You are on page 1of 7

J Periodontol • July 2006

Case Series
A Histologic Evaluation of Various Stages of Palatal
Healing Following Subepithelial Connective Tissue
Grafting Procedures: A Comparison of Eight Cases
Kristi M. Soileau* and Robert B. Brannon†

Background: It is often necessary to procure tissue

I
n recent decades, reconstruction of damaged
from the same area of the palate in cases where con- periodontal tissue has taken on an increasingly
nective autogenous grafting procedures are war- important role in surgical periodontics. It is be-
ranted due to limitations caused by anatomical cause of the similarity of reconstructive periodontal
features. The purpose of this study was to determine surgery to the medical specialty that many clinicians
whether the length of time between a first procure- have referred to these refined approaches as peri-
ment and a second would have any bearing on the odontal plastic surgery.
quality of tissue available for recipient sites. Recent emphasis on periodontal reconstruction co-
Methods: Eight patients requiring more than one incides with restorative dentistry’s emphasis on es-
grafting procedure underwent surgery at baseline thetics, and although the emergence of excellent
and again at various intervals ranging from 6 weeks bonding agents has amplified restorative possibilities,
to 11 months. Specimens were taken from the palate bonding alone cannot address mucogingival defects.
and evaluated microscopically, and photographs The restorative dentist should consider reconstructing
were taken for purposes of visual comparison. damaged periodontal structures before recommend-
Results: The 6.9- to 7.7-week specimens exhibited ing cosmetic bonding or altering pontic design.1 Ex-
complete reepithelialization. The lamina propriae were clusive use of dentin bonding cannot reproduce the
composed of a cellular proliferation of fibroblasts functional and esthetic characteristics of soft tissue.
with loosely arranged collagen deposition and an oc- This is particularly true in cases of single tooth reces-
casional thin vascular channel. However, remodeling sion where contour and harmony are essential for
of the wound appeared complete in the specimens optimal esthetics. Once a restoration has been placed
removed at the 9-week interval and beyond. The lam- on the root, soft tissue grafting becomes difficult with-
ina propria was, in general, composed of thick, dense, out extensive root preparation. Also, in cases of pro-
interlacing bundles of collagen. Small-caliber blood gressive recession, additional loss of attachment can
vessels were interspersed throughout the fibrous negate the esthetic results of the restorative therapy.
element. Therefore, it is in the patient’s best interest to include
Conclusion: Reharvesting of tissue performed ear- reconstructive periodontal surgery as a principal op-
lier than at 9 weeks may result in poorer autogenous tion in cases of recession. Connective tissue grafting
graft quality due to indications that remodeling of the has expanded our options in this area. In cases of gin-
connective tissue is still progressing and not as mature gival recession, periodontal root coverage procedures
as specimens noted at weeks 9 to 47. J Periodontol can create a naturally esthetic result that will blend
2006;77:1267-1273. with the adjacent tissue. Ideal results can be obtained
with the replacement of lost periodontal tissues fol-
KEY WORDS
lowed by bonding of any residual defects. The two
Grafts; healing; histology; palate; tissue. go hand and hand, enhancing our ability to restore
form and function in a manner not possible previ-
ously. The development of the connective tissue graft
has significantly improved treatment options and
predictability.
Autogenous subepithelial connective tissue graft-
ing has been used in the field of periodontics since first
described by Edel2 as a technique for increasing
* Private practice, New Orleans, LA.
† Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Pathology, Louisiana State University
School of Dentistry, New Orleans, LA. doi: 10.1902/jop.2006.050129

