slFS
International
Featured Standards
IFS Foreign Body
Management guideline
Mee ne een
management from the perspective of IFSACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
FS would the to thankallpatcpant nthe working group who assed ceting this quien
{oc foreign body management FS would ao het thank the members of th Internationa Technical
Comanitee who partipated Fa developing and improving ths document Ther contbutone and
pinons were agrest help oS.
Participants nthe IFS Foreign Body Management working group
mens Anwander ‘Austian Chamber of Commerce
Chasing Baggemann ators,
Fyancarney METRO AG
‘Olver TOV rd cert
Jurgen Behmann ulna arena Gmbh & C4
‘rg Kinemann gust trek KS
\Wotgong Leste DEXA Handesceselichaf Siwest mbH
Anko Lorence ‘Austian Chamber of Commerce
oi baden Zens Gb CONG
Florin reut ‘Quart Qalttscherang Gmbh
its Mle Ya 105 cFS Gna
De Jorgen Sommer Freberger Leben GmbH &.Ca
Anoaberth van der Steege METRO AG
‘Alezandia Weber tegut
‘anne Gone IFS Monagement mb
Inmet Rather de Suster IFS Management be
Im addition the IFS wants tothank the fllwing members ofthe
IC for theirsupport
odes Aton ‘CONAD, on beha of ANCD (Associo Nasonale
Cooperative ta Detain aly
Sébasien Bian Groupe Cas, France
Finally IFS would aso like to thank the following people for their professional suppor
Andes rie -MerneRTOLEDO
Stéphanie erate Bureau eras
Dirgen Hofmann Ingenieubie Hofmann
ylene Russo Garefour
‘Gadine Tit Gorefour
Mathew Fours Carefour
Vincent Prodtonme Gnetour
Romain Cuyrat Canfour
Thomas Reinold Procema GmbH
Michael Mayer AZO Soe
Peter aggenrock Str neeCONTENTS
+ troduction
2 ISrequtement reacting Foreign Body Management
2. Risk analysis for Foreign Body Management
‘Question cateogue:Quertone that shold be akan every werkace
and during every processten
4 Entry foreign bodies via awmaterials
5 Optons or detecting freon bodies
51, Visual consol by aff
52, Sevesand magnets 2
53, Met detecionsytems and Kay nspection systems 2
6 Handling foreign body contamination 26
7 Taining ca
Appendix
AY Special area: Glass pacaging “
122 Vesifcaton and validation “6
|A3__Rskeminimising machine design and preventative maintenance
[M__teSaquiements-hanling orsign body contamination and complaints
so1 Introduction
Metal wires in Cookies
‘Consumer reports finger
stall in sausage
Is
thetic material
jin chocolate bars
Dark chocolate shavings - foreign body
in the product, bristles from a cleaning brush
jign: Warning
Product recal tin baby food
of glass fragm
Plastic parts in sausages
Due to metal parts in
food,
recast manufacturer must
{Seall its ready-made pr
sold ata discount Supermarket,Introduction: Foreign Body Management
Foreign bos in ood always lead to negative publity and healnes. They cause nt only
tnvousness end outrage but may also be spotentl kt the consumer and lsd tof
ampli he Incesaing perception of foregn Boees being fund in food not ust &
Curent fad o¢ 9 short ved complain wed that wl lssn in mpertance in the ear ture
IFanything tian neressingly important aspect for consumers and the medi
Consurars parceve anything that det not belong tothe product as orig boy. Experts
ftingueh between mo dant ype of foreign bodes endogencus foreign bodies that
ould orgist om he produc (2g coresorbones or exogenous foreign bates tha donot
belong to the product eg. plate part) The dference i ot revant forthe consume 3
they la nat sczept form bodies even they donot pose a det iskto heat such 35 sal
‘eras cf paper nthe product. The consumer expects t fecal the produc sit as buen
tdesenbed anda t's dated ~no more and roles.
