Comparison of offered separator with existing separator

S.No Parameter Existing Offered Without Offered With 1st Stage (31/41 2nd Stage (31/41
Top Flange Flange MV-16) SLV 5014 MV-17) SLV 4010
List of Nozzles (Ref Drg. No. 2-166-80-00266 Rev.
02)
MV-16 SLV 5014 SLV 5014 SLV 4614 Fig.1 Fig. 1

1 Price (Euro) _ 68,100 101,000 12394200 Ref Service Qty. Size Size

2 Shell OD (mm) 1282 1282 1168 14” ANSI 150# 10” ANSI 600#
S1 CO2 Inlet 1
WNRF WNRJ

3 Data, Connections & _ As per existing As per existing 14” ANSI 150# 10” ANSI 600#
Manufacturing features S2 CO2 Outlet 1
WNRF WNRJ

4 Nozzle orientation _ As per existing Not mentioned Water Drain 2” ANSI 150# 2” ANSI 600#
S3 1
(Normal) WNRF WNRJ

5 Shell thickness 6 6 Not mentioned 1” ANSI 300# 1” ANSI 600#

S4 Level Gauge 2
WNRF WNRJ

6 66544* Not mentioned** 66544 2” ANSI 300# 2” ANSI 600#

*As per hitachi recc. S5 Level Transmitter 2
WNRF WNRJ
Flow rate Kg/Hr ** Confirmation to be taken

MV-17 SLV 4010 SLV 4010 SLV 3610 20” ANSI 150# 20” ANSI 600#
S6 Manhole/handhole 1
WNRF + BLRF WNRJ + BLRJ

1 Price (Euro) _ 84,300* 95,800* 1” ANSI 300# 1” ANSI 600#

87,000# 110,400# S7 Level Switch 2
WNRF WNRJ
* Manhole flange rating 300
# Manhole flange rating 600

2 Shell OD (mm) 1046 1046 914 15342600 2” ANSI 150# 2” ANSI 600#
S8 Drain from cooler 1
WNRF WNRJ

3 Data, Connections & _ As per existing As per existing 15834000 1” ANSI 150# 1” ANSI 600#
Manufacturing features S9 Shutdown Drain 1
WNRF WNRJ

4 Nozzle orientation _ As per existing Not mentioned

5 Shell thickness 15 15 Not mentioned

6 Flow rate Kg/Hr 69514* 69514 Not mentioned** *As per hitachi recc.
** Confirmation to be taken

offered MV-16 with flange 4614 offered MV-17 with flange 3610
If the dimesnions & data of offered separators are same then
re same then how it can be operated for higher flow rate as recomm
ate as recommended by hitachi