Professional Documents
Culture Documents
437-444
Vocational Program, University of Indonesia, Kukusan Beji Kota Depok, 2 Human and Health Sciences
1
College,Swansea University, UK, Singleton Park, Swansea, Wales SA2 8PP, 3 Faculty of Communication
Science,Padjadjaran University, Jl. Raya Bandung Sumedang Km 21 Jatinangor, 4 Vocational Program, Univer-
sity of Indonesia, Kukusan Beji Kota Depok 5Communication Department, Kwik Kian Gie School of Business, Jl.
Yos Sudarso Kav 87, Sunter Jakarta
email: 1 deviers@vokasi.ui.ac.id 2 f.e.verity@swansea.ac.uk 3 deddy.mulyana@unpad.ac.id 4 elsa@vokasi.ui.ac.id 5 dhita@kwikkiangie.
ac.id
Received: July 16, 2017, Revision: Oktober 15, 2017, Accepted: December 13, 2017
Print ISSN: 0215-8175; Online ISSN: 2303-2499. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.29313
Accredited B based on the decree No.040/P/2014, valid on February, 18, 2014 until February, 18, 2019. Indexed by DOAJ, Sinta, IPI
in West Java. Some studies have dealt with having intensive interpersonal communication
the effect of certain social (communication) with the researchers they are willing to
strategies on patient health. Among others, complete the questionnaires and even then,
Hatta (2013) examined the effect of group only when facilitated with assistance from the
counseling on the self-regulation of drug researchers.
(ecstasy) users with the results that the group
The questions investigated in this
counseling contributed to the self-regulation
research are; a) exploring the satisfaction
of the ecstasy users. Yusuf and Setianto
of families who had children suffering from
(2013) examined the effect of ‘Cognitive
cancer, with the performance of therapeutic
Behavior Therapy’ on the decrease of stress
communication of health staff; and b) gaining
intensity among patients suffering from Low
insights into aspects of dissatisfaction with
Back Pain (LBP) in ‘X’ Hospital in Bandung.
therapeutic communication and barriers when
They found that the Cognitive Behavior
communicating with health staff (nurses). The
Therapy decreased the degree of the stress
research total sample (N) was 23 families
among the LBP patients.
who had children undergoing treatment in
In this context, our study is intended to a public hospital in Jakarta in the period
fill in the scarcity of research on communication December 2014 to March 2015. The patients
between medical providers and patient. themselves were those who occupied the beds
Although this study tries to find out the in the hospital at the time of the study. The
satisfaction of therapeutic communication as majority of the respondents were mothers
felt by families whose children suffer from (though at times they included fathers),
cancer, it may lead to further studies that grandmothers, and even aunt. The median
involve other families whose members suffer age was 33 years as it can be seen in Tables
from other ailments, such as tuberculosis, 1 and 2 below. Ethics approval was obtained
heart attack, psychological disturbance, and by the Health Research Ethics Committee of
general diseases. the participating hospital. All the respondents
gave informed consent to participate in the
The purpose of this study is to investigate
research.
whether there is a connection between
therapeutic communication employed by the
medical staff (nurses) and the satisfaction
Table 1. Distribution of Respondents
of cancer patients’ families. It also aims according to Age (N= 23)
to explore aspects of dissatisfaction with
therapeutic communication as employed Variable Mean Median SD Min Max
by the medical staff. It is expected that Age 35,04 33,00 9,79 19,00 54,00
the findings of this research will give some
Source: Research Results
feedback to the medical staff to improve their
services for children suffering from cancer
Table 2. Characteristics of
as well as their families.
