Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CHAPTER 3
TOOLS FOR MANAGING AND HEDGING AGAINST RISK
1
Learning Objectives
• The Use of Derivatives: Financial Futures, Options, Swaps, and Other Hedging Tools
2
Chapter 3: Tools for managing and hedging against risk
4
3.1.1 Asset-Liability Management Strategies
• Asset-Liability Management:
o Definition: coordinated and integrated decision making in managing asset and liability
portfolios
o Purpose: controlling a bank’s sensitivity to changes in market interest rates and limit its
losses in its net income or net worth.
5
3.1.1 Asset-Liability Management Strategies
6
3.1.1 Asset-Liability Management Strategies
7
3.1.1 Asset-Liability Management Strategies
8
3.1.1 Asset-Liability Management Strategies
• Financial institutions today sell a bundle of financial services, credit, payments, savings,
financial advice, and the like-that should each be priced to cover their cost of production. I
• ncome from managing the liability side of the balance sheet can help achieve profitability
goals as much as revenues generated from managing loans and other assets.
• Many financial firms carry out daily asset-liability management activities through asset-
liability committees (ALCO), usually composed of key officers representing different
departments of the firm.
9
3.1.1 Asset-Liability Management Strategies
10
3.1.2. Market Rates and Interest Rate Risk
11
3.1.2. Market Rates and Interest Rate Risk
n
CFt
Market Price = å
t =1 (1 + YTM)
t
12
3.1.2. Market Rates and Interest Rate Risk
13
3.1.2. Market Rates and Interest Rate Risk
• Yield curves:
o Definition: Graphical picture of relationship between yields and maturities on
securities (at a single point in time, assuming ceteris paribus)
14
3.1.2. Market Rates and Interest Rate Risk
• Yield curves:
o Shape of the yield curve
ü Upward – long-term rates higher than short-term rates (economic expansion)
ü Downward – short-term rates higher than long-term rates (economic recession)
ü Horizontal – short-term and long-term rates the same
o Shape of the yield curve and the maturity gap
ü Typical maturity gap of a bank: longer maturities of assets (loans & securities) than
liabilities (deposits)
ü Upward sloping yield curve benefits banks, generating positive net interest margin
ü Downward and horizontal yield curve put negative pressure in bank earnings
15
3.1.2. Market Rates and Interest Rate Risk
• Interest rate risk: is the potential loss from unexpected changes in interest rates which
can significantly alter a bank’s profitability and market value of equity, including:
o Reinvestment risk: If interest rates change, the bank will have to reinvest the cash flows
from assets or refinance rolled-over liabilities at a different interest rate in the future.
o Price risk: If interest rates change, the market values of assets and liabilities also change.
16
3.1.2. Market Rates and Interest Rate Risk
17
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
• Goal of interest rate hedging: to insulate the bank from the damaging effects of
fluctuating interest rates on profits (net income).
o Must concentrate on those interest-sensitive assets and liabilities
o To protect profits against adverse interest rate changes, management seeks to hold fixed
the net interest margin (NIM)
18
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
• For example, suppose a large international bank records $4 billion in interest revenues
from its loans and security investments and $2.6 billion in interest expenses paid out to
attract borrowed funds. If this bank holds $40 billion in earning assets. Calculate its net
interest margin.
19
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
• Practice: First National Bank of Bannerville has posted interest revenues of $63 million
and interest costs from all of its borrowings of $42 million. If this bank possesses $700
million in total earning assets, what is First National's net interest margin?
• Suppose the bank's interest revenues and interest costs double, while its earning assets
increase by 50 percent. What will happen to its net interest margin?
20
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
• Answer:
If interest revenues and interest costs double while earning assets grow by 50 percent, the
net interest margin will change as follows:
21
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
• If the interest cost of borrowed funds rises faster than income from loans and securities, a
financial firm's NIM will be squeezed, with likely adverse effects on profits.
• If interest rates fall and cause income from loans and securities to decline faster than
interest costs on borrowings, the NIM will again be squeezed.
• Management must struggle continuously to find ways to ensure that borrowing costs do
not rise significantly relative to interest income and threaten the margin of a financial firm.
22
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
23
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
• Among the most popular interest rate hedging strategies in use today is interest-sensitive
gap management.
• Gap management techniques require management to perform an analysis of the maturities
and repricing opportunities associated with interest-bearing assets and with interest-
bearing liabilities.
