Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gabriel Prieto, John Verano, Ann Pollard Rowe, Feren Castillo, Luis Flores,
Julio Asencio, Alan Chachapoyas, Victor Campaña, Richard Sutter, Aleksalia
Isla, Khrystyne Tschinkel, Rachel Witt, Andres Shiguekawa, Jordi A. Rivera
Prince, Celeste Marie Gagnon, Carlos Avila-Mata, Fuyuki Tokanai, Claver W.
Aldama-Reyna & José M. Capriles
To cite this article: Gabriel Prieto, John Verano, Ann Pollard Rowe, Feren Castillo, Luis Flores,
Julio Asencio, Alan Chachapoyas, Victor Campaña, Richard Sutter, Aleksalia Isla, Khrystyne
Tschinkel, Rachel Witt, Andres Shiguekawa, Jordi A. Rivera Prince, Celeste Marie Gagnon, Carlos
Avila-Mata, Fuyuki Tokanai, Claver W. Aldama-Reyna & José M. Capriles (16 Jul 2023): Pampa La
Cruz: a New Mass Sacrificial Burial Ground during the Chimú Occupation in Huanchaco, North
Coast of Peru, Ñawpa Pacha, DOI: 10.1080/00776297.2023.2221481
Gabriel Prieto , John Verano , Ann Pollard Rowe, Feren Castillo , Luis Flores, Julio Asencio,
Alan Chachapoyas, Victor Campaña, Richard Sutter, Aleksalia Isla, Khrystyne Tschinkel ,
Rachel Witt, Andres Shiguekawa, Jordi A. Rivera Prince , Celeste Marie Gagnon ,
Carlos Avila-Mata, Fuyuki Tokanai , Claver W. Aldama-Reyna and José M. Capriles
Gabriel Prieto, Department of Anthropology, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL, USA (ogabriel.prietob@ufl.edu)
John Verano, Department of Anthropology, Tulane University, New Orleans, LA, USA (verano@tulane.edu)
Ann Pollard Rowe, The Textile Museum, The George Washington University Museum, Washington, DC, USA (aprowe@
gwu.edu)
Feren Castillo, Escuela de Arqueologia, Facultad de Ciencias Sociales, Universidad Nacional de Trujillo, Trujillo, Peru
(fcastillol@unitru.edu.pe)
Luis Flores, Programa Arqueologico Huanchaco, Trujillo, Peru (lfdelaoliva@gmail.com)
Julio Asencio, Programa Arqueologico Huanchaco, Trujillo, Peru (alasencio23@gmail.com)
Alan Chachapoyas Programa Arqueologico Huanchaco, Trujillo, Peru (alanchflores93@gmail.com)
Victor Campaña, Proyecto de Rescate Arqueologico Las Lomas de Huanchaco, Huanchaco, Peru (vitu.cale@gmail.com)
Richard Sutter, Department of Anthropology, Indiana University – Purdue University at Fort Wayne, Fort Wayne, IN,
USA (sutterr@pfw.edu)
Aleksalia Isla, Programa Arqueologico Huanchaco, Trujillo, Peru (aleksaalayo21@gmail.com)
Khrystyne Tschinkel, Department of Anthropology, Tulane University, New Orleans, LA, USA (ktschink@tulane.edu)
Rachel Witt, Department of Anthropology, Tulane University, New Orleans, LA, USA (rwitt@tulane.edu)
Andres Shiguekawa, Programa Arqueologico Huanchaco, Trujillo, Peru (shigue2@gmail.com)
Jordi A. Rivera Prince, Department of Anthropology, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL, USA ( jriveraprince@ufl.edu)
Celeste Marie Gagnon, Department of Anthropology, Wagner College, Staten Island, NY, USA (celeste.gagnon@wagner.edu)
Carlos Avila-Mata, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL, USA (cavilamata@ufl.edu)
Fuyuki Tokanai, Center for Accelerator Mass Spectrometry, University of Yamagata, Yamagata-shi, Japan (tokanai@sci.
kj.yamagata-u.ac.jp)
Claver W. Aldama-Reyna, Laboratorio de Óptica y Láseres, Departamento Académico de Física, Universidad Nacional de
Trujillo, Trujillo, Peru (caldama@unitru.edu.pe)
José M. Capriles, Department of Anthropology, Penn State University, State College, PA, USA ( juc555@psu.edu)
This article has been corrected with minor changes. These changes do not impact the academic content of the article.
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies, pp. 1–86. # 2023 Institute of Andean Studies. All rights reserved.
1
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
This article describes six sacrificial events carried out during the Late Intermediate Period and the beginning of the
Late Horizon at Pampa La Cruz (PLC), located in the Moche Valley, North Coast of Peru. The archaeological
context and circumstances in which the children and camelids were sacrificed at PLC are different from the previously
investigated site of Huanchaquito – Las Llamas. PLC raises the question of whether the nature and the purpose of
human sacrifice among the Chimú was more diverse and complex than previously thought. We discuss possible scen-
arios for the various sacrificial events identified at this site. Eighty AMS dates published here for the first time con-
stitute the largest and most precise series of absolute dates for Chimú society obtained from one site, and by extension for
the Late Intermediate Period in the entire coast of Peru.
En este artículo describimos seis eventos sacrificiales llevados a cabo durante el Periodo Intermedio Tardío y el inicio
del Horizonte Tardío en Pampa La Cruz (PLC), ubicado en el valle de Moche, costa norte del Perú. El contexto
arqueológico y las circunstancias en que los niños y los camélidos fueron sacrificados en PLC son diferentes al sitio
previamente investigado de Huanchaquito Las Llamas. PLC plantea la pregunta de si la naturaleza y el propósito
del sacrificio humano entre los Chimú fue más diverso y complejo de lo que se pensaba en un principio. Aquí, dis-
cutimos posibles escenarios o causas para los diversos eventos de sacrificio identificados en este sitio, intentando
amarrar estos eventos a la secuencia cronológica Chimú en general. Ochenta fechas AMS publicadas aquí por
primera vez, constituyen la serie más grande y precisa de fechas absolutas para la sociedad Chimú obtenidas de un
solo sitio en toda la costa del Perú y por lo tanto se vuelve en una herramienta útil para estudiar esta sociedad
prehispánica.
Keywords: Ritual Violence, Sanctified Violence, Chimu Society, North Coast of Peru, Pampa la Cruz
2
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
evidence of human sacrifice than the “civilized” Old some of these subadults and adults deserve more
World, is an idea that has been eradicated from discussion, which is offered at the end of this
scholarly circles, but is one that continues to be a paper. Nonetheless, Pampa La Cruz (hereafter
popular belief among the general public (Yoffee PLC) is similar in this respect to what was observed
2005, criticizing the neo-evolutionary model). at Huanchaquito Las Llamas where up to 19% of
Glenn Schwartz has correctly pointed out that one the victims did not show perimortem injuries that
of the sources of possible biases is the abundance may have caused death (Prieto et al. 2019). When
of archaeological evidence in the Americas, in con- the PLC data is tabulated by events, an interesting
trast with primarily textual evidence written thou- pattern seems to emerge. There is a systematic
sands of years ago in the Near East (for example increase in the cases with evidence on transverse
the biblical narrations) and even in Greek and cuts across the sterna from Events 1 and 2 at
Roman societies, although there is an increasing ratios of 32% and 25% respectively, to 68%
corpus of archaeological evidence across Europe (Event 5) and 82% during Event 6 (Appendix 1).
and the Middle East (Meyer et al. 2018; Porter These numbers suggest that killing victims by a
et al. 2021). Colorful interpretations, moral justifica- clean cut across the sternum is a practice that
tions, and even the neglect of data have been empha- increased over time. However, it should be noted
sized in both academic and non-academic circles, in that well-preserved sternal elements were not
lieu of detailed investigations of human sacrificial always recovered in the field, making the number
practices. The best approach to learn about human of unobservable cases high, reaching in some cases
sacrifice in the past should include all possible up to 49% (Appendix 1). Individuals scored as
direct and indirect sources, emphasizing the archae- “n/a” indicate that either the sternum was not
ological evidence collected during fieldwork and found during the excavation, or that it was so
later in the analysis of human skeletal remains heavily damaged, that a diagnosis was not possible
(Klaus and Toyne 2016; Meller et al. 2020; (Appendices 1 and 2).
Verano 2001). The purpose of this article is to report the results
Fortunately, the Chimú case does not require the of multiple seasons of excavations at PLC, a Chimú
need to convince the audience that children were site located north of Chan Chan, on the Huanchaco
actually sacrificed, because the skeletal evidence is coast, where hundreds of children, adults, and came-
unambiguous at the site of Huanchaquito Las lids were ritually killed between 1050/1100 and
Llamas, making it one of the best documented 1450/1500 cal. A.D. To date, PLC is the site that
cases reported from the ancient Andes (Cagnato has yielded the largest number of sacrifice victims
et al. 2021; Dufour et al. 2020; Goepfert et al. associated with the Chimú occupation (humans =
2020; Goepfert and Prieto 2016; Le Bailly et al. 2471; camelids = 211). The archaeological context
2020; Prieto et al. 2015, 2017, 2019; Prieto and and circumstances in which the children and came-
Verano in press; Verano and Prieto 2020). lids were sacrificed at PLC are different from the pre-
As will be shown here, the sacrificial victims viously investigated site of Huanchaquito – Las
found at Pampa La Cruz, also show unequivocal Llamas (Prieto et al. 2019). Indeed, PLC raises the
evidence of perimortem injuries (51%), although question of whether the nature and the purpose of
nearly 20% do not show evidence of cause of human sacrifice among the Chimú was more
death based on osteological evidence. However, con- diverse and complex than previously thought. At
textual evidence such as individuals buried in the the end of this article, we discuss possible scenarios
same fashion and next to those showing clear evi- for the various sacrificial events identified at Pampa
dence of a violent death, can be used to argue for La Cruz. Eighty AMS dates published here for the
sacrifice rather than normative mortuary practice. first time, constitute the largest and most precise
The absence of cutmarks and other trauma on series of absolute dates for Chimú society obtained
3
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
from one site, and by extension for the Late of skeletal remains and their contextual location.
Intermediate Period and Late Horizon in the Studying the materiality of violence through the
entire coast of Peru. Based on these results, we temporality, location, and associated objects buried
propose the existence of at least six sacrificial with the victims, we can begin to explore the multi-
events that occurred in sequence over almost 500 plicity of meanings of ritual violence, understanding
years at PLC. its causes, consequences and impacts upon society
In this paper we contextualize the case of the mass (Ralph 2013: 3).
sacrifice at PLC with an interdisciplinary approach A theme that is tacitly embedded in the Chimú
to the study of violence in the past (Martin and case of the mass sacrifice of children and young came-
Harrod 2015; Tung 2021; Vega Dulanto 2016). lids is the role played by violence as a political tool.
We recognize that the creation of a single definition Ralph (2013) has called attention to what Weber
of violence is impractical, given that its function and (1991 [1921]) called “sanctioned violence” as an
meaning is specific to the society or culture being accepted way of inflicting harm in a given society,
studied. Indeed, it has been suggested that our where the state or political organization is considered
understanding of violence varies according to our the sole arbiter of the “right” to use violence (Weber
own sociopolitical climate (Vandkilde 2013). In 1991[1921]: 78). At its core is the concept of dom-
broader terms, violence can include any action that ination: the control or power over others either
intends to hurt, damage, or kill someone or some- directly through the use of sanctioned violence, or
thing (Ralph 2013: 2). We suggest that the Chimú through the construction and reproduction of ideol-
society had multiple concepts of violence, and there- ogies that may mask the real nature of social relations
fore, even within this society, the function and (Orser 2002: 179; in Ralph 2013: 5). Did the Chimú
meaning of the taking of human lives should be use sanctioned violence (child sacrifice) as a mechan-
explored on a case-to-case basis. Under this ism of social control and domination, and to what
premise, Chimú violence as documented by the degree did the concept of violence change through
killing of captives at Pacatnamú (Verano 1986) time in Chimú society? We argue that not only is
and Punta Lobos (Verano and Toyne 2011) there the issue of evaluating the concept of violence
should be distinguished from a definition of ritual on a case-by-case basis, but also a need to consider
killing that applies to the mass sacrifice of young the temporal dimension in a complex society like
women buried in the royal burial platforms of the Chimú, which was in constant change due to
Chan Chan (Pozorski 1980). As it has been its imperial nature. We suggest that sanctioned vio-
suggested for the analysis of violence in ancient lence was a mechanism of social control by the
European societies, an interdisciplinary approach is Chimú, but we are still far from understanding it.
needed, one that should include the study of skeletal The data provided in this article should serve as the
remains, iconography, literature, landscapes and foundation for more elaborate theoretical models in
ritual behavior. Certainly, for the Andean case, not the future.
all these approaches are available (Benson and In this context, and for the late Prehispanic and
Cook 2001; Klaus and Toyne 2016). It has been early Colonial Andean case, Klaus has proposed
argued that violence played an important role in the concept of structural violence as an approach
the development of past sociopolitical systems, so to exploring the biological effects of inequality
its identification is an essential part for a better resulting from hierarchical social relationships. In
understanding of social change both on micro – his definition, Klaus states that “structural violence
and macro-scales (Ralph 2013: 3). Unfortunately, describes social structures that suppress agency and
for the Chimú case we are just beginning to prevent individuals, groups, and societies from
explore this interdisciplinary approach, and at this reaching their social, economic, and biological
point, can only offer a perspective from the study potential, promoting the avoidable impairment of
4
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
fundamental human needs or human life, which women and children). Massacres are also preceded
lowers the actual degree to which someone is able by other acts of destruction, which serve to provide
to meet their needs below that which would other- emotional momentum for the perpetrators and to
wise be possible” (Klaus 2012: 31). Structural vio- frighten the victims. These may include, but are
lence is considered a subtle form of violence not limited to capture, torture, and theatric perform-
because it is embedded in long-standing and multi- ances. It has been suggested that the death of every-
generational social structures. As a theoretical model, one in the social unit is not the intent of all
Klaus sees structural violence as a link between massacres; instead, a massacre of some individuals
anthropology and bioarchaeology, because it may can occur in order to force the submission of those
produce disparities in individual and community that remain (Anderson and Martin 2018: 6).
health that may be detectible in skeletal and dental In this article, we hypothesize that neither struc-
remains. In the case of early Colonial Period tural violence, nor the concept of massacre fits the
societies in Northern Peru, Klaus has demonstrated mass sacrifice at PLC. Instead, we suggest that sanc-
clear evidence of structural violence in the frequency tioned violence was at the core of Chimú as a mech-
of skeletal and dental stress indicators. anism of social control. We also propose that unlike
VanValkenburgh has noted that the societies of the previous assumptions (for example Prieto et al. 2015,
Lambayeque region experienced the impact of politi- 2017, 2019), ritualized violence in Chimú society
cal, economic, and ideological change imposed by and specifically the mass sacrifice of children and
three sequential empires (Chimú, Inca, and young camelids, was not only performed as a despe-
Iberian) in the span of less than two hundred rate response to mitigate extreme weather patterns
years (VanValkenburgh 2021). (such as ENSO events), but instead was a regular
Finally, we would like to approach the idea of mas- practice deeply embedded in Chimú political ideol-
sacres, since the number of sacrificial victims at ogy as part of a program of sanctioned violence.
Huanchaquito Las Llamas and PLC seems to fit The main evidence to support this idea are the six
the classic description of this concept. From an sequential sacrificial events found at PLC, which
anthropological perspective, massacres can be seen occurred over a period of five hundred years. This
as a process, as a chain of events that precede the mas- timeframe, identified by the aid of 80 AMS dates
sacre itself and continue longer after. It is defined on (Appendices 1 and 2), covers the entire history of
large numbers of victims killed at one time or by Chimú society from its origins until its consolidation
many events over a short period of time. Recently, as an empire and its final conquest by the Inca. We
it has been argued that the issue of how many argue that the mass sacrifice of children and camelids
victims are necessary to be considered a massacre was a mechanism by which the Chimú established
should take into consideration the cultural context and maintained political and ideological dominion
and population size of a given case (De Vore et al. over their subjects, imposing social control and max-
2018). Massacres can have varying aims, including imizing the power of the empire.
subjugation or total eradication of a group based
on status, ethnicity, or religion. Massacres can also
be powerful messages to witnesses or survivors Chimú, Chan Chan, and Human
about power dynamics and can be used as a tool Sacrifice
for social control (Anderson and Martin 2018: 1).
However, in the classic literature massacres are com- Chimú is the name given to the society and archaeo-
monly carried out by males and are intimately related logical culture of the so-called Kingdom of Chimor,
with warfare, such as a surprise attack initiated to which emerged around A.D. 900 in the north coast
annihilate an enemy social unit, including non-com- of Peru (Campana 2006; Moore and Mackey 2008;
batants (entire families or communities, including Moseley and Cordy-Collins 1990; Moseley and Day
5
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
1982; J. H. Rowe 1948). The Chimú conquered other Pachacamac in the southern Lurín valley have discov-
well-established contemporary polities like the Casma ered Chimú style high status objects made of wood,
in the south and the Late Lambayeque polity in the carved Spondylus shells, feathered objects, ceramic
north around A.D. 1250–1350 in a sequence of vessels and textiles within a structure that also
expansionist events (Moore and Mackey 2008: 789– resembles North Coast architecture, although most
793; J. H. Rowe 1948; Vogel 2012: 166–174). of these artifacts were found in association with a
Despite different opinions about the Chimú expan- Late Horizon occupation (Eeckhout 2017). Indeed,
sion, they incorporated a vast dominion of the Eeckhout believes that North Coast ritual practices
North Coast of Peru by A.D. 1400–1450, becoming and socio-political organization patterns were deeply
the most important political force on the Andean rooted in the Central Coast for a very long time,
coast. Although the nature of the expansion of the well before the Chimú began their expansion. He
Chimú territory is now under discussion, (see thinks that the elites of both regions were in contact
Moore et al. 1997), it appears that its level of political through long distance maritime trade, although
as well as economic control surpassed the modern armed conflicts could have occurred between the
boundary of the southern area of the present-day Chimú and the Ychma prior to the Inca presence on
Lima province, while in the north, the Chimú the Central Coast of Peru (Eeckhout 2005: 123).
reached as far as the Tumbes region (Figure 1). The Also, the presence of Chimú imports of textiles,
issue of Chimú territoriality needs to be further dis- silver, and beadwork (but not ceramics) in Chancay
cussed, considering indigenous perspectives indicates some level of Chimú presence in that valley
(Netherly 1984; Ramirez 2004; Rostworowski (A. P. Rowe 1984).
2004). Recent investigations by Peter Eeckhout at Recent DNA analysis suggests that people from the
Chimú kingdom could have been in contact and even
living in the Chincha valley area before the Inca con-
quest of the central and north coasts (Bongers et al.
2020). To the east of the Pacific coast, Chimú influ-
ence reached the upper highlands. Chimú pottery
was common in the highlands of the Moche and
neighboring valleys, in sites near Otuzco, Salpo,
Carabamba, and Agallpampa. It has been found at
sites in San Jose Porcon, including the Sanctuary of
Catequil itself. Topic also reported a few Chimú
ceramic fragments in the Huamachuco area (John
Topic, personal communication to Prieto, March
2022). Recently, Yamamoto has reported Chimú cer-
amics at the Ingatambo region, in the Jaen mountain
forest (Yamamoto 2007: 5). This evidence by no
means suggests territorial control by the Chimú, but
it marks a vast area of influence in which Chimú arti-
sans were in constant interaction with contempora-
neous peer polities beyond the coastal region.
Chan Chan, an urban settlement of more than 20
square kilometers in area located in the northern
sector of the Moche valley, is considered the capital
of the Chimú polity (Campana 2012; Gayoso
Figure 1. Map of the Chimú kingdom. Rullier and Gamarra Carranza 2023; Moseley 1975;
6
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Moseley and Day 1982; Pillsbury 1993; Rengifo However, it is without a doubt that the research led
2021). The city was built in an artificial valley by Michael E. Moseley and Carol J. Mackey during
created by a system of irrigation canals and the the “Chan Chan, Moche Valley Project” and the sub-
massive collection of earth for the construction of sequent “Proyecto Riego Antiguo” that have contribu-
walls, roads, agricultural fields and leveled terrain ted the most significant and influential models and
(Moseley and Deeds 1982; Nials et al. 1979; Ortloff ideas about the when, what, how, and why Chan
1981). It would be beyond the scope of this article Chan was a major settlement for the Chimú
to provide an accurate summary of the state-of-the- (Keatinge 1975; Moseley and Cordy-Collins 1990;
art investigations of this site, since recently two Moseley and Day 1982; Moseley and Mackey 1974;
major projects have been working there, the Chan Ortloff 1981; Topic 1990). One of the major accom-
Chan-Moche Valley Project during the late 1960s plishments of the Chimú empire was their magnificent
and early 1970s and the Proyecto Especial Chan hydraulic infrastructure (Kus 1972; Ortloff et al.
