Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Case Report
Diffuse large B cell lymphoma expressing the natural killer cell
marker CD56
Toru Sekita,1 Jun-ichi Tamaru,1,3 Kouichi Isobe,1 Kenichi Harigaya,1 Syu-ichi Masuoka,2
Toshio Katayama,2 Masayuki Kobayashi2 and Atsuo Mikata1,3
1
First Department of Pathology, School of Medicine, Chiba University, Chiba, 2Department of General Internal Medicine,
Kashiwa Hospital, Jikei University, School of Medicine, Kashiwa and 3Department of Pathology, Saitama Medical
Center, Saitama Medical School, Kawagoe, Japan
The expression of the natural killer (NK) cell antigen, CD56, detected on neuron, astrocyte, Schwann cell, myotube and
in hematological malignancies is rare. However, there are natural killer (NK) cell.1–4 The NCAM is a glycoprotein con-
several reports that some hematological malignancies, taining a single polypeptide chain and plays an important role
such as T/NK cell lymphoma, multiple myeloma (MM) and
in a variety of morphogenetic events in the nervous system.
acute myeloid leukemia (AML), express this molecule. In B
In addition, the NCAM also appears to be involved in signal
cell non-Hodgkin’s lymphomas (NHL), however, very limited
number of cases have been reported to express CD56 transduction pathways.5–7 The NCAM has been detected on a
molecule. Although one study has recently described that number of neoplasms (e.g. neuroectodermal tumors, NK/T
half of microvillous B cell lymphoma (MVL), an uncommon cell lymphoma/leukemia, multiple myeloma (MM), and acute
subset of large cell lymphoma, expressed CD56, there have myeloid leukemia (AML)).8–20 In these literatures, the
been no reports about most common type of B-NHL, diffuse researchers have described that the CD56 expression was
large B cell lymphoma (DLBL) other than a mention of weak
associated with frequent extranodal involvement in NK-cell
CD56 expression in one of 83 DLBL. We herein presented
lymphoma,13,14 clinical behavior in MM19,20 and prognosis in
the first case of diffuse large B cell lymphoma expressing
CD56 clearly. The immunophenotype determined by AML.17
immunostaining and flow cytometric analysis was CD101, In B cell non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma (NHL), there have been
CD191, CD201, CD45RO2, CD32 and CD561. On immuno- reported only six cases expressing CD56 on immunostaining.
histochemical study, neither bcl-2 nor TIA-1 was positive for A case of B-lymphoblastic lymphoma reported by Ng et al.,21
tumor cell. Monoclonal immunoglobulin heavy chain (IgH) one case of diffuse large B cell lymphoma (DLBL) reported by
gene rearrangement was detected, and the sequence Kern et al.,13 and four cases by Hammer et al.22 Hammer et
analysis of the variable region of IgH (VH) suggested that
al. have recently described that four cases out of eight
this tumor was derived from antigen selected post germinal
center B cell. Conventional combination chemotherapy microvillous lymphoma (MVL), an uncommon subset of large
(CHOP) was administered, and the patient has still been in cell lymphoma, expressed CD56.22 Although the details of the
complete remission for 10 months. other two cases were not described in their literatures,
Hammer et al. have analyzed in detail and suggested that the
Key words: CD56, diffuse large B cell lymphoma, immunoglob- expression of CD56 was involved in a sinusal growth pattern
ulin heavy chain gene rearrangement, variable region of im- seen in MVL.22 However, the biological role and the mech-
munoglobulin heavy sequence
anism of the CD56 expression in these B cell lymphomas still
remain unknown due to its rarity. Therefore, it is very
The nerve cell adhesion molecule (NCAM), CD56, is a
important to know how this molecule is expressed in B-NHL,
member of the immunoglobulin superfamily, and can be
and whether these CD56-expressing tumors possess char-
acteristic features similar to those observed in NK/T cell
lymphoma or MVL. Also, it seems to be important to
Correspondence: Dr Toru Sekita, First Department of Pathology, recognize that DLBL, one of the most popular subtype of
School of Medicine, Chiba University, Internal Medicine, Kanagawa
NHL, express CD56.
