Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Book Name: Transformed Culture and Praxis: Engaging People in the Margin, Taiwan: PTCA
& YTCS, 2017. Pages: 216.
This world is Facing crisis because of Concentration and abuse of power with a few
privileged people as a result marginalized peoples are push back to more poor, so that this book
give a voice for that voiceless people as they have to bunt their ideology of institutionalized
unjust structure and system. this book give voice that, margins are having difficulties by different
layers by colonialism, oppressive culture and market culture, but when it come as theological
term of margin, it portrayed margins are structured by unjust communities, dominated by
superiors but this book shown how God is revealing through margin, theology is not alone done
by people by people in their power, but it also reveling by fait journey of God.
Rev. Dr. Wati Longchar is belongs to Ao tribe of Nagaland in India, He is well experience in
theological field, he has taught 15 years in Eastern theological collage, Jorhat, Assam. From
2001 to 2007, he served as a consultant of ecumenical and theological education for Asia and
Pacific as Joint program of WCC and Christian conference of Asia. From 2008-2015, he served
as dean of the extension department of the Serampore university, during this time, he took
additional responsibility as director-incharge of South Asia Theological Research institute for
two years. And he has authored four books and edited and co-edited thirty one books.
Introduction:
Culture and Practices are forming by Human being itself with that environment and Collective
heritage by throughout the generation after genaration, it is not similar with other place culture,
there culture and practices are also determined by their environment and heritage of there
generation by there racial and religious group. But modern culture and Practices are varied and
determined by market capitalism, migration and cyber theology. These all force change our
culture and to bring new cyber global culture and Practices. With is idea, first I would like to
summarize every chapter shortly and then ill bring out my understanding and view of this book.
Chapter-1
Colonization is known as “Exercise of Power and Control over one people by another people by
behavior, ideology institution, policies and Economics. There are several methods of colonizing
certain place, firstly they colonize land and territories either by diplomatic words or forceful
eviction and take over the land. Because of colonial people occupied the place indigenous place,
now they are landless and it leads to poorer them and poverty. And second phase is colonized
there culture and social colonized, by colonized they apply there new law, it leads to change
indigenous peoples tradition is getting eradication and colonial power take out there children and
teach there method. And change there name and there language.
Chapter-2
Commercial Tourism: Objectification of Culture and Nature.
Myanmar is known as fast changing in all spheres of life after the political reform in the
recent past. Myanmar is magnificent place which has Buddhist temple, rich cultural heritage,
life giving rivers etc…because of that tourism becomes boom in Myanmar,Government take
it and push hard to attract tourism, that result since 1992 invite tourism to do economics
development, later military ride off and civilian power control, then touristarrival reach
1million plus, then they bring many idea to attract tourism to Myanmar. But Pre-democracy
advocate define in “Voice for Burma”, that “tourism can create more benefited that harm, as
long as tourist are fully aware of the situation and take steps to maximize their positive
impact and minimize their negative impact… raising awareness of the situation
worldwide”.23
Chapter-3
Culture, Church, Disabilities and Marginalization
Person with Disability and Obvious cultural discrimination:
In the society or in community, PwD’s are consider as second class people, they are
consider as object of Charity and their position in work place is “First to discharge and
last to Hired in any form of employment” an culturally PwD will not get any privilege
from there family inheritance, and stigmatize from the society by consider as inferior,
sinner, imperfect and sometimes PwD born child killed by his parents in order to protect
their status in the society.
Cultural belief in the Society:
“Do Good thing to get blessing, if you do bad thing it will bring Curse”, Pwd are
understood as outcome of bad thing and curse from God, the effect is killed them in the
stage of infanticide., so that, child will go back to God and God will give perfect child.
K.C. Abraham defined, “All image of God created by abled people for the abled
people”42. As a result the disorted of God’s imagefrom disability as imperfect, unclean
unholiness, sinner not only this there are many misinterpretation and misunderstanding in
the society, so that, it brings out several understanding which mainly hit againstPwD
peoples, like sin and Disability, sin and Image of God, Suffering and Disability in Virtual
Suffering view. “Here Nancy L. EieslandStated that, “Disability is a temporary affliction
that must be endured to gain heavenly rewards.”47.
Misinterpretation of Temple:
According to Jewish understanding, Disability is outcome of Sin, in lev 21:16-24.
There defined disability peoples are not allowed in temple service. But WalisUkan OT
Scholar stated that, PwD are not excluded but they are relieved from the temple. Even if
disabled priest are in the temple, offerings has t offer daily from early till whole, as a
disabled people cannot to do that it demands to abled people and relief disabled people
from the labourish work v.22.
