A wl! 3 pe lae sal le 3 liam (8 Ay Li — : a , Bg praca se JY) sheet pb DAS Sau IST pucral Ogi 35 JLiiyLe or glé AeLul doe oss) a _f ay, _— - pai a ease@ Du 1 3 0 Lae Abad Le 5 yliam (58 really preset! JN! heat pduusl! ese poss Ogun sg Jli le Aer gr glé Aolui a all Vs ‘a a DAN y Sho Aya pall AS aan rTP /AND PUBLISHINGpally DW dy pall AK atte]. tll ol Le gd JEL CS guera gh Beth eed DY Ble dees tO peerage ILE IL Ale Lar surge UL “gt ISBN 978-614-431-211-7 Ape Y glad. Y eb PLY Bul cage 1 EY Sy sbl ol : Olga Gam) 909.097671 Boa pb pod V Ob Le oats ol eV Wolly Sly dy ll I Bi tees oe The Venture of Islam Conscience and History in a World Civilization Marshall G.S. Hodgson ©1974 by the University of Chicago All Rights Reserved Licensed by the University of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois, USA (pam iB plone tly ll ne DI Ogi Geer tall Ke VOVN oye Jy VI dbl Augpall ASuat pitty Glas gig pT aN Cag pt sByUial ey Gly loyal cass pole agp pam VT LOYAO 2.50 Our Se MUVVVTSAVY rcile SS MUIVIYEVAEY tgace E-mail: info@arabiyanetwork.com ApS - Car eSISAN cop Lola pptetguatl cts 5S pall ay SPATNVANVAES ccs SATAY TAL VOY sigan AgS0 3 polas! ayy GIL ae gy LE YY all day SAYS YYTAO*ATO seatle SEY EV YVIVIUDAY i Sgecee WS dys Ft sail pall 3ylae LL LL cbyle pda! aye gold YE SHYSYOAOAYVY sage THY VYSOYASTAO gana WS ola stat! gol elalas sLagy a5 YA USM Gaasal Gye +S YVYOYYA* VAAV scala SHYVYTSETVAAEA ilgacee Bess. ug s@losish we Jar sbedl Bh) UL SeYVW TASOY ska SSYVIYOVTIAEA gare AgSe~ Jgilaw! Rdg pI BB stl GLE WV gSlall yo Layo 398 gold Os ¢ patel! SMS OVTOAVOTIA :JgazeeGb abate Vly Lit 595) egauogy put! ot! iN ye Les St Fate pth eed! dias O99 Ge duoly RL Go guade ural! 1e6all gd Bede GI «>, : Oday Oe poland O98 Binge Jats! 658d oly 083 O92 ol! tial bteet HAI Ge) daar) 55 5S Les ppl set COV WT) lds yy Oye Cae) 2 Lasley pad ish bis, lsliy bal 3 Wigs (bel, ols DLs Opi CSleS OT DLS Gy ply oylidly DEY OLE Lue COL OLIYI le ee Fa Geb pd le Uproye JEL By 5 SSG TS 1b catey Woegv gy) tvy ora oay Vw vio vo4 vay ptt tion (lal 2a AL Aico Coll 5 ylaaoal! Pll Obs tb LalyY J VY] Vou 2 VAY LY Lebel! (1) [AVG ~ WY] ANY ~ Vo% Gilat! pSoul jlasjl (Y) Lorre _ NY] (4E0 Vor os) SY de 455 OF) 8) ATL, Qa Qe Ole lye geeks! ane Cad! spill (£) Lorre _ \¥Y] (Ato _ vor PIS ples dud : lish jbl (0) Lorre . WY] (4£0 Vo gos) Ay pl Goi BWI jle95) ssi (1) Lars - 148A] (480 - ANY os) DaY¥é ~ 4A] 4£0 ANY Glad) SoS subs J 57 (Vv) cog Use axl»A> fall Actas GON) i das VL! al ys isha! ola ig of ibn 2 Agee of BB ogloy bi > OS OB pte ol OSS 2) DI geal ge Bi ele ht Pubash jel ble oyu ot tty Qe PLY! SL Gam Oprah Jess colel pS oe gS dees Ly Clee tl a plead abe ge Tite Glad obs yey Opezogs ULL Wad «lull gat! Oper rye det ASV Gyrtdl dodacey COIS del coy AULT HS ge tte ge Gd LY ty Ld lt Lal 3 S529 Rady RAN Ey Eyeradl har rely Ay) Oby ne o- ll gad eet cles Lee tide ye Uday pede! ol BI Y cheese aby geal yet ps At yee Oigk PLY! oF ot bes Lal dude ge Upsets - set 155K ot Syl gay A} BB I Spey J ok py OWS Ls ly alge OLS J ree gb ple oT (1) ee od UL BN Cs Pe Sey pte ty BL OW eleols Bi ary gS Sal Ct Raa ode Ug) AU etter Le oT Ql epider Le J jal gill 4, Gite ford oP bby bie se UN Ps ot BL oy eg JI LS 20 gd td YOY pel SUS I 5 Sy lay ope Mell pb Kee gle WE ola, LG SS TUG ee tae FU pre 6 oth toatl Marshall G. S. Hodgson, Rethinking World History: Essays on Europe, Islam, and World (¥) History, edited with an Introduction and Conclusion by Edmund Burke III (Cambridge, MA: ‘Cambridge University Press, 1993), p. 97.a pies i hee ed Al ell go orld Uber Lad J pas ited! ee GE hall oles Byars Grad Sly tla YI 5 yao DAT led Fy A Bypall RBs) eereily nb Ls cLershty teed Y df el ys 58 J co of Uysey Og precdly Cree ot Until J ted Ly Lee op HE gen y anal! td cub p Chats abs ap J Lis pall J A) doe Epo ye) EL, TSU cals Gob GE Operas ols gals che ge Ler OEY Ny abel oo GLAM Sbilesl 4é P Ble WS ae Bb see LS NA ell cee A ot 55a! tabbed pt oLst es Glas Sls Ib a bb! we Ciass sets JIS bs L Al op gble dls Gad GB Jess Tage LS ogee OS gly Sy pdly GUY! Jolsly Hled! bybo gall @uttly SLOLY SLL», Ble ge 8 ES Oygkd spre begs pees sae pl lb jb oe Gptenny Ge Bled Eyed Dhl Byala ole pe PLY oe Gd! Ry Laad! ila dl piy GLY ee ates elle Gl BSN GA Ole OL ee als chery ple Gt I Glecmey SLU ollar ge bal sly pols! bbe el Gels GE Le phy ILA OV poy dy oy SL! Ot ted He Lele YI les gels AIL ASUS ES pay peal TUS appeal eles goles BLS, RU ASL by I ples SI ple BW GAS dee gy ALLS aL LG ALL ey OLY pled Oe) peas gb Last aalty tb Ege fol pall cree yey Set ayre te ye eV ete Vs pel bey ged tl oll go ee pul (pda Bil pe WS Webs J Lal dele, eI! SL § ola yall lerjgle by 6S elpwatl oye Lai) J cdl pe lY! GA Ely Opera ye Sez ly Sele cded yall ULES ole Hodgson, Ibid., p 304, ye MB Woyl aped Bball (1)enpnad bliss opiasy 0 ts blG Jylley pr Yl spl oi Us pl Say PY Elae Qene clad ob aL LS owes Be SS SES Me Sea Gel (WW APY GSU witb, eh dy UL Ls, PESy be) GL lp Vly Spt BP Uebel ip Sby tee dl od bbe ga thane Goel adil USI Nie Bel 3 Yo ele GULY! ye WW Ge Yb yey obs! Le Logmerage ILL ga oy el lobed yo pte gob! POR IE jee Gir ge SLEL Wy ole ob Grell AS VI ULW OYy Ge pete, QS ANY ple BN s Fb 5S SU GQ ye ay ENT Og ceey Leyes dale oe VAY ple i pp MSI de ye ke fray LHL, solely BEY TE gS le ppb Lad G5 gal SS Be le eb BH eUl Opi Loe EIS Gay ply! DIS Ge Obey! plead OSs ASU ILI Gyo pt Gb A OLS 55K ells atl he By eT dlp Y glu BL Opnroge dolely SEY Gaby GEIL Jol OU cy pied Gans LS LY! RSLS! Godt dhpal & Stl so glee] taleb pg oF GLE! (Bly 255! GUL Oper aye