Available online at www.sciencedirect.

com

ScienceDirect
Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996


  
  


! 

"# 

"

 $#%
& 
   '
(

# )
( 

*+
 % (, -
.!'
.!% /0
1+ %&-
"( 
"(&-
 (
2 /
.!'3&-
4 

4 &



  

 
   
 
 
  
  

  

 

!

  

 
   
  " 
 
#$"  
  

  

 



5
6#6


#%
 

( 



 $#%
& 
   '
(

# )
(  7

 $#  
 
8#6
2'
 
(6 %


 
(


66# 


#%
 
(6


 ' 
# 
  '

9 # %

"# 

6
: %7
5
; 
 '

<   '

=# 
; <=

 
 6
&%
 -
(-
8 

;> 
??

 6
 
5#+
&%

3%3+@!3+-
A+'3 -
.!+ 

2(

 
66 

( 
# )
(  7
9

 # 



  -
 
%
 
66 7



B

5
A#7
#&
© 
&%
"
2013 The Authors. Published 
<7

by Elsevier Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
  and
Selection

6 
#
peer-review under
6 & %

5
A
responsibility of The Association 

Education
of Science, -
"#and
Technology-TASET,


5  '% 5A "5-
Universitesi,
Sakarya + %

: -
5#+%7

Turkey.

%&  C
 $#%
& 
   '-
# 
(  -
(
$# &#(

  

< & %
+
6 %

(6 
 

 

(%
  '7

 


#''
 
# 

&
(
##
#'
6 6 




 
& %
 


<#  -
?D-
E
 -
??E
5& -
??E
8  

+ '-
??F7
5%
& 
 
6

 6( 

#

  )
(  '#
   '-


 6#
#   '







#

 
6 %

 $# 


6 6 

 $#%
& 
& %
7

G 


 
 
 
&
+


$# 

 '

' 
 


<#  -
?DE
5&

8 '-
?DHE
5& -
??E


<#  -
7

#
 
&

#  -
 ( %


#

' 
<# 

5 (-
?H?E
2( -
???E



,

6  '
#7

"( 
C
!+7& % ((I'(  7(

1877-0428 © 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of The Association of Science, Education and Technology-TASET, Sakarya Universitesi, Turkey.
doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2013.12.112
 Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996 989

<#  -
7
# 
 

 # 
6
&%
6



J6( E
 
%

#


(6  '

J6( 
%

+ '
 -

%
 

#  

6

J6( 

67

A '

( %
# -
+ '


&
( 
+ '

(  

J6( -

#
&K


   '

 ' '



'

  %
(6 
 

<#  -
7
5-

 $#%
& 
+


& %
# 
&
 
A& " > +

7-
7
 $#%
& 
   '


 


6

  )
  '
(  '#

##
+  '
(
+  '
  
&%
+ '

$# -
  '-

%! '

+  '
%

G  -
7


   '
  ( 


 $#%
& 
   '
 +
6 -
# 
6(

J6( 



 # %



'#6-

#


( 
#
 
+  '
&(
(
(  '#

(
6(  7


6-

# 
%

6 


6& (

&


 


 

%
 #
#'


6 6 
5  
L
>##-M7

 

N &'
??F
  
 

& 
& 

 $#%


 

 

   'E
& #
%
( +
# 
6 6 

#
6

(6  '
 
$# 


6& (-
'   '
%6-
'  '
J6( -
  '

%! '
  -

( + '
  

&#
 
6& (

6 (
 


= '-
O '

P -
7


  -
 #(



# 
 
# 
 %
+
6 


   '
6


 $#%
& 
&
 '-

 
%
 6
6
#
 
& 7
5
6 6 
 

 
 $#%
& 
&
J6( 
6
(


66# %

 6
 6  
#'-


#  

(
 6-


(

'#6
(6

(
# 7



A '

2(
???-
# 
' !

6& (
 


J6( -
 %

#&
6& (-
 

 
 %


 #


#& 6& (-

 
 
  # 
&%

%! '

 
 
%
& 





%6


 

J6( 

&
 
&%
( 


 $#%7
5%
6 %

 
# '
#
J6( 
 
%
( 


6& (

%

( 
 6

 # 


6& (
  -
??7


"' -
4  -
+(!

. '
"
F
(6 !
 
# 


66 

 
%




 $#%
& 
J6( 
-

 
' 
&%

 7
9
  
 
#
%

# 
&C
Q 

 %
 

'  



 
%(R7





6-
# 

J6




 
 
%(

&-

'



J6( -


 

%!