Jesus and Disability people:
Jesus mostly focus on Disability people to caring and Healing, eg: healing at Sabbath,
for Jewish day of Sabbath is more important than human life, but for Jesus Human life is
more important that Sabbath, so that he ready to break Sabbath ritual, then he defined
“the Sabbath was made for humankind and not Human kind for a Sabbath”. so that he
stood for the cared of sick and Disabled.
Church and Disabilities:
Ecumenical Disability advocate Network draw an attention to by defined “without
include the gift of Pwd , we cannot talk about the unity of the church, if there is no Pwd
in the church, then there is no unity in the church. Because church need to understand all
peoples are with or without disabilities are created by the image of God and to called an
inclusive community. Like Jesus, He was protected, forgave, love and cared for them,
like wise church need to follow.
Chapter-4
Culture, Christian Mission and Marginalized People:
Huang Poho says “People, especially the suffering, poor people are the subject of Christian
mission, The subject of the Gospel and Theology”55.
Context and Subject of Mission:
Christian mission mostly need to focus on marginalized people, because the unjust global
economic system makes deeply rooted the poor, Global activity system makes eradicate the
cultural activity and resources, due to that many lost their culture, livelihood due to political
manipulation.moreover, cultural nationalism and religious fundamentalism against minority
becoming so rude, attacking by fundamentalist during special occasions in Christianity.So we
need to focus on marginalized people, those who in pain of exploitation and to address what
makes them to excluded and marginalized.
Civilization Mission:
Civilization mission was happened in colonization period, Christian mission abandon
the culture, tradition and their tradition in order to follow Christianity. as a result there
are several military warfar activity, attacks, battle/war, campaign, crusades placed, and
started to portrait indigenous God and Goddesses and there belief as “Pagan, Heathen,
Darkness”. it leads local people abundant their own culture and betrayed their countries
in order to follow foreign mission.
Charitable mission:
Charitable mission is approach marginalized people by giving of helping by their
needs. Just like help to poor and sick by providing cloths and food and do prison ministry
and support their family. It is known as charitable mission.
Development mission:
Development mission began in west toreducetension betweeneast and west during
cold war and later it focus on hunger poverty development, it been 2 decades, in current
situation development mission requires to disable people and those who are affected by
HIV/AIDS and some other dieses and also focused on urban and rural poor people,
because industrialization and globalization poor people are become more poor. Here
development mission play a good role.
Transformative Mission:
It is focused on Church. Church should take responsibility to create new social justice
structure for those who suffering by depurative and violation. So church has to be
transformative like, “Marginal People have to be subject for history not an object and
there no motivation of pity instead to justice and need to raise awareness among people.”
Because transformative mission is not just an ideal or emotion or just give some clarity, it
is a commitment for transformation from sinful social structure and liberative social
victims.
Here Charity and development alone cannot bring justice and peace. Transformative
mission also need for listening of the people’s crying in the pain.
Chapter-5
Church, Homophobia and Marginalization
Chapter-6
Power and Powerless: Mission From the Margin.
Chapter-7
Marginalized people and Asian: Liberation and Vocation of Theologians
Poverty and Poor are playing vital role to lend liberative theology, one is market
capitalism dragging economic and political poverty and in other sideexploitation of poor and
earth resources beingreach to massive scale by one sided extraction of globalization of
development process, in between sufferers and margins, it raises several questions of
liberation theology, and it can unmask between globalization, climate-justice and survival of
the marginal communities can relocate margins through liberation theology? Is that vocation
theology is the context of continuing marginalization of people and God’s creation?
Margin-location of Liberation theology:
In academically, Liberation theology reduces as a piece of History after the neo-
liberalism it was dislocated, as missed a God’s revelation. But again it was Re-located in
the site of margin, but in not as absolute option, but an imperative. Liberative theology
not only meant for margins, because it relocated ad an hermeneutical action, so as a result
it brings out many dimension of Liberation theology and relocated as Liberation
theology.eg: Rich man and Lazarus. Luke 16: 19-21.
God among Margin:
In today Asian context, Poor and margins peoples are often unbearable incidents like
formers commit suicidebecause of unable to pay loan parents kill there parents by
pushing in lake because of uncertainty of future, like many millions of lazarus are
longing for fulfill there hunger stomach and poverty, but in other side superiority peoples
are like rich peoples earning millions per day and to looking to build their place to reach
the sky, as like in this situation. That our church and ecumenical movement must be
located in the point of margin, through there lives and struggles for life, they need to hold
what God wants in the world while also bring reservoir of Hope, resistance and
preservance.