Gaull eld cule Je ORI w BY! Spel 553 Sor Graiall jecasll lel] le aw olf gl 6 WUS Gab) Ey ae BS yy TSI LIL Gok oT Oper ge Ue WS ails Za ilps eee ge dls V oad) dial SF be Ket! GLY SL See Od (V4ET = 1429) Sly SU ead ELS Bd! ge Voed oll ls elles Sl dell il J Boy ALS y BLA, CEU CH ye 2SL Idd Dperage he us AIAN 935555 Gite J Ge LL Sa YW Ld CS dll Gast Jye Ujke Lely «Clad! Michael Geyer, “The Invention of World History from the Spirit of Nonviolent (£) Resistance,” in: Edmund Burke III and Robert J. Mankin, eds., Islam and World History: The Ventures of Marshall Hodgson (Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press, 2018), p. 56. \\ely JS 4b cole Gay Ssl rely Opener gh ee LS ees! ey eI at els 5S SS! Cade Olde OLS 455 . ands Boni Ol pal Ailes] ands Lad $425 95S rl ek 6 SSI LY! Oo peasy pre Jit cers el ob as! we 9 oI PL! aul wl t+ BF 6 2Y opt JytsS) Opacra ye BL> wet ult alt gb ULSI of alt (140 ele) gt deals Lele Ope There Is No) 1G ASI gd Leh, (Orient! byte Ot pli deb oJ) Jy> OLS labs gg tiSiul tJ pte Byte 532529511 om Cpe eh Aehgal placed! Maas gh capes Lindl gf 5 Sal polo So Cape dase SL oy ay le tee qylall dll akest Bs cape Oo Gupta gd gape OLS Laae (V4 = VE) ll eye Hag) Lg) aghy cLabe ADU! Gym Cpe Bygh WI calydal GS SL sckatl he Sta hast yy Yate tpt Ganthay Call af pins OLS LT scygglacie pall US igeglYl pill Zain ga GLa Gopal Jaolyatl cle oaystd palsy eeial ignd Y eaniz sl eeive AE LAM SISEMy Gye gl eLlauegtl Coe G95 i] Le Leal yo salt ae ping gall Slay Loan pone ill Mah AISI gL psig Gaya 1 cage SI Ad pial Le 131 iG 1Se YS co ably Acoli aches 2 pil engy Latlag 8 pblee Gas calalig ala «pally Angee os gabe Ayal GSIgLalLy ola! ibnsy pall CL! jaa coh pleas Y My alah dogg galytlly SLIM Gd ay GoSge Gold Dayal GoLtSI BlgLicey GLAYly glatl Bney eelbsuollly 9 ealenl gudtl vy fast tol Yh adit Las! patel ys pl ialy Gamer! pla Rach gales iy cenit gf ball GIS gly «GWT daly plat! he rebel! Glueatl gus Legs JES OLS Le gay an exgLaall Lilly pelea Wl cao Yls GaSg Gali RewiStly Ruled! LS acyl gb Glin aaa (aS aad stage 3ylad play dub! BNW! AVI yas Le Gee ce Lae Opa V+ ge Yeas ot Ig ly Gum delat ste Jaogy crated digas JSly «| gle Spal Baal GoM Il cele Vs Gye pS sue, pol pclebncel S515 Gent! GLa! Gebel pe spar gains ol Jul Rhett! 509) Oop plaly sata! plied agian ohaly wedges iLdag nll ASLAN LeSomal po GeoLAS due Ce (Gabiball a SLIT SSapSI gua paul gil LES lal gr Ag dl cdLae Cony speenniins JySu9SIl gatl Lilibeds ga Lilileds gapuld So le gh opie LyidLial 31 iGpaaleol GLSaall a egihio Guus ly etl Vyas Late) eal com pila eagle ly bly yin Ml iS Le Splat! 7d eagaley daze yo jVl a 8 cle gy pall elyil agie phe gylaal pall Aglgs Lin 5 SoSH! pale Atuadl del jl ols WS pol Reale Igy Leta on tesa aN peal egy (Mein +> gall ematanel igles Y Qaiedall oye ala Y! Fassel gl 93 (agen ng le eS gis) Wel Magda! GLa! 2 datitl agbl pails 5 SgSI! git Yall) agile! Rpdkaagy AaLall Jaa eal apn Aig Le a Lee gaad 5,595 atl (Saint PATEL Ope ASN pat caainng (a paSLESIs I pleas) ve Lab eqeegle i adil igual LOY lela icytalec \Yoe fle Gol oe ot lle ul ge Sebel ge GS ol Ler OU ree dag Vl OLLI a ole EYL Law bite als teed de Ql re Spell he 5 SS tools Operaye fas Oddly slaty padi ye cle ale wey BETA Ope hs SU oa dy OM ye Huricihan gle 5] pe] Oley ge Sab Gao] eA Le yay eae) perers Les ILI gb Osoye ye tS tose Leuyl 3 clslamoglu Suet crete ha AI OUI Oy Ul ye Deal psi D an Su SB Cb Cpe oh ILD poled a Ig chal LIY! ILS gar OI aoe - f sb SS Jel ya be cays! OF Seb V Soy Gy bl ode OT Y) Cel Gy LU dewey thy te Aged has SWE pty gery th Gan YI paid D5 GUIS ye III GES Oro ge gy ec GUI pL 3 BEY! pled JI Urey Bo gal aba prcall 6 S95! heel ll Oly, eal 3b alse I5+] ppbey pt! A) pal ge Lbs Sp Meg BLO Dbl pe ed el Ze oy oe Moly Dh Soper wl Ree gd Ope ro gs JL LoL st led JE A} LSI 4b LB SS OA 1) age ottly OLS GL YI wed IK dele Bb ele YI SHI be Gt) ye cee ee bls Claas phil angry alld! WL a! pla! OL ghee oN) elate YI SAS) Lad Cs by OU ge iy Eat! Geyer, Ibid. p. 61, and Katja Naumann, “Decentering World History: Marshall (0) Hodgson and the UNESCO Project,” in: Burke II and Mankin, eds., Ibid., p. 84. (pt Bite Ob 53 val Ny pos cht elie 1B > ol ple bles isl (1) E050 COVAVA cdadlall jlo O52) Bruce B. Lawrence, “Genius Denied and Reclaimed: A 40-Year Retrospect on Marshall (V) G.S. Hodgson’s The Venture of Islam,” (Marginala, A Los Angeles Review of Books Channel, 11 November 2014), Lydia Kiesling, “The Professional Life and Educational Vision of Marshall Hodgson,” (A) (MA, Thesis, University of Chicago, 2012), p. 6. \yALS get Gd ES Al iy! oe (IS Le Lats Opera ys Gated! Tayllly Za gly SY Gabsl co jely Glad! olla Ads Eb aad Jpboly Glassell ye gale (Bye Bul ye cil at pels gps y GY Sled! Hw Sp JDL argue dell ape diiary doly UL Clhs gyal ol GeV ol Aust ot A’ Soe Gy OT NU ey OLA! ole gar ede Gob Al Ce! foley Lei gerald ke QALY! pe Lat ode Ge arlon bs plan AS Gedy - WS de dy eo lees ple Ele B elpll le Hodis dye dpi LEY OGLE Gi dry cole Erdy de 35 al Cl Bile Bee le Sa als SL Oppo ILL gal Jw : OP lI oda Lend Lace Uy ba CPL QTL Oprro ye plea! gb colar! Sal ted 3 all syndy Slt] os foey dA! dentin piles Bla] cod pally OM ELS Ss O98 Glogs pel! Galea Ger! (le al tha gl PY gb Ge Cte) Ol re ely gSaU atl, A Dissident Community in Medieval <3 goSI Lgi> (63 13), Hcl Ugeles «Uslam: A General History of the Nizdri Ismabilts in the Alamut Period Typ BLS GEL Oper ye OIS V40N ple J oly eSul days le rar OP Boke ly Sede dad ol Oly leabSy The John U. Nef Committee on Social Thought, University of Chicago (2019). (a) Kiesling, Ibid., p. 6. as) OF Nyy SA dye he fray VAG ple Lan i Uy cpyliy 2 O55 Ge (11) de Bed OLY I Ll ye el I gall all 8 lll Ge cole ody TAT gE ASHI Gerel 43 OLS Oly Tages BT yp OIS GY WS, cLELUT LS yo Ye oF Ld VAOV ole gb iy pi dUS Reale Sl Jail AF VAET ple IK duke Bin al epics VY] cgay all atl Go wats Barbi i) ey po dey FA OLLI PPA ES US gle tptey US pet od LL Lal gis eats 5M eels YE 6a Aad ll glo egy) Vb egy pttall Repay Sse ar Nl et sl dae ll asl : HVAT VAT Go C440 NM el BG ad ET Ge) ale y peoall LS 3 colt ple HUH ag (1) aS Operas tle fp Lee! ol BUI Hs wl gat ols = de - Gol Chy bs F Sl bly ol Jo aS al yy Es La SL att Jols § ales \¢ples Sou (ele Sil dad) 8 US Glile ole de Gar bbs Opera ge le 5a La GL My pool GL Sie gale Jats ose ols al, OB AS AgealD 2Se 3 aby plane 2b OS ai ary tel dl oe ches ol O92 gt ERIS Oley ke Gis! whe MS 40d oe etd Y clk) cg bbl tole ULL oly rl cess OP GWE ey Gadd Se ad WH Base dISy vb yle da ola Cul Jy eee le SLI Le fae cy sill Glo ea Ligh ga fe he cal ob Ble EIS 5 Gly pS Ay L) ite BGAN Steg he ad OLS ay Ola) J cil Gan aly oly eglpre LW ole NAF le Gy SLI ASS LU (ele SAI tad 3 lsu evs! Spe GH Gy peed J SLE Opera ye J! UE oN 408 ple BDAY Operas peels AU Bld ple Aol ab Sud VVVO Wee Sopdet ILA Guan Sy ee el ST OLS 2 Iya! phan C25 ST LS ULE Gays atl! E55eU pleas Eaptell gd OS ogy pet Web LY! Lead 5 tal webs tpl Sled) Gy pte Gai Add HOprroye SS le Gee, Maazel Lp ep SLI! OIL Get ge te ee Ul BSI ES pl ye et le @ wt Ble GB lpobsy polly rally Bel gay (Slap SLE oe Qe Operas Lely Jpaill daly 3 ple! cal tage OS LS «hell Wl yey dyes Ger) Gretbend op US gy ptell go ALLY eg gly Lest 09. as15 Lay aL) Gell: yebiae Gpelecal ge Operay® GI COUUL ad rey Glas Led en de bd AS OS ED, LW Ll 2 S prad UI Me BAS Ly Like gS pb Sh pd alsy VE Ge eg se Cite O53 aby pall ele ON) Naumann, “Decentering World History: Marshall Hodgson and the UNESCO (Vt) Project,” pp. 88 -89. jogh le ete (ele VI SWI ded? elprl cil aay LLY! EDF WH dye als SLT Ga Gab typhi! US Yb SLL Ca Cieleall ilar IU QD 2 BLS Coley goles YI et GUI LS Opnroye Gul pglise ob tL) (ploy! pally ar aye SSI aS fete ply jul clpnti dealedl dy (thn Berne Uyleus S51 OS GUly BIS! Glibgeed| 13 (The Rise of the West LK ede Ge 3 oll ope Le of dye of ell! Avil 3 ijLaadl es lly goles! dots bybes jl pL bbe Jy> th 2 e phet 5s des Operoye Stl a Sp) Sr en 8V deste ply Cis CB! LLP Cases SLA edd Cree Og Gs gee AV Uday Le AS caylee ye ered cls gb Opero ye aue olinel GUL Byes Zolsr VI Leys SV gy pte 5hi Wall ole yey ley SyLaadl dol Glas Les] 3,55 OS Soph GU ohLant OV - VAOV dea) Opera ge Ty GUI Gaal! yay (1400) GLY! Opera ge Ep Glaell Me des wa) Mey a (le Oi GS! ial) Text book (jbo tes O95) (PAY Flea Bhyi &&S Sylverdl Gis yt, VAOA ple dns ilps Dprroye ai pts NAA ob ailbg SI VION ye Baza let Uy de LY! Coal acy per PLAY OUT ol SLA ys Uae Operays Gptcene 54h GI) LG Glue cal aay dled! Gaal assy SASL Ge ep yell OLA OL ST OLED Ge 5 pot Lake od QL nd Ld (19) (Louis SULti ye jag) Lay MSL Gell Lad BV ac Op mrroyay BPS eal oye Ae By ¢ gD Qt pgs oe Zs wll 355)! 442 GI! « Gottschalk) (Leiten or plane Gaby pS nd gl Ey pin gb dae Dpenragn foe Gilly 61410 ple Hae (Sb oS BU gS Les SUL OI Gy Lely Liga Ge Jag Gall «Stavrianos) OVS Gp phe) gable Gus V0++ te ge pill Las pl cglldl QUI > Se y+ at Ute T ly cas sich Leake I] Jasl Gd EIR teak J Ca Gad gi ile ae iy il ype TRY GG pails Est 2b Ui. Opnrase che she tl cu yg + Edmund Burke III, “Marshall G. S: Hodgson and the Hemispheric Interregional Approach to World History,” Journal of World History, vol. 6, no. 2 (Fall 1995), p. 237. \NBE SIL fos ek ols Lily, 350) abd. 5b vi Coe3 SE Neely amgias Leghtuy 25) Whar leg Qe ye guy he Sa SS a By Get La LST phy dob! Sah alte arene met OS pS GUI Goll oll Ly pad dbs IV EY eS Cals GUI HAY Bpalaad ge acy etl da Lad algal Bly dele AU dye Col wo (SU JyV! Olle) deel pall bist USl Golly HES Ge Upad Gan ole 92 HBA) Opera ge oe) Osha GI] CLS qlee! ay dl 939 Wb any YI lard! Glas Gy bp dpe Oper USF A OU Lely GY Cpe ol sY Gals eee yatsy Heliny UI LIS 3 US frat gle LS) Gasly 3 oot SS ob eI Qu! Je SUI CUS LT 6 pata SSI be 3S 6 3 vad EY Hey Opera ge Andy GU! dL pl Ble) OLS GON pad au GS tet Ls dpa A SI SAD Soy Byeal ox> GU OM GILY Gast od Kall UE SI gee OF ter lged Ld! tS So Getay eb pid Berle OAT) ple GB CLS py BzeaIl Operogye GLL> Gee J pall anid GL hg VAAN Le gd HSL dane le Operagan ua Ste BN Obels dade LEY Geel bb ge eres Sl Bel Ws VANE ple gol YI SI On, dL Geel VAY de pad LS NATO ple 5 Meg GAN Lado 5S pe aoe cade gb Re VG SLs 3 1515 BLT 410 a ys Lan, SLST ope GR ge GoLed Dperoge gle ES YY club! obs ld tL Geb Ma gts (PLY) Flat JLSY EAU SY! EE JS she Sulina Lg, silge opt lis] deal cine LIS See ly tcgelell BAU Ee ene oT Ub pi LS catty Hodgson, Rethinking World History: Essays on Europe, Islam, and World History. av Kiesling, “The Professional Life and Educational Vision of Marshall Hodgson,” pp. (1V) 32-33. WwAE A yd ET VATA ple oe shy [Lae oe ALS! 3 oe date OS Late dated! pels SH tl od eS! GLI! cde Geel gb ale pat ab SLL GS pl IRA tole p> BLS] EY byes ge SUI het deal Geil FOS ply ales Ll. tll bo BEV OL! jes Gils SI Le oe tee He FeV SS ply egos dle Y OIG etl! Gall gd 26 yl rexel ceplstul ei tlgil dba) Ul aid g olf GUI yal YW gS ple od Gall enti ed bs CALS Ge Opmroye olisl Male Gl B tee LG) Olelad ie pee Of dey cpl dl Bjley scl! ld ergy QI! 5 ULL ols ably tee gee BIS J) eb, ill LS Geel CLT wglinl Bb reey LES GS SUD Le lel ja Udo MOL SLeD gel ale WET OpiKinry Liber 3 Yo Letty caleba OLS See OEE Cok, SH Gackdy