Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bhallis - Paper2
Bhallis - Paper2
Brittany Hallis
Summer, 2022
2
Benefits Of A School Counseling Program On Academic and Social-Emotional Success
Abstract
The evolution of School Counseling programs has adapted and changed over the last 30
years bringing clarity to the school counselor’s role resulting in benefits for students. With the
counseling program; school counselors provide quality counseling to students improving their
academic and social-emotional success. There are various strategies a school counselor can
implement within their program to enhance student academic and social-emotional success.
Classroom lesson plans, improving communication between teachers and staff, and promoting
Table of Contents
Introduction ………………………………………………………………………… 4
Methodology…………………………………………………………………………10
Participants…………………………………………………………………………..10
Procedures…………………………………………………………………………...11
Time Schedule………………………………………………………………………12
Table 1. ……………………………………………………………………..12
Budget……………………………………………………………………………….12
Discussion……………………………………………………………………………13
References ……………………………………………………………………..…….14
4
Benefits Of A School Counseling Program On Academic and Social-Emotional Success
Success.
Introduction
social-emotional and academic support that promotes success and achievement for all students
(Trust, 2020).
This study describes the role and responsibilities a school counselor has, the ASCA
National Model, strategies for a school counseling program to consider, and how it ties into
The purpose of this study is to discover what benefits a quality school counseling
The School Counseling profession has evolved radically over the years. One of these
changes is the movement away from the term “guidance counselor”. Nearly 30 years ago, the
American School Counselor Association (ASCA) issued an official statement on this change from
guidance counselor to school counselor as they felt this old term no longer encompassed the
broad scope of work that was done by the professionals in schools (Zyromski, Hudson, Baker, &
Granello, 2019). With this change, there were individuals within the school district that were
unaware of the updated school counselor’s function and role (Gordon, 2019).
The initial role of a guidance counselor was to help “guide” students through their
classes, get them registered for upcoming classes, and provide advice on college choices. Now
5
Benefits Of A School Counseling Program On Academic and Social-Emotional Success
there is a shift when the term school counselor is used, and their job responsibilities are
through identifying and supporting struggling students, reducing barriers to accessing rigorous
coursework, individual counseling, classroom lessons, suicide prevention, and shape post-
The ASCA National Model was developed to define the school counselor’s role in
define, manage, deliver, and assess (Bowers, J., & Hatch, P. A. 2005). These components help
school counselors develop a quality school counseling program which aids in promoting student
By following the framework of the ASCA National Model, the school counselor develops
a quality, comprehensive school counseling program focused on student academic and social-
emotions, set goals, demonstrate empathy, build healthy relationships, and make constructive
choices (CASEL, 2019). School counselors can implement social-emotional learning programs
study by Kamour and Altakhayneh (2021), a counseling program was built based on social-
emotional learning and then engaged with students for 15 sessions to help students with their
math anxiety. Students were broken up into two groups, there was an experimental group
6
Benefits Of A School Counseling Program On Academic and Social-Emotional Success
receiving the counseling sessions, and a control group which followed the traditional learning.
Results showed there were statistically significant differences between the experimental group
and the control groups in favor of the experimental group (Kamour & Altakhayneh, 2021).
success.
Classroom lesson plans is one strategy for school counselors to improve student
academic and social-emotional success. When the school counselor can execute classroom lesson
plans tailored to a specific subject those students have shown an increase in knowledge, skills,
being an advocate for students of diversity. Understanding the backgrounds and complexities
each culture has, the school counselor can ease the transition between primary and secondary
school and high school. Professional school counselors have an ethical responsibility to take the
next logical step in creating safe and inclusive environments for all students by assessing the
cultural climate of the schools in which they work and creating programs that enhance the
learning environment for all students (Nelson, J. A., Bustamante, R. M., Wilson, E. D., &
Onwuegbuzie, A. J., 2008). When school counselors embrace the role of becoming an effective
multicultural social justice advocate and organizational change agent, they actively demonstrate
their commitment to promote the right of all students to high-quality educational opportunities
by confronting school policies and practices and challenging administrative decisions that
reinforce rather than eliminate social/educational injustices (Bemak, F., & Chung, R. C. Y.,
2008).