1267
Histologic Evaluation of Stages of Donor Site Palatal Healing Volume 77 • Number 7

attached tissue in areas of inadequate gingival width molars and molars. Prior to making the initial incision
and for root coverage. More recently, with the intro- to procure the donor tissue from the palate, the sur-
duction of the subepithelial connective tissue graft geon should attempt to palpate the bony groove. This
performed by Langer and Calagna3 to build edentu- palpation allows the surgeon to determine the maxi-
lous ridges and by Langer and Langer4 to cover roots, mum apical placement of the incision that is possible
procedures have become more successful, esthetic, before violating the neurovascular bundle. When the
and predictable. Several modifications in the surgical palatal vault is shallow, the neurovascular structures
procedure have been and are currently being made.5-9 will be located more proximally to the CEJ. When
The principal applications of the connective tissue the palatal vault is high (U shaped), the structures will
graft include the following: 1) root coverage with spe- be located at a greater distance from the CEJ. The
cific applications in cases of esthetic concern, pro- retrieval of donor tissue from the premolar region in
gressive recession, and recession where marginal the high and average palates offers a greater margin
tissue inhibits hygiene, causes root sensitivity, and of safety than retrieval from the shallow palatal vault.
increases risk of root caries; 2) edentulous ridge aug- The mean height of the palatal vault in an adult male is
mentation or recontouring before restorative therapy; 14.90 mm with a SD of 2.93 mm. The mean height in
3) gingival augmentation in conjunction with ortho- an adult female is 12.70 mm with a SD of 2.45 mm.
dontics or restorative dentistry; and 4) tissue buildup Caution must always be exercised not to violate the
around implants to enhance esthetics.1 neurovascular bundle when obtaining the donor tis-
Although the option of donor grafting is a viable sue, but extreme caution must be exercised when
alternative for some clinicians, many, and perhaps the palate is shallow.10 The area of procurement gen-
the majority, still choose to procure tissue directly erally occurs a minimum of 2 mm from the gingival
from the patient undergoing surgical therapy. margin in the region located between the distal of
Regardless of the final destination, the palate is the the cuspid and mesial to the midpoint of the maxillary
most commonly used donor site when considering au- first molar in an effort to stay away from the greater
togenous soft tissue grafting. The hard palate is com- palatine artery and nerve. In the hard palate, mucosal
posed of the palatal process of the maxillary bone and thickness increases with greater distances from the
the horizontal process of the palatine bone. It is cov- marginal gingiva. The mucosa over the palatal root
ered with masticatory mucosa. The soft tissue extend- of the maxillary first molar is significantly thinner than
ing superiorly from the cemento-enamel junction at all other positions in the hard palate.11
(CEJ) of the maxillary posterior teeth for ;2 to 4 mm The desired thickness of the tissue procured de-
is composed of dense lamina propria. The connec- pends on the intended use. For root coverage, 1.5 to
tive tissue continuing on to the midline of the palate 2 mm is typically adequate, whereas ridge augmen-
contains loosely organized glandular and adipose tation procedures require a much thicker graft. Some
tissue. The height, length, and thickness of donor fatty or glandular tissue may be inadvertently in-
tissue that can be obtained varies with the different cluded in the graft, which generally is not considered
anatomic dimensions of the palatal vault. The greatest a problem.1
height (inferior-superior dimension) can be found in Predictable root coverage can be anticipated on
the high (U-shaped) palatal vault. The greatest length roots without significant interproximal loss of attach-
(anterior-posterior dimension) can be found in a large ment, as in those labeled as Class I and II in Miller’s
palate. The thickest tissue can be found in that area classification.12 Root coverage becomes increasingly
from the mesial line angle of the palatal root of the first less predictable in areas with greater interproximal
molar to the distal line angle of the canine. A thick al- bone loss, as in Classes III and IV in Miller’s system.12
veolar process and/or exostosis is often encountered in In obtaining autogenous donor tissue, the subepi-
the molar region, which limits the length and thickness thelial graft technique typically involves the making
of tissue that may be obtained. The clinician can deter- of two parallel palatal incisions ;2 mm apart, with
mine the thickness of the donor tissue by needle sound- the incisions carried along to the free gingival margin
ings following the administration of local anesthesia. of the teeth adjacent to the site selected for procure-
The greater and lesser palatine nerves and blood ment of donor tissue.
vessels gain entrance into the palate by passing Oftentimes, it is necessary to repeatedly use the
through the greater and lesser palatine foramina. same area of a patient’s palate for consecutive graft-
The foramina locations vary, but generally can be ing procedures due to limitations caused by inade-
identified apical to the third molar at the junction of quate tissue or vascular anatomy. Therefore, if there
the vertical and horizontal parts of the palatine bone. is a shortage of tissue necessary for treating all of
These nerves and vessels course anteriorly within a the sites, a patient may ultimately need grafting, un-
bony groove. The neurovascular bundle may be lo- less the same palatal donor site is often used on more
cated 7 to 17 mm from the CEJs of the maxillary pre- than one occasion. The purpose of this study was to