Oper ge G55 -Sleadl Gaul Gl Sey Seale] ace SLE Ga V glite Seat ye a; Ulla’ Ge ed SB) he Qe de GM Lys Gaels NAW ple OS A sel Dl Glee atts J cline Wad Lee, Sy iy GUI tt pgeceatl OLS Dey te VI ip Lge bb Lag) een Min ge Lids et Ube ce ee Gost alee G Jol Joe (GU fos Ble de ed!) CsI ales Qe LS Glad! a epee LE Ges pt Ge) SI ty Qed cb OF“, BP Sil BLE) GES Glyl altel Bouck, (YY Bleed cl +] YOM ple 3 Cad Ugly > et lL Qt WByiod! LLaull 3 2b Operoye JB a oly JE wa thal p obedly Clieesd Ol J bs as LI, oP pails elt 3 La sy! Jee! 5535 Gall gy jel cles Geyer, “The Invention of World History from the Spirit of Nonviolent Resistance,” p. 60. (\A) Saul Bellow, To Jerusalem and Back (London: Penguin Classics, 1998), p. 106. aa \Apel Gaps ade Operage gal OLA Gah aS py otal! Lin EBLy css th LI! dye tat b dye Leyyoy LG VIS yy Stace GUN SLI Qs gape GB bel HL Wa ley Blue ssi ples ped GBP Sle] al de ella Ars sles YF Cay cal ce Spent Ly ble YI By LLY PBS eds Ak II Sal bs’ oF cael de Lali oS pb Aull bes te Ob ol Bocas! AM oped Ged ge hy LS ble YI Mis pbs «yl BF gle dnd UST Op neo ye JLGL als MSL Gat obs soll gpd = Opera ge ULE pled Gad ead) gle ISS duke ols Yo UB AW GO Cll 8 quad ge tb SUI GL Lad Sn OWS Sf 3} thy Spe fe US OPIS all 29GB opeall lal SS es ke Spl ee ol CS iy pal IS OL Shae Boy ppt Yc gel Let ppiey peal) bod LY RLS ISG Geb Uylas yr Oprroye bey Le sl ols sinks BU Gee ggd O59 Ua GA le Gal VGA gyehlll edger eats SIT gy LG Opry eS! a BA oyde SM ead I eg MEV cold Paty «US Ge sig pote Lal Ei5ell 29) Oj aol OT ELAS LAS WI as Liga ols aay SUE Laps ayt Uo Les oe VY Gey Sb pi — Sy gleel ees [045 of jaed - tole UB Ge 33) Ly ee oe epee eee alts cpl es UJ) foo i Lele He BR BY pe 683 ge VAT pe aye GB Ce Sp B> PM NT) eB) eed gee gers Lis dey CVAV0 ple > dons Ln SY LE EG VL Bae he 2p Spal Bpdt Sad Cea ptr chy oe UG I Es HO SII eae BS Ae] LLL BS] pL lye Goel ER A Lag patel Soles B pate ch patall sole Burke III, “Marshall G. S. Hodgson and the Hemispheric Interregional Approach to (vy) World History,” p. 239. Bellow, Ibid., p.108. (ry) Keates Dele 3 321 Ls (TY)Ye psh YE tbls i nti cals plaka ent ILS pense ole (ble She G5 Ue et ly Gb Jeu of GS) bua LOperage SLL ped JB hia Patio wliljoy ald ye alley gay claely LUS VY] 8 td Oper age Qh PJ cailiy Le cyrtltod! (lis Olga, 1800 ple Laas ot lear» slel Al col gS (The Secret (gu! ltall ar Je IV BJ Well glpe igi! Order of Assassins: The Struggle of the Early Nizari Ismai'lis Against the Islamic OI go BS) LLU Gee ped ye CHES Lo Ay - World) © OP Sie Syaa9 doy Byer] dee LS ete gold! BAU BUR JR! Sym Lge Lele Uperoge 4 et ell 3 (How did the Early S cyeiSle JS Zagtl! aeol S9 rol pn GLY! oda Jybe, CES Yay 3 ok OLS .Shi‘a Become Sectarian) , : Pats ramelys VAY ple bpd Sool GAL lesa Liye Gb Get OAV) ged Mugs sal el Spel Bb ery GaP Deis pe LS OIEY Ch eld QUE FB Lele! Uy dl pe Bb ye Uling ALY Gyles Ilo ge WI Ghd! (5 DI ge MUS asl Lydia Kiesling, “Letter of Recommendation: The Life of Marshall Hodgson,” The (¥£) New York Times Magazine (6 October 2016), . Edmund Burke III and Robert J. Mankin, “The Ventures of Marshall G. S. Hodgson,” (¥ 0) in: Burke III and Mankin, eds., Jslam and World History: The Ventures of Marshall Hodgson, p. 3. ag SH Ole V4 stl colgee dhe UG pty Dall I Ul eee Fay (1D, ade I tl we cp deel gp Bers Girl GSH frelen| gy dine Leary (TV) Said Amir Arjomand, “Hodgson, Marshall Goodwin Simms,” Encyclopedia Iranica (¥ A) (online edition, 2015), . YeLOlpray Lelyo W404 ple gd p25 cpl PLY! Gy i> Gi ce ob lel «(Attention to the Case of Islam) HY Ue Jf obsvio Bay HL dy Slat OA GL Megha VATE Jags daly ts we adatell Cla I Gel 6 PLY ALU Le Qbabne gle 5 go AS PHY Bplte OLL Bebe Gan WW! ee Ugly tee CBee J aged Ge by SMye oct fs pS LS Bybee gl} Ge aus! B legrees ore Jal oly Gb Bre US ples ly pally LY ye Lalo VATE ple J dpeo ye TA GS op Boye PB sol edly OUR yyally pelea 4 eS Gwe PLY ae: LOlye dls J opt alig dey OAV) la Bb oleLe daly iS QI & GL Opera ye plaal fy Ps ISS tole Ss LI Sone BEA! boo CUI Shale Soh 488) GIL 8 Ely ILI awl» Lolo Oly gag VM0E ple 3 abd! bbe Lk Yb ly sibel pS GI ao djles Ls, WS Gai 3 OFS! a br el 65 AS A SI Se iP CUY Ol ps Lele WOT Ole 3 oo ees aks Al auls op VAM ple gy Maubll Oy Was AS LS Ha § Clem dle! OW JL aU! tole B lanes Gilly aay JESU ply CLS Caged Tpe ye Las (NAW) Bly ple Bd Os CAD GSU! LU Go foul de? ee bts che ET AST gay tale Gates pr OLE? pe SB LWI ised Bt ay lage ehoy eopeliny te SLul PW oS GAS Udy MA SHI Sled J cyt GLa oN +S > ye tan 3S exe WHS > 3B eve sey) Spelt! Gk pail pany Le UF Op nro ge lS WSS AI CLAS! jae I] BLY] - Spall ole opt iy tp llal Sas talep ol gia opty Nyy: Bipea] aeae GUI OLS g - odtel ESS gay SW ry SLL! ode sls Gib! au 3 Y\Le yates! Lroyt> : eels Glas! g3 evo sods Ke yd yo) ae rgb, oi on Wey Bad by tr oti gstibe, TALL Jp bee Gio, Cabbage SLL wn ctl gta ee Brel dey Label dee gable geld at U Chad yeelaad! Med fo i Op roe O OLL a ot se Dee peY Bybee 3 opal lreoal Haare] Cis SL Ly ates L le Jal bh op roys ols BU pits 053 9,9 (The Valley of Vision) (a5 I) galy? Olan: Jor 4] Url sy ola ll gee eh Y hose CaS soy AEE ple de Syl aly ell Ls ay 61400 ple SN oyd (oll Ly Gael 3 ad SH yl ge SLU 5) Ae EY! Lae pS Le le Gat for Toe oF Seb Ey gare foe Shy ae gpl al Ogle Oye eel erat ol fa dow GST IL, 66 Slag ee Ibe pate Ly CLS OL sel tof i N41) ple ye UL, dy ONS EF gy Hgeblee YI HIS pole Gey (gabe JL yy Ley rye Yb dae OB eye] CES ISS Bad WS ye BAS glen ge oI apa putin aobl (i TS Giey shod! yo U5, pil of as asl, soLSY! Lad) toll dioy ty ote als GLY SIs fe of WW Gh iby By Ob