Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract: Whole lettuce plants were used to evaluate the effect of leaf age (and
exposure level) on ascorbic acid (A), chlorophyll (C), microbial quality (M), colour
and overall visual quality of fresh butterlettuce exposed at three isothermal
environmental conditions: 0-2, 10-12 and 20-22ºC during first hours after harvest.
Temperature, leaf age and time significantly affect the quality parameters under
study. Detriment of lettuce quality was detected in the first few hours after harvest.
In general terms, decreases in quality indices were higher at higher temperature and
time. Outer leaves (older leaves) resulted the most affected tissue by exposure
conditions, while inner leaves (younger) were the least affected.
Keywords: lettuce, leaf age, temperature, quality indices.
1
XII Congreso CYTAL - AATA
Facultad de Ciencias de la Alimentación, UNER,
Entre Ríos, Argentina, 7-9 de octubre 2009
2
XII Congreso CYTAL - AATA
Facultad de Ciencias de la Alimentación, UNER,
Entre Ríos, Argentina, 7-9 de octubre 2009
between ZONE and TIME factors. This fact implies in lettuce exposed to different temperature
that each zone have a particular behavior during conditions. The significant differences detected
postharvest. In this way, while the external zone between zones at harvest were maintained as time
exhibited chlorophyll pigments degradation advanced at the three evaluated temperatures; i.e. at
throughout 24 hours at any assayed temperature, the each sampling time and at the three assayed
middle and internal zones showed no chlorophyll temperatures, outer and mid leaves resulted more
content changes during such period. Fig. 1 depicts green (lower a* values) than inner ones. Samples
the evolution of TC in external zone during 24 exposed to the highest temperature registered the
hours after harvest. lowest absolute value of a* parameter during the
60 sampling time in the three lettuce zones. Significant
decreases in the absolute value of a* were observed
(mg / 100 g fresh weight)
50
Chlorophyll content
40
during 24 hours in the three zones and the three
analyzed temperatures and the highest decrease was
30
observed in internal zone at 20-22ºC.
20
10 Table 2 – a* value in external (E), middle (M) and
0 internal (I) zones of lettuce heads during 24 hours of
exposition to three different isothermal conditions (0-2,
0 5 10 15 20 25
10-12 and 20-22ºC).
Time (hours)
Time (h) Zone a* values
Figure 1. Chlorophyll content evolution in external zone E -19,73 ± 0,83
of lettuce heads during 24 hours of exposure to 0 M -19,25 ± 1,28
I -16,30 ± 1,25
isothermal conditions: (U)20ºC; (×)10ºC; (♦)0ºC. 0-2ºC 10-12ºC 20-22ºC
-19,37 ± -19,35 ± -18,89 ±
E
Differences in chlorophyll degradation between 0,32 0,56 0,24
-19,49 ± -18,85 ± -18,90 ±
zones could be related to the higher exposure of 3 M
1,52 0,56 1,07
outer leaves to environmental factors such as light I
-15,89 ± -13,47 ± -12,88 ±
and oxygen, which could fasten pigment 0,88 3,86 1,52
-19,51 ± -18,13 ± -18,93 ±
deterioration. As a response to harvest stress, when E
1,09 2,37 0,03
water and nutrient supply was cut off, outer leaves 6 M
-18,43 ± -16,84 ± -18,03 ±
0,90 0,21 1,61
(the most mature leaves of lettuce head, and leaves -12,86 ± -12,49 ± -12,43 ±
I
that are also near its physiological senescence) 1,04 0,58 2,41
could trigger different physiological responses. At -19,32 ± -19,07 ± -18,87 ±
E
0,34 0,35 0,06
harvest, senescence process is induced artificially -19,14 ± -17,94 ± -17,44 ±
24 M
as a result of the removal of nutrient supplies (Page 0,16 2,26 0,40
-15,26 ± -12,22 ± -11,06 ±
et al. 2001). As a rapid response, the degradation of I
0,76 1,86 2,04
TC was evident in outer leaves, which started
showing signs of chlorophyll losses. A decrease in the absolute value of a* indicates a
Colour reduction of green colour mainly associated with
chlorophyll degradation (Rico et al. 2008).
