Carlos Vazquez, Juan Helguera, Manuel Lopez Ramos, Gustavo Alanéz, Sergio Ortiz, Jorge
Alcézar, Bernardo Kupfer, Ron Purcell, Martin Kaaij, Mirek Kotecki, Rogelio and Lucy
Arellano, Miguel Querol and Father Antonio Brambila who in one way or another
contributed to the realization of this book, as well as to Alan Stark who made the final
revision of the English text. I made the recording during 1997, of all the works here published,
to be released by Tritonus.
Mineral del Chico, July of 1998
17