• If management feels its institution is excessively exposed to interest rate risk, it will try to
match as closely as possible the volume of assets that can be repriced as interest rates
change with the volume of liabilities whose rates can also be adjusted with market
conditions during the same time period.
24
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
25
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
26
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
• What happens when the amount of repriceable assets does not equal the amount of repriceable
liabilities?
Clearly, a gap then exists between these interest-sensitive assets and interest-sensitive
liabilities.
• A gap exits: the amount of repriceable assets is different from that of repriceable liabilities
27
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
• For example: If interest-sensitive assets (ISA) are $150 million and interest-sensitive
liabilities (ISL) are $200 million, then
Dollar IS GAP= ISA - ISL= $150 million - $200 million= -$50 million.
• An institution whose Interest-Sensitive Gap is positive is asset sensitive, while a negative
Interest-Sensitive Gap describes a liability-sensitive condition.
28
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
29
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
30
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
• To sum up, gap positions and the effect of interest rate changes on the bank:
31
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
• There are several ways to measure the interest-sensitive gap (IS GAP).
Ø The Dollar IS GAP
Ø The Relative IS GAP ratio
Ø Interest Sensitivity Ratio (ISR).
32
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
33
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
34
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
35
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
36
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
37
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
o No as practically the interest rates attached to assets and liabilities are not perfectly
correlated in the real world
Ø E.g: Loan interest rates tend to lag behind interest rates on many money market
borrowings.
Ø So interest revenues often tend to grow more slowly than interest expenses during
economic expansions, while interest expenses tend to fall more rapidly than interest
revenues during economic downturns.
38
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
39
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
40
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
• A useful overall measure of interest rate risk exposure is the cumulative gap.
• Cumulative gap: the total difference in Dollars between bank Assets and Liabilities which can
be repriced over a designated time period
• For example, suppose that a bank has $100 million in earning assets and $200 million in
liabilities subject to an interest rate change each month over the next six months. Then its
cumulative gap must be:
Answer:
Cumulative gap = ($100 million in earning assets per month x 6) - ($200 million in
liabilities per month x 6)
= -$600 million
41
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
42
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
43
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
44
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
45
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
46
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
Exercises:
1. Commerce National Bank reports interest-sensitive assets of $870 million and interest-
sensitive liabilities of $625 million during the coming month. Is the bank asset sensitive or
liability sensitive? What is likely to happen to the bank’s net interest margin if interest rates
rise? If they fall?
Answer:
• Because interest-sensitive assets are larger than liabilities by $245 million the bank is
asset sensitive
• If interest rates rise, the bank’s NIM should rise as asset revenues increase by more
than the resulting increase in liability costs. On the other hand, if interest rates fall, the
bank’s NIM will fall as asset revenues decline faster than liability costs.
47
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
Exercises:
2. People’s Savings Bank, a thrift institutions, has a cumulative gap for the coming year of
+$135 million, and interest rates are expected to fall by two and a half percentage points.
a. Calculate the expected change in net interest income (NIM) that this thrift institution
might experience.
b. What will occur in net interest income if interest rates rise by one and a quarter
percentage points?
48
3.1.3 Interest-Sensitive Gap Management
Exercises:
2. People’s Savings Bank, a thrift institutions, has a cumulative gap for the coming year of
+$135 million, and interest rates are expected to fall by two and a half percentage points.
Answer:
a. For the decrease in interest rates:
Expected Change in Net Interest Income = $135 million * (-0.025) = -$3.38 million
b. For the increase in interest rates:
Expected Change in Net Interest Income = $135 million * (+0.0125) = +$1.69 million
49
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
What Is Duration?
• Duration is a value- and time-weighted measure of maturity that considers the timing of
all cash inflows from earning assets and all cash outflows associated with liabilities.
• It measures the average maturity of a promised stream of future cash payments (such as
the payment streams that a financial firm expects to receive from its loans and security
investments or the stream of interest payments it must pay out to its depositors).
• In effect, duration measures the average time needed to recover the funds committed to
an investment.
50
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
v Calculate the duration (D) of an individual financial instru- ment, such as a loan, security,
deposit, or nondeposit borrowing:
(1)
Where: D stands for the instrument's duration in years and fractions of a year
t represents the period of time in which each flow of cash off the instrument
CF indicates the volume of each expected flow of cash in each time period (t)
YTM is the instrument's current yield to maturity.
