Wepewersee it ‘Hcnonsosanve yu pose menvonceui nu pacompenusyeonosns dens ce pearsnods unepciexmues MU. MW. Wepemetbes* UCNONb3OBAHME UMOPOBbIX TEXHONOTMM NPM PACCMOTPEHMH YIONIOBHbIX AEN B CYME: PEASIbHOCTb WM NEPCHEKTMBbI" Annomauua. 8 cmamve paccmompusaiomca akmyanbNble eonpocel, CeAsaHAbIe C Ucnom2080- ueM yudppoeex mexonoeuil @ yeanoaHom cydanpousaodcmee, Aamop uanaeaem HanpaeneMua uu@poeuzayuu denmenswacmu cyda u npuk4unei UcnonesoeaKun @ Heli ucKyecmaeHwoza UNMeN aekrna, cthopmynupoaanivie opeanamu Cosemo Eaponss. Mousodamcn amanti noseneHun om Genvavix yubpoeeix mexkonoeul @ pa6ome cHowana apSumpaxxHx cydos, a noxdHee — cyd0e Obie 1opucduKyuu. Jeticmeyouue u nepcnexmusHwle yutbpoedie mexwonoeuu paccmampu- ‘aaiomea no mepe dauxeliun yeonoalioz0 dena, nocne nocmynneliuA E20 a cyd om npoxypopa. Bhowimenstoe enumonue 6 cmamee ydeneno noprdxy ¢opmupoeaHua cocmasa cya Gna pac- cmompenua KoKKpemHoz0 yeonosHo20 demo, oHaNUsUDyIOMCA mpydHOCIMY, eosHUKAOWUE KO hymu ucnoneaoeanus aemomamusupososHod uMbopMauuoHHod cUcmeMs! @ amam eonpoce, npednazaiomca nymu ux paspewenus. Aamop caumaem Heo6xodumeim ucnonesoeam» Baa abi 3060 nomepneswux, caudemened u Spyeux ywocmnukos cyde6u020 pas6upamenscmsa 60340 Hocmu anekmponols nownss, daa 4e20 npednaeaem eHecmu coomeemcmayioujue UEMEHEHUR 8 Seticmayioujee npoyeccyanvuoe 3aKoK0damenvcmeo, 8 cmamve packpeiaaamca dedicmayiousul nopadox u nepcnexmussi ucnonss0ea4iun @ yeonooHom npoyecce cucmen audeoKoNipepeNycessu, ayuo- u eudeonpomaxenuposanun xoda cyde6Hoee paa6upamenscmea. Coobusaemca o6 onsi- Herx pospa6omMax npozpames pacriosHasoHuR pevu yuacmMuKos cydebHoz0 pas6upamenscmsd, (OcoBoe ehumanue yOeneno docmumenunm ao exedpenuu uudpoetsx mextonoeull @ cyBax 2. Mo- x86), ocywiecmaneuserx @ xode peanuzayuu menkdyrapodHoz0 npcexma «Mloddep\cKa cyBeGwou ‘pechopmer». B amoll cerau onucwaaemen coaBaiiue @ cyBax 2, Mockabi anekmpontiix Konull mpa- Guuvonnen eBymarkibix» Gen, Genarowux cydonpoussodcmeo Gonee omnkpsimneim, Knvoveavie cnoea: yubpoevie mextonoeuu, yeonoeHoe cydonpouseodemeo, @opmuposaHue cy- Ge61020 cocmaaa, aneKmpounan nowmo, eudeoKorihepencanse, ayduonpomoxanupoaaiue, au: Geonpomoxanuposavue, anexmponnoe demo, DOI: 10.17803/1729-5920.2019.150.5.117-131 Xapaxrepnayn nepexnsaembil Hamn 6 Hacro- Aujee spema nepHon, GONbuMHCTEO yueHIK CoA 3oIBa!or ero ¢ BypHbiM passuTHEM HHdopMaLH- ONHbIX TexHOnOFHii, nocTeneHHo oxBarbIBaIoU\AX Gyxeansio ace ceps! xHaHH O6wecTea. Coape- MeHHole CHCTeMbI nepenayn MHdopMaLinn 8 UN PoBoH Gopme cyuecTaeHHo ycKopAIoT pazauTHe SKOHOMMKH, NOBbIMIaIOT ab_KTHBHOCTS NPAHATHA ynpaanenveckix peuleniii, cnoco6cTayior AocTH- 2MeHMIO MPOPbIBOB B HaYYHbIx HCCNEAOBAHKAX, APOHMKaIoT 8 MeAUMHY, C6pazosanve, He ocTaB~ ‘89, KHEBAHATEIX TEPPHTOPAI» HB OAHON O6Na- Tm venoseveckolt nenTenbHocTH. Nogasnmouee Gonbumucrso aKTHBHbIx TpyAOCnOCOBHEIK rpaHK- Cravea nogrorosneiia B pamKax uccnesonannA no rpairy POOM Ha ocHosaninn Aorosopa oT 04.10.2018 Ne 18-29-16041.MK, Crater nonroroenena ¢ ucnonbsosakvem cnpaBosHo-npaBosoli crcTembs «KoHcynsTaHTiTmoc». © UWepemersen i. 1, 2019, Uepememsea Veope Mzopeeauy, KaHAMAAT IOPHAMNECKHX HayK, AOUEKT KaxeAps! yronosHo-npoyeccyant- Horo npasa Mockosckoro rocyapcrsehHoro lopwjameckoro yHHsepcuTeTa wmeKH O.E, Kyradana (MIHOA) igorsheremetyev@gmail.com 125993, Poccva, r. Mockea, yn. Canonan-Kyapmncnan, 2. 9 (150) mais 2019 117118 HAYKM KPHMHHAMBHOTO WMKNA JUS CRIMINALE fal 8 Haweli crpave, 8 mMpe 8 YenoM Ha paBoTe M 8 GbITy NonbyioTcA KOMNLIOTepaMM, NaHuleTaMA wx mutHMaTIOopHbIMM aHanorama — cMapTboHa- mu, npegocrasnsiownmn AOcTyN K caMOM pasHo- o6pasHol n oSwMpHOH HHGopMayan M nonyHe- into pasHoro poaa yenyr. Cornacko onpacy, npo- BeneHHomy BcepoccHiickHm WeHTPOM HsyHeHAMA obwecrseHHoro mHeHiMa (BLOM) 17 centa6pa 2018 r., ona wHTepHeT-nonssosaTeneli 8 PoccHH coctasnaer 81 % rpamaaH, "3 KOTOpbIX 65 % abt- xognt B Cer exenHesHo. Cpean poccial 8 803 acre or 18 go 24 ner stor noxazatent cocrasnser 97%. Takum o6pazom, akrHMeckm CosqaHa H No- CToAHHO pacwmpaeTca MaTepManbHaA Gaza ana ‘acé Gonbulero sHeapeHHA UNdpoBD:X TexHONOTHit B MSH» OBuecTea, B atx ycnosuax npouecc sceobuseti unbpo- BH3ayHH He Mor He 3aTPOHYTE TaKyIO BaKHYIO céepy rocynapcraeHHoi AenTenbHocTH, KaK OCy- lectanenne npasocygna. B cBa3M ¢ 3THM BO3HINK Wa nocnepHne ronbl akTHaHo Hcnonbayerca Aame ‘TepMHH «3NeKTPOHHOED HN «uAposoe» NpaBo- cyane, 8 conepaHne KoTOpoTO yueHbie, CyAbM M Tpaxqane, sosneYeHHbie 6 npouecc cyAonpoHs BOACTSa, aknagbiBaloT MHOrAA pasHbil CMBICN. Beictynan 8 deapane Tekyuwjero roa Ha coBe- laknv-cemmbape npencenarenek pernoHanbHbix cypos obulert IopHCANKYMA H ApGUTpANKHEX cy- 08, Npeacenarens lpasurenscrsa PO fl. A. Mea Benes NoANepKHYN BakHOCTE yYACTHMA CyAeBHOH cHCTeMbI B NPoUecce YAdpoBM3auMn CTpAHe! MH canaan ocyu\ecTanaloulyiocn paboTy No TexHiMve- ckoli MonepHusa\nn cyqos c peannsayneli Gonb- Wolk HauMoHaNbHo nporpamMol no unbposoii BKOHOMMKE. B 3TOM COAIM HM GLIA OTMe4eHDI Takne 3HakOBbIe AOCTIMKeHHA B UMpoBHsauMK cypos, Kak evicrayioujan ¢ 2012 r. asromaTH3n- posaihan ccrema [AC «Mlpasocyanen, 6 6ase AaHHbIx KoTOpOH HaxonITcA yike Gonee 80 MAH Aen, pacuMpAIOUaRCR BOSMOMHOCT NORAYH A0- KYMeHTOB 6 cya © a7eKTPOHHOM BHze, yuacTHe B cymeBiteix sacemannax c NOMOU\S!O CHCTeMBI BA- AeoKondepenyni?. C passutHem anekTpoHHoro npaBocyA~MA cy- Aelicknii Kopnyc cTpaHe! OGocHOBAHHO CeRSbIEa- eT fanbHeviuiee paasuTue ero RocTynHocTH KaK AHO} M3 COCTaBNRIOUIHX ero CoMMANEHOR 3b >eK- tHaHoctHt He pqasance 8 ToHKOCTH BbIcKasbisaeMmbIx Ha cTpanintiax iopHaMdecKol ne4aTH MHeHMi 0 TOM, \T6 npegcrasnset cobi aneKTpoKHoe npaso- cyave, Mbi 8 AanbHeliulem 6yaem McKoAMTS 43 NOHMMaHHR TOrO, NTO Ha CeroAHAUIHH eHb 3TO AeRTeNbHOCTD CyAOB No paccMOTPEHMIO H pas: PeUIeHMIo yronoBHIx, rPaNKAaHCKAX W MHBIX OT- HeCeHHbIX K HX KOMMETEH\UAN en, C AKTHBHIM WcnonbsoBaHiien MHopMmayHoHHo-TeneKoMMy- HMKauMOHHOH CeTH «MHTepHET» 4 pasnHuHbIX Un posbix TexHonornii, nosBonmoUynx cRenaTe ero Gonee AOCTynHbin, oneparMaHbim M aobex- THBHBIM. B 3TOM BONPOCE MoI NoNHOCTbIO cOrNaC- Hei ¢ NOHATHeM 3nexTPOHHOTO npasocyaMA, AaH- Hoim (npaeaa, npAMeHHTeNbHO K AeRTenbHOCTA ap6uTparkiiix cyaos) Goiswnm npeacenatenen