You are on page 1of 11

46 PROSPECT / 50 THINKERS FOR A TURBULANT WORLD 2022

50
THINKERS
FOR A
TURBULENT
WORLD
Exclusive ebook edition—
all the names and all
the results
1 PROSPECT / 50 THINKERS FOR A TURBULANT WORLD 2022

50
THINKERS
FOR A
TURBULENT
WORLD

We present a list of the intellectuals coming up with the most exciting and potentially
ILLUSTRATION BY MIGUEL PORLAN

game-changing ideas in their fields—from war analysts, climate scientists and tech
regulators to the philosophers rethinking sex and gender
2 PROSPECT / 50 THINKERS FOR A TURBULANT WORLD 2022

Alaa Abdel Fattah Fawzia Amini Emily Bazelon 2020. The book charts Putin’s
Democracy activist Judge Journalist & lecturer rise to power and the
Kremlin’s influence on
Egypt was once Until August Long an expert western societies—issues that
the hope of the 2021, Fawzia commentator on have come to the fore since the
Arab Spring, but Amini was a US law and Ukraine invasion. Last year,
now with General senior judge politics, Emily Roman Abramovich sued
Abdel Fattah el-Sisi in charge dealing with women’s cases in Bazelon came to prominence Belton and her publisher for
a distinct chill has set in. Afghanistan. After the Taliban with her smart analysis on defamation over the book’s
Blogger and pro-democracy takeover, female judges and Slate’s political podcast, allegation that Abramovich
activist Alaa Abdel Fattah took prosecutors who had presided commenting on the bought Chelsea Football Club
part in the 2011 protests; over cases of male violence rollercoaster ride of the Trump on Putin’s instructions.
during the years since, he has were threatened, jailed or years and his tearing up of (Abramovich has since been
been imprisoned several murdered. Helped by human norms and conventions. Now sanctioned by the UK and sold
times. In 2021, a collection of rights barrister Helena that attention has turned to the club.) That libel suit was
his writings, some of them Kennedy, Amini, a former head the US Supreme Court’s settled; but since then,
smuggled out of jail on scraps of the Ministry of Women’s recent controversial numerous other oligarchs have
of paper, was published as You Affairs, sought refuge in judgments on abortion, guns brought lawsuits against her in
Have Not Been Defeated. This London and continued to and religion in schools, what the Observer called “a
April, he went on hunger advocate for her fellow female Bazelon has been offering pile-on from Russian
strike to draw attention to his judges and their families from expert and clear insight on billionaires on a scale this
plight. Fattah is a joint her hotel room. In May, Amini what can be an arcane and country has never witnessed.”
British-Egyptian citizen, and won the prestigious interna- polarising subject. A journalist Still she fights on.
his supporters are appealing to tional human rights award the for the New York Times
the Foreign Office to push for Lantos Prize for her continuing magazine, she also recently
his case. work to educate women and wrote a ground-breaking piece Joy Buolamwini
girls on their rights in Afghani- on children changing gender— Computer scientist
stan—work she now undertakes one of the first of its kind in
Raghib Ali through secret Zoom sessions. the US. She lectures at Yale. When she was an
Epidemiologist undergraduate at
the Georgia
When Raghib Ali Corina Amor Catherine Belton Institute of
began studying Immunologist Journalist Technology, Joy Buolamwini
the health was trying to teach a robot to
outcomes of During her PhD, Former Financial play peek-a-boo when she
British ethnic minorities, he Corina Amor Times Moscow found it couldn’t recognise her
discovered that, contrary to developed a correspondent face. When another robot
what he had assumed, revolutionary Catherine Belton failed to identify her face
non-white people had a higher experimental therapy that published Putin’s People in unless she wore a white mask,
life expectancy than whites. could help cure serious
So for Ali, there is no such illnesses. When we’re young,
thing as “white privilege” in our bodies destroy damaged
the UK—at least when it cells responsible for cancer and
comes to health. He found that ageing. As we age, these cells
“deprivation, not race” was far begin to accumulate. Two
more significant. For example, years ago, aged 27, the Spanish
people in Blackpool have a
healthy life expectancy on
scientist presented a plan to
transform a patient’s white Corina Amor’s
average 25 years less than those
in Westminster. Covid-19
blood cells, known as
T-lymphocytes, so they can breakthrough could
muddied his findings
somewhat, since ethnic
destroy these so-called
senescent, ageing cells. The
help treat chronic
minorities died at a higher
rate than the rest of the
breakthrough could help treat
chronic diseases, improve
diseases, improve quality
population—though Ali
ascribes this to social factors
quality of life and possibly even
extend human life by decades.
of life and possibly even
like patterns of shared This year, Amor set up her own extend human life
by decades
housing and risky research group in New York to
occupations. build on her findings.
3 PROSPECT / 50 THINKERS FOR A TURBULANT WORLD 2022

Even if we were living may be one of his most


important pieces of work yet.
female bodies. Her new
podcast, Visible Women,

in something like the explores how to fix the gender


data gap.

