Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BS7025
Consultancy Project
Group
Niklas Odegaard K1542398
Sofie Kramers K1541131
Caroline Nordlid K1255318
Therese Langeland K1244366
Projects
1st Choice
Sysdoc
Pitch on the following pages.
2nd Choice
Czarnikov
3rd Choice
OLIO
ku58530
CONSULTANCY PROJECT
PITCH FOR
1
Introduction
With the vision to lead sustainable change, Sysdoc has operated as an innovative specialist
consultancy company since 1986. Sysdoc works together with their clients to address their
most complex business issues and to deliver successful and sustainable transformation and
change through different consulting practices spanning from intuitive documentation to
organisational design and development.
Currently, around 70% of companies are reconsidering their performance appraisal processes,
as the nature of work is changing. Companies see a wider need to set shorter goals, attract
new talent and make employees collaborate better, which many systems today are not
reflecting (Rock and Jones, 2015).
As a team we can offer Sysdoc dedicated and hardworking individuals, which can benefit
Sysdoc by adding value to their internal operations by improving their performance appraisal
process. We are motivated to provide Sysdoc with a high quality report and presentation of
our findings and recommendations, by undertaking thorough research and data analysis. This
motivation is underlined by the interest and curiosity all team members have towards the
opportunities the performance appraisal process offers. The team is also motivated to affect
change and implement improved employee engagement, performance and development.
2
Objectives and Scope
Drawing on the brief provided by Sysdoc, we understand that Sysdoc wants us to explore if
their current performance appraisal process should be revised. The goal is to align Sysdoc’s
identity and values with their performance appraisal processes. Building on this, the main
objectives for the project can be summarised as:
2. Identify how to improve these areas by undertaking extensive secondary and primary
research.
3. Create and present a new and improved process which include all of Sysdoc’s
objectives, which can be summarised as:
a. All staff is to receive up-to-date feedback on their performance from the most
appropriate person.
b. The process must ensure that all staff are able to develop in accordance with
their potential and career goals.
c. The staff must know that the feedback and appraisal systems used by Sysdoc
are recognized as ‘best-in-class’.
It is believed that the background for this project is part of recent trends where companies
find that their current process is losing alignment with their strategy (Buckingham and
Goodall, 2015). In recent time, companies such as Deloitte, Accenture and Adobe have made
large changes to their performance appraisal systems and processes.
Generally, the new systems have a larger focus on the employee in his or her specific roles,
instead of comparing them with others, they are done with a higher frequency and are less
time consuming. Additionally, the new systems tend to have a larger focus on the future
instead of the past (Marr, 2015). More specifically, for Adobe employees the new system
consists of Check-Ins, which are meant to eliminate questionnaires and forms previously
required, and have a larger focus on keeping in touch with the employees (Impraise, n.d. a).
For employees in Deloitte, the new system is focused on Recognizing, Seeing and Fueling
performance (Impraise, n.d. b).
The scope of the projects includes exploring Sysdoc’s current performance appraisal process
and determine which areas could be enhanced by new initiatives to better meet their
organisational objectives. Furthermore, the scope includes comprehensive research into
3
current trends and how other companies approach performance appraisals. Building on this
research and findings, recommendations will be presented on a new appraisal process for
Sysdoc. By completing this project, we aim to ensure that Sysdoc is seen as highly attractive
employer, where employee progression and development are faced in the best possible way.
The project will run between June and September 2016, a Gantt chart displaying the timeline
can be found further down in this pitch.
4
Methodology
Research done by Deloitte (McGregor, 2015) has shown that current performance evaluations
are ineffective, unreliable and unsatisfactory. Moreover, they consume too much time, leave
most workers deflated and feel increasingly out of step with reality. Companies have picked
up on this research and are now looking to change their appraisal process to be more efficient,
reliable and satisfactory among both managers and employees.
We will use secondary and both internal and external primary research in order to answer this
question, using exploratory and qualitative research methods, such as online surveys and
interviews.
Going more in depth, focusing more on Sysdoc specifically, our second research question is:
HOW CAN A NEW PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL PROCESS BE TAILORED TO SYSDOC, SO THEY CAN PROVIDE
THEIR EMPLOYEES WITH BEST -IN -CLASS CAREER DEVELOPMENT , FEEDBACK AND COACHING ?