 
 


A%S#

"' -
D7



A

 #
(  
 
 $#%
& 
   '
(
 
&
# 

&
(



 
 #

( 
 &# 


 6( 

# )
 (

( -
 + '-
6& (   '-
( 

& %
+ 
 #%
??E
(
??ME
%( +%-

'-

N
??E
G#&
??ME
 -
E
 &+

>  -
E
; J

7-

E1  %

7
E
1  %

A 
FE
5#

7-
FE
;G %-
8 -

>+

ME
;  -
7




, ,  0   
 
$


A




  
 #
(  
 
 $#%
& 

 &#


# )
#   '

#

 
 +#-
F-


 6( 


+  '


6

<

1+!+-
M-

+ 

 
6
   -


>6-
E
2-

FE
A%S#L"' -
D-

#
 
 
   '
O -
8

O ( -
E
8&


 -
E
<

1+!+-
M-

( 

 
   '
5# -
 -
5 

 '-

F-


((#  
+ 7

 
 #
&%
A 

2 
?H

&%
 


8'
?H-

 
# 
 
 $#%
& 
J6( 

( 
 &# 


 6( 


# )

 + '
+ 
 


= '

7-
7

#
# %-
 
#


 #'

#'
 ( %
%6

-

 $#%
& 
J6( 

  %
#7
5
6 6
(


990 Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996

 &# '

6( '
 $#%
& 
J6( 

 
 

( + '

#
6 E





#
J6( 

# )
( 


 ' 

 

#
6#67
5#-



#'


  '
$# C


A

%
'  
 
&
# 
 #'

 $#%
& 
   '
66 

J6( 
'#6

# 
 #'

 
 #
 
'#6

6

  
'


   -
J 
'
   -
 +
 #-
 

   '
& -
   %

   '


6( -


J%

(

(%
#T

#&
 
6& (


#%
C


 A

%
'  
 
&
# )
; <=
6 


J6( 
'#6


 
'#6T


 A

%
'  
 
&
# )
; <=
6 

6 



J6( 
'#6T


 A

%
'  
 
&
# )
; <=
6 

6 



 
'#6T


 A

%
'  
 
&
# )
; <=
6 


J6( 

'#6

 
'#6T

 

+ ,
1  $
2 

5
#%
 
 #


 $#  
 
8#6
2'
9  +

N  -
ME
8 %



A  -
7

+ +

3  

A


H
# 
  '

26 ( 

  %
 

; ( 
"# 



9 # %

"# 

6
: %
6 6 


 7

+ -
 
#  
  

; 
 '

<   '
=# 
; <=C
5
; 
 '

<   '

=# 
 
(6 %



( 
# )
( 

(%
#7
5
; <=


 
 6
&%
 -
(-
8 

;> 
??

 6
 
5#+
&%
3%3+@!3+-

A+'3 -
.!+ 

2(
 


 # 
# %
# )
( 
K#( 



#

 '
   '
 '


#

# %7
5
; <=
(6


( 
6 C

(  -

   '
 '7
5
( 
6 
   

(


#& (  

  

'
  
81-
J 
'
  
"81-
 +
 #
5U-
 

   '
& 
1<-
 
 %

   '

6( 
 <-


J%
5A75
# 

 ( %
 
%


 
6(

( 
# %
# )
( 

(%
C
VW
X
--
89X
7DH-

A89X
7HH

G; "AX
7H7
5
  & %
 

7H

81-
7FHF

"81-
7D?

5U-
7H


1<-
7?

<-

7FM

5A
4 -
7

5 & 



 (+

( 
6 


; <=

&
 7

 Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996 991

!,4
$
$  
 "& 
 
2   
( 
 
256

9 
"J6 

  
'
  

<  )
& 

  

U #
"J 
'
  

&#

(6 

 +

5 +
 #

   %
<  )
& 

  

"J6 %

 

   '
& 
&#
6( 

<  ))

 


A
5
J%


 +

3%3+@!3+-
A+'3 -
2( -
L
.!+ -



+ 7
 
 


5
 
&  

%!
#'
; N %
: 

N J
' 
G +
57



+ 8
(   


5
(
$# &#(
J6( 
 
 

 $#%7
5
(


J6( 
 

6


  & %


& 


 
# '
&

> 

9



 # 7




J6( -
'#6

 
# 

(-


 '#6
 

&#7


7
  '
6 C
5
J6( W& 

 7
5 C
6 

  '
6


 

6& (7
5
 
6#

 # -

(



# + 


# 

 # 


> 
Y
9
-
 



 



