25*. AULA. Direito ¢ argumentagio juridica. TEXTO: ALEXY, Robert, Teoria da argumentagdo juridica, Traduedo de Zilda H., 8. Silva, Landy, 2001, ps. 91 a 117. CASO PRATICO: O CASO DA CASA DE REPOUSO Enquanto pessoa com deficiéncia, Emanuel foi internado em fungio de docnga mental ¢ transtomos psiguiétricos, numa Casa de Repouso, vinculada ao sistema de saide piiblico municipal, no Estado do Ceara. A Casa de Repouso funcionava como uma instituigio manicomial. Diante da caréncia de outros procedimentos, ¢ ‘operando com eapacidade de funciondrios muito absixo da demanda, era comum que os pacientes fossem sedados, sofiessem maus-tratos,forturas ¢ privacio de convivio social. Emanuel, apés alguns dias de internagao, vem a falecer nas dependéncias da Casa de Repouso, tendo marcas de eletrochoques e marcas de violencia fisica, Soube-se, depois da morte de Emanuel, que este ndo foi o tinico caso de dbito, mas que varias outras vitimas padeceram por waus-tratos na Casa de Repovso. ‘A familia inconformada inicia uma Inte por justia, € leva o caso & midia, a delegacia local, a justica, © & Comissio de Direitos Humanos da Assembigia do Estado. Algumas providéncias administrativas slo tomadas, ‘mas com grande lentidio, baixa devolutiva de respostas © resolugbes satsfatorias a familia. A omissfo, a desinformagio ¢ a inverdade, em varias fases dos procedimentos administrativos, levam a familia a procurat 0 apoio de uma ONG, que resolve peticionar em favor da familia de Emanuel, junto & Comisséo Interamericana de Direitos Hamanos - CLDH, sabendo-se que o Brasil é parte signatiria da Convengo Americana sobre Direitos “Humanos, visando a responsabilizagao do Estado Brasileiro junto a Corte Interamericana de Direitos Humanos dda Onganizagio dos Estados Americanos - OBA. Em se tratando de uma questdo de relacao entre o Direito Nacional ¢ © Direito Internacional, envolvendo grave injustign e negagio sistemdtica de providéncias do Estado, hi risco de impunidade e ictesponsabilidade por parte do Estado, L. Enquanto advogado(a) da famitia de Emanuel, identifique as fontes do Direito eplicaveis como fundamento do pedido de indenizagio judicial a tramitar junto ao Poder Jadictério brasileiro; 2, Enguanto membro ativista da ONG, prepare 0 pedido a ser levado a0 conhecimento da Comissio Interamericana, demonstrando na argumentagao a grave inustiga cometida, os danos softidos pelos familiares, ¢ argumentando invocando 0 uso das fontes do Direito Internacional dos Dircitos Humanos, ao caso concrete,oO ees Gf PEReC ei e) bt Boenoac) recente re PEE teeter a pane nya ico mesa erty ete gaa fee) eral) Coa) a ccs) bac ang eke erase} ?Pewtdosd { : soa 99 ° ot i Bena GPCR Enercon cayorecr ae oy SOSVD SO SOGOL WHse SBAMEIAION Saqssaidx9 sup ops: ¥ apuodsaneo suotdwe sooteuuue sep pup sogdeuye se 2 sa cUISaU 2p 23 ‘uapod so{ea 2p soneuof2 suaps0 owes “sesnsusou so9ssaudy> sv anb eulye SoULeqeH apepian 9p osuasues op euoay ens ut, ‘seusaqey 9p vis -oa1v woo oxrsune souarepry “seonyid sagrsenb sou tayse2u09 lopssnosip w “suu0s) senp seyy weSUElAS ap ¥IOase ep / -aquea ap v1.09], © 2 SeKLEGUH 2p 2pUPIaA Bp osvasuo[ op wi ops pu ste SvWHaSVH 3d 3GVGY3A Vd OSNSSNOO OG VIHOAL V ‘ll voypymnf opSenuoumnSie wp rom ued as0g ap suas td suo swuauiawalayns 9 anb 2 'siodap rpewas -aade yuas anb ‘ooppd [muorD0s osinasip op wyreat pun 2p o¥3eI09, uj e ened sosorrea sazopeorpuy ap jaxsuepisuos oxsuunu win w=IHe9 lw3quim sey2 “0 pSnjos uss Seuofqaud SoKeU Wex499 p seca) se 2nb 1221p 25-apod e398 wis, sxo sol ‘sexZa1 seayna w asopaqa ange opSewaundie W “5 9p a20uen op urge wut} seus) SUSIAAIP 1 Y 'N 920d oaNOUL no O7ze: pd wifax wun agdnssaxd‘cauoussou O73 ‘ojvawnro ap souof sepa of opfeuownie ap suo sy“ coonpad osinosip quot opod » epuniesv ‘on Wp o soudqad wujoupsd y “staBas Sess3 9 ojuaulow ou saivastx2 sesanjed 2p i 9 rananasap ane unfunsip aeuedut po esso weUsAo8 anb swBa1 sep oF) yp op buoy vp eames ayueuodus sou nsip 498 uaKap -roadsoz seuauepury SOMO sop sesfas v.23 2 ose) sores OY “ap ‘y aapozes eutiy 2p'sass ‘suoued tne snd dod ypy8ou 2pop Le + volgen’ oxtinanouy vo mca, ibe gue soossnastp sep a ap oFoWptL ons wan seat Ip "YeNmUeD ap sary seneuodu! artowremnoned 5% souiaaap ‘seuaqey ap e100 ‘OpSrinsoaut sop wns ‘Las stusurEI9 serIom sessap OESENISIp R00 Tui, ‘Taal 3p vO ¥ OuLoD wag "seein 08 soruo0ah sagSeSieoauy sesotounu ‘7 souoaag “inbe mvp oda OU ene sacs sant ete Sonptaoe epee i Ww ottsp op Bao! ep stenuoa Hous Sop wn 9283 pepGeEaed ap esbes ~sdbeseymar os jiur a Sp cued op Snip gona = ise and stjonbe 2 soanjow no ‘voz8s ununusoiap sob sea sjonbe anus sameg ep oPSunsIp y “1 a ‘cueY9 stu2saad o wed wi ea ttanfye ws) FEE 9p som w "eaUpIoWp vssap resady ‘opinios wos seusiqaud sorta Spa oon mitoo nb « muy one ange nage ‘88 seiouanbosuos spur 5 Sa nb ag re aad an nds tom opSeouti ep aerap soa uneea sop eee ae, s00 otha nissan 9p Organs usm wat 29 eus cous qo7 ap 2a it sou yopunb an ine “ape cp 20 uo pun ops wont go ee et tn 2. Soap 95 ode ans eset 2270) 2p aes ug or repeal eto '5] SepeBjamoad sue en nd Seu souseried ste sepa eu sp s09 jtalen uateeunde. ap Heat cs 039 resopinp Siow sit sp supe Say eeu foes ssa eed soups ou aso aed ume fi see ae ‘odo urugp anbsepspuco sno enpuoasanb 9 easy unt sxeW neoY + 06sowapod — smuageyy 9p wis]e opus — omus Seanieuuou sooseut aye ap seposypsnf sagssaidxe susse wainsixe 2g “saneuu0U OFS SBMULE SUIT wIQqUIE epEaysAsn! opSeUILE DUN OW0> WS;0> BuIA ob senso wis ‘oponu03 “apepten ap jen nes OF asayat as anb ou apeprendt 2p sooSipuco wa svaceusou-opu 9 seseUnION sapdeuuiye se seo9j09 v owt swezodutt ossed wn wos 109 ogu apapzan v anf sensow! sourpapod ‘ourauiig soanafqo siop spesursye sourars [aayssod 40) anSnjos ‘vonpusiead up onUpWDS Up J9RJU Op opeAUA 7 apLPIBA 3p OHRSUOD O SRzAP LIS 9 20g “opSeuniye up oxSnaysnsat up opuadap oppusye opuss Ties nb op aprpian & oe “upuod "ausuyeuo!oypen equndns 38 ouloa ‘oppuye 9 anb op apnpsaa up sapuadap stour aA9p OpU ‘cn uouod “opSeuye cua 2p ovseaynsnf ¥ ,tpeayust 9 seduowas sup oyeu sod eyay opdmauye e anb soureuuyuos 