JCMM: POM: Module 1: Introduction to Management

The Hawthorne Effect: A Case Study on Elton Mayo's Theory of Management

Introduction:
Elton Mayo, an Australian psychologist, made significant contributions to the field
of management theory during the early 20th century. His research at the Hawthorne
Works of the Western Electric Company in Chicago led to the development of the
Hawthorne Effect and the Human Relations Movement. This case study examines
Mayo's theory of management through the lens of the Hawthorne experiments,
highlighting its impact on organizational behavior and management practices.

Background:
In the 1920s, scientific management principles dominated organizational thinking,
focusing on efficiency and productivity through strict control and supervision.
However, Mayo challenged these principles by emphasizing the importance of
human factors in the workplace. His research aimed to understand how social and
psychological factors influenced productivity and employee behavior.

Case Study:
At the Hawthorne Works, Mayo conducted a series of experiments from 1924 to
1932 to investigate the relationship between working conditions and productivity.
The initial experiments focused on the effects of lighting on worker productivity.
Contrary to expectations, changes in lighting conditions did not significantly affect
productivity. Instead, Mayo observed a consistent increase in productivity
regardless of whether the lighting was increased or decreased. This unexpected
finding led to further investigation into the social dynamics within the workplace.

Mayo and his colleagues shifted their focus to the social factors influencing
productivity, particularly the effects of group dynamics, supervision, and employee
morale. They found that workers' productivity increased when they received
attention from management and felt valued as part of a group. This phenomenon
became known as the Hawthorne Effect – the tendency for individuals to improve
their performance when they know they are being observed.

Furthermore, Mayo's research highlighted the importance of informal social

interactions among workers. He discovered that informal groups within the
pg. 1
JCMM: POM: Module 1: Introduction to Management

organization had a significant impact on employee behavior and attitudes towards

work. These findings challenged the traditional view of workers as rational
economic beings and emphasized the role of social relationships in shaping
organizational behavior.

Implications:
Mayo's theory of management revolutionized traditional approaches to
organizational management. By recognizing the significance of human factors, he
emphasized the need for managers to consider employees' social and psychological
needs in addition to task efficiency. The Hawthorne experiments paved the way for
the Human Relations Movement, which advocated for participative management,
employee empowerment, and a focus on employee well-being.

Organizations began to adopt more humanistic approaches to management,

prioritizing employee satisfaction, motivation, and job enrichment. Mayo's work
laid the foundation for modern organizational behavior theories, influencing
management practices such as team building, leadership development, and
organizational culture management.

Conclusion:
Elton Mayo's theory of management, as demonstrated through the Hawthorne
experiments, challenged conventional wisdom and reshaped our understanding of
organizational behavior. By emphasizing the importance of social and
psychological factors in the workplace, Mayo highlighted the need for a more
humanistic approach to management. His insights continue to inform
contemporary management practices, underscoring the enduring relevance of his
contributions to the field of management theory.

Questions:

1. What were the primary objectives of Elton Mayo's experiments at the

Hawthorne Works?
2. How did Mayo's findings challenge the principles of scientific management?
3. Describe the Hawthorne Effect and its implications for organizational
behavior.
pg. 2
JCMM: POM: Module 1: Introduction to Management

4. What role did social factors play in influencing productivity according to

Mayo's research?
5. How did Mayo's experiments contribute to the development of the Human
Relations Movement in management theory?
6. Discuss the significance of informal social interactions within the
workplace, as highlighted by Mayo's research.
7. In what ways did Mayo's findings impact management practices and
organizational behavior theories?

pg. 3