Chan (2006 to present), formerly the Unidad 1982), inherited from their Moche predecessors and
Ejecutora Chan Chan 005 (Campana 2012; possibly improved by their contact with the
Moseley and Day 1982; Rengifo 2021), in addition Lambayeque polity, who also built significant canals
to work done before and in between. Accurate maps such as the Taymi (Tschauner 2001). The same is
were drafted by the bishop Baltazar Jaime Martinez true for metallurgy, which could have been signifi-
Compañon in the eighteenth century, as well as few cantly improved at Chan Chan by Lambayeque’s
sections by Squier (1877) and Bandelier during nine- gold and silver smiths. This does not mean the
teenth and early twentieth centuries (Pillsbury and Chimú inherited or adopted all their technological
Trever 2008; Squier 1877; Trever 2012). Similarly, progress from the Lambayeque polity. We believe
the excavations during the 1980s at the Tschudi this subject deserves further investigations using
palace by Alfredo Narvaez and colleagues and work materials with secure provenience and well-dated
by the mural friezes project of Joanne Pillsbury in context from the site of Chan Chan itself and its
the 1990s, are good research that has improved our immediate surroundings. Former Lambayeque small-
knowledge of Chan Chan and Chimú society in scale residential settlements located in the
general (Narvaez 1989; Pillsbury 1993). Joanne Jequetepeque valley, were reoccupied by the Chimú,
Pillsbury analyzed the mural friezes of the Chan changing slightly their food habits and relationship
Chan palaces, one of the major features of this with state-like tasks (Cutright 2010). In any case,
ancient city. She re-opened some of those known there is no doubt that the Chimú were also influenced
since the Colonial and Republican periods, and also by Lambayeque mass sacrifice of subadults. The dis-
discovered new ones (Pillsbury 1996). She pointed covery of the Cerro Cerrillos mass sacrifice of around
out that the presence of friezes was restricted to big A.D. 900/950–1100 (although not conclusive, since
plazas, U-shaped structures, and more conspicuously, the dates rely on ceramic fragments rather than on
decorating the burial platforms of Chimú elites. absolute measurements), seems to be the earliest evi-
Pillsbury has also suggested that the friezes could dence of a mass sacrifice including children in the
have embodied large textiles “wrapping” the burial north coast of Peru (Klaus et al. 2010). However,
platforms as a symbol of shrouds covering the body the new dates obtained at Pampa La Cruz seem to
of the ruler deposited within the platform. Another challenge this notion (see below).
important contribution of hers was to define two man- When Prieto discovered the mass sacrifice of HLL
ufacturing techniques for the friezes: additive and sub- in 2011, one of the first indicators that distinguished
tractive. She suggested some possible chronological this site from a regular Chimú cemetery was the body
connotations, with the additive earlier and the subtrac- position in which the children and adolescents were
tive later, but in fact they were used indiscriminately buried: extended or resting on their backs with the
during both periods (Pillsbury 1993: 107; 2009). lower limbs slightly flexed (Prieto et al. 2015: 265;
7
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
Prieto et al. 2019). The body positions observed in Chan, indicate that the burial pattern during this
HLL were different from “standard” Chimú burial period is more diverse and complex than previously
positions for adolescents and adults. It should be assumed (Donnan and Mackey 1978: 376;
noted, however, that our knowledge of Chimú Valladares 2018: 31, 115, 121). This is also sup-
burial practices is very limited, despite the hundreds ported by recent findings in the Late Horizon ceme-
of tombs that have been excavated in the last 50 years. tery at Iglesia Colonial de Huanchaco (Moche
Very little has been done in systematizing body pos- Valley), where the majority of the burials are in
ition and orientation based on age, sex or social seated and flexed positions, but others show different
status. Other important variables like chronological patterns such as resting on their knees or flexed on
differences and valley and intra-valley variances their sides (Chimoven et al. 2016). Similar diversity
seem to exist, but they need to be synthesized in is observed in the many Late Horizon burials
light of new research (Mackey and Nelson 2020). (both of low and high status) at Farfán in the
In very general terms, the seated and flexed position Jequetepeque valley (Mackey and Nelson 2020: 94,
seems to be the standard for Lambayeque and Chimú figure 3.11 and page 112, figure 3.43).
during the Late Intermediate Period on the North Although a more detailed analysis on Chimú
Coast of Peru, although more regional-based burial practices is needed, it seems clear that the sacri-
studies have attempted to distinguish burial patterns ficed children, adolescents, and adults buried in mass
by ethnic affiliation (see for example Shimada et al. at Huanchaquito Las Llamas and at Pampa La Cruz
2004). The same can be said for the Lambayeque do not share the typical seated and flexed position of
burial patterns in the Jequetepeque valley, where at standard Chimú burial practices. The great majority
the site of San José de Moro, the dominant body pos- of sacrificed victims at HLL and PLC were buried in
ition was seated (middle Lambayeque), while during an extended position resting on their back or side
the late Lambayeque occupation burial position with the lower limbs slightly flexed. At PLC,
shifted to bodies resting on their backs (Prieto around 11% (26 out of 247, see Appendix 1) were
2014: 117–122). The scarce evidence available for buried in a seated or flexed position. Most of them
the Moche valley during the Late Intermediate were placed facing north. Almost all of these burials
Period suggests that during the early Chimú period, are associated with Event 3, which included 12
the burial position was exclusively flexed, although burials of adults (Appendix 1). As it will be shown
there was considerable variation in the exact posture later in this paper, we found that seated burials at
of the body: seated upright, seated but bending PLC are more elaborately dressed, and apparently
forward, while a few were lying on their side, back reflect a desire to have them facing a particular direc-
or front. Middle and Late Chimú burial position is tion in a standardized pose.
exclusively flexed and seated, but not with a standard Around 1450/1470, some sixteenth-century
orientation relative to the cardinal points or direction Spanish chroniclers have suggested that Inca troops
in which the skull is facing (Castillo 2019: 242; had their first unexpected encounters with the
Donnan and Mackey 1978: 288, 340, 356). Cajamarca and Chimú forces (J. H. Rowe 1948:
During the Late Horizon or Chimú Inca period, 42–43). Apparently, these encounters continued
the burial practices are more complex and diverse. into a long-lasting war, perhaps the longest ever
Although Donnan and Mackey have suggested a con- fought by the Incas (Covey 2020). This war ended
tinuation from Late Chimú of the flexed and seated when the city of Chan Chan was captured and occu-
burial position (Donnan and Mackey 1978: 376), pied by Inca officials, who sent the former Chimú
recent research by Katya Valladares has challenged king Michanzaman to live in Cuzco and to marry
this observation. Her analysis of 30 burials belonging one of the Inca’s daughters. Michanzaman died
to low status individuals associated to the Late soon after, while one of his sons, Chumun-caur,
Horizon found in the Chayhuac Palace in Chan who was at the time in the Huaura valley with his
8
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
mother, Chanquir-guanguan, was appointed to rule refused by the local curaca Don Antonio Chayhuac
in Chan Chan under Inca control (J. H. Rowe and his lords who claimed that “the discovered bones
1948: 45). Before the end of the fifteenth century, were the remains of his ancestors and not of sacrificed
the former Chimú domains were brought under boys like the Spanish are arguing” (Ramirez 2004:
Inca imperial control. In subsequent decades, 261, 274, referring to AGI/ J404). Would it be poss-
Chimú culture gradually vanished from the north ible that Don Antonio was trying to hide the fact that
coast of Peru, although the Inca supported the wide- his ancestors sacrificed numerous children a few
spread distribution of Chimú-Inca objects. The decades before the arrival of the Spanish? This infor-
gradual vanishing of Chimú culture is particularly mation deserves more analysis, which will be the
true for Quignam, the language spoken in Chan topic of a future paper. In any case, there is scarce
Chan and the valleys south of the Jequetepeque but compelling evidence about the knowledge of
river. It was almost forgotten at the time of the first child sacrifice among the descendants of the former
journey by the Spanish explorers along the North Chimú empire during the sixteenth century.
Coast of Peru in 1531–1532 (Quilter et al. 2010; Prior to our discoveries in the Huanchaquito and
Rabinowitz 1983). Recent excavations carried out Huanchaco area, scattered but consistent evidence of
at Chimú sites show that Chimú architecture and ritualized human sacrifice was known among the
material culture was more resilient than their Chimú. The excavations at Las Avispas, a royal
language, since most of their architectural techniques burial platform at Chan Chan yielded hundreds of
and layout, as well as ceramic objects and textiles human bones, which turned out to be principally
prevail until late in the Colonial period (but not exclusively) of young women (Pozorski
(Chachapoyas et al. 2020; Mackey and Nelson 1980; Andrew Nelson, personal communication to
2020; Mayer 1984; Moore and Mackey 2008; A.P. John Verano, 2018). The bioarcheological analysis is
Rowe 1984; Tschinkel 2022). As we will describe inconclusive regarding how these young women
here, human sacrifice especially of children and ado- died, but their massive presence in the royal mauso-
lescents became a central element in Chimú religious leums at Chan Chan suggest that they were deliber-
performance, and it seems to have continued in the ately killed to accompany the high-status individuals
surroundings of Chan Chan (and perhaps within buried in the funerary platforms. The presence of
the city as well) during the Inca control of this site. several women buried around high-status males in
the elite burials of Lambayeque society confirms that
this practice may have represented retainers or second-
Ritual Violence in Chimú Society ary wives and that it was a common practice during
and Mass Sacrifice Sites in the the Late Intermediate Period on the North Coast of
Vicinity of Chan Chan Peru (Shimada et al. 2004). A different context was
found in the Huarmey valley, well south of Chan
The Spanish Friar Antonio de la Calancha claimed Chan. At the site of Punta Lobos nearly 200 (n =
that child sacrifices were made by the Chimú in the 178) individuals were brutally executed during the
Jequetepeque river valley during lunar eclipses Chimú conquest of this valley. The demographic
(Calancha 1977[1638]). There is documentary evi- profile was composed primarily of adult males
dence that late sixteenth-century descendants of the (66%) and subadults younger than 18 years old
Chimú elites knew about child and camelid sacrifices. (34%) (Verano and Phillips 2016; Verano and
During the excavation of the Yomayoguan treasure in Toyne 2011). All the victims were found face down
Chan Chan, the Spaniards involved in the looting with their wrists and ankles bound with rope or
described that on the surface of the area excavated cloth, and cloth blindfolds were found still in place
there were “many children and camelid bones, along on many individuals. The throats of all victims had
with other signs of sacrifice,” something that was been slashed repeatedly, which suggests that the great
9
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
majority of the victims were forced face down and sometimes feet tied suggest that they could have
then killed by someone straddling the victim from been sacrificial victims (Jackson 2004; Prieto and
behind (Verano and Phillips 2016: 259). The isolated Verano in press; Verano and Prieto 2020). A very
location of Punta Lobos on a hillside facing the sea large Chimú textile known as the "Prisoner Textile"
and distant from any urban center or temple suggests (apparently found in the Virú Valley), depicts
a mass execution, possibly a reprisal killing done by bound and mutilated captives, possibly camelids,
the Chimú (a typical massacre), responding to local and carrion birds (Hamilton 2016; Lapiner 1976).
resistance perpetrated by the Casma society (Verano The presence of Lambayeque artistic elements on
and Toyne 2011). Two AMS radiocarbon dates the Prisoner Textile was perhaps attempting to
place the event at around A.D. 1250–1300, coinciding appropriate the graphic styles of the conquered
with the estimated date of conquest of the Huarmey peoples to make their identities apparent to viewers
valley by the Chimú (Mackey and Klymyshyn in the absence of text (Bergh 2022). Hamilton
1990). At the northern site of Pacatnamú in the believes that Chimú painters were perhaps decipher-
Jequetepeque valley, a different form of ritual killing ing the sequence of conquest of the kingdom of
was found. Fourteen males (adolescents and young Chimor (Hamilton 2016: 87). More recently, 20
adults) were killed and thrown into a defensive wooden sculptures depicting warriors holding
trench at the entrance of the major architectural com- trophy heads have been found at the entrance of
pound of the site. Surface weathering on some bones one of the palaces in Chan Chan (Gayoso Rullier
and the remains of insects indicate the bodies were and Gamarra Carranza 2023). It should be stressed
left to decompose on the surface. The victims suffered that Chimú art is largely non-representational, and
multiple injuries, including stab wounds, cut marks, therefore topics such as ritualized violence could
skull and long bone fractures, opening of the chest have been intentionally avoided. Elsewhere, one of
and dismemberment. The victims are believed to us has suggested that the Chimú city of Chan
have been captive local and non-local warriors killed Chan was surrounded by a sacred landscape where
around A.D. 1100–1200, contemporaneous with the sanctuaries and shrines were deliberately and strategi-
suggested expansion of the Chimú into the cally located, similar to those described for the ceque
Jequetepeque valley (Verano 1986; Verano and system identified for Inca Cuzco (Prieto and
deNiro 1993; Verano and Phillips 2016). Although Burmester 2015). One of the reasons for the exist-
there is scattered evidence of ritualized executions ence of sacred landmarks and sanctuaries around
during the Chimú hegemony, no other mass sacrifices Cuzco was the necessity of making offerings framed
are known. Indeed, ritualized violence is very restricted in a ceremonial calendar to their gods, goddesses,
in Chimú art, in sharp contrast with the multiple powerful spirits and ancestors (J. H. Rowe 1979).
manifestations of ritual violence depicted by their pre- The description of the offerings made by the Incas
decessor the Moche. Santiago Uceda found within a to these shrines and sanctuaries includes mainly
Chimú burial at Huaca de la Luna a wooden architec- human and camelid sacrifices, noted in sixteenth-
tural model with a number of human figurines, repre- century sources but not yet confirmed by archaeolo-
senting some form of ritual activity likely related to gical excavations (Besom 2009). In contrast, for the
ancestor worship. Two of the “scenes” (Scene 1 and 5) Chimú case there is abundant archaeological infor-
depicted a male holding a tumi-like knife, while mation on human and camelid sacrifices in sacred
the other portrayed a naked male captive with his shrines and landmarks around Chan Chan, but no
hands tied on his back and nearby two officials ethnohistoric data. It seems as if the sixteenth-
holding trophy heads (Uceda 1999: 279, 293 century descriptions by the Spanish conquistadors,
figures 17 and 31). Wooden sculptures found at which emphasize “biblical” numbers of children
Huaca El Dragón and Huaca Tacaynamo depicting and camelids sacrificed by the Inca around Cuzco,
naked male prisoners with their hands and have their archaeological (rather than historical)
10
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
evidence in the vicinity of Chan Chan, in the littoral adults, and 206 young camelids were uncovered in
of Huanchaco. direct association with a thick layer of mud formed
The sacred organization of the Chimú landscape by a flood as the result of torrential rains associated
around Chan Chan is unknown, due to the lack of with a strong El Niño Southern Oscillation event.
written records and oral testimonies from early in Twenty-one calibrated AMS dates indicate that this
the Colonial period. However, the presence of cere- event occurred around A.D. 1400–1450 (Prieto
monial platforms outside of Chan Chan, ritual et al. 2017, 2019). One of the most significant dis-
roads connecting the sea and mountains, as well as coveries at HLL is that the subadults and camelid
irrigation canals, and now the presence of mass victims, escorted by adults and dogs, came alive to
human and camelid sacrifice burial grounds around the sacrifice ground, leaving their bare foot, hoof
Chan Chan, indicate frequent ceremonial activity and paw prints in the wet mud. This evidence con-
around this coastal city (Prieto et al. 2019; Prieto firms that the event occurred during a heavy rainfall,
and Burmester 2015; Sakai 1998; Valle 2004; which is unusual in the Moche valley, and suggests a
Zuidema 1964). Some of the burial platforms of strong ENSO event around that time.
the Chan Chan palaces seem to have been aligned As shown in Figure 2, the Pampa La Cruz site
with the surrounding mountains, while some artifi- (PLC), is north of HLL, which will be described in
cial platforms profusely decorated with polychrome detail later. Just north of the PLC site is the Jose
mud friezes surrounding Chan Chan could have Olaya Sector, Iglesia Colonial de Huanchaco or
been used as temples, mausoleums, and sanctuaries JO-IG (Donnan and Foote 1978). This was the
for ritual activities, including human and camelid first mass sacrifice discovered on the Huanchaco
sacrifices (Brooks et al. 2008; Jackson 2004; Prieto coast. It was reported by Christopher Donnan and
and Burmester 2015; Sakai 1998; Schaedel 1966). Leonard Foote in 1968 at the site then known as
Integrating the landscape and its natural resources “Zone C,” next to a public elementary school on
in the surroundings of Chan Chan along with the the east side of Huanchaco and south of the
construction of artificial irrigation canals, gardens, Colonial Church (Donnan and Foote 1978).
and irrigated lands suggest a special treatment of Today, this site is known by the Huanchaco
the surrounding territory and the necessity of trans- Archaeological Program (PAHUAN) as the “Jose
forming it into an anthropogenic landscape Olaya Sector, Iglesia Colonial de Huanchaco” site
(Cornejo 2005). All this evidence points to an (JO-IG), after the name of the public school that
active commitment by Chan Chan planners to inte- today lies on top of the former archaeological site.
grate the city into a sacred landscape and to ritualize Donnan and Foote reported a total of 17 children
the daily activities of its citizens into a seasonal calen- and 20 young camelids spread over a relatively large
dar that supported, among other things, the Chimú area (Donnan and Foote 1978). Although the exca-
elite and its political structure. Part of Chan Chan’s vators did not report evidence of perimortem
sacred landscape were areas for mass child and trauma on the bones, such as cut marks on the
camelid sacrifice along the seaside, on the north sterna or ribs, they were convinced by contextual evi-
margin of the city. Today, this area is the dence of the sacrificial nature of this context
Huanchaco coast. Previous investigations and our (Donnan and Foote 1978: 407). A single date
ongoing research project have identified four mass placed this event around A.D. 1400–1450, although
sacrifice sites north of Chan Chan along the a more accurate measurement is not possible due to
present day Huanchaco beach (Figure 2). the lack of specific information on the radiometric
The Huanchaquito Las Llamas (HLL) mass sacri- determination. In 2019, the PAHUAN project con-
fice site is arguably the largest child and animal sacri- ducted new excavations at JO-IG to test an area of the
fice known in the ancient world (Prieto et al. 2019; site that was not excavated by Donnan and Foote
Romey 2019). At this site, 137 subadults, three (Flores 2020). The excavations uncovered seven
11
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
Figure 2. Map of the Moche Valley, indicating the location of Chimú sites. Note the mass sacrifice grounds located north of the city of
Chan Chan.
children and one adult, including a few camelids as isolated area, although 1.5 km to the northwest lies
well as Spondylus sp. shells that seem to have been the Late Horizon and Early Colonial residential site
aligned on a SW-NE axis across this section of the of La Joyada (Dominguez 2019; Domínguez and
site. Laboratory analysis by Verano showed that the Prieto 2019; Kautz and Keatinge 1977; Prieto and
children were sacrificed using the well-known tech- Domínguez 2018). At present, EP is the northern-
nique of cutting across the chest cavity marked by a most location of a mass sacrifice site in the
transverse cut on the lower part of the sternum. Huanchaco area, 13 km north of Chan Chan
A more recently discovered sacrificial site is 7.85 (Figure 2). EP is an unusual site marked by a large
km north of JO-IG. It was given the name “El rectangular enclosure surrounded by sacrificed
Pollo” (EP) due to its proximity to a large chicken victims (subadults, adults and young camelids)
farm (Chachapoyas and Witt 2020). EP may be (Prieto and Verano in press; Witt 2023; Witt et al.
either the Late Intermediate Period site of 2022). It is possible that other mass sacrificial sites
Caracoles identified in the 1970s by the Chan in the Huanchaco area remain to be discovered and
Chan-Moche Valley Project (Beck 1979; Pozorski excavated, while many others are now destroyed
1976) or another nearby site. It is located in an due to urban expansion and other modern activities.