Vocation of theology:
The primary work of theologians is involved into the margin peoples suffering fir
transforming the sinful societies, by involve we need to bring radical change in the
system of oppressive by proclaiming in the name of Jesus Christ, sometimes in order to
bring iberation, we need to take risk and struggles against misuse and abuse power by
doing protest, organizing protest movement, neo-cooperation movement, etc… because
Jesus also did in his ministry, He was lived with people of suffering not with high
community and understand there pain and struggle.
Chapter-8
M.M.Thomas on Marginalized People and Contextual Theologies in Asia.
M.M.Thomas was born in 1916 and died 1996. He was a deeply influenced in socialism
and he been parted in colonialism, independence struggle and national building. Bastian
wieslang says about M.M. Thomas that “Ideologically MM was moved from Gandhian Non-
violence to Marxist Class-War to Nehruite State centered development and social justice
oriented modernization”115. And he was a radical thinker with the prophetic voice that
challenged both the church and the society.
Theology and oppressive Structure:
M.M. Thomas context is theology through opprasive people, For that he defined,
“Theology is the living thing, having to do with our existence as Christian and as
churches”.116. In Asian present context, Thetimes are Subaltern, untouchable, women,
poor, vulnerable section of Asian society as notion of Purity-Pollutiondichotomy. In that
situation, M.M.Thomas try to find out to locate theology within the oppressed context
and he defined “Egoism” is a root to caused unjust in the society by making hierarchy,
poor’s are object of exploitation, Legitimize the belief and practices of the religion, so
that, Christian needs to expressed in terms of “Spirituality of Combat”, which means,
called to radical departure from the power and institution and take the position to save the
life.as protection to take over the life from power.
The Devine presence in the context:
In this context, divine presence in protection of marginalized people. For M.M.
Thomas, understanding of The Bible is God is God of Justice and Compassionate God.So
that God’s love is Paivitallove.God’s heart is aches at the pain the people. Therefore, in
the situation of widespread structural injustice of class, caste, patriarchy. God is in the
side of oppressed community.
Looking Forward to Future:
By thinking very critical way, M.M.Thomas found there is no option to overcome
from the capitalism, because of science and technology and also on side of extractive
development and it leads to marginalization. so that he raised adequate challenges that the
danger of modern technology and the result of destruction, exploitation, commoditization
of marginal communities. This question has raised in contextual theology by continuing
marginalization and objectification of the culture. This all connected to the globalization,
climate-justice and survival of marginalization. For that he brings out five points.
1. Location of contextual theology.
2. Contextual theology without name.
3. Contextual theology disconnected from earth.
4. Methodological Re-location.
5. Mobilize solidarity justice movement.
Chapte-9
Indigenous culture is interconnected with the life. The life with environment and the living
creatures and to understand the earth in the home for all, the fitness of life the peace, justice by
interrelated and interconnectedness, “Justice to the marginalized people is impossible without
justice to the God by vice versa”.
Technology is one of the main source to science revolutionary in the world. Many
scientist put a basement to develop the science and technology in order to destroy the nature,
Bacon says that “Goal of the science is conquest if nature” as “Knowledge is power”.128. as
mathematician Descartes said,” Humanities are lords and masters to nature”128. As the
world could be understood as a group of independent, separated, competitive object rather
than interconnectedness and independence, for strengthening this ideology they defined that
the only difference between human and other creature is mind and ability to think.
Land is the Big mother for indigenous people, thus have a spiritual connection with
land, everything is organically related to each other, nothing to neglect either supreme being
of spirit, interconnectedness of Indigenous people not only by God and also to mother land,
they take utmost care on land with special occasion day to celebrate 3-6 days and there
culture and beliefs are maintaining towards between human and ecological needs by balance
was maintained through practices of taboo and totem, it is legitimize religious basis through
myth.
Chapter – 10
Domination people consider God is Success oriented God, SoIndigenous people don’t experience
God, Because God is mystery, sometime God defined as personal image of God even the Bible
defines as Patriarchy, hierarchy image of God.
Hierarchy: Hebrew and Greek people defined God in Hierarchy way, and give the
structure to God as He is male and old man and give thenature of God as omnipotent and
omnipresent and omniscience and even create the hierarchy in God’s creation as angel in
high and inferior peoples are low. And dualism of human relationship also bring out that
lack-white, Body-Soul, less value inferior-high value superior, heaven-earth.