ely a BG td! QW! fod wy cdl Gur dl Go BAS Ey cay all gassls) efor HL yey .cpeey sl (v4) Hoggson, Rethinking World History: Essays on Europe, Islam, and World History. * UES Bola yaad Ge palin iy Kiesling, “The Professional Life and Educational Vision of Marshall Hodgson,” p. 39. (¥ +) VA Ge ctends stead! (11) FA 2 (tend saandl (FY) yyshal poy Lest) SV Opera ye deel le sal! wl OO Neds ASI 5S ge BS Gh Be OF Lin ab ios al SE GUL = LY! Flin cages dele 3 Bag! labo 3 PLY! Ay Sel Os) aylta, oLal PSS op eo Ge CIEE OH Sao] dp roy OI YI (Gayl Ce SAS RI, Cg SH pel Gs ty ly pI ee ge phall E5pell ole asy OP sl aed AI (6 thiy Grail oe kj GUtsl Lb Ls, oee ode frais goluutsl de a) GI eI OLS ge bs U3) 12 bo) iba poe Al obdadly SLLSIL he V bets bby et op eae aa oad shee Ms el ye Li8 Udy of Oyo culy> fir Lele 6 Ke IS GI So fim gb dah oy Lily Leg Oprro ye Gb duly Ue gl Kel hill estas te BF IAL gale GS ge daljs Jala Le [ts By ay ALO EL Lp opal Buy U Gly Sliglee ye Gopal ade Ly LEK. ULSI GUI Ale Cloed Ce Sybil GEN ye Gab iy Operas cl Hy Bal Wel! JS, Ta W SEN yl djl Gus eal Bt pSess bly BUI! 6 SL, ZW bbe ey dy ES pail re od Kolidl aSl debs WLAd YI LUI Llo po Wily dag pdell Bla sorb! JU al S QE JW! A yWly LAY O15 ob Ope Gh GPW oe Lene) BSN 8 655 ep Sbdl Se Gall oe ford es 4 Ge bands pea (FT) De AV Rl alge thaws C6 pSLU! sty MAY ZyLarII dye] sylbe, (PE) NAA Ge 6940) TV TT cya PRY O52 598 JEL Opera) lel» Qul a 5 gill wb dele 3 WS, (To) CON GG pall gaale oLeael! 1D golLtd pI he tee sy Qe ggellll enh i 1N0- Vue yyUl gest (5 pall Spnal Blood pS pe E Lag) pod Obs A Lee By geal a ke hale OS OT pty WW Opt SE AvU weap Ul pats ole Tall 455 poll des cde di ple Ope ye Ged I BS SL GAY SE 4b lb de Cy cg aT Bp gall cols gb Aba! te og oleae Aas Seely OF be OPS ARID Sp dae ogi ya] OLS LV GlLery Baral fel We oe BAI oe Hes pI Operaye EYL O35, LdLy le Lely ols dy - DLS EK Eerglly Bpoliy epee Sly paiy Oleres py aed Ly OSI ijl le pti ge Mier Glu] ey Lyte Gybll Lele B Opera Cale OW iy Ps GSES! GINS Ley for JN (meres Opera: ote 2B SV oe QSL ge olan ol aebe OLS ofp cs deT Lp Le ed eS LU Ga SW Clie Wy cl} 51S GI ALY sbel bs (fas VAG ley Cli oblLardy fo MAT jis COIS Le yay) ae OF ShLard! SLljoy Qs) phall The Great Books 5,55) SUID gle 5.5L gelae Vl Sal de) Mel Lard gle Ge ylall er Ul (all aisLI 0,55 lve dole] J} dul bp coheed le Opera st parts «SA Se UE tte oe ge aly adie Mele py (SI olde! Wigs Spi LS op eatI pel Clif tod OF ops! elbveatt Obs gy a YI ot SL ol Lye ee ley Lay ha gy oles PD Se cfr Nab Tata appa tl alae yaad oe der pli gale piers GLte 53 gh ene MT I Sle pethy Oper a rtily gal oplSy Opnraye JLE,L dlvel US ge ane Sy By Bt dae olbacd gy gharall ye Opty Guill pd teed Vge BL ots SF le IT eT GU ee ie BAST L ee Gojle Y9 5 OL JwL Sie OL bal CET Ga) tee Jbl Gaé yh Urabeeel Seb Y All ail yal ge dey 0a yu Model has shee Ob ST ES, gd tell Js ney Lab ob yo shail a Rene GL le Sleds tee obo] IL AV ALI eo Shi Beg el AVN ge ORAT tly lel all dey pall denall Ty ) Gane Gre pay YtThe vel his Ul gol Ge pines Al) cede (boot Tye Lend patete Mr stbe gl Lelés y1¢ (le Western Mugaddimah Ugeadl Las tradition ulasin dad Gals eld olalrea! deel al Males Ley Eyl SplVL Uailen ld gd piel ye 2! Leb] Fe goose ole des tI) yh Cee el died! & Wn 2 tiny AI) lla tals Zelor Vi sled! S JR I Glad! olybetly JEU! ys she GE tamed Slanted aolye sleds S300 elles Gales 83 Mla) ye Shay yee ee Sb fey (Opt ne gy ot RSG Glebe lel py ede GC sdID ey (GsSID BY 6 AS. feeitl Gh LS LY Fold, (Brup jos Oe par VY Seas) fee le - Gb cleat Lil eed) OL Mawes GB) Olas Lawes Chey GIy (2G tIID eles PST elec GbE ans Bole] ge BY LY co peroge dLY lye gatlat OB Oper 6 Al Sol 8 os Ke Al tie cigs Hank Lge! Seb LALLY By Lar Spe ay iglie Diy Gly Gen BUA bt BN ple oS Seas oS OL fp Hope Gol felt ahs pe PAL crbtne JSS gle oN Une parse gl! CasslS 4 PS) SISET laced ye Vy coh pd le Qyedly DL Geta! vt ee GR OLS ol Uger> Lyyyl lacy bi su webs LS oe Migs bl 3 5G Us LT dey Su Lede UF cLelysl shag WS yl gf pad GU ct Garp pera) Op reel pagel aa don! Lepball 259 CPIM ess Goal asl ge Solely tiled! GB gd teal OF FS Bees type LAL) globe cpa bi iy Bla ys loud L Spd JRE GUS Geel Le ge tga opi dle Ct PY Bel BGM gay Chadd Goole! oe ge LV + ae pare Spo dard BS a5) boy Opes CLI AW patey Cpl yy Steve Tamari, “The Venture of Marshall Hodgson: Visionary Historian of Islam and (YV) the World,” New Global Studies, vol. 9, no. 1 (2015), p. 76. Yo= PIA Leys bey Gl RY GLE G5 Vs pane ey is 1938) 3b Celli) pgaslia gad tell Bb Opero se UY CS al pe ealeaSl isla Leja Ge pall Lily Leto yy Zeya le BUS le pg) BSbeaI TiS I Ip - ele CL - pil Sl tyes Lene eyery ST rey based! ae! co bys. OS GIpY! paw! Sb dswI 3 ksl Ono ge de ad aha Leys ole pel SL Gr se lay Le LY peal gel « rey chs A ok bes Gl tll = gid! alas! Joss b Lat als Shey pal Of ol Gs col, Big) pall ole J! oo owl 3 teal BIBLES, pre 65 BUI by cls ULy oy oy by gai As edly gland! uy UE Gs Spel by die Ul 6 al past NSF BF el nadt of us Pn lew oily ghWl 65 LW se Ly Oly Alla! LID GS yai Gules Wale y GleLtl ptt elabe Lg pbedl ie ll te MeY Ll ells capa pele abbey SM heto gd pall Liu plo GtaLI! TEN, ae! TBI ALY Go SL Opmroge et I a eazl tl - au Bos so LY Avldl Ob wes II a. dude rae GUS 6S 65M etl pas Fb clad WES AS plsl cabs Lede Cle inte I Vyoy patel Gill bus! 3 OF SN Operoye aestl AUS oe Vy peal Joly dt Oph U ogee SN CIs Seetegdl dy rhb, Lyd oye Stead!) daa I fot all POT Bos .dI Ska sbl eal opme oo) ol CITE - 64£9) Goall cote Spel hy CBU SLM ye deat 5 Sgt Ed cos Big 251 65S pV Gl pes spelen Te gs Gilt OU 5 phy