Matrix, David Chalmers Don Mee Choi


Poet & translator
argues, our experiences The Korean-
Jennifer Croft
Translator
would still be “real” and American poet
and translator Jennifer Croft has
even meaningful explores the changed how
“conjoined” histories of her people view the
nations using images, graphic art of translation.
notation and verbatim The American, who works
interviews. Her 2020 from Polish, Ukrainian and
collection DMZ Colony, Argentine Spanish, was
named for the demilitarised shortlisted for the Internation-
zone between North and al Booker Prize for her
South Korea, literally decon- translation of 2019 Nobel
she realised that there was reality—it’s an oddly structs words and letters into laureate Olga Tokarczuk’s The
racial bias in the datasets both reassuring view from one of their constituent lines in a way Books of Jacob. The book runs to
robots had been trained on. our greatest living that recalls her fragmented more than 1,100 pages and
She launched the Algorithmic philosophers, who has homeland. She became a took Croft seven years to
Justice League in 2016 to followed up his definitive MacArthur fellow complete. The pair had won
promote equitable artificial work on consciousness with in 2021, with the committee the same award in 2018—split-
intelligence and developed another significant judging that she has borne ting the prize money—for
something called “InCoding,” contribution. “witness to the effects of Tokarczuk’s novel Flights.
a series of practical steps to military violence and US Croft, whose autobiographical
make AI models more imperialism on the civilians of novel Homesick will soon be
inclusive. In 2022, as the Raj Chetty the Korean peninsula.” released in the UK, has called
possibility of sentient AI grabs Economist Speaking of the young girl she for increased awareness of the
headlines, Buolamwini’s once was in South Korea, she collaborative nature of
theory of code will be more Raj Chetty and his says: “I still converse with her translated works and co-
vital than ever. team at Harvard in my poetry.” launched the #TranslatorsOn-
built an TheCover campaign, which
impressive argues the profession deserves
David Chalmers data-tracking tool at the start Caroline Criado Perez greater visibility.
Philosopher of the pandemic. Feminist thinker
& cognitive scientist Tracktherecovery.org took
masses of anonymised Caroline Criado Mark Elliott
Are you living in a information to work out the Perez successfully Legal scholar
simulation? It is a impact the virus was having— campaigned for a
familiar question and continues to have—on woman to appear The past few years
for philosophers employment, business revenue on the £10 note in 2015, while have seen
and science fiction fans. and consumer spending in the her campaign for a statue of a constitutional
Chalmers, in his new book US. They could even measure suffragette to be erected in vandalism. Mark
Reality+, brings his formidable which sorts of people were Parliament Square led to one Elliott, chair of the Cambridge
philosophical armoury to bear spending their stimulus of Millicent Fawcett being law faculty, former adviser to
on answering it. Even if we cheques from the federal unveiled in 2018. But her parliament’s Constitution
were living in something like government. The data, broken biggest contribution has been Committee and author of the
the Matrix, he argues, our down by income group, her game-changing 2019 book blog Public Law for Everyone,
experiences would still be industry and location, has Invisible Women, which has offered indispensable
“real” and even meaningful. In been invaluable in informing describes how gender bias in analysis of the Tories’ alarming
a world where worries about the economic debate on big data collection negatively project to tear up the Human
tech are becoming more Covid-19 and the price of affects women. For example, Rights Act, undermine the
© IBL/SHUTTERSTOCK

dominant—and Facebook, lockdowns. Chetty has during the pandemic many judicial review of illegal
now renamed Meta, is previously won the John Bates women working in hospitals government decisions and
building an all-encompassing Clark medal for outstanding found that their PPE was violate international law by
“metaverse” using virtual economists under 40. But this designed for male rather than reneging on the Brexit treaty.
4 PROSPECT / 50 THINKERS FOR A TURBULANT WORLD 2022