12
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
The four sites described here indicate that the arid lit- site (Figure 2). Today it is surrounded by modern
toral north of Chan Chan was used intensively for residential construction, including the Hotel
human and animal sacrifice by the Chimú between Bracamonte on its northwest edge. In the past, the
A.D. 1050–1450/1500 (see below). Why did the upper sector of PLC was a flat area on top of the
Chimú choose this area of their sacred landscape marine terrace where numerous architectural struc-
and why did they conduct mass child and camelid tures (domestic and ceremonial) were erected at
sacrifices? We believe that there was a systematic various times beginning with the late Early
program of ritualized violence sponsored by the Horizon Salinar occupation around 400 cal. B.C.
Chimú Empire, in which the killing of children until the late Moche Period A.D. 800/850 when
and young camelids played a central role. the Moche ceremonial and residential settlement
was abandoned (Barr 1991; Barr et al. 1986;
Campaña and Prieto 2022; Centurion 1989;
Pampa La Cruz and the Sacrifice Fernandez et al. 2022; Parker et al. 2018; Prieto
Ceremonies During the Chimú and Chavarria 2017). There is slight evidence of a
Occupation post-Moche or Transitional Period occupation
(Castillo et al. 2020). Near Montículo 1, an artificial
PLC was recorded and officially inscribed in the structure built on the NW corner of the site, we
inventory of archaeological sites of the Moche recorded isolated materials possibly from looted
valley by Genaro Barr in 1986 (Barr 1991; Barr burials, including textiles and ceramic vessels similar
et al. 1986). However, the site was first visited and in style those found at Huaca del Sol (Moche
reported by E.G. Squier (1877) and briefly examined valley), El Brujo (Chicama valley) and at San José de
by Ales Hdrlička in 1911, who called it a “children’s Moro in the Jequetepeque valley (Cruz et al. 2019;
cemetery” (Hrdlicka 1911: 7; 1914: 46). In 1965, it Franco and Galvez 2005; Pariona and Prieto 2022;
was excavated by Francisco Iriarte Brenner who Rucabado and Castillo 2003) (Figure 4).
named it “Rio Seco” or “Sitio Rentsch.” A few Due to urban expansion, PLC is now almost com-
years later, the site was called “Zone B – La Poza” pletely destroyed, with only 1.5 ha of its total surface
by the Chan Chan – Moche Valley Project (originally 11.83 ha) still intact and suitable for
(Donnan and Mackey 1978; Iriarte 1965). archaeological research (Campaña and Prieto
PLC is located on the southern end of the modern 2022). This area is subdivided into two sectors:
town of Huanchaco, on the left side (south) of the Montículo 1 (around 6,500 sq meters) and
Quebrada de Rio Seco. The main sector of the site Montículos 2 and 3 (around 5,500 sq meters). The
lies on top of a bluff overlooking the sea. There is first sector is located on the NW side, while the
also an archaeological occupation on the west slope of second is on the NE side of the site (Figure 3(a
the bluff, extending westward down to the beach. and b)). The remaining area has been severely
This lower sector was known as “La Poza” in previous affected by modern construction (Figure 3(a)).
publications (Donnan and Mackey 1978; Escobedo Excavations conducted by PAHUAN between 2016
and Rubio 1982; Millaire 2002) (Figure 3(a)). and 2019 focused in the Montículo 1 sector.
Therefore, PLC today has two sectors: the upper one Between 2017 and 2018, the City Hall of
(where we carried out excavations) and the lower Huanchaco sponsored a salvage excavation project
sector. Unfortunately, the latter is now private property on all the streets and public spaces of the modern
and previous requests by Programa Arqueológico village known as Las Lomas de Huanchaco that
Huanchaco (PAHUAN) to excavate there have been today lies on top of the former surface of the upper
denied by the owners (Figure 3(a and b)). part of the PLC site. Thanks to these excavations,
PLC is 5.6 km north of Chan Chan and 2.6 km many occupational surfaces were recovered, including
from the Huanchaquito Las Llamas mass sacrifice domestic and non-domestic spaces, and more than
13
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
Figure 3. (a) Aerial view of the Pampa La Cruz site (hereafter PLC). Photo taken with a drone. (b) Aerial view of the site in 1942.
Photo taken by Servicio Aerofotográfico Nacional, SAN 104-4, March, 1942.
150 burials (of which 25 are Chimú sacrificial project confirms the main sequence (late Early
victims) (Campaña and Prieto 2022). A preliminary Horizon through Late Intermediate Period) observed
analysis of the materials recovered in the salvage in the Montículo 1 sector by PAHUAN and
14
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
previously by Barr (1991). Some of the Chimú skel- and Nelson 2020), to our knowledge no remains of
etons recovered by the salvage project were analyzed deforming devices are known from northern Peru,
by John Verano and some data are included here with the exception of a cradleboard reportedly found
(Appendix 1; see also Verano 2018). in the Virú valley (Verano 1997: 250, figure 8) and a
The focus of this article is on the Chimú, and poss- cotton T-shaped band and a woven fiber ring (presum-
ibly Chimú-Inca ritual activity found in and around ably used to fix an infant’s head to a cradleboard) that
Montículo 1, including the sacrificial victims discov- were found associated with a Late Intermediate
ered on top of this platform. In addition, we are Period infant burial at Pacatnamú in the
including Chimú burials found on different areas Jequetepeque valley (Verano and Cordy-Collins 1986).
of PLC (outside of the Montículo 1 sector) excavated In distinct contrast to what we interpret as unin-
by the rescue project between 2017 and 2018. As can tentional occipital flattening in some children,
be seen in Appendix 1, most of the Chimú burials eleven individuals at PLC show a distinct form of
found during the salvage project had transverse cuts intentional cranial modification known as annular
across the body of the sternum and were children or circumferential. This form of cranial modification
consistent with the age profile of sacrificial victims has only been seen in a few isolated individuals from
found clustered in and around Montículo 1. Based northern coastal Peruvian sites (Mackey and Nelson
on the burial distribution, we suggest that the total 2020; Prieto et al. 2019) but is common in various
extent of the area at PLC with evidence of Chimú highland Peruvian populations (MacCurdy 1923;
sacrificial victims could be larger than previously Verano et al. 2016). This suggests to us that the
thought, covering at least 5,200 m2, not including PLC children with annular modification may have
Montículo 1. Of this total area, we have only exca- been of highland rather than coastal origin. As was
vated 750 m2 or about 14.4%, which means that also observed at HLL, the adolescent and adult
the expected number of sacrificial victims (children, burials found at PLC all show occipital flattening
adults, and camelids) and offerings such as consistent with a coastal origin.
Spondylus shells, metal miniatures and wooden sculp- The upper sector of PLC is not the only area with
tures may be significantly larger than the current evidence of Chimú ritual activity. In previous exca-
counts and the materials described in this paper. vations carried out in the lower sector of the site
As was observed in the child sacrifices at (earlier known as La Poza, see Figure 3(a)), Francisco
Huanchaquito-Las Llamas (Prieto et al. 2019), variabil- Iriarte reported many subadult Chimú burials (Iriarte
ity in forms of cranial modification in the children at 1965). Such burials were also mentioned (but unfortu-
PLC suggests that individuals selected for sacrifice nately not described in the field report) by Manuel
were a heterogeneous sample, perhaps drawn from dis- Escobedo and Emilio Rubio in 1982, who wrote only
tinct ethnic groups and geographic regions of the of a “Chimú occupation” in this lower sector
Chimú Empire. The great majority of the PLC children (Escobedo and Rubio 1982: 1). Therefore, it is
have unmodified skulls, while only a small number suggested that the sacrificial area may have extended
(eleven individuals) show mild occipital flattening along the lower sector of the site, which may have
characteristic of prehistoric populations of the north doubled the area of the upper sector. In addition to
coast of Peru and known as tabular erect or fronto-occi- the lower sector, the salvage project found a few
pital modification (Appendix 1). This form of cranial Chimú subadult burials along with young camelids
modification is generally considered to be an uninten- on the NE side of the upper sector at PLC2
tional result of cradle boarding of infants, and at PLC (Montículos 2 and 3) in an area that was originally
it is relatively mild in its expression. Although some covered with Chimú agricultural fields, canals, and a
authors have suggested that certain variants of fronto- rectangular building (Campaña and Prieto 2022: 23–
occipital flattening may represent intentional shaping 25, figure 13, see also pp. 115–117; Castillo Soto
of the head by specific deforming devices (Mackey 1986; Jauregui 2001; Varas 1989).
15
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
Figure 4. Ceramic vessel typical of the Transitional Period (Middle Horizon 2) found on the SW sector of Montículo 1, PLC as well as
fragments of Middle Horizon textiles found at Pampa La Cruz.
The presence of superimposed burials suggests that addition, we noticed at least two distinct body pos-
the PLC Chimú sacrificial victims were interred as itions and orientations at the time of burial at
the result of many successive events and not just PLC. The earliest pattern observed at PLC was
one, as has been suggested for the nearby site of bodies being placed in an extended position on a
Huanchaquito Las Llamas (Prieto et al. 2015, W-E orientation, with the skull towards the west
2017, 2019). The idea of many successive events is and the feet towards the east. Later, burials were
also supported by burials at different depths. In placed in an extended position with an E-W
16
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
orientation (skull to the east). The latest burial probably abandoned after 1500 and not before.
pattern was marked by bodies in an extended pos- Some of the events are better represented than
ition but with the legs slightly flexed, and in most others, and at this point it is difficult to say
of the cases in a different orientation than E-W, whether this is the result of less intense ritual activity
mainly on a S-N axis. The average age of the suba- at PLC or simply a problem of sampling.
dults at PLC is 9–13 years old, while the average
age of the adults is between 18 and 25 years old.
Confirmation of multiple sacrificial events is also Montículo 1
suggested by a consistent set of 80 AMS measure-
Until the excavations carried out by PAHUAN,
ments published here for the first time. The
Montículo 1 was identified as an amorphous artificial
samples for AMS dating were carefully chosen,
platform first built during the Moche occupation
using in most cases cotton yarns taken from the
A.D. 500–850 and measuring approximately 1500
shrouds or other textiles found in direct association
m2 with an estimated height of 2.5 meters
with the bodies, following best practices on AMS
(Fernandez et al. 2022) (Figure 5). Previous exca-
dating (Contreras 2022). For the camelids, the
vators described it as a rectangular structure with
samples were taken from sedge ropes binding the
stone wall alignments found on the top of the plat-
limbs or snout. In a few instances, samples were
form (Barr et al. 1986). It is located on the NW
taken from cotton strings wrapping Spondylus
corner of PLC and was built on the edge of the
shells or from textile offerings as well as seeds of
bluff, overlooking the dry riverbed of the Quebrada
Nectandra sp. found as votive offerings with the
de Rio Seco and the Huanchaco cove. During the
burials or as caches around Montículo 1. We tried
Chimú occupation it is estimated that it was a rec-
to date burials placed in different locations in and
tangular platform of approximately 820 m2, with a
around Montículo 1, and achieved very consistent
minimum of 66 sacrificed humans and six camelids
results (Appendix 2). As shown in Appendix 2, the
buried in the platform. It is likely that more
burials and caches with AMS dates are listed indivi-
victims were buried during the Chimú occupation,
dually, so it will be easier for the reader to compare
but intensive Colonial looting disturbed the central
the absolute dating obtained from each burial with
sector of the platform during the sixteenth century.
the suggested event that we believe the burial or
caches were part of. Based on the recurrence and
associative principles in archaeology and applying Early Chimú Occupation at Montículo 1, Events 1
additional criteria such as burial proximity, burial and 2. After a period of abandonment ( possibly
alignments or clustering, body position, body orien- between A.D. 800/850 to 1050/1100 although we
tation, and clothing, human and camelid remains cannot rule out a late Middle Horizon occupation
lacking AMS dates were assigned to their most prob- at PLC), the late Moche platform was backfilled
able chronological placement. As shown in Appendix and leveled during the earliest Chimú occupation.
2, there are a total of six suggested sacrifice events, Based on recent AMS dates, it appears that the
with “Event 1” being the earliest and “Event 6” the construction of the first Chimú platform on top of
latest so far identified at PLC. One of the most the previous Moche building occurred around A.D.
notable results of the analysis of the 80 AMS 1050/1100 cal. There is evidence of the
measurements is that there is a clear continuity in construction of a large rectangular extension of the
the Chimú occupation at PLC from A.D. 1050/ south sector of the Moche platform, measuring
1100 to 1450/1500, suggesting that if these sacrifice approximately 24 meters (E-W) by 7 meters (S-N),
events were directed from Chan Chan (only 5.6 km with a total surface area of 168 m2 (Figure 6). The
to the south), then the city must have been Chimú built the outer wall separated by seven
founded slightly earlier than A.D. 1050/1100 and meters from the southern end of the Moche
17
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
platform. Inside, the empty space was filled with an Nectandra sp. that was found on the floor,
intricate system of retaining walls built with small immediately next to the southern wall of the early
cobbles, creating a pattern of rectangular cells filled Chimú platform, which was later covered by the new
with clean river pebbles and gravel alternating with construction event. If this date is considered as the
earth fills (Figure 6). This first Chimú platform terminus ante quem, it seems plausible that the
had a straight wall on three sides (south, west and renovation occurred around the late A.D. 1200s or
east), although on the west side, it appears that the before 1350. The renovation project involved
Chimú continued using the surface of the latest slightly enlarging the area of the previous platform
Moche platform, with no major effort to modify by adding inclined walls on three sides of the
this sector during the early Chimú occupation. The platform (south, west and east). This new
northern end of the platform, which is on the edge modification gave Montículo 1 the form of a low
of the bluff, has not been excavated, and the layout truncated pyramid (Figure 7). The most distinctive
of the central part of the Chimú platform is feature is that somewhere on top of the platform
unknown due to the major destruction by looting ( possibly the now destroyed central sector), there
during the Colonial period. were walls decorated with polychrome mud friezes
made in the additive style identified by Pillsbury
Middle Chimú Occupations at Montículo 1, (1993). The friezes were placed on a thick white
Events 3 and 4. At some time around A.D. 1300/ painted background, and the high reliefs appear to
1350, the Chimú conducted another construction have depicted seabirds, fish and even the moon
project at Montículo 1. This date is derived from an animal. Unfortunately, we were unable find a
AMS date (YU-13283; A.D. 1223–1299 cal. 2 complete design in the dozens of fragments found in
sigmas), obtained from a buried ritual cache of the backdirt left by sixteenth-century looters on the
south and west sides of the mound. The most
18
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
19
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
Figure 9. General view of the L shaped walls built during the latest Chimú occupation at PLC and the wooden scepters found during
the excavation of the floor inside the L shaped walls built on the NW corner of the Chimú platform at PLC.
miniature textiles, and wooden idols were buried as based on the AMS results and the spatial distribution
well. The number of sacrifice victims associated and burial patterns of the victims. In some instances,
with the proposed six sacrificial events around finer distinctions, or subevents are suggested within
Montículo 1 is very large. In the following section the larger events, based on burial superimposition
we will describe each of the six events identified and available AMS dates.
20
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
21
Figure 10. Map of all the sacrificed children, adults, camelids, and other offerings made on top of Montículo 1 and around it.
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
Event 1 (A.D. 1050–1180 cal.). Five dates were skull that shows pronounced symmetrical occipital
obtained from what seems to be the earliest flattening. The sternum was complete with no cuts,
sacrificial event so far excavated at PLC during the and there is no indication of cause of death. PLC-
Chimú occupation (Figure 11, Appendix 2). 369-E2 was a young adult female, around 18–20
Twenty-one burials (total 22 bodies) were years, that showed no trauma or skeletal pathology.
identified for this sacrifice event (Appendix 1). The On the east side, but this time on the platform,
dates were obtained from two child burials, two PLC-301 was a subadult of approximately seven
camelids and a metal knife. The latter was a years of age. This child was placed in an extended
foundational offering placed on the NW corner of position with the head towards the east and the feet
Montículo 1. The human victims were located on to the west, with the right arm lifted toward the
the east side of the platform, while the camelids right side of the skull (Figure 12). Two camelids
were on the west side. Burial PLC-369 was were buried on the NW corner of the platform in
immediately east and outside of the platform. It has clear opposition to the location of the human
two individuals with no offerings, both placed on burials. Both camelids were subadults placed resting
their knees facing down. PLC-369-E1 was an on their backs with their necks twisted towards the
individual approximately 12–13 years of age with a north and west, while the limbs are flexed toward
Figure 11. Multiple plot showing the ranges of the AMS results associated with Event 1 and Event 2.
22
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Figure 12. PLC 369, found outside of the platform, along its east side, PLC 301, a subadult found on the NE corner of the platform,
Event 1. Camelid 104 and 107. Note their snouts tightly wrapped with a sedge rope.
the center of their bodies. One camelid was of beige mushroom-end head had four lumps of mud
color and the other was brown. The snouts of the placed in a cross-shaped pattern (Figure 13(c)). At
camelids were tightly wrapped with sedge ropes, a least two double cords crossed the top of the rattle
practice that has not been observed in later events in a cross and then in a diagonal pattern, which
(Figure 12). Another offering associated with the seems to have been done to keep the rattle attached
first event is a metal knife that was placed in a hole to the handle and the metal blade (Figure 13(c)). It
with its blade pointing toward the south and is not possible to demonstrate that this knife was
wrapped in a white cotton fabric. Some traces of used for child and camelid sacrifice at PLC, but the
red paint were apparent on parts of the textile location of its discovery suggests it may have played
(Figure 13(a)). The form of this knife is most some role, but was perhaps more symbolic rather
unusual; we are not aware of any other examples than practical.
that have been found archaeologically. The metal Event 1 is the least known of all the sacrificial
blade is not the typical semi-crescent tumi-shaped events at PLC. Evidence of perimortem trauma or
object, but instead looks more like a flat chisel cause of death was not observed, but this does not
attached to a kind of mushroom-end sphere that rule out the possibility that they were intentionally
also served as a rattle (Figure 13(b)). The metal killed in some manner as not to have left osteological
handle of the knife was wrapped with a cotton pad evidence, such as strangulation, given their context
and unspun cotton strings, while the top of the and burial positions. The two individuals buried
23
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
24
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
25
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
Figure 15. Multiple plot showing the ranges of the AMS results associated with Event 3.
26
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
27
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
Huanchaquito Las Llamas or in previous or later included multiple events performed at different
events at PLC (Figure 19). Due to the number of times. This is because PLC 234 was disturbed
sacrificial victims (both human and camelid) as well (cranium and mandible) by the time PLC 236 was
as other types of offerings associated with Event 3, deposited, suggesting that some time must have
we will describe them by sectors as follows. passed between the burial of the two bodies to
allow for the decomposition of soft tissue of PLC
South Sector 234 (Figure 20(a and b)). Another interesting
This area corresponds to the southernmost edge of aspect of PLC 234 and 235 is that sharp stones
the archaeological area that is still available for were found inserted in their chest cavities, with pos-
research and that modern houses have not destroyed itions that suggested they may have caused serious
near Montículo 1 (Figure 10). We obtained five bleeding or even death. PLC 234 did not show cut
AMS dates associated with Event 3 for this sector marks on the sternum, but PLC 235 did and also
(CA 72, CA 82, PLC 235, 236 and 243). All the sub- had stones in the thoracic cavity (Figure 20(c)).
adults buried here were placed (E-W) in an extended Due to their proximity and similarities (mainly the
position with the head toward the east and the feet to presence of the 1x1 cotton shroud and the knotted
the west. A distinguishing feature of the cotton feature close to the feet), burials PLC 219, 239,
shrouds used to cover the bodies of the victims was 242, 262, 227, 230, 231, 232, 247, 248, 249, 250
a simple cotton fabric usually tied around the feet and 241 may be victims sacrificed during Event 3
of the victims with a simple knot. An overlap of (Figure 21). This can be confirmed by the fact that
PLC 236 on top of PLC 234 and 235, suggest PLC 240 was buried on top of PLC 241 and
PLC 236 was later than the others. AMS samples yielded a date associated with Event 4 (see below).
were taken from PLC 235 and 236 to evaluate In this sector, many camelids were also recovered.
their contemporaneity or difference in time. The They were located mainly on the east side of the
results show that PLC 235 (YU-13245) is slightly south sector, which appears to have been an exclusive
earlier than PLC 236 (YU-13251) but still within area for camelid interment. We obtained AMS dates
the range of the same event (subevent 3B). It is poss- from two of them (CA 72 and CA 82). They were
ible to argue that even subevent 3B could have buried resting on their backs, but their skull orien-
tation was not consistent, which indicated that
their long necks were twisted into different positions.