ApGutpamHoro cyaa r. Mockati C. 10. Yel, MHO- To chenaBWMM AA BHEAPEHHA UNdpoBbIX TeEXHO- norhii 8 AeATenbHOCTe apGUTPAMHDIK CyAOB™. Cneayer ormerite, uo np ecem pas6poce Hen no NOBOAY Toro, 76 cutTaTs sneKTpOH- HbIM MPABOCYAMEM M Kak rMy6OKO WNbpoBLIE TexHONOTHH MOTYT NPOHMKHYTS B STOT BHA rO- cymapcrseHHol aesTenbHocTh, yNeHbIe M cyabA npakrnveckn eAMHOLYWHE! B TOM, TO coBCTBEH- Ho paspeweHne npasoabix cnopos, KoTopoe co- cTasnaet cyuiHocte npasocyain, cevivac W 8 060- SpHmom GyAyWeM He MoxeT Bie AOBepeHO WckyccTBeHHOMy HHTeNeKTY K MOET 6bITS 803- OMEHO TONbKO Ha Nenosexa. Yenosexa, \MpOKO cnonbsyioujero 8 3TOH AeRTenbHOCTH nepenOBbIe AOCTMKEHHA COBpeMeNHOM HayKH, BKIONAR MC- kyccrBeHHbili MHTenneKr®, Aymaetca, so nocaHoBneHe no paccmarpH- Baemomy Aeny npHroBopa Wak NpMHATHE ApyrAK CYAeBHIX peweHit, coRSaHHEIX C OUCHKO MHO- M€CTBA CROKHBIX, NPOTHBOPEYABDIX M NOpOH B3a- WMoncKMo“atoulMx MoKazaTenbcTs, ¢ npasosoh 2 URL: wwwcbizhit.ru/index/users_count/0-151 (nara o6pauleHM: 28.02.2019). + Poccuiicnaa rasera.13 espana 2019. No 31 (7789) + TMipencegatent Cosera Cygel Po Momoron B. 8. Kavecrao, oneparHBHocTe, AOCTynHOCTe. O KBHTEpMAX Cou anbHofi abipextsHocTa cyqeGHoll BnacTH. BbicTynneHHMe Ha NapnameHTcKAx cnyiiaHHAK CoseTa denepaynn no Teme «Bonpocs! oBecneveHHA rapaHiMit npae M cao6oR YenoBeKa M rpaxAaHnHan 21 HoAGpA 2018 // Agonatexaa rasera. Ne 24 (281). 16—31 nexabpa 2018, 5 yyya C. 10, nexrpoxKoe npasocyave. 3neKTpoHHeili AOKyMeHTOOGopoT. M. :Mpocnext, 2018. c. 20, © ByneaKoea E. B., enucos H.C, BynzaKos B. . KrGepnpasocyane // AaMmHMCTpATOp cyfa. 2018. Ne ; Bnaco- 20°C. B. K sonpocy 0 npucnoca6avsaHnu yronosHo-npoueccyanbHoro MexaHHaMa K uAgpOBOK peanbHoctH // BuGnmorena Konmunanncra. Hays mypHan. 2018, Ne 1. C. 17 ; 2opoea 0. A., npencenatens MocKoncxoro N*5 (150) wali 2019Wepewersee it ‘Hcnonsosanve yu pose menvonceui nu pacompenusyeonosns dens ce pearsnods unepciexmues keanndvkaunelt yctaHosneHHbix o6cTonTenbcrs, W nOHATHOe ANA yNaCTHMKOB Npouecca H ATA O6- lecrea 6 WenoMm o6ocHoBaHHe aTAx PewleHHis He MOryT 6biTe Aosepelsi McKyCCTBeHHOMY MHTeNTEK- Ty. HyMHO NIpH 3TOM NloHMMaTs, ro NporpaMmy ANA NDMHATHA TaKix pewleHii «aNeKTPOHHbIM Cy- Aveli» W anropHTm ero Aelicrenii cosnaior nionh, Y KOTOPbIX MOTYT BbiTb H ECT pasHble NoAXoAb! k peweHiio Tex sonpocos, KoTopsle cocrasnntoT cyuHocTs npasocyaMA, 1 HH OAMH M3 STHK No~- XOAOB He MOMeT CHHTATDCR CAMbIM AYHUIMM H CO. Bepuenisin, B Haweli crpane cnomunoce Tak, YO UMbpO- Bole TexHonori palibule Bcero Cran Mcnonb30- Barbca 8 ap6urpaxvom cyaonpowssoacTee, 4ro CcaR3aHo ¢ OcoGeHHOCTHIO paccmaTpHEAeMbIx ap- Gurpartibinn cygamn 3KOHOMMNECKHNX CNOpOS. YeraHopneHie 3HaMMbix ana paspeweHia 3THX cnopos o6crortenscre rmashbim o6paz0m cBAza- Ho c uccneposaHMeM pasHoro pona NAcoMeHHbIXx oKasaTeNSCTE, KOHMN AENAIOTCA ConepRALyMe ceemenna 06 atmx oBcronTenbcTsax AOTOBOpLi, aKTbI, cnpaBki, Aenoaan KoppeCMOHAeHUMA, MHbIE AOKYMCHTDI, BbinonHEHHBIe B SopMe UndpOBO!, rpacbmMeckoi 3anMCH MM MHbIM CNOCOBOM, Nlo3BO- ‘ARIOW\MM YCTAHOBHTS AOCTOBepHOCTe AOKYMeHTa (4. 1 cr. 75 ANK Po), OGvacHeHWMA ny, YHACTBYIO- ax @ pene, Kak npaBHno, npeAcTaBNAOTCA B CYA B NMCEMeHHOM GopMe, cahgeTeNsCKHe NoKasaHiAA cnonbayiorca 8 noKaSbisaHnn cpasHHTeNbHo pea- Ko WM TakiKe MOrYT GoiTb H3NOMeHEI 8 NCeMeHHOH opme. eqepanbHbim 3aKOHOM oT 27 MiOnA 2010 r. Ne 228-3 6bina npeaycmorpeHa 803- MOMHOCTS NowaNM 8 apoUTPAKHbIM cya sanane- Hii, Mano6 M ApYTAX AOKYMeHTOS 8 a/eKTpOHHOF opme, naBeueHve AMu, yYacTByIOWlMx B AenNe, C ncnonbsosannem caiira ap6uTpaKHoro cya M Si1eKTPOHHOH NONTHI, BOSMOMHOCTS YHACTHA 8 Cy- eGHOM sacenaHnn nocpegcTsom sHaeoKoHde- PenucsAsn, fosaHee 8 apGurpaxrom npouecce 6bina pacumpena cepa Aevicrana ynpoweHHoro NpowssogcTsa M BHeAeHO NpMKaSHOe NPOW3BOR- cTa0, nossonaiowyme paccmatpHeaTs Aena 6e3 YHaCTAA CTOPOH, HCKnIONMTeNEHO No NpeAcTaBnel- HbIM MMH AACTAHLUAOHHO ROKYMeHTAM, B TOM 4iC- sie 6 aneKTpoHHoM euge. K sTomy cneayer Ao6a- BiTb xopoulee OcHaujeHMe apGuTpaMHbix cyA08, npeacrasnnioux coBoli Kpynuie crpyktypHbie eAMHMUEL, KOMTBIOTEPHO! TexHHKOH M COOTBET- crayiouwmmn cneynanneramn. flanHbie HosoBpe- AeHHa AaNM UMpOKMA MNAnynbc pasBHTHIO TOTO, ‘10 ceronHa mbt HaablaaeM s/eKrpOHHbIM paso cyanem, # ykaaann o6uHi BexTop ero pasanTan’. Bo mHOroM cxO~HbIe BO3MOMHOCTA AINA TaKOTO paaBHTHA HMeIOTCA © chepe rpaMAaHCKOTO CyAO- powasonctaa, 8 KOTOPOM TaKKe NpeaYCMOTPEHb! npoueAypet yNPOWeHHOrO M NIpMKASHOr NpOMS- Boncrea, npenrionaraiowre paccmorpenne 1 pas pewlenie len no MMceMeHHBIM AoKa3zTenbcreaM, Bkios.an aneKrpoHHbte HOKYMeNTEI, Ges yuacrHA cropor. B yronosiom cyonponssonctee foKasarenb- cea, ucnoneayembie ana ycraHoBneHia oBcroR- ‘Tenbera cosepulenan npectynneHine, oTAnuaioTcA shavmTenbHbim pasHoobpasem m HHAMEHAYaNE- Hui NO ceoeMy COepHaHNID. ITO OTHOCHTCA KaK i AOKYMeHTaM, TAK M K APYTHM HOKasBTENbCTBIM ‘«aepBanbHoro» (nokaaaHnn, OUKBIe CTaBKH H HM nonoGHite) m «Hesep6ansHoro» xapakrepa (npo- ToKonbi cneqcTaeHHerx Aeticroni, seujecrBeHHbIe AowasaTenccrea M mHbie). 3Ha4MTenbHyIO acTo Ccpequ Bcex AoxazaTencte no yronosHomy feny rpana 4 nponomaior mrpare noxasaHHA nono- apeeaeMbix, oBsMHAeMbIx, NoTepnesUInx H cBHAe- Teneii, KoTopeie 8 xone NPoNsBoACTBA NO OAHOMY TOMY ike yronosHoMmy Keny MoryT npeTepnesate MaMeHeHun, “ MHOraa CyulecreeHHble. 3a04H0e, Ges noncyanmoro, paccmoTpeHne yronoaHbix ‘hen npeacrasaner nnuie McxMo4eHHe H3 OBuIero pagina, Ho H 8 Tom cnyyae He MOKeT NPOBO- Aureca 8 oTcyTcTane OBeMHITENR W S2U\MTAHKa M Ges wccneqoBakna acex npemcTasenHeix 4OKa- 3aTEMBCTB, #3 KOTOPDIX AOKYMeHTEI NpeACTaBNAOT ‘MWe HeahauMTensHyio WacTe, 370 AesaeT 3aTPYA- HATENbHO}, CCIM BOOBUIE BO3MOMHOM, KaKYIO-NM- 60 dopmannsaunto noxasatenscTs M npyMeHeHne nipH vx cobMpannn n ecneqovaHnn Tex xe CxeM, To W no MHOTHM apBuTpAKHoIM H rpAxKAAHCKHM enam, nepegayy ux 8 cya, 8 anexTpoHHom BHA. Yaaaauible o6cronrenscraa w ny6AMUHbil xapak- ep yronostoro npouecca senaior ero Gonee Tpa- AMUMOHHOIM H KOHCepBaTHOHbIM TpnmepHo no Taknm xe HanpasneHHaM paa- ensaetea «anekrpoHHoe npasocymner M 3a pyGe- roponckoro cyna. MaTepabio raaere «KommepcaHre» 18.06.2018 ; Zaxupos P. ©. cnonbaoeanne cospemeH- Hoix T-TexHonorHi Kak CpeAacTao AOCTHMeHHAA OcHORHENK 3ana4 cyonpoHanoncTaa // BecTHNK rpaxAaHicKoro mpouecca. 