For UK constitutional experts


Elliott’s work is a must read.
an emeritus professor of war
studies at King’s College Across his deeply
He has shown that you can
remain signed up to rights in
London—his outlet of choice is
now the Substack newsletter researched and
principle while making it far
harder to enforce them in
Comment is Freed, run jointly
with his son, Prospect
imaginatively bold novels,
practice—and do immense
damage in the process.
columnist Sam Freedman.
The elder Freedman’s
Abdulrazak Gurnah has
expertise on nuclear warfare
will, it is to be hoped, remain
charted the influence
Christine Emba
Writer & journalist
purely theoretical. of imperialism on
east Africa
Five years into the Gita Gopinath
#MeToo move- Economist
ment, feminists
are becoming The International
increasingly critical of the Monetary Fund
sexual revolution. In her new has a crucial role
book Rethinking Sex, Christine to play in
Emba, a columnist for the stabilising any crisis. So it is
Washington Post, quotes both reassuring to know that, as the Nobel in autumn 2021. Cited and making a bold case for the
Andrea Dworkin on the left world economy suffers the by the committee for his democratisation of science.
and Roger Scruton on the fallout from the war in Ukraine, “uncompromising and One year on, AlphaFold has
right to argue that the culture one of the IMF’s central figures, compassionate penetration of provided researchers with
of dating apps and easy Gita Gopinath, proved herself the effects of colonialism and almost a million protein
hook-ups damages women. so thoroughly during the the fate of the refugee,” he is structure predictions.
A more casual attitude to pandemic. Her statements also a master of evoking the
relationships once seemed during the coronavirus crisis sights and smells of his home
liberating, she argues, but do showed a willingness to rethink island, Zanzibar. If you don’t Frances Haugen
we need boundaries around the Washington fiscal know his work, start with Facebook whistleblower
our desires to meaningfully orthodoxy that can handicap Paradise, an account of a slave
fulfil them? Emba’s thought- multilateral institutions. Her boy called Yusuf, and then When Frances
provoking polemic has shifted academic work on the role of Desertion, set during the 1964 Haugen quit as a
the debate, and even those the US dollar has been hugely Zanzibar revolution. product manager
who disagree with her important in understanding for Facebook in
solutions for re-sacralising sex the role of global trade and May last year, she took tens of
may recognise the loneliness finance. She is now the IMF’s Demis Hassabis thousands of internal
at the root of the problems first deputy managing director AI researcher documents along with her.
she identifies. and will play a huge role in the The documents became the
turbulent times ahead for the Last July main source of a Wall Street
global economy. DeepMind, the Journal investigation into
Lawrence Freedman AI research Facebook last September,
War studies expert company of which alleged that the social
Abdulrazak Gurnah which Demis Hassabis is media giant was aware that its
The UK’s leading Novelist co-founder and CEO, caused a platform is being used to incite
expert on military revolution in the life sciences. violence and harm teenagers’
strategy quickly Across his deeply It published the code behind mental health. She also
became the go-to researched and AlphaFold, software claimed it has failed to curb
voice on Ukraine. His analysis imaginatively developed using machine misinformation and allowed
of the latest developments on bold novels, learning that can accurately high-profile figures to flout its
the ground and the relative Abdulrazak Gurnah has predict how proteins fold. By rules. Haugen disclosed her
strength of both sides has charted the influence of sharing rather than hoarding identity in a 60 Minutes
proven indispensable since various kinds of imperialism— this precious information, interview last October, and has
Putin chose to launch the most Arab, German, British—on east Hassabis handed scientists the testified before the US
dangerous European conflict Africa. Always respected but tools to find new drug Congress and UK parliament
since 1945. Having sat on the hardly a household name, treatments in record time, advocating for greater
inquiry into the Iraq War— Gurnah was thrust into the supercharging research in government regulation of
serving in more recent years as spotlight when he won the almost every area of biology Facebook.
5 PROSPECT / 50 THINKERS FOR A TURBULANT WORLD 2022