7
Benefits Of A School Counseling Program On Academic and Social-Emotional Success
School counselors are uniquely positioned in schools and districts to provide access to
many of the supports that help bolster the well-being of students and allow them to be present
and succeed academically (Strear, M., Duffy, H., & Sunde, A., 2021). An example of this that
one could encounter is when students don’t have access to internet at home and presents the issue
to the school counselor, with permission from the student, the school counselor brings the
information to the teachers. Both parties can collaborate to come up with ideas for the student to
Student resource officers are sworn law enforcement officers specially selected and
trained to promote safety within schools (Rosiak, J., 2014). When school counselors cooperate
with SRO’s and students observe positive interactions between the two entities, it allows students
to feel comfortable dealing with SRO’s if needed. Students who report feeling safe in school are
more engaged in class, have higher academic achievement, and have lower rates of absenteeism,
When school counselors communicate with other school counselors in the school, it
allows students the flexibility to discuss classes or problems with any of the school counselors.
When school counselors communicate with other counselors throughout the district, each person
can discuss issues going on in their respective school, share knowledge, and resources with each
other, and diverse ways to promote student academic and social-emotional success. During the
year of COVID-19 and virtual learning school counselors were in constant communication with
each other collaborating to adapt school counseling programs. Since the pandemic there has been
for families, creating templates, and forms students could use to reach out for support, and
8
Benefits Of A School Counseling Program On Academic and Social-Emotional Success
tracking student contacts across the district by working in teams and sharing these resources and
tools with one another (Strear, M., Duffy, H., & Sunde, A., 2021).
plans, individual counseling, and small group counseling (ASCA, 2012). Utilizing group
counseling provides numerous benefits for students and is an efficient use of time for school
counselors. Group counseling provides a safe environment in which students can express their
feelings and obtain group support, as well as exchange interactions with other participants, and
sympathy between them, which enhances their self-confidence and their tendency to form
successful friendships (Banat, S., Heyem, A. T., Alshoubaki, N., & Younes, W., 2020).
incorporate into their school counseling program. When a student is struggling in school, having
a difficult time making friends, or having outbursts, adults often question what is wrong with the
student. Instead, the first question school counselors ask is, “Are external factors causing the
problem?”. This question leads the school counselor into an assessment of conditions in the
environment that need attention and discussing with the student. The World Health
Organization’s (2004) definition of mental health is: “A state of well-being in which the
individual realizes his or her own abilities, can cope with the normal stresses of life, and can
work productively and fruitfully, and is able to make a contribution to his or her community.”
Mental health conditions are becoming more prevalent as younger students are living with a
mental health condition. Students needing mental health support are more likely to pursue
services within the academic setting than through a local mental health agency (Carlson, C., A.,
& Kees, N., L., 2013). Schools that focus on mental health concerns show they care about
students and helps enhance equity of opportunity and a positive school climate.
9
Benefits Of A School Counseling Program On Academic and Social-Emotional Success
and further validates its influence within the field. A popular question asked is “Does it work?”,
works assumes that it is accessible and effective for all student populations; however, this is not
always the case and can be a limitation among the school counseling program (McMahon, H. G.,
& Patel, S., 2019). Each student is unique from their upbringings, worldviews, ambitions,
accessibility, and needs. Therefore, certain interventions may not impact students the same or
have the same level of effectiveness as others which limits the relevance of the intervention.
School Counselors use evidence-based practices to understand “For whom does this intervention
improve student academic and social-emotional success. ASCA recommends a ratio of 1:250 to
build relationships with their students, allow for extra time spent on their counseling duties, and
increases the overall performance on student academic and social-emotional success (Grossman,
2019). This student-to-counselor ratio has a direct influence on the success and overall
performance of students among various school-related subjects (Carey and Dimmitt, 2012).