2018. Ne 1. ToapoSueii atanns atoro «npomenyrouroro sTana» passuTHA 8 POCCHH «a/IeKTPOHHOTO NpaBOCyAA” cm. Towomapexko B. A. SneKrpoHHoe rpakfaHcKoe cyonpou3sopicrao @ Poccw. LITpHXH KoHLIeNYAK. M. : Npo- next, 2015. 69-74 (150) mais 2019 119120 HAYKM KPHMHHAMBHOTO WMKNA JUS CRIMINALE 24om. Hanpumep, @ BennkoBpuTaHin 8 KavecTae epevix waros HMCTS (Cay»k6a cyqos 4 TpHbyHa- zn08 Ee Benwuecrsa) sanycrana oXmat-cepBMcel, CengaHHble c O6pauleHnAMa 6 cyano NoBoay pas- BON08, AeHEMHEIX B3bICKaHKI K Hanoros, OTcNe- aknBaHHA NPOXOKAeHHA fen B cyAaX®. KomuteT Mannctpos Coseta Eaponti 8 cB0- eft Pexomenaunn No R (2001) 3 of 28 espana 2001 r. «Mo pacnpoctpaHeHnto cyne6HOl m HOM opmaeckoli wopmaunn nyrem wcnonesosa- Hi HOBbIX TexHonorHii» peKomeHAosan rocyaap CTBam-ssieHam «MaKCHMaNbHO ynPOCTHT» CBAIb TpayaaH € CyJOM... NPM NOMOLIA HOBBIX TEXHONO- Twit», TO Mpeanonaraet npx ycnoBMa coGmIone- Hwa TpeGoBannli BesonackocTa M coxpaHHOCTH wacTHoli nH opmaunn: = BosMOmHOCTS MHKUMApOBATS CyAeGHOE pas- Guparenucreo npn NOMOW\M aneKTPOHHEIX cpeacrs; — BoamoxHocTe npeANPHHAMaTe AanbHerune aelicrana 8 xone paccmorpennn nena 8 cyne & aneKTpOHHO# cpene; — BOsMOKHOCTE NonyHaT> CBeReHMA 0 COCTOR- iW ena np Hanuma aoctyna K cyae6HOH Mi opmaliMonHod cucTeme; — BosmomHocTe nonyeHinA MHGOpMaLNn o pe- aynbrarax cyqe6Horo npouecca & sneKTPOHHOH ‘opme; — B03MomHocTe nonyNeHHA AocTyna K M06O% HHidopmaynn, HeOBxoRMMOH Ana AOCTIOKEHIAA aébexTHsHOCTa BbINONHEHHA cyAeGHBIK peule- Hui. B pexomeniaauan takike ykasbioaerca, 4To Mi opmauna o cyae6HbIx npoueccax aonaHa Bit o6weqocrynvoi m pacnpocrpaHATeca np noMmo- lun cera MuTepHer Nosanee EsponelicKol Komnccneli no 26- dekrnatocta npasocyana Cosera Eaponst Obiia Tpunata Xaptia o cyAe6HOM NpHMeHEHMH Hc- kyccT8eHHoro MHTenneKTa, 8 KOTOPOK OcoGo TopMepknaaerca, TO HCKYCCTBeHHDIA MHTeNNeKT MomeT cnocoBcTBOBaTS NoBbIWIeHHO KaYeCTsa M addexrnsHoct paGors! cyo8, Ho ero sHenpeHHe ‘AOMMHO NpOHSBOAMTECR OTBETCTBCHHbIM O6pas0M We HapyuraTs nonomennit Eoponeiickoli KoHBeH- Uni 0 sauypTe npas venoBeKa M OcHOBHEIX Ceo60n, B sro¥4 cana Kommccued chopmynnposansi npHl- Unni NPUMeHEHHA HcKyccTBeHHOFO MHTeNNeKTa 8 npagocyann, oBecneunaaioume coBmioneHne mips ecex yacrunkos cyonponssonctsa, cpenM KOTOpbIK OTKDDITOCTS, GecnpHcTpacTHOCTS M HecT- Hoctb @ o6pa6orKe unppoeol Hopmayinh, B03- MOKHOCTS €€ KOHTPONA M MIPOBEPKH CO CTOPOHE sannTepeconanHen anu!” BHa4HTeNbHble BOSMOMHOCTA NO BHEADEHHIO 8 npagocyane unposbix Texkonornli npenocras- nnet peanvaauna bepepansHoi Yenesoi npo- rpammsi «PaaeutHe cyaeGHol cHcrembi PoccnH Ha 2013-2020 rogpi»"!, nonioe sbinonHeHne KoTopoli noasonnt caenars npaaocyaue B crpane Gonee cospementtins, TexHoniornveckh Gonee oc- HUUIEHHBIM M 8 KOHENHOM ceTe NOgHATS ero Ha KavecTseHHo HosbIli yposeH. OuesupHo, 470 pasBuTAe URppoBbIX TexHoNO- wit 8 cepe yronosHoro cyaonpowseoactea xoTA wonipaerca Ha onbir apGuTpamHbix cyA08, HO He -MOMeT ero KoNHpOBaTE MCKOAA HS CyLIECTBeHHEIK ovnnanii paccmorpenina yronoshinx sien 8 cyax. BHenpenine THX TexHonorHii He MOMeT BoITS ‘OnHoMoMeHTHBiM Hc YueTOM OrpoMHOTO KOnHYE- Tea cyqo®, paccmatpnaarounx yronosHbie Aena 8 Nawiei CTpane, OTCyTCTEMe GO MHOTHK H3 HK HeOBXOAMMBX TEXHHMECKAK CpeACTB M CooTBeT- crayiouynx cneunanncros, Tpe6yer, nomnMo 32- KOHOMATEMDHEIK, CepbeSHEIX OPTaHHsauHOHHLIX, unaticoabix, TexHHNeCKHX H KaPORBIX Mep. Opnako ectecrsennbie TpyanocTm, cansaMnbie ‘cat npoyeccamh, He jalor npaga Ha TonraHMe a mecTe. Mave pactylunit ean yronoBHerx Aen MW coAzaHHBIX c HAMM MaTepHanOB no cyAebHOMY KoHTponio ceeayt Ha Her Bce YCHAKA no NOBbI- Wevinio Kauecrea npaaocyaua. Tam, fe 270 803- MOMHO, UA POBBIE TEXHONOTHH AOMKHB! aKTHE- Ho BHEAPATECR, a No HeKOTOpbIM HanPaBMeHMAM peanbHo BHegpAIOTcA ynke celivac. Mx ymenoe NenonsaoBaHie cnocobHo cyulecreHHo o6ner- Te «npoueccyanbHyio KH3HE» aceM yACTHMKaM yronosHoro npouecca H caMOMY cyAy H 8 KOHeN- Hom Hrore ¢genare yronoBHoe cynonponsBoncrso Gonee octyniisim, OTKpsiTeiM, oneparHBHim W abekTHeHbiM, BaxHbiM WaroM @ pasBMTAH unposnaayan yronosHoro cyponponssoacTea 8 Hawiei crpane ABHnoce AononHeHHe YK PO cr. 474.1, acrynwaweli 8 cany ¢.1 aHBapa 2017 Kax yxazaHo 8 Denepanstiom saKoHe OT 23 MioHA 2016 r. N2 220-3, sHeculeM naHHoe AononHeHHe © URL: https://www.gow.uk/guidance/the-hmets-reform- programme (nata o6pausewun: 06.03.2019). * URL: docs.cnté.ru/document/90199650 (qara o6pausenna: 05.03.2019) 2 URL: rapsinews.cu/international_news/20181204/292074043.html (aara oBpauenun: 22.01.2019). * @enepanvtan Yenesan nporpamata «PaseuTue cyfe6HOH cucremb! PoccHH Ha 2013-2020 rofl», YTB. NO- ravionnenmem Mpasirenscrea PO or 27.12.2012 Ne 1406 // CNC «KoncynsranMnwac». N*5 (150) wali 2019Wepewersee it ‘Hcnonsosanve yu pose menvonceui nu pacompenusyeonosns dens ce pearsnods unepciexmues 8 YIIK PO, ero nonoxeHitA NPHMeHRIOTCA NM Ha- MSM TeXHUMeCKOH B03MOMHOCTA B CyAe, TO ECT Tonbko oTKpsIBaIOT BosMOMHOCTb McnoMbsOBAHKA unposbix Texhonorni Mira, ecru nog anekrpoHHLim npasocyanen ToHMMaTe paccMoTpeHHe Aen CYOM c AKTABHEIM MCnonbsoBaHeMm pasnM4Hoix KM>POBbIX TeXHO- AOrnii, TO AV YACHEHAA ero CyWIHOCTH HEOBXO- Aumo paccmotpets, 70 coBoll npeactasnaior 3TH TeXHONOTMM — KaK peanbHo NpHMeHREMbIE, Tak M nepcnekTisHbie. MlosTomy Ha ceromHAUHAH Aeib MOnHO roBopHTe OB oTAeNbHBIX sneMeHTaX anektpoHHoro npasocyauA. B nutepatype abickas2Ho npennomenie paa- ‘enue Wx 8 3aBHCHMOCTH OT Hx NpeAHASHANeHHA 4 HanpasnenHoctu. Mexons Ws vero npegnaraeT- cA Hennte wx: 1) Ha Te, MTO Orpaxaior OTKpHITOCTE npasocyan 1 cyaeGHO! cacrembs 8 yenom; 2) Ha- pasnenneie wa Bsanmogelicrane C OTaeNbHbIMA iyaMi, YHACTBYIOW\AMH B CyAONPOMBBOACTBE, NO ommensiim qenam; 3) HanpasnenHbie Ha oBecne- Neline AeATenbHOCTH cyaa Mero ezanmonelicrene C Apyrumu rocyaapcTBeHHoimn opraHam?, Ham xorenoce Got wsnomiTe Kak ye AeticrBy. Joule, To ects npeayemorpenibie yronoBHo-npo- eccyanbHbim 3aKOHOM, 3neMeHTbl 3nexTPOHHOTO pawocyamA, Tak H Te, KOTOpBIe HCxONA H3 CyLte- CTayiouynx TeHAeHUAA pasauTTAn npoeccyanbHoro 3akoHomaTenscrea (npHeM He TOnbKO yronOBHO- 0) # BoaMomHOcTel UM>poBtix TeXHonOIMi MoryT BOSHHKHYT 8 GninKaliwiem Gyayulem