Fiona Hill family made billions through Christian faith and mental tion 80,000 Hours, named for
Foreign affairs expert selling first Valium and then ill-health, as well as the amount of time we work
damaging opioids. In this homophobia and transphobia over a lifetime, advises
Born to a miner prize-winning book, the among African Americans. He individuals on which career
and a nurse in journalist revealed that the is the first rapper ever to win a path will help them do the
County Durham, Sacklers, known for their Pulitzer Prize—for 2017’s most good. His new book,
Fiona Hill’s philanthropy, raked in $13bn album Damn. His headline slot What We Owe the Future,
testimony at Donald Trump’s through Purdue Pharma’s at Glastonbury this year, when advocates a philosophy of
first impeachment hearing in aggressive marketing of he wore a diamond crown of long-termism, arguing we all
2019 briefly made her one of OxyContin, a drug which thorns, confirmed his genius. have a moral obligation to save
the most famous faces in her contributed to the opioid our dying planet.
adopted America. The foreign crisis that’s claimed 500,000
policy expert, who advised lives in the US. In March, the Patricia Lockwood
presidents George W Bush and British Museum was the latest Novelist & essayist Darren McGarvey
Barack Obama before Trump, cultural institution to cut ties Writer & rapper
accused the Trump administra- with the Sacklers. Keefe’s new If anyone can
tion of pursuing a shadow collection, Rogues: True Stories claim to have “If all the best
foreign policy strategy of Grifters, Killers, Rebels and written the people are in all
intended to benefit the Crooks, was released in June. definitive the top jobs, then
president rather than US fictional account of the why is Britain
national interests. Hill, author internet, then it is Patricia such a fucking bin fire?”
of Mr Putin: Operative in the Kendrick Lamar Lockwood. Her 2021 novel No Author Darren McGarvey is a
Kremlin, remains one of the Rapper One Is Talking About This former rapper-in-residence at
most compelling voices on explores life and grief in the the Scottish Violence
Russia, warning that Ukraine is Lamar is the online world and asks whether Reduction Unit, where he
the frontline in a hot war on outstanding there are some things that can performed under the stage
western democracy. Putin, she popular musician never be turned into social name Loki. He grew up in
argues, will not stop until he of our time, media fodder. Lockwood first poverty in Glasgow and his
has won. representing a bridge between became famous when her 2013 mother suffered from
the hyper-masculine gangster poem “Rape Joke” went viral. alcoholism. He won the Orwell
rap of his native Compton, Los She has since published two Prize in 2018 for his debut
Patrick Radden Keefe Angeles, and something more poetry collections and has book Poverty Safari and his
Journalist & writer reflective, as he reckons with written hilarious takedowns of second book, The Social
the social issues especially John Updike and Karl Ove Distance Between Us, was
Few stories have affecting young men. His latest Knausgård. Her 2017 memoir, published this June. McGarvey
as much drama as album—his fourth consecutive Priestdaddy, describes her argues that the vast distance—
Empire of Pain, triumph—is an honest, if Midwest childhood—her geographic, economic and
Keefe’s 2021 abrasive, exploration of black father was a Lutheran pastor cultural—between the people
exposé of how the Sackler trauma, sexual abuse, his who converted to become a making decisions and the
married Catholic priest. people affected by them is
destroying British politics.
© REUTERS / ALAMY STOCK PHOTO, MATT CROSSICK / ALAMY STOCK PHOTO, SHUTTERSTOCK

William MacAskill
Philosopher Lisa McGee
Writer
If you want to
make a differ- The Northern
ence, should you Irish playwright
spend your time and screenwriter
working for a charity, or is the brain
making a fortune in the City behind Derry Girls, the hit
and then donating half your Channel 4 comedy series that

Few stories have as income—thus saving more


lives in the process? This is the
depicts teenagers growing up
in Derry during the 1990s,
much drama as Patrick sort of question MacAskill has
been wrestling with for years,
amid the final years of the
Troubles. The show, which
Radden Keefe’s exposé using rational arguments to ended in May this year on an

of the Sackler family


uncover the optimum moral emotional note with the
course. MacAskill’s organisa- signing of the Good Friday
6 PROSPECT / 50 THINKERS FOR A TURBULANT WORLD 2022