To answer this question, the best way possible, we will build on the results from the research
already undertaken to answer the first question, by focusing even more on internal primary
research with in-depth interviews of Sysdoc employees.
A large focus will be placed on both qualitative and quantitative research, in order to answer
our research questions. As it is currently not clear which areas of the performance appraisal
process requires change, exploratory research is needed. The proposed methodology includes
secondary and both internal and external primary research.
There are some limitations that may arise during our internal and external primary research.
We have compiled a risk analysis (see appendix A) in line with what we as a group think can
be possible risks. This analysis provides an explanation of the potential risks with impact,
probability, exposure and preventive actions.
Secondary Research
As a starting point, secondary research will need to be undertaken. The credibility of the
sources used for this research must be considered, therefore there will be a main focus on
academic journals, research papers and reports on the topic.
The secondary research will identify what the current trends within performance appraisals
are. Additionally, it will investigate what the pioneers behind any of these trends have done
and why they have done it.
Primary Research
The primary research will include both internal and external research. Internal research will
be needed to uncover what Sysdoc employees and leaders think of their current appraisal
5
process, whereas external research is needed to find out what other companies are doing and
how they are finding it. In order to achieve this, the aim is to conduct in-depth interviews with
key employees across different levels of seniority through qualitative and exploratory
research.
The primary research will form the basis of our recommendation, which will be a bespoke
appraisal format that fit with the company and its objective.
In order to complete the internal primary research, the project team will need access to
Sysdoc employees. The different methods and desired sample sizes can be found in the table
below.
To get all employees engaged with the new process, their input is invaluable.
Scenario 1
Scenario 1 has a narrow focus, mainly on the consultancy industry, looking at which appraisal
processes and techniques they are applying today. The sample sizes within this scenario are
relatively small, due to few companies to engage with.
Minimum Desired
Method
Sample Size Sample Size
Online Sent out to employees and managers within
20 40
Survey consultancy companies
Managers and employees in different consultancy
Interviews 3 8 companies, which have different appraisal
processes.
One limitation to this scenario is that we might not get the number of respondents we want.
Therefore, we must possibly look outside the consultancy industry and send out online surveys
and interview accordingly.
6
Scenario 2
The second scenario has a broader focus, where information is gathered from a wide range of
companies within different industries on the performance appraisal process. This is to get a
broad perspective on how appraisal techniques are being utilised today, and to see clearly
what are working/not working.
Minimum Desired
Method
Sample Size Sample Size
Sent out to employees and managers of both
Online
30 60 similar companies and companies operating in
Survey
different industries
Managers and employees of similar and different
Interviews 5 8 companies - industry, which have different
appraisal processes.
7
Project Timeline
The Gantt chart below is based on the project being allocated during the last week of May,
enabling the project team to start working 30th of May. However, if the allocation process
were to be finalised earlier or later, this timeline would need to adapted accordingly. A more
detailed timeline can be found in appendix B.
30.05.16 07.06.16 15.06.16 23.06.16 01.07.16 09.07.16 17.07.16 25.07.16 02.08.16 10.08.16 18.08.16 26.08.16 03.09.16
Project Planning
Secondary Research
Primary Research
Data Analysis
Recommendations
Write Reports
Prepare Presentation
Present Project
Based on the initial meetings with Sysdoc the project plan and timeline will be outlined in
further details in accordance with their expectations and timeframes.
8
Staffing
Our project team consists of four members, which as a whole has analytical and strategic skills,
gained through both academic achievements and professional experiences. The team has
experience throughout a range of companies, which varies, from smaller SMEs to large
international corporations. Moreover, in relation to the professional experience and
involvement in performance appraisals, the team members have worked across different
industries, such as oil, banking, design and recruitment with areas including both change and
project management.
Subsequently, we believe that the project will broaden our horizon, develop our interpersonal
skills and competences within leadership and human resource management. Our
international profiles, combined with knowledge, skills, and experiences makes us a strong
team, which have diverse skill sets and are highly driven and motivated. Our strong interest is
also reflected by the experience and skills we anticipate to gain through the project, which fits
into our individual career plans that we wish to pursuit moving forward.
