You are on page 1of 6

GeneralDentalPractice

Simon Shepherd

Graham Ogden

Alcohol and the Dental Team:


Relevance, Risk, Role and
Responsibility
Abstract: An enquiry about alcohol use, whenever a patient presents for dental treatment, is now firmly established within the taking of
a social history. Dental professionals are well placed to provide relevant alcohol advice. Indeed, it is now embedded within the training
of undergraduates as required by the General Dental Council (GDC) in Preparing for Practice.1 Practitioners therefore need to be aware of
recent changes in alcohol guidelines commissioned by the UK Chief Medical Officers. This paper explores alcohol-related harm, screening
tools to facilitate an enquiry, and our roles and responsibilities for providing alcohol advice accepting the limited time available within the
dental appointment.
CPD/Clinical Relevance: Alcohol has both local and systemic effects. Understanding these effects, the recently updated guidelines and
available screening tools are important steps towards supporting dental professionals in the provision of alcohol-related advice.
Dent Update 2017; 44: 495-501

A greater recognition of the adverse about the lifestyle risk factors of alcohol domestic violence as well as road traffic
effects of alcohol, both locally (on the and tobacco is their potential role in the accidents.
oral cavity) and systemically, has helped development of various oral diseases, It is important to note that
heighten the importance of asking dental not least that of oral cancer. many people who are at risk of alcohol-
patients alcohol-relevant questions. As It is important to note that related harms may not attend other
such, recording alcohol intake is now firmly this approach focuses on a small and (by health professionals such as their own
embedded within the taking of a social comparison with other alcohol-related medical practitioner. Evidence suggests
history. harms) relatively rare disease. Although, that approximately 90% of the population
One important reason for asking as dental health professionals, the oral in Scotland are registered with a dentist,
cavity is our natural environment, under with 74% of those having attended in
the more encompassing scope of health the past 2 years.2 Dentists are therefore
professionals we hold the responsibility health professionals well placed to deliver
Simon Shepherd, BDS, MDSc, MFDS for understanding and delivering alcohol sensible alcohol advice to their patients.
RCS(Ed), RCPS(Glasg), Clinical Lecturer/ advice related to its broader effects too. Alcohol-related risk is,
StR in Oral Surgery University of Dundee As such, our awareness should extend however, not easily determined and often
and Graham Ogden, BDS, MDSc, PhD, to its link to cancers of the larynx, begs the obvious; what do patients think?
FDS RCPS(Glasg) FDS RCS(Ed), FHEA, phayrnx, breast, liver and colorectal Which question or questions should
FRSA, Professor of Oral Surgery and Head cancer. There is also emerging evidence we ask in order to identify a patient
of the Division of Oral and Maxillofacial for an association with skin, pancreas, potentially at risk of alcohol-related harm
Clinical Sciences at the University of stomach, lung, gallbladder cancer, not accurately? How should we approach
Dundee; Dean of the Dental Faculty to mention the role alcohol plays in the the subject? What makes an alcohol
of the Royal College of Physicians and development of liver disease, mental history difficult compared to tobacco for
Surgeons, Glasgow. health probelms, interpersonal and example?
June 2017 DentalUpdate 495
© MA Healthcare Ltd. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 144.082.238.225 on December 29, 2017.
Use for licensed purposes only. No other uses without permission. All rights reserved.
GeneralDentalPractice