2nk 0 wea “osina “sup ap o1e owe ap oS;puoo-¢ wwe opuenb etep -npina 9 opdruaye Bui] ‘osmorIp ap SoATE|sUOD Sow Sov sourBxSUE an apupyie ep opSipuo9 uum, 9 apepuaa v "seusoaE opunBas “uttulae sopestyeue osraseip lode 2s ,SeuLaqeHt ap osussuos ap BIC= ¥ ‘2p S016 sop suc? 2pEpi0n Bp BUDD} 2 lod osinosIp ap OJ Op BUCR ep oBSEUICUIOD Y -z vate apod apuprsa ep osuasuos op eyoa) euun os “seauoqeyy opund ‘so1g} Sop apuadep sebuauas Sup apopraA ap Jo[ea o “ouino sod 2p wapuadep ope{ wn sod sores so anb ‘opucoy ap eureys Size at nf Jaze p wa vps “penbape 498 S9pUBINA Up yuOR ‘pexag “soodouusge seyad soy so Ogu 9 soy Sojad Seprfat 209 w124 -ap sapSewsie se anb ap opSipltoa v nico aiuar209 9 oFU Ossi SEI ‘aden ep onqug o8 epeNy WUPOY epurapUadsaLIO9 ep PLGA ' ‘oup:tu9a ose> “epnues J syed Joy apapran ep viougpuodsexies 1p uyoa} @ af “SHuLTaREH opunay “9s wouracap ‘six anb of ‘soafgo so cwoo fet ‘OES opu sere “opus WISSY _quodenuy ep s1auey -uasse wapuadap soye} 0 ‘sore 29any “~spod ovu seSuquas was, sopoplon seduayie Sead apuasaxdar 9 anb 0 ors ny apunSes usa ‘@ of$ anb o ostowud ops ops s0%, uote opus ou waste Mouguad on no 2 DURLOEN H snf BGP Mee om says agony ay woes ght 2 om Sou. un seater nn co nS on us) sae my a see Soo 509 Sony 9 aus ogiua tam a ata nT o.ep ase aD Bodo hits See 2a9p cab 0 zou " "oR Wid s2}u09 3 sab 6 nia: ue "erapn ms wd nj Tee OD ford) ebuayes wan 9 th suatna {modi asst sb sont ea “apna ik pe 50 mip 99 cnb ota sin Sr cuodsauio9 wun owes ‘unty “gts wan co sop 8 aod spon ecu a hase abesin smi ah ana pansloe Suan sms no sep ope © eps sa ee {etn taped 9 ita) oxSsaye van ne ees ‘9x2 40d ‘opssaidxe vue no) eSusquas eur anb wus “Ye i Hstepstiouna wp nso © oa Ua ane 20 pa 9p wotaed opie 99 ease 5 09 sano 50 Of pape wu santo sop osu wound e ear a6 “F9A sup sustey sapseustye se a © ogo op ai aetna 9 BUEa YP SPEEA op soups opang "whoa ens aL a Bo sopsuois stra Hh go swoup ted ox 28} 2 "pops ep crate 9 tos mprcny tego 3 0m tapd op eo tone wan {£48218 oapcodiaoa wp usar uty sueuquonins ene iB ‘80 Woo aya 20d Eptajoattos * spas st2S0pos0tu09 op ein Tow eo oveund setuoqeyy ‘oso ens aivousepuny pany epmpion ouepuedeauo® ep woe» seuLOGeH ep ate fy ewe + 26p jaxsssod 9 ostasueo op 20% sup sopeoynent sopSeunye mn W ‘un 3p eraiuoo ou anb“Opeascu 0 spony Ibu! 95-98180apepron Spo et om 9p 8p ab rua ON end a ‘Nf “9pepIeA ap JojeA sy OPU sBAREULIOU segseUYE snl oe consuniie un 9 “opunus 2 opseuuye anjue opSejan sodas euin ap estsuoo ovu apepioa v anb 9p ores Q) spayeuuou seodeuuye ap ovde ¥ sepipusiy ouoe open pe 238 ogSquyap wun eed seoSipuoa st "oieuru wseq] “opunuL fu soyalqo weusoi as sore; safs9 anb tas sore} Sop seoSeuLtye sop louppuadap v ayueavl (Sore) 2 opLMUL alae OFxaKOD seu auEAIE se “rpuguodxe sv anbiod sued wa) osinosip 0 ope] enno Jog “=aeueus ad wioBeriBuy up vraugpuadap ¥ ‘oESeutye ep sopeise ura Jayap 498 apod oft stepou 2 sreze8 ‘scaryeou sa! -xproa Vy ‘Soxaydutoo steur opSeune ap seuLi9} eed ‘tea opdeasesgo 2p sojduns sogSouusye aagos oxrepupsen 9 anb Q, ‘HUSUDAIIOOSID SET sod ondalgo 9 ogu “oweued ‘ovSeaiasqo op sajdiuts ‘ap opSeorpi} V “qqopl0De Un aIsixe OBSMIADE Ens Ep eww (eostdi) ou 3p 0S S721 01305 sop bingo sod s05: auigquada ew opeSinay[2 ayuawiow: sogseuaye,, 2p vumy> 22 aab “opSeasasqo ap salduus sopSeuyo jonsot saddog “jpayilsrsnsut 3 “o]UEUO OU “OBbafGo BSE, sooSrusue sajdans sy aay 9 onb ox souous 00 “en y94 “anasip 9 opSe ana opssnastp V “opSeuAWNSLE up spaene opEYpoL ‘p ozu anb opunuw o a sagSeumye anita opSoyax vusns sisisvoo peunye -agosd 9p 2438 yosaide osinosip 2 ode ans 86 + YONA ovOrNENNOENY wa YitOaL oid sagéezttaiqaul ap spuvne sepesseaoad wefoy {woo opiumbpe jeusIeus op satotew 2a. vps sowed anb joxjsod BL -seonpe(gosd sepeasoi ops anb sade toys seu jeubep superedas “sage sup Hongued> 9p epupuiics © wiapinssaid sossnosip septnbpe 338 wopad suvausdva se ant sou fu deme ogu seiouguadya se an ss2p son ont Mouguedye ep amit ogs soxmanp so nb seu ‘orniog oumasip Sp gson0ed ou soprenpord ous souauntze ap wy epeu onsinonip osseoord 0} 180 oyuawyoayto3as OW sistsuo9 S08 ou sooSemapin se so suago ap “.0smn2s%p, 8p onguiy og -svana sat aay “Hoda suse 440 50 woo ‘aispes wosar od sepetode sapse se opuen eanatq °N “SPEPHEA op svonpuaqaxd sagSiptoa ap opsialyy ve ossaooud wed o5edsa, op ouqiuy ou ‘osea © ty Aap Ok 33908 sepianp wins anb aussy Ryo no seayisfyns sersugsiadxe wa elouphiodya © 2 opsvoyunsios uss dye Pau 5 Sp @ ov ou my oFSeuaye v 25 azgos oxisanh “04 ep sae 3) aluoUIEHION OES OssNDSIP ap soyD sou ‘ne tadenuy 9p soBo| ‘osmnasip 9 ope Stpuod se an wa zpos, pupae wp san ara SOpESeseqwasap Oise opu sosunosip so 5 1 s0SmND5Ip SON, wa109 Up Ogue ou Sousa “OBSe. cb Jo) oubaiO}4 vp opssnusuE #8 3p apupion v an wusse wfes no — opSenuscyun Sepipaons.uiaq ov ro] Sws8q “ssr0Ug 4 SopSeunogt sepeaay ong “opunuu ou Sorat 9 &P OPES 0 9¢ nO ‘exepEpraR 9 osm 2050 FON gop ‘opSeayjamnf tns 9 wuor e seprzen ops vantusajgozd nowaen »PURIAN v alqos soOSouLyE so ‘sos: sou “oupauo oy 3) soh2!ahp sreouIresawepuNy seuLO} sonp =asansIp ab opseo © snb ap ore ou atsisue0 seusrageyy ap e021 op o, suse 9p + -uesq > anatt tsa epost wun op syed ze ossnosip osunosiq 2 opdy enue 018 sop vizaon 109p osyed wip, ovdugsip y og “4284 328 ueK—p x an 3p 0% oF s9puods21409 apod , outa} 128 usonap os ‘eSuaquaE ¥ oMOD WHSSy “soALeT busitos » Batoy ENG 9 anattv anb ap O1Ry OF Zapuodseiiao apoll 20 some 2p rey searssaud squads +6sayy sod “apn os -osmuoanco optaxls ea op opf2y eb cing oie pcan ss sous ant tip sabop oeapnbe sont, peut suey sn son csc 9 3p ne i 2p HE #0 8h “Ge msmso,uosueng va 024 oF8 so ope Wh 30g “Su stop ap ames aed soa apa ONC teas 204 wun pep 5 an Otis paypal aye nb es pun sp oatgy of 9 sag sep a eoeedNeS 7 oteuoo ome mag un © yp on ea tape! ona “pop oe un ta tia open| ms aap ona, oo Salers wos eppngno ne mop Ont 2863p CSOT os sofas eos Y 9 sod esos ea) op Oeaasn eat nro ou tng Sve) Sop vn dep et ® PAP 69 aes oo om bode om pay 9 oe rain Gouna tena 909 AKU SD Sp seat ap vee sane 2 oF opto pf om] 0 Esai OP sewatu me ‘ap cyusumns inf op 