Ultimately, research uncovers a correlation between access to school counselors and the
wellbeing, academic performance, increased likelihood the student will consider college as a
possibility, and improved student attendance with a decrease in their disciplinary rates (Savitz-
Romer, M., & Nicola, T. P., 2022). Research continues to indicate students in schools with fully
10
Benefits Of A School Counseling Program On Academic and Social-Emotional Success
developed, comprehensive counseling programs are more likely to obtain high grades and be
prepared for college or a career after high school (Mau, WC.J., Li, J., & Hoetmer, K., 2016).
Statement of Hypothesis
The statement of hypothesis for this research is: Having a quality school counseling
program in place provides greater benefits for student academic and social-emotional success
Methodology
Participants
largest city in the south-central part of the state. From these sixty-one elementary schools, two
were chosen due to convenience of the school counselor. One school in the sampling would not
have a school counselor on staff, due to school counselor shortage. School counselors at the
elementary school level split time between two elementary schools that serve 300-500 students
and have an estimated 56 students in sixth grade. In this prospective study, students enrolled at
the school with a school counseling program who interact with the school counselor will be
recruited. Due to the ease of availability and accessibility for the school counselor, convenience
sampling will be used and students from sixth grade will be used for the study.
A correlational research study involves collecting data to determine whether, and to what
degree, a relationship exists between two or more quantifiable variables (Mills & Gay, 2022). In
this study, a prospective correlational research design will be used to determine whether, and to
what degree a relationship exists between a school counseling program and students’ academic
and social-emotional success. Data will be collected in the form of surveys to measure students’
11
Benefits Of A School Counseling Program On Academic and Social-Emotional Success
perspectives on their own academic and social-emotional success prior to participating in school
counselor interventions and then at the end of the school year. The predictor variable is
interactions with the school counselor. Student academic and social-emotional success is the
criterion variable.
Procedures
Letters of consent will be given to the guardians of each student with a detailed
description of what the study consists of. To determine if there is a relationship between having a
school counseling program and student academic and social-emotional success, surveys will be
given to each student in sixth grade via their classroom by an outside observer a month into the
school year and a follow up survey at the end of the school year. These surveys will ask students
to rate their own academic and social-emotional success. The outside observer will code the
surveys, so names will not be used. The level of school counselor involvement will be measured
The data in the study can be analyzed using the Pearson Product-Moment Correlation.
This statistical test determines if a relationship exists between two variables. The researcher will
need to consider interpretation of the data if the sample size is larger, since this will decrease the
value needed to reach statistical significance. The means for the independent and dependent
variables will be computed and compared to determine if a relationship exists between the two.
Because most scores from instruments used in education, such as achievement measures and
personality measures, are classified as interval data, the Pearson r is usually the appropriate
Time Schedule
Table 1.
Time Schedule
Select X
Participants
Pretest X
Execute
Study X
Posttest X
Analyze Data X
Write Report X X X
Budget
Due to this study needing paper surveys and these being completed in class, the estimated
budget would be $35 to cover the cost of paper and printer ink.
Discussion
13
Benefits Of A School Counseling Program On Academic and Social-Emotional Success
The results of this study support the original hypothesis: Having a quality school
counseling program in place provides greater benefits for student academic and social-emotional
success verses schools without a school counseling program. The students at the elementary
school with a school counseling program in place reported higher scores of academic and social-
Results cannot be generalized to all classrooms because the study took place within sixth
grade classrooms at two elementary schools. However, results were consistent with research on a
School Counseling programs continue to be a resource for students, parents, teachers, and
staff with benefits to student academic and social emotional success. Further research can be
conducted on individual school counseling sessions, group school counseling sessions, the
relationship between a middle school or high school counseling program and student academic
and social emotional success. It is important that school districts implement school counseling
References
American School Counselor Association. (2012). ASCA national model: A framework for
BANAT, S., Heyam, A. T., ALSHOUBAKİ, N., & YOUNES, W. (2020). The effectiveness of a
group counseling program in enhancing the ability to form friendship among academically
talented students. Journal for the Education of Gifted Young Scientists, 8(2), 701-710.