Patient-centred factors levels of alcohol that were actually sold. 3. Professionalism; and
When we enquire about They discovered the equivalent of a 40% 4. Management/Leadership.
tobacco use, the patient usually under-reporting of what people say they Arguably, the taking of an
understands his/her relative exposure. drink in a typical week compared with accurate alcohol history may impact upon
Frequency and amount tends not to alcohol sales. That is, what is declared in all four areas. However, some examples
fluctuate greatly but other variables, such an official capacity (for example when that serve to illustrate this include the
as whether they roll their own cigarettes or completing a social history) might be following. Under the Communication
use a filter, are implicated. In general, the inhibited by preconceived expectations or domain (which applies equally to dentists,
patient has no vested interest in not telling societal norms and so result in moderate dental therapists and dental hygienists),
the truth, and each day is fairly consistent; estimates, whilst in social gatherings and Section 3.1:
they smoke because of their addiction, in the presence of peer pressure those ‘Communicate appropriately
which in turn drives the frequency of use. norms might act in the reverse (actually … when discussing issues such as alcohol
However, patients may believe increasing consumption). consumption.’
that there is indeed little relevance in Or under the Clinical domain
linking their alcohol consumption to a Dentist-centred factors in Section 1.10.7 (for dentists) which is
dental visit. This represents the first major indicative of involvement beyond the
Several factors may influence
hurdle we need to overcome, that is, to confines of the oral cavity that dentists on
a dentist's approach to the ‘alcohol’
highlight to patients the following: graduation should be able to:
question. Topics mandated for regular
1. Alcohol consumption does have an ‘Evaluate the health risks of
CPD update (such as oral cancer) will
impact on oral health, most notably as a alcohol on oral and general health and
furnish the dentist with information
risk factor for oral cancer; and provide appropriate advice and support.’
about risk factors such as alcohol but,
2. Dentists and dental care professionals For dental hygienists and dental
unfortunately, factors persist in preventing
are primarily healthcare professionals therapists this falls within Section 1.10.6 as:
engagement by dental professionals. The
who, although specializing in the oral ‘…providing appropriate advice,
barriers have been previously explained
cavity, have a broader skill set and a referral and support.’
and reported,5,6 and are closely entwined
wider responsibility for the health of their The directive is clear. Dental
with dentists’ attitudes to alcohol, beliefs
patients. Their advice may reasonably professionals should be involved in
about a dentist’s role in delivering risk
extend beyond the effects on the oral assessing risk and delivering appropriate
advice, the perceived relevance (or lack of )
cavity. and relevant risk advice. However, in
to dentistry by both dentist and patient,
For patients to give an accurate the ever-changing world of health risk
concerns about negative consequences,
alcohol record they need to engage with assessment, how is it best to achieve that
lack of confidence and potential
and what currently represents someone ‘at
difficult mental acrobatics. That is to recall embarrassment.
risk’?
the different levels of consumption over These barriers can make it
time, days in a week that they take an difficult to engage but they do not absolve
alcoholic drink, types of drink, volumes responsibility for doing so. Reports from The updated national
of each and also to know the alcohol GDC Fitness to Practice hearings have guidelines on alcohol use
content of each drink, which may vary included critical accounts of dentists within the UK
widely. Thus there are a number of reasons either not delivering or not recording In 2016, the Chief Medical
why the patient may be unable to give the delivery of risk advice (because if it’s Officer (CMO) published revised guidelines
an accurate response to the question; not recorded it’s assumed that it hasn’t on alcohol intake for men and women in
‘How much alcohol do you drink in a typical been addressed), whether the patient the UK. The new document entitled UK
week?’. Adverse influences on accuracy of may admit to the use of relevant risk Chief Medical Officer's Alcohol Guidelines
response may include uncertainty over factors for oral cancer or not. As such Review. Summary of the proposed new
volume or alcohol content consumed, reasonable conditions have been imposed guidelines7 replaces the previous report
fluctuating frequency of consumption, on those failing to do so, including entitled Sensible Drinking8 which was
memory fade, the potentially sensitive personal development plans for the published over 20 years ago in 1995.8
nature of the subject, fear of being implementation of tobacco cessation At that time, the panel had largely
labelled with a drink problem or failure and alcohol moderation advice. Indeed, concentrated on the effects of alcohol on
to appreciate the relevance to the dental this is now thoroughly embedded in the the body, especially the liver. Given the
setting. GDC training standards of our dental passage of time, much more is now known
That patients tend to undergraduate colleagues, in the evolution about the influences of alcohol, not just on
underreport their alcohol intake is perhaps from The First Five Years to Preparing for health, but also on society. To that end two
demonstrated best by the work of Boniface Practice. The skills required on graduation workstreams were commissioned by the
and Shelton.3 They compared what now fall into four core domains of: CMO in 2012. One workstream aimed to
people reported they drank according 1. Clinical; study the evidence base regarding health
to the General Lifestyle Survey4 with the 2. Communication; and the other to consider behavioural
496 DentalUpdate June 2017
© MA Healthcare Ltd. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 144.082.238.225 on December 29, 2017.
Use for licensed purposes only. No other uses without permission. All rights reserved.
GeneralDentalPractice