agreement, has been praised and its impact on small island the US failed to take account of the bestselling cars in the
for its humour and honest nations like her own. A lawyer of local structures of UK—paving the way for the
depiction of how people coped by trade, she has united accountability. Corruption phasing out of petrol cars due
with the conflict. It is the progressive movements in and cynicism flourished— to start in 2030.
most-watched series in Barbados. Having practised a Afghans quickly realised that
Northern Ireland since pragmatic politics to get into the flashier a new government
modern records began—a power, she has been described building was, the less authority Pap Ndiaye
mural of the main characters is as “fearless” in using her it had in reality—and the Historian and politician
now a popular tourist mandate—for example when rebellion was fuelled. Her
attraction in Derry. In June, calling for reparations for the sobering analysis is found in After Emmanuel
McGee was awarded freedom slave trade from European more detail in Order and the Macron was
of the city. countries. State in Afghanistan (2016), re-elected as
vital reading for any occupying French president
force contemplating nation- in April, he surprised everyone
Stefano Mancuso Samuel Moyn building. by appointing Ndiaye, the
Botanist Political theorist French-Senegalese historian,
as education minister.
Should plants Putin’s invasion Elon Musk An expert on African-
have rights? of Ukraine has Tech entrepreneur American history and the
Stefano Mancuso, been met with African diaspora in France,
an Italian near-universal He faced serious he is one of the founders of
philosopher of plant intelli- censure in the west, and opposition with Black Studies à la française,
gence, is one of the most rightly so. But is the invasion his aggressive bid a subject he wrote about in
persuasive advocates for “yes.” also being used to rehabilitate to buy Twitter 2008’s The Black Condition.
His book The Nation of Plants, failed ideas about how the (see Ethan Zuckerman on He was also head of France’s
published in English last year, world works? Samuel Moyn, a p80) and was mocked by Joe Museum of Immigration.
even contains a charter professor of history and Biden for his hubristic plans to Attacked by the far right
including “the right to clean jurisprudence at Yale and colonise Mars. But the help for his support of causes like
water, soil and atmosphere.” author of last year’s Humane: Musk has given to Ukraine anti-racism, feminism and
As leader of the International How the United States Aban- with his Starlink system has climate action, Ndiaye is
Laboratory of Plant Neurobiol- doned Peace and Reinvented been genuinely impressive. in fact something of a
ogy, he argues that a more War, argues that the worst Starlink (part of his space moderate in his tone,
expansive view of intelligence possible response to the crisis exploration company SpaceX) claiming that he does not
can reveal to us the wonder of would be to set Russia up as uses private satellites—more “approve of moralising and
the botanical world. Plants the great adversary of our than 2,000 of them—to keep sectarian discourse.”
may be less mobile than we time. Why not focus on the country’s internet As France is torn apart by
are, but they have been around repairing our own democra- connected and out of reach of political extremes, Ndiaye
far longer and are essential if cies, rather than lapsing into Russian attacks. In addition, shows the value of calm
we want to save the world from Cold War-era certainties his Tesla Model Y is now one erudition.
climate catastrophe. which were questionable even
when they were coined?

Mia Mottley
Politician Jennifer Brick Murtazashvili
Afghanistan expert
In the Barbados
general election When the Taliban
in January, the retook Kabul last
prime minister
Mia Mottley—the first female
summer,
everyone was Samuel Moyn argues
leader of the country—won
re-election by a landslide. The
searching for answers about
why it happened. Murtaza-
that the worst possible
previous November she made
history by removing Queen
shvili, an academic and
researcher with years of
response to the war in
Elizabeth as head of state.
Since first coming to power,
on-the-ground experience in
Afghanistan, provided a
Ukraine would be to set
Mottley has made powerful compelling thesis: in trying to Russia up as the great
adversary of our time
interventions on the world impose models of democratic
stage about climate change engagement from the outside,
7 PROSPECT / 50 THINKERS FOR A TURBULANT WORLD 2022

Not everyone is essence, its morality and its


future. Pannick is now being
to hold the former president
accountable for his assault on

comfortable with what briefed by the Home Office to


defend the Rwanda deporta-
democracy. Raskin’s new book,
Unthinkable, focuses on the

Paul B Preciado has to say: tion plan in the courts—even


though he voted against
traumatic 45 days when his
son, just 25 and suffering from

an invitation to speak at elements of the relevant


legislation in the Lords. As he
depression, committed suicide
shortly before 6th January
one annual conference explains in his lectures, a
lawyer is just a taxi for hire.
2021. He is chief sponsor of
legislation that would create a
led to heckling commission capable of
removing a president under
Paul B Preciado the 25th amendment. Having
Philosopher lost his son, Raskin refuses to
lose his country too.
Women should go
on a “uterus
strike” and we Timothy Snyder
should stop Historian
Naomi Oreskes But Otto, one of the authors of defining sex at birth—these are
Historian of science the most recent report from just two of the radical ideas One of the
the Intergovernmental Panel proposed by Paul B Preciado, clearest voices on
Why trust on Climate Change, is one of continental Europe’s Putin’s invasion
science? The changing that. She is the most original thinkers on of Ukraine,
pandemic might driving force behind World gender. A self-proclaimed Timothy Snyder, author of 15
have laid all Weather Attribution, an “gender migrant,” Preciado books including the ground-
doubts to rest for some, but as international project working uses his own experience of breaking Bloodlands: Europe
Harvard historian of science to prove how far not only transitioning from female to Between Hitler and Stalin, has a
Oreskes argues in her new patterns in weather but male to interrogate the power deep understanding of
book, which takes that specific events are influenced relationships latent in gender Ukraine’s history. For
question as its title, scientists by climate change. It’s an and sexuality. Not everyone is centuries, he says, it has been
sincerely believed in now innovative area of climate comfortable with what bruised by the ambitions of
discredited theories like science that will have very real Preciado has to say: an neighbouring empires. The
phrenology and Limited implications for insurance invitation to speak at the École current war is an expression of
Energy Theory (the latter of companies—as well as for de la Cause Freudienne’s Putin’s imperial mindset. But
which claimed that women countries arguing they deserve annual conference in 2019 led Snyder is not only a student of
didn’t have the physical ability compensation for the to him being heckled before he history; he is a shrewd analyst
to both bear children and be climate-related devastation could finish. With recent essay of how western leaders are
educated). As such, how can they are experiencing. collections translated into responding to the present war
we be sure that current English, Preciado may soon be too. Above all, he warns,
scientific approaches won’t be ruffling feathers in the European and North
considered as absurd in 100 David Pannick anglophone world too. American leaders must not tell
years’ time? Oreskes’s answer is Barrister Ukraine how and when to
to further diversify the make peace. Great powers
© DUILIO PIAGGESI/IPA/SHUTTERSTOCK, NEIL HALL/EPA-EFE/SHUTTERSTOCK

