Chapter 3- Decision making under uncertainty

Decision-Making and Decision Theory

The success or failure of individuals or organizations hinges significantly on making

timely, sound decisions. A decision-maker's ability to weigh viable courses of action,
anticipate their consequences, and establish effectiveness metrics is pivotal in identifying
the optimal choice.

Decision Theory meaning and practical applications:

Decision theory is a systematic and mathematical approach to decision-making that

involves assessing choices in uncertain situations. It provides a framework for analyzing
decisions by considering possible outcomes, probabilities, and the preferences of the
decision-maker. Here's how it's used in real life:

1. Business Strategy: Decision theory helps businesses evaluate different strategies,

such as product launches or market expansions, by considering potential
outcomes and risks in uncertain market conditions.

2. Investment and Finance: Investors use decision theory to assess investment

options by weighing potential returns against risks, considering various market
scenarios and their probabilities.

3. Healthcare: Doctors use decision theory to choose treatment plans by considering

potential outcomes and risks associated with different medical interventions,
especially when faced with uncertain diagnoses.

4. Public Policy: Governments apply decision theory in crafting policies,

considering multiple possible outcomes and their probabilities, to make informed
decisions that optimize social welfare.

5. Personal Decision-Making: Individuals use decision theory when making personal

choices, such as career decisions or major purchases, by evaluating potential
outcomes and risks.
In essence, decision theory provides a structured approach to decision-making in
situations where uncertainty plays a significant role, allowing individuals and
organizations to make more informed and rational choices.

Key Components of Decision Models

1. Decision Alternatives: These represent the finite options available to a decision-

maker at the point of decision-making.

2. Decision Analysis: This analytical approach involves comparing decision

alternatives based on expected outcomes.

3. States of Nature: Events or scenarios beyond a decision-maker's control, such as

economic conditions, weather, or political developments, fall under this category.

4. Payoff: A numeric value resulting from applying each possible combination of

decision alternatives and states of nature. These values are conditional due to the
unpredictability of states of nature and serve as a quantitative measure of
outcomes.

Decision-Making Process using Decision Theory

1. Problem Identification: Define and recognize the problem at hand.

2. Future Event Enumeration: List potential future events beyond control that
might occur.

3. Course of Action Identification: Identify all available courses of action.

4. Payoff Expression: Determine and express the payoffs resulting from each
combination of action and state of nature.

5. Decision Theory Model Application: Apply an appropriate decision theory

model to select the best course of action based on effectiveness criteria, aiming
for an optimal payoff.

Examples Illustrating Decision Theory

  Investment Scenario: A financial investor considering various investment
options (stocks, bonds, real estate) amid uncertain market conditions (bullish,
bearish, or stagnant) uses decision theory to select the investment yielding the
highest expected return.

 Manufacturing Decision: A manufacturing company, facing fluctuating raw

material prices and demand variations, utilizes decision theory to opt for
production strategies that minimize costs and maximize profits under different
market scenarios.

Decision Making under Uncertainty

1. Maximax Decision Rule:

 Objective: Aim for the best possible outcome, maximizing potential

profit.

 Example: Suppose you're considering various investment options. You

choose the one with the highest potential return, assuming the best-case
scenario for each investment.

2. Maximin Decision Rule:

 Objective: Ensure a guaranteed minimum gain.

 Example: When choosing between job offers, you pick the one with the
highest minimum salary, ensuring you won't earn less than a certain
amount.

3. Minimin Decision Rule:

 Objective: Aim for the least potential cost.

 Example: In selecting suppliers, you opt for the one offering the lowest
possible cost, assuming the best-case scenario in expenses.

4. Minimax Decision Rule (Minimax Regret Rule):

 Objective: Minimize potential regret or loss.

  Example: Imagine choosing an insurance plan. You select the one with
the lowest potential maximum loss, considering the worst-case scenario in
costs or payouts.

Each rule guides decision-making based on different criteria: maximizing gains, ensuring
minimum acceptable gains, minimizing costs, or minimizing potential regrets or losses.
They help individuals or businesses make choices in uncertain situations, considering the
best and worst potential outcomes for each decision alternative.

Abraham Wald was a mathematician known for his work in statistics, particularly in decision theory and
sequential analysis during World War II. The "Wald criterion" or "Wald's criterion" refers to a principle he
developed, often associated with decision-making under uncertainty.

In the context you mentioned, the criterion you're describing involves a decision-maker who takes a
pessimistic view of the future and anticipates the worst possible outcome. This approach seeks to minimize
potential losses or risks. In decision theory, Wald's criterion focuses on minimizing the maximum possible
loss (i.e., being conservative by considering the worst-case scenario).

For example, in statistical decision theory, Wald's minimax rule involves minimizing the maximum possible
loss that could occur. This principle is applied in various fields such as economics, engineering, and military
strategy, where decision-makers need to make choices in uncertain situations while considering potential
risks and losses.

Wald's contributions to statistical decision theory have had a significant impact on how decisions are made
under uncertainty, particularly in situations where the consequences of an adverse outcome are severe.

****************************