Figure 1. Descriptive illustration of the representative volumes of a unit of alcohol.10

issues. Their report concluded that there men and 14 units/week for women). Now perhaps surprising to learn that this is not a
was no evidence to suggest that the it is ‘advice’ rather than a ‘safe limit’ not to universal ‘currency’, with the definition of a
alcohol limit should be raised for women exceed 14 units/week and no more than 2 unit of alcohol varying widely throughout
(largely because of the strong link that had units/day for both men and women. the world (Canada – 14g, Austria – 20g).
emerged from the Million Women Woman Not surprisingly, the message In the UK, the number of units of alcohol
Study and since confirmed by others, of for those women who are pregnant is within a drink can be calculated by
a link between alcohol intake and breast ‘don’t drink alcohol’. multiplying the volume of the drink by
cancer.)9 Rather, they concluded that the In dentistry, the increasing alcohol concentration and dividing by
guidelines for men should be reduced number of oral cancers reported, and their 1000. For example; a pint of beer (568 ml)
to that equivalent to the women (down continued association with alcohol (and of 4.5% strength equates to approximately
from an average of 3 units/day and 21 tobacco) makes for a compelling case 2.5 units of alcohol.
units/week to 2 units/day or 14 units/ to moderate alcohol consumption. The
week). This was in part due to a fear of Scottish Government passed legislation Volume x ABV% 568 ml x 4.5% = 2.5 units
mixed messages, not least arising from the for bringing in 50p Minimum Unit Price 1000 1000
previous advice that, although 3 units was for alcohol sales in Scotland in 2012.
a so-called safe daily maximum for men, However, the drinks industry continues This information is often
they could (in any one occasion) drink up to challenge the rulings that have been revealed on the label of the bottle being
to 4 units, as long as they remained at or made in Scottish, European and British consumed. Otherwise (particularly for sales
under 21 units for the total consumed in courts. At the time of writing, this has in licensed premises) this information is
that week. Some chose to misinterpret this still not been resolved. However, all pub perhaps more easily calculated by the use
as 28 units (4 x 7 days), ignoring the 21 measures are sold above the 50p/unit of of a smartphone App on a mobile phone,
unit weekly level. alcohol. It is argued that access to cheap for example the Mydrinkaware version on
Another consideration within alcohol (mainly cider, but also vodka) is the Drinkaware website. This also has the
this reduction from 21 units to 14 units wrecking lives and could be reduced if advantage of being able to track one’s own
was the modelling exercise carried out cost was inflated. intake over the course of time.
by the Sheffield group reported within In terms of obtaining an
the CMO’s guideline7 and a decision to accurate response to the alcohol history
align the ‘safe’ level to an acceptance of a Assessing how much alcohol is question, pictorial aids that illustrate what
1% lifetime risk of mortality from alcohol. in a drink a unit is or the number of units in a typical
Furthermore, the behavioural elements Regardless of whether we drink, for example a standard pub measure
played into this, such as the possibility of ourselves drink alcohol, it is important glass of wine, can be helpful (Figure 1).10
being killed in alcohol-fuelled violence or to understand how alcohol intake is On average, a pint (4.5%) of beer will
road traffic accidents. They also decided measured, so that we can advise our equate to 2.5 units, a large (175 ml) glass
to emphasize that there is no safe level for patients appropriately. In the UK, one of wine (13.5%) is approximately 2.3 units,
alcohol intake (previously reported safe unit of alcohol is equivalent to 8 g of whilst a pub measure of a spirit (such as
levels were at or below 21 units/week for pure alcohol (or 10 ml by volume). It is whiskey) 1 unit.
June 2017 DentalUpdate 497
© MA Healthcare Ltd. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 144.082.238.225 on December 29, 2017.
Use for licensed purposes only. No other uses without permission. All rights reserved.
GeneralDentalPractice