Due to their proximity and similarities in the way
they were buried, 18 contexts of buried camelids
were identified for this event in the south sector
(CA 94, 90, 89, 76, 75, 88, 58, 87, 91, 92, 68, 67,
73, 74, 71 and 93) (Figure 21). Some of these
burials had up to four individuals, comprising a
total of 33 camelids in this sector (Figure 10).
28
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Figure 20. (a) General view from north to south of PLC 236, 234 and 235. (b) PLC 234 (south) missing skull by later intrusion of
PLC 236. (c) Close-ups of sharp stones placed in the chest of PLC 234 and PLC 235.
Chimú occupation at Montículo 1), excluding the Although the absence of the typical cut marks on
burials placed in an extended position facing down, the sternum or any other perimortem injury may
were buried during subevent 3A and were all suggest that these are not victims of human sacrifice,
women between 16–17 and 40–50 years old, with their similarity with those found on top of the
most of them in their 20s at the time of death. mound in the same event (Event 3) suggest the oppo-
None showed evidence of fatal perimortem injuries, site. Two adult males (PLC 397 and PLC 3101),
and the typical position of their bodies was flexed each wearing a loincloth and one of them a simple
in a seated position facing north. Another interesting headdress (PLC-397), were buried in an extended
characteristic is that all show occipital flattening, position but facing down and with evidence that
unlike the majority of PLC children who show no their lower and upper limbs were tied. Both males
flattening, suggesting that they could have been also have occipital flattening, and no signs of injuries
from north of the Moche valley. PLC 3100, 3102 were observed. Along with the adult women, this
and 3103 were buried with painted textiles and sector yielded the largest concentration of adult indi-
tabards decorated with feathers, but unfortunately, viduals at PLC as well as the highest frequency of
they were not well preserved. PLC 3102 wore an occipital flattening (Figure 22).
elaborate headdress decorated with blue, red and Apparently, by the beginning of subevent 3B,
white feathers, and like PLC 3103, held valves of some offerings were made before the architectural
Spondylus shells in each hand (Figure 22). renovation project that changed the straight walls of
29
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
Figure 21. Selected photos of sacrificial victims found in the south sector of PLC and associated with Event 3. Selected burials of
camelids associated with Event 3, south sector at Pampa La Cruz.
the platform into inclined walls (Figure 7). During aquatic environment. They were placed in groups
this subevent, and close to the SW corner of of three, four and five shells. This alignment may
Montículo 1, a total of 40 complete Spondylus have been longer, but due to intense looting activity
shells were carefully aligned over an imaginary line on the west side of the site, many shells were lost,
over 20 meters in length (Figure 10). One AMS although a few were found still in place in this
measurement comes from a string attached to one sector. Close to the SW corner of the straight
of these shells (PSUAMS-4528, see Appendix 2). façade of Montículo 1, the Chimú deposited a
Almost all were tied with cotton string or sedge cache of ishpingo seeds (Nectandra sp.) from which
ropes, suggesting that the shells were still fresh at an AMS measurement was taken (YU-13283). This
the time of burial. The latter is suggested because ritual cache was found on the floor between the
bivalve mollusks tend to open once out of their straight façade and the new inclined façade of
30
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Figure 22. Details of the burials found in the southwest sector of Montículo 1. Burial event 3B. Details of PLC 3102 and 3103. Note
the feathered headdress, painted textile and Spondylus shells on each hand.
31
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
32
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
33
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
and 129 all were subadults between 8 and 10 years Northwest Corner on Montículo 1
old at the time of death and all had a transverse The last group of sacrificial burials during Event 3
cut on the sternum. Due to the spatial proximity was placed near the NW corner of Montículo 1. At
and the similarities in form of interment, other least two rows of burials were found as well as a
burials forming rows aligned from E-W can also be group of ten individuals (PLC 267, 268, 271, 273,
considered to belong to this event: PLC 135, 134 274, 275-E1, 275-E2, 277, 278 and 279) with
and 141. Another row aligned in the same direction especially rich clothing buried on top of the platform
contained PLC 122 and PLC 129. All individuals towards its NW end (Figure 10). Many more such
except PLC 122 had cut sterna and were between rich burials were located in the southern and
9 and 12 years old and all were wearing loincloths. central sector of the Montículo 1, but were heavily
Other burials were not aligned in rows, but were disturbed during the Colonial period by treasure
oriented similarly in an E-W direction (PLC 136, hunters. All these individuals were buried with deco-
208 and 123) (Figures 10 and 24). Immediately rated attire, including feathered headdresses and
north of the row defined by PLC 122 and 129, ornaments that suggest they could have been
two complete Spondylus shells were found members of the Chimú elite. Alternatively, these
wrapped in a string with ishpingo seeds. Nearby individuals may have been chosen and carefully
was another Spondylus valve and very close, a dressed to represent specific meanings/characters
partial skull of a monkey. To the west of these arti- during the sacrificial event, but were not necessarily
facts, a hole dug on the floor contained a cotton members of the Chimú elite (see discussion below).
fabric of 160 x 166 cm painted with red pigment, All of them except for PLC-279 were buried in a
depicting anthropomorphic and anthropo-zoo- seated position facing north. Another remarkable
morphic characters, surrounded by rectangular pat- similarity is that all (except PLC-278) had occipital
terns simulating small rooms and open spaces cranial modification, suggesting that they might be
(Figure 17). The size of the textile and the technique from north of the Moche valley. Only two individ-
used to paint the designs suggest that it may have uals show clear evidence of lethal injuries (PLC-
been used as a banner or a hanging, possibly on 271 and PLC 279). Almost all (except PLC 268
display during the sacrifice ceremony. An AMS and PLC 273) were buried with painted textiles,
date was obtained from one of the cotton yarns of feathered clothing or fancy headdresses. All ten
the painted textile, placing it in Event 3A (MF- burials had a valve of a Spondylus shell firmly
2021-PSU-8, see Appendix 2 and Figure 15). bound to each hand (Figure 25). Finally, the
Approximately 35 meters towards the NE, another bodies were placed in circular pits and covered with
hole dug in the floor contained a bundle containing stones. Five AMS dates are available for this cluster
several metal artifacts, including a pair of silver ears- of burials (Appendix 2). Two dates fall in subevent
pools, two silver plumes, a silver sheet shaped as a 3A (PLC 265 and PLC 279), while the dates taken
moon animal, four shawl pins, a miniature of a from PLC 271, 275 and 278 fall within the range
cylindrical copper-alloy crown and various other of subevent 3B.
metal artifacts that must have been adornments for Starting from the east side, three burials were very
textiles. Two miniatures of tabards and many green close to each other: PLC 271, PLC 267, and PLC
mineral beads were also recovered (Figure 18). An 268. PLC-271 is a child of about 12 years with occi-
absolute date obtained from a cotton yarn taken pital flattening who was struck on the forehead,
from the textiles that wrapped these artifacts placed resulting in a lethal perimortem fracture of the
the offering at the beginning of subevent 3B skull. This individual had either two impacts or a
(PSUAMS-6640 see Appendix 2 and Figure 15). single impact from a large oval-shaped weapon.
Apparently, this offering marked the northern Radiating fractures extend from the impact area
limit of the sacrificial space used during Event 3. across the right parietal (Figure 26). Once
34
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Figure 27. Attire of PLC 271. Note the bright color of the blue
feathers due to the excellent state of preservation. However, there
was an unusual concentration of salt on the cotton fabric of the
turban. Due to conservation issues, the headdress had to be
untied, cleaned, and then re-done, but it was impossible to get
the original shape despite our efforts to bring it back to its
original form. Figure 27-A shows the original way in which the
turban and the tabard were found prior to the conservation done
Figure 26. Cranial fracture of PLC-271. at the laboratory.
35
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
extra padding at the back. The body panel passed asymmetrical occipital flattening and no evidence
between the legs and was secured by the tie in of perimortem injuries who was wrapped in white
front, with the end hanging down, but in this cotton fabrics and dressed in a simple turban and
instance was broken off. The hands were wrapped loincloth. West of these three burials was another
with cotton straps, each holding a valve of cluster of four tombs carefully arranged. PLC 274
Spondylus shell. The entire body was wrapped in a was a young adult woman 19–24 years old with occi-
delicate cotton cloth. pital flattening, who was also placed in a flexed pos-
Toward the NE of PLC-271, another child of ition facing north. She had hair slightly below
about 11 years with occipital flattening (PLC-267) shoulder blade length, worn loose, and was wearing
was buried, but with no evidence of lethal injuries. in a painted dress with rows of a curving motif in
The child was wearing a cylindrical headdress deco- different colors that resembles a wave or the headdress
rated with blue and red feathers. On the front, the of Chimú fishermen (Campana 2012: 123, figure
headdress had three penaches made of green, blue, 137) (Figure 29(a and c)). Over the dress she wore
yellow, and red feathers. The headdress was sup- a cotton tabard decorated with blue feathers. She
ported on the small head of the child by a delicate also held in her lap a gourd bowl with two complete
textile with a warp-resist dyed (ikat) pattern of Spondylus shells (Figure 29(a and b)). Like the other
stepped zigzags in brown on the beige ground with burials, each hand was wrapped with cotton straps
blue overpainted in some areas (Figure 28). Like holding a valve of a Spondylus shell. This burial
PLC-271, the child was holding a valve of was facing PLC-275-E1 located immediately north
Spondylus shell in each hand, held in place with (Figure 29(a)). PLC-275 contained two individuals.
cotton straps. PLC-268 was found west of PLC One was another young adult woman who was 19–
267 and was a 10–11-year-old child with 21 years old at the time of death (PLC-275-E2)
showing mild occipital flattening, located north of
PLC 275-E1 but facing south, towards PLC-275-
E1. The latter was a subadult of 14 years old at the
time of death, with occipital flattening, who was
also placed in a flexed position, facing north.
36
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Neither showed evidence of a violent death, but three loom panels sewn together, mainly tan with
PLC-275-E2 had lost her upper front central incisors pairs of dark brown warp and weft stripes. The hori-
before death. Loss of these teeth at such a young age zontal stripes do not line up across the seams. The
is unlikely to be due to dental caries or abscesses. It is lower corners of the mantles have decoration outlined
possible that she lost the teeth traumatically due to a with a stepped border, with brocaded (supplemen-
blow to the face. Both bundles (PLC-275-E1 and tary-weft) patterning in camelid hair yarns, using a
275-E2) were covered by a simple cotton fabric mix of colors that differs from other known pieces:
which gave the impression of a single bundle, but dark red, yellow ochre, yellowish brown, a soft
when it was removed, two separate bundles were green, dark brown, black, and likely deep purple
documented. Each was covered by a large mantle without a regular color repeat. The supplementary
measuring approximately 225 x 332 cm made with weft is laid in between design areas and floats across
13 different strips of cotton fabric alternating the design areas, forming a scrolling design in hori-
brown (or tan in PLC-275-E1), blue, and check-pat- zontal bands. On the edges of the steps is a narrow
terned and with the outermost strips contrasting with border with a diamond design (Figure 31). Spots of
those in the center (Figure 30). The checks are made cinnabar were also applied to the neck area ( possibly
with brown cotton supplementary weft on a beige after face painting observed on the skull). Under this
ground. mantle, each individual wore a cotton tabard deco-
Each piece had been folded in half crosswise and rated with polychrome feathers. The tabard associ-
draped over the body with the warp vertical. ated with PLC-275-E2 is decorated with a vertical
Beneath this large mantle, each was covered on its stripe pattern of blue, red and yellow feathers. The
back with another mantle also folded in half cross- tabard associated with PLC-275-E1 has a more
wise, of thinner cotton fabric measuring approxi- complex design made of a background of blue feath-
mately 210 cm (before folding) x 140 cm, made of ers with a design of red feathers which could not be
Figure 30. Fragmentary large mantle, associated with PLC 275-E2, opened out after conservation. It was originally folded in half
crosswise but covering the entire mummy bundle of PLC-275-E2. A very similar mantle was found in the same position in association
with PLC-275-E1.
37
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
Figure 31. (a) Tan mantle shown folded in half along the
upper edge, with a pattern of pairs of dark brown warp and weft
stripes. Brocaded decoration using camelid fiber threads
representing polychrome scrolling motives and diamonds on the
edges. (b) Details of the polychrome scrolling motives and
diamonds (PLC-275-E1).
38
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
39
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
40
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
41
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
Figure 39. Partial view of textile associated with PLC-279 and the graphic reconstruction of the main design on this large hanging.
burials are contemporary (Appendix 2). All these PLC 260, 363 and 281 (Figure 10), indicates by its
individuals were placed in an extended position proximity that it also belongs to Event 3. These chil-
with the skull toward the east and the feet to the dren were between six and eight years old and none
west. They were children between seven to nine showed evidence of perimortem injuries.
years old at the time of death and only one, PLC-
264 had evidence of a cut on the sternum. PLC
342 and PLC 327 both have annular cranial modifi- Event 4 (cal. A.D. 1300/1320–1400/1420). Forty-
cation. Associated with PLC-266 was a bundle of cut four burials were associated with this event (46
canes and a few carved wooden sticks (Figure 40). bodies) (Appendix 1). This event seems to be as
South of this row is a second alignment of burials, large as the previous one, as indicated by a total of
16 AMS dates obtained from human and camelid
burials and one textile (PLC354, 228, 220, 346,
380, 238, 116, 373, PRALLO3-E2; camelids CA
62B, 81B, 117G, 15, PEALLO-CA 1, PRALLO-
CA 18 and textile PLC-A22-CS-TX 247) (Figures
41 and 42). The size of this event is also inferred
by the wide spatial distribution of victims, which
were placed as far as 80 meters from the SW corner
of Montículo 1. The identification of the
southernmost victims (human and camelid) was
possible thanks to the excavations carried out by
the rescue project directed by Victor Campaña and
sponsored by the City Hall of Huanchaco in 2012,
2017 and 2018 (Campaña and Prieto 2022). In
addition, a cluster of burials excavated by
Figure 40. Bundle of canes and carved wooden sticks found PAHUAN on the south end of Montículo 1 in
along with the body of PLC-266. 2018, suggests that part of that area, especially the
42
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Figure 41. Multiple plot showing the ranges of the AMS dates associated with Event 4.
west side had many victims sacrificed during Event Montículo 1 and on the NW side of PLC (Figure
4. Apart from the burials on the south sector, AMS 10). The lack of burials of this event in the area in
dates suggest that more interments associated with between is likely the result of the heavy looting
this event were made near the SW corner of observed in this sector of the site. Three
43
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
Figure 42. Group of burials associated with Event 4, note PLC-238 double burial and packs of camelids dated to this event.
characteristics distinguish Event 4. The most previous events. During Event 4, taking into
distinctive is that the burials no longer form rows consideration only the burials with AMS dates, the
aligned on an E-W axis. Another significant average age is between 9 and 13 years. Another
difference, although just one case has been detected notable difference is that the privileged treatment
by AMS measurements, is that for the first time observed in the special burials of Event 3, such as
two individuals were buried together in an decorated textiles and headdresses, was not present
extended position (PLC-238-E1, 12 years old and in the burials of Event 4. However, a date obtained
PLC-238-E2, ten years old) (Figure 42), although from a fine textile (MF-2021-PSU-14) found in the
the AMS date places this burial late in Event 4, and looted materials in the central sector of Montículo
it is possible that it dates to the earliest portion of 1, falls within Event 4, suggesting that elaborate
Event 5. The third characteristic is that the average burials may have been present closer to the center
age of the victims is slightly older than those in of Montículo 1, an area that was heavily looted
44
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
during the Colonial period (Figure 43). Based on the 15, PEALLO-CA 1 and PRALLO-CA 18 were all
bioarcheological analysis, all the burials (except PLC burials with more than three camelids each (Figure
354 and PLC 346) yielding AMS dates associated 42). For example, CA117 had a total of seven
with this event, have cuts on the sternum. As camelids. Immediately beneath these camelids
mentioned before, PLC-373 (YU-13233) was (CA117), 14 ceramic cups fired in a reduced
buried on top of PLC-385 (YU-13236), belonging atmosphere were found. The style and shape of the
to Event 2. Another difference from previous events cups resembles those of the Transitional period
is that camelids were buried in greater numbers observed at sites like San José de Moro (Rucabado
during this time, although that tendency was and Castillo 2003: 30, figure 1.6b), although these
already observed during Event 3. CA-62, 81, 117, ceramic vessels were clearly used during Event 4
(Figure 44).
45
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
Figure 44. Detail of eight of the set of 14 ceramic cups found under CA117, located on the SW corner outside of Montículo 1.
orientation and body position of the burials with AMS rectangular loincloth. His face is also painted red,
dates for this period, suggesting that the practices and his hands appear to have been crossed on his
observed in the previous event continued in use. In chest. More details are not visible, since it is a very
terms of the camelids, there seems to be a preference schematic depiction compared with the previous
to bury more than one together, and in most cases one. An interesting element is the presence of a
with the neck twisted in such a way that the head was sedge rope around his neck, which suggests that he
toward the south or SW (Figure 46). Of all the child may represent a captive. One AMS date was obtained
burials with AMS dates, only PLC 240 and 214 did from the sedge rope found around the neck
not show transverse cuts on the sternum. (PSUAMS-6638, Appendix 2). Another unique
In addition to the children and camelids, two finding was an elongated hearth on the west edge
wooden sculptures were found on the NW end of of the excavation area, possibly associated with the
the excavated area (Figure 47). Both were beautifully sacrificial event. Due to their stratigraphic proximity
carved. The shafts on the lower part of these wooden and similarities in terms of burial patterns and cloth-
sculptures suggest that these were part of an altar or ing, it was difficult to distinguish burials of Event 5
possibly a now-destroyed entrance, since in Chimú and 6 without AMS dates. Therefore, only a few of
architecture, wooden sculptures are commonly them are shown with suggested dates, while many
placed at the principal access to sacred precincts others are of uncertain date (Appendix 1).
(Donnan 2014: 142, figures 35–36; Gayoso Rullier
and Gamarra Carranza 2023). One has a length of Event 6 (cal. A.D. 1450–1500). Twenty burials were
43 cm. and depicts a hunchback anthropomorphic associated with this event (28 bodies) (Appendix 1).
figure wearing a “V” shaped loincloth and a rectangu- This is the last event of sacrifices documented at PLC.
lar hat standing on a “T” shaped base. His right hand The range of absolute dates suggests that it must have
rests on his abdominal area while the left holds a cup occurred after the Incas had conquered the Chimú
or a beaker. His face is painted with red pigment, and empire. A total of eight AMS measurements are
he wears a pair of cylindrical earspools. The other available, derived from child and camelid burials
wooden sculpture is 112 cm. in length and the (PLC 103, 118, 137, 138, 359 and PRALLO E-11;
upper part depicts an anthropomorphic being in a CA 4 and 19) (Figures 48 and 49). Most of the dates
slightly flexed position, wearing a conical hat and a come from burials found on the west side of
46
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Figure 45. Multiple plot showing the ranges of AMS dates associated with Event 5.
47
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
Figure 46. Burials and camelid associated with the Event 5 from which AMS dates have been obtained, indicating their absolute
chronological affiliation with Event 5.
Montículo 1, and from the SW corner of Montículo was a multiple burial context with children of 8, 9
1. We hypothesize that many burials were disturbed and 10 years of age, while PLC 359 had children of
due to their proximity to the surface. One of the between 6.5 and 8.5 years of age. Finally, like the
main differences from the previous event is that the children from Event 5 they were wrapped in large
bodies of the children were placed in diverse mantles and dressed in hats or turbans or both, with
orientations and body positions compared to previous loincloths, and sometimes tunics, usually of
events, primarily flexed on their side on a S-W axis, undecorated cotton. In some cases, camelids were
with fewer placed in an E-W extended position. placed on top of the bodies, just as was seen for Event
Another difference is that the sacrificial victims were 5 and at HLL (Figure 50).
often buried in pairs or in a group of three, although One burial is different from the others. It was
there are also examples of individual burials. PLC 137 found by the Salvage Project (PRALLO) in 2017
48
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Discussion
At the beginning of this article we proposed that
sanctioned violence was at the core of the Chimu pol-
Figure 47. Wooden idols found in association with Event 5.
itical ideology. Sanctioned violence is envisioned
Figure 48. Multiple plot showing the AMS dates for Event 6.