scientific community—and to The UK’s Jamie Raskin have decided its fate for too
maintain a sceptical approach outstanding Politician long.
to all claims of absolute public law
scientific truth. barrister repre- A former
sented Gina Miller in the constitutional law Oleksiy Sorokin
Supreme Court and beat the professor who has Journalist
Friederike Otto government—twice—when it represented
Climatologist tried to sideline parliament Maryland’s eighth congres- After Ukraine’s
during the Brexit process. He sional district since 2017, first English-lan-
The extent to presented the most recent set Raskin led the second House guage online
which a particular of the prestigious Hamlyn law impeachment trial of Donald newspaper the
flood, heatwave, lectures, formerly given by Trump in the wake of the Kyiv Post was interfered with
drought or storm such luminaries as lords Capitol insurrection. He is by its oligarch owners, in
is linked to climate change has Denning and Bingham. His now on the select committee November last year Sorokin
never been well understood. subject was advocacy—its investigating the siege, seeking was one of several journalists
8 PROSPECT / 50 THINKERS FOR A TURBULANT WORLD 2022

who left to establish the Kyiv


Independent. Led by editor
such is the heat around the
trans debate that the author of By challenging green
Olga Rudenko, the Independ-
ent was originally set up to
Material Girls, who believes in
the importance of biological orthodoxy about the
uncover the corruption at the
heart of the Ukrainian
sex distinctions between men
and women, felt forced to
simplicity of the energy
government—including under
the watch of Volodymyr
resign from her position. Stock
is now at the vanguard of a
transition, Helen Thompson
Zelensky. It has since gained a
new purpose exposing the
movement supported by JK
Rowling and others. Often
presents an alarming
horrors of Russia’s brutal accused of bigotry, Stock account of the
climate crisis
invasion. Reliant on crowd- stresses her target is not trans
funding, Sorokin’s work people but a strain of trans
keeping the Independent afloat ideology. Whether she will be
is a testament to the bravery of proved right or not is an open
the journalists who have found question. More certain is that
their home turned into the her case has become a test of
frontline of a war. institutions’ willingness to
defend free speech.
It means purging former though, the charges are
Karen Steyn colonies of all vestiges of trumped up—and Teltumbde
Judge Anna Della Subin cultural imperialism, and has was targeted by Narendra
Writer been applied to institutions in Modi’s government for his
What protection the west like museums and advocacy of Dalit rights and
should a Why would whole areas of study like criticism of the Hindutva
journalist have to anyone want to philosophy. But in his bristling ideology sweeping the
pursue a story in worship Prince new takedown, Against country. A sophisticated
the public interest? This Philip? In her Decolonisation, Táíwò, a thinker, Teltumbde is the
question has just been subversive and often Nigerian professor of African author of 2018’s Republic of
answered in the High Court by entertaining book Accidental thought at Cornell, argues that Caste, which argues that his
Justice Karen Steyn who, in Gods, Anna Della Subin traces it is not possible to create a country’s free-market reforms
her libel judgment in favour of the tangled history of men “pure” African philosophy or are not, as some argue, the
Observer journalist Carole who end up being granted artistic tradition, given how solution to inequality between
Cadwalladr over Brexit-backer divine status against their will. entwined both are with castes, and that positive
Arron Banks, has struck a blow Often the story involves western ideas. After rightfully discrimination for Dalits in
for freedom of expression that colonial conquest, with the rejecting political imperial- fact only reinforces unfairness
recalls the famous 1964 defeated people turning the ism, he says, Africa should and thus should be abolished.
Sullivan judgment in the US. (usually) white male hero into embrace the benefits of
As the court found then, the a god as a form of obeisance modernity—including
press needs to be allowed to but also covert resistance. democracy, a free market and Helen Thompson
make mistakes if it is acting in Oppressed people in Jamaica the rule of law—which Táíwò Political scientist
good faith. That is especially read a 1931 National Geographic considers universal values
true of issues of public article about the crowning of rather than parochial imposi- Thompson is one
importance like the financing Haile Selassie I of Ethiopia and tions from the west. of the most
of political campaigns. All eyes took him for a “black divine.” fascinating
now turn to the next judgment Subin’s book has many lessons guides to the
Steyn will write—in the case of we can learn about the Anand Teltumbde challenges currently afflicting
Vardy v Rooney. hero-worship of leaders in our Dalit rights activist the world economy. The
current strongman age. Putin Cambridge professor deploys
the Eternal, anyone? In 2020, the her vast range of specialisms—
Kathleen Stock Indian scholar geopolitics, energy, monetary
Philosopher and civil rights policy—to document the
Olúfémi O Táíwò campaigner failures that led to the
˙
A feminist Philosopher Anand Teltumbde was financial crash and, through
philosophy arrested for allegedly inciting the course of Brexit, Trump
professor at the The word caste-based violence and and Ukraine, have presented
University of “decolonisation” associating with Maoist the west with fundamental
Sussex might seem an unlikely is very of the groups. According to the US questions. The next immense
target for student protests. But moment. ­ and human rights groups, issue is the climate crisis.
9 PROSPECT / 50 THINKERS FOR A TURBULANT WORLD 2022