NHS Health Scotland Alcohol at risk. Screening provides a simple way from question 3 of AUDIT. Instead of; How
and Oral Health briefing paper to achieve this and there are plenty of often do you have more than 6 drinks on
NHS Health Scotland published, screening tools available. one occasion? the modification is gender-
in 2012, the Alcohol and Oral Health: Some, although with specific and asks; How often do you have 8
Understanding Risk, Raising Awareness potential utility, exclude themselves units (for a Man)/6 units (for a Women) or
and Giving Advice (NHS HSAOH).11 The automatically for reasons of invasiveness more on one occasion? (Table 2).
document outlined the scale of the alcohol (blood and breath tests), lack of brevity The advantage of the
problem in Scotland, clarifying the link (the Michigan Alcohol Screening Test or modification is that, by delivering this
between alcohol and oral health. MAST for example is over 20 questions question first, over 50% of people will be
As part of Scotland’s alcohol long) or failure to capture immediately classified using that question alone. If they
strategy at the time, and under the relevant information. One such example, answer either Weekly or Daily or Almost
which was successful but has now been Daily (they will score 3 and breach the
umbrella of Changing Scotland’s Relationship
superseded, is the CAGE screening tool. risk threshold) and warrant advice. If the
with Alcohol: A Framework for Action
The CAGE broadly asked: Have you felt the individual does not respond with either
document,12 the aim was to support the
need to Cut down on your drinking? Do of those answers then the subsequent
delivery of alcohol brief interventions (ABI)
you feel Annoyed by people complaining questions are asked and a composite
in the key areas of antenatal, A&E and
about your drinking? Do you ever feel Guilty score of 3 from the remaining questions
primary care and crucially develop delivery
about your drinking? Do you ever drink would indicate likely hazardous or harmful
in a wider range of settings, including
an Eye-opener in the morning? Despite drinking (Table 3).16,17 This represents a
dentistry.
the enormous affinity for the test, which quick and easy way readily to identify
An ABI, in its briefest and
may be in part due to its ease of recall, many patients with potential alcohol
broadest definition, might be defined as:
it is recognized that it does not gather problems.
information on quantity, frequency or
‘Practices that aim to identify
pattern of drinking.
a real or potential alcohol problem and The new UK guidance − an
A more robust test is the
motivate an individual to do something about opportunity?
Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test
it.’13 An alternative question, or
or AUDIT. This test, administered either
The NHS HSAOH paper advised verbally or in written form, is a 10-item maybe in combination with the FAST
that, as healthcare practitioners, dentists validated (using a large multinational (or the first question of FAST) would be
have an important role in facilitating the sample), sensitive and specific instrument to query a patient’s weekly guideline
recognition of lifestyle risk factors in both for identifying problem drinking (Table amounts according to the CMO report.
individuals and communities and that they 1). Each item of the AUDIT is scored on Two real advantages may be seen by
can support improvements in health and a 5-point scale from 0−4, except for the adopting this approach. First, these
wellbeing by informing patients of those last two questions for which there are weekly amounts are national government
health risk factors. just three options each scored as 0, 2 and guidance, or in other words, we can
There is good evidence of the 4. The sum of all 10-items gives a global suggest that there is an external influence
effectiveness of ABIs in primary care for score; the greater the score the more likely advising these figures (the dentist does
moderating the recipients drinking with alcohol-related harm is present, with the not feel encumbered with the burden
a durable effect lasting potentially 12 generally accepted risk thresholds of: or responsibility of making a judgement
months,14 and that they may even reduce  <8 is considered low risk; about an individual‘s drinking). Secondly,
alcohol-related mortality.15 Importantly,  8−15 the individual is likely consuming the new guidance may represent an
although a strong evidence base is lacking, to hazardous levels; excellent opportunity for the dental team
screening alone may initiate some change  16−19 represents harmful drinking; and to enter into discussions, gently engage
and simple advice may be as effective as  ≥20 is probably representative of and raise awareness. For example:
longer interventions. That is, identifying the dependent use and would warrant referral
problem and straightforward advice may to specialist services. ‘I’ve noticed from your social
help patients towards moderate drinking. For reasons of brevity, various history questionnaire that you are drinking
Recent research has been suggestive that, shorter forms have been proposed, ‘x’. Were you aware that the guidance on
even an ultra-brief (30 second) discussion including the exploration of a single how much we drink has recently changed?’
by doctors about obesity may result in defining question which retains practical
behaviour change. value for identifying problem drinking.
Scotland has gravitated Conclusion
towards the FAST – Fast Alcohol Screening It is clear that dental clinicians
How to recognize those who Test. The FAST is a short version using four have a professional duty to enquire
need advice questions from the AUDIT with a score >3 about alcohol intake. Our regulator has
Advice delivery is obviously indicative of a potential alcohol problem. embedded the need to appreciate (and
contingent upon identifying those who are The first question of FAST is modified communicate) the health effects of
498 DentalUpdate June 2017
© MA Healthcare Ltd. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 144.082.238.225 on December 29, 2017.
Use for licensed purposes only. No other uses without permission. All rights reserved.
GeneralDentalPractice