25 Inoue Soul x) sord seesponn a a a) fe 9 ops aso an onsen, agsania Shun ot up 9 anb 0» x) 9 ab oan usp ap ape ou Weta ro ons 9 oping a ©3328 oa agg sm "ap Sed wife BUN a OSI: Db usp wu sso SOU SY ‘gO 92nd 8 yg anh ose suo opupsp st 5 a nap 9 op0d dl, op ese seuean eb St cRNA 9 01 29.02 “Sp og te eso eae an lg pod 3 ey 1 24t8@plo J © woo aonb op on "uapi0 wun pasted 1 5 ssp mp op epeadoude ets un ¥ ogbeja: & “oyduioxs 10d a sayuy sou “OUSOW Is WD 0 nasip 24861 op erate O “ope: © opeiopisuao os opod 9j2 35 eoqU3A 25 esed opeIse1 408 angp onjreusopzad owouiaja assq “onnMéed ossnap 2p OTe OP oareutroyied oruoiLo[s owo9 auswEsodas euoToefal sas OBSo209 =p euototsodexd opparuas © 22 snap ap SOW SOP OSt ON 198 (oy Asean ‘ded ap esttanad v aus unsniy “enp 9 nb o vpn? 1 ojod nay 9 anb 0 usseuda aed suzourud y K2eaoqin20) 0 16 + vounior oySusnenneey va wwost ‘osodoud oppeioo op aiwapuadap nSuaitas, ap (oyueure und epundas v a ,eaewiopiod wSuastas, 2p (~onb oteus ord a) ebuotues esp oud exfourad vy mumeye semages aj moog ia Suanpeucyiad $9950) osanosip 2p sore 50, eS tia vonpuraygord 9 anf 3p Saye S00 enoai w srope 9f9 9p ory © ios wievorDuten 85 S9}g‘S0un2Sq0 Sojuod souspa wayu0D soanE}ABas OSINaSIp 2p soy Sou seiaydu sapSipu09 aigos srusageH 2p ottoou0a 0 ‘opmie > ‘SPEpION ap 4o[eA nos OF 21ajax 25 anb ow sooiduza sowauezint 50 we> aprprendt zp ad wa autewo1seg ona ‘oxsmuod “ondesiugo 3p sowaureinf so 2 2078s ap soitsurjnt sq ‘anwourealsmasip se -2de-wproaqaqeisa 298 ‘Sonnesto9 osmosp 2p same sou wyytd sp “SPA 9p oxtpuos © wes aeaurTUNt“apod ‘soan|nox OsINaENp ap Som sou irondw apepysqriuaisns no oxsasi0g ap osSipuas o ‘ow “FsIwo9 OY “SOI sms Sop seatsTE JOpEsO WN ap apEproetan t ioe “SH¥02as apod os os “ossnasIp op ssausre wploqoquise = ofu apepio BRA 9p oBSipuca yp eorSeatunKCD ap O1IGO Un OBE 9 wIapad O88 “puna vu 9 spepiuarso[siu ap orSypuco w "sautageH opundes apuitasardas osmiasip ap SOW, o83N95'p 3p soyD so $9 umys stusxegeH opera op “¥3 sepmaye “saoSuanuy uressaidee anb osinasip ap so sou eruosaude as apepiseios 2p of ~uouujeurg ‘sessauodd se 9 saqysaBns se ‘opustuoo ap st sin>sup ap soaneinSea sore ‘son “seun2q2y] opines “roan ein osatostp op sow v vpeioosse 9 apepinqeuaisas no option 9P apSipuoo y ‘sapdeuune owioo ste osmnasIp ap soasnEsua> soie = iadS91 woo maya ape “osmmastp nas op apeprTigEiusisns no ops 8 csuo|9 op apopea &“sogSeIsojNEUE Sep 2pmp1) -2andotenn @ owmmnb sagseuuyy,, :apopsiea op sogdruye aarenb op ‘veunizeyuooar ompu o apdnssa3d opipaons-taq wale lum ‘stusxoqeyy opundag ‘esanostp ap sore a2g9s soodetnise 3p purinop wu woraq 92 ‘aqyeue yOsORY wp odues Up OFSSHOSIP Up Jenta9 oxuod o ws Bf an ‘seuusoqe 3P W001 & woo opxauo® we wiutfied wuIsaw ® EourezE ‘oss wor) ‘ay efas opSunstp essa anb wenuusad amb sofas sejna0} faajssod fps onb 9 osst ezed orsodnssaid Q “seiani03 ow sup (i) ‘sed (0) os ap sapSeuuye op ser ‘swwomeapondsar10d ‘Zan vns sod upeoynsnt 295 aped ( sxaad opowai op oxuap soded ss uraaap sou 4) Bias Up spKENE Of ‘9p ownssidava in 23) gan ap () » sooreut 0S ‘ou opSeayisnf ep aausoyf2 © euLI e(g “ea4Dat OsINOSID OU ssa, soobeayjdya syqusums myed wpssn 9 owuaunsz0 9p ws 8 sods "wopio ou no opSeusyye eum oo ® sa9equ0ass B ‘seanous aaap sou anb ‘opbeatysal 9 cwwoUl | OMIUTEID 9 FBS OSANDSIP OP Ea “peanpuSead eow8oj cua ‘owuauinife wn ap sossed so anna so} eine 8 9 osmmastp op wOIFOI BON 9p THEI O *4,OSINDSIP Op wun 9p oqxs}uo ou ogsanb x9 sANaIM]ss= axjosal SUULISQUH ‘ojvauundie Joujaut op e8ioy © rs1s409 anb lua 2 tanto ont op soqfou owaxanfie win eo} anb Sepy 104) ant owuoun®se op wSaog ou, wasuq as opueN osuasyos wn 3 opryuauiepuny wing osuasued aif, %,,opesaULepUNy Weg OsUasuOI ‘un 9p e7RH 95 anb wraaesd anb sooSipuco sen29 qos ostesu09 wn :wbangye Sowopod ‘osinasip tunu souumaiue onb wa sen sanbyenb twa 2 troy zonbrenb v enb :01 Bune or op ot sv3suoo tine anb 2p oje) Ox vise oFu apuptaa ap opdeyn J PPODIEA ap CLIN} owed aAAZs Op ;auos anb opuyindnsa “apzpsen vp st 03 st jjunyjua vse) SouMaQrH aug ostasues ws uqps soresua snos win sopepynau 66 + voIoMor OyoWNaIRNGUY va vO ‘opdisoday) swin no ousa wan ‘21qos os-amuaunpuny ‘o\dursxe sod “wuapod ata“, apepr94 ap on ‘outoo euiasss cru JoUOIsES0 opso5e wn ‘omuIda er sesoxdxD \wassapnd sopoo anb owsou 3 “opjudo wns ops rie) fenb sao0jaqnisa ‘2p0d 96 emu a opSusisauoo ep zedjzared sjeui Wapod opu oVusuOU © 18 wieiauiou anb s0 anb ois “jeasSuszeu 9 F0p01 ep viouepscoui0s NrD4JNs plz OvU Osst‘assapnd anf olusOUN‘osIn0 10d "9 oxay 488 2p0d ou ope un 0d :seoug.o\op senp aio aprpLon ap. yo ass "TANTEULCK OBSeuLKY pan ap ORSaLID9 wed OWEN ‘vanCaMoU-oFU CBSeUAIe ein sp apepron v Used OWE) OBSiptio® + s0po1 ap twlousiod srougpioaues w “esuatueD ep eutoal v opunag osinosip.op eoiBol y “s ‘ede ap on onnao sonbpenb ‘nb opow owseu op sopedinf oyna ops soanetion os:nst|p 9p ‘welas opa anb soanrjnies osinosip op sory "upeBtal 195 wap 04 ‘oanunox osinasip ap ow winu sopeuuye Bs anb ,ordosdumt sopeudosde 10; ‘sednasep 9p apipad ©, 21103 ‘soaH|ns1 osINo8ID ‘9p sone sawo augos soins eaNeuOU OFSeUUrH wun anb oIStA Uopasord Pus ‘ojduaxa 40d ‘sejnasop sped ap oy a ouioo “oustn 3sou uae> oxtt anb soaneinas osss091p ap so sossap asiirue 19 2p sore 89 "oLSUSIago ap no 20; ap onzauresjah ogiwaniye aun oBpuolan2e, ope susse seA9 PIP qdOMtOUDIEN OWS © wreqanas of sosanip aluniseq osINaSIp ap sow" sassq “osUEY ‘maueyodtves tun aiqos opSewunje nuin Saye seu “OLuOFaNOO| ue ‘nv amb stssailoxd oxroo osinosip ap save 9 ouspuotansey opvoxnusis nas oM0> (oySeBiuco ap 9 10jes 2p soyususdie) seancunou soodmuaye wp -uoo an osinasip ap sar id opus wn wp 3§ ov wHINeN “uysny anb ous ouseu ap opeanes np © Zep ay] aAep 200A) seiouIUeape ted “ald an wuaeod +96sopupissas2u s2zeisnes ap apepiuaissod e wrejfar seuLoU se “seu ‘nb wa oidioutsd ootun ‘9 anatosap sulusoqes 19 owioD opdentape ous ap omseab x yen sedge enas so soo) uo inbe o[-nnosip apod 25 opt pep “asp ot oe opod extant spate cE “Spas nb omvseoo 0, ope weg once nap 019109 toro oss mmungy ob esa op enc ap me Typos od a pseu for eonmpy oP “Shoo wuld ue ob