Caroline Nordlid
I finished my undergraduate degree in Business Management at Kingston University in London
2015. Since I wanted to further my knowledge within project management and international
relations did I pursue a master's degree in International Business Management with Project
Management by the same University.
During the last four summers have I been working at National Oilwell Varco within
documentations, where good customer relationships and in-house communications are highly
important. Additionally, was my teamwork experience and intercultural communications skills
enhanced.
Through prior experience at the university have I conducted a consultancy project for an IT
firm. This has further my interest in project management, and I have therefore taken the
Prince2 Foundation course and is currently studying for Prince2 Practitioner.
I find myself to be a reliable and hardworking person that always meet the goals I set for
myself. I also like to get challenges, and see this as an opportunity to learn and develop my
skills even further.
Niklas Odegaard
I have a bachelor degree in business and economics from the Norwegian Business School.
While completing my bachelor degree, I worked part time for Norway’s largest investment
bank as a FX-trader for 1 ½ year. Moreover, after that as a Project Manager for one of
Norway’s largest marketing agencies. After Graduating, I worked for Nigel Wright Consultancy
and Harvey Nash across the Nordic countries as a consultant within the executive search and
consultant industry. Through this experience I have interviewed a number of leaders that has
provided me with a good insight in how they manage their team/s. My main tasks were Client
Relationship Management, Business Development with new and existing clients, consulting,
9
interviews, testing, headhunting and research. Furthermore, I have worked with some of the
biggest Retail/FMCG and Telecom companies worldwide.
Sofie Kramers
As a result-driven career woman with a background in Business Development, Account
Management and Design Consultancy, I thrive in a collaborative and cross-disciplinary
environment where my skills can be employed.
Through international work experiences across different industries, I have developed a strong
set of commercial abilities and understanding of how to implement new initiates and improve
existing business processes.
The MSc in International Business Management at Kingston University has further contributed
to the development of my commercial skill-set and academic level.
I aim to achieve the best results in each project I take onboard, by thinking innovatively and
approaching challenges with a positive and inquisitive mind-set, whilst building long-lasting
client relationships.
Therese Langeland
After graduating with a bachelor's degree in International Business from Kingston University
in 2015, I found that I wanted to increase my knowledge on and improve my leadership and
managerial skills, whilst keeping an international focus. To meet this objective, I pursued a
master’s degree in International Business Management at Kingston University.
Before coming to university and during the summer holidays, I have worked as an IT
Consultant within Group IT in the Swedish bank SEB in their Oslo office. This job was mainly
focused on in-house first line IT support, which enabled me to develop good problem solving-
and communication skills. Furthermore, through both work experience and university
lectures, I found a large interest in both Project Management and Change Management.
Furthermore, during my undergrad I worked on a consultancy project, where we designed a
website for an IT/Software company. This only increased my interests in both project
management and consultancy work.
To develop my project management skills, I have taken the PRINCE2 Foundation certificate
and is currently studying for PRINCE2 Practitioner.
10
I see myself as a hardworking person, which enjoys working both alone and as part of teams.
My goal in everything is to do the best I can and deliver good quality results. I see working on
this project as a great opportunity to take part in change management, further develop my
project management skills and get invaluable insight into what a good performance appraisal
system looks like.
11
References
Buckingham, M. and Goodall, A. (2015). Reinventing Performance Management. [online]
Harvard Business Review. Available at: https://hbr.org/2015/04/reinventing-performance-
management [Accessed 26 Apr. 2016].
Impraise. (n.d. a). Why Adobe got rid of performance reviews. [online] Available at:
http://blog.impraise.com/360-feedback/why-adobe-got-rid-of-performance-reviews-360-
feedback [Accessed 11 May 2016].
Impraise. (n.d. b). Deloitte joins Adobe and Accenture in dumping performance reviews.
[online] Available at: http://blog.impraise.com/360-feedback/deloitte-joins-adobe-and-
accenture-in-dumping-performance-reviews-360-feedback [Accessed 11 May 2016].
Marr, B. (2015). How Accenture and Deloitte Got Rid of Performance Reviews — And You Can
Too. [online] LinkedIn. Available at: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/how-accenture-
deloitte-got-rid-performance-reviews-you-bernard-marr [Accessed 11 May 2016].
