Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(昭和57年11月 日本 造 船 学 会 秋 季 講 演 会 に お い て講 演)
Summary
Thispaperpresentsan outlineof newconstructionmethodof 125,000 M3Moss
Rosenbergtype LNGCaluminumsphericaltanks whichwestartedbuildingin 1981.
Thisconstructionmethodhas manycharacteristicpointsand employsmoreadvanced
techniquesand has producedthe expectedresultsin savingson specialfacilitiesand
laborand in achievement
ofa highqualitylevel.
*
A B C D MHZ
three sections construction method made it As regards the accuracy of tank volume, the
possible to construct tanks without any modifi- required accuracy level of each tank must be of
cation to the existing facilities of Koyagi Works. an extremely severe value in order to attain the
The points to be considered in constructing guaranteed cargo carrying capacity while minimiz-
spherical tanks are the accuracy control of the ing an surplus tank volume. Incidentally, when
spherical tanks and quality of welding joints the tank girth length is 30 mm shorter uniformly,
(welding quality). The accuracy of tanks is there will be a shortage of 20 m3 in a 25,000 m3
twofold ; accuracy of tank volume and accuracy tank. In the case of Al 5083-0 material used for
of tank form which is important by strength the tanks as shown in Table 1, the 10-meter
reason. girth length varies by 2.6 mm in every tempera-
Application of New Construction Method to Aluminum Spherical Tanks for LNGC 495
3. Development of Construction
Method by Stage
As shown in Fig. 5, we purchased trapezoidal The Mitsubishi type three-line press machine
plates mainly to minimize scrappage and cut has three lines of press heads, with ten pairs
them into the specified shapes with NC plasma of heads, at top and bottom, on each line, and
cutting machines. The plasma cutting machines can be set at any desired radius of carvature.
are of the air plasma type which had previously The machine has an arithmetric formula built in,
been used for cutting steel plates. The plasma which is preprogrammed to be obtained the desir-
cutting machines were also used for marking of ed radius of carvature, so that bending operation
various lines, which were kept to the required can be performed by feeding initial values cor-
minimum. responding to the shape and thickness of seg
498 日本 造 船 学 会 論 文 集 第 152 号
ments. Plates to be bent are checked for dimen- that the curvature of segments is not 100% ac-
sional accuracy on the accuracy measuring curate, the machine is provided, on the support
device, and are finished to the final dimensions bed, with the vacuum support stand to maintain
with the NC bevelling machine. The machine the curvature radius of spherical tanks. NC
has two sets of bevelling heads which can be put control is performed on the plane (x, y axes)
to work simultaneously. In order to shorten only, and the copying system is used for the verti-
loading and unloading time and thereby increase cal control (z axis). The bevelling accuracy was
the bevelling time ratio, the machine is provided held within 0.25 mm in dimensional error and 2°
with bevelling heads in two stages. Considering degree in angle; as a result, the gap at the joint
Application of New Construction Mlethod to Aluminum Spherical Tanl, T.NGC 499
A B C MHI
between two plates was kept less than 0.5 mm. tion of welding distortion, but the high curreilt
and the segments for spherical tanks for two MIG welding method was developed which was
ships have already been processed to the aimed capable of keeping welding distortion withIl
accuracy. Fig. 6 shows the NC press bender an allowable limit, and a procedure for correctinh.,.
welding distortiom was established in case weld-
(Mitsubishi type three-line press), and Fig. 7
the NC bevelling machine (Mitsubishi planoma). ing distortion should occur.
3.2 Assembly Stage The aPpllcation ratio of the high current MIG
The decisive factor of the spherical tank as- welding niethod reached about 56% of all weld-
sembly method would be to increase the ratio of ing length of about 2,000 m/sphere, thcreby
work to be done in the assembly stage as much achieving a remarkable reduction in the spherical
as possible within the range in which ring assem- tank assembly time while achieving nearly 100%
bly and block assembly can be carried out perfect welding quality. Figs. 8 and 9 show a
smoothly. We reviewed two-segment (petal) comparison of the application ratio and welding
subassembly method which had been com- efficiency by welding method. It can be seen
monly used in the past, compared and analyzed from the figures that the increase in the ratio of
the possibility of three- or four-segment sub- work on the ground and the increase in the size
level, and reached a conclusion that they were and welding were performed on positioners
practicable from the standpoints of accuracy and shown in Fig. 10. The positioners which we made
quality. An increase in the number of segments and used this time can be operated with single-
in subassembly is liable to cause difficulty in. shaft control and can be held at any desired
adjustment of dimensional accuracy and correc- inclination angle within 6•} 1 degrees when weld
500 日本 造 船 学会 論 文 集 第 152 号
welding.
poler segment subassembly. At the time of set-up, diameter in the standard range. One of the
ApplicnLtioll of New Construction Method to Aluminum Spherical Tamks for LNGC 501
taken. Defects were all blowholes, which were from designing, material inspection, transport
repaired by welding to the perfect quality. Table storage, forming, assembly, measurement, inspec-
2 shows an example of typical welding condi- tion, etc., a fine mesh of quality assurance system
tions. was set up, so that anything which did not con-
4.2 Problems and Remedies in Welding form to the standards in one stage would not
It is known from various literatures that the move to the next stage, which is, as it were,
working environments have a great effect on 100% check system. To carry out this system
welding of aluminum materials. We conducted smoothly, necessary measures were taken such
a thorough investigation into all factors which as development and application of element
seemed to have an effect on welding quality. techniques.