“These suis shoul act ta bss forthe interested user in tems of how to handle ts
‘anstivetopi thin food incu The ebjecve so produce food 3 fey spose
tnd o not desppoint consumers Ths guidlinecontalns leas regarding foreign body
management are ako provides potential solitons,
Isobjectve isnot to set mandatory standard techricalequlpmentor detectors Detectors
focforelgn boss maybe ofinterest to companies andactasa valuable suppor. homevethe
tdecsonregnding tet wse mustbe madelndvdaliyonthebasi#ofshazardand kaso
mont. This gudline intended to hep plement an effective and stable foreign body
‘management forthe cernpany. The IFS viewpoint ociseson the prevention f foreign oss
{nd tant orale avarenestof the possblesouces of eontaminato. neon ke shoud
leaatosenstized employes who ate encourage to report ay contamination istsataneaty
‘age ssedon the nlmationrordeby this qucetne, companies shouldbe bleto beter
‘decide how somthing canbe safely used ad what mantring neces,
‘The guldlne does no: cm tobe Fly comprehensive, buts base on yeas of eperience
from tore involved inet cartiication bodies and inst.P | IFS Food requirements regarding
Foreign Body Management2.
IFS food requirements regarding
Foreign Body Management
hen It comes o food - row mot tan ever belore— lists reales and corsues
trot the highest posible eats of fey and qual, For this purpors, i neceuay to
Profersonally montarand conta he whole supply han incang delivery an production
Drow meters and packaning services manufctrng processes, storage and varsprt).
Far the food manufacture tis means tht inplemenation ofthe IS requirements fr
forelgn booy managenent should not just focus on the requeents epected of the
production process, Eut als tke requiements from other chapters into consideration,
(Seedagrny ps7)
Senior Management Fesponsibilty
Corporate poly an
re
aes ak
| smugness fn
eee am) ahs ae
Lean ie eae
I ete machine seting fren monte? "Mat ong dettason
Is the collection vessel fequemty empie?
| ‘packaging from rior preduction fully removed?
+ Ssttenon pid to product remants/ulkups and ae they uly
removed?
| Maintenance/Repairlnstallation
l + Mom isi ensuted thal os and atv aback nthe poster
sion of saenteral sve provides fer wos complete?
«re parts ising or are too many avalble?
+ Temporary reps roduc fey considered an shot
I
Ce5a.
Visual inspections by staff
Where are visual inspections cara out?
“Theisalnspecion or visual checks an optical test ofa product for defects. These can ether
bein regards tothe produce. ncoming goods reduction a nainspecton or regards
‘What diferent Hinds of sua inspections exist?
In gener vsualinspetons canbe eistingushed between:
+ itc vivalpecton without id fbserving the tt ares withthe ke ye)
Dect sal spection with sop aie such t magni, mete
+ Indvect visual nspaction with eamra systems 08 bot Inspection
Which influences must he taken nt acount?
This chat foeies ony on veal checks aan act cared out by people Due to the
fluctuations mayarse depending on the complet ofthe product and working conditions
However, inspections only conducted via machines may ct aways be pore Fagerding
checks cared ou: by people tsimportanto ensuetha seul and Fequert waning isgven
fan that a sutabie work envionment provided
The company shoul aways wy te esr hat the Work conden fora vil nspeton ae
35 good 35 posite inorder ta reduce the numberof undacovered defects,
Anite test cn be crests to monitor the eicincy of detection and fo estabihing the
{ptimum belt pied ot regular intervals In this cae, cfd and relevant frign bodies
‘optimum setting:5.2.1, Sieves
When ate sieverused?
Within the context of pedut safety contr! sting
ud be usd to ensure that foreign
bodies do net et into the product. In ation, coare sifting may protect subsequent
machinery and equipment fom being damaged due to large pieces
Inter of process engineering sleving ls seen asa separation process that involves the
mechanical breaidown of product Thi i frtner divided into casitation end sorting,
Which product properties must be taken into account?