1268
J Periodontol • July 2006 Soileau, Brannon

determine whether the length of time between two Table 1.


separate surgical procedures, both using the same
Time Intervals Between
palatal donor site, would have any bearing on palatal
healing and readiness for a second surgical take. Surgical Procedures
Thus, should there be a minimal healing time prior
to reinvading the palate so as to maximize donor Time Interval (days/weeks) Between
tissue value and function? Therefore, the issue is Group/Case First and Second Surgery
whether or not there should be a 9-week minimal I/1 48/6.9
healing time prior to reinvading the palate so as to
maximize donor tissue value and function, according I/2 54/7.7
to the histologic findings presented in this study.
II/3 63/9.0

MATERIALS AND METHODS III/4 87/12.4


Patient Population and Study Design III/5 94/13.4
Eight patients from a private periodontal practice in
New Orleans, Louisiana, were selected to participate IV/6 160/22.9
in the study (age range: 31 to 62 years; seven females
IV/7 184/26.3
and one male). Subjects were made aware of the case
presentation submitted, and the study was conducted V/8 331/47.3
in accordance with the Helsinki Declaration of 1975,
as revised in 2000. It was necessary that none of the
patients were smokers and that their medical histories
were unremarkable. ceived 0.5 mg alprazolam and 20 mg valdecoxib. A
Additionally, all patients required grafting of sev- general polishing was performed on all teeth, and
eral teeth such that a one-stage procedure would the patients were given a 0.12% chlorhexidine gluco-
not have been adequate to achieve an increased gin- nate solution to swish with for 30 seconds. Marcaine
gival width for all of the teeth scheduled for treatment. 0.5% with 1:200,000 epinephrine was administered
Two patients underwent surgery at baseline and be- in the recipient surgery site, whereas xylocaine 2%
tween 6.9 and 7.7 weeks; one patient had surgery with 1:50,000 epinephrine was administered in the
at baseline and at 9.0 weeks; two patients had surgery palatal donor site. The donor site received a total of
at baseline and between 12.4 and 13.4 weeks; two pa- ;0.9 to 1.2 ml per surgery, with some being adminis-
tients had surgery at baseline and between 22.9 and tered following surgery when deemed necessary for
26.3 weeks; and one patient had surgery at baseline postoperative bleeding control.
and at 47.3 weeks. Therefore, these eight patients After preparing the recipient site for accepting the
were divided into five groups according to healing in- graft, the palatal donor tissue was procured. A double-
tervals (Table 1). All surgeries were completed be- bladed scalpel was employed, using 1.5 mm of width
tween 2003 and 2004. between the two blades, and an incision was made be-
tween the mesial of the first molar and the distal of the
Surgical Procedure cuspid and ;3 mm from the free gingival margin of
The presurgical workup included review of allergies, the nearby teeth. The incision was made until resis-
medications being taken, and medical history tance was felt on the osseous tissue, and the incision
changes since the patient’s last visit. All patients were was carried horizontally through an amount of tissue
instructed as to the discontinuation of aspirin and necessary to fulfill that length of tissue required at
aspirin-like products, vitamin E, and alcohol consump- the recipient site. The ends of the graft were released
tion for the 10 days prior to surgery in an effort to by using a 15C blade, and the graft was lifted from the
prevent bleeding problems at or following surgery. palate. Photographs were taken of each donor graft
An impression was taken so that a palatal stent could site, and the last 2 mm of each piece of donor tissue
be used postoperatively, and patients were generally taken from each patient was submitted for histologic
given prescriptions for propoxyphene with acetamin- evaluation of collagen organization and maturation.
ophen, alprazolam 0.5 mg, valdecoxib 20 mg, and The area from which the piece sent for histologic test-
doxycycline 100 mg, the latter of which was to be ing came was also measured with a probe and docu-
taken daily for 2 weeks. At the time of surgery, med- mented so that, with photographs, it would be certain
ical history was again reviewed and monitoring of that the same area would be procured at the rehar-
blood pressure, SaO2, and electrocardiogram vesting for a comparative histologic evaluation. As
(EKG) was performed on all patients throughout the stated in Table 1, reharvesting occurred at ;6 weeks
procedure. One hour prior to surgery, patients re- and at 2, 3, 6, and 11 months. All of the surgically