aif open unui 9 “sep sown ustenduy ap ease, an ap onset ons tir nojinesoueaey ed onsap Ox Gf Nau wed epewoted ops sagSuun saa 38 9b OYE] “Spr er pod ps opps soneppion or oped ape Sprsomans oo > woken 9p sun #0 san thet eeugyonmts ay SEB 3p eels ee aeentape Sp sous sou epeiee sop ue Ono! 90 nd SoC iy oper apscudsob2apeboge 3 utes ost Un “Gocuod apuodap oni in 2p owveso go 3p wie} ea »pIAJOAUaSOP coped LoL» vorgune ovovinsnneuy va W032 2qFH Opundes — owuewod 9 yea¥ oySuussye mun vied sosepasus SegdouuuIs ap aups euin 2p opSisues w “opSnput ¥ “soaluluzo9 som 2 2P Spaune opMsUEN wisse 9 a wand gf ap opsisuEN ‘se0B B09 epar wuRwaDp 2 DIAgId oBSipuoD v OBS s2OSiUIStIOD sUssq “east fonuas9p nas 3p osino ott apeporsos opeunictap wun ap oiuau sepenbud op antop 2 opramnnss sauauepountuat=p opunul tins sogde sens op spanuie ‘vongus8 site ppausearsiop wn woo soxatns 0d stprzaposd sagénuisuco owoo seplpuaia Jes SOW OIL wianap STI “owsHeu0IDe o eusisns O09 “opeuIEAFONap awwowseotioNes ‘To oveuy 08 ofS usu ‘ouside 0 tope eulo> ‘oUx9 opunt 9p lulepio epep tusn ap seund saqxajjar ogs wu anb senna susan 2 08S Banoo opopiedvo up srivewepuny suminnca se sade Opunifos waBeig ap vanpuDd eiForounsrda y Opes piso souaqery 9 SOAnHUBOD seuantsa ap oif2ou09 Q “S0AmUROD sewane nent ep faxpLjuo> wraSenuy| wp stewaurypuny sopeaipard ssIUpe o8s SePtgrIadso 3p 0 an yoArssod 9 aus esodug soonprd sosmosip sou soupssscau soot se 809 “9% Sosmosip sou soprp so weUONsan 2 sreuoIDeaIasgo OLS sero -uusdas sms “Suzyo0g owes opsequsuindie ap ossoo00d on lweped serouanadys ap saescqo onb seulusiap ap ura; apSeuowinsie bu opesn woSenuy ap vuloisis Q “eRSeownre ap ossonasd ov opronide weeny ap ouesss op oeSeubape wp apuadsp yy wed gy Sp opbisusn ep ostastoa 0 J219o op wey v ‘emuzaquys opundey SeaueqeH{ od aiusuipeuy epep -Sodtss oan 9p osad o uzuatsese> oss “5041039 SoAsInaSHp sort Santora! Boa) nuun ap ssuad ware 2s oFiU3 no [EUCIDeI asIRaSIp SP Boo) wun fansssoduy e135 OFNHG “epEOLINSHt 295 apod “epvortdxo Jor sosaindiy sep souyaus wa ‘apod yy ered 3 9p nzaiseid v ‘Osea o 40) axsa 9g jepessazetut nossad ep [o BSNL Ep no 90s ru;CIr Op "naEo}oaxsd ORSEuLIO} pp ayuatLotuN spuadap oi: sand © no *K wied 6 9p se atspe9 ay VATIMULOG ‘opSof2s up 0 ‘uosuanais ut of ogisanb nse 94 ord gf 9p oxSisuan vp owdsar x esuasuca 0 sedumoye ayruad onl os #04 SP tod Ho v ‘seuzaqayy aod oprpnesyp euso[qoxd ox apuodsaio> oztsanb wssq “opoouisnf aas apod ,s4 “owioa “as 9 “35 ap oxi jo SuauTe(poR " Av LuBROH + GOL‘ureasai oN “OW ‘opunsias ¢“sogSqqosd 9 suspr0 ‘o(duiox2 Jod “ap ep spansne 211020 ooqead ossnssip ou epee u “1 up srongmarsis svdvepnus 2290s ues ossed oun © “eisaweui ausuteuu0 wad) 9p caren & 3 ossed curoazaQ “(0oug21 cor ap sfanus ev aisisuoo ossed opt ‘up sip sopapistanoe sessou sup ony ne SoWEHoUD caprproedeo 2 owueuuta=M (0 “(otmasip ou opera) onSrumye yun ap opSeznewaigosd vied ,osinasp,, 0 eed ,axbe,, cor jan m4 ayesuo9. o24s9s: esi oW oxen oxtauund 1p 398 wapod ssuspuodsauoo sossud oanb 2 siaayu SOBIRYIP SO aNIvO ZHAN] o1vaUUOIDE| sed e eqdnosoid oss ‘suuueqey; opunag ‘op ‘op opstsaa e snuuiad & 3281p 0 stouow Sagssaid9 sup su}98) Bea osofeson, opssaidx 2p osm o wstiioq08 onb spjanby wouss sesBor sessep opducexe wip eiow weffendus op sp sod opso anb siesow sesBai -anossp avis) ap vaugSixa ewn one> oprpusrsa 39s “o1ueuod ‘apod -pepisseoou Sup opSoardiaus ¥ wuruLsiap an wro8endia 816 op opSenbape vp ostsinssipaisanvjad seuuzagey 2 ‘ apquisy ‘owed 2 ‘sepipumd wwazefqas "294 ens sod ‘seifay sess “yjgoe oquouuied J95 2aap an vu ib seztp sowspod waquie)*,opunG fu¥o> seuionbso, ep 32(0j ap S9au) OY enh, ap taminunse ep Onuep ‘aaaiasD sManpoU ‘pois en ap opesegeie Jes ap wo spa sod anysa anb se3a1 Sep 0A) i809 sowonbso sop TanLIs2 CD 199 9p o1:71 rq tuo np supeuuos xs ScurMNY SepepISFAD0U So “yeffubEY NozTEsLE voloune oyourennouy vo vost ‘wos ‘onb op ony ou yas epnsed ap omod assap ozSenbepeur » eed ‘eens y eu} essap opzpo9p Los seco|qoid ap esau ouenbad tu 95 ‘onssuasip y oveqe zenuaUoD euEUUTY Buk seg5tpuos cwoo seiuo9 axap anb © anb ap axxy op ‘un 9p opnuss ow 24,0) — O50) CHBUCLcISap “aatnargos ap wa) eos 9p essnuaud B souraSsjnput 9g nu wan scuofousu feajssod ef ‘opeunararapaid ov ops opU suossad sep sapepissaa0d sy “so 809 suutanso ap wnat was ¥ vijon seuLocey “oIUNSsY 2959 s2U0;2m] -28 tana “Bopor Jod = uipn}e sod apmpyssaoaU YM aMt03 oit200 108 9p tua offs "eaou wun v oyuenb osuesueo wey anb ured ‘apup “uqe2yjessu08 ap ordionud op seuuaqely 2p ogsis4 v opundag ‘eeporedes onedsar ip orwsanb ‘orbipuas woo arty 2p oust op asp “Shs e edpsa opnuas 2ej sersupisunan sussaN “ox OUST win nb op [eaps win auyjop situs pen 9 “BIBL win outea “seutroquH ap vjELUED) & ‘sq “50 2 eInUNDs wp ONE -uviope Epeuuny> 198 2p0¢ apepy +19} 0 9 amo 9p ouawNMIE o anes orOxe ZaaTa “ope; “it 9p Pua|gaxd nguow s83ne ONE fod onb jearaoid oynun aoaneg ipa( fv) jrtuaaun OpDrpretdy ap cedipuoa v 2 apupmiqeztsiansun ap ojdiouud op spaunye wssaudxo rxDifaisewea ap oxSipuoov "oyduraxa sod ‘sepeu2aSotat 126 wpa staino srenb se spepiyqztyuiousd ep vz9pvcsqos sagssan san stssap ‘no tun ep 3040) v oBsiaap ap od (012889090 9 OPN ‘e890 WHEE st. sopo1 2p surougnbasuc ‘avd seiougnbasuen se aan mip an 2 “2I0y] opundog eS wozwsseou + Z0L1} ap [apr ossNOHIP ap OBbeaIS 2s HzauD9 UOD ys90d 9 gounu and ap opSafgo v Puoyso(a! 2s asst wo ‘3p ofuad aisixa op anb ~laoap ou opcesea) osuasuos-opaand nov@ [rv sopeztjennou ops osinosip ov souaueut! sefonbe 2 seuia, xa s29Susos opuenb,, aisnxe awatogas ogSeztfeat wssa onb 26-z1¢] srnasyp 8 sowtedait anb sosueulanba sop ajusrayns ovSezi7a, Tey 08 2xp seuUagEH anb av spuOdSANOD OFS “IEF We BIND “uoo ap stoop} sogtxpuoe sy usuea!un ywapt osinastp ap opSomis ‘wed seoSypuoo sv sean oxu opruas Ze) OME “OSINOSIP Op S9A “ano svpnga s9Qpuos se zepnus Jaajssodust mos *,searEDqUNIUOD ‘aiaureind sagse,, ap rary smuaqey anb op opSezifeas ep set suropuadap syuatu]2101“2pep19A 2u "wAHO) fap osnasyp ap apsemIs ‘ua tind sages stp opbrazyeas © 9s “ossIp WL “esIMOEIP op B10} snucoo ont ons Ogu (epuie) anb ‘exmiaqe