M CBRZaHbI C PaccmoTpeHitem yronosHbix flen 8 cynax. [Ina Hac Gonee yAobHbIM npencraBnnerca Wx AeneHHe M NocnenosatenbHoe paccmorpeHne He no Hanpaa- TeHHOCTH Hx AeliCTBHi, a 8 3aBHcMMOCTH OT cra Ani w oTgenbHerx aTanoB ABHMEHIMA yronoBHoro ‘ena nocne nocryrvienhA ero or npoKypopa e cyA, fo noctaHosneHina npuroBopa. Cneaya atomy NopAaky, Hafo OTMeTHTS, TO AHO! Hx aKTyanbHEIK NPOEAEM, BOsHMAKaIOUAX cpaay nocne noctynneHua yronosioro nena 8 cyA, anierca Sopmuposatine cocraea cya, KoTopo- my npencront paccmatpnaars aro weno. Tosopa © npase Ha cnpaseanuace cyqeGHoe pas6upa- Tenbcrao, KoHBeHuMa © saulATe npas HenoneKa M OcHOBHEIX cBoG0A HaabIaZeT ORHMM M3 OCHOBHEIX efo cocrasnatoulnx paccmoTpeHne ena He3a6n- cumwim m GecnpHcTpacTHBIM CyaOM, CO3RaHHbIM Ha ocHoBaHinn 3aKoHa. CosepuleHHo o4esHqHO, Wro 8 Takoe NoHHMaHHe cyaa eknapbIBaeTcA HE Tomko 3aKoHHbIli NopAgOK o6pazoBaKHA caMoro cyae6Horo oprata, ypexqeHHoro rocynapcraom AVIA paccmoTpeHna COOTRETCTBYIOWINK eM, HOM Nepconansibilt cocras cyael, HaaHaeHHbIx ANA ‘ompasnenna npasocyamn rio KoHKpeTHOMy Hem. To cnomnawerica 8 Hauiel crpake mHoroneTHelt Tpannunn pacnpenenenve yronosHbix nen MeKAY CYAAMI, GXOARLAAMH 8 COCTaB Toro MM KHOFO cyna, ocywecrenanoce pykosomcraom aTAx cyA08, \To Hawino orpaxKeHne, HanpuMep, 8 nonOMeHH- Ax npemHel penaKumn cr. 31 m 35 emepansHoro KoweTuryyMontioro saKona oF 7 eapann 2011 r. No 1-0K3 «O cyaax o6uleli lopucAHKYn», Kaca- rouaxca nonHomounit npeqcenarenel cyqeGHeix konnernit cyqos cpeavero 3eeHa (O6nacTHbIx H paBHbix Hm) H parionHbix cygos. Takoe pacnpene- enne Aen MeKAY CyABANK, YeNAKOM saBncAMyee oT yemoTpeHHA cyabit-pykoBoaMTenr, ucNOML3yIo- lero cBon aaMMHMcTpaTHBHbIe NoNHOMONHA, NO- poli cnoco6Ho nopognr> comMeHKa B HenpejeaR- TOCTH pewieHnié o SopmupoBannn cocrasa cyaa M NoM/MHHOM xapakTepe MOTMBOB TAkMX peweHini. Y nocropoxHero Ha6niogatenA MoMeT CROMUTECA mvienne, 4To Aena, HMeIoU\He NO KaKMN-TO NBM: unnam ocoByio aHasHMocTe, Moryr nepenaBareca Ana paccmorpeHna «nposepeHHbiM» CyABAM, KO- Topbie He NPMMYT HeOKMAaHHENK PeUIeHHi, HM cyapam, umelouynm npeqcKaayemyio nosMynio no zeny. Ml ocraansiem 8 cropoHe Bonpoc 0 TOM, Ha- CKONGKO OBOCHOBHHBIMM MOTYT BbITe TakHe NEA nonomeHina Ka6utet munnctpos Cosera Esponei 3 cB0- x Pexomengaunax Ne R 94 (12) oF 13 oKta6pA 1994 r. rocygapcTaam-uneHan 0 HesaeHcHMocTH, 06 addexrnsHocri m 0 ponk cyneli 8 yenax uc- Knjo¥eHHa BAMAHMA Ha pacnpeneneHne Aen 3a MnTepecoBanibix MY peKoMeHgoBan npoBogMTe €F0 Kc NOMOUYBIO MEpEBBEBKK HM CHCTEMB! aB- TomaTnwieckoro pacnpegeneHia 8 andaBHTHom TOpRAKe MM KAKMM-/IMEO MHbIM aHANOrMSHbIM o6pasom». Tposogusuieeca now armaok Opranwsayan no GesonacKocth m corpyannuecrey 8 Espone 8 2010 r. 8 Knese Kondepenyna no sonpocam He- SasHcamocTa cyje6HOR Bnacth 6 crpaHax Boc- ‘Tounois Eaponss, KOmHoro Kaakasa u LledrpansHoit A3Mi 8 CBOMX peKOMeHAAYAAX TaKwKe YKazara, To «pewiennn o pacnpegenennn wen 8 cyge He MOTYT HaxogMTbCA 8 MCKMONMTeNbHOM KOMTeTeH: UME npegcenatenn cyna H AOAMHB! NpHHUMaTeCA 2 Wapudynnun P.A., Bypeanoe P. C., Bumuee P,F. SnemenTe snexTpoHHoro npasocyaun // PoccniicKni cyabA, 2018. Ne 6, URL: does.cntd.ru/document/901927870 (gara o6paujenna: 11.03.2019). (150) mais 2019 121122 HAYKM KPHMHHAMBHOTO WMKNA JUS CRIMINALE M60 no xpe6io, M60 No sapakee onpeneneH- HbIM npaBHaM ¢ MOHATHBIMM M OBBEKTHAHLIMH kpHTepnam, yCTaHoBneHHbimi Ha 3aceqaHnn ¢ ‘yuactuem cannx cylin", Victopavecki cnomMBwiniicn & poccAiicHnx cy- ‘ax nopAgok pacnpemencHiaa fen, Kak cnocoGHbih NocrasHTb NOR cOMHeHMe OBPEKTABHOCTD B 3TOM Bonpoce, ebiabieaer KPHTHKY yHeHbIX H OBUIe- creeoctas Tipenctaenserca, To MMeHHO coapemeHHiie ndpoBbie TexHonorMn qaioT BosmomHocTe cos fave TaKO} NOpRAOK, KOTOPHIT cHuMaeT rloAospe- ina 8 KaKoH-nKBo npemssaTocra nipx dopmAposa- ni coctasa cyna. IKpe6ui, Kak NPMHATO CNMTaTS, «cnen» i, 8 OTAHMe OT KOMNbIOTepHOH NporpaN- Mol, He MoMeT yMHFTBIBaTS Harpyaky, cneywann- 3aunio cymes, oBweM H ChomHOcTe yronoBHoro ena, npegnonaraemyio nponONKKTeNsHOCTS ero PaccmorpeHna W apyrHe oBcroaTenbcrsa, HMeWo- lywe sHa4eHHe ana pacnpeneneninn men. Kak M 80 MHOrAx ApyrHx BONPOCAX, KACAIOUIHXCA YMG- Poabix TexHonorMli, nMOHEpaMH B CO2zaHAM cO- oTpeTcrayiouleli asTomaTHaMpoBaHHol CAcTeMb! ABHANCS apGUTPAMHIbIe CyAbI. Tak, BOIMORHOCTE pacnpepenehin Aen meray CyAbAMH ¢ NOMOWYbIO nporpammuoro oBecneveia 6bita npenycmorpe- Ha PernamenTom ap6urpaHbix cytos, yreepym- ‘AeHHbim nocraHosnenHem MneHyma BAC PO cue 5 wins 1996 r. K HacToRWemy BpemenH TaKan cuctema gelicrayer 80 ecex apSurpamuurx cyqax crpanei. enepanvibim 3aKoHOM OT 14 WiOHA 2011 F. No 140-03 enecentsi namenenin 8 cr. 30 YNK PO, cornacHo KoTOpbiM cocTas cya ANA paccmoTpe- Hua KoHKpeTHOFO ena opmupyeTcA c yueTOM Harpyakn w cneyMannaaunn cypeli 8 nopAaKe, Hcknloualouem annanne Wa ero opmposanne ‘vy, 3anHTepecoBAHHEIX 8 MCXOHE CysleBHOFO paa- Gupatenscrsa, 8 Tom uncne C McnoNb30BaHMEM 38- TomaTHsHpoBaHHoli KdopMayMOHHOH CHCTeMbl (sect w pane — ANC). OgHako nocne npHHsTHA 3roro 3akowa 8 npakraueckom nvane a cucreme Pacnpemenesia yronosHbix Aen memay CyAbARM onHoro cya mano 4To HaMeHHoCe. Yepes cems ner Denepanbivim 32KoHom oT 29 wiona 2018 r. Ne 228-03 TpeGosaHun K pM menennio AUC 6bi1M pagnianbHo HaMeHeHDs, cormacho HoBol penaKunn cr. 30 YNK Po ee Hc- nonbsosaHve np GopmuposaHnn cocrasa cya ‘Ann paccmoTpeHA KaxAoro yronoBHoro Aena (c yHeTom Harpy3kn M cneyannsaunn cynel) Gb1N0 npHaHaHo oGRaaTenbHbIM. JIM B cnyuae HeBoamomHOCTH McnonbsoBaHAA @ cyte AMC 3a- Ko aonyckaer bopmuposanne cocTasa cyaa 8 HOM TIOPRAKe, HCKMONAIOUIEM BAHAHME Ha ero Gopmuposanne nm, samiTepecosanietx 8 nc- xone cyae6Horo pasGuparenscrsa. Takne Ke H3- MeHeHHA ObiH BHeCeHLI 8 apGuTpamHbilt NPO- ueccyanbHbil, rpampaHicKnit npoueccyanbHtit kopexcbi w Kopekc aamunuctparnakoro cyaonpo- wagog{crea PO. OnHoBpemeHHo C aTMM m3 cr. 31 eqepansHoro KOHCTHTYUMOHHOTO 3aKOHa «O Cy- ‘ax O6uei iopHCAMKWWAH» HCKMIONEHO ykaaaHHe 0 NlonHoMoNMM npegcegaTens cype6Hol Konner cya cpequero agena Sopmuposare cyaebHbie cocTasbi cya Ann paccmoTpeHiA cyaeSHbx nen Ha 3acemaHiMAx CooTBeTCTBYIOUIMK CysAeGHEIK KON- neraih Bee ykaaalible HameHenin scrynaior 8 cMay ¢ 1 ceuta6pa 2019 r. C Momenra actynneHin gal HUIx