Thompson, by challenging might all be living in the Bari Weiss White’s sharp wit and, in the
green orthodoxy about the background of other people’s Journalist face of harassment and abuse,
simplicity of the energy lives. her courage in highlighting a
transition, presents a more In 2020, the New new form of online power.
alarming account than we York Times
have become accustomed to. Josh Wardle opinion writer
Best known for the (recently Software engineer Bari Weiss Lea Ypi
wound down) Talking Politics resigned, saying her colleagues Political theorist
podcast, her new book Sometimes it’s had bullied her for
Disorder is a must read. the simplest ideas “wrongthink” and that The Kant scholar
that prove to be “intellectual curiosity—let and LSE professor
the most effec- alone risk-taking—is now a of political theory
Joachim Trier tive. That’s certainly true for liability” at the paper. Weiss Lea Ypi grew up
Film director the online game Wordle, set up her own forum called in 1980s and 1990s Albania,
created by US-based Welsh Common Sense, which has during the country’s transition
A lot of people developer Josh Wardle. since become a lively home for out of communism. In her
have written Originally published in “cancelled” writers. It has 2021 memoir, Free: Coming of
about the January 2021 to entertain platformed interesting Age at the End of History, she
millennial family and friends, it was alternative views: its podcast describes her childhood
experience in the 21st century: made public in October and with Amy Cooper, the Central hero-worship of Albania’s
fewer have shown us how it soon the one-a-day, five-letter, Park dog walker whose life was communist leader Enver
looks. Norwegian director six-guesses word puzzle had ruined by accusations of Hoxha and Joseph Stalin. Her
Joachim Trier was depicting captured the imaginations of racism, was a coup. But family hid their Muslim
the lives of aimless millions, before being scooped perhaps Weiss’s greatest heritage and also concealed
20-somethings feeling their up by the New York Times for success has been the from Ypi that her great-
fraught way through over $1m. Despite furious noticeable change at the NYT, grandfather was Xhafer Ypi,
adulthood long before the arguments over whether where more voices sceptical of the former prime minister she
idea of “the millennial certain offensive words had current progressive thinking had been taught at school to
experience” was a thing. been banned by the newspa- are now published. despise. Her memoir critiques
Completing his loose trilogy per, at a time when many have both the repression of
of films set in Oslo with this become jaded by the demands communism and the
year’s award-winning The of social media and sceptical Molly White inequalities and violence that
Worst Person in the World, Trier of the web as a platform that Software engineer she witnessed as a teenager
has brought his own aesthetic still offers meaningful after Albania became
sensibility to a life of boxy connection, Wordle and its When capitalist.
apartments and multiple creator reminded us that the cryptocurrency
dead-end jobs—and given internet can still be fun. went mainstream,
visual form to the commonly Just don’t tell anyone your Molly White got Profiles written by David
held millennial worry that we starting word. worried. The software McAllister, Sarah Collins, Alex
engineer and prolific Dean, Ellen Halliday, Emily
Wikipedia editor had observed Lawford and Sameer Rahim
the hype around blockchain,
the technology underpinning
cryptocurrencies, with some
detachment. But when
ordinary people began to lose
money to dodgy schemes, she
felt compelled to challenge the
received wisdom of the
cryptobros. White set up Web3
Is Going Just Great at the end
© TT NEWS AGENCY / ALAMY STOCK PHOTO