McGregor, J. (2015). What if you could replace performance evaluations with four simple
questions?. [online] Washington Post. Available at:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/on-leadership/wp/2015/03/17/deloitte-ditches-
performance-rankings-and-instead-will-ask-four-simple-questions/ [Accessed 11 May 2016].
Nabaum, A., Barry, L., Garr, S. and Liakopoulos, A. (2014). Performance management is
broken: Replace “rank and yank” with coaching and development. [online] Deloitte
University Press. Available at: http://dupress.com/articles/hc-trends-2014-performance-
management/ [Accessed 27 Apr. 2016].
Rock, D. and Jones, B. (2015). Why more and more companies are ditching performance
ratings. [online] Harvard Business Review. Available at: https://hbr.org/2015/09/why-more-
and-more-companies-are-ditching-performance-ratings [Accessed 12 May. 2016].
12
Appendices
On the following pages, all appendices for this pitch can be found.
13
Appendix A – Risk Analysis
To be ready to tackle potential risks, the team have undertaken a risk analysis of some of the
potential risks this project might face.
14
Appendix B – Detailed Timeline
Here is the more detailed timeline the Gantt chart is based on.
No. of
Start Finish Working Activity
Days
Project Planning
Includes;
• First mentor meeting
30.05.16 03.06.16 5
• First meeting with Sysdoc which includes agreeing on the
overall scope of the project, expectations and
milestones.
06.06.16 10.06.16 5 Secondary Research
Primary Research
Includes;
• Create research methodology and find which methods to
be used
13.06.16 08.07.16 20
• Present the research we want to undertake to Sysdoc
• Agree on the research to be done, to ensure we are on
the same page with the same objectives.
• Collect data
11.07.16 15.07.16 5 Data Analysis
18.07.16 27.07.16 8 Recommendations based on analysis results
28.07.16 19.08.16 17 Write reports
22.08.16 31.08.16 8 Prepare presentation
01.09.16 02.09.16 2 Present project
15
Appendix C – CV’s
On the following pages the CV’s for all team members can be found.
16
CV
Name: Caroline Milana Heitnes Nordlid
Address: Johan Øydegardsvei 71, 4632 Kristiansand, Norway
Date of Birth: 03.10.1992
Mobile Phone: +47 48155390 / +44 7955988344
E-mail: cnordlid@gmail.com
Personal Profile:
I finished my undergraduate degree in Business Management at Kingston
University in London 2015, where I was among the top 10% off 200 students
on my course. I am currently finishing my Master in International Business
Management with Project Management by the same university. I am a reliable
and hard working person with experience in teamwork, leadership and
intercultural communication skills.
Education:
2015 - 2016 Kingston University, England, Msc International Business
Management with Project Management
2012 - 2015 Kingston University, England, Bachelor Business Management
2011 - 2012 Soltun Folkehøyskole, Backpack Surprise linje
2009 - 2011 Nadderud videregående skole
2008 - 2009 Kristiansand katedralskole Gimle
2005 - 2008 Grim Skole
2005 - 2005 Canadian International School, India (6 mnd)
1998 - 2004 Hellemyr skole
Work Experience:
References:
Kate Smeland Knudsen- Manager MRB National Oilwell Varco
Mobile Phone: +47 98207629
Email Address: Kate.Knudsen@nov.com
ku58530
Niklas Odegaard
Address: Kingston Upon Thames, United Kingdom
E-post: Oedegaard.Niklas@gmail.com
Phone: 00447598429637
Birth: 06.06.1990
Education:
2015 – 2016 Kingston Business School, International Business Management (MSc)
• Strategic Project Management, Consultancy, Business Strategy, Innovation and
Environmental & Trade.
2011-2012 Waitress and Bartender – Part time, Lille Bar and Kitchen, Bergen
2011 Waitress and Bartender - summer job, Cafe Oscar, Fredrikstad
2010-2011 Kjelsås Activity School, Oslo
2009-2010 Kjelsås Activity School – Part time, Oslo
2009-2010 Kjelsås primary school – Part time, Oslo
2008-2010 QZ-Promotion – Part time, Oslo
References:
Will be proved on request.