Christian was influenced by the concept of construct image of God as male, because
God in terms of power, authority, ruler, lord of almighty, father etc…, here military power
oriented image of god as portray, such metaphorical image of man and woman as subordinate
role model, Sallie Mcfaghu says that “Content of Judea – Christian tradition, which project
domineering God as absolute, transcendent and omnipotent as patriarchal concept. It permits
no sense of mutuality, shared responsibility, reciprocity and love in terms of relationship with
God, human and the world.”148.
The Bible speaks even about non-personal relationship with God, like creator,
sustainer, rock, fortress, etc… but it is hardly used in Christian theology, but need to
experience of God for marginalized people and non-personal images of God are also
important and need to be explored to enrich God-World-human relationship. Indigenous
people believes that God is inseparable related to the sacred land, but transcendental believes
God is from above, but for the blooming flower, bearing fruits and rich signifies the presence
of God as creator. They see the God in creation, but it is more relevant in constructing
Christian theology. The affirmation of earthly spirit ishelp us to reconstruct divine
relationship with the world in a new way.
Chapter-11
Theological education playing key role in life of church and society. For that many theological
movement, seminaries comes forward and bring new face for the challenges by giving
variousoffers of studies, workshop, consultation, through that various theological reflections
coming out, mainly from subaltern, women, margin, now disabilities and people with
HIV/AIDS, But How do we integrate margins choices in theological education? Do we broaden
out theological education and integrate with secular studies? Do Asian theological seminaries
collaborate with organization and movement? Many challenging questions makesensuring
quality of theological education today.
Missionary movements were began at 16th century by martin Luther to gave rise to
protestant theological education in global south, that time mission was meant for engage in
community for socio-economic and cultural transformation. Mainly Serampore trio, they
involved multi-community transformative work. But common understanding of theology or
religious studies are only meant for priest. This narrow orientation bring unhealthy
theological competition, mistrust and violence. Mainly current situation theological study
mostly defined ecclesiastical position of priest/pastor. Not to give sufficient scope for
community development, inter-religious engagement and cultural research to bringout social
transformation and change.
Chapter-12
This world experienced and experiencing ruthless role of imperialism, killing and
Genocide. eg, over 6 million Germans were killed by Adolf Hitler, Hiroshima-Nagasaki
nuclear test made more than 209 thousand Americans and Indian were killed and made
thousands of people disabled. Like many heart rending stories of genocide and mass
destruction and unequal distribution of resources in the world today. The reality of today
world is that the value of human beings, especially the poor and marginalized once aretreaed
like a commodity and beast. Power, military, economic and social benefits are so unevenly
shared and used vast majority of the world’s population in left excluded and abused.
Book Review:
The Book, Transforming Cultures and Praxis: Engaging People in the Marginscontain 13
chapter in 216 pages. But one of the notable thing in this book is, it’s not just a book from one
site. It’s an collection of paper from athor, which a author did various semeninor papers, even he
dismantle the repetative content,we can see some repetition,but author already ackonow about
that as, that repetitive content is for clarification. Even thoughIt is the challenging book for
theologians and Christians, in this book author brings our many dimensions about Marginal
People and brings out different layers of marginal groups and brings out there oppression,
challenges from colonialism and market capitalism, and since author focused on marginalized
group of people, he began his chapter from the heart of the cause and problem of issues of who
are marginalized and why they are marginalized and what caused them to as marginalized
community, in this book author vailed that the margins are not born, instead they portrait as
margin by so called superior group of people, for strengthening his idea, Author brings out
various scholars idea of approaches in certain problem and there solution, in some chapters he
brings out two authors of different ideas and brings out his idea or objection of certain issue and
solution, for e.g. in Chapter 5, topic of Sin and punishment, Crystotom said, “Homosexuality is
worse than punishment” and striate opposite john Mcnail defined “it is Gift from God”, like he
strengthen his idea by adding scholars and theologians ideas and there concept. And most
probably author brings out the most of the problem’s solution from the bible, and even
author.Mainly this book focused on marginalized people engagements in doing theology of
God’s mission in Justice-Peace. Moreover throughout this book, author show his consistency of
his concerns about margins, indigenous and oppressed people’s problems and challenges in this
books. As per my opinion, this book is very useful and very informative and also challenging
book for us, this books makes us think and also to understand about margins communities deep
understanding.
Students of MBCBC
Shamshabad, Hyderabad.