Bemak, F., & Chung, R. C. Y. (2008). New professional roles and advocacy strategies for school
Bowers, J., & Hatch, P. A. (2005). The ASCA national model: A framework for school
counseling programs. American School Counselor Association, 1101 King Street, Suite 625,
Alexandria, VA 22314.
Carey, J., & Dimmitt, C. (2012). School counseling and student outcomes: Summary of six
Carlson, L. A., & Kees, N. L. (2013). Mental health services in public schools: A preliminary
2156759X150160401.
Collaborative for Academic, Social, and Emotional Learning (2022). Fundamentals of SEL.
Dack, H., & Merlin-Knoblich, C. (2019). Improving Classroom Guidance Curriculum with"
Gordon, J. M. (2019). Principal Perceptions of School Counselor Roles: The Impact of Training
Kamour, M., & Altakhayneh, B. H. (2021). Impact of a counseling program based on social
emotional learning toward reducing math anxiety in middle school students: Impact of a
2038.
Mau, W. C. J., Li, J., & Hoetmer, K. (2016). Transforming high school counseling: counselors
McMahon, H. G., & Patel, S. (2019). Who benefits? Adding inclusive innovation into the
Mills, G. E., & Gay, L. R. (2022). Chapter 9: Correlational Research. In Educational research:
Competencies for analysis and applications (12th ed., pp. 223-230). essay, Pearson.
Nelson, J. A., Bustamante, R. M., Wilson, E. D., & Onwuegbuzie, A. J. (2008). The school-wide
Rosiak, J. (2014, March). School resource officers: benefits and challenges. In Forum on Public
Strear, M., Duffy, H., & Sunde, A. (2021). When Schools Go Dark, School Counselors Shine:
School Counseling during a Global Pandemic. Brief. American Institutes for Research.
Trust, E. (2020, October 15). School counselors matter. The Education Trust. Retrieved May 20,
Zyromski, B., Hudson, T. D., Baker, E., & Granello, D. H. (2019). Guidance counselors or
Submit one complete copy to IRB Chair – allow at least two weeks for review
Brittany Hallis
Department: Telephone: Email:
School Counseling 440-773-3954 Britt.hallis3@gmail.com
As the investigator submitting this proposed research and signing below, I agree to conduct the
research involving human participants as presented in the protocol or modifications to it and as
approved by the School/Unit and the Institutional Review Board.
As School Dean/Unit Head, I certify that the proposed research meets School policies and
complies with the requirements for Exempt Status Certification.
Using the following format and numbering, please submit the following:
Principal Research Credentials:
1. Attach copies of current certificate of training in ethical issues involving human subject
research for the all investigators (including student researchers and principal
investigator(s); not required if the administratively-reviewed exempt project is conducted by
a unit of CSC with the intent to assess and improve unit performance.)
Consent Procedures:
6. Provide a copy of the written informed consent form to be used and signed by participants
(see Appendix IV). If no consent form will be used, the research must qualify for a waiver of
informed consent; explain how the research meets each of the following criteria required for
such waiver:
Research involves no more than minimal risk to participants;
Waiver will not adversely affect the rights and welfare of the participants;
Research could not practicably be carried out with the waiver or alteration; and
Subjects will be provided with pertinent information in some other format.
i. Research will use anonymous surveys which will minimize any risk to
students. The surveys completed will not adversely affect the rights and
welfare of participants since they are only commenting on their
perspective of their academic and social-emotional success.
Confidentiality:
7. Specifically describe if and how participant privacy and confidentiality will be maintained.
19
Benefits Of A School Counseling Program On Academic and Social-Emotional Success
Benefits of Study:
8. Describe the potential benefits of the research, for the participant and for society. Summarize
your analysis of the risk/benefit ratio for this particular research, including participant
benefits for participating.
Note: participation financial/course grade incentives are not considered a benefit, and
must be used cautiously so as to not coerce participation or to skew participation from
potential population of interest.
o Potential benefits of the research, for the participant and for society would be
to show how beneficial having a school counseling program within the
elementary school is for student academic and social-emotional success.