anb jaasqaou0d eruows auouu) 9 “ofdiusxe 10g ceupyoa uprA yp ou anb op osmasIp op ‘oguiy ou sopuSuzae sta souuas (owyssod eyes ort anb sod sey) ‘sunosup ou OatreFou oy tin 29} CHESSOA PUEYPHOO UpLA Ep S032 -sa1 se a seisuoodiy se anb ozisoo > auawyfaaragnpay “H0j OF EU “oy 2p seghypuoo sessa sejnurio} opquas Wa} 2s jaaguonsanb ‘onde op apepiy ‘yp msinbuoo v oWwo9 wag “eUeIpHES HPIA aU MAGE FD ope rr agdasseud (wep osanostp ap ovSonnIs ewn ap opSezyuas v onb ap 1 sovsinbas sownyn stop so and sowsZIq ad 8 no Seiuoa seysasd & seossad se ioumys ap no 'sossauioNd ap opea08 2 sessou0sd no soodiqiod 9 sanssnuad sagSefqo suaps0 mpedxa po ‘nas osunasip ap Sovesosn op sapepjuniodo syenswg2 ‘omtoa opue ‘nf sazapmio sayanbe ossn2sip ou SopmUpE OFS 9S “p SO} + von’ opbyinanrow va vMODL saq5uaaut 9 Sonmouuss ‘sepnyne sens sosssidx2 ap '9 e134 s0an, -touosaadeu osmmosip ap soe sean ap apeplunniodo feng} wip) ‘393 uae outoo ‘anb saiopeio soyanby soja) wed opssnaiod 19 95 “¢ seode sep ‘onxanuoo ou opigequia isa axduias asinasyp © outoo opomt o woD sqeur oy urBuoIonjes a8 sayuRBes somueunluanbos siop sO -osino “Sp 6 woo syuounaienus ureuo!ae}21 as Sowuaustienba stop Sass ourstonua 9 oRdezqiewat =p etuido puunyuoU aa opotl ap too no reuaurepuny ‘seznewie]qoud ap 2 s295e: s0un9 BulsaUw sa} WI9ADD SosinosIp sou SayuRdIonaEd S0 SOPOL,“Z ‘snsodsar 9 smundiad op wn ap 2 oBo[E op saneze so|-Tznpuon a sesinosip so fodway senbyand ¥ wessod anb opout 9p ‘, cud esa, ossana aides fa se os epepP OSHS rae ado ep op o=4E) revi aeproe srpa ant ti spur op suman oar bed osip Wa og S0 "Conupmss no axes © uo asudtaln¥e ep oF a so ap suis os ruta soso sled vonpud sod ep opto m9 pepo om sb 3k os tan so an i pou seu sod ope "ase (ody 03k THO} omn9 enon eyed op otSeo8 ques apd ee suo na) ear E5925 -apsad osstassnzyy smb 2109 ap SELIG asd 398 “ySope{nisod snes Sop af-ayaso9 "opmueo apod sou ep! LoL + vomidne oybvansinouy wa vasa -anosip 2p onSenotsv sogdussaud pf oxSeayunwios ap wutoy sonbqen tsa uen pe > sopor anb enuaisns souLaqeH! “onueit0g 2 OKA sp SuNUOD sagSestIEN seu SoH} apLpIfeA ap S908 10 Sop smn sod opisa wipquie sua seus “SosInasIp sou seasod ~asiaid ofs os omu (eap) osinasip op opdemuis ep sctusey sou epee “Yop ftuoDe1 osmasip op svaisyg seaLtoU se “srAuaqayy Opunog ee IOUOIOAINSUY Sep au 10d epszifennou 48s apod sinasip 2p som so atsn wid 3p eprurwado 2p jeoBysop orsieqiasip w anb ap ayy o witd opSuate 1 muroyp SuuszoqoH “opriuas a1saN Taasssod 9 leapt osmasip 2p op tnus up vpownvorde opsez}ear wun anb sexqUH9| sowiensp “3eBn} ‘opundas aig “sruow sep ouistonuo o ered so usuapia oud qeapy osinosmp ap apSenns v wouyjap nlp sciBeu se ‘ren onto ud wig “sex.ueut semp 2p eponian “osv9 epeo we soptajnsas so sazeja ox sand oupiyo wan smjuesaude opu ap ui ‘opezyyoa) fas eounu on jrope wan ‘nb ‘sogstoap ap As9p ¥ cynosasde a [eatssod anuowennyuly BA Jo uisop 219 “pauuojep fa 2p oaptauot omauepury ©, enon ‘nascud eprpyynos run saree seus ‘owSoy Baul eM sso} GPU Jeap! ‘sanosyp ap oubeis & 9s ouso> sourmedueo Sou ‘sey so epueanss, “Yoo “S94 osmasip ap oye uin seyo9x9 o8 anb fe 9 Os4NOSIP Op fax 390d warannsa Y “y,0PEaynsAY wag osuosuoD th eaed anolouAs Ddnoipus 3 osuasuaa ostopspaon 9 as.zeureces9 2 of-ruonsanb wed coq opiped un wuosoude “oduioy awsaws ov “forzozes osuasu0y lun ap mien 2s onb =p opSounye 9 221 ‘opesunoge aivauyeas josttssuoa wn wloa sowepod anb ap ap opSena's sun ap wsinéuoa ep os thunsse osinosip op owouexyeqat 2p ¥ ‘ovjnur seas ‘sojduts o#Snujsuao nun thet! wu, 22 2p somety> asst e—urs 9s opt truosse ostnasip op seaIsp SLOW ssa ap enuod 25 9 sousinanp sewinss suscep 9p oyogen op apepyoxdea v 1s0 assa opundog onSeuniye senbjonb Jezey was susse16x9 198 wopod -atyuoo 2p apepsseaau By “apepyouy W559 seg “sBIOpet SooeD syosou sopdisod se use opi “ope S59 TUCO) 2p 503 too ap eéuosaid wy ppbioyous 198 ped uouindia op ap -ujaanued sagdesajmeus sep opfenoo panes ogsnomp zanbyenb -epE1g1s80d © owoa a rapanoud 2.29 2 2p08 jeuoipes chuaumése un icquia anb reyce sown2pog opSeBugo ap no Jofea ap ojotue 2ob)puo wido oUNsau ‘owes seBSanUH 9 OS!DSIp OP te sh ap opssardxo vpor ws wperuundy siwausaisydu fs opepH Ig Sep BUA Oso 0 9 U2859 sup SEapH eOQ5ipUED ap so ap oBSipuoo worn 2ub wueoytusis ony oss and ‘i642 coxSmjsod au epease sooy v upeSiigo asso} oie) 2p esinosIp Op fogs Foon ssqseap sv anb op apepitssod w agdnssaid os "32021998 obsomip op toe) ¥ EuED onUDM Um oa eAMINGD