52
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
(2)
Where: D stands for the instrument's duration in years and fractions of a year
t represents the period of time in which each flow of cash off the instrument
CF indicates the volume of each expected flow of cash in each time period (t)
YTM is the instrument's current yield to maturity.
53
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
Example: Suppose that a bank grants a loan to one of its customers for a term of five years.
The customer promises the bank an annual interest payment of 10 percent. The face (par)
value of the loan is $1,000, which is also its current market value (price). What is this loan
duration?
Answer:
54
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
Example (cont):
55
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
v Duration (D):
o A bank with longer-duration assets than liabilities will suffer a greater decline in Net
worth (NW) when market interest rates rise (than a bank with short-term asset duration
or matching the duration of liabilities with assets)
o Equating asset and liability durations à stabilize NW from interest rate risk.
56
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
DP Di
» -D*
P (1 + i)
where
: the percentage change in market price
: the relative change in interest rates associated with the asset or liability.
: duration, and the negative sign attached to it reminds us that market prices and interest rates on
financial instruments move in opposite directions
57
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
58
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
59
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
60
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
61
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
TL
D = DA - DL *
TA
o D: Leverage-adjusted duration gap
o TL: the total liabilities divided
o TA: the total assets
The larger the leverage-adjusted duration gap, the more sensitive will be the net worth to a
change in interest rates
62
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
é Di ù é Di ù
DNW = ê- D A * * Aú - ê- D L * * Lú
ë (1 + i) û ë (1 + i) û
63
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
Answer:
64
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
65
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
66
3.1.4 Duration Gap Management
67
3.2. Risk management: Financial Futures,
Options, Swaps, and Other Hedging Tools
68
3.2.1. Financial Futures Contracts
69
3.2.1. Financial Futures Contracts
70
3.2.1. Financial Futures Contracts
71
3.2.1. Financial Futures Contracts
72
3.2.1. Financial Futures Contracts
73
3.2.1. Financial Futures Contracts
74
3.2.1. Financial Futures Contracts
75
3.2.1. Financial Futures Contracts
76
3.2.1. Financial Futures Contracts
77
3.2.1. Financial Futures Contracts
78
3.2.1. Financial Futures Contracts
79
3.2.1. Financial Futures Contracts
80
3.2.2. Interest-Rate Options
81
3.2.2. Interest-Rate Options
82
3.2.2. Interest-Rate Options
83
3.2.2. Interest-Rate Options
84
3.2.2. Interest-Rate Options
85
3.2.3. Interest-Rate Swaps
86
3.2.3. Interest-Rate Swaps
87
3.2.3. Interest-Rate Swaps
Firm A: Firm B:
88
3.2.3. Interest-Rate Swaps
89
3.2.4. Caps, Floors, and Collars
• Interest-rate caps:
o Protecting its holder against rising market interest rates.
o Borrowers are assured that lenders cannot increase loan rate above the cap interest rate
by paying an upfront premium/fee.
o Alternatively, the borrower may purchase an interest-rate cap from a third party who
promises to reimburse borrowers for any additional interest beyond the cap.
90
3.2.4. Caps, Floors, and Collars
• Interest-rate caps:
o Typical conditions when a bank buy interest-rate caps:
Ø When it has fixed-rate assets with floating-rate liabilities
Ø When it possesses longer-term assets than liabilities
Ø When it holds a large portfolio of bonds that will drop in value when market interest
rates rise.
91
3.2.4. Caps, Floors, and Collars
• Interest-rate floors:
o Guaranteeing minimum rate of return for lenders/investors, used in periods of falling
interest rates
o Banks use interest-rate floors most often when their liabilities have longer maturities
than their assets or when they are funding floating-rate assets with fixed-rate debts.
92
3.2.4. Caps, Floors, and Collars
• Interest-rate collars:
o An agreement combining a rate floor and a rate cap
o E.g: a customer who has just received a $100 million loan may ask the lender for a collar
on the loan's prime rate between 11 percent and 7 percent. In this instance, the lender
will pay its customer's added interest cost if prime rises above 11 percent, while the
customer reimburses the lender if prime drops below 7 percent.
o In effect, the collar's purchaser pays a premium for a rate cap while receiving a premium
for accepting a rate floor.
93
Q&A session
Thank you for listening!
3 94
7