Lightness parameter (L*) in lettuce at harvest However, in the present work, decreases in
showed significant differences among zones (Table chlorophyll concentration were not detected in
1). The highest L* value was observed in internal internal zone while changes in a* parameter were
zone, decreasing towards the external one. The detected in this zone. Del Nobile et al. (2006),
exposure of lettuce heads to different temperature studying the effect of film packaging on quality and
conditions during 24 hours did not introduce shelf life of lettuce, found the highest changes of a*
significant changes in L* parameter as a function of parameter in inner leaves and associated this result
time or temperature (data not shown). Other authors to the highest susceptibility of this leaves to
(Han et al. 2004; Martínez-Romero et al. 2008) also browning.
found for lettuce no significant changes in L* Blueness/yellowness parameter (b*) in lettuce at
parameter throughout storage time. harvest resulted positive in all zones indicating the
Redness/greenness parameter (a*) in lettuce at predominance of yellow in this scale. Significant
harvest resulted in a negative value in all zones differences between zones were found in b* values
indicating the predominance of green colour in the at harvest, being higher (more yellow) in inner
product. Results showed significant differences leaves than in mid and outer leaves (Table 1). b*
between a* values in each zone at harvest, being values obtained for lettuce zones during time of
more negative (more green) in external and middle exposure to different temperatures are presented in
zones (without significant differences between Table 3. During the sampling time no changes were
them) than in internal one (Table 1). Green colour registered in b* values as time advanced at any
of inner leaves is less intense and this fact was analyzed temperature and zone. Moreover,
reflected in a* values obtained for each zone. Table significant differences in b* values detected among
2 presents a* values obtained during sampling time lettuce zones at harvest were maintained as time
3
XII Congreso CYTAL - AATA
Facultad de Ciencias de la Alimentación, UNER,
Entre Ríos, Argentina, 7-9 de octubre 2009
3,0
External
stress induced by harvest (Davey et al. 2000; Lee et
2,0
Middle
al. 1982).
1,0 Internal Sensorial quality
0,0
Table 4 shows changes in overall visual quality
0 10 20
(OVQ) of lettuce head during 24 hours of the
Temperature(ºC) exposure to different temperatures. Panelists did not
detect significant changes in OVQ of lettuce heads
Figure 2. Microbial counts change (LOG(N24/N0) ) in exposed to optimal temperature. When lettuce
external, middle and internal zone of lettuce heads after heads were exposed to abusive temperatures,
24 hours of exposure to isothermal conditions. panelists detected significant decreases in OVQ at
24 hours of exposure (p= 0.0021 and p< 0.0001,
respectively). Main differences were registered at
24 h in texture quality of lettuce heads exposed to
4
XII Congreso CYTAL - AATA
Facultad de Ciencias de la Alimentación, UNER,
Entre Ríos, Argentina, 7-9 de octubre 2009
10 and 20ºC. Panelists detected moderate losses of age on the evolution of quality indices is of
turgidity and texture. Another phenomenon fundamental importance for producers because they
detected by panelists was the degree of browning can take decisions in order of this differential
developed in the base of the lettuce due to the cut behavior according to degree of development of
made during picking. At 24 h of exposure, lettuces tissue. In this way they could use different lettuce
at 10-12 and 20-22ºC presented cut bases with leaves for different uses as fresh consumption,
moderate and objectionable browning to severe minimally processed products, among others.
browning (rusty-brown), respectively. At optimal
exposed temperature, only slight and not ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
objectionable browning in the cut base was This work was supported by Consejo Nacional de
detected. After 24 h of storage the best quality Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas (CONICET),
attributes were observed in lettuces exposed to Agencia Nacional de Promoción Científica y
optimal temperature immediately after harvest. Tecnológica (Secyt), and Universidad Nacional de
Table 4 – Overall visual quality of lettuce head during the
Mar del Plata (UNMDP).
exposure to three different isothermal conditions (0-2 ºC,
10-12 ºC and 20-22 ºC). REFERENCES
Agüero, M. V., M. V. Barg, A. Yommi, A. Camelo
Time (h) Initial OVQ and S. I. Roura (2008), Postharvest Changes in
0 9 ± 0.1 Water Status and Chlorophyll Content of lettuce
0-2ºC 10-12ºC 20-22ºC
(Lactuca sativa L.) and their Relationship with
3 8.9 ± 0.1 8.9 ± 0.2 8.9 ± 0.1
6 8.9 ± 0.1 8.8 ± 0.1 8.7 ± 0.3 Overall Visual Quality, Journal of Food Science,
24 8.5 ± 0.5 8.1 ± 0.3 7.5 ± 0.6 Vol. 73(1), pp. 176-185.