saKOHONONOMeHHi 8 cHny cOCTa® cyfa, CbOP- uponaHHbilt Ans paccmoTpeHIMn KOHKpeTHOTO YronoBHoro ena, MOKeT CUMTaTECA 3aKOHKEIM, Cn OH cosqal c McnonesosaHnem ANC. McKnio- Nene MOrYT COCTaBnATD AMLb MAPOBBIe CYAbM, aelicrayioume 6 npenenax cBoero cypeGHoro Ywactka, M ogHococrasHbie (ecnv OHM rHe-T0 ule coxpannuce) ni Take ManococraaHile paiow- Hole cys, KOTOpble 8 cMuly HeyKOMnMeKTOBAHHO- CTH MAM WHDIX MpHMH He HMCIOT BOSMONHOCTA pacnpemenenna fen MeXAy cyABAMM C HOMOLYDIO ANC. Vicnonesosanne AVC 8 cyaax o6wel topic AMKUAM 8 YeNOM UINO He TAK BbICTPO, Kak 8 apGH- Tpayx cyAaK, BOsMOMHO, BBMAY Hx GonbUOrO KonmuecTaa W cnOmHOCTelt ¢ Hx TeXHHUeCKiM OC- Haulenem. Kak npegcTaennercr, c HaMGONbUIMN adpextom AUC Moer AeticTBoBaTe B KPYTHEIX * Pewomenqaunn Kuesckolt KondepeHunn no sonpocam HesasHCAMOCTH cyAeEHOH BnacTH 6 cTpaNax Bocro4: Hoi Epponts, KOmworo Kabkaaa u LlenTpanbHoli Aann, 23-25 monn 2010 r. // URLG https://www.osce.ore/ rufodihr/71179?download=true (nata opauenen: 03.02.2019). Tae cynoe xorat ocaoGoqHtb OF «KOppynuWoHHbK nogoapeHnii» sanperom pacnpegenennA jen // URL: https://pravo.ru/news/view/47488 (qara oGpauenua: 22.02.2019) ; Byxapoe A. B. OGecnevenne of wexTus: Horo H He3asMcnmoro pacnpeneneninn Aen MeNay cyAbRONM KaK ad\pexTuBHaR Mepa NPOy/aKTHKM Koppyn Uni 8 palionniom cyne // Agmunnerparop cya. 2016. Ne 2 ; LCP npencrasun nonvyio KapraHy cynebHOF pe- ‘opm // URL: https://pravo.ru/news/view/147743 (qara oBpauyenis: 03.02.2019) ; Bonkoe B. 470 Meulaer cyay crave HeaaBncMmon seranio enacta // Benomocra. 27 qeKa6pa 2018. N*5 (150) wali 2019Wepewersee it ‘Hcnonsosanve yu pose menvonceui nu pacompenusyeonosns dens ce pearsnods unepciexmues cyne6Hbix opratiax, 8 cocrase KoTopbix paGoraer Sonpuioe wucno cyneli, paccmaTpHEaroUyHx 3Ha- unTenbHoe uitcno Aen. Tak, 8 TeHeHMe HecKonb- kx mer Takaa CHCTeMa ycneulHo McnonbsyeTcA 8 menrentHocra Mockosckoro o6nactHoro cyAa. B cyge aelicrayor cneunanbHo paspa6oraHHbie monynu pacnpenenenna fen, BxonAuyme BIC TAC «Mlpasocyanen, o6uyAlt KOHTPONe 3a paBOTOH KO- Topbix BosNOMeH Ha NpeAceaaTenel cyaebHEIK konnernii, ManorHbie npoeKTsl ucnonbsoBaHHA AMC aelicrayior 8 prae palionHiix cyqos Kpacho. ‘AapcKoro Kpaa, ManeuKoi, TamBoscKom oBnacreli W Apyrx pernonos. B npaktaeckoli peannsauwn astomaTaan- PosalHoi cvcTembi pacnpeneneHia gen sHa4n- Tenbhylo cnomHocTe peactasnaer oBecneveHne pasHomepHolt HarpyaKn cpean cyaelt oAHOrO M Toro e cya. 3T0 CBAZaHO C Tem, NTO CNOMHOCTD KoHKpeTHOTO Jena, 8 YacTHOCTH yronoBHOTO, ero «cpygozatparHocre» onpesienseTcr NCH MHOrA- mn akTopami: SMCHOM OBBHHAeMBIX K Hx OTHOWE- HiteM K npembABNeHHOMy OBBMHEHHIO, TAKECTEIO O6sHHeHWA, KOnHYeCTBOM ToMoB ena, BHAOM wa6pannbix mep npece¥eHia, 4AcnoM nomena lux BEI30BY 8 Cy NoTepnesuinx W cangeTeneh, Hx mectoHaxomaeHitem, bopmoik cyae6Horo pas6n- parenecraa (o6uiHi nnn ocoBui% NopAAOK, cyAbeyt eAMHONMAHO WnH KonNeTHeH U3 TpeX Cyne, c ar THM npvemKHbIX sacenaTenei), npeacKasyembim npekpaulemem yronosHoro wena acneactene akta 06 amicTHi, HcTeNeHiMA cDOKOB AaBHOCTH, NpA- MMPeHHA CTOPOH WAM MHBIX NPHYMH, NOBBIWEHHbIM OBulecrBenHeim HHTepecoM K eny H pxAOM ApyrHX o6crorTenscrs, KoTopbie TPYAHO NpocuHTaTs, O4e- HitTe M 3aOMHTe 8 COOTBeTCTayIOUIYIO NporpaMMy. Bencreme ap6uTpamnoix cynos nelicrayior cneun anbiie peKomenqauimn no npHMeHeninio KpHTe- ies cnomHOCTH Cnopos, paccmarpHBaeMbIX 6 ap- Smrpaxierx cynax, yreeprigeHHble Npeananymon BAC 1 npeaycmarpneaiowne Henpoctyio cHcremy mHoxectea Kop >\MeHTOS NpasoBOH m GaKTHYe- colt cnomHocta copos. 3ra cAcTema nosBonaeT paccunroisare cnomwocre Alen, HaxOAALYMXCA 8 npo- waBo”cree Toro Hn HHOTO cys, M ero HarpyaKy"® B cynax oBuer opncaMKuAN, nO HaWAM flaH- Hoim, nlogoBHoro HOpMaTHsHOrO AOKyMeHTA NoKa He npninro. B Mockoackom oBnacrHom cyae 4 Tex paiionHuix cyaax, ‘ae npHMeHReTCA aBToMa- twueckoe pacnpesenenne fen, Harpy3Ka Ha cy- eli W cnomHocTs ena onpegensiorcn MCXOAA M3 napamerpos, 3a4aHHbix paspaboruakamu CooT- BeTcTayiownx Moaynel. KoHTepKH, ZanoweHHbIe paapa6oranKamm np onpemeneHnn HarpysKn Ha cyaeli m cnokHocTH yronosHbix Jen, 8 oTReENb- HbIX CAYMAAX BbIabIBIOT KPUTHKY NpaKTHNECKHX paGotHnkoa. Moayni, ucnonbayembie & paiion- Hunk cyaax, NpeAYCMaTpMBaIOT HeMaNO «ACKIIO Gurenbitix cnywaes», Korga oTgenbhble ena He nognenar pacnpepeneHinio c NoMoUbIo AUC, a pacnpegenatorca npeacemarenem cya no cace- my yemorpeniio”” Mexkay Tem sonpocei o KpHTepHAK cOMHOCTH YyronoaHbix (u He TonsKo yronoBHbix) Aen, nogne- aun pacnpeneneunto Mexay cyabANn, onpene- rnenne Harpy3ki Ha cysleH npAMO B”ARIOT Ha noKa- 3aTenn 4 oUeHKY pabOTo! KOHKpETHOrO CyAbY, ero -marepiansHoe nooulpenie 4 npodeccnonanbisil Oct, noBTOMY MOryT BbIabIBaTb PasHOrnachA W He- AONOHMMaHNe B KonneKTHBe cyaen” Tostomy Ham npeactasnneTcr, To 3TH 0: npocel, Kak H canta npoueAypa pacnpemenennn, AomHbi crate npeaMeTOM oBcymAEHKA NpeA- crasurenel cynelicxoro cooGutecrea (kak TyT He comune pexomenqaynn KnescKol KondepeH- Un o 3apanee onpenenenitix npasHnax pacnpe- AeNeHNA EN «C NOHATHBIMM H OBBEKTABHEINM KpHTepMAMM, YCTAHOBNeHHbIMM Ha 3aCeqaHHH ¢ yaacTnem camnx cyein). Boipa6oTanHble KpHTe- piu morn 6b GbIrs no MpAMepy apBUTparKHex cyfos 2aKpenneHbi & NoKaNbHOM HOpMaTHBHOM axTe, oGazaTenbHoM A/A Bcex cyfos O6wer fopMcaMKuwH. 310 MOrnH Goi ObITb, K nPUMepY, nocranoenenue Cosera Cygeii PO Hin npHKas Teepansuoro anpexropa Cyae6Horo genapra- ‘eta npw BepxosHom Cyge P®, aocrynibie Ana ‘oaHaKOMTeHHA OBulecTeeHHOCTIA. BaXKHO, 4TO6DI 8 HeM Bbino orpaneHo MHeHHe cypelicKoro co- obwectaa, a He BKyCoBbIe npeANONTeHMR cocTa- antenel KomnbiorepHo nporpamml. B 2TOM axTe -MowHO 6sin0 Gol OnpeAeAKTE M AcKNIONHTENbHBIE cnyyan, Korna bopmuposanne cyna sna paccmo- TpeHia KOHKpeTHOrO ena MOMeT ocyWNecTanATECA Visopmaynonnoe nichmo Npesnqnyma BAC Pd or 1 nlona 2014 r. Ne 167 «PekomeHqaunn no npHMeHEHHIO kpnrepites ciomHoctn cnopos, paccmarpHBaembix 8 apGuTpamnbrx cyfiax Poccuiickoh denepayian» // CIC «koucynsranfinioc», ® URL: lipraisud.Ipk-sudrf.ru/modules.php?name=press_dep8op=38&did=1 (qara o6pawjenmn: 10.02.2018) * Co,, Hanphmep, KommeHTapwi no sTomy nosoay npegcenarenn oAHoro us cyqos r. Kpachonapa: Byxap08 A. B. OBecnevenne oBveKTHsHoro 4 HeBaBHCHMOrO