ps oss aE peiten OsunasIp 2p SearMuroyTe seoSezzu¥Bio ap $34 se10yjsu ap s9py ostp nb opSCUNLy LR ZOy .opSEELsGo op 2ankyend ap sagSeazuu a soquedusasap so seioqpa wed nu wang) “apepsaA 2 oFHe1509 ‘apepID vpmdepe unq vis voupa-euasis welepuoge e anb eyuodns ‘euioe sepa luuetinynT 9p so9dafgo sump se malon ap vaal LUISINTS Op ELOM & UOD eanedwoous 3 esanos}p op zu0a1 ¥ anb wo Nes¥ op oFIsonb y ‘BwOISIS 0p 21 anb wo owuod 0 9 fotos sorsia 198 waped ude Soi 1 wssap opopyssaoau w 9 3pep! ‘ontaunye wun ouioa taj 18s aped oBu ela Sepy “osstosIp op vO= AD RaUpAIRRUBW|S aBSafyO Wy “eORE sod ¥ owuenb wow ap 5205 outdo ‘soperdoxde seqsounaie sung woo sep ogSujniso t 139p “eay dat on ‘tun “o8masIp op eUoe ep oreu sod anb op SEULSISIS sop eLIO=1 ‘wofiemoge ep orout rod sepipuswis axustuspenbape sie 29s wapod svsso anky semuzasaioe sowaiap “SRW2pot $epeparoos 2 ogSeounsnt ap apepyaissod ‘apapsaa x svanejas stouofoipen sapivenb stp vrouewodiay ye agbafgo vsso argos oi + volgune ovtvunannow vo vost sav auaocu + EDL‘op apuaiap wrau ozSiao nonpsd Wau * ‘onSney Cor ay3ja1 08 an ot soueus oP “Sten SouasIp WOD OSANOSTP o Stpoved outioa oso o seiaoe apuayeid sousts ov ‘eRye swoynsnt xed Soanout syuasaide wong “ps aSNEsIp ap eube's WP OTSAPUOD U fuoo epeviogoe[ai ataaumrusr pve rod opseays ap WHA Y EL, ‘orSeorunoo sonbyanb copdraypusnl op 1 ap adisnsed ab wipe sey "WSIs an souou v 21203 unre 35 ogy wt sEpoueo [eASOd 9 OPN 109 es lugioos ogy anb sagdursoytuTut op ODS “opsooyfnenf ap yora wu, 9p TPew nawSeougsn bush ep ap rsttas EU tuonbygsnf ab sogeer reo ese anb sovaut e o|-g2m)a20d wtaaped uy opuea guunye anb © raed sega 2ep esi 9pe40 ODOL ‘opdeaunye ap ossnasip ap ove ot aydaaefqns 1x8: ‘nu owseo seprjniasoy 95 e208 wopod seURSIAD Sa ‘x SEABDEPION fo sapied somsosinb ogu ag “sowaurejaf 2p opsaas nas fesso snyde> sowtapod anb ‘opeouuiis nas op epm b “ape yayea anb op apuodsausa9 as opieuugo ruin 2p orafgo te ‘wipndye anb =p ap oxéisod wu 93 “opusiod 9 O&N squsesojduns ie oyowunzenouy wo WHOL soiao wed svuadie sejede w afButasas 2s 2p war Jopese ‘0 “opnnosip 405 ussod 2prpuseynn 9p apsooady ciuounsre 0 anb ses -nfosse op uy y ‘ose assau OvSouys up panumsgns ogfeni09 vt “oupssscou $2794 Seni “9 ss0d vos 2antns, "9S0} uns up opaxi09 e eyumseS aquauyyeas JopwIO ojad eprooaut epep boine v 2s seyundsod apod as tussy “opms0) 496 pod seantay NSH sogzts sap tied sone sop proumediioa @ woups9}21 ewan 9p spUp Fo] Yopssncerp y seu2qe UMaY wpquiey sogzex sanbevenb 36) -uasaids opu tied seazes sy “onssnasip y seuoge uranby sagseysast -vut se sepor onb euspuo seus ‘opSounnye vpea vied sopei0 op oued Lp fonpiaipur opSeaunsnf eum afixa opu wIBes sey -svossed sen no © segzes sup ap sunno sp miougiaduies v UIPRay=p ne “oRSeMIS pop wo sogaus st sep wasefosap aBu no sazedeou t2s9s wied S997 -2 wagp and awaioyos ‘vossed Jenbjenb exed “odusmy sonbyenb 1 niay opSeunye wpa> nied sogz sop 2p weyust soper ant aBixe ‘OpU upuie was essa ‘opSeaysaf aftva anb miBas Pun wouasazde forty 2p souope0 so -nzoquia ac axnfo tule waar OFSSMOSIp Y 8" OBS anuaaUSNba1y soozvi sess] “opsnasip w sewage oms9 Youlsiue oFSeuLyy rp segze st onto ‘sogzes suse “ntunueu opuep vid cpu anuod opueartdxs “ouuos ose> “ne $292: opuep papuodsar 9 sft axz09 9. ‘Se Stunsigo Sessop oLNIEUNSED 0 "SHIDUULEILION ISWUOISHS B soauout Jenbas anb wax raun opusayar as paso uopezo © an op voyBojoidoap sepssoidyo sy “,0|-271p ULOASp ODU Ga 2p J84ep wun way ¥ enb Joep wed sages pl OBU a8, 0,05 seoznr rep wanap 9004,, eysodses ¥ w09 Beau SouLetsapad opdemys ‘sol OE sonb ws opSouuye w wad sogzes yy oy onb opuszip upuod -sau oo “esnaas ens eued saga sonbsteal 3 sonbyenb sp v asnaan as ,2.9nb sod, hun ~ewuou onSeuige wun Se) 9 ‘youtmb opeu zip ov opémuuyp bun seioursqas rdsipay ese no zedeou 9 wandye anb sp omy Q “tanplueIsne jpop anb sajanbe nied seaneay sass sore s2908 + O14e wugnbosuod seas se rouiayas vjad wifas euin 2p ovr: sod opSef go 2p no sofes op eww ‘ouswnre ap sew; senp seuady euoroua runny, ws 2s-opuryode) ona qUH ap eaugajaH € JeUBIIUaLE ap SOW aa}ssod suewealsinasip op ox.quIE ou sasopeoipuy sun je euaserde wRquI) SeULDGRH 2p wOal ¢ ‘owWEWUD ON “cUsHbed 1p ous9 Jod syeasssodiuy equaweasnasip Sou ap osstEn O ‘SeUsOU SUSSSP APEDIUGISSIUDER! EP SEA sypsaf sagzos sicuspiaoid vssod ofa anb osinosip op 20% vp Su) OpSeaeas BuIM 9p VIL 3S OFN Jauscodu eaAD " AA}ESUPU § OSS} URJaxD anb TULOU ew ‘oS ow. ronbyenb v “esuscu peo