#&7
5
# 

+

&

6 (
# '7

G# C

 +
&
 #

7

( 

( 
&#
(
$# &#(



# 7

5%

'#
#'


 $#%

  #
 


(
$# &#(7


7


( 
#
 
# 
 


   $#%C
# 
 

6
+  '

6 


7
5 C
6(

# -
##

 $#%-
'
(

 

75
 

+

# 

( +
(( 
& 


 +
&
 #
&  -


 

 
#'C

 
 66 
T



7


( 
#
 
# 
(# 

#'

(6 
(

)
C
5 C
'


# 

 

6  -
 #
 

(6 

( 
&

6
+  '

 
# 7

5
# 
(( 


&  7
1 


'#6
((&


 
 '

 


&
(6 
&%

'#67
5
'#6

+

6 

 


 
 
%
 
 7
5




&#
(
$# &#(

( 
&%

 7

( 

$# &#(

( 

%7
5
 
+


$# C
N 

 66




 
(
9


 #



 # T


%#
6 7


7
%6! 'C
 '
( 

 
6& (-
'#6

# 
(

%67
5 C

 6


(#  '

 
6& (-



(#  '

%6-
' '


 
&

7
5
# 
'  

%6

 
 66 


9


 #





(J#7


(%
%6

 -

# 
&

 '-
7


F7
5
# 
 





%6
J6( -
&  -
$# -
#( -
7

5 C
6(
# 
 #'
(

+
# (# %-

( +
#
%
(6 

7


 (

(

 $#%
 7
-
# 
 



#

+  '

 


+  '



%67


992 Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996

M7
5 '

%6C
5
%6




(

(
J6( -
&  -

$# -
#( 
 
 7
5 C
& '
'

(  

#( 



66 %

(

 $#%
 7



&
(
9


 #


(J#

  #C


 +
&
 #

&  7


 #

$# 7
5
 '

(6



$# 7






9


 #
  # 


    T-
77777

H7
5
# 

&  -
%




6  
5 C
 6

 6 '

# 7
5

 
&  

' !7
5
'#6
6(

6   7


D7
" 
%6



 %C
# 

%6

 -
%
'
& +

6
7
5 C

 # '

  

6

 $#%7

%6

 
 C
 6

 '


#66

( '

% 7

(( 


66  
#  7

5
+  '
&  


  
&%

 -


#7




   

!+4
2 )9$  
) 
 

81
"81
5U
1<
<
5A

; N %
:
H-
DH-F
?-
M?-F
MM-F
MD-

N J
N
M-
FD-F
-
-F
FM-F
FD-

*
-
-FF
-D
-M
-H
-?

A%(67 '7
-
-
-
-?M
-D?
-?H

  

"J 
'7Z,
-
-
-
-?M
-D?
-?

  
'[



7



7



&7
8#6 '
U  & C
8#6



A '


; N %
: 
# -



'  
 

 

 
'#6

&
6


J 
'
  
:XDH-F-
6\7F7
 &  



'  
 

&

6




 

# 
6]7F

!-4
N J
' 
G +
5
G# 

81
"81
5U
1<
<
5A
81
"81
5U
1<
<
5A

*
-
-DF
-F
-
-D
-H&

A%(67 '7
-H
-
-
-DDM
-M
-

  



7 

' 
 +7



&7
 

6
 +7



7
N J
' 
G +
5

 Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996 993

A '


N J
' 
G +
5
# -



'  
 

 

6

&


J 
'
  
!X -DF-
6\7F
6 6

# 


J6( 

'#67
 &  



'  
 
&





 
6 6


# 
6]7F
#  0
$
 
 
$




$
$
 $#%
& 
<   '
"
  

  ! 

$
"   
 
 

$
!) " 
 
J 
'
  

!74
N J
' 
G +
5
G# 

81
"81
5U
1<
<
5A

81
"81
5U
1<
<
5A

*
-MMH
-
-FH
-DDH&
-?
-MF&

A%(67 '7
-?M
-?D
-M
-HF
-?F
-

  

7 

' 
 +7



&7
 

6
 +7



7
N J
' 
G +
5



A '


N J
' 
G +
5
# -



'  
 

 

6

&



J%
!X -MF-
6\7F
6 6

# 


 
'#67
 &  




'  
 
&





 
6 6

# 
6]7F



!84
2 )9$  
) 
1 


81
"81
5U
1<
<
5A

; N %
:
FF-F
H-
D-
M?-F
FD-F
D-

N J
N
M-F
DD-
??-
F?-F
D-F
?D-

*
-H
-M?
-
-M
-D
-?H

A%(67 '7
-MF
-??
-?
-?M
-H
-F

  