pacnpeneNeHAR fen MEKAY CYALAMA KAK 9OGeKTHBHAR Mepa npodunaKTuki Koppyniynn # pavonnor cyge // AaMMHMcTpaTOD cyqa. 2016. Ne 2. (150) mais 2019 123124 HAYKM KPHMHHAMBHOTO WMKNA JUS CRIMINALE 6e3 ucnonbsoBaHha AMC, To npegoreparhno 6bI ToRBneHMe HaNOG, KaCaIOLAXCA 38KOHHOTO COCTa- fa cyna, chopmuposanHoro AA paccmoTpeHAa konKpetHoro mena OpHospemeso c yronoskim aenom win fBckope nocne ero nocrynneHiaa oT npoKypopa 8 CYA TYAa Me MoryT HanpaBnaTocA xoRaTalicrea, xanoBbi M ApyrHe OBpaweHna, sarparneaiouyne pasHbie sonpocss, caAsaHHble c oBcToRTenbcTaa- mu npeacronulero cyaeGHoro npouecca HM NoA- mexaume paspeuieHiio Ha cTaaMM noAroTOBKM k cyge6Homy 3aceqannio. Ux moryt HanpasnTt kak cam npoKypop, Tak M Apyrne yuacTHHKH yro- sosHoro cygonponssogcTaa. OHM Moryr KacaTéCA wa6paHHA Wan nPoATeHMA Cpoka AelicTBMA OT- AenbHbix Mep npeceeHia H OBecne¥nTenbHEIX ep, nposeqetna npegsapmTensHoro cnywarinn, opm (o4HOe Man 3a04Hoe, OTKpbITOe WAM 3a- kpbiToe) 1 nopaaka (ocoGeiit wan O6u4Hii nopR- ox) cyae6Horo pas6upatenscrsa, cocTasa cya (cyapeli eqnnonnuno, Konnernet 3 Tpex cyaeh, C yWacTHem npHcamHbix sacemateneli), yWaCTHA 8 npouecce 3aKoHHbIx npeactasTeneii, KoHKpeT- HbIxX 3au\HTHHKOS, NPMOGWYeNMA K AenY OTAENE HbIx ROKYMeHTOS H MHOTMx Apyrinx Bonpocos. Mc- NonbaosaHve UnopoBbIx TexHOnorHli NossonAeT ceiiwac HanpasnaTe Takoro pola O6paUleHAA 8 CYA 8 Gopme aneKTPOHHbIx AOKYMeHTOB, 4TO 3HaHM- TenbHo ynpowaer wx aocrasky aapecary n enaet ee momeHtanbHol. K cnoay ckasarb, 6 TaKoi me dopme o6pauie- ia 8 cya MoryT nocTynaTe M Ha APYrAK craaMAK yronosHoro npouecca. BepxosHbili Cya Po pase- CHA, NTO yacTHAki Yronoskoro cyaonpowseoa- crea enpase HanpasnTe 8 cyA 8 3neKTPOHHOM Binge xonaTalicrea, 3anBneHMA, KaNOBb, NpeA cranenina 9 xone nocyge6Horo w cyge6Horo npo- waBoncTaa no yronoBHOMy Aeny, 8 TOM “ACNE 1 Bonpocam, cansaHHbiM c HcnonHeHHeM cyae6HO- ro axra!®, Coorsercrayiownm sanenennem, agpecosan- Hb MAOBOMY CyAbe, MOXKET Beit HHNUWKPO- BaHo so36yxKaeHHe yronosHoro jena wacTHOrO o6snHeHnA. Tlo coo6wennio Npeacenarens Mpasurens- crea PO fl. A. Meagenesa, 6 2018 r. cyqpi ob meri FOPHCAHKUMH NpMHANH B TakOK bopme Bonee 500 Tole. sansneHnii, apSurpaxxbie — Gonee 250 reic.2° Kak ycraHosneno tenepb W. 1 cr. 474.1 ¥NK PO, xonaraiicteo, 3anenenve, mano6a, npeacTasne- Hue MoryT 6biTe NoAaHb! B Cy 8 NOpAAKe 4 cpo- ku, KoTopble ycraHoeneHb! 3aKoHOM, 8 opme 3/eKTpOHHOrO AOKyMeHTa, NoANMCAHHOFO AMYOM, Hanpasusium Tako AOKyMeHT, 3neKTPOHHOH NoanMcbio 8 CooTseTCTBNH ¢ 3aKOHOAATeNLCTEOM Poccnlickoi Senepaunn, nocpeqcteom sanon- HeHHA opm, pasMeWeHHor Ha Of MUMANLHOM caiire cya 8 uHdopmaunoHHO-TeneKOMMyHIKa- UMOHHOH ceTH «MHTepHeT». MaTepuanbi, np somennble K xonaralicrey, aanenennio, xanobe, peactasneniio, rakxKe noqaloTca B opme a/eK- TPOHHbIX AOKYMeHTOB, JneKTPOHHble JOKYMeHTEI, W3rOTOBNeHHbIe MHBIMA AMUAMM, OpraHaMn, Op- raHusaynamn 8 caoSOAHOM dopme unn dopme, YcTaHOBAeHHON ANA 3THx AOKYMeHTOR 3aKOHO- AaTenecraom PocciicKoli Senepauwn, AOmKHE! GoiTe NoAMMcaHbI HMM SneKTPOHHO NognMcEIO a cooTsercTamn ¢ TpeGonaHMAMM 3aKOHOMaTeNbCTBA Poccwiickor Seaepaunn. Bepxosnbim Cyqom P@ 4 Cyqe6Hbim aenap- TameHTom np BepxosHom Cyae Po ycraxoane NOpRAOK, 6 COOTBeTCTBHH c KOTOPHIM AOKyMeH Tol B 2NeKTPOHHOM BHA NoAaIOTcA Hepes NMM- Holi Ka6HHeT nonbsoBaTenn, cosqaHHbii 8 pa3- ene «Mlopava npoueccyanbHbix oKyMeHTOR B 9NeKTPOHHOM SHAE» Ha OHYMANbHOM CaitTe cyaa, pacnonoweHHom Ha ukTepHeT-noprane [AC «Mlpasocyane 8 cern «MHTepHer». B npHHATEIX Milt oKANbHbIX HOPMaTHBHBIX aKTax ycTaHOBNe- Hol Tpe6osannA, npenbABnAembie K opme nepe- AaBaeMBIX B CYA AOKYMEHTOR, H nlopAROK pa6oTe! 8 AWMHOM Ka6HHETe NonbaoBaTens. OcoBoe BHM manne oGpauiaeTca Ha WjeHTHdHKayIAIO M ayTeH- THOMxayMIo MonbsoBaTenA (c Hcnonb3oBaHHEM NopTeepHAHHO! yueTHOH sane duaHYECKorO anya ECA mn c HcnombaoBaHnem UMeoUelica Y Monbsosarena ycuneHHolt Keanndvunposat- Holi 3nexrpoHHoli nognucn), 6e3 Yero AocTyN B MHI KABNHeT HeBoaMoKeH. OBpaujenne 8 C¥A 8 Bye aeKTPOHHOTO OKyMeHTa AONKHO GbiTD NogNncavo ycuneHHOA KeannuunposaHHol aneKTPOHHO! NoANHCEIO, a ecnh 3TO 3neKTPOHHEIH (06pas oxymenTa — sasepexo TaKok noanuceio. B cyge npocmorp AOKyMeHToB, nlog2HHbix @ 3neK- TPOHHOM Bue, OCyUIeCTBNAETCA OTBeTCTBEHHEIM pa6orHnKom annapara cyfa, KoTopbil npoBepaeT Wx coorsercTave ycraHoBneHHbim TpebosaHHAm 5 Toctanoanenne Mnenyma Bepxoskoro Cyaa Pé> Ne 57 or 26 aeKa6pr 2017 r. «O HexoTopbix sonpocax npH- MeHeHHMA saKoHOgaTenscTea, perynHpyiowlero MCnONLIOBAHNe {OXYMeHTOR 8 a7eKTPOHHOM BUA B EATEN HocTH cynoB oBujed topucqukunn H apBuTPAMHbIK cyAoBY. ABB. 2. 3 // CIIC «KOHCynbTaHTTLnIOc». * Pocciiicnan razera. 13 espana 2019. Ne 31 (7789). N*5 (150) wali 2019Wepewersee it ‘Hcnonsosanve yu pose menvonceui nu pacompenusyeonosns dens ce pearsnods unepciexmues yeemomnner nonbsoBaTena 0 nony¥eHH A0- KyMeHTOB NGO 0 TOM, HTO AOKYMeHTEI He MOTyT Spire npwaHaH! nocTynMawMM 8 cyA, KonKA nO- cryniaulero o6pauyennn, a nph HeoBxogMMOCTA M NpWNOKEHHEIX K HeMY AOKYMeHTOB, 8 YeNAK NpH- o6ujeHHA K MaTepHanam cyae6HOTO pena (npoHs- oncTea) 8 cyne pacnevarbisaioTcn. lpnem, yer M Perncrpaynn noctynMBuIMx 8 aneKTpOHHOM BHAe AOKYMeHTOB OCYWIECTENAETCA B YE/OM B TOM HE NOpRAKE, TO H AOKYMeHTOR Ha GyMamHOM HO- curene?! B cnyyae ecan no pesynsraram noqroToBKn K cyge6Homy saceaannio cyabeli npHHATo peweHne © eFo HasHaveHHn, To OH peulaeT BoNpOC 0 BbI30- Be B cyge6Hoe 3aceqanne miu no cnAcKaM, NpeA- crasnennbim cropoHami, H AaeT cooTBeTCTByIO- lee pacnopmxerne corpyalinkam annapara cyaia (n. 44, 2 cr. 231, cr. 232 YTIK PO). Mlopraok euiz08a 8 cya norepneauimx, cengere- sei m apyrinx yxacrauKos yronosHoro cyqonpons- BOACTBA NpAMO 8 3aKOHe He yKasaH. [lo aHanorMn co cr. 188 YNK P®, pernamenTupyiouleli nopAdoK ‘i308a Ha ONpOC 8 Xone NPeABapMTeNbHOTO pac- cepoBanna, yxasannibie Mya BbIsbIBII0TCA 6 CYA noecrkam, Hanpaennembin no noure. OAHaKO Tako NOpAAOK No MHOTHM HaBECTHOIM NDHYAHAM, BNRCTCA HECOBEPLIEHHLIM, HTO 3aTpYAHAET pac- cmoTpenve yronoBHesx fen NoctaHosnennem Mnenyma BepxosHoro Cyma Po or 9 espana 2012 r. No 3 «O BHeceHHn wameHeHni 8 HeKoTopeie nocTaHoBneHia llneHy- ma Bepxoshoro Cyna PoccniicKoii benepauvnnn?? CYAaM salts! paswACHEHAA 0 BOIMOMHOCTA H3Be- eHina