Questions 0 1 2 3 4
1. How often do you have Monthly or 2−4 times a 2−3 times a
Never 4 or more times a week
a drink containing alcohol? less month week

2. How many drinks containing alcohol


do you have on a typical day when you 1 or 2 3 or 4 5 or 6 7 to 9 10 or more
are drinking?

3. How often do you have six or more Less than


Never Monthly Weekly Daily or almost daily
drinks on one occasion? monthly

4. How often during the last year have


Less than
you found that you were not able to stop Never Monthly Weekly Daily or almost daily
monthly
drinking once you had started?

5. How often during the last


year have you failed to do what was Less than
Never Monthly Weekly Daily or almost daily
normally expected of you because of monthly
drinking?

6. How often during the last year have


you needed a first drink in the morning Less than
Never Monthly Weekly Daily or almost daily
to get yourself going after a heavy monthly
drinking session?

7. How often during the last year have


Less than
you had a feeling of guilt or remorse Never Monthly Weekly Daily or almost daily
monthly
after drinking?
8. How often during the last year have
you been unable to remember what Less than
Never Monthly Weekly Daily or almost daily
happened the night before because of monthly
your drinking?

Yes, but not


9. Have you or someone else been
No in the last Yes, during the last year
injured because of your drinking?
year

10. Has a relative, friend, doctor, or other


Yes, but not
healthcare worker been concerned
No in the last Yes, during the last year
about your drinking or suggested you
year
cut down?

Total
Table 1. The Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT): self-report version.

alcohol, not only on the oral cavity but on potentially malignant lesions per month)18 member of the Medical Advisory Panel for
general wellbeing. Whilst not every oral should encourage us all to act on the Drinkaware.
cancer is associated with the use of alcohol, results of such an enquiry.
or indeed tobacco, the increasing number References
of oral cancers (coupled with the estimation Disclosures 1. General Dental Council. Dental Team
that every dentist sees, on average, two Professor Graham Ogden is a Learning Outcomes. Preparing for
500 DentalUpdate June 2017
© MA Healthcare Ltd. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 144.082.238.225 on December 29, 2017.
Use for licensed purposes only. No other uses without permission. All rights reserved.
GeneralDentalPractice

1. How often do you have 8 units (for a Man)/6 units (for a Women) or more on one occasion?
Never Less than Monthly Monthly Weekly Daily or Almost Daily
2. How often during the last year have you been unable to remember?
Never Less than Monthly Monthly Weekly Daily or Almost Daily
3. How often during the last year have you failed to do what was normally expected of you because you had been drinking?
Never Less than Monthly Monthly Weekly Daily or Almost Daily
4. In the last year, has a relative, friend, doctor or health worker been concerned about your drinking or suggested that you cut down?
No Yes, on one occasion Yes, on more than one occasion
Scoring
The FAST is scored according to response with 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 representing; Never, Less than monthly, Monthly, Weekly and Daily or almost Daily,
respectively. The last question is scored as 0, 2, 4 for No, Yes on one occasion and Yes on more than one occasion, respectively. A score is 0, 1 or
2 on the first question prompts continuation with the next three questions. A score is 3 or 4 on the first question or an overall total score of 3
or more is FAST positive and warrants the delivery of alcohol advice. In the dental setting simply undertaking the FAST screening process and
raising awareness of consumption may be sufficient to elicit change.

Table 2. Fast Alcohol Screening Test (FAST).