"J 
'7Z,
-M
-F
-??
-?M
-HH
-FH

  
'[



7



7



&7
8#6 '
U  & C
8#6


A '


; N %
: 
# -



'  
 
&





6

# 


J6( 

 
'#6
6]7F



     
A '


 
# -

 
# 
 
# )
J 
'
  
 6



66   7
"J 
'
  

 

 #  '
# )
( 

(6  '


 

  '
' -
  '
' 

6( 
 -
(-
8  -
L;> -
??75



  '
#66 '

  '
&  

  
 
#
  # '
 
 $#%
& 


6(
# )
( 
 -
E
 &+

>  -
E
; J

7-
E
5#

7-

FE
;  -
7


( 
 -
8&

 
-

( -
N

9+



  #
 
 $#%
& 


  # 

# )
  '
6
#
 
 

   '7



994 Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996


 
 #(  

7-
??E
" (-
E
<66-
N  -
;#((

8# -

??E
 ( -

 
 
 $#%
& 

('
 
# )
( 
#


 
 
%

'
# 
(

( + '

-
6
(

66# 

 %
#
 
'# 



 +
6 

6K
%

 

 


5#

7-
F7


# 
 -

# 

  '
 
# )
( 
  


#& (  

J 
'
  



(



6


J6( 
67


     
N  #
 
6& (

+ %

 &#

# )
(  '#
   '7
 $#%

& 
J6( 
  

 
& 

 ( %
%6
( +
# 
(
7
5
 $#%

& 
J6( 
(

  %
&
(6 ( 

#
# %-


 #
66 


6E



 6 & 

( + '
6
 &# 

   '



  & 




( 7


A '


 
# 


# 
 # 

 #-


( %


  & 
  # 

( 7
5-
( + '
 $#%
& 
J6( 
 $#
6 



#

6
& 

 


(' 

 
# 

&
 

 7


66
 
#-
 


 
 ( %
%6
& 
( %
&
(( 7

  
A& " > +-
97-#O #-
7-
2# -
G7-
<( -
787-
; ( +  ( -
G7-
 -
A7-
 !-
;7-
5 '#-
27
5# -
7<7

7
 $#%

 #  C
  
667
  
   

?H ?7



A%S#-
7

"' -
.7
D7
9

5+  K
 
+# 0
 + 0
 %
+ +  
@S  
& (
3/
&  

+ 7
 0
 :  "
  0 
;*-F M7



 +#-
<7
F7
A
% 
#
6#7
$
  
$ 
<+H-
F FD7



3%3+@!3+-
47-
A+'3 -
.7
"7-
2( -
97

.!+ -
.7
7
833  (

.S (
 K 
. /S) 
53+/
(# #

'/ +

'3  +
/ 0^( 07
% "

0"
 :  "
  " 
7-
H ?7



 -
7
A7
7
"(&  '

 

 $#%C

 

 
 7
=  
 
1  $

  
$ 0
-<?-

?M ?H7




2-
>7;7
F7
# 
6  
'  '
 $#% & 
&7
=  
 
#$" 
  
+-
HD D7



2( -
27 7
???7
A


& %
 #
% 7

=  
 
#$" 
   
<-
F FH7



9  + -
O7G7

N  -
7"7
M7
 &

 0
 
 
  $

 
M
77

P+C
;8  
+

(6 %7



8  -
7O7

+ '-
;7N7
??F7
G# '

(%
&C
A
 

& % & 
 '  7
   
  

$
=  -
7,-
M7



8 %-
<7
G7

A  -
7
7
   
1  $4
# "  

 
 
  
M
77
" ' 
 -
OC

  7



8& -
7<7

 -
7
7
< '#
(6 


 $#% & 
 
6' (

( 

# )
#
 

 7
  
   
-M? HF7



#%-
27
??7
$ 0
  
$  0$
> 7
"G
2#( 
G6#
7
"2
F?
D7



 -
27
??7
A

+

6 
+ '

 7
$  
  
1 &
<,-
7



 Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996 995

 -
A7

<# 
U77
7
5
& %

 
#  C
9#   


 % 
 #%7
  
   


-
D F7



 -
A7- -
G7

>6 -
;7
7
 '' (%# 66#  6    '+ 


 $#%
%6 & %C
A
 
#%7
?    
=  
 
  
   
+-H M7



 -A7

<#  -U77
?D7
5
 


& %

 
  'C
' 
6

 7
1 &
 
   

1  $
8+-
H7



 -
A7

<# 
U77
7
5
& %

 
#  C
9#   


 % 
 #%7
  
   


-
D F7



 -
A7

<#  -U77
7
5
& %

 
#  C
9#   


 % _
 #%7
  
   -

DF7



 -
A7- #(
57
<7


G7
7
A( 


<   '
"  ( 

 $#% 5%6
< & 

'


(%7
5 0
  " 
1  $
7-
? H7



 &+-
O7

>  -
O7
<77
   '

 6( 


 $#% & 
 
 (7
  $
?    