Holes Vy dela! OUEL I 45 il si Gelecel plas pyghy SS Lae ptt All yp Zab Gell cos LSAT sel pl OT) ORY eo WY DTU YES SIV tle Sat Ud CaS ele Gy ae has YNbe he eS phadl 5531 ) Gel AIy OLE pla GS Le yay) Jol eet pygby cider Lol WSS Ys J! GSW Glo yo ae By Spadl OgMl Hey BS 5p WW ols A tel J 4 SI + eld Glad BASE cLeajlesjly Hobdy GV abl 3. Silas ar 155 spar del J! DUS! GG Opero ge hit Sop pall oF tg yyreell pall Gly A) dea GU! daw! Zel, jt Srl gol dylan! SUL! pbs ag Gil (eG Ves Ar) Sek - Qa bY dahiSly eg! dahl depad! dh! (3 leissy A gape) panda Le Zell ae yall ob Lage Gl fll dilanny Oars dee ty GU) Cote pad Lastly (YI yeh oagt ced ESL xsl sls GB PLY Opera ye Rope Coebatll Nigey dole gle cabled Op YS LY yeh Jb db I Uys eB SLI wigs he MOM BS da pd Bp jel old Ge Qe yl ode fy tere Bye! bd Spl Le Syly BR Vs 1 LY Ailey Sly LL Shh eW ipy Uasead! 5 SU ULI Se Spline WISI Lee tel bts Gi pyr Of Atel Qapbl uly Sel le aly ded le Ge ab Fhe cles rere poll US peBE SS Sole SE I] PY Gul Operaye pe 6S Va Qe GELS RL PY Bl CS 9) Greed I) Ls ely Hy Spel Slay ge LGHSy GeV Hleadl lo dey ea Ge! Lads AVES Gilpell TAY) age ye USM eed Ke elestl Ge po deeds Dy Bpetly oo) fay te gelar! pli 4b AS AN eo only rt tee op LL GE de aS JS ilpadI 6980) cortege oy GB oly bydeny UG pelea pmsl Pl ase pls SI dy ybl jee] JR Saget coll Ue pl gay ITE GSS Bly Ce By) BU Gls Shy eye g HT ude LU Gls gl aS SL abe ye a Zl dae NI Ae yatta go LL YVA! BABI gay CATON I Sil pel AVON) J yiell cher & pe GET Jyoy le costs Cole aie le pls JR yt Oy BSH) gtd p55 gelerl pli ES, Lan Yaa ile, AG BIS OLY BLS BF gable bly Ul pleat a3 dios ob! J LI Bu dls HW OLE aaigly Gad! chy Ue poll Al Apeadl Spi pene EELS Uap gl Ue ll leas ELI poll bts Ge Oper cd! fel dike J! Up Ue ohy USI Jy eB tye OL gr hel, Dac, ZS USL! Opi Lb 6 oyraj! WI GLE oye Le (hes Cuddy el JI ELSI geal PLAY! a, tbe pat ode JB by tyleost Lat nal o daisy cel seal cal Lad ol 3 Jubb odd Bors Al ae oe Us Si oie hel. Lye Leh St Opes coz dbl dee! AVA S Sips VOOM ple yous) SIT! oy Ly shh aa) aypre Dyaraye YAM A Leach gay) dell. Lyyelly epheally Gilet Le] copelill DI Syed OU gb eal ciogle Cam CaS AalIn le Bde USle CSS gy¢h Ollygbl Wl WE cages tute LET le He pil ope Tale oS pb Splits Ube 3 E55 Jpel OH ASW y oleh Solel Gals Lay UI Igy Cols LS Zell Ke pg BS BU Lb I aa ole I eV Jul ty He ytd! Gy pbl Vl Gb - Shy sbl Yl ole (3 oy5hsy Ranedall ¢ gla — B55 yall Ly gb el Opera ge Wha, ll ye pal pb ttle pal ode Gy CHL! oleh pat eddy Gall gape pil Ls lal Si ply sll he Ad GF geabeall Gila Go BS 5% Gypbl peal Goh Liles he Eo geod) AUS Go gas Bed! thy yVI ele) cat pall oT Lt ly ell ale Olle GV) pees Bote sedi Mal yay cope SLI pe Salt Vjos ag gl cL Ae) = BM apparel gd LEVI Lhe 9S pl jes yey elyaal s ee ly GLI LOY dpb le O51 ee OL Fhe ge Lely lak etsy Ll de LiKe taal! gp lagi yy VT LS dye MI AS dull oblast YASU she Sod ge A gttl gc e Gael bbs ttl Bek Ll Opera ge ols GUI pent OS OF OLS GI ULE At sl peels eel aul uke oy SILL YY glsh bys ths Held oll Ob Jb GAY ST Ye Lad Ue Bid Le Bes peleall Sell OS a Sal oe Gel Ue, MAT Gy tly GS gy Bw blah B wey cyeler VI ob Bs Hat Bel le aes oll A gy BW, pall LO a3 poe oS gb css pl dl de ge Shs SWI de> LI Sed oo hy ey, bol ILE gy all Ree Ge tay til Le Has Bb te gh Cadell Oe Cig! Ged Lede Vir Operas SAS We peat Gy Lb Cau Vilas (SEY, Syl Qo oes) cet jee ol Ot pI dee Gla ae ge ee VY she PI kee PLY y5¢8) Gas Soe Gle ble! But! ol silly Giedl tl ot elie pend) solestl gl (peo Clee) ge of Boe OI OMe ole B55 Casal Lag) poe) G3 yl (Quod Bylvaedl he amend ge Mash UgbaSh ilar le [gered Cres TI aps) Ue SIS Olay SI ody EAM! Gatlads vel Sb! sf Lge eyed gb pelos AS pe Gather ge bbs bss i tb Uy Bobs Gla Ll] ayy nL ete J be Epes Ey Bed! GWE gs dees J! Qu! Jj YS cee Gly SN oly EPL og) Le Gayl AE Y BU Gabe Yl DS yell BB IKAYN Lin Ge Opaeoge ge BL Gerd ol J Te ed GEV Led ge fell SadI SL ALY) By pl Gt SILLY oh Ls & (sy Gael Gates fous lb Les pb bb ode VES ole de CePA Bplaey Operas SLE eile Si aray VAs 990) TV VT cso (VO pall BUSI 5S yall Sele IUD) Eb caste pppdie esa pall dil Le (E+) YAY AV Ge v4pe ols cy Gill ge Hed OY Su ele oe Sool olge wblbsdl yyb gl ope ash bl le b Le ga Gels le BF pl cecil! Gul Usltae p EY S-lee Jiow (ye pesee Gl AAS 3 Lge SN dgts Al ol le: Gh BASU 5 ad! sad, OF O59 Gye Tipe Qulpl ode Ugly of GW QRS op legs Ghd tl GSI Be CSL Ay lpll ode das sl PEM! Geld ELS apa fers ly Let dilate! Slt sll tol CA de ygae SPD gy Heth Operage fae B cee! UKs lb Hs ae dymey phe alll Oil ge Opera ye Uh) le pee tl bios Ls Ula OW gal Kags par Ob Opera 6p VY dng yl Sloat baal ge eye VY gS J okie Lag! pad ded! utd! Slo! Gh) BSI De ye Uplts geal lar orgs ll ebyll BAS Ue poy Lag)! poe Ib «ee De SS OL! Gra ress Sloe and dep pata De yo glad BOL y Gadl I Ao giy S51 pal Lil 5 i Oljes bas falas oe OSU ply elas as5\ eb ot Key ace Boyd Sel Ll cyl! Ge] phe by Jonah AI OD BO para ye Le LY bles pany 52! sill Sed CIS BW OA GLI 45) ye yerlenll pre tee ge Cte OY abd Bae det SW iil LG ge ey oll B Sb Gay ag ole yall aul gob ols B Ble DE ui (E)) Es He el gd DS Gilly HOLY Fb UE ga OL 3] CO peraye TMB Gee pd pd OA BG CAS I Jj OL lags Galas pte COA agpall Gell OLALe 554 toy) a sall aul Yd OME Wolie LL AY V4 EDAD LY syle coy bh GS uel yg Ole ay lb cs elie PE SS TH Sel lyse OF Ll VALS WAY ge Le pad deh shania W ele 66 5 Cildy Lele OV5o0 Vy Ags CUS pas Sty cyte Gall Ow! tebe Lab ales Gall ao ye oe Sled I iL GB pee Fie) ly ELLW ea hae NAGS ITS pee IU OY oye coe Cis.3] oll wW Sail jlo sald) Ol Yetaste Gaadions cialely Ladtind Gudas GLautly Gabbe Cagun age Sigal caaely sLazuey clio Lal! ode 8! cle Encyclopaedia) 72 «paul qilatly 33Le 79 Wo Sh Juss Heel ada ula! ISagll Lip sll genill te Ugusiod clay .