49
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
50
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Figure 50. Hats, shirts, and loincloths, Event 6. First row: PLC-103-E2, PLC-137-E2 and PLC-137-E1. Second row: PLC-103-E2,
PLC-137-E1, PLC-359-E1. Third row: PLC-210, PLC-211 and PLC-137-E1. Fourth row: PLC-137-E2.
here as a method of social domination and the for the specific case of PLC, a scenario of structural
execution of power over others. This way of exerting violence based on skeletal evidence does not seem
control over others changed over time in Chimú to apply. This of course does not imply that struc-
society, but it was always materialized through child tural violence was not present in the Chimú
and camelid mass sacrifices. Under this model and empire, but that in this case, the bioarchaeological
51
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
evidence does not support it. Examples of structural Pampa La Cruz records a sequence of at least six
violence have been reported for other regions and sacrificial events occurring between cal. A.D. 1050/
timeframes in the North Coast of Peru. For 1100 and cal. A.D. 1450/1500. Five centuries of
example, in the Lambayeque region, the early Late continuous human and camelid sacrifices indicate
Intermediate Period case of mass sacrifice at Cerro that sanctioned violence was central in Chimú reli-
Cerrillos and the Late Horizon sacrifices at gious practice and not just a desperate response to cli-
Chotuna-Chornancap and at Túcume show elevated matic or political crisis, as was previously thought
frequencies of skeletal and dental indicators of stress. (Prieto et al. 2017, 2019). We have identified 247
This evidence suggests that victims of sacrifice at human victims and approximately 211 camelids in
these sites were from a lower social class (Klaus six sequential events (and some possibly divided
et al. 2010; Toyne 2011; Wester et al. 2010). In con- into subevents), confirmed by 80 calibrated AMS
trast, the sacrificed children from Huanchaquito-Las dates (Appendix 2). Two hundred twenty-nine
Llamas and PLC appear to have been in good health, bodies were securely associated with one of the six
without evidence of nutritional or metabolic indi- events, while 18 bodies were impossible to link with
cators in the skeleton or teeth that was noted in the one of the proposed sacrifice events (Appendix 1).
Lambayeque cases and some other sacrificial Future investigations may help to solve this
samples in Peru and elsewhere (Verano et al. 2022). problem. Although Events 1 and 2 seem to be the
As previously mentioned, the concept of massacre smallest sacrificial events in terms of number of
does not apply to the PLC case, although other cases victims, this could be the result of sampling and
have been reported for Chimú and contemporary recovery bias, so a note of caution should be con-
societies. This is certainly the case of the massacre sidered when these numbers are evaluated. Event 3
identified by Toyne at the site of Kuélap at is the largest and most complex event yet reported
Chachapoyas, where the population targeted by at PLC, but again this could be an illusion given
the perpetrators were men and children, suggesting by the location and emphasis of our excavations.
that the goal of the massacre was likely the annihil- Events 4, 5 and 6 are underrepresented in terms of
ation of the community (Toyne 2018). Under this the numbers of sacrificial victims since these bodies
perspective, neither the Huanchaquito Las Llamas are closer to the surface and could have been severely
nor the PLC case fit in the concept of a massacre. affected by looting, especially during the Colonial
The only point in common is the large number of and early Republican periods (Hrdlicka 1911,
victims. Similarly, based on cranial modification 1914). Our excavations revealed later Chimú sacrifice
and stable isotopic evidence from Huanchaquito events only had a minor impact on burials from
Las Llamas, only 20% or less of the victims seem earlier ones, which suggests that a master plan for
to have a foreign provenience, assuming that the the distribution and layout of the victims was in
remaining 80% were locals or members of Chimú place at the time of each new sacrificial event,
society living in the Chan Chan area. The systematic which knew and respected the location and position
way in which the children were killed, the careful of former offerings.
disposal of the bodies after death, and the fact that Subevents are clear during Event 3A and 3B, but
most of them were locals, are all indicators of a cer- others can be suggested if we take into consideration
emonial act rather than a frenetic or planned revenge the variability in radiocarbon years (Appendix 2).
against an enemy. The victims were brought from This observation reinforces our main point: human
different locations and social backgrounds but may and camelid sacrifices were more regular among the
have been from medium high or high status families Chimú than previously thought. Another general
based on their excellent health for the standards of conclusion of this research is that the way of dispatch-
the Late Intermediate Period on the North Coast ing the sacrificial victims was from the beginning a
of Peru. single clean transverse cut across the sternum,
52
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
although these cuts were not universally observed in occurred in a permanent state of climatic instability
all the victims. There is also a clear pattern that (Dillehay et al. 2004; Wells 1990). In the following
this sacrificial method became more systematic paragraphs, we would like to link the six sacrificial
during later events (4, 5 and 6) than during the events found at PLC to the larger context of
earlier ones (1, 2 and 3), suggesting that some Chimú society, especially the political, economic
victims were dispatched in other ways ( possibly stran- and religious realms, rather than restricting them
gulation with a rope or cloth that left no skeletal evi- solely to ENSO events.
dence), particularly in the case of adult women and Events 1 and 2 (1050–1220 cal. A.D.) are chrono-
males (Figure 51). logically related to the first centuries of Chimú political
Previous research has identified large ENSO events organization. This is the time when a historical dynasty,
occurring in the Moche valley as early as A.D. 1050/ probably ruled by a powerful leader named Taycanamo,
1100 and around A.D. 1250, which caused severe who later became the mythical founder of the Chimú,
damage to the irrigation infrastructure built by the came to power in the Moche valley. His successor,
Chimú around the city of Chan Chan (Nials et al. Guacricaur, was possibly the ruler who politically
1979). Evidence indicates that one or more ENSO reclaimed the lands in the Moche and neighboring
events of lesser intensity may have impacted the valleys (Moore and Mackey 2008; J. H. Rowe 1948).
Peruvian North Coast between cal. A.D. 1050/ Therefore, if we can establish a correlation between his-
1100–1450/1500 (Billman and Huckleberry 2008; torical and archaeological data, the first sacrificial events
Wells 1990). We suggest that not all the sacrificial at PLC may have taken place a few decades after the
events identified at PLC can be hypothesized to be founding of Chan Chan and the rise of a powerful
a response to one of these climatic events. dynasty that ruled the valley and neighboring lands.
Paleoclimatic records suggest that the emergence, According to previous research, this was a time of exten-
consolidation and expansion of the Chimú state sive construction of irrigation canals, especially on the
northern side of the valley surrounding Chan Chan
(Moseley and Deeds 1982; Nials et al. 1979). These
lands included but were not limited to the arid
pampas around Pampa La Cruz, especially the NE
sector of the site (Figure 3(b)). However, current
interpretation suggests that the irrigation canal system
and the agricultural fields were damaged by floods
and then partially abandoned after the Mega ENSO
event reported elsewhere for the Moche valley around
A.D. 1100 (Nials et al. 1979). Refining our chronologi-
cal data, Event 1 must have been before the occurrence
of the Mega ENSO event in the Moche valley, while
Event 2 could have occurred several decades after this
climatic anomaly. If we are correct, then Events 1 and
2 are not linked with the climate phenomenon of
A.D. 1100; rather, they could have been performed to
consecrate the construction of the irrigation system
and to keep it functioning after several challenges,
including the impact of ENSO events. The orientation
of bodies during the earliest event (W-E) could be an
intentional connection with the newly irrigated lands,
Figure 51. Mosaic of cuts on sternums. since those were located immediately east of
53
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
Montículo 1 at PLC. The discovery of a ceremonial rarely present in previous events (Events 1 and 2) and
knife associated with Event 1, which had on its clearly absent in later events (Events 4, 5 and 6). A
surface four lumps of mud intentionally placed on few adult males, always facing down, are also a charac-
top, may symbolize a connection between the sacrifice teristic of Event 3 and were not found in other events.
and the mud which might represent either irrigated At this time also a large quantity of Spondylus shells
lands or mud from ENSO floods (see Figure 13). were buried in E-W alignments along with bundles
Another indicator of possible connections between containing silver and copper-alloy metal miniatures
the sacrificial events and ENSO activity is that PLC and scattered feathers of exotic birds on the ceremonial
361 was placed on a surface of wet mud that left an platform (Figures 16–18).
imprint of the body during Event 2. The high frequency and variability of cranial modifi-
This evidence does not rule out a connection cation, adult victims, and precious artifacts (Spondylus
between ENSO events and the first sacrificial events shells, metal miniatures, and feathers) indicates a more
at PLC. It also points to the establishment and func- complex ritual associated with the mass sacrifice of chil-
tioning of the irrigation system built by the Chimú dren and perhaps the intentional display of a larger
near PLC. Events 1 and 2 at PLC are chronologically network of connections with greater access to valuable
connected with a similar context reported at the site goods. Therefore, Event 3, which took place around
of Huaca Santa Clara in the Virú Valley. There, 11 cal. A.D. 1220–1300 could have been performed
children and 28 camelids were sacrificed in a very during Chimú military campaigns or territorial/social
similar way. Indeed, most of the children were expansion resulting from political alliances. To the
placed on a W-E orientation, similar to the one high occurrence of cranial modification can be added
observed for Event 1 at PLC, suggesting that the the presence of one child (PLC-372) with a successful
Chimú performed synchronic child and camelid trepanation that could suggest that this individual may
sacrifice ceremonies in the Virú valley and in have come from the highlands or the northeast
Huanchaco (Millaire and Surette 2011). montane forest of the Andes. On the other hand, the
In contrast, Event 3 (cal. A.D. 1220–1300) seems to clothing buried with some victims appears consistent
correspond to a period of Chimú territorial expansion, with similar pieces in several burials. Unfortunately,
most likely the historical era attributed to textile documentation is scarce on the whole north
Ñançempinco and his descendants (Moore and coast during this period, and it is difficult to compare
Mackey 2008; J. H. Rowe 1948). This period represents the excavated garments with those found elsewhere.
a time of an active and dynamic Chimú state, possibly But they all have north coast technical features, which
expanding militarily over a vast territory south and are found not only in the Chimú heartland but also
north of the Virú-Moche-Chicama region. We extending north, south (exactly how far is unclear),
cannot rule out the possibility of more conciliatory or and into the adjacent highlands. Again, while they are
diplomatic strategies, which may have involved political technically consistent with the clothing described in
alliances and treaties. The latter strategy (diplomacy and Ann Rowe’s Costumes and Featherwork of the Lords of
political alliances) is perhaps where Event 3 at PLC Chimor (1984), she views the pieces from Event 3 of
could be framed. As previously mentioned in this PLC as stylistically slightly more conservative (and thus
paper, this is the event with the highest diversity of arti- earlier), or from slightly farther north, if the clothing is
ficial cranial modification among children, including understood to correlate with the cranial modification.
an annular form and occipital flattening, suggesting a It is tempting to hypothesize that the sacrifice of
higher diversity in the geographic origin and ethnicity non-Chimú victims during Event 3 may have been
of the victims in comparison with previous and later part of a Chimú political strategy to establish political
sacrificial events at PLC.4 The same is true for the affiliations or to consolidate conquests under their
adults associated with Event 3. This event also has the regime. This is an open question that has been
highest frequency of adolescent and adult women, suggested for the Inca practice of Capa Cocha,
54
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
where political favors, alliances and ethnic affiliation We would like to suggest that the women buried
were central to child sacrifice events (Besom 2009; along with the sacrificed children during Event 3 at
Duviols 1976; Reinhard and Ceruti 2005; Schroedl PLC were either closely related to the children or
2008). Was Event 3 at PLC in Huanchaco a singular were representatives of their local lineages or family
event, or could it be possible that many others were groups. Their sacrifice at PLC may represent alliances
performed around and in the city of Chan Chan at or affiliations between their hypothetized family
about the same time? The existence of two penaches groups or home regions and the Chimú state. The
of feathers with unknown provenience, one stored at standardized body as well as the decoration of the tex-
the American Museum of Natural History (AMNH) tiles, position and orientation, especially facing north,
and the other whose location is currently unknown may intentionally reference their geographic origins in
(see King 2012: 183, plate 51 for the one at the the neighboring Chicama, Jequetepeque, or
AMNH and Reid and de Lavalle 1987: 248 for the Lambayeque valleys (Fernandez 2019).
one without a current location) are both identical Event 3 is also contemporaneous with the massacre
to the penache found in association with PLC 271 reported by Walde and Verano at Punta Lobos, in the
(Figure 27). Assuming they are not from PLC, they Huarmey valley (Verano and Toyne 2011). This scen-
could represent a sacrificial event from elsewhere ario suggests that Event 3 occurred when the Chimú
around Chan Chan. were aggressively expanding over a vast territory along
Interestingly, all women buried at PLC during the north coast of Peru between cal. A.D. 1200–
Event 3 had no sign of a violent death visible on 1300. Both scenarios, military conquests or political
their skeletons (but see above case of PLC-279). negotiations, could have been sealed through the offer-
They could have been dispatched by strangulation, ing of children and women who were ultimately sacri-
poisoning, or some other form of suffocation. These ficed at PLC as part of the interactions with non-
women were all buried in a flexed and seated position Chimú groups. Preliminary biodistance analysis
facing north, holding Spondylus shells in each hand suggest genetic variabililty among the sacrificed chil-
and when the preservation allowed, dressed in beauti- dren at PLC (Sutter and Prieto 2023). Further analysis
ful clothing with painted decoration or with poly- of stable isotopes (light and heavy), and ancient DNA
chrome feathers (Fernandez et al. 2020). All the variation may help to affirm or question this hypothesis.
women also had occipital flattening, suggesting that Events 4 and 5 (1300–1450 cal. A.D.) are contem-
they may have come from further north, where this porary with the moment of Chimú apogee as an
cranial modification is more common during this empire or as an expansionist state along the coast of
period than in the Moche valley. Izumi Shimada has present-day Peru (Moore and Mackey 2008;
noted that young and adult women with similar J. H. Rowe 1948). At this time Chan Chan became
cranial modification were buried in elite tombs of the most powerful pre-industrial city in the New
the Lambayeque or Sicán society at Batán Grande World and an important political, religious, and econ-
around cal. A.D. 950–1100 (Shimada 1995; omic hub along the Andean coast. This corresponds to
Shimada et al. 2004: 375). An interesting suggestion the large number of children buried during these
made by Shimada and his team is that these women events, possibly greater in number than Event
may have represented different segments of Sicán 3. The location of the victims, based on AMS data,
nobility and society, recreating a symbolic affiliation indicates that the sacrificial area extended as far
between them and the moieties they represented. south as 100 meters from the Montículo 1 or ceremo-
According to Shimada and colleagues, Sicán rulers nial platform, with an average surface of 5500 square
had, through ritualized weddings or political alliances meters on the upper part of PLC alone. We are not
in life, access to these social connections sealed with considering the burials present on the west and
wedding arrangements, somewhat similar to strategies lower side of PLC (La Poza) which could add
used by the Inca nobility (Hernandez Astete 2005). another two hectares of area with potential sacrificed
55
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
victims. Given the massive looting and the inability to The fact that around 1400–1450 cal. A.D. (Event 5),
excavate the lower sector or La Poza, the total number four sites were actively participating in camelid and child
of victims for Events 4 and 5 could be substantially sacrifices (HLL, PLC, JO-IG and EP) (Prieto and
larger than that reported here. Verano in press), suggests a peak in Chimú sanctioned
The standardized burial pattern, sacrificial tech- violence and demonstrates the power and resources avail-
nique, and similarity of the clothing buried with the able to the religious and political apparatus of the Chimú
children, as well as the large number of camelids sacri- state. Interestingly, during this time of the Chimú apogee
ficed during these events, indicate the power of represented by Events 4 and 5, the children were dressed
Chimú during this time. It is interesting to note that in a sort of “uniform” which consisted of an undecorated
the age of the subadult victims was higher than in pre- loincloth with the front panel passed under the tie and
vious events. Our data show that the preferred age then over it, covering the legs, a short, sleeved tunic,
during Events 4 and 5 was between 9 and 13 years and a turban. The turbans consisted of at least two
old, in contrast with the 8 to 10 observed in previous plain fabrics wrapped successively around the head and
events. The number of children and especially camelids secured around the outside with a tightly woven (weft-
sacrificed during these events shows a mature state with faced) narrow band, knotted and with tassels falling
the capacity of hosting large sacrificial events. Also clear over the left side of the head (Figure 50). Some of
is the importance of camelids during Events 4 and 5, these bands had simple painted designs, but this has
where burial pits contained from two to seven and not been observed at PLC. Events 4 and 5 are when
sometimes even 10 young camelids. Camelids and cut marks across the sterna are more frequently observed
their importance for Chimú religion and daily subsis- in the sample at PLC, and dominant at the site of
tence have been discussed elsewhere (Goepfert and Huanchaquito Las Llamas (HLL) (Prieto et al. 2015,
Prieto 2016; Pozorski 1976, 1982; Topic 1990). 2019). Their frequency indicates a standardized and
Hundreds of these precious animals were killed for reli- more systematic way of dispatching the victims (Figure
gious ceremonies held at PLC and then at JO-IG and 51). The presence of wooden sculptures at PLC during
HLL. The high selectivity in age (6–9 months) and Event 5 suggests the intention of creating spaces like
coat color (mostly brown) shows the capacity of the those at the palaces of Chan Chan and other ceremonial
Chimú state to gather these animals from state herds buildings like Huaca Taycanamo and El Dragon on the
but also from non-state sponsored farms (Goepfert northeast side of Chan Chan (Gayoso Rullier and
et al. 2020). At PLC, during Events 4 and 5, camelids Gamarra Carranza 2023; Jackson 2004; Prieto and
were preferentially buried in groups or multiple burials, Burmester 2015; Schaedel 1966). The wooden sculp-
sometimes containing ceramic vessels (like the 11 cups tures may mark a sort of formalized space around
found with CA-117, see Figure 44) or with ceramic Montículo 1, which was decorated with similar sculp-
spindle whorls from previous occupations intentionally tures. The presence of various double burials during
added to the camelid burials (Brito et al. 2020). The Event 5 indicate that a new pattern was emerging: boys
discovery of a fragment of fine textile (Figure 43) with and girls sacrificed and buried together, possibly creating
an AMS date within the range of Event 4 in the symbolic “weddings” between the parts. This idea has
looting pit located in the central sector of the ceremo- been proposed for the Inca Capa Cochas, where symbolic
nial platform or Montículo 1 at PLC indicates that unions served to create social bonds between the groups
either (a) elite burials were placed there during this giving away their offspring for the sacrificial ceremonies
event or (b) elaborate textiles were also offered in the (Besom 2009; Reinhard and Ceruti 2005). If the oppo-
central sector of the ceremonial platform during site sex of the subadults in these dual burials can be
Event 4. Both scenarios show the importance of PLC demonstrated, we may be seeing a Chimú version of
as a ceremonial site for the mass sacrifice of children, the same idea: ritualized unions in the afterlife that
adults, camelids, and fine textiles. cemented not only the relationship among the relatives
56
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
of the victims with the Chimú state, but also among their own variety in open areas, close to the ocean
different Chimú families. and in mass sacrificial grounds, where previous
Finally, Event 6 (1450–1500 cal. A.D.) fell within events had been hosted. Capa Cochas are known to
the timeframe when the Incas had conquered the have been made in close connection with the Inca
Chimú. Therefore the mass sacrifice at PLC may emperor’s life, health, and political desire. In contrast,
document (a) the very last child sacrifice performed the Inca found that the Chimú child and camelid
by the Chimú, or (b) a continuation of this Chimú sacrifices were made by the state apparatus, not necess-
practice under Inca domination (as has been docu- arily related to the king. The Chimú motivations
mented at the Temple of the Sacred Stone at could have been to cement their relationships with
Túcume, in the Lambayeque valley, and at alterations to the natural environment (irrigation pro-
Chotuna-Chornancap (Toyne 2011; Wester et al. jects on arid lands), as a response to extraordinary
2010)). We believe that the sacrifice of children climate or telluric calamities (like ENSO events)
and camelids did continue after the Inca conquest, and/or to strengthen social relations among conquered
since it was an important structural element of territories and within Chimú society.