1269
Histologic Evaluation of Stages of Donor Site Palatal Healing Volume 77 • Number 7

removed specimens were submitted to the Depart-


ment of Oral and Maxillofacial Pathology, Louisiana
State University School of Dentistry, to ensure that
an official pathology report was issued. All cases were
evaluated microscopically using the standard hema-
toxylin and eosin (H&E) stain.
Following surgery, the palatal site was covered by a
surgical acrylic stent, as did Rossmann and Rees13 for
bleeding control and minimization of discomfort,
which had been fabricated prior to surgery. However,
sutures, acrylates, or dressings were not employed on
the palatal donor sites in this study.

RESULTS
Figure 2.
Clinical Findings Normal (baseline) palate from case 8 showing keratinized stratified
All eight patients healed as expected with no unfore- squamous epithelium overlying dense collagenous tissue. Adipose
seen adverse occurrences. Discomfort was typically tissue and small-caliber blood vessels are in the lower one-third of
diminished by day 10, at which time wound closure the specimen (H&E; original magnification ·40).
appeared to be clinically complete in all eight cases.
An area of slight redness persisted for up to 4 weeks,
at which time color began to blend with surrounding
palatal tissue, as did tissue contour. Recovery of sen-
sation did not occur for months in some cases. Addi-
tionally, a certain shrinkage of all grafts was noted at
the recipient sites as maturing occurred.
Histologic Findings
The histologic findings of the eight hard palate spec-
imens at the time of the initial surgery (baseline)
showed normal palatal mucosa and submucosa.
The specimens were composed of orthokeratinized
or parakeratinized stratified squamous epithelium
with well-formed rete ridges (Figs. 1 and 2). The lam-
ina propria possessed thick dense bundles of collagen
Figure 3.
with small-caliber blood vessels scattered throughout Normal (baseline) palate lamina propria from case 5 composed of
(Figs. 3 and 4). dense interlacing collagen bundles (H&E; original magnification
The group I specimens that were removed at the ·100).
6.9-week (48 days) to 7.7-week (54 days) intervals

Figure 1. Figure 4.
Normal (baseline) palate from case 5 showing keratinized stratified Normal (baseline) palate lamina propria from case 8 composed of
squamous epithelium overlying dense collagenous tissue (H&E; dense interlacing collagen bundles (H&E; original magnification
original magnification ·40). ·100).

1270
J Periodontol • July 2006 Soileau, Brannon

showed that reepithelialization of the wound was com-


plete. The lamina propria was composed of a cellular
proliferation of fibroblasts with a loosely arranged
deposition of collagen fibers and an occasional thin
vascular channel (Figs. 5 and 6). These findings indi-
cated that remodeling of the connective tissues was
still in progress.
Remodeling of the wound appeared complete in the
specimens removed at the 9-week (63 days) interval
and beyond. Reepithelialization was complete, and
the lamina propria was composed of thick, dense, in-
terlacing bundles of collagen. Small-caliber blood
vessels were interspersed throughout the fibrous
element (Figs. 7 through 9). Figure 7.
Reepithelialized wound of case 6 at 160 days. The lamina propria is
DISCUSSION composed of dense collagenous tissue with several small-caliber blood
Regarding the recipient site, Rossmann and Rees13 vessels interspersed throughout (H&E; original magnification ·40).
followed patients an average of 10 months and found

Figure 8.
Figure 5. The lamina propria of case 6 at 160 days exhibiting interlacing
At 48 days, note the loosely woven collagen fibers in the lamina bundles of dense collagen. There is a capillary in the center and lower
propria of case 1. A thin-walled blood vessel is at the far left of the left of the photograph (H&E; original magnification ·100).
photograph (H&E; original magnification ·100).

Figure 6. Figure 9.
At 54 days, numerous spindle-shaped fibrocytic nuclei amid loosely Case 7 at 184 days reveals a densely collagenous lamina propria.
woven collagen fibers are noted in the lamina propria of case 2 A capillary is at the far left of the photograph, and the tip of a rete
(H&E; original magnification ·100). ridge is at the top left (H&E; original magnification ·100).