In essence the flowing properties of Haus and dry product
inlunce the sieving behav and thus the steering ate
Viscosity, prtce size ctrbuton, cohesion forces Ginterpart
‘ular adbesivefoces) pate shape and electostatcchage 8
wo asthe meshes ofthe seve. The screening proces for
‘Stanulted Buk Froducts canbe estimated Amajorceteron for —[ |
{hi the ati particle sze Oto rash opening (W inthe
steve for.The open sving ars 40 sve fabri canbe etblihed in ine with 50478
Buk product with gain sz x < 100 jn eather uncutable for sieving due to aesve
forces between partes (Van der Wess ora) The smal parties bond teach other and
form sggomsater clamps) which maybock the mesh
The clectetaticbeaviour fhe blk product has
majorinfvene onthe emering a
Product moisture aot the sreening at gresty
inthe case of ul the voy ithe dace factor
regula grin forms canal influence sieving bebavout Long particles prim clinical
treed frn aad to sieve and on dependlng on the orentation, passthrough the
Sieve even though the poricle lengths somewhat longer than the gaps in themes
Spheticl partes and regu, compact farms are ease to ov.
What influences the flow rate?
‘Ahesive forces between the tices nd azolatedchmping can have a tong eet on
ine passage through re seve, For this reason tessto determine th respective screening rat
tre recommended The quantity of matron the seve surfaces the determining fact for
on optimum screening ate The gebte the quanty of materl onthe seve netting or seve
Suvfce thelongerthesovng process Moreover therein ko breakage
isthe mesh size appropriate forthe product?
Depending on the aplication, mesh ss of 0.09 mm to 20 mm have proven effective
fegerding protective nd canal iting of bulk product Mesh sizes up to 4 mm re used
forpoteetieandcortol iting Wider math openings are wed for corse siting of larger
foreign bosies Such conse ives shouldbe red rng the product n-eed of a mate
Tals in ord to lowe the isk ofthe seve breaking de to foreign bodes in subsequent
Siving macnines SU 4703 contains gudenes for seecing the combina mes
‘opening size and wie diameter,
What rates te ued forthe saves?
Depending on the aplication, valour mater can be used fr te slve neting Typical
sieves vein indtlseing technology ae made ron, carbo, ane tails see and
fre sed a8 fable or perforate plates. During the sk assessment process the usabty of
Inca ives wth th wie should be evaluated and partiubfocu laced er How thn
broken wre pce canbe detectedWhat must be taken into account when monitoring the sleves?
Sieve should bechockd Frequent or defectivemeshesandforegn body residues Fesuent
sual checks shouldbe caredout aossthe enti seve nating andbe documented acon
Ingy nding the mesh gps covering the ene see neting ate are checked for detect
Gieve breakage) and unacceptable expansions, Defective seves must be replaced ted
stely~furtheruseisnotpermted Upon replacement, the produc that wae being tested prior
{othe replace ofthe sieve shouldbe checked agan here ae foreign bodies on he
sieve nting they shoul be removed inmedlataly, Sve beshage can cca do material
fague ofthe sive netting, sharedged or henvy objects orsign bose), but ao du to
‘ovetading the seving machine with bage quant of need mati
The folowing types of damage may occur tosleve nating
«Sieve breakage due to tearng ag holes appearing asa est of meth ening none or
more places)
+ Espanson of mesh e.g. impemisibie expansion of indus mesh gaps)
Expansion Geese se)
seve
account when ung sleves wth weaden frames.
What must be taken inte account during deaning and maintenance?