Chimú religion and politics. It seems to have been Under the Chimú, human sacrifice acquired a new
so important that the Incas continued its practice, dimension on the North Coast of Peru, going beyond
following previous practices observed during Events mere situational responses to natural disasters. It
4 and 5. The undyed clothing observed in previous became a dramatic and visual experience that
events, with the loincloth, tunic, and turban helped to build their empire, maintain social
uniform, continued. However, it was noted pre- control, and cement their social interactions. The
viously that individuals of Event 6 were also buried PLC case is a good example of the continuity and
wrapped in a loosely woven cloth (1 x 1 plain long-lasting tradition of human sacrifices during
weave) and then covered with a heavier cotton more than 500 years in the heart of the Moche
shroud (2 x 1 plain weave). This double shrouding valley during the Late Intermediate Period and the
was not observed in previous events. Late Horizon. It opens a window into a previously
There also were more children buried in pairs, and unknown ritual practice and offers new opportunities
sometimes even three individuals. Camelids were to explore social dynamics and to reconstruct the
more commonly buried on top of the children but structural principles that underpinned Chimú social
outside of the shroud that wrapped the child. Also, organization and ideological system(s).
more individuals were buried in an extended but
slightly flexed position on one side, on an S-N axis,
although the E-W was still prevalent for the PLC
site. Most of the victims associated with this event Notes
were located on the west side of Montículo 1, but
this could be simply the result of destruction of 1 At the time this paper was finalized, during the 2022
field season, a total of 67 new sacrificial victims were
other areas by looting activity. We should not forget
documented, 47 of which were found on top of
that at the beginning of the twentieth century, Ales Montículo 2, located on the NE end of Pampa La Cruz.
Hdrlička reported hundreds of subadult bones scat- 2 During the 2022 field season, the excavations
tered across the surface of this site, which were possibly carried out on top of Montículo 2 have yielded 47
the most superficial burials of Event 6, those disturbed children with cuts on their sterna.
by Colonial and Republican looters. 3 PRALLO (Proyecto de Rescate Arqueologico Las
Lomas de Huanchaco) and PEALLO (Proyecto de
If we are correct, the Incas found that their Capa
Evaluacion Arqueologico Las Lomas de
Cocha practice had a similar Chimú version, but Huanchaco) refers to the Salvage Projects sponsored
instead of burying a few children in remote places by the City Hall of Huanchaco in 2012 and 2017-
like ice-capped mountains, the Chimú practiced 2018.
57
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
4 Previously, it was noted that during Event 1 and 2, a and Traditional Cultures of Latin America.
few individuals with occipital flattening and annular Radiocarbon dates were obtained by a multitude of
modification were reported. funding sources especially from Start-Up funding
given to Prieto from the Office of Research and the
Acknowledgements College of Liberal Arts and Sciences, University of
Florida, the Humanities Scholarship Enhancement
The 2016–2019 field seasons were possible thanks to Fund of the University of Florida and Nilaya
funding provided to the first author of this manuscript Productions (Especially to Marianne Jestaz and
by the Peruvian government: INNOVATE PERU, con- Jérôme Scemla). Special thanks to Dr. Yuichi
trato 354-15; Proyecto Concytec-Banco Mundial Matsumoto and the team directed by Dr. Fuyuki
“Mejoramiento y Ampliación de los Servicios del Tokanai, Center for Accelerator Mass Spectrometry,
Sistema Nacional de Ciencia Tecnología e Innovación University of Yamagata. Similarly, special thanks to
Tecnológica” 8682-PE, a través de su unidad ejecutora Dr. Brendan Culleton, Energy and Environmental
ProCiencia [contrato número 07-2018-FONDECYT- Sustainability Laboratories, Penn State Radiocarbon
BM-IADT-MU], as well as a grant from the National Laboratory and Laurie Eccles, Department of
Geographic Society, Grant # 305R-18. Special thanks Anthropology, Penn State University. Special thanks
to Kurt Mutchler, Kristin Romey, Robert Clark, to Manuel Lizarraga and Christian Moncada, supervi-
Mark Thiessen and Rebecca Hale, at National sors of the Huanchaco Archaeological Program, as
Geographic Society. The second author of this manu- well as to all the staff and students (graduate and under-
script received support for the research at Pampa La graduate) from the University of Florida and the
Cruz from the National Geographic Society Universidad Nacional de Trujillo who participate in
Committee for Research and Exploration, Grant the Huanchaco Archaeological Program between 2016
#9830-15 (2018-2019), The Roger Thayer Stone and 2022. We would like to acknowledge Dr. Andrew
Center for Latin American Studies Summer Faculty Nelson and Dr. Haagen Klaus for their excellent sugges-
Research Grants (2018, 2022) and the Tulane School tions to improve this manuscript. Finally, special thanks
of Liberal Arts Faculty Research Award (2019). The to Daniel Hernandez who worked on formatting the
excavations at Pampa La Cruz were also supported in extensive bibliography for this manuscript. This
2016 and 2018 by MOCHE INC, Dr. Brian material is based on work supported by the National
Billman, and the University of North Carolina at Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship
Chapel Hill Field School Program. The conservation program under Award #1842473 (JARP), and the
and study of the textiles presented in this paper were National Academies of Science, Engineering, and
possible thanks to the National Geographic Society Medicine Ford Foundation Predoctoral Fellowship
(Grant # EC-58047R-19) given to Luis Flores and to (JARP). Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or rec-
the 2019 Ambassador Funds for the Conservation of ommendations expressed in this material are those of the
the Huanchaco Cultural Heritage given by The authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the
Embassy of The United States of America in Peru National Science Foundation or the Ford Foundation.
given to P.I. Prieto. Special thanks to former U.S.
Ambassador in Peru Dr. Krishna Urs, Vanessa Disclosure Statement
Wagner, Cultural Senior Specialist at the American
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the
Embassy in Lima, Peru as well as to Arabel Fernandez
author(s).
Lopez, Lisbeth Pariona and all the students from the
Universidad Nacional de Trujillo who participated in Notes on contributors
this project. Archaeological excavations in 2021 and
2022 were supported by the University of Florida and Gabriel Prieto is at the Department of
the Study Abroad Program, UF in Peru: Archaeology Anthropology, University of Florida, Gainesville,
58
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
FL, USA (ogabriel.prietob@ufl.edu). Prieto (PhD in edu). Professor Sutter interests include the Peopling of
Anthropology, Yale University 2015) is the Director the New World, South American Archaeology,
of the Huanchaco Archaeological Project. Mortuary Analysis, Prehistoric Ethnicity,
John Verano is at the Department of Anthropology, Bioarchaeological Theory and Methods, and Human
Tulane University, New Orleans, LA, USA (verano@ Behavioral Ecology. He has ample experience in investi-
tulane.edu). He got his Ph.D. in anthropology from gation human remains of the north coast of Peru.
the University of California Los Angeles in 1987. He Aleksalia Isla, Programa Arqueologico
is a biological anthropologist who specializes in Huanchaco, Trujillo, Peru (aleksaalayo21@gmail.
human skeletal anatomy, paleopathology, bioarchaeol- com). Isla is an Andean archaeologist with experience
ogy, and forensic anthropology. in the North Coast of Peru.
Ann Pollard Rowe is at The George Washington Khrystyne Tschinkel is at the Department of
University Museum, The Textile Museum, Anthropology, Tulane University, New Orleans, LA,
Washington, DC, USA (aprowe@gwu.edu). Ann USA (ktschink@tulane.edu). Tschinkel obtained her
Pollard Rowe spent most of her career as Curator of Ph.D. at Tulane University, investigating the health
Western Hemisphere Textiles at The Textile Museum and social dynamics of Chimu-Inca and Contact
in Washington, DC, and is now Research Associate Period populations in the North Coast of Peru.
there. She has curated many exhibitions and written cat- Rachel Witt is at the Department of
alogues for Warp-Patterned Weaves of the Andes, A Anthropology, Tulane University, New Orleans,
Century of Change in Guatemalan Textiles, Costumes LA, USA (rwitt@tulane.edu). Witt has recently
and Featherwork of the Lords of Chimor, and Hidden defended her Ph.D. thesis. Her dissertation research
Threads of Peru: Q’ero Textiles (with John Cohen). combines bioarchaeology and biogeochemistry to
Feren Castillo, Escuela de Arqueologia, Facultad de reconstruct trauma, diet, and migration patterns to
Ciencias Sociales, Universidad Nacional de Trujillo, examine how policies and practices of ancient
Trujillo, Peru (fcastillol@unitru.edu.pe). Castillo is an societies impact the life histories of child sacrifices
archaeologist focused on the social complexity in the in prehistoric Peru.
North Coast of Peru and particularly in the Viru Valley. Andres Shiguekawa, Programa Arqueologico
Luis Flores, Programa Arqueologico Huanchaco, Huanchaco (shigue2@gmail.com). Shiguekawa is a
Trujillo, Peru (lfdelaoliva@gmail.com). Flores is an conservator with vast experience in Archaeological
Andean archaeologist with experience in the North artifacts of the Central Andean región.
Coast of Peru. Jordi A. Rivera-Prince is at the Department of
Julio Asencio, Programa Arqueologico Huanchaco, Anthropology, University of Florida, Gainesville,
Trujillo, Peru (alasencio23@gmail.com). Asencio is a FL, USA ( jriveraprince@ufl.edu). Her research
Bachelor in Social Sciences with experience in the focuses on the emergence of social inequality in
archaeology of the North Coast of Peru. small-scale ancient maritime communities in the
Alan Chachapoyas, Programa Arqueologico Moche Valley, North Coast of Peru. Specifically,
Huanchaco, Trujillo, Peru (alanchflores93@gmail. her work employs a bioarchaeological and mortuary
com). Chachapoyas is an Andean archaeologist with archaeology perspective to study the La Iglesia site,
experience in the North Coast of Peru. a Salinar cemetery excavated in Huanchaco.
Victor Campaña, Proyecto de Rescate Arqueologico Celeste Marie Gagnon is at the Department of
Las Lomas de Huanchaco, Huanchaco, Peru. (vitu. Anthropology, Wagner College, Staten Island, NY,
cale@gmail.com). Campaña is an Andean archaeologist USA (celeste.gagnon@wagner.edu). Gagnon is an
with experience in the North Coast of Peru. anthropologist specializing in examining skeletal
Richard Sutter is at the Department of indicators of diet and disease and interpreting these
Anthropology, Indiana University – Purdue University data within archaeological and biocultural contexts.
at Fort Wayne, Fort Wayne, IN, USA (sutterr@pfw. She investigates the dietary and health consequences
59
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
of sociopolitical change and how changes in diet and Jordi A. Rivera Prince http://orcid.org/0000-0001-
health affect economic, social, and political lives. Her 8865-3011
research areas include the Moche Valley of North Celeste Marie Gagnon http://orcid.org/0000-0003-
Coastal Peru and the Susquehanna Valley of New 0112-3240
York and Pennsylvania. Fuyuki Tokanai http://orcid.org/0000-0002-
Carlos Avila-Mata is at the University of Florida, 3563-3882
Gainesville, FL, USA (cavilamata@ufl.edu). Avila- José M. Capriles http://orcid.org/0000-0001-
Mata is a former undergraduate student at the 6046-0939
University of Florida.
Fuyuki Tokanai is at the Center for Accelerator
Mass Spectrometry, University of Yamagata,
Yamagata-shi, Japan (tokanai@sci.kj.yamagata-u.ac. References Cited
jp). Tokanai is an expert on processing Mass Aldama, Wilder
Spectrometry at Yamagata University, Japan. 2020 Informe del analisis de pigmentos arqueologicos del
Claver W. Aldama-Reyna is at the Laboratorio de Programa Arqueologico Huanchaco. Manuscript
Óptica y Láseres, Departamento Académico de on file, Department of Anthropology,
Física, Universidad Nacional de Trujillo, Trujillo, Universidad Nacional de Trujillo, Peru.
Anderson, Cheryl, and Debra Martin
Peru (caldama@unitru.edu.pe). Claver W. Aldama-
2018 Introduction. In Massacres. Bioarchaeology and
Reyna is a Research Professor and Group Leader of Forensic Anthropology Approaches, edited by
the Optics and Lasers Laboratory at the National Cheryl Anderson, and Debra Martin, pp. 1–11.
University of Trujillo. He received his Ph.D. in University Press of Florida, Gainesville, FL.
Physics from the National University of Trujillo. Angelats, Luis
José M. Capriles is at the Department of 2021 Informe de pigmentos verdes y blancos Chimú del sitio
Pampa La Cruz - Huanchaco, aplicando microscopia
Anthropology, Penn State University, State College,
EDS (Espectroscopia de Rayos X de Energia
PA, USA ( juc555@psu.edu). Dr. Capriles is an Dispersiva). Manuscript on file, Universidad
anthropological archaeologist specializing in environ- Privada Antenor Orrego, Trujillo, Peru.
mental archaeology, human ecology and zooarch- Arnold, Denise, and Christine Hastorf
aeology. Before joining Penn State University, he 2008 The Captured Fetish, the Mountain Chest and
was a Visiting Scholar at the University of Sacrifice. Routledge, Oxfordshire.
Barr, Genaro
Pittsburgh (2012-2013), a Chilean FONDECYT
1991 La Poza Alta. Un proyecto de rescate arqueolo-
Postdoctoral Researcher (2013–2015) and an gico en Huanchaco. Revista del Museo de
Assistant Professor at Universidad de Tarapacá Arqueologia, Antropologia e Historia de Trujillo
(2015–2016). 2:39–48. doi:10.1002/ajpa.20514.
Barr, Genaro, Cesar Lecca, Edgardo Silva, and Julio
Vasquez
1986 Investigaciones arqueológicas en el Montículo I de
ORCID Pampa La Cruz Huanchaco, valle de Moche: Un
estudio preliminar. Professional Practice Report,
Gabriel Prieto http://orcid.org/0000-0001-6229- BA Archaeology. School of Archaeology,
986X College of Social Sciences, Universidad
John Verano http://orcid.org/0000-0002-0263- Nacional de Trujillo, Peru.
5611 Barth, Georg J
1993 Native American Beadwork. Edited by
Feren Castillo http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5242-
R. Schneider and Stevens Point, pp., 138–145.
5885 Wisconsin, R. Schneider.
Khrystyne Tschinkel http://orcid.org/0000-0001- Beck, Colleen
5199-8550 1979 Ancient Roads on the North Coast of Peru. Ph.D
60
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
61
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
2020 Excavaciones en la Iglesia de Huanchaco De Vore, William E., Keith P. Jacobi, and David H. Dye
(Sector Iglesia Colonial). In Programa 2018 Rethinking Massacres. A Biorchaeological and
Arqueológico Huanchaco. Informe Técnico Anual Forensic Investigation of Prehistoric Multiple
2019, edited by Gabriel Prieto, pp. 304–358. Burials in the Tennessee River Valley. In
Informe Anual Presentado al Ministerio de Massacres. Bioarchaeology and Forensic
Cultura del Peru, Trujillo, Peru. Anthropology Approaches, edited by Cheryl
Chachapoyas, Alan, and Rachel Witt Anderson, and Debra Martin, pp. 12–36.
2020 Excavaciones en el Sitio Arqueológico El Pollo. University Press of Florida, Gainesville, FL.
In Programa Arqueológico Huanchaco. Informe Dillehay, Tom, Alan L. Kolata, and Mario Pino
Técnico Anual 2019, edited by Gabriel Prieto, 2004 Pre-industrial Human and Environment
pp. 244–303. Informe Anual Presentado al Interactions in Northern Peru During the Late
Ministerio de Cultura del Peru, Trujillo, Peru. Holocene. The Holocene 14(2):272–281.
Chimoven, Anthony, Ernesto Olazo, Diego Santamaria, Dominguez, Jonatan
Jennifer Toledo, and Astrid Vasques 2019 Relaciones núcleo - periferia entre asentamientos
2016 Estudio del Patron Funerario durante el Horizonte domésticos Chimú Tardío y Chimú Inca en el
Tardio y Periodo Colonial Temprano en el Sector valle de Moche: el caso La Joyada. Bachellor’s
Sur de la Iglesia Colonial de Huanchaco, valle de Degree Thesis, School of Archaeology, College
Moche. Informe de Practicas Pre-Profesionales. of Social Sciences, Universidad Nacional de
Submitted to Escuela de Arqueologia, Facultad Trujillo, Peru.
de Ciencias Sociales, Universidad Nacional de Domínguez, Jonatan, and Gabriel Prieto
Trujillo, Trujillo, Peru. 2019 La relación núcleo-periferia entre asentamientos
Contreras, Daniel A del periodo Chimú Tardío y Chimú Inca en el
2022 Stages. Periods, and Radiocarbon, 14C. Dating in valle de Moche: el caso de La Joyada. In Actas
the Archaeology of the Central Andes. Ñawpa deI V Congreso Nacional de Arqueología, Volume
Pacha – Journal of the Institute of Andean I, 63–71. Ministerio de Cultura del Perú, Lima.
Studies 42(2): 205–233. Donnan, Christopher, and Leonard Foote
Cornejo, Luis 1978 Appendix 2: Child and Llama Burials from
2005 Un Jardin en el Desierto: La Metafora. In Huanchaco. In Ancient Burial Patterns of the
Chimú. Laberintos de un Traje Sagrado, edited Moche Valley, Peru, edited by Christopher
by Luis Cornejo, and Carole Sinclaire, pp. Donnan, and Carol Mackey, pp. 399–408.
40–61. Museo Chileno de Arte Precolombino, University of Texas Press, Austin.
Santiago de Chile. Donnan, Christopher
Covey, R. Alan 2014 Huaca dos Cabezas. Nawpa pacha 34(2):117–146.
2020 Inca Apocalypse: The Spanish Conquest and the Donnan, Christopher, and Carol Mackey
Transformation of the Andean World. Oxford 1978 Ancient Burial Patterns of the Moche Valley, Peru.
University Press, New York, USA. University of Texas Press, Austin.
Cruz, G, D Lázaro, L Pariona, and J Vilca Dufour, Elise, Nicolas Goepfert, Manon Le Neün,
2019 Contextos funerarios del Horizonte Medio en el com- Gabriel Prieto, and John W. Verano
plejo arqueológico Huacas del Sol y de la Luna. 2020 Life History and Origin of the Camelids
Professional Practice Report, BA Archaeology, Provisioning a Mass Killing Sacrifice During the
School of Archaeology, College of Social Chimú Period: Insight from Stable Isotopes.
Sciences, Universidad Nacional de Trujillo, Peru. Environmental Archaeology 25(3):310–324.
Cutright, Robyn Duviols, Pier
2010 Comida, familia e imperio: relacionando 1976 La Capacocha: mecanismo y funcion del sacrifi-
cambios políticos y domésticos en la periferia cio humano, su proyeccion geometrica, su
del Jequetepeque. In Comparative Perspectives on papel en la politica intergracionista y en la econ-
the Archaeology of Coastal South America, edited omia redistributiva del Tawantinsuyu. Allpanchis
by Robyn Cutright, Enrique Lopez-Hurtado, 9:11–58.
and Alexander Martin, pp. 27–44. Fondo Eeckhout, Peter
Editorial PUCP Center for Comparative 2017 Ofrendas rituales, peregrinaciones y ancestros.
Archaeology, University of Pittsburgh, Lima, In Pachacamac. Oraculo en el Horizonte Marino
Pittsburgh and Quito. del Sol Poniente, edited by Denise Pozzi-Escot,
62
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Luis Millones, and Jose Canziani, pp. 222–237. Gayoso Rullier, Henry L., and Nadia V. Gamarra
Coleccion Arte y Tesoros del Peru BCP, Lima. Carranza
2005 Imperial Strategies in a Regional Context: 2023 De Palacios a Mausoleos: Nuevas Evidencias e
Chimús and Incas at Pachacamac. In Wars and Interpretaciones Sobre Los Accesos de Los
Conflicts in Prehispanic Mesoamerica and the Conjuntos Amurallados de Chan Chan, Perú.”
