Problematics | Five-way tie in race to World

Cup semifinals
ByKabir Firaque
Oct 16, 2023 04:13 PM IST

A reminder that 7 wins in 9 matches may not be enough to ensure a berth in

the top four. Given this points table, can you work out which team won
which game?

The men’s ODI World Cup is now at a stage when you start to calculate
how many victories in nine matches are likely to get you into the
semifinals. It’s a stage that comes after the first few matches in most
tournaments that feature a large number of teams, including the IPL.

Welco
me to Problematics!(Shutterstock)
When 10 teams are playing, it might be tempting to assume that 6 wins
will help you finish fourth if the top three teams win 9, 8 and 7 matches
respectively. This reasoning, however, can be flawed. What if, for
example, A defeats B defeats C?
Wrap up the year gone by & gear up for 2024 with HT! Click here
One possibility that seems to escape many of us at such a stage is that even
7 victories in 9 matches may not be enough. It is possible for 5 teams to
win 7 matches each, in which case one of them would have to miss the
semifinals on account of net run rate. Below is one such combination.

#Puzzle 60.1
#Puzzle 60.1
Although it should be pretty obvious, here’s the disclaimer to prevent any
misinterpretation: the results depicted in the table above are entirely
fictional and any resemblance with an actual World Cup is purely
coincidental.
As in the actual ongoing World Cup, every team plays every other team: 9
matches for each, 45 in total. The results of some matches will be
immediately obvious from the table. For the remaining matches, here are
some conditions:
 Afghanistan defeated two teams that both defeated Sri Lanka
 Bangladesh defeated two teams that both defeated England
 Afghanistan defeated England
Can you work out the results of all 45 matches?
#Puzzle 60.2
Suppose I offered you the following challenge. I bet you ₹100 that if you
gave me ₹200, I would give you ₹300 in return.
If you accepted the bet, would either of us make a profit?
Mailbox: Last week’s solvers
#Puzzle 59.1
Hi Kabir,
Say, the batter played X innings, remained not out Y times, and scored N
runs.
N/(X – Y) = 47
If he had scored 5 runs more in Y innings, then N + 5Y/(X – Y) = 55
This gives 8X = 13Y
Taking X = 13 and Y= 8 gives N = 235. Assuming that the batter’s scores
(other than the three 0s) were in arithmetic progression with a common
difference of 1, his highest score was 28*.
— Anil Khanna, Ghaziabad
While the above was the answer I had in mind, readers have pointed out
that there could also be other solutions: if the batter’s scores were not in
AP but otherwise all different (other than the 0s), the highest possible
score would be 190*; if not, it increases to 226*.
#Puzzle 59.2
Hi Kabir,
If we assume that the diagonal is not already shaded gray then it took me
10 “shade” operations. But then, that's no better than just going row by
row or column by column.
— Amit Khanna (Fremont, California)
Indeed, 10 operations are correct under the given constraints. Some
readers have said 9, but they have missed the point that you also need to
grey out the diagonal that is shown in red. As Amit notes, shading 10
times is the same as going row by row or column by column. One reader,
meanwhile, has pointed out something that will make it easier for me to
create crossword grids in the future:
Dear Kabir,
In a “one-handed” mouse operation, the “Shade” button will need to be
pressed at least 10 times. However, MS Word in its current avatar allows
us to select multiple cell ranges if we hold down the “Ctrl” key. Therefore,
all 10 columns or all 10 rows can be selected, with lengths as required, and
then the “Shade” button needs to be pressed only once to shade the entire
selection.
— Group Captain RK Shrivastava (retired), Delhi
Solved both puzzles: Anil Khanna (Ghaziabad), Amit Khanna (Fremont,
California), Prof Anshul Kumar (Delhi), Dr Nakul Makkar (Noida),
Solved #Puzzle 59.1: Dr Sunita Gupta (Delhi), Sumit Malhotra (Delhi),
Amar Lal Miglani (Mohali), Siddharth Nagarajan (Krea University) &
Nagarajan Subramanian (Gurgaon), Yadvendra Somra (Sonipat), Group
Captain RK Shrivastava (retd, Delhi)
Problematics will be back next week. Please send in your replies by
Friday noon to problematics@hindustantimes.com
Unlock a world of Benefits with HT! From insightful newsletters to real-time news alerts and a
personalized news feed – it's all here, just a click away! -Login Now!

 ABOUT THE AUTHOR

 Kabir Firaque
Puzzles Editor Kabir Firaque is the author of the weekly column Problematics. A journalist for
three decades, he also writes about science and mathematics.

 World Cup
 Results
 Team
 Ipl