Bbiabis2emsix s cya nny nocpeacraom CMC- CooGuleHMA B cnyuae Mx Cornacna Ha yaenOMmeHMA ‘Takum crocoBom M np dxKcaunn daxTa oTnpaBKn wm mocrankn CMC-naseujenna anpecary. Mp arom dakr cormacna Ha nonyweHne CMC-vaeujeHna NogTaepyqaeTcA pacnickoi, 8 KOTOPO!H, HapRAY ¢ AanHbImn 06 yuacTHnKe cynonpomssoacrea H ero Cornacnem Ha yenomnenne nopoBHbim cnoco- 60m, ykaabisaeTca HoMep MOBMnbHOrO Tenedona, Ha KoTopbilt OHO Hanpaannercn, Wnponoe pacnpoctpalenne sneKTpoHHoli no- ‘TBI npeAOCTaBNAeT KOPOWYIO BOSMOMHOCTS MrHO- BeHHoro AosemeHHA AO BbISbIBaeMOrO AYA BCE Heo6xoAMMoli MHbopmayiin, caAsaHHO! c ero BpI3080M 8 cyq. M npeqocTaBnaer BbiabIsaeMoMy BOSMOXKHOCT COOBLINTE CyAY © KaKHX-TO COM HOCTAX, CeAZaHHBIX C ABKOM, HanpaBMT> KONMIO conpaggatenbHoro» AoKyMeHTa, coracoeaT YTOSHUT MHOe Bpema ABKM. K npumepy, 6 u. 1 ct. 96 KAC P®, npunatoro 8 mapra 2015 r., npeaycmorpeHa BosMomKHOCTS HanpasneHna W3BeueHHA MAM BbI30Ba B CYA yuacTHinkos cyae6Horo npouecca ¢ Hx cornacHA kaK ¢nomouybio CMC-cooBuenni, TaK W nyTeM Ha- pasneHina w3BeuleHKA Mik BbI308A N10 3/1eKIPOH- Holi noure. MonyeHue cornacia Ha Taxoii cnoco6 aBeulena odopmnnerca Tem Ke cnoco6om, Ko- Topbilt oncaH abilve. Tlepabiit war 8 ucnonbaogaHnn caaan cyga ¢ yuacTHHKom npouecca No 3neKTpOHHoH NoUTe Gwin caenat m yronoaHom cyfonpowasoacTee ¢ TpunsTem @epepanbHoro 3aKoHa oT 30 mapra 2015 r. Ne 62-03, npenocraavawero norepneawe- My npago Ha nonyueHHe HHdopMAUH o NopAA- ke oT6bieaHiva OcyKAeHHbIM HakazaHHIA 8 BAe MWeHHA CBOBOAb! M Ha yYacTHe B CyAeBHOM 3a: cegainu npx paccmorpeHuK Bonpocos, canzak- Hex ¢ HcnomHeHMem npHrogopa. B cooTBeTCTEHH cu, 5.1 cr. 42, 4.5 cr, 313 YMK PO Ha ocHosaHHn coorserctayiowero xonaraficrea norepnesuiero, cogeprkausero cpean npovero ero anpec mecta dknTenecTBa, agpec 2nekTPOHHOM NOUTEI M HO- ‘Mepa TenedoxoR, cya onHOBpeMeHHO C OBBHHH- TenbHbIM NPHTOBOPOM sbIHOCHT NocTaHOBNeHHe (onpegenenne) o ero ysenomneHnn no AaHHbim Bonpocam, & KOTOpOM yaabiBaeT NpemocTaaneH- Hole noTepnesuiMm anpec mecra xuTenscrBa, aApec aneKTPOHHOA NouTeI H HOMepa TenedoHoB. Konwa nocranoanenna (onpenenenia) cya ame- cre c Konneli o6eHHHTenbHoro npHroBopa Hanpas- DAeTCA 8 yupeRkseHHe HAM OpraH, Ha KOTOPBIe BO3- 7omeHo vchonHeHMe npHroBopa. Conepmauynecr 8 nocraHosnennu (onpegenennn) cyza ceeneHnA alot BosMOMHOCTS aAMMHMCTPAYIM HcNpaBH- TenbHoro yupenqeHnA no Mecty OTGbiBaHMAA Ha- kagaHna ocyKAeHHbIM 4 CyaY NpK paccmoTpeHWH cooTseTcTayioW\nx BonpOCoB HanpaBnaTe noTep- % Tlopagok nojaun 8 Bepxosnsili Cyq Poccitiickoit enepaunn AoKyMeHToS 8 aneKTPOHKOM Bue, B TOM 4ixcne ® opme anexTpokHoro AoKymeHTa, YTB. pwkasom Npeacegarena BepxosHoro Cyaa Pé ot 29 HoRGpA 2016 r No 46-N1 ; Nopanok nonayn 8 denepanbivie cyAb! OBu\el IOPHCAMKLIMH AOKYMeHTOR B a/eKTPOHHOM BHse, B TOM uncne B opMe anexTpOHHoro AOKyMeHTa, YTB. npHkazoM CyqeGHoro AenapTamenra np BepxosHOM Cyne Po or 27 qexaGpa 2016 r. Ne 251 ; NopafoK noga4M mHpOBEIM CYABAM AOKYMENTOB & 37eKTDOHKOM supe, 8 Tom Wicne 8 opMe anekTPOHHOTO AOKYMeKTa, YTB. npHKaz0M CyneGHOrO Aenapramenra npH Bep- xoBHom Cyne PO oF 11 ceHTAGpA 2017 r. Ne 168 // CIC «Koncynbraxtf nace. 2 CIC «Koucynsrantfinioc». (150) mais 2019 125126 HAYKM KPHMHHAMBHOTO WMKNA JUS CRIMINALE Nesulemy HeoGxoquMyto MHopmalitio name cny- CTA npofomKUTeNLHOe BpeMA Nocme OKOHYAKMA cyae6Horo npoyecca”? Bbino 6b oueHb HenorHuHbiM He HcnonbaoBaTS BOsMOXHOCTH, NpeHocTasnaembie 3/leKTPOHHOH NowToH, A/a abiaoea B cya yuacTHHkos cyae6Horo Pas6uparenocrea. /|nA peannaayan 3THx BO3MON- Hocteli Hanpaunealotcn HeKoTopble AononHeHHA eB YNK PO. Tak, crarsto 190 «MporoKon gonpoca» YNK PO cnepyer AononiTe ykasaHiem Ha To, To NOMA mo OBUyAX aHKETHBIK AAHHEIx AONPAWMBAeMorO sMua W appeca Mecta ero mMTenbCTea CneAoBa- Temb JonMeH ykazaTe HOMepa ero KOHTAKTHBIX Tenedoxos m agpec aneKTPOHHO! NowTbI, a TaKOKE BBIACHMTS, COrNaceH 1M OH Ha MSBeULeHHe 0 ero BbI308e Ha HoNpoc # nocnenyloulee spems nyteM CMC-coo6eHinA 1160 no anexTpoHHoi nouTe, ak cornacna ROMKeH GuiTb yAocToBepeH nop- nucbio aonpauineaemoro. Tlonoenna 4. 4 cr, 220 «O6sKHMTenbHOe 3a- knioveHnen, 94, 1 cr. 225 «OSEMHMTeNbHEI akt» YITK Po oTHocHTenbHo cocrasanembix cne- Aosatenem (gosHasarenem) cnHcKOB AML, NOs, Fleaulyx BbIs0BY B CyeGHOE saceqaHHe, HeO6- XOAMMO AoNONHHIT» TpeGOBaHHeM Oo TOM, UTO6bI 8 Hem, loMMMo mecTa mirTenbcTea H (HM) MecTa HaxOMAeHKA ITHX iu, Goin NpHBeAeHDI cReAe- inn o HoMepax Hx Tenegonos H 06 aapecax Wx anekTpoHHOH nourel. B ornmune or Hopm ITIK Pe, ANK P® w KAC PO, yronosHo-npoueccyanbHbii 3aKoH He TpebyeT o6azarenbHoro paameujeHia Ha obMunanbHOM, caifre cooraerctayrouero cyaa 8 ceTH «MHTep- Her» niopmauini, caAsaHHOli c paccmoTpeHneM yronosHoro ena. Ho, Kak paswacHiin BepxoBHiii Cya P®, paameujenne Tako wn>opmayyn ABnA- ea AononHMTeNbHbIM cnocoboM KxopMupoEa- Hida YMaCTHHKOB yronoBHoro cyBonpoMaBogcTea O Bpemenn mecte cyqe6Horo 3acenannr™. Npen- cTasnaeca, 4To He cyulecTayeT HUKaKHx OGEK- TWBHEIK NpenaTCTaKit K Tomy, ToBI Ha OAYMANE- Hoix caifrax cyqos pasmeujanace M4dopmauMA, Cansannan c paccmoTpeHwem yronoaHbix Aen, Cpegy pacnpocrpaHeHHbix Lndpoabix TeXHO- ori, yKe NOHO BOWeAUIMX B NpAKTHKY Pac- ‘cmoTpeHa yronosHbix men, cnenyeT ykazaTe Ha Ncnons3oBaHne cACTeM sneoKoNtepeHycanan Cornacko Permamenty, yraepMeKHomy npH- kasom CymeGHoro aenaptamexta mpm BepxoBHOM Cyne PO”, suneoKoHepenucansb — ato cnoco6 ocywectenenna npoueccyanbHeix geticrenh, NpeaycmoTpeHHbix 32KOHOM, c Mcnons30BaHneM nporpammHo-TexHMecknx cpecTa nepenaun ay- AMO H BHACOHHopMAUMHK NO KaHANAM CBABH C OAKMM WAM HeCKOnBKAMM abOHeHTaM Bnepabie npameHeHHsil 6 1999 r. YenaGnHcKnm oGnacrHbin cyaom npw paccmoTpeHin KaccauMoH- Holi KanoGbi OcyMMAeHHOTO, conepyKaWierocA Now cTpaxelt 6 cneacreentiom nsonaTope”, stor cno- 06 ocyulectaneHina npoueccyansieix nevicreni Goin 3akpenned 8 HoBOM YIIK PO (HuIKe yrpaTHs- war cay 4. 3 cr. 376 YNK PO) ana nopoGHEIK Ke cnywaes M nocreneHHo pacunpun chepy ceoero Aelicrena Ha gonpoc norepnesuinx, camneteneh m oacyaumerx 8 xoge cygeGHoro pas6uparenbcrea 8 cyne nepeoli nucraHUpn (4. 4 ct, 240, 4, 6.1 cr. 241, cr. 281.1 MK PO), wx y4acraa 8 paccmoTpenian Aen cyamn anennauonHor m KaccayMoHHok MHCTaH- Unit (4. 2 cr. 389.12, 4. 