1271
Histologic Evaluation of Stages of Donor Site Palatal Healing Volume 77 • Number 7

a mean shrinkage of recipient grafts of 24% in total Kremenak20 looked at healing of mucoperiosteal
surface area. In the palatal donor site, healing is mainly wounds in beagle dogs by use of ultrastructural ster-
by primary intention, and postoperative discomfort eology. When the quantitative data from healing
is dramatically decreased compared to the free gin- wounds was compared to values from normal, un-
gival graft (FGG). In beagle dogs, Squier et al.14 wounded control tissue, values for the periosteum
found that actin-containing cells with the ultrastruc- and submucosa returned close to control values 13
tural characteristics of myofibroblasts (contractile days following wounding, whereas those values for
fibroblasts) are present in the granulation tissue the subepithelial layer and lamina propria were still sig-
of healing skin and oral muscosal wounds and nificantly different from the controls at 18 days. Thus,
may be responsible for the wound contraction ob- Squier and Kremenak20 concluded that there is a gra-
served clinically in the healing palatal mucoperios- dient of healing between the bone and the surface ep-
teum. Cornelissen et al.15 found myofibroblasts in ithelium, and complete repair and remodeling of the
rat palatal wound tissue between days 4 and 22, tissue is likely to take longer than 18 days. Donn21
with the highest density at 8 days postwounding. studied three submerged connective tissue autografts
The number of collagen type I and type II fibers that were evaluated at 4, 7, 10, 14, 20, 30, and 90 days,
gradually increased until about 8 days postwound- and at 1.5 and 4 years for similarities in a wound-
ing, and thereafter the staining intensity of collagen healing study. One wound-healing sequence was actu-
type III fibers decreased. At 60 days postwounding, ally presented to evaluate the role of the specificity of
there were more transversely oriented collagen type connective tissue in the creation of a new gingival at-
I fibers and fewer type III fibers and elastin present in tachment procedure. In Donn’s study,21 he admits that
the submucosa than in normal tissue. This suggests difficulty often exists in obtaining adequate amounts of
that wound contraction occurs in the mucosa mainly donor tissue. He also notes that healing of the palate
between 4 and 22 days.15 after 1 month will not leave any depression at the site,
The parallel single incision (PSI) method was used and thus the area can usually be entered again for ad-
in expectation of a more rapid surface healing/epithe- ditional connective tissue material.21
lialization due to proposed earlier advanced healing It is for this particular reason that this research
with this technique. In a comparative study of clinical bears clinical relevance. Should there be a 9-week
healing in the donor site between patients treated with minimal healing time prior to reinvading the palate
a trap door (TD) technique or with a PSI, which uses a so as to maximize donor tissue and function?
scalpel with parallel blades, Harris16 recorded a high Because maturation of tissue was notably better at
rate of sloughing of the superficial flap (11 out of 63 days versus the 48- and 54-day specimens, an ad-
13 cases) for the TD group. Del Pizzo et al.17 showed ditional study following biopsies daily from the 6- to
faster reepithelialization in the SI group than in the TD 9-week intervals may further elucidate that particular
or FGG groups they studied. However, Del Pizzo et point at which an acceptable collagen maturation is
al.17 showed no statistically significant differences re- truly reached.
garding the return of sensibility among the SI, TD, or
FGG groups they studied; complete recovery of sen- ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
sation occurred in at least 8 weeks in a number of pa- The authors thank Dr. James Weir, Department of
tients. Discomfort was absent or minimal in the TD Oral and Maxillofacial Pathology, Louisiana State
and SI groups, whereas the FGG group reported more University School of Dentistry, for his assistance in
problems postoperatively in the first 2 weeks after sur- photographing the histologic specimens and Dr.
gery. Clinically, eating habits showed a faster return to David DeGenova (spouse of Dr. Soileau) for contribu-
normal by the second week, whereas 25% of the TD tions toward the layout and design of electronic im-
and 34% of the FGG groups still followed a soft food ages. This paper is dedicated to Dr. Roland Meffert,
diet.17 postdoctoral professor and mentor of Dr. Soileau at
Interestingly, Pedlar18 demonstrated that a rugae the Louisiana State University School of Dentistry.
does not regenerate if it is removed; thus, a return
REFERENCES
to normality does not occur.18 In the Kahnberg and
1. Cabrera PO. Connective tissue grafting: An option in
Thilander study19 on palatal healing in rats, epithelial- reconstructive periodontal surgery. J Am Dent Assoc
ization was noted to have progressed from the wound 1994;125:729-737.
borders, and reduction of the wound surface pro- 2. Edel A. Clinical evaluation of free connective tissue
ceeded by contraction of the wound margins and by grafts used to increase the width of keratinized gingiva.
epithelial cell migration. After 3 weeks, the defects J Clin Periodontol 1974;1:185-196.
3. Langer B, Calagna LJ. The subepithelial connective
were completely covered with epithelium, although tissue graft. A new approach to the enhancement of
epithelial rete pegs had not yet developed in the cen- anterior cosmetics. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent
tral part of the former defect.19 Squier and 1982;2(2):22-33.