Davey, M. W., M. Van Montagu, D. Inzé, M.
Sanmartin, A. Kanellis, N. Smirnoff, I. J. J.
CONCLUSION Benzie, J. J. Strain, D. Favell and J. Fletcher
Leaf age had a significant effect on the initial (2000), Plant L-ascorbic acid: chemistry,
greenness and nutritional indices of butterhead function, metabolism, bioavailability and effects
lettuce. Older leaves (external zone) showed higher of processing, Journal of the Science of Food and
chlorophyll concentration and lower L* and a* Agriculture, Vol. 80, pp. 825-860.
values, than younger leaves characterized by Del Nobile, M. A., A. Baiano, A. Benedetto and L.
clearest colour (high L* and a* values and low Massignan (2006), Respiration rate of minimally
chlorophyll content). Ascorbic acid in mid leaves processed lettuce as affected by packaging,
resulted higher than in outer and inner leaves. Journal of Food Engineering, Vol. 74, pp. 60-69.
Microbial counts in lettuce at harvest were not ICMSF (1983), Microorganismos de los Alimentos
affected by leaf age, showing the three lettuce I. Técnicas de Análisis Microbiológicos, Acribia
zones, similar values of these parameters. SA, Zaragoza.
Detriment in butterhead lettuce initial quality Ihl, M., L. Aravena, E. Scheuermann, E. Uquiche
begins in the first hours after harvest and was and V. Bifani (2003), Effect of immersion
affected by both temperature and leaf age. solutions on shelf life of minimally processed
Important nutritional losses occurred even though lettuce, LWT – Food Science and Technology,
lettuces were exposed to optimal temperature (0- Vol. 36, pp. 591-599.
2ºC), however losses were more important at higher Jedermamm R. and W. Lang (2007), Semi passive
abusive temperature. Leaf age did not affect the RFID and beyond – steps towards automated
degradation of ascorbic acid and the three lettuce quality models tracing in the food chain. In: Fifth
zones showed similar degradation pattern only RFID Academia Convocation. Orlando, Florida,
affected by temperature. Chlorophyll losses were 30 April 2007.
detected at 3 hours of storage at the three exposure Johnson, H. (1983), Head formation in crisphead
temperatures and were only evident in outer leaves. lettuce, HortScience, Vol. 18, pp. 595-xxx
Mid and inner leaves did not show any change in its Jones, H. G. and F. Tardieu (1998), Modelling
chlorophyll contents during 24 h of exposure at water relations of horticultural crops: a review,
different temperatures. From a bacteriological point Scientia Horticulturae, Vol. 74, pp. 21-26.
of view, 24 h of exposure to both 10 and 20ºC Kader, A. A. (2002), Quality parameters of fresh-
dangerously increased the number of microbial cut fruit and vegetable products, Fresh-cut Fruits
counts diminishing the microbiological quality of and Vegetables /eds. O. Lamikanra/, CRC Press,
the product. In conclusion, maintaining the correct New York.
storage and transport temperature from the harvest Khuel, R. O. (2001), Diseño de experimentos, 2nd
to the consumer is an important factor in edition, Thompson Learning International,
minimizing quality loss. Despite this, it is often México.
overlooked. This is sometimes due to commercial King, V., C. Liu and Y. Liu (2001), Chlorophyll
constraints, but it can also be due to a lack of stability in spinach dehydrated by freeze-drying
information. The knowledge of the effect of leaf and controlled low temperature vacuum
5
XII Congreso CYTAL - AATA
Facultad de Ciencias de la Alimentación, UNER,
Entre Ríos, Argentina, 7-9 de octubre 2009