Andes (BAR International Series 1385), Vol Latin American antiquity 34(1): 97–115
1385, edited by Peter Eeckhout, and Genevieve Goepfert, Nicolas, Elise Dufour, Gabriel Prieto, and John
Le Fort, pp. 110–127. Oxbow Press, Oxford. Verano
Escobedo, Manuel, and Emilio Rubio 2020 Herds for the Gods? Selection Criteria and Herd
1982 Liberacion Arqueologica en La Poza, Huanchaco. Management at the Mass Sacrifice Site of
Informe General Presentado al Instituto Nacional Huanchaquito-Las Llamas During the Chimú
de Cultura La Libertad. Manuscript on file. Period. Northern Coast of Peru. Environmental
Instituto Nacional de Cultura, Trujillo, Peru. Archaeology 25(3):296–309.
Farrington, IS, and CC Park Goepfert, Nicolas, and Gabriel Prieto
1978 Hydraulic Engineering and Irrigation 2016 Offering Llamas to the Sea. The Economic and
Agriculture in the Moche Valley, Peru: c. A.D, Ideological Importance of Camelids in the Chimú
1250–1532. Journal of Archaeological Science 5 Society, North Coast of Peru. In The Archaeology
(3):255–268. of Andean Pastoralism, edited by José M. Capriles,
Fernandez, Arabel and Nicholas Tripcevich, pp. 197–210. University
2019 Los tejidos de Pampa la Cruz. Informe Final pre- of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.
sentado al Dr. Gabriel Prieto B. Director del Hamilton, Andrew James
Programa Arqueológico Huanchaco. Trujillo, 2016 New Horizons in Andean Art History. Record of
Peru the Art Museum, Princeton University 75/
Fernández, Arabel, Gabriel Prieto and Andrés Shiguekawa. 76:42-101.
2020 Fifteenth Century costume of elite Children Hernandez Astete, Francisco
buried at Pampa la Cruz, Perú. Paper presented 2005 La mujer en el Tahuantinsuyo. Fondo Editorial
at The Annual New Research in Dress History Pontificia Universidad Catolica del Peru, Lima.
Conference. 18-21 August 2020. Organized by Hogg, Alan G., Timothy J. Heaton, Quan Hua, Jonathan
The Association of Dress Historians. G. Palmer, Chris S. M. Turney, John Southon, Alex
Gothenburg, Sweden. Bayliss, Paul G. Blackwell, Gretel Boswijk, Christopher
Fernandez, Arabel, Gabriel Prieto, and Luis Flores Bronk Ramsey, Charlotte Pearson, Fiona Petchey, Paula
2022 Aspectos tecnológicos y simbólicos de un con- Reimer, Ron Reimer, and Lukas Wacker
junto de tapices Moche con escenas complejas 2020 SHCal 20, Southern Hemisphere Calibration, 0–
de Pampa La Cruz, Huanchaco, Costa Norte 55,000 Years cal BP. Radiocarbon 62(4):759–778.
del Perú. Arqueologicas 31:45–81. Hrdlicka, Ales
Flores, Luis 1911 Some Results of Recent Anthropological Exploration
2020 Excavaciones en la Iglesia de Huanchaco (Sector in Peru. Smithsonian Miscellaneous Collections,
Colegio José Olaya). In Programa Arqueológico Vol. 56, No. 16. Smithsonian Institution,
Huanchaco. Informe Técnico Anual 2019, edited Washington, DC.
by Gabriel Prieto, pp. 158–243. Informe Anual 1914 Anthropological Work in Peru in 1913, with Notes on
Presentado al Ministerio de Cultura del Peru, the Pathologies of Ancient Peruvians. Smithsonian
Trujillo, Peru. Miscellaneous Collection, Vol. 61, No. 18.
Franco, Regulo, and Cesar Galvez Smithsonian Institution, Washington, DC.
2005 Muerte, identidades y practicas funerarias post- Hubert, Henri, and Marcel Mauss
mochicas en el Complejo El Brujo, valle de 1964 Sacrifice: Its Nature and Function. University of
Chicama, costa norte del Peru. In Muerte y Chicago Press, Chicago.
Evidencias Funerarias en los Andes Centrales: Iriarte, Francisco
Avances y Perspectivas. Actas del III Seminario de 1965 Los Trabajos de Rescate Arqueologico en el sitio La
Arqueologia UNFV, Vol. 1, edited by Claudio Poza de Huanchaco. Manuscript on file,
Olaya, and Mariana Romero, pp. 79–118. College Patronato de Cultura de Trujillo, Peru.
of Humanities, Universidad Nacional Federico Jackson, Margaret
Villarreal and J&R AENAGO Associates, Lima. 2004 The Chimú Sculptures of Huacas Tacaynamo
63
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
64
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
65
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
Porter, Anne, Thomas McClellan, Susanne Wilhelm, Jill O’Neill, Matthew J. Walsh, Marianne Moen,
Weber, Alexandra Baldwin, Jean Colley, Brittany Enriquez, and Svein H. Gullbekk. Routledge, Oxfordshire.
Meagan Jahrles, Bridget Lanois, Vladislav Malinov, Prieto, Gabriel, John Verano, and, Nicolas Goepfert
Sumedh Ragavan, Alexandra Robins, and Zarhuna Safi 2017 Lluvias e inundaciones en el siglo XV de nuestra
2021 “Their Corpses will Reach the Base of Heaven”: A era: sacrificios humanos y de camelidos Chimú
Third-Millennium BC war Memorial in Northern en la periferia de Chan Chan. In Actas II
Mesopotamia? Antiquity 95(382):900–918. Congreso Nacional de Arqueologia, Vol. 1, edited
Pozorski, Shelia by Ministerio de Cultura del Peru, pp. 55–65.
1976 Prehistoric Subsistence Patterns and Site Economics MCP, Lima.
in the Moche Valley, Peru. PhD dissertation, Prieto, Gabriel, John W. Verano, Nicolas Goepfert,
Department of Anthropology, The University Douglas Kennett, Jeffrey Quilter, Steven LeBlanc, Lars
of Texas at Austin. Fehren-Schmitz, Jannine Forst, Mellisa Lund, Brittany
1982 Subsistence Systems in the Chimú State. In Chan Dement, Elise Dufour, Olivier Tombret, Melina
Chan: Andean Desert City, edited by Michael Calmon, Davette Gadison, and Khrystyne Tschinkel
Moseley, and Kent C. Day, pp. 177–196. 2019 A Mass Sacrifice of Children and Camelids at the
University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque. Huanchaquito-Las Llamas Site, Moche Valley,
Pozorski, Thomas G Peru. PLOS ONE 14(3):e0211691.
1980 Las Avispas: plataforma funeraria. In Chan Chan, Quilter, Jeffrey, Marc Zender, Karen Spalding, Régulo
Metropoli Chimú, edited by Rogger Ravines, Franco Jordán, César Gálvez Mora, and Juan Castañeda
231–242. Instituto de Estudios Peruanos, Lima. Murga
Prieto, Gabriel 2010 Traces of a Lost Language and Number System
2014 El Fenómeno Lambayeque en San José de Moro, Discovered on the North Coast of Peru.
valle de Jequetepeque: Una perspectiva desde el American Anthropologist 112(3):357–369.
valle vecino. In Cultura Lambayeque. En el Rabinowitz, Joel
Contexto de la Costa Norte del Peru, edited by 1983 Lengua Pescadora. The Lost Dialect of Chimú
Julio Cesar Fernandez, and Carlos Wester, pp. Fishermen. In Investigations of the Andean Past.
107–137. EMDECOSEGE S.A., Chiclayo. Papers from the First Annual Northeast
Prieto, Gabriel, and Angie Burmester Conference on Andean Archaeology and
2015 El Entorno Sagrado de Chan Chan. ARKINKA Ethnohistory, edited by Daniel H. Sandweiss,
240:96–105. pp. 243–267. Ithaca, NY
Prieto, Gabriel, and Jonatan Domínguez Ralph, Sarah
2018 El Camino Prehispánico 1 de Huanchaco, valle 2013 Introduction. An Interdisciplinary Approach to the
de Moche: un tramo olvidado del Qhapaq Study of Violence. In The Archaeology of Violence:
Ñan. Cuadernos del Qhapaq Ñan 5(5):100–125. Interdisciplinary Approaches, edited by Sarah
Prieto, Gabriel, and Helen Chavarria Ralph, pp. 1–13. State University of New York
2017 La ocupacion domestica Moche en Pampa la Press, State University of New York, Albany.
Cruz - Huanchaco. ARKINKA 261:78–87. Ramirez, Susan
Prieto, Gabriel, Nicolas Goepfert, Katya Valladares, and 2004 El mundo alreves. Contactos y conflictos transcultur-
Juan Vilela ales en el Peru del siglo XVI. Fondo Editorial
2015 Sacrificios de Niños, Adolescentes y Camelidos PUCP, Lima.
Jovenes durante el Intermedio Tardio en la Reid, James, and Jose Antonio de Lavalle
Periferia de Chan Chan, Valle de Moche, Costa 1987 La Textileria del Reino Chimor. In Chimú. Arte y
Norte del Peru. Arqueologia y Sociedad 27: Tesoros del Peru, edited by Jose Antonio de Lavalle,
255–296. 138–249. Banco de Credito del Peru, Lima.
Prieto, Gabriel, and John Verano Reinhard, Johan, and Constanza Ceruti
in press From Brave Warriors to Innocent Children: 2005 Sacred Mountains, Ceremonial Sites, and Human
Understanding the Foundations of Ritual Sacrifice among the Incas. Archaeoastronomy 19:
Violence in the Moche Valley, North Coast of 1–43.
Peru Between 200–1450 A.D. In Human Rengifo, Carlos
Sacrifice and Value. Revisiting the Limits of 2021 Chan Chan: esplendor y legado. Redescubriendo la
Sacred Violence from an Archaeological and antigua capital del Chimor. Ministerio de Cultura
Anthropological Perspective, edited by Sean del Peru, Trujillo.
66
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
67
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of the Institute of Andean Studies
68
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Verano, John, and Gabriel Prieto Wester, Carlos, Fausto Saldaña, Samuel Castillo, and
2020 Ritual Violence in the Ancient Andes: Haagen Klaus
Archaeological Evidence from Northern Coastal 2010 Huaca de los Sacrificios. In Chotuna-Chornancap.
Peru. In Rituelle Gewalt – Rituale der Gewalt. Templos, Rituales y Ancestros Lambayeque, edited by
Ritual Violence – Rituals of Violence. 12. Carlos Wester, pp. 57–108. Ministerio de
Mitteldeutscher Archäologentag vom 10. Bis 12. Educación. Unidad Ejecutora N° 111 “Naylamp
Oktober 2019 in Halle (Saale), Vol. 22, edited Lambayeque”. Museo Arqueológico Nacional
by Harald Meller, Roberto Risch, Kurt W. Alt, Bruning - Lambayeque Chiclayo, Lambayeque,
Francois Bertemes, and Rafael Mico, pp. Peru.
529–542. Tagungsbände des Landmuseums für Witt, Rachel, Gabriel Prieto, Alan Chachapoyas, and John
Vorgeschichte Halle. Museum for Prehistory Verano
Halle, Germany. 2022 Death that Endures: A Bioarchaeological and
Verano, John, Anne Titelbaum, Bebel Ibarra Ascencios, Biochemical Study of Human Sacrifices from the
and Melissa Lund Valle Moche Valley, Peru. Paper presented at the
2016 The Northern Highlands and Cloud Forest. In Annual Conference of the Institute of Andean
Holes in the Head: The Art and Archaeology of Studies, Berkeley, CA.
Trepanation in Ancient Peru Vol. 38, edited by Witt, Rachel
John W. Verano, pp. 141–174. Dumbarton 2023 Death that Endures: A Bioarchaeological and
Oaks Research Library and Collections Studies Biogeochemical Study of Human Sacrifices from
in Pre-Columbian Art and Archaeology, the Late Intermediate Period and Late Horizon,
Washington, DC. Moche Valley, Peru. Unpublished Ph.D.
Verano, John, and Marla Toyne Dissertation, Anthropology Department,
2011 Estudio Bioantropológico de los restos humanos Tulane University. New Orleans, LA.
del sector II, Punta Lobos, Valle de Huarmey. In Xerez, Francisco de
Arqueología de La Costa de Ancash. Boletín Del 1938 Verdadera relación de la Conquista del Perú y
Centro de Estudios Precolombinos de La Provincia del Cuzco llamada la Nueva Castilla.
Universidad de Varsovia, Vol. 8, edited by G Biblioteca de Cultura Peruana, primera serie,
Milosz, pp. 421–446. l’Institut français no. 2, pp. 15–115. Desclée, De Brouwer, Paris.
d’études andines, Varsovia. Originally published 1534 (the quote is on
Verano, John, Khrystyne Tschinkel, and Gabriel Prieto p. 52 in this edition).
2022 Healthy, But Doomed: Paleopathological Profile Yamamoto, Atsushi
of Chimú child sacrifices at Huanchaquito 2007 El reconocimiento del valle de Huancabamba,
and Pampa la Cruz, northern Peru. Paper presented Jaen, Cajamarca, Peru. Arqueos. Revista
at the 49th Annual North American Meeting of the Electronica de Arqueologia PUCP 2(2):1–16.
Paleopathology Association, Denver, CO. Yoffee, Norman
Vogel, Melissa 2005 Myths of the Archaic State. Cambridge University
2012 Frontier Life in Ancient Peru. The Archaeology of Cerro Press, Cambridge.
la Cruz. University Press of Florida, Gainesville. Zeballos, Elvira.
Weber, Max 2020. Informe del Analisis de pigmentos y enlucidos del
1991 [1921] From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology. sitio Pampa La Cruz, Huanchaco. Manuscript
Translated and edited by H.H. Gerth and on file, Crystalography Laboratory, College of
C. Wright Mills. Routledge, London. Physics, Universidad Nacional Mayor de San
Wells, Lisa E Marcos, Peru.
1990 Holocene History of the El Nin∼o pHenomenon Zuidema, Tom
as Recorded in Flood Sediments of Northern 1964 The Ceque System of Cuzco: The Social Organization
Coastal Peru. Geology 18(11):1134–1137. of the Capital of the Inca. E.J. Brill, Leiden.
69
Appendices
Appendix 1
Bioarchaeological profiles of all the sacrificial victims found at PLC during the 2016-2019 PAHUAN excavations. This table includes at the end the
25 Chimú burials excavated by the rescue project between 2017-2018 (Campaña and Prieto 2022). Event numbers in black have secure temporal
association by 14C dates. Event numbers in red mean indirect temporal association with an event, based on similarity or physical proximity to a
nearby dated burial or other archaeological context.
flexed
PLC-101- PLC 3 sup 6 12 n/a yes yes N-S Resting on
E3 its back and
lower limbs
flexed
PLC-102 PLC 3 sup 6 9 n/a yes N-S Lateral
flexed
PLC-103- PLC 3 sup 6 5-6 n/a annular yes E-W Resting on
E1 its back and
lower limbs
flexed
PLC-103- PLC 3 sup 6 12 n/a yes E-W Resting on
E2 its back and
lower limbs
flexed
PLC-104 PLC 3 sup 6 12 n/a yes fractures on two teeth? E-W Resting on
its back and
lower limbs
flexed
Continued
Continued
PLC Cut
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Sacrificial Cut on marks Body Body
Burial # Site Area Level Event Age Sex Cranial modification Sternum on ribs Fractures orientation position
PLC-105 PLC 3 sup 6 13-15 n/a yes W-E Resting on
its back and
lower limbs
flexed
PLC-106 PLC 3 1 6 10 n/a n/a E-W Resting on
its back and
lower limbs
flexed
PLC-107 PLC 3 sup 6 12-13 n/a yes E-W Lateral
flexed?
PLC-108- PLC 3 1 6 15 n/a yes yes E-W Resting on
E1 its back and
lower limbs
flexed
PLC-108- PLC 3 1 6 9 n/a yes E-W Lateral
E2 flexed
PLC-109 PLC 3 sup 6 15 n/a yes N-S Lateral
71
flexed
PLC-110 PLC 3 1 5 12-15 n/a n/a N-S Extended
PLC-111 PLC 3 sup 5 7-8 n/a yes E-W n/a
PLC-112 PLC 3 1 5 8-9 n/a yes n/a n/a
PLC-114- PLC 3 sup 5 9 n/a n/a E-W Resting on
E1 its back and
lower limbs
flexed
PLC-114- PLC 3 sup 5 ? n/a n/a E-W n/a
E2
PLC-116 PLC 3 1 4 12-15 n/a yes W-E Extended
PLC-118 PLC 3 sup 6 10 n/a n/a E-W Lateral
flexed
PLC-122 PLC 3 1 3 9 n/a n/a E-W Extended
PLC-123 PLC 3 RC1 3 6 n/a n/a E-W Extended
PLC-128 PLC 3 RC1 3 n/a n/a n/a E-W Extended
PLC-129 PLC 3 3 3 9 n/a annular yes E-W Extended
PLC-131 PLC 3 sup 6 14-15 n/a yes W-E Lateral
flexed
Continued
Continued
PLC Cut
Sacrificial Cut on marks Body Body
Burial # Site Area Level Event Age Sex Cranial modification Sternum on ribs Fractures orientation position
PLC-132 PLC 3 sup 5 11 n/a yes yes W-E Lateral
flexed
PLC-134 PLC 3 2 3 11 n/a yes yes E-W Extended
PLC-135 PLC 3 2 3 12 n/a yes E-W Extended
PLC-136 PLC 3 2 3 12 n/a yes E-W Extended
PLC-137- PLC 3 2 6 9 n/a yes W-E Lateral
E1 flexed
PLC Cut
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Sacrificial Cut on marks Body Body
Burial # Site Area Level Event Age Sex Cranial modification Sternum on ribs Fractures orientation position
PLC-207 PLC 18 RC1 5 12 n/a yes Healing rib fracture E-W Resting on
its back and
lower limbs
flexed
PLC-208 PLC 18 RC1 3 8 n/a yes yes E-W Extended
PLC-209 PLC 18 RC1 5 13.5 n/a annular yes yes E-W Extended
PLC-210- PLC 17 RC1 6 13.5 n/a yes W-E Lateral
E1 flexed
PLC-210- PLC 17 RC1 6 11 n/a yes E-W Lateral
E2 flexed
PLC-211 PLC 17 RC1 6 11.5 n/a yes E-W Extended
PLC-212 PLC 17 RC1 6 11 n/a yes E-W Extended
PLC-213 PLC 17 RC1 6 12 n/a yes E-W Extended
PLC-214 PLC 18 RC1 5 9 n/a no E-W Extended
PLC-215 PLC 16 RC1 4 7.5 n/a yes E-W Extended
PLC-216 PLC 16 RC1 4 10.5 n/a annular yes E-W Extended
PLC-217 PLC 18 RC1 5 12 n/a n/a E-W Resting on
73
PLC Cut
Sacrificial Cut on marks Body Body
Burial # Site Area Level Event Age Sex Cranial modification Sternum on ribs Fractures orientation position
PLC-223- PLC 17 RC1 6 12 n/a n/a n/a n/a
E2
PLC-224 PLC 17 RC1 5 12 n/a yes yes E-W Resting on
its back and
lower limbs
flexed
PLC-225 PLC 16 RC1 3 9 n/a yes yes E-W Extended
with lower
limbs
crossed
PLC-230 PLC 16 RC1 3 13 n/a occipital flattening yes E-W Extended
PLC-231 PLC 16 RC1 3 8 n/a yes E-W Resting on
its back and
lower limbs
flexed
PLC-232 PLC 16 RC1 3 9 n/a yes yes E-W Extended,
facing
down
PLC-233 PLC 16 RC1 2 n/a n/a n/a Healed fracture, third E-W Extended
(R3-10)
PLC-234 PLC 16 RC1 3 8 n/a Tabular erect, no E-W Extended
bilobular cranial
modification.