eo pl 2pEp veajoauesap 26 ap zedo9 9 wsquin pssa0g0 sevede pasa o¥Y Bu0at ens ‘eT ap vi02 vp sepeagap 488 wapod ootd owouInim ap ses89) enous “Opn wis Jog “opeisaiua> sas 24sp + oazoa sim “Searieunrou seouaio Sap no ‘oUEspIA0D ‘op xb vinpuao v ered 2025940 o2n0d Ha “sop seusaqey 2p 21409) BuOguIa “a tn}2u09 apod 2s Ossi “ORS nis epeuuistep wa osno oviee tonjoses apod “o|diuaxe sod ‘ope anoud win urgaoad ogu seisodoad seiBs: soagoysnt 298) rumpeuiosde guy BF 1vd sop sapeplungrodo se 2 Sy sro ered oqwawnsut wun W294 ypebunoye 128 apod an Yeap) uHn WHO + votoqene oydwunannow vo Yue S812 onb nonaxd o7u cabelqo wisa ‘uuse owisapy “ovourmua|d sepez yesi 398 wopod opu sxja oxb eusroe nouojouaut 2s pf “sean Sessa sPuotouate ura CaUeR a5 oaned anb sesuad sewasreAap Za}, pope olor ap seifas, ap sepauiey 238 wesap ojuetiog “sosstosIp sop 3p ~eptfeuoroesw exed sewumuoduur srw sahipuea 58 trawyop ¢ > | eyoadsa was 2p soimis 0 wet ¢ anb se1ou sauawusoqduns wseq “opm ON 2 #1 2p ovsezqeanv eid esapisuoo sas ‘ped tipeust og “esanasip ap aa 9 ¢ 98 reuonsenb sonrepoq ‘osinoeip 09 wu ~ranx9 no euse1us 061009 2p edi senbjenb Jod “7 opt -2489 soypenp so Jear0x9 2p opipadu 195 apod sopero wunguoyy “¢ ‘auinfios 0 p opnons0s jord ap yam e epugaixa een U1 “Conpid osiosip ou axtouedioutsd easeourulis g (p) “sopop idea opod wossad wpa, (2) 35IP ou oBSeue zombjenb srenpaxur apod vessod ep, (a) ‘opSounys mum sezrewaigoud apod vessed poy ss200u 2 solasap “Sapmine seas 308 © selougdi39 595 9 epiprap “ans ses opod tig -oyssnosip ap apuptoqy v alas mx801 epunos Wy ‘nOsi9951p OW az ewe pod amjey sopnd anb eossod epay, “1 98 oPpauce to 9 “eoep ou ye yao ia ‘¥ ‘eyBuiize epciuoseide epeaigndwis oxsran eu [apt osinesip =p ofemis v wm seuuaqer 0d sypeuorsusw se9Sipuca sy wapuod -souico seaiiaa sessq‘suifar seus s0d epojntwioy 48 sped opSiooa ap ‘axap goon sein “merosdesap stuaUoe) Ig 0, No ,oFaxdwu9 nos prope SED -anon ont 26,, owoo sagssaidxo tussy “opdtou ‘ouroa sors 105 tropod opt spicata sert9 won | ap S080{ 5Q ‘sos)no sop ewoIp opSeaLe Ens repuajop ap zede> warvsussoy + Zh‘opU ‘aayosar osmnosIp op ssnuedyonied so ap nfos ossi anf) “SopvoutpoUL J08 wA9p soIta0U09 sass mnasip win ap ssiutdionied so ied epaed 2p oyuod 0 anuL9g Wanap s yoouos enb weraanasaud opt osinasip 1p swiaz so ap city op u0D HU 9 OSS] “OSUNONIP Op SEB suns oysonb soya om anb eo masyp ssoauutaaty oys “owenua Ou 1 Y“TOLPEEDDOUE SEALSINARIP SUMO STIED W asa} -at 9s anb ou osea 0 9 oru os assx‘sopeynsar sop aySauoo e used ‘bqueie3 op 314105 apad opu inbe aie sepesieue Feu se You ou. ar sepesogeye seifan se opundas opezyeal esimosIp Win, ¢°Z epesn nis ose sep opeub souIWJUE Sou seoxnd31 sound sens wo Sepesaqefa UHBIO$ sib so “pnaug 9 xanyy “e8aq 2p soa:Z9joutnsido wista ap sojuod Sop stied ¥ “qs0UIset 3p 0d opwioge|a cutoo ,wan0 asoUa,, ep owDuNpSD 21 0 wo opxauon wun asofaqenss 2]2 by ‘oRnasip op wo ons ©" erxeiuo9 ou sapaoaid ap opaw win aiafns seuade seuaqet3 “s0jep stn sod stezou sesBa1 sup onSau09 & 380 squab se opunios seutzoy 9 ses i op ewes) wusn see OBU LIZqUIM esinDsIp op ‘opsmye wrour e “antowan “e1zeA 10 SIDA tun woednssaud 10) Cus — steIourrpuny souau sep oS “EIHUS 8 g4g08 wlougvajaxd ut sEMVaupuny Sopapiscozou sup OFS “HESHUE Vy, NO ,Ses01RA souatu suanafgo sOpEpIsseDaU 21908 LDU syed 491 Waxop sesotfea stews searaf4n apaplss220N,, :oudo Sein ‘op anuaa "upsed ‘oanpad esanastp op eri931 u epepton|s Jas pod exw oeisanb v anb 9 visodsas gurowud y gereu09 orserasdionuy 9 jonb :9 osimosip op jesjuaa wiunrod v ‘onto, ~tutsia8 opus ewca sonia sop sep 2 sapepissson sep ovSerandiouun v wofar sofas seseR 0590: ‘op oszna ou wipquimy 9 apep!o0s uiuR Sp “or ~{oner89p op oss au wosINfORA a ayjeious8 sepesepisu0o s952U Sop apepluuntsa vp osanasip 0 “opuas Wiss pO} baed siaaynivae 495 2p war Sopa) ap sopep F290 Sup orSussES & wind mIMIOU MA ap seiovanbesuoD sy "DIA € por sod ens owoo eprint ed jaagnsaoe 9 un epee, ap sepop jupur a seiaap sejouggbastioa sens 38 upazsyoseuat sas ap zedeo 9 nuusou wun ‘oss; opuniing ‘aor op odn asa iqeztesoUs8 ap oxdiounsd 2 wrofavaniguy anb swaas ep we 99 Sep =MUOUIPANUEY two argos ogseivato eusnyuau s9e13}0 Ogu epulE Sowuownue ap smu sep asypus wun anb snnwpe Souaasp oe 20g “oumuodo cwuowow ou sepeziatorss 9 sepmouintia OB158 set naw wwsa0s + pL‘8909 op odes or oa ye 9p eayenua) BUN 7 *DULLIDAYDS rod epnjoatiossp syususpjnonued "2 sezuase7 10d epeyneszoy hoa essa “osu osmasip ep wUoD 9 93¥d oPSinguUOD easeOd ‘un nun pp ua@uelsa ap wjans9 up vonpad opSes2qHeP YP DUDS y us6uep3, 9p ejoosy ep woNels OBSeIAgIIEG BP RUOAL Y “IIL ‘corpad yeuotors ossnasip op jue vue eum op svaisyq suudou se usmpsues sey “ogSeoyysal op sexBas ‘> oxeaynsnf ap yo wifes wy sopeaseg epeptjeuoroes 2p suas 1b 9 Tae zaa vase syeu opeznue 195 anap anb O “eHOs) ‘op osig ou searreaynsnt segzes woo soptiouluds 2 sopeynuoyes aiuouesored 2 sopmsogny> wie; of sopuucer we 95 » sowod 30 “Jou0roe) opSewauune ep euoar ved sqquEROdu seuaqoosep smal wsnuos seaLogepy ap ex0ar1 “soany30 somied ap ‘uswnu wn ep onpdsap v anb ssz1p 2s-9pod “opm ss-opuawos ued & jaros 2 sogusanb ops suaSupuoge sunno woo 03) 8 ouU09 9 or139u09 a5Eap atUeIOYNS 199 ep sotoadsv suri 2m) yoo 0p wu0a W's waumpanoid Sop sense sod saisal senbsienb wed (opSnutsuover ap sions euersas osanasip ap S018 2p 0x5 apad era “apepisa ap oUDIED asix2 0 1000 9p 0529 ‘ou USO, "aPUPIST 2 2pUpLOA ap SOU: mpuan wp wuOR san OWED EPH uo syesaipal s295190p sep onssosip ‘dwar 2p orssaul qos epeutr 0 ure 9 js ses + vogue oySvunatmouy wo vivoas ‘ojéwaxe 1od — opiose v wSayp as agu opto weoyde a8 anb seul 21 se tied walsmasip opSeoytysal 1mp taajsod 9's op 3 snisoda sof sagzes esn reste ap ofaus won wa2eU0} Se jard puso} op sepeousiep owewun ue ap sets03 se > s9qap Sess0p eoIgu w Bed o}uotuns 9 seoiseq lipquiey sopeuuarap Fs seassnosip sist oab oma ‘ossip uigty “ows no ofassoa ope wh seSucaye wasn 96 snbe wpqury, “seosoqiap svss9 211000 yenb gos 21 opSeuye e mou dea reser BIg “otuasu0s op Toe Ep oF “oo ® aptcs8 9 "0ssa owioa seasunus © SEIS}4 WOD OLS SOY ‘oyduisx9 sod ‘Sopesnt ap odioa ‘unt oto ‘oduros op opssaid © qos supeaiot 428 wAsp saOsioap se ‘opucnb awusuureyeored acaiuone oss] 1200 epses eism opueasng luefaisa soiedqued so sopoy rroquio ora ‘osvest09 wun 2093,0q sso roalssod 9 ogu “aewjenre wa1090 amb seat saps. SeunUL we anb ejeusse 28 sazeA sy “seUaqEH ap BLO= ep SPEDE, wound gvaj opSafgo cane wun feremu0> faassod vui0) O88) 97 ip © sevade sou “sanap.o ‘woo vlag “onSeauns a IWsmraauPUIaY “,cIUENb PLIAPISUOD 195 wXEp 98 “oyLION uns0y Wapl osmasip ap oySenys u wate sagSypuos se onb orweuis)vanbas manu 28-2p0q “souwa0U ap soaIyuc> so wed Hpeuadsap 103 oF ~s9re P aiuaiasoLers0d og wiuoa wa sepPAat OPIS 23 OpU taped se) 20 “openbapeur 9 abe are opus janes es-apog “ep sped apap. Sy oqowiow o 91 mrsoe austuTeI8 apis i ap ovstofes v wasd sagzes SENUL saAuy apog nf ens ap suje) apod as opU osusstCS UT wIO9 couisou opus ‘OxIN8Ip OP 48s wopod anb) ou stoayis sepruson sogSvotput seumnSte ef “osiaosip op ehl0m np $0} DU OWS OESIo9p EP rHO= ep SoM we suDsep oss“ soayyoadsa sopminsar Y09 ne wrousiosead ap Suspro ‘sapepyssamoK 2p uy wsopea