Respondents by Gender and Occupation
(N= 23)
Level of Performance
Therapeutic Communication
Never Sometimes Frequent Always
Techniques
n % n % n % n %
Greetings 5 21,7 8 34,8 10 43,5
Calling the child’s name 2 8,7 5 21,7 16 69,6
Using a friendly tone 1 4,3 7 30,4 15 65,2
Listening with full attention 2 8,7 10 43,5 11 47,8
Explaining their actions 3 13,0 11 47,8 9 39,1
Explaining the target of their actions 1 4,3 3 13,0 9 39,1
Explaining the effect of their actions 7 30,4 8 34,8 8 34,8
Giving the opportunity to families to 1 4,3 9 39,1 9 39,1 4 17,4
ask
Informing the family of the
developments in the condition of their 3 13,0 1 13,0 9 39,1 8 34,8
childs health
Providing clarification 1 4,3 6 26,1 10 43,5 6 26,1
Providing an opportunity for the family
to state their opinion in connection with
their child’s treatment 3 13,0 4 17,4 11 47,8 5 21,7
Not forcing their own opinions 1 4,3 1 4,3 13 56,5 8 34,8
Allowing the family time to decide
about continuing their childs treatment
3 13,0 1 4,3 11 47,8 8 34,8
Table 5
Distribution of Respondents according to Family Satisfaction based on
Communication Techniques (N=23)
Level of Performance
Less than Very
Communication Techniques Dissatisfied Satisfied
Satisfied Satisfied
n % n % n % n %
Friendly 1 4,3 20 87,0 2 8,7
Understand able language 1 4,3 18 78,3 4 17,4
Asked about child’s progress everyday 1 4,3 16 69,6 6 26,1
Asked how the child was feeling 3 13,0 15 65,2 5 21,7
Listened with full attention to complaints 1 4,3 17 73,9 5 21,7
Responded patiently to complaints 1 4,3 16 69,6 6 26,1
Gave encouragement so that hope was not 1 4,3 3 13,0 16 69,6 3 13,0
lost during treatment
Gave clear information about reason and aim 1 4,3 15 65,2 7 30,4
of teatment
Gave clear information about results/side 4 17,4 18 78,3 1 4,3
effect softreatment
Remind a child politely when he/she didn’t 21 91,3 2 8,7
obey rules
Provide honest praise when families do 2 8,7 19 82,6 2 8,7
something to help a child’s recovery
Involve the family intreatment 2 8,7 17 73,9 4 17,4
Involve family in decision making 2 8,7 18 78,3 3 13,0
Respect family decisions regarding medication 2 8,7 18 78,3 3 13,0
Collaborate with medical team regarding 1 4,3 1 4,3 14 60,9 7 30,4
patient medication
Variable N Percentage
Family Satisfaction
Less than satisfied (score<45) 10 43,5
Satisfied (score≥ 45) 13 56,5
Performance of Therapeutic Communication
Low performance (score<41) 10 43,5
Good performance(score≥ 41) 13 56,5
Source: Research Results
Family Satisfaction
Performance of Therapeutic Less than Total Odds
Satisfied P Value
Communication Satisfied Ratio
n % n % N %
Low 8 80,0 2 20,0 10 100,0 22 0,003
Good 2 15,4 11 84,6 13 100,0
Total 10 43,5 13 56,5 23 100,0
respondents, was generally shown that Charles, C., Amiram, G. & Whelan, T.
therapeutic communication by medical staff (2004). “Decision Making in the Physician-
(nurses) was well employed, and this effective Patient Encounter: Revisiting the Shared
therapeutic communication is connected with Treatment Decision-Making Model.” In
the satisfaction of the majority of patients’ Michael Bury & Jonathan Gabe, eds. The
families. Sociology of Health and Illness: A Reader.
London: Routledge.
This study has focused on the
Davis, J., Foley, A., Crigger, N., & Brannigan,
individual and social aspects of therapeutic
M.C. (2008). “Healthcare and Listening: A
communication. There are other technical,
Relationship for Caring.” The International
structural and even cultural aspects of
Journal of Listening 22:168-175.
therapeutic communication that can be further
Dida, S. (2011). Pengaruh Optimalisasi
investigated in the future, some of which
Komunikasi Kesehatan pada Pusat
can be explored by alternative theoretical
Pelayanan Kesehatan Dasar terhadap
perspectives and research methods such as
Peningkatan Derajat Kesehatan Anak Usia
phenomenology, symbolic interactionism,
Dini. Unpublished Doctoral Disssertation
and ethnography that will make the research
Padjadjaran University.
more challenging, as it may take more time
Hadisiwi, P. (2011). Konstruksi Makna
to collect rich qualitative data. Based on the
Penyandang Filariasis: Studi Fenomenologi
objective-positivist perspective, research
tentang Konstruksi Makna Penyandang
involving a much larger sample will also be
Filariasis dalam Komunikasi Risiko
beneficial to make some generalizations that
Kesehatan di Kabupaten Bandung.
may be applied by the healthcare providers to
Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation
better serve patients and their families in the
Padjadjaran University.
real world. More specific studies comparing
Hafiar, H. (2012). Cacat dan Prestasi Melalui
different groups of medical providers such
Pengalaman Komunikasi Atlet Penyandang
as general practitioners, medical specialists,
Cacat: Studi Fenomenologi Mengenai
and nurses in terms of their therapeutic
Konstruksi Makna Kecacatan dan
communication effectiveness are also worth
Status sebagai Atlet Berprestasi Melalui
investigating.