Since the details of this investigation will be Figs. 12 shows an example of studies on surface
reported at another opportunity, only the con- protection of aluminum tank by FTA.
clusion is briefly mentioned below. First, high 5.2 Accuracy Standards and Results
temperature and humidity of the atmosphere had Fig 2 shows the accuracy standards for tank
little effect upon the high current NHGwelding, conLtiuction and the results 'the accmacy
and tended to cause blow-holesin the ordinary standards w ere set up taking into account all
MIG welding, especially in the horizontal weld- deformations anticipated donut; the construc-
ing. To prevent them, it was necessary to heat tion process and the standard \allies w hick could
cooling water (torch), pre-flow shield gas, and be permitted from the standpoint of design The
dehumidity of wires. There is a literature which accuracy standards is ere developed from the
reports that a humidity of 85% is the upper final process back to the preceding processes,
limit permissible for welding, but according to and the accuracy le\ el to be achievel in each
our experiments, the upper limit varies with stage was determined. The target shown in
temperature and absolute humidity. Fig. 2 is what we set up as the standard range.
In regard to the effect of various kinds of dust The target values for the diameter errors of the
and dirt, the degree of effects of iron dust and three tank blocks were severe, which were dictat-
welding fumes was examined since aluminum ed by the tolerances for STJ (structural transi-
materials were worked on in the shop previously tion joint), that is, the joint bete cen steel and
used for work on iron and steel materials, and aluminum skirt structures, and the earlier the
as a result, it was found out that there was no construction process, the severer the accuracy.
problem if welding conditions (protection of Thus, it can be recognized how important the
temporary parts, etc.) were selected in a proper accuracy of each petal is. The errors of the girth
range. As a matter of course, cleaning of petals length of spherical tanks were us the range of
and welding edges was carried out as part of 10-20 mm, so it can be said that there was
the established work system. Grooves for the vintually no error in the tank diameter. The
high current MIG welding need sti act checking accuracy of tank joalt, with the hull structure
since foreign matter is liable to fail into them. is as also satisfactory
As regards the effect of wind, the level which 5.3 NDI Standards and Results
had no effect on welding quality was about 0.5 m/s As the NDI standards for s erilying the quality
although it had relation to the constinetion of of welds, the NV rules were generally used in
tin. welding torch and gas flow. the past This time, however, we conducted
many tests and as a result, adopted an inspec-
5. Quality Control tion method mainly using VT as shown in Table
5.1 Control Method 3. The inspection standanls were approved by
The objectives of quality control in spherical NK. and the ship-owners. In the case of the NV
tank construction are, needless to say, to secure rules calling for an mspecirm method mainly
the required tank volume, prevent tank deform- using RT, cracks and insufficient fusion are
ation for s*rength reason and prevent foreign difficeilt to detect with RT; therefore, we decided
matter from entering the tanks. We thoroughly to use an inspection method mainly using UT
conducted quality assurance programs for ac- combned with RI whick is superior in detecting
curacy, welding quality and surface cleanliness, spherical defects such as blownoles Details of
etc. Besides the stage-by-stage control by the the applicat ion standards of the inspection
exclusive line organization for aluminum spherical method will be reported separately
tank construction, a direct staff responcsibleto The ratio of welds winch passed the initial
accuracy and welding was assigned, and every inspection reached 99% (the first ship), and al-
piece and part were thoroughly followed up in though blow holes are liable to occur in the
all stages from the start of marking to comple- horizontal automatic welding and semi-automatic
tion of spherical tanks. Therefore, in all stages welding, cracks or insunicient fusion did not
503
Application of New Construction Method to Aluminum Spherical Tanks for LNGC
504 日本 造 船 学会 論 文 集 第 152 号
Total 99.0%
occur at all. Table 3 shows non-destructive test standing problems were solved by thorough
plan and inspection result. advanced verification. In order to achieve further
improvement in construction efficiency and
6. Concluding Remark
stabilized quality, we will continue to make
This paper has presented an outline of the con- various technical improvements. Since there
struction method of spherical tanks. The con- are many things to do including expanded ap-
struction method has been determined through plication of the narrow-groove welding method,
the earnest efforts of our naval architects exerted we intend to steadily accumulate technical im-
over many years, and the construction of the provements. Though the brief description, we
tanks has been progressing very smoothly. In hope that this paper would be helpful in the
implementing this construction method, out- field of aluminum tank construction.
Application of New Construction Method to Aluminum Spherical Tanks for NLGC 505