#   
 
$
5 0
   
 H7



O -
;7"7-8-
G7
O ( -
G7
7
 '  

6 


+%
 '
 
## #(


 7
  
 

1  $

   
,7-
 H7



<-
57

1+!+-
57
M7
; '
(
 

 $#% & 
 #


 
& %7
" 
   0
$ 

M-
 F7



<#  -
U77

5 (-
7
?H?7
;  '
&


  '
' 7

$
  
$ 
7F-
 7



;  -
>7
G7
7
$
 
 
> )! 
  

  
"   
 
" 



$ 0$
$  
!   0
   "7

; 
5-
; 
 
: %-
!( -
;  7




; J-
G7
N7-
 #(  -
7
7-
> K+-
O7
7-
9( -
7-
  %-
"7-
8-
G7

G -
57
57
7
 $#% & 
 



( 
' C
A( 


   '

#&
%(
(7
=  
 
1  $

  
$ 0
7,-
M D7



; %-
7<7-
8 -
;797-L>+7
G7

M7

 #


' 
(%
& %C
A( 

# 
   '7

=  
 
#$" 
   
-F-
D7





;-
7-
  (-
27

* -
:7
H7
#6 %
  '


6(

' 
 + '
+ C
A
 



 + '7
1  $

  
   
-<-
FM?7



%-
U7
G7-L
7
7
G  7
7
$
&
"@ 
$" 
 
  
$ 0
  0 "4

@" 
" 
 
> )! 

 07


A ""W"""
9 

"# 
  -
G 7



 -
7G7-
(-
27A797-
8  -
57

;> -
N7O7
??7
A
( #


#


( 
 '

   '

$# 
; <=7
A
A&-
;C
 
 

G 

(6
  %
5  '

<   '-
5
: %


;' 7



= '-
*7-O '-
87

P -
N7
7
( '
6
 )
 + '
+ 
&%
 $#% & 
(
J6( 7
(   

  
 
$   
  
+
-
F?HM7



1  %-
;7-A  -
27
# -
N797
# -
O7
L-
A7
7
"



   '
  ( C
5  '
   



 
 # 7
=  
 
#$" 
   
,-
D7



1  %-
;7-LA  -27
F7
A#



# 
 

   '
  ( 7
=  
 
#$" 
   

+M-
??7



G#& - 7
??M7
  
 
") 
 

  $


$
!  
 "  
 
!0 0
 0
 
  7

27-5(6 : %7



996 Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996

( -
57A7-
N-
7P7

9+ -
O7G7
7
# )
'
  

   '
 $#%
+ 

(_ & 
 

7
?    
  
 
=  
-
M7



%( +%-
O7- '-
<7-LN-
87
??7
A
 ( 




 $#% & 
  
##


M)

# 

6( 7
=  
 
1  $

  
$ 0
+<-
H7



(-
27
??M7

") 
 
 
  "
 !!

$
$ 0
 
  

> 

 " 

    

"$   07
27-5(6 : %7



4 -
47
7
% " 
: A "
" 

 
 A 
B:  "
" 
 "

CBDE "
   
B:  
!A F F


"    
 P3++
< 
5!7
A +  C
6
` 
9
 ( 
" 337



5  -
7-L
>##-
;7
M7
5


 $#% & 
   '
66 

 
# 

 (
( 7
 G
 :  "

E
  0 
-,-
H FD7



5& -
>7
??7
G 

 
& %
C

6##

&
$# 



(6
   '7
$  
  

 
2$"  
;
D7



5& -
>7

8 '-
O7O7?DH7
N 
 66 

'

 
 (T
=  
 
# "
  
,;M-
F? FM7



5# -
7<-
 -
77-5 -
77

 '-
797
F7
 '  '

 

 $#%
 #


( 

 

   '
% 
# 7
?    
=  
 
  
 
2$" 
   
--
F FMM7