In order to cleanseving machines, the sieve materi generally removed without at)
when the machine Isnetin operation, Seving machines ae dry oF wet cleaned depend
Ingon hysiene requirements Foreign bodiesmoy be reested during the cleaning process
hen removing the seve Fortis eason, cleaning work should ony be performed by
{tained and supervised stl. Every cleaning procedure shouldbe documented. Brshes
‘with natural or pastcbristies and clearing wipes made ofnatural and synthetic ives are
‘recommended for dy cesning onthe outide
nen using bruses for the inside parts there es that individual bristles may become
detached and ssbsequemty enter the process 25 foreign bodies. Depending on the5.22.
degrees of contaminstion, leaning agents canbe usd that are pected by the manu
factuer ofthe equipment The ive neting should be uly monitored for damage after
‘leaning and only berenstalled when ts re of defect.
Necessary maintenance work svogested by the equlpment manufacturer should be
followed accordingly.
‘Magnets
When ae magnets used?
Magnetic separators hve watious applications and ses: They an separate Impurities in 3
[anger spectrum of shoes nd sins than mata detector andray devices They a terefore
especialy in combination nth other metal detection devices highly een for detecting
{ong thin shop andmagnbsabl foreign bodes (29. wire pices).
Whereare they used?
Magnet re nthe production proce often located before metal detectors his potion
‘makes the most eerie an finan sense Adtonall, magnets can be used to monitor
Incoming goods (e9. ous aan o sugar sack or big bag). Here, the detectors ar used to
imonitor potently centaminated goods and to prevent lage magoaticforegn bodes such
{5 ides rom entering the production rocess, where they may be shred fries and
‘Subsequent nay no bnge be detectable under certain conetion could end o damage
own then,
ow are the metal pats found inthe product?
Magnet sepratorsytes attract metalic foregn objects when te mantored goodshave no
Imopnet ably end theefore arena attracted tothe meget themselves Magnet separator
Spates ere therefore not suitable for repaating nortenous metas steels and organic
materi
Staines ste! poricls which ate generat by fcton sheer ec have 2 modified mio
Seucture defo the hysa ses (lphomartenst Thus they have developed magnetic
properties which paitseparton
lethe strength of the magnet appropriate forthe product?
ogneve systems mua aapredo he product quant, aw wei especie process
tepleators Ingenent the smal the suspected contaminants the higher the fx ens.
‘The same applies o hgh speedo al and lange product flows. Therefore whe using m3
hesIn the productonrocees the focus shoul be on high a densty and durbiity other
tse the mage wl be the effecvenest ina shor ero tne, Monitoring the magnet
‘ome regula ase wt regard tos perfomance a equred mantenance mesure,281
‘ne sgnicant option of vetfying and checking magnet performance Ie uking magnet
meter to messire the fx densty at regular oth intervals The cunt fu ders
measured onthe magnet’ roduc facing surface using Hal probe. The magnet ea
heck for defematon and suo damage, When product temperatures ae constant a
‘or above 40% a shorter interval between inspections Is ecommendd. The manufac
‘pecieatioe ae ecommendatonssheulbe ken io acount
the strength of he magnet stil present and suitable?
Revalidation tesng has tote place atleast onan anna bass wth 2 eile mesuring
‘device rom thenational menting authori) and tested reference magnet. nth cse,
the magnetomear is compared onsite with the telerence magnet then the magnets are
tested by messing the surface fox density. Ths method I lable a i fly tacesle
“Tesing methods by ataching and removing metalic txt places are physics wrong and
witout reference tothe intended purpose ~ namely to separate smal impure, Shortt
‘montoring interes should be chosen a higher produc nd deaning temperature 2g.
(CP cleaning or szombse sera.5.3.1 Metal detection systems
What do find whenusing ameta detector?
In prince, metal detectors detec al types of metals, However, magnetic metas fa. ron)
tre mow really ecegnlsed compared to nommaghetc metals (ronderous metals and
non-magnetic tales sel).
How are the metal
ys found nthe product?
ith metal detector the product moves trough anelecromapne il Metal pats can
be detected also within» product they cause changes to the eecomagneti fel The
Cente ofthe deve’ opering ithe pont where the electromagnet ld a ts weakest
Snel therefore wher the detection capably alo atts est Te coret ratio of product
‘imensons ta the tunel mension important and a tunnel thats oo large should be
=| (im
What effects do the shape, postion and type of metal have on the detection?