The distinction between the different drinking patterns is an important one as it guides us as to who should receive advice. Those who
are drinking to Hazardous or Harmful levels may benefit from alcohol-related health advice in primary care. Those who are classified as
dependent drinkers should remain the preserve of specialist alcohol services and an appropriate referral made.
Harmful drinking: A pattern of alcohol consumption that is causing mental or physical damage.
Hazardous drinking: A pattern of alcohol consumption that increases someone’s risk of harm. Some would limit this definition to the physical
or mental health consequences (as in harmful use). Others would include the social consequences.
Alcohol dependence: A cluster of behavioural, cognitive and physiological factors that typically include a strong desire to drink alcohol and
difficulties in controlling its use. Someone who is alcohol-dependent may persist in drinking, despite harmful consequences. They will also give
alcohol a higher priority than other activities and obligations.
Table 3. Drinking definitions and harm.

Practice (revised 2015). Review. Summary of the proposed new Care. Geneva: World Health Organization,
2. ISD publications. Dental Statistics – guidelines. January 2016. 2001.
Registration and Participation. Update 8. Department of Health. Sensible Drinking: 14. Kaner EFS, Beyer F, Dickinson HO,
of statistics as at 30 September 2014. Report of an Inter-departmental Working Beyer FR, Campbell F, Schlesinger C
Edinburgh NHS National Services Group. Great Britain, DoH, 1995. et al. Effectiveness of brief alcohol
Scotland National Statistics, 2015. 9. Allen NE, Beral V, Casabonne D, Kan SW, interventions in primary care populations
3. Boniface S, Shelton N. How is alcohol Reeves GK, Brown A et al. Moderate (Review). Cochrane Database Syst Rev
consumption affected if we account alcohol intake and cancer incidence in 2009 (CD004148).
for under-reporting? A hypothetical women. J Natl Cancer Inst 2009; 101: 15. Cuijpers P, Riper H, Lemmers L. The
scenario. Eur J Public Health 2013; 23: 296−305. effects on mortality of brief interventions
1076−1081. 10. Drinkaware. What is an alcohol unit?
for problem drinking: a meta-analysis.
4. Office for National Statistics. General 2016 [Available from: https://www.
Addiction 2004; 99: 839−845.
Lifestyle Survey 2009. Basingstoke: drinkaware.co.uk/alcohol-facts/
16. NICE. Alcohol-use Disorders: Prevention.
Palgrave Macmillan, 2011. alcoholic-drinks-units/what-is-an-
Public health guideline [PH24]. National
5. Shepherd S, Young L, Clarkson JE, Bonetti alcohol-unit/
Institute for Health and Care Excellence,
D, Ogden GR. General dental practitioner 11. NHS Health Scotland. Alcohol and Oral
views on providing alcohol related health Health: Understanding Risk, Raising 2010.
advice; an exploratory study. Br Dent J Awareness and Giving Advice. NHS Health 17. Institute for Alcohol Studies. A Good
2010; 208: E13; discussion 304−305. Scotland, 2012. Measure: Units and Drinking Guideline.
6. Shepherd S, Bonnetti D, Clarkson JE, 12. The Scottish Government. Changing IAS, 2013 (Available from: http://www.
Ogden GR, Young L. Current practices Scotland’s Relationship with Alcohol: A ias.org.uk/uploads/pdf/Consumption
and intention to provide alcohol-related Framework for Action. Edinburgh: Scottish docs/Alcohol consumption factsheet
health advice in primary dental care. Br Government, 2009. August 2013.pdf
Dent J 2011; 211: E14. 13. Babor TF, Higgins-Biddle JC. Brief 18. Ogden GR, Scully C, Warnakulasuriya S,
7. Department of Health. UK Chief Intervention for Hazardous and Harmful Speight P. Oral cancer: two cancer cases
Medical Officer's Alcohol Guidelines Drinking: A Manual for Use in Primary in a career? Br Dent J 2015; 218: 439.
June 2017 DentalUpdate 501
© MA Healthcare Ltd. Downloaded from magonlinelibrary.com by 144.082.238.225 on December 29, 2017.
Use for licensed purposes only. No other uses without permission. All rights reserved.

You might also like