You might also like

• Her Body and Other Parties: Stories

  

  From Everand

  Her Body and Other Parties: Stories

  Carmen Maria Machado

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (822)
• The Sympathizer: A Novel (Pulitzer Prize for Fiction)

  

  From Everand

  The Sympathizer: A Novel (Pulitzer Prize for Fiction)

  Viet Thanh Nguyen

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (122)
• A Man Called Ove: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  A Man Called Ove: A Novel

  Fredrik Backman

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (4610)
• • Magazines
  • Podcasts
  • Sheet music
• A Heartbreaking Work Of Staggering Genius: A Memoir Based on a True Story

  

  From Everand

  A Heartbreaking Work Of Staggering Genius: A Memoir Based on a True Story

  Dave Eggers

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (231)
• Rise of ISIS: A Threat We Can't Ignore

  

  From Everand

  Rise of ISIS: A Threat We Can't Ignore

  Jay Sekulow

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (137)
• Team of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln

  

  From Everand

  Team of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln

  Doris Kearns Goodwin

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (234)
• Sing, Unburied, Sing: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  Sing, Unburied, Sing: A Novel

  Jesmyn Ward

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1104)
• On Fire: The (Burning) Case for a Green New Deal

  

  From Everand

  On Fire: The (Burning) Case for a Green New Deal

  Naomi Klein

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (74)
• The Perks of Being a Wallflower

  

  From Everand

  The Perks of Being a Wallflower

  Stephen Chbosky

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (2104)
• Fear: Trump in the White House

  

  From Everand

  Fear: Trump in the White House

  Bob Woodward

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (738)
• The Yellow House: A Memoir (2019 National Book Award Winner)

  

  From Everand

  The Yellow House: A Memoir (2019 National Book Award Winner)

  Sarah M. Broom

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (98)
• Brooklyn: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  Brooklyn: A Novel

  Colm Tóibín

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (1947)
• Devil in the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New America

  

  From Everand

  Devil in the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New America

  Gilbert King

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (266)
• Yes Please

  

  From Everand

  Yes Please

  Amy Poehler

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1898)
• Shoe Dog: A Memoir by the Creator of Nike

  

  From Everand

  Shoe Dog: A Memoir by the Creator of Nike

  Phil Knight

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (540)
• The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America

  

  From Everand

  The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America

  George Packer

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (45)
• Bad Feminist: Essays

  

  From Everand

  Bad Feminist: Essays

  Roxane Gay

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1018)
• A Tree Grows in Brooklyn

  

  From Everand

  A Tree Grows in Brooklyn

  Betty Smith

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (1929)
• John Adams

  

  From Everand

  John Adams

  David McCullough

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (2409)
• The World Is Flat 3.0: A Brief History of the Twenty-first Century

  

  From Everand

  The World Is Flat 3.0: A Brief History of the Twenty-first Century

  Thomas L. Friedman

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (2259)
• Manhattan Beach: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  Manhattan Beach: A Novel

  Jennifer Egan

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (792)
• Wolf Hall: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  Wolf Hall: A Novel

  Hilary Mantel

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (3811)
• The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer

  

  From Everand

  The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer

  Siddhartha Mukherjee

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (271)
• Hidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space Race

  

  From Everand

  Hidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space Race

  Margot Lee Shetterly

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (897)
• The Woman in Cabin 10

  

  From Everand

  The Woman in Cabin 10

  Ruth Ware

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (2521)
• Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance

  

  From Everand

  Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance

  Angela Duckworth

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (590)
• The Outsider: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  The Outsider: A Novel

  Stephen King

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1850)
• Elon Musk: Tesla, SpaceX, and the Quest for a Fantastic Future

  

  From Everand

  Elon Musk: Tesla, SpaceX, and the Quest for a Fantastic Future

  Ashlee Vance

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (474)
• The Light Between Oceans: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  The Light Between Oceans: A Novel

  M.L. Stedman

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (789)
• The Art of Racing in the Rain: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  The Art of Racing in the Rain: A Novel

  Garth Stein

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (4203)
• The Little Book of Hygge: Danish Secrets to Happy Living

  

  From Everand

  The Little Book of Hygge: Danish Secrets to Happy Living

  Meik Wiking

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (401)
• The Glass Castle: A Memoir

  

  From Everand

  The Glass Castle: A Memoir

  Jeannette Walls

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (1716)
• Principles: Life and Work

  

  From Everand

  Principles: Life and Work

  Ray Dalio

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (608)
• The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: A Counterintuitive Approach to Living a Good Life

  

  From Everand

  The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: A Counterintuitive Approach to Living a Good Life

  Mark Manson

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (5810)
• Angela's Ashes: A Memoir

  

  From Everand

  Angela's Ashes: A Memoir

  Frank McCourt

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (441)
• The Hard Thing About Hard Things: Building a Business When There Are No Easy Answers

  

  From Everand

  The Hard Thing About Hard Things: Building a Business When There Are No Easy Answers

  Ben Horowitz

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (348)
• The Constant Gardener: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  The Constant Gardener: A Novel

  John le Carré

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (104)
• Little Women

  

  From Everand

  Little Women

  Louisa May Alcott

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (104)
• Never Split the Difference: Negotiating As If Your Life Depended On It

  

  From Everand

  Never Split the Difference: Negotiating As If Your Life Depended On It

  Chris Voss

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (844)
• The Gifts of Imperfection: Let Go of Who You Think You're Supposed to Be and Embrace Who You Are

  

  From Everand

  The Gifts of Imperfection: Let Go of Who You Think You're Supposed to Be and Embrace Who You Are

  Brené Brown

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1092)
• Avelar Lamy, Eduardo De. A MANUTENÇÃO DA AMBIGUIDADE DAS CORTES DE VÉRTICE EM FACE DA

  

  Document16 pages

  Avelar Lamy, Eduardo De. A MANUTENÇÃO DA AMBIGUIDADE DAS CORTES DE VÉRTICE EM FACE DA

  joaom2106

  No ratings yet
• Steve Jobs

  

  From Everand

  Steve Jobs

  Walter Isaacson

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (807)
• DANTAS, Bruno. GALLOTTI, Isabel. Crise Do Recurso Especial e A Função Constitucional Do STJ PDF

  

  Document4 pages

  DANTAS, Bruno. GALLOTTI, Isabel. Crise Do Recurso Especial e A Função Constitucional Do STJ PDF

  joaom2106

  No ratings yet
• Thamay, Rennan. BREVES COMENTÁRIOS À EMENDA CONSTITUCIONAL 1252022

  

  Document10 pages

  Thamay, Rennan. BREVES COMENTÁRIOS À EMENDA CONSTITUCIONAL 1252022

  joaom2106

  No ratings yet
• RTST 78 04 Efeito Prospectivo Alteracao

  

  Document9 pages

  RTST 78 04 Efeito Prospectivo Alteracao

  joaom2106

  No ratings yet
• DANTAS, Bruno. GALLOTTI, Isabel. Crise Do Recurso Especial e A Função Constitucional Do STJ

  

  Document18 pages

  DANTAS, Bruno. GALLOTTI, Isabel. Crise Do Recurso Especial e A Função Constitucional Do STJ

  joaom2106

  No ratings yet
• Arruda Alvim, Teresa. MAIS UM FILTRO, AGORA PARA O STJ UMA ANÁLISE DA EC 1252022. 2022

  

  Document8 pages

  Arruda Alvim, Teresa. MAIS UM FILTRO, AGORA PARA O STJ UMA ANÁLISE DA EC 1252022. 2022

  joaom2106

  No ratings yet
• Ygoralbino, Gerente Da Revista, 3

  

  Document22 pages

  Ygoralbino, Gerente Da Revista, 3

  joaom2106

  No ratings yet