‘Thagetctabty ofmtal objects dependsonthelocation athe posionin which the et!
parts ess through the the metal detector, Anon-sphreal metal part (2g 2 ple of wire
Tigges smaler or lager sigals depencing onthe eitecton in which It passes through
the detector, Detection becomes even mote effcult with meta shavings 8s the shavings
Structures porus inhomogeneous and generates an even weaker inal than awe201
In aon the oetectionacuacy varies depending onthe typeof metal and he locaton in
ict posses though the mata detector (28g)
Fes
Non-maget on oneragnte
ediontiermepat ano eefeout mid nonmgne
Seiad snnea
Tenataaye pond ‘Boer
writen ‘poor
Has the positionof the test ample been correctly chosen?
Since detection sens atts oust inthe center ofthe cpening the test sample together
wth the product shuld pass tough the metal detector in thi locaton, The felwing
agra show a tent test procedure
rows Metaldetcor Eq pode pcg
In general est saps should be a smal as posible in onder to detec the widest posible
spectrum of mete foreign bodes Furthermore, customer speciation have to be taken
Into account shuld be ensued that the ts soipes re tact and donot pose ay ype
“contamination ri therselvs there re doubts about the integrty ofthe tet specimen,
Should be replacedte the sting of the mata! detector appropiate forthe product?
there isa prodict change, the progam modified accordingly?
“The conductivity of product = product fect depends on vaious factors sch a5
+ Moisture and sain (sat content texture, nd composition
= Temperature
* Preduct quantity ae dimensions
» Packaging materials
etal detecing dvcescan minimise prod fe through ged ajstment fa prod
te change scarred ot hen acoreqponding programme change shoul aloe pa atten
ls the belt peed adaoted to the detection and rejection process?
1 vansgontion speets ae exceeded or oe too slow, then detection accuracy cannot be
‘uarnted plese obzerve monuactutrsspctatons) With flauatng transport speeds
{ea star stop operations), there a isk fal under the real wanspertation seed which
ould yest the lof detecon accuracy. oducts that ate within the detector une
‘his point in time shoud be inspected once again. is nacessary ens that the ection
procter mantored song wth he selected belt speed
gues{sthere reporting systom/alarm system ifthe rejection device fais andifthe
‘ejection bin al?
ftherejction bull othe election device fle ti pore that contamina product
snot propery rected wilcontinuein the process Therefore the entersecton process,
Including the ection bin and the contra sncors shouldbe checked Fequenth
‘Are environmental actors taken into consideration?
Environmental fictorcan havea negative ffecton metal detection. Theo Include vibra
to, ar hums er ra, insulation, elcrc supa and interference fequencies
A see seen ~~
( &>~
Vw
ave the manufbctrer’ specifications and instrctions been taken into account?
‘The manufacturers operating instructions and guidelines may conan addtional or other
requirements are should be folowed accurately,
Is there suitabledocumentation?
Appropriate acuacy fo the detector shouldbe etblihed and monitored depending onthe
roduc, Frequent montring must be documented and comectiveacone must be estab
lished inthe event of malfunctioning. the fllowing points shouldbe logged nthe doc
Product nd ne
+ spect
* ate and ine, necessny)
= Tesssample
Measures in cae of crepancies
«+ Signatar or dt cllection system5.3.2. X-ray inspection systems
What an find usingan Xray inspection sytem?
Ferrous and non erus metas 35 welas tines steel can be eal ecogised th Xay
inspection syst Te technology ia stable for recognising other foreign bodes such
‘aes stone ceramics, bones, dense plastics, or rubber compounds
What additonal advantages does an Xray inspection system provide?
Kay inspection sts can cy outa sees af adonal quality assurance tests on the
producton line, hes incide counting components, recognition of missing or damaged
products monitoring oduct forms or fil lve checking eas to ensure they are nac. ane
the cognition of aged packaging
How ae the foreign bodies found inthe product?