( Britannica Sbemad Rae aSs gel JIM Ratt Sly ol (UTE ple col Rag!) As gilly OFSUI Ayae 1 2 oe Mal 8 GS laws Roe Ot gs pul aSa Lye ole All (AVs VE) oghecly auld Rabel kas Lgang «(£1 — AVS) BLA Sally Sfmt Aas ¥ aASLe antal pela! nt IBY pid Cpealnall elein aaanll Sg GS FyliamS pgle pu! 58s siyualaall so Oa Couaball 5ybinad ALA McLee Yl BS pol cp gls Lgudy «(E50 £1) ayselly Syengll Saae - £ Maal! ol pag! Jl! ple Aue! ByLarall 3308 Us pall oe 9 cry gls igSs Le tel Bag pe cphly pall clan Wl Redan! oh Gees -oTatally Lill ASLAN UGS 5 Gace Lgglaialy cohaglel pee Yl ag gle cag all Aedeall crag (VAT 160) ategilly sungill Guan 0 ya Be asia! Jha Ge a pall oa cag By Lada ybly Maglell pla! yh @ LAY! aig’y 25S pal! aed IS abe Lhasa! Coneeaas ll ee egal Ol pee OMA Aylay le SyLE! OLS Le gay Linge La gad cll Aa pal cong «(pola — UAT) clan tly Udall ceo! Ale pe 1 pegatigs Ala ps " (UU Jackin le wisi align nn MadLaY! 3 pola! Lged culaly sobs Lyed lalasy GrpAll ad pbaiall capill Spy GLa! Uglaey Maat! ye Bl OW ab gay LSS yy pally SI oy V ely bus SFY] deals Lye 3 yy Syl dlog Had Geb SEAS sali L Las Lal abl bg te ee Becks 6 FV ob 5 yylard! ge] OF yy al UB ge co Lay PLAY Blan SS alan yl lene L255 oe Obes olay yaad Oped ge USF A SL SL aT Fw SU alt ss eee Tle! eyeing poll Get g-l 6229 IGS poe 3 GLI & 2st sl) SLI aut fr in OBI gb BLY Slob! 3 a. Bygh gp igleadl og» tt ayy Bo Mplall GasWNl J Wher ald foe J US UT te pa te cull dere GUI Ugh ghey dikeg NM dy gl pe! SHeeadl? Oper aul y2] Jor ete EP GSS yg) pe LS Opera ge foe co GLE! aADe Gow Robert J. Mankin, “From Gibbon to Hodgson and Back,” in: Burke III and Mankin, (£¥) eds., Islam and World History: The Ventures of Marshall Hodgson, pp. 25-37. y\leg ge Gb by pylll Ql pre w dela peal | da St JB (geugiy poet Jal) tylaedl tig OF yy pes ley 3 Toe YB ples SFY ctl Bull ge gpl Me lee YI [plat Da pdliny We Olypai ir ale Gyhy LI LoL cel ojly Oleg! LILI Gpdl dey be algal SF pe Pol Lead pS dali Sbygbl Vl Bae slhesly GI! hl dL stl) as Ble Gags L J) Gls) desl Gaya eI SL erly Ble eS ge apt! Oa dlls de oped ony dle ESM BE OUST J) BLA) GLI Jk ty ol Rss ope ede gy PLT LI ad ole UB (Lary SI fae OES 4 IVI Ip! abst! Cole Jes eld ols «LI elle Gl ges Syl aga Lad BLS LET GU tS al agar Teel Ub oly oyperatl oli le SL Leed! ge dal le 5S p taal 55 pall de JB) ees (VAYA 3 Coil gar pe) Lend Op roye 13 ad ge cabal Gly VAT) - VANE ge Le ey Cee Lal jo A) Vyilsd ye Las Ble Hyy2 IW Dye CUS Givy SL! JI Dy jae Giey Sl baedl NM by GUI perl Gaby ST LS cde stl one Sb OY LES Geog eee le YI cand des oe Vass GTS tee V Lae [age lee US fans Lasky AS belly Gelb {PSL Last go Gopely BY fetus gel J Soretas pf OLSLS ol Ol sles Yo cibizy Lar Ligy begs Sylar gl oA De LS EY ye hel Lacs Bey Lae Libs aly BA ikea)! BLAU O45 OT ee Ley FLY Ey gbl eal ge fege coh See BUS Gane aS Mee sgl Guth BLN pSoya 149 goldtll pI Le (EF) sag yea] ldo! ye opti Opera ge saad Spey AUS Dye ype il (£8) WV Edd Calg dees (pL 5 pling Operaya ILL: ibd LU LY! Aube Mel ey VO e CVAK0) TVA caja te rybag r age Spy as ! Opamrays shy CIA ode lan 5 Jabs euly pens La, beenity tats LS Leber: yaoi ME Oe lees | I god Gate ALE) GUL! oy es ats, | aul glade! fols lea! GL! ASS gas sulasybuyaas | cyte ESokis Us> Gis Slant! fa Gl Bogue ple L4SI ie Lae He . ie f. ae Ha as JSaU WG Lebar ls cls GUS Y coll feasiygpnnss | rela! eo Jelistt pe Sas dsb gle djl, Mbadewriettel| UB Olj|yol gr Jelally eermell shad Ualell es ohlaadl a otal! dnl ge Lad Ugberuy Ze wl al bagtotis | ZU LIS Gan YS LS aa Sly ols by yleeal gil JSS ata Lat Wy US! TS Sl oie Ub 3 Spal cH lay Sylaod! eres GUI Ls cgay JRE Esl Slpsey GS ASE ga lye pe ly Lan LL Jet il SEY Js slo A olay Leipe YF Ll Epes! lary 15 Lal! I oe) Ebel athalny eetrea Ze tl ete Gil (atazel des ude oo ty tb ope bey) SS ge GLI Oe Sal oD plead of BUY 5st! gas Sued de GU goS all Joli pre Us gd Glad GF cay de perce lial he Jelay Leal bled! le ay Kale Jolo yay Wye JSty Baybee EL Cans Leer lee ferry Cg pera allary deed! El ee Bo gdoes Bp XL WE 345 GW Shled! G0, BUI! 4s Raped WS) JRL Blot ably day Oylyled Gell gertnall ye oul Lal gas ge Date bay) OI ger ow Udy Lead Lbs! JR de Sylaad! ties oy Ob AS Y op roye E85 aaoly 5b phasN) Maat oe G5 Ope pil opt Opera git alized ll il Slyge Syl (£0) Wg Ose ol o Sy Les asl (V+ Toye pao Spang Opera JL ple BBS oe Uf egypt Upheld UL ta gdaall ce I GHLI J yl F gr ffeil 9 Age ayes rrale ye 5] EY BL Us bepey tyes bho pace A) pre) ye Thea! Sylar! cde O50 OF Slee! 3 pS ad! sled! cae bay BL de oe, i es ep OIL Gall 5d Skislly Olas J lad! oleLe 3 ald! Bslill Opera BSB) pre Osele foe on benelinl y 6K dole Syd Sly ohlad BSI Lele beg AM gre (Al SLI HLS BU! gt CLL! BL gle WEYL FjLaod! Or tagt le BLE Bly (pSodl by feat ly dal Bg Res ale Liles Ls AST LiL arly Ql bys pe Bylprw Vly Str sll Se agitly Das! SI Obst we il Opae aye Eyl! dpe I obls sof SL ds y Gulsis Seal ull gle 8, ily De Lay WI Sbbs! rd Gulls pee dome PG Ay ge OF EL GE celal Oly cadets Glam gf OLS Gee Lerloals Yardy Gre ty vee! AS oped oo LL BUI ANS 8 LL oll Ll all oda ye Lbs Last & ib - Bes Jo. bee gallate! spats Liga! Ly OBI le USy5 cgebatt SPU N ye La Whe Uke A Slade OLS i Operas Gob pir tied (£9) sagt Goel Ue STM] gas Gp id flee La 25 ay es 5 Ut) dad) Slencel Grey op MA Jee Oproy OI Ud toll sid « DL pile pS shee Js spel ge a8 SV OGL Cte ibe BWI Jel ee Ley ele VI ell SLE cell et HI gp Las Je II LSI te WS past desl bse le Gee Ley ot By pl) path