PLC-235 PLC 16 RC1 3 6 n/a yes yes E-W Extended
PLC-236 PLC 16 RC1 3 13 n/a yes E-W Extended
Continued
Continued
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
PLC Cut
Sacrificial Cut on marks Body Body
Burial # Site Area Level Event Age Sex Cranial modification Sternum on ribs Fractures orientation position
PLC-237 PLC 16 RC1 4 12 n/a no E-W Lateral
flexed
PLC-238- PLC 16 RC1 4 12 n/a yes yes E-W Extended
E1
PLC-238- PLC 16 RC1 4 10 n/a yes yes E-W Lateral
E2 flexed
PLC-239 PLC 16 RC1 3 11 n/a yes E-W Extended
PLC-240 PLC 16 RC1 5 12 n/a no E-W Extended
PLC-241 PLC 16 RC1 3 10 n/a yes yes E-W Extended
PLC-242 PLC 16 RC1 3 10 n/a yes yes E-W Extended,
missing
lower limbs
PLC-243 PLC 16 RC1 3 9 n/a yes yes E-W Extended
PLC-244 PLC 17 RC1 4 12 n/a yes yes E-W Extended
PLC-245 PLC 16 RC1 3 11 n/a yes E-W Lateral
flexed
PLC-246 PLC 16 RC1 3 9 n/a annular yes yes E-W Lateral
75
flexed
PLC-247 PLC 16 RC1 3 11 n/a yes yes E-W Extended
PLC-248 PLC 16 RC1 3 12 n/a no yes E-W Extended
PLC-249 PLC 16 RC1 3 7 n/a yes yes E-W Extended
PLC-250 PLC 16 RC1 3 7 n/a annular yes yes E-W Extended
PLC-251 PLC 16 RC1 3 7 n/a yes yes E-W Extended
PLC-252 PLC 19 RC1 4 13 n/a yes E-W Resting on
its back and
lower limbs
flexed
PLC-253 PLC 20 RC1 2 12 n/a yes E-W Extended
PLC-254 PLC 20 RC1 2 9 n/a Angular(depression) of n/a E-W Extended
frontal bone.
PLC-255 PLC 20 RC1 2 n/a n/a n/a E-W Extended
PLC-256 PLC 20 RC1 2 11 n/a no E-W Extended
PLC-257 PLC 20 RC1 2 11 n/a n/a E-W Extended
PLC-258 PLC 20 RC1 2 13 n/a no E-W Extended
PLC-259 PLC 21 RC1 2 9 n/a annular no E-W Extended
Continued
Continued
PLC Cut
Sacrificial Cut on marks Body Body
Burial # Site Area Level Event Age Sex Cranial modification Sternum on ribs Fractures orientation position
PLC-260 PLC 21 RC1 2 6-7 n/a Mild occipital n/a E-W Extended
flattening
PLC-261 PLC 16 RC1 4 or 5? 10 n/a Mild occipital no E-W Extended
flattening with lower
limbs flexed
PLC-262 PLC 16 RC1 3 8 n/a yes E-W Extended
PLC-263 PLC 21 RC1 2 12-13 n/a yes E-W Extended
of the skull.
PLC-272 PLC 21 RC1 3 8 n/a no yes E-W Extended
PLC-273 PLC 21 RC1 3 16-18 female Symmetrical occipital n/a S-N Seated
flattening
PLC-274 PLC 21 RC1 3 19-24 female Occipital flattening no S-N Seated
PLC-275- PLC 21 RC1 3 14 n/a Occipital flattening no S/N Seated
E1 with notable bilobular
shape due to expanded
parietals.
PLC-275- PLC 21 RC1 3 19-21 female Mild occipital no Asymmetrically-fused N-S Seated
E2 flattening, slightly coccyx (healed
asymmetrical fracture?). Upper front
central incisors were
lost antemortem. Loss
at such an early age
unlikely due to caries/
abscesses. Perhaps lost
traumatically (blow to
face).
Continued
Continued
PLC Cut
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Sacrificial Cut on marks Body Body
Burial # Site Area Level Event Age Sex Cranial modification Sternum on ribs Fractures orientation position
PLC-276 PLC 21 RC1 3 7 n/a Angular flattening on no E-W Extended
the frontal
PLC-277 PLC 21 RC1 3 16-19 female Occipital flattening no E-W Seated
asymmetrical
PLC-278 PLC 21 RC1 3 8 n/a no S-N Seated
PLC-279- PLC 21 RC1 3 8 n/a no n/a n/a
E1
PLC-279- PLC 21 RC1 3 20 female Occipital flattening no S-N Lateral
E2 flexed
PLC-280 PLC 21 RC1 3 8-10 n/a n/a E-W Extended
PLC-281 PLC 21 RC1 3 6 n/a no E-W Extended
PLC-301 PLC 22 RC1 1 n/a n/a n/a E-W Extended
PLC-302 PLC 20 RC1 3 7 n/a n/a E-W Extended
PLC-303 PLC 20 RC1 2 8 n/a yes E-W Extended
PLC-304 PLC 20 RC1 2 5 n/a no E-W Extended
PLC-305 PLC 22 RC1 4 13 n/a yes W-E Extended
PLC-306 PLC 22 RC1 4 8 n/a yes E-W Extended
77
PLC Cut
Sacrificial Cut on marks Body Body
Burial # Site Area Level Event Age Sex Cranial modification Sternum on ribs Fractures orientation position
PLC-323- PLC 22 RC1 4 n/a n/a no N-S Extended
E1
PLC-323- PLC 22 RC1 ? 10 n/a no n/a n/a
E2
PLC-324 PLC 23 RC1 2 10 n/a no Well healed left E-W Extended
proximal femur
fracture
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
PLC Cut
Sacrificial Cut on marks Body Body
Burial # Site Area Level Event Age Sex Cranial modification Sternum on ribs Fractures orientation position
PLC-348 PLC 21 RC1 ? n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
PLC-349 PLC 21 RC1 3 n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
PLC-350 PLC 20 RC1 3 10 n/a no E-W Extended
PLC-351 PLC 20 RC1 ? 15 n/a no n/a n/a
PLC-352 PLC 23 RC1 2 11 n/a yes E-W Extended
PLC-353 PLC 23 RC1 3 n/a n/a E-W Extended
PLC-354 PLC 23 RC1 4 6 n/a Mild occipital no S-N Seated
flattening
PLC-355 PLC 23 RC1 4 11 possybly n/a W-E Seated
male
PLC-356 PLC 21 RC1 4? late male n/a E-W Extended
adolescent
PLC-359 PLC 21 RC1 6 6.5-8.5 n/a no S-N Lateral
flexed
PLC-361 PLC 20 RC1 2 10 n/a yes E-W Extended
PLC-362 PLC 20 RC1 2 n/a n/a n/a E-W Extended
PLC-363 PLC 20 RC1 3 n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
79
PLC Cut
Sacrificial Cut on marks Body Body
Burial # Site Area Level Event Age Sex Cranial modification Sternum on ribs Fractures orientation position
PLC-377 PLC 20 RC1 3 12 n/a yes yes Healed trephination at E-W Extended
the back of the head,
right side (right
parietal notch)
PLC-378 PLC 20 RC1 4 12-13 n/a yes yes Lost perimortem - E-W Extended
upper first left and
right first premolars,
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
PLC Cut
Sacrificial Cut on marks Body Body
Burial # Site Area Level Event Age Sex Cranial modification Sternum on ribs Fractures orientation position
PLC-392 PLC 21 RC1 2 11-12 n/a no E-W Extended
PLC-393 PLC 20 RC1 3? 7-8 n/a n/a E-W n/a
PLC-395 PLC 20 RC1 3 13-14 n/a yes yes E-W Extended
PLC-396 PLC 20 RC1 3 9 n/a yes yes Antemortem healed E-W Extended
head trauma to the
left front head (left
frontal bone)
PLC-397 PLC 21 RC1 3 15 male Assymetrical occipital n/a E-W Facing
flattening down
PLC-398 PLC 20 RC1 5 12 n/a no yes Healing depression E-W Lateral
left parietal at the flexed
parietal notch
PLC-399 PLC 20 RC1 3 27-30 female n/a N-S Seated,
facing
down
PLC PLC 21 RC1 3 25-35 female Symmetrical occipital no n/a Seated,
3100-E1 flattening facing
81
down
PLC PLC 21 RC1 3 20-23 female Symmetrical occipital no Perimortem upper n/a Seated,
3100-E2 flattening right first incisors, facing
lower right and left down
lateral incisors
PLC 3101 PLC 21 RC1 3 40-49 male Assymetrical occipital no Numerous S-N Facing
flattening antemortem toothloss down
PLC 3102 PLC 21 RC1 3 27-35 female Occipital flattening no Possibly perimortem N-S Seated,
fracture to the anterior facing
body of C5. down
Antemortem parry
fracture to the right
mid ulna. Almost
healed, bony callus
still present
PLC 3103 PLC 21 RC1 3 16-17 female Occipital flattening n/a N-S Seated,
facing
down
Continued
Continued
PLC Cut
Sacrificial Cut on marks Body Body
Burial # Site Area Level Event Age Sex Cranial modification Sternum on ribs Fractures orientation position
PLC 3104 PLC 20 RC1 3 9 n/a Frontal depression and yes E-W Extended
depression at bregma
PLC 3105 PLC 20 RC1 3 13 n/a yes possibly E-W Extended
PLC 3106 PLC 20 RC1 3 10 n/a yes E-W Extended
PRALLO- PLC Trinchera C4 4 12 n/a yes E-W Extended
E-01 1 - Sector
B
E-06 1 - Sector
B
PRALLO- PLC Trinchera C4 3? 50 F Occipital flattening no N-S Seated
E-07 1 - Sector
B
PRALLO- PLC Trinchera C4 3? 10 n/a no S-N Seated
E-08 1 - Sector
B
PRALLO- PLC Trinchera C2 4 7 n/a yes yes E-W Extended
E-09 1 - Sector
C
PRALLO- PLC Trinchera C2 6 9 n/a no S-N Seated
E-11 1 - Sector
C
PRALLO- PLC Trinchera C1 4 7 n/a yes yes E-W Extended
E-12 2 - Sector
B
PRALLO- PLC Trinchera C2 4 8 n/a Occipital flattening yes fracture on crania? E-W Extended
E-13 2 - Sector
C
Continued
Continued
PLC Cut
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Sacrificial Cut on marks Body Body
Burial # Site Area Level Event Age Sex Cranial modification Sternum on ribs Fractures orientation position
PRALLO- PLC Trinchera C2 4 6 n/a yes E-W Extended
E-14 1 - Sector
C
PRALLO- PLC Trinchera C2 ? 5 n/a no E-W Extended
E-16 2 - Sector
C
PRALLO- PLC Trinchera C3 4 11 n/a yes yes E-W Extended
E-19 2 - Sector
C
PRALLO- PLC Trinchera C2 ? 9 n/a no W-E Seated
E-27 5
PRALLO- PLC Trinchera C2 ? 6 n/a yes E-W Lateral
E-46 17 - 18 flexed
PRALLO- PLC Trinchera C1 ? Not E-W Fetal position
E-50 19 -20 Analyzed
PRALLO- PLC Trinchera RC1 ? 8 n/a possibly S-N Tightly
E-82 5 - 23 Flexed
83
Event numbers in black have secure temporal association by 14C dates. Event numbers in red means indirect temporal association with an event, based on similarity or physical
proximity to a close-by dated burial or other archaeological context
Appendix 2
Description and results of the 80 AMS measurements prepared for this manuscript. PSUAMS or PSU: Pennsylvania State Institute of Energy and the
Environment. YU: Center for Accelerator Mass Spectrometry, Yamagata University. All samples were calibrated using OxCal V4.4.4 Bronk Ramsey
(2021), r:5 Atmospheric Data from Hogg et al. (2020).
YU-13293 CA 12 485 21 Sedge rope EVENT 5 1423 1441 68.26895 1412 1448 95.44997 1405 1455 99.73002
YU-13280 CA 25 486 21 Sedge rope EVENT 5 1423 1441 68.26895 1412 1448 95.44997 1404 1455 99.73002
YU-13295 PLC 214 487 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 5 1422 1440 68.26895 1412 1447 95.44997 1404 1455 99.73002
YU-13298 PLC 203 495 21 Cotton yarn EVENT 5 1418 1439 68.26895 1408 1444 95.44997 1400 1454 99.73002
YU-13274 CA 01 496 22 Sedge rope EVENT 5 1417 1439 68.26895 1407 1445 95.44997 1398 1454 99.73002
YU-13252 CA 18 504 20 Sedge rope EVENT 5 1414 1434 68.26895 1406 1441 95.44997 1396 1450 99.73002
PSUAMS-6638 Wooden sculpture 505 20 Sedge rope EVENT 5 1414 1434 68.26895 1406 1441 95.44997 1396 1450 99.73002
YU-13247 PLC 201 511 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 5 1411 1431 68.26895 1404 1440 95.44997 1327 1450 99.73002
YU-13238 CA 118A-B 519 20 Sedge rope EVENT 5 1409 1426 68.26895 1401 1438 95.44997 1326 1445 99.73002
YU-13243 CA 09 519 20 Sedge rope EVENT 5 1409 1426 68.26895 1401 1438 95.44997 1326 1445 99.73002
YU-6058 A3-C1-R1-Hearth 524 20 Plant charcoal EVENT 5 1407 1426 68.26895 1398 1437 95.44997 1326 1444 99.73002
YU-13255 CA 83 524 20 Sedge rope EVENT 5 1407 1426 68.26895 1398 1437 95.44997 1326 1444 99.73002
YU-13234 PLC 375 535 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 5 1403 1423 68.26895 1327 1434 95.44997 1322 1440 99.73002
PSUAMS-10656 PLC 114 530 15 Cotton yarn EVENT 5 1424 1441 68.26895 1415 1448 95.44997 1406 1453 99.73002
PSUAMS-1273 CA 11 555 20 Sedge rope EVENT 4 1328 1418 68.26895 1324 1424 95.44997 1310 1433 99.73002
MF-2021-PSU-14 PLC-A22-CS-TX 247-1 610 15 Cotton yarn EVENT 4 1328 1408 68.26895 1323 1413 95.44997 1317 1421 99.73002
YU-13279 CA 15 OT 8 563 21 Sedge rope EVENT 4 1327 1410 68.26895 1321 1422 95.44997 1305 1430 99.73002
YU-13233 PLC 373 563 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 4 1327 1410 68.26895 1322 1421 95.44997 1306 1429 99.73002
YU-13281 PLC 116 576 21 Cotton yarn EVENT 4 1325 1405 68.26895 1313 1415 95.44997 1303 1424 99.73002
YU-13282 PLC 238 590 21 Cotton yarn EVENT 4 1322 1400 68.26895 1306 1408 95.44997 1300 1419 99.73002
YU-13166 PLC 380 597 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 4 1321 1398 68.26895 1305 1405 95.44997 1299 1411 99.73002
YU-13237 PLC CA 117G 605 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 4 1312 1396 68.26895 1303 1401 95.44997 1298 1409 99.73002
Continued
Continued
Prieto et al.: A new mass sacrificial burial ground during the Chimú occupation in Huanchaco, North Coast of Peru
Name Unmodelled (BC/AD)
Laboratory Code Context 14C age (BP) ± Material Dated PLC Event from to % from to % from to %
PSUAMS-4524 PRALLO E-2 610 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 4 1307 1396 68.26895 1302 1400 95.44997 1297 1406 99.73002
PSUAMS-6637 PLC 346 625 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 4 1303 1392 68.26895 1298 1396 95.44997 1290 1402 99.73002
YU-13289 CA 81B 628 21 Sedge rope EVENT 4 1302 1392 68.26895 1296 1397 95.44997 1287 1401 99.73002
YU-13239 CA 62B 631 20 Sedge rope EVENT 4 1303 1391 68.26895 1296 1396 95.44997 1286 1400 99.73002
YU-13278 PLC 220 640 22 Cotton yarn EVENT 4 1300 1389 68.26895 1287 1395 95.44997 1283 1399 99.73002
YU-13297 PLC 228 643 21 Cotton yarn EVENT 4 1299 1388 68.26895 1288 1394 95.44997 1282 1398 99.73002
YU-13288 PLC 354 644 21 Cotton yarn EVENT 4 1299 1387 68.26895 1287 1394 95.44997 1282 1398 99.73002
PSUAMS-4523 PRALLO CA-18 645 20 Sedge rope EVENT 4 1299 1387 68.26895 1289 1394 95.44997 1281 1398 99.73002
MF-2021-PSU-5 PLC-A21-CS-TX 205-1 720 15 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1289 1381 68.26895 1284 1385 95.44997 1278 1390 99.73002
YU-13241 PLC 243 664 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1288 1383 68.26895 1282 1389 95.44997 1276 1395 99.73002
YU-13251 PLC 236 681 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1283 1377 68.26895 1277 1385 95.44997 1275 1390 99.73002
YU-13165 PLC 397 685 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1282 1377 68.26895 1277 1384 95.44997 1272 1390 99.73002
YU-13276 PLC 3101 716 22 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1275 1292 68.26895 1267 1378 95.44997 1230 1387 99.73002
YU-13245 PLC 235 718 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1275 1290 68.26895 1267 1300 95.44997 1260 1384 99.73002
PSUAMS-6642 PLC 271 730 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1271 1286 68.26895 1265 1297 95.44997 1228 1379 99.73002
YU-13283 A21-RC1-R114-OT 1273 742 21 Nectandra sp. seed EVENT 3 1268 1283 68.26895 1229 1294 95.44997 1223 1299 99.73002
YU-13284 PLC 278 TX1 749 21 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1265 1282 68.26895 1228 1288 95.44997 1222 1296 99.73002
85
YU-13242 CA 72A 754 20 Sedge rope EVENT 3 1263 1281 68.26895 1228 1285 95.44997 1221 1292 99.73002
PSUAMS-6641 PLC 275 760 15 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1264 1278 68.26895 1229 1282 95.44997 1224 1285 99.73002
PSUAMS-4528 Spondylus sp. shell 765 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1233 1279 68.26895 1226 1280 95.44997 1220 1286 99.73002
PSUAMS-6640 PLC-A19-C1-Me 81 770 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1232 1278 68.26895 1226 1279 95.44997 1220 1285 99.73002
YU-13287 PLC 391 783 21 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1229 1272 68.26895 1224 1275 95.44997 1216 1282 99.73002
PSUAMS-4520 PLC 129 785 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1229 1271 68.26895 1224 1275 95.44997 1216 1280 99.73002
YU-13235 PLC 3102 785 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1229 1271 68.26895 1224 1275 95.44997 1216 1280 99.73002
YU-13296 PLC 309 787 21 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1229 1270 68.26895 1223 1275 95.44997 1215 1283 99.73002
YU-13248 PLC 310 788 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1229 1269 68.26895 1223 1274 95.44997 1215 1281 99.73002
YU-13294 PLC 279 792 22 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1229 1267 68.26895 1220 1275 95.44997 1180 1282 99.73002
YU-13250 CA 82 794 20 Sedge rope EVENT 3 1229 1266 68.26895 1221 1273 95.44997 1181 1280 99.73002
PSUAMS-4521 PLC 136 795 15 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1229 1265 68.26895 1223 1270 95.44997 1218 1276 99.73002
PSUAMS-4527 PLC 147 795 15 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1229 1265 68.26895 1223 1270 95.44997 1218 1276 99.73002
PSUAMS-10657 PLC 123 830 15 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1227 1270 68.26895 1221 1276 95.44997 1213 1283 99.73002
MF-2021-PSU-8 PLC-A3-C1-TX 18 825 15 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1228 1271 68.26895 1223 1276 95.44997 1215 1284 99.73002
YU-13249 PLC 208 814 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1222 1260 68.26895 1213 1271 95.44997 1175 1276 99.73002
YU-13273 PLC 326 815 22 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1222 1261 68.26895 1180 1273 95.44997 1171 1276 99.73002
YU-13292 PLC 265 817 21 Cotton yarn EVENT 3 1220 1260 68.26895 1180 1271 95.44997 1169 1275 99.73002
YU-13291 PLC 343 835 21 Cotton yarn EVENT 2 1180 1260 68.26895 1172 1264 95.44997 1161 1271 99.73002
YU-13236 PLC 385 852 20 Cotton yarn EVENT 2 1176 1223 68.26895 1161 1257 95.44997 1053 1267 99.73002
Continued
Continued
PSUAMS or PSU: Pennsylvania State Institute of Energy and the Environment. YU: Center for Accelerator Mass Spectrometry, Yamagata University. All samples were calibrated
using OxCal V4.4.4 (Bronk Ramsey 2021), r:5 Atmospheric Data from Hogg et al. 2020.
86