1272
J Periodontol • July 2006 Soileau, Brannon

4. Langer B, Langer L. Subepithelial connective tissue 14. Squier CA, Leranth CS, Ghoneim S, Kremenak CR.
graft technique for root coverage. J Periodontol 1985; Electron microscopic immunochemical localization of
56:715-720. action in fibroblasts of healing skin and palate wounds
5. Raetzke PB. Covering localized areas of root coverage of beagle dog. Histochemistry 1983;78:513-522.
employing the ‘‘envelope technique.’’ J Periodontol 15. Cornelissen AM, Stoop R, Von den Hoff HW, Maltha
1985;56:397-402. JC, Kuijpers-Jagtman AM. Myofibroblasts and matrix
6. Nelson SW. The subpedicle connective tissue graft. A components in healing palatal wounds in the rat. J Oral
bilaminar reconstructive procedure for the coverage of Pathol Med 2000;29:1-7.
denuded root surfaces. J Periodontol 1987;58:95-102. 16. Harris RJ. A comparison of two techniques for obtain-
7. Journee D. Partially buried connective tissue grafts for ing a connective tissue graft from the palate. Int J
gingival recession: Clinical results apropos of 22 cases Periodontics Restorative Dent 1997;17:260-271.
(in French). J Parodontol 1989;8:339-346. 17. Del Pizzo M, Modica F, Bethez N, Priotto P, Romagnoli
8. Harris RJ. The connective tissue and partial thickness R. The connective tissue graft: A comparative clinical
double pedicle graft: A predictable method of obtain- evaluation of wound healing at the palatal donor site.
ing root coverage. J Periodontol 1992;63:477-486. A preliminary study. J Clin Periodontol 2002;29:
9. Zabalegui I, Sicilia A, Cambra J, Gil J, Sanz M. Treat- 848-854.
ment of multiple adjacent gingival recessions with the 18. Pedlar J. Healing following full thickness excision of
tunnel subepithelial connective tissue graft: A clinical human palatal mucosa. Br J Plast Surg 1985;38:
report. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 1999;19: 347-351.
199-206. 19. Kahnberg KE, Thilander H. Healing of experimental
10. Reiser GM, Bruno JF, Mahan PE, Larkin LH. The excisional wounds in the rat palate. (I) Histological
subepithelial connective tissue palatal donor site: An- study of the interphase in wound healing after sharp
atomic considerations for surgeons. Int J Periodontics dissection. Int J Oral Surg 1982;11:44-51.
Restorative Dent 1996;16:130-137. 20. Squier CA, Kremenak CR. Quantitation of the healing
11. Studer SP, Allen EP, Rees TC, Kouba A. The thickness palatal mucoperiosteal wound in the beagle dog. Br J
of the masticatory mucosa in the human hard palate Exp Pathol 1982;63:573-584.
and tuberosity as potential donor sites for ridge 21. Donn BJ. The free connective tissue autograft: A
augmentation procedures. J Periodontol 1997;68: clinical and histologic wound healing study in humans.
145-151. J Periodontol 1978;49:253-260.
12. Miller PD. A classification of marginal tissue recession.
Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 1985;5(2):8-13. Correspondence: Dr. Kristi M. Soileau, 2820 Napoleon
13. Rossmann JA, Rees TD. A comparative evaluation of Ave., Ste. 470, New Orleans, LA 70115. Fax: 504/899-
hemostatic agents in the management of soft tissue 1237; e-mail: kmsperio@earthlink.net.
graft donor site bleeding. J Periodontol 1999;70:1369-
1375. Accepted for publication January 6, 2006.

1273

You might also like