2 cr. 401.13 YNK PO), a TaK- ke pyre caywan (4. 6 cr. 35 YNK PO). Vcnoneaonanne eyjeoKondepenuicensn npn paccmorpeni oBnacrHbiMi H pasHbiMi AM cysa- mv, a TakKe cyqeGHLImM KonterMAMM BepxosHoro Cyna Po anennauwonHeix m KaccayoHHEix Kan06 B cnyanK, KorAa OCyKAeHHbIM ConePAKMTCA NOR ctpaxelt nnn or6bi6aer HakazaHne 8 supe nMWwe- Hina cBoGom, AaBHO CTano OBbINHOM npaKTHKOli Cornacho HassaHHomy PernameHTy npeqcenate- ‘naa OB NACTHDIX M PABHBIX HM C¥AOB MOET 6biTo ycranoBneno pacnucanne mcnons30BaHAns cooT- BeTCTaYIOUAX KOMNNEKCOB BHAEOKOHEPEHUCER- 3, YCTAHOBNEHHBK B yUpemgeHnAx OCH AaHHorO cyGvexra benepaunn. Onpenenentian HacTb ape- ‘eH 6 3TOM pacnncaHinn MoxKer GbsTe npenocTas- neva m paiiontsim cygam. PernamerTom npenycmo- ‘Tpevo nposeneHne MeperMoHanbHeix (c yuacTHem Snwnxariwnx paiionnbrx cyaos) 4 MHOrOTONeHHIX 2 @enepansiil aaKon oT 30 mapra 2015 r, Ne 62-03 «O avecenma vameNeHHi 8 YronoaNo-npoyeccyanbitili ogee Poccniickol Segepaunn m Yronoano-McnonniTensHiblli KogeKC PoccHiicKol emepaynn no Bonpocy acta noTepneswnx now paccMoTpeHA com BoNpOCOB, CaRsaHHbix c MCnonHeHeM NpHTosopan // CIC «koncynbranlnioc» * Tlocranoanenve Mnenyma Bepxosuoro Cyqja Po ot 26 jexabpa 2017 r. Ne 57. A63. 4 n. 14 % Tipwkas Cyge6xoro aenapramenra npw Bepxosnom Cyge P® or 28.12.2015 Ne 401 «06 yrsepxaennn Perna: menra oprakvsalyMn MPHMEHEHKA SHAEOKOHDEpeHUCEASH 8 denepanbHoK cyfax OBuIeH pHCAMKUKK» // CNC «KoHcynsrantaic». URL: otpacnu-npasa.pd/article/25834 (nara o6paujenna: 14.03.2019), N*5 (150) wali 2019Wepewersee it ‘Hcnonsosanve yu pose menvonceui nu pacompenusyeonosns dens ce pearsnods unepciexmues (c yuacrmem HeckonbKux yupexqeHiii CMH 1 cyaos) cyne6Hux saceqannii c ucnonbsosaHem AaHHO; TexHonorMn. B yenax 3>h_KTABHOH pea- ‘sMsaLIMM HMeIOUIAXCA BOaMOMHOCTeH 8 aTOM chepe vopmaunn o HanKunn 8 cyne 3ana, CGopynoBaH- Horo KOMTTeKCOM BHAeCKOHOepeHUCAAsH, AOMKHA Spire paameujena Ha odnuanbHoM caitre cyAa. Ha ceroqHAwnnit qeHb aktyanbHoH saqauer ABAWIETCA TeXHMMeckoe OBecneveHHe cucTemol| BHAeOKOHepeHuicaAsH CyoB ParoHHorO 3BeHa, Cogepmanne npotoKona cyae6Horo saceaa: kasaHni, sanBneHnit, sospamenni, xonaraiicrs, oTmenbHbix penank npeacenatenscrayiouero M APYrax Mu — npepMeT HaCTeIx HM ynOpHEIx cno- pos yuactankos cyqe6Horo pas6uparentcrea ¢ JMUAMN, HaroTOBHELMMH HM ogNHcARWIMMM npo- ‘ToKoN. Ero sHaveHHe npM npoBepke 3aKOHHOCTH, oGocHoBaHHocTH W cnpasepnMBocTH BbIHeCeHHO- Fo cyom npurosopa Wan Horo peweHnA HeBO3- MoXKHO NepeoyeHHMTs. 3aKoHOM npeaycmoTpeHa BO3MOMHOCTE Noga CTopoHaMH 3ameuaHHls Ha AporoKon. Ho OrpaHWeHHble BOsMOMHOCTH AAA CTopolib! AoKa3aTb comepmaL4necA B NPOTOKONe HenonHory i HeTosHocra, a Take cyiecTayroujan Npouenypa paccmotpeHHa sTHx samewaHnli npea- cegaTenbcTayiou\ne (yke NocTaHoBHBLMM NpA- roBop Ha ocHoBaHMn sToro NpoTOKoNa), He MOKeT RonHoctblo YcTpanite ace COMHEHMA, BOSHHKAK- lywe no nosoay npasinbHocra cocrasieHuA 3TOro AoKyMeHTa W O6bexTHaHOCTH NpeACenaTenbcTBy- fowjero np paspeuieHnn nonaHHbix aame4aHii Paarosops! 06 ucnonssoBaHin seyxo3anHcel- Baloulx ycTpolicTa ANA >uKcHpoBaHUA BenMcb AasHo, 8 Aevicreyiowe peaaKunn v.1 Hu. 5 cr. 259 YNK P ykazaHo, uTo ana oBecneveHMA NosHoTeI npoToKona npH ero BeAeHHA MoryT BbITS vicnonssoBaHil Texknuecne cpeactea, AonycKaer- ca npnmenenne ayavo- H (Man) eqeosanvcn. On- Hao Ha npakTuke np paccmoTpeHHn yronosHbix Ren Takne cpegcraa Mcronsayiorca Kpaline peaKo. Hosbie 803MOKHOCTH B 3TOM Nate OTKpBIBa- 1OTCA C HcNOAbIOBaHHEM COBPEMEHHEIX UAPOBbIX Textonornii 38yKozanicn. Kak M8 pAAe APYTMX BO- Npocos ucnonbsosaHMA uAdpoBbIX TexHOnOTHA, NepabiMH 8 NPUMeHEHMH ayquonpoToKonnposa- Hina crann ap6uTpamibie cyabi. B cooTseTcTaHH Cyme ynomahyrbim DeAepanbHLim 3aKoHOM OT 27 wons 2010 r. No 228-03 w aTHx cyfax, noMMMO coctasnenna npotoKona & nAcoMeHHO opme, Gbino eseneno O6AzaTenbHoe npoToKonApoBaHine cMcnonb3oBaHiem cpeacts ayanozanvcn, a TaK- ke NpeAycMoTpeHa BOSMOMHOCTe M sHAeOsATHICH (cr. 155 ANK PO). Hosaa peakuna cr. 259 YNK Po (npeaycmo- TpeHHaA TakiKe YNOMMHABLLMMCA Boilie Dene- ambHbim 3aKOHOM oF 29 wionA 2018 r. No 228-3), Bacrynarowyan 8 cary ¢ 1 ceHTaBpa 2019 r. anano- TM4HO NpeayematpHsaer KaK cocrasneHHe NpoTO- Kona 8 nitcbMeHHOl dopme, Tak u oBAZaTeNbHOe ayamonpoToKonnposanne cyneGHoro 3acemann. Vcnonbsosanne cpegcrs ayamosanich He aony- ckaeTCA ToMbKO NPM paccmoTpeHMA Ken B 3aKp: Toik cyMeGHEIX 3acemaHAAX, NPeAyCMOTPEHHEIX cr. 241 YMK PO. Sra gonromnaHHaR M coBepuleHHO HeoBxoqMMan Mepa, C OAHOH cTopoHH, criocobHa oGecneunte nonkyto ukcaunto xona cymeGHoro paa6uparenscrea, a c apyroh — 9 sHauMrenbHoi mepe cHHMaeT cropbi 0 To¥HOCTA 3anHceli B NHCb- -MetHoM sapmarTe npoToKona. A 8 YenoM cnoco6: ayer Gonee sbicoKomy KavecTay paccmoTpeHia yronosHirx nen. CxonHwie TheGoBaHHA 06 OGa3aTenbHOM ay- AvonpoToKonHposaHinn cyaeGHoro 3acenaHina Tenepb sHecenbi 8 INK P® u KAC PO, Cheayer ormernt®, 470 cama no ce6e ayaHo- Bann cyae6Horo 3acenaHHA, YHHTEIBAA CKOEKO enosex y¥acreyer rosopi 8 cyne6HoM npoUec- ce (savactyio onHospemenHo), He Bceraa MoKeT AaTe Nonloe H WeTKoe NpeACTaBeHne O ero xone. Tlostomy 8 HeKoropbix cyax r. Mockabi npoxoat TecTposaline cneunanbian cHcTeMa pacnosHasa: Hina pewn yuacTayiouynx 8 gene nM, NpHaBaHHAR cnenare Gonee AcHoii Kaptiy «cygoroBsopeHnan. B cnysae ycnewHoro sasepuieHiMA TecTHpoBaHnA cuicrema yer PeKomenAosarbcr k BHEADEHHIO. Mnanmpyerca Ha ee ocHose cosqats nporpammy aBTOMaTHSMpOBAHHO nogroTOsKK NpOTOKONOB cyneGubix saceaannii??. Tlo wroram peannzaunn denepanbHok uene- Bom nporpammbt «PasaHTne cyqebHOH CACTeMB! Pocen Ha 2013-2020 roasi»#® npeanonaraet- Eroposa O. A., npencepitens MockoBcxoro roponckoro cya: «13 coBpewaTensHori KOMMaTS! MHE HAKTO He 380HuT» // Kommepcadt. 18.06.2018 ; Eroposa 0. A., npencenaten’ MocxoBcKoro roponckoro cys. MHTep- ‘bio 26.12.2018 arenrcray «tutepipaxc» // URL: https://www.interfax.ru/interview/643992 (nara o6pauye un: 16.03.2018) ; Mexayrapoawar KoHdepenumn «Cyq XXI Beka : TexHonoran Ka cny»k6e npaBocyaMA®, 29-30 man 2018 r, HroroBuili cOopHink. Mockea. C. 27, ‘Senepansian yenesan nporpamme «PaseuTHe cyeGHOH cHCTeMb! PoccHM Ha 2013-2020 ropbi», YTB. No- craHosnenmem Npasurensctea PO or 27 aeKa6pa 2012 r. No 1406 // CNC «KoHcynstanrTlnocy. (150) mais 2019 127