“rayinsoectons re wie scan for foregn bodes that absorba geste quant ofrdtion
omar to the redit within which they af ou. The quantity ofthe absorbed 3)
fadation depends on product hicknes and dent Imputtes uchasqlssormetal become
Ville during an Xryinspection due to the dering desis. Anas of the ay image
‘ried cut set on an vation ofthe shades faethe more homogeneous the product
Is the Bette the detection sens.
owns
2Wat effects de the shape, postion and type of material have on detection?
In general detecson of foreign boos sony posible if thy are denser than the product wth
Inch they aelcate The folowing etealimis apply to most ods containing water
Density inkgint
epedrgen rit
Donen hes ey
ee )
Isthe elt speed coordinated with the detection and rejection process?
“An uneven or inegular tans rom and othe transport conveyer af the Xray device can
lead to product backups and problems with the X-ay mage preesing. Nevethles the
‘necessary minimum dlstance between individ! products s general determined by the
‘requirements for oflectve rejection aed nt those orceting images The correct functioning
ofthe eecson process shouldbe established in conjunction withthe slated bet speed,
'sthere a reportng system/alarm system ifthe rejection device falls and ithe
‘ejection bin ial?
Fhe eeton bins fl othe jection device or proces fl spose that a contai-
rated product ot propel ejected an wl continue inthe process Therefore the ene
rejection process including the rejection bin and the contol sensors should be checkedregent
\sthe sie and the materi ofthe test amples appropriate forthe product?
General cet tales steel an ls pers are sed forthe ection tests thelr
‘erty canbe relsbly quntfed Problems moy ase Ia gas test pacman has 3 higher
‘deri than the loss mater that are used onthe production le. In sucha case, the cass
tert pecan wil be recognised but nt the gas part ofthe vessel. With a glassin-lass
polation fl recormended thatthe glass nprodcton used fr vtificaten purposes.
‘The ptmal verison method shouldbe established for every applation an est samples
‘ould be selected in acordance wth the product and the requlrements ofthe customer
‘peciestion If there ne doubts abou the Integy ofthe fest samp, hen should be
replica
lethe potion ofthetert specimen comect?
ely thee should be cecrely attached to the bat ofthe pachaged product should be
sare under ay cieumstanc, thatthe est spl an be found at ever location within
the pactaging To dom the equpment should have stable settings and the eats sample
sae ertslished sing test sees.
Wa products changed. isthe program modified accordingly?
with» product change, the maid varies of the pruct and packaging must be taken
into accoun. the prod compost eg. homogeneity), product dens and thickness and
the packaging mater as they can infuence absorption Behaviou With anew reduce
forelgn bose: can emg tat que a medication fo the setings or the fage ans.
For ths eason, inthe cae of product change - Ifthe properties vay spac atenton
shouldbe pact the program change
Have the manufactur speciiations an instructions been taken into account?
“The operating instucons and guldelnes from the manufacturer may contain aditonl or
ther equremants and ehoud be flowed eeu.
Ie suitable documentation avalable?
Aesroptemesierant accra forthe inspection stem should be established and
Imontored fr the a Inpacon sytem depending on the prec. A requlrcheck must
be documented
Conctv actions mutbe established for cstrbances The following pont should belogged
nine dacumenston 39,
» Product nd ine
» rspector
* Date and tine.
+ Testsarple
Teresa
* petonmeasures incase of discrepancies
* Signaturear dectroe data recoding6 | Handling foreign body incidents
and complaints\ 6. Handling foreign body incidents and complaints
Ie. despte all preventive sctionsan interna contos, foreign bodies ar found in prod
{cts by staf, eonsumes or authors, then isimportant that a comprehensive analysis
is eared out In ti cate, the folowing poets should certainly be considered (see
‘Appendix At detledrequitements of the, 26,50):
Management of complaints rom autos and customers
Management of no-conformttes and nor