SOFIE NORDSTRØM
CURRICULUM VITAE
EXPERIENCE
Creative Director | -V\UKLY, Nordstrom Studio, London 2012
Founded the Interior Design company Nordstrom Studio with the vision to create timeless, Scandinavian inspired interiors.
Worked on a selection of high-end interior projects, achieving unique designs through attention to detail, creativity and personal
engagement. Summary:
• Performed in the top of the sales team, including the achievement of the largest,
single-purchase Minotti order in the UK.
• Experienced in dealing with a variety of clients ranging from (high-net worth) individuals
to working with Architects & Designers (A&D community).
• Furniture consultant in large scale, high-end residential and commercial design pro-
jects in London and internationally (e.g. Tel Aviv, Florida and Cairo).
• Experienced in setting up direct contact, negotiating terms and maintaining
relationships with various European manufactures.
• Through the company's multi-brand showroom EDC London, I gained a broad in-depth
knowledge of the different manufacturers and their respective collections.
• Formed a new PR strategy in collaboration with the company's external PR agency
• Represented Minotti London to press editors on international trade shows and exhibi-
tions and involved in hosting and planning events at both company showrooms.
• Co-responsible for the redesign of the Minotti mono-brand showroom, with focus on
the visual merchandising, presenting the collections in an inspiring and commercial way.
• Implemented a new cloud-based Customer Relationship Management (CRM) system
with the objective to minimise administration costs and to generate more valuable data.
PAGE 1 OF 3
SOFIE NORDSTRØM T +44 (0) 741 162 8822 E nord.sofie@gmail.com A Pimlico, London SW1V
SOFIE NORDSTRØM
CURRICULUM VITAE
Assistant Sales & Marketing Manager, Honeyrose Bakery Ltd, London 2010-2011
Performed a one-year graduate internship from Aarhus Business School at the Honeyrose Bakery, who serve a niche in the
luxury food market, producing own- and private label cakes for major food retailers such as Waitrose and Wholefoods and cater
to some of UK's leading catering companies. Summary:
SOFIE NORDSTRØM T +44 (0) 741 162 8822 E nord.sofie@gmail.com A Pimlico, London SW1V
SOFIE NORDSTRØM
CURRICULUM VITAE
EDUCATION
SKILLS
Language proficiency: Danish (native), English (fluent), Dutch (basic), Spanish (basic).
Technical qualifications: MAC and PC user, Sage, TAS, Newbase, Maximizer, basic CAD.
Additional: Full Driving License B, Powerboat License.
INTERESTS
Entrepreneurship, Concept Development, Brainstorming & Creative Processes,
Interior Design & Architecture, Traveling & Exploring Cultures, Active Lifestyle.
PAGE 2 OF 3
SOFIE NORDSTRØM T +44 (0) 741 162 8822 E nord.sofie@gmail.com A Pimlico, London SW1V
Therese Holter Langeland
66 Kingsworthy Close, Kingston Upon Thames, Surrey, KT1 3ER
Phone: 07450274101 E-Mail: therlang@gmail.com
Objective
Norwegian student graduating with an MSc in September 2016, currently looking for entry-level jobs in London. I am
available to start work in October.
Experience
Skandinaviska Enskilda Banken / SEB June 2015 – August 2015,
May 2014 – September 2014,
February 2012 – September 2012
Worked within Group IT in the Oslo office. Responsibilities included internal IT support via telephone, email and face to
face. The support included hardware, software, iPhone and Blackberry.
Education
MSc International Business Management September 2015 – current
I am taking my degree with a pathway in Project Management. Other modules include Leadership, Change & Consultancy,
Alternative Dispute Resolution and Contemporary Business Strategy. The classic dissertation is replaced with a
consultancy project, where I will be part of a group working as consultants for a company. This starts in May and ends in
September.
Skills
I am a fast learner that both enjoy working independently and as part of a team.
I have good computer skills and like technology. I find it both fun and interesting to learn new programs and features
within programs I already have some knowledge of.
I have completed the PRINCE2 Foundation exam and am currently studying for the PRINCE2 Practitioner exam, which will
be taken before the end of May.
Fluent in both Norwegian and English. Also understands a lot of Swedish and Danish.