VY tbe gly Zaye! Vee S eaceall $ RS fell US OP) ET SH oye ai yal ble gt ed pe pall gb By SAN I, EU Gedy) papal dese VATA Gly las pinay ogl Lad ayaa age Ui dy of 5p Opry %, (pe Jy Y Spaced AW jbo eg OWS GLI lia JEU Leads -pUY! SM Egke pall Jue aby 3 Hele Glpaiy ci Go par lacie GUY Jue SL Gy ols SLs IN Laglye I} Ube ols Nia foil yo p> ase Eat! Lae Ys cis A Say er a ae 2 pe Ue LE MDS ls spar SLs ogo gabe all aad gd eh veoF Al eg UI EL p65 Y Opes tyte OEY) .leut, Balogh bye cng ah bln os Le se Sl! ge Fel SUI ay yall ain LS pai Opmerrge Lys b) . te ol 3 adnosis das de 53 lg AY ollie! Che Y sly aeatII B Uebes Ls at ah V Op ero ye Uylie BT Ls « Lge hih phalglly Stal fells SUL ye GI By dl il aly Elva by geal put dey lard! aed I LI! JR es Us Il gb HSN ge eg ge Let aye pled ole Y Ley cnet pl bya, loge Bee ce SW pl IY paw dp oy dy) DL, Tae pla Lhd) feos! pias de. Apel OS ages there Geet of GS dle fais Y SLU ge By pal Gly CE Let ge peye cegeall avs SES Uf gay) SLIT odes GLLSy 0,55 Fpes ent SLs Cod Heal Ly Eps ytl Let! ge as (oles VI PTY OL wpe Ue AUS cee Fhe Op eroges Ge Y Lew AS ple 13] dangle Bi LL; C5 Be Bod eddl ot aay a GS ley SL ad edad all Slee! oe dette epee] Sob oe 5 98 Opnra ye a> ky GU Yost 5) alle call dees kt pe ge (de clés collins engin E55eI! Sal et Opera yt ph eB ydl Gyi SI le J} ULe] eH! Yo) seb ore et (abl Gata I) GbL ae Ostele ot ele dy al bl oe rob! el ten ol G35! Ak ee clase HS AB LY Fylde Bb lsat y peel Gate LS Orage LT LT ee Spl pes GL AY Sli pan ee oll Chal palo» Lewy Lis si ius LUND pad p otal lia pa gle COBY! oSery QoS EV Bly L oles bal WW OS ge pill feadll by IW OLS BAIL, ip sbd on pet iy § SI OLS 5 LY Be 5 feed (3 1H, BIS 3 lye PPL! (I fad 3 5 59S BEN She pal eUbly eS dy eal oe ll (PM i ples BG Al Be Kelp gy I OLS Yoees Fale Sf igh cle Os rtyy bee] Os by Ose ld OIS ES peins Ose SLL! gl} Bd! le 3 all Operodgh PAE Lmgiell olilkistly ollie! ole lal ile “ dae Uapeteel AI Ud! attly peY Cyd Le! Gel 3 ot toe) Lebel fell ola Slew) gh) Avil § Lh bubs ot Oe et AS Srdy Opnernge Jae GS Le 3] LEV Leer sar plnatl Se AI Boa) LIE Dypredl Lae eo (aus Dy GS Ga Led Sy) God chs siey al cul Yup yp ty cil! Le ge LLL 4) SLE SI OLR! Ob seer Hel Bb 8 Bask (Lalo gale came id Y ob I Gyo ols OO Wl ble Last fad ie GU callin Taye Wd J] Gal (ul) de lanl Gye Ole of el VW Sb cp Y Yb GU ae oe Boe Jb BP Pts eels! Dye Geel gi YY! cptle pa Y gral! Lyl GES ode GS nad of yd. Gla! ALT pls onl Se treba! Qu dy wl BlyY adel 3 opaed! QU cee oS hee OF LY Sl gull Ob GS pl island el OF gXap LS 46 FI BL Slate ge ple toy gal obs lb A Bed! Gly iS tel ye Ee Gs Mu i SLI heel le tase Clb, cgalle ghlyaS pLutl at Oy PLY Gales gee ted! Opel Ole ley BSI ce sy GLI lye ge Lee Uae ode Gl] Operas Dey Who Vl Gag asl cesy bp aa LW GLI! Lay ede pW GF el! bb Gan Lay «Slot US By cell ole Operage Jee ae GU Lendl ode Gy et BS GH LS OLY Feld Uy bey ee bas pa Aad LS jes Chel dele 3 lel Gye Olly Sy 5.) AVON 2 Cape Bling Dpueraye SLE; Le lll! us Gp PLY! GsUP yy (EV) "MO eadod! ital Oats Ygurrge SLEjb :baiily Jlail - o Bymrags SLL oe Galt Ob yKad 1D pteule ys gle Likes Tose ad y TIN le Syed GUI ipl pill Genel Hay he pak ol ye ot ce jly pally psheadl 3 ae eee lye PREY ema Cals! tat Luke Sled clase 3b (LU oe AI BLEB Hide ler ge Let Lee ea ol gS Sd 9 ULE SUL A fer Legler OS ct gallo el 3 ol (dbl jet! bee! aly SUL elas plaxaly (POLY 8 Li pally Gant BLS a by gee eee ely GeV SLi) pli J] BL! Oper ge ji ob Soy Shey OWS So ge SLL) eldel aos He dre olga le ST yo Lely Spall plea 3 Gd od Cele Vy dy tl le foley Great le 5.5L Opts LW OA pASI Opmrage Sb gb cep Lana at gS SS A line If polis d Of Gly AG Ue CLIN gd teal BIG dale Gols de Ue cll cde Bly Jb Gil olab ress) del je ee fae GUI pyline peed ty oV40V ple c= ee Operas Lele ge BEV Oly Gb (Gud! PLY peel ebyy abet QU lady GUS! SLI! ag ppd odie ari BK le derle f oly pS jlei] dey Ete Le La qty fb Hd “on aL SEE Ghey CLV (UG (3 Lb Le 25 of gS oe Bk ely yt plysy oe OL & Lal cose Gly eae DISs (Ads Spe Gree IS Gry tod el! RIB Geta ot Ser coped cshuT Gory oll] Leys Lawrence, “Genius Denied and Reclaimed: A 40-Year Retrospect on Marshall G.S. (£A) Hodgson’s The Venture of Islam”. ¥vIjymoee (fe Lcae Ltt SF YL OP Lee SVs cally pel eleley eb WILE Oly Ny rege Ge Upro yt sine GUI nd SL Ue pe JS EIS CSL! bled ob dent 25 Bpeaygd Lede dig V tiled) Soles Vly WLS! olba! QS) bb au Gael eet JS dy et ob hai Wit busy SIS! Gey LS Shpall ola eps GB She dels A yale aL! SLA 4309 J iy ald BLS Ul pe oe pI de Opa oe Gn SES fem de «sey Ujoall J ys» bay GQILU olsy! (Al stechnicalization (iI) Hae Gb gS Blodl ISL op eae Tyler! peat) pou gp thee tatlly cles tel qed! JS Lele VW OWE SI be Fpaiy Ure! Class! bs eV, Bolas ae oe pb le cl] gated B gall 1 ae rox Dhesl aye Ob ES Dall ole Chee A Mb! Dolly Hee he Lay - Nyy Wyerl py LS ee ile fb JES gol CY Balin BL Ys ad) OO UM jo syle pail laa 48 Ilo Lewy per Lele peed 4d ppd GUI fot pa 25K oF YR ob a5) OL 3) LN ge Ls Us (6 TY] US J Gad J OLY Be thay Gell yer BIL ghey Lad pod By WES Opry : iY ghee LS (Salih GALESD cpp Lal aad» BK tale bldg Coed BG chy oe pel ube Hs CSUS ALG Gedo Gey he Tb Lilye ST Y colt iy Call ee ins Cll Gogh 8 Sl! SL os tute Sl oe cas AB lly 4 ey SEI Qos el = 1S Ayal Operas SP ae LL Hs GI ype eel oF od ge gs Y SUL Bis OF eyed Ss ol ge 2s 1p OL ode Jeol ae bil (£4) Christopher A. Bayly, “Hodgson, Islam, and World History in the Modern Age,” in: Burke III * and Mankin, eds., Islam and World History: The Ventures of Marshall Hodgson, pp. 39-42. Vb ge Cpe i plany Opry JL LE SLs Bese BPM sl Ay y (0%) YA