Pengalaman Komunikasi Atlet Penyandang
In the meantime, workshops should Cacat Berprestasi di Bandung. Unpublished
be given to both medical doctors and nurses D o c t o ra l D i s s e r t a t i o n Pa d j a d j a ra n
to enhance their communication skills to University.
deal with patients and their families, so that Eggly, S., Abrecht, T.L, Kelly, K., Prigerson,,
they can understand that the satisfaction of H.G. Sheldon, L.K., & Studts, J. (2009).
patients and their families depend not only “The Role of the Clinician in Cancer
on their medical expertise but also on their Clinical Communication.” Journal of Health
quality of communication with the clients. Communication 14:66-75.
Fa t r i a n s a r i , A . ( 2 0 1 2 ) . T h e r a p e u t i c
Communication Relationships of Child
REFERENCES Nurses and Family Satisfaction Levels with
Children under Hospitalization at Al-Ihsan
Anindhita, W. (2017). “The Colonial Project” of
General Hospital of West Java Province.
Mentally Ill Patients: A Phenomenological
Depok: Unpublished Thesis, Faculty of
Study of Communication between Nurses
Nursing - University of Indonesia.
and Mentally Ill Patients in a Jakarta
Hatta, M.I. (2013). “Pengaruh ‘Group
Social Rehabilitation Center. Unpublished
Counselling’ terhadap ‘Self-Regulation”
D o c t o ra l D i s s e r t a t i o n Pa d j a d j a ra n
Pecandu Napza pada Jurnalis Televisi X.”
University.
Mimbar 29 (1):57-68)
Bartz, C. C. (1986). Nurse-patient
Hugman, B. (2009). Healthcare Communication.
Communication during Critical Illness
Grayslake, IL.: Pharmaceutical Press.
Events (Order No. 8623822). Available
Iba, L. (2005). Hubungan antara Komunikasi
from ProQuest Dissertations & Theses
dari Paramedis dengan Sikap Pasien
Global. (303476710). Retrieved from
Rawat Inap Mengenai Layanan Perawatan:
http://search.proquest.com/docview/30
Studi pada Layanan Perawatan Medis
3476710?accountid=17242
Rumah Sakit Umum Daerah Propinsi
Berry, D.C. (2007). Health Communication:
(RSUP) Sulawesi Tenggara. Unpublished
Theory and Practice. Maidenhead,
Master’s Thesis Padjadjaran University.
Berkshire, UK: Open University Press.
Jacobalis, S. (1990). Menjaga Mutu Pelayanan Dominance and Digital Ethics in Indonesia:
Rumah Sakit. Jakarta: CitraWinduSatria. The Prita Case.” Health Sociology Review
J e r a n t , A . F. , M . M . v o n F r i e d e r i c h s - 25(3):300-311.doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.
Fitzwater,andM.Moore (2005). “Patients’ 1080/14461242.2015.1116021.
perceived b a rriers to active s e l f- Mulyana, D. (2016). Health and Therapeutic
managemen to chronic conditions.” Communication: An Intercultural
Patient Education and Counseling Perspective. Bandung: Rosda.
57(3):300-7. Rahmawati, D. (2017). Communication as the
Koerber, C. (2012). Family Communication Key of the Life Navigation of Online Game
Practices about Death in the Setting of Players: An Ethnographic Study of the
Pediatric malignancy relapse: A qualitative Online Game Players Life in Jabodetabek
study (Order No. 3539823). Available Cafes. Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation
from ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Padjadjaran University.
Global. (1101238697). Retrieved from Robinson, W. D., Carroll, J. S., & Watson,
http://search.proquest.com/docview/11 W. L. (2005). “Shared Experience
01238697?accountid=17242 Building around the Family Crucible of
Mallinger, J.B.,J.J.Griggs,C.G.Shields. (2005). Cancer.” Families, Systems, & Health
“Patient-centered Care and Breast 23(2), 131-147. Retrieved from http://
Cancer Survivors’ Satisfaction with search.proquest.com/docview/61443997
Information.”Patient Education and 5?accountid=17242
Counseling 57(3):342–9. Skalla,K.A.,M.Bakitas, C.T.Furstenberg,T.
Monterosso, L., & Kristjanson, L. J. (2008). Ahles,J.V.Henderson. ( 2004). “Patients’
“Supportive and Palliative Care Needs Need for Information about Cancer
of Families of Children who Die from Therapy.” OncologyNursing Forum
Cancer: An Australian Study.” Palliative 31(2):313–319.
Medicine 22(1):59-69.doi:http://dx.doi. Yusuf, U & Setianto, R.L.(2013) “Efektivitas
org/10.1177/0269216307084608 ‘Cognitive Behavior Therapy’ terhadap
Mulyana, D., & Verity, F. (2016). “Health Penurunan Derajat Stres.” Mimbar 29
C o n s u m e r Pa r t i c i p a t i o n , M e d i c a l (2):175-186.