The following models of Informed Consent Forms are provided to guide the researcher in
developing an appropriate consent form. Inclusion of vulnerable populations may require a
more detailed form, as discussed above.
Project Title
Invitation to Participate: Your child is invited to participate in a study of (describe what is to
be studied) being conducted by (give names of investigators and their affiliations with Chadron
State and other institutions that may be involved).
Basis for Participant Selection: Your child has been selected for participation in this study
because (state reasons why. This statement should help the participant assess the nature and
importance of participation. Include in here any criteria for subject exclusion, such as age,
health restrictions, etc.)
Overall Purpose of Study: (Provide a clear description, in simple language, of the overall
purpose of the research. This should help the participant assess the importance of the study
relative to individual values.)
Explanation of Procedures: If you and your child decide to participate, your child will be
asked to do the following things: (Describe study design, description of procedures and
duration/frequency of occurrence, identification of who will perform the procedures, a statement
of where and when the research will be conducted and how much time will be required, etc.)
20
Benefits Of A School Counseling Program On Academic and Social-Emotional Success
Potential Risks and Discomforts: (Describe physical, psychological, social, legal, and
economic risks (both immediate and later), clearly and adequately, including the probability,
severity, average duration, and reversibility of any potential injury.)
Potential Benefits: (Describe direct benefits, if any. If there are no direct benefits to the
participants, explain the benefits that could result to others from this research.)
Compensation for Participant: (Describe the amount or nature of compensation, if any, for the
participant. The nature and amount of compensation must not constitute undue inducement to
participate. If no compensation is to be offered, this section may be deleted.)
Assurance of Confidentiality: (State whether or not the information will be kept confidential,
and under what conditions the participant’s information will be disclosed. Describe the ultimate
disposition of data.)
Withdrawal from the Study: Your child’s participation in this study is voluntary. Your and
your child’s decisions whether or not to participate will not affect your child’s or your (grade,
treatment, present or future relationship with the College, etc.). If you or your child decide to
participate, you and your child are free to withdraw your consent and discontinue participation at
any time.
Offer to Answer Questions: You and your child should feel free to ask questions now or at any
time during the study. If you have questions, you or your child can contact (your name and
contact information, plus that of the PI (if different). If you have questions about the right of
research subjects, contact the Chair of the Chadron State College Institutional Review Board at
1-308-432-6203.
You are voluntarily making a decision whether or not to allow your child or legal ward to
participate. Your signature indicates that, having read and understood the information
provided above, you have decided to permit your child or legal ward to participate in this
research.
Note: If the minor is between the ages of eight and nineteen, the minor must complete an
“Assent Form” as well. A copy of this assent form will be provided to the parent or legal
guardian.
22
Benefits Of A School Counseling Program On Academic and Social-Emotional Success
Project Title
I am doing a study on benefits of a school counseling program on student academic and social
emotional success). I hope to discover if there is a relationship between schools that have a
school counseling program and students’ academic and social-emotional success versus schools
that do not have a school counseling program..
If you decide to participate, this is what I will ask you to do: complete a survey at the
beginning and end of the school year regarding your level of academic and social-emotional
success.
You may feel some discomfort, such as feelings of not being successful in the academic arena
or feelings of social-emotional disarray.
(Also describe any benefit). Benefits include throughout the school year: Various topics of
academic and social-emotional success will be completed by the school counselor which will
give students the tools to take control of their academic and social-emotional success.
You are being asked to participate in this study, but you do not have to. You should talk over
with your parent or guardian whether or not you should participate. Your parent/guardian will
also be asked for permission for you to participate in this study.
If you decide to participate and then change your mind, you can tell me and you can stop at
that point.
You are making a decision whether or not to participate in this study. Please read and
understand the information above. If you agree to participate, please sign the form below
to show that you have decided to be involved in this study.
Your parent/legal guardian will be given a copy of this assent form to keep.