of 2021 to document the

Wordle creator misinformation,


mismanagement and full-
Josh Wardle reminded blown scams proliferating in
the world of Web3—the
us that the internet decentralised next stage of the
Continue reading for
the readers’ choice
can still be fun
internet, based on blockchain.
The endeavour has showcased for top thinker 2022
10 PROSPECT / 50 THINKERS FOR A TURBULANT WORLD 2022

TOP THINKERS

THE WORLD’S TOP


THINKERS RESULT
From philosophers on gender to anti-poverty campaigners, here’s who readers voted
for in our annual list of top thinkers

T
he votes are in and the people on the Prospect podcast for some choice O Táíwò, author of Reconsidering Repara-
have spoken. From a list of 50 top arguments—and language.) tions, both published this year. For the re-
thinkers we presented in the sum- Alaa Abdel Fattah and Anand Tel- cord, we meant to nominate the former,
mer issue, our readers chose the philos- tumbde are both prisoners of conscience. though the latter was suggested to us as
opher Kathleen Stock as the winner— Abdel Fattah is a British-Egyptian who well. Kudos to the eagle-eyed voter who
and by a significant margin. Stock’s 2021 was involved in the 2011 uprisings in Cai- nominated Olúfẹ́mi Táíwò and then in
book Material Girls argues that feminists ro, and has since been highly critical of the “who we missed” section suggested
should be worried that the biological dif- Sisi’s autocratic regime. He was impris- Olúfẹ́mi O Táíwò. In any case, apologies
ferences between men and women, and oned in December on charges of “broad- to both Olúfẹ́mis. Maybe they’ll both be
thus the sex-based rights of women, are casting false news.” Currently on hun- on the list next year. ♦
being eroded by “trans activist think- ger strike, Abdel Fattah has been writing
ing.” Last year she resigned from the Uni- from prison on scraps of smuggled paper.
versity of Sussex after protests by activ- Teltumbde, meanwhile, is a respected
ists about her gender-critical position, Dalit rights activist and thinker from In-
turning her into an emblem for open in- dia, who has criticised his government’s
quiry and free speech. You can read more Hindu nationalist ideology.
about her argument, and the opposite Two different historical political con-
point of view, in the debate she conduct- flicts have gained new resonance with
ed with trans lawyer Robin White for our current events. Lisa McGee wrote the
winter double issue, which can be found comedy gem Derry Girls, about teenag-
on the Prospect website. ers growing up during the Troubles in
Further down the list is Caroline Cri- Northern Ireland. The show ended its
ado Perez, a feminist who has analysed run on Channel 4 this year in an era when
with incontrovertible detail how we live the Irish border has become a flashpoint
in a world built for men. From crash test once more. Lea Ypi’s moving memoir
dummies to doctors’ PPE during the Free told of her childhood in a commu-
pandemic, the default for manufactur- nist Albania dominated by Russia.
ers is male. Already her work has had re- Looking to the future, philosopher
al-world impact in pressuring companies William MacAskill argues in an upcom-
to do better. ing work that we have a moral obligation
Just above her is anti-poverty cam- to look to the future if we are to save our-
paigner Darren McGarvey, who beat selves from environmental disaster. (A
fellow nominee Kendrick Lamar to be- review is upcoming in these pages.) The
come the first rapper to appear in our solution of another top thinker, Elon
top 10. McGarvey’s new book, The Social Musk, is simple: colonise Mars and use
Distance Between Us, lambasts the peo- its resources to power our lifestyle—pre-
ILLUSTRATION BY MIGUEL PORLAN

ple who run the country for having lit- sumably until we leave it uninhabitable
tle awareness of the desperation at the and move onto another planet.
bottom end of the social scale. For Mc- Lastly, a mea culpa: an editorial mis-
Garvey, brought up on the south side of hap in last issue’s thinkers’ list saw us mix
Glasgow, everything in Britain comes up philosopher Olúfẹ́mi Táíwò, author
down to class. (Look up his appearance of Against Decolonisation, with Olúfẹ́mi

You might also like