Rehabilitation Center, 516 Nanasawa, Atugi City, Kanagawa 243-
0121, Japan. In the present study, we present a 16-year-old patient with
Received 21 January 1999. Accepted for publication 20 March CD56-positive diffuse large B cell lymphoma, and investigate
1999. histologic feature, surface marker and karyotype for eluci-
CD56-positive DLBL 753
Cytogenetic analysis
Figure 1 Lymph node biopsy showing effacement of normal The PCR product of the rearranged IgH gene showed a
architecture by large atypical lymphoid cells. monoclonal band on 6% PAGE (Fig. 4). The result of VH
Figure 2 Immunohistochemistry of lymph node. (a) Neoplastic cells stain positive for CD56 and (b) CD10.
CD56-positive DLBL 755
Figure 3 Flow cytometric analysis of double-labeled suspended lymph node cells. The dot plots reveal (a) CD561/CD161 and (b)
CD101/CD341 population of lymph node cells.
Antibody (%)
CD3 20.4
CD4 6.7
CD5 20.2
CD8 11.6
CD10 75.5
CD16 0.2
CD19 81.0
CD20 83.9
CD34 0.4
CD45 70.1
CD56 84.8
K-chain 0.4
L-chain 78.6
Figure 5 Sequence analysis of the polymerase chain reaction products variable region (VH) sequence obtained from this case. The first line
shows the amino acid sequence of germline gene. The second line shows the published VH germline gene most homologous to our sequencing
data. The third and following lines show our sequencing data. Replacement mutations are in upper case, while silent mutations are in lower
case.
reported in detail that four cases out of eight MVL expressed aberration thoroughly, it may be involved in the CD56
CD56.22 They have suggested that CD56 expression in MVL expression in this case, because the single NCAM gene is
was associated with a cohesive sinusal growth pattern seen known to be located on chromosome 11q23. Furthermore, we
in MVL. The histologic features of MVL have been reported to could observe 6q deletion in our case. The 6q deletion is
show a cohesive sinusal growth pattern of large transformed observed in about 20% of NHL.29,30 In particular, two distinct
cells similar to anaplastic large cell lymphoma, and display regions of minimal deletion (RMD), at 6q25–27 (RMD-1)
large areas of necrosis in some cases. In electron micro- and at 6q21–23 (RMD-2), have been identified, suggesting
scopic examinations, MVL shows predominantly large the presence of two tumor suppressor genes.31 However,
transformed lymphocytes with thin villous projections on their the exact break point of the 6q deletion could not be identified
surfaces. The typical histologic findings in our case were in this case, as it may have been associated with tumori-
some apoptotic bodies and an increase in tangible body genesis.
macrophages in their vicinity. Although we were not able to The biologic significance of CD56 expression in B cell
assess the presence of villous projection ultrastructurally, our malignancies is unknown. In NK cell lymphoma, CD56
case was distinct from MVL microscopically. In addition, our expression has been reported to be associated with its
case did not show the evidence of angiocentricity, angio- extensive extranodal disease.13,14 Baer et al. reported that
destruction, and zonal tumor cell death (interpreted as AML with CD56 had poor prognosis.17 The role of CD56 in B
‘coagulative necrosis’), which were characteristic findings cell malignancies is being well clarified in MM. CD56 is
seen in NK-cell lymphoma. positive in 80–100% of MM and tends to be overex-
From the previous ultrastructural studies, the cell origin of pressed,8,12,32,33 whereas Pellat-Deceunynck et al. reported
MVL was presumed to be the transformed follicular center that dramatic down-expression of CD56 was observed in
cell.27 In addition, Hammer et al. demonstrated the presence advanced extramedullary lesions or in cases that progress to
of Bcl-2 protein expression in 88% of their cases and leukemia.19 These observations suggest that expression of
membrane expression of CDw75 in 63%, and suggested a CD56 and quantitative changes in its expression may be
follicular center origin of MVL. Furthermore, they identified critical in defining the mechanisms by which plasma cells
bcl-2 gene rearrangement in one of three cases examined. adhere or detach from the bone marrow micro-environment.
Although our case was CD101 by immunostaining and flow Hammer et al. suggested that CD56 expression in MVL was
cytometric analysis, it was negative for bcl-2 protein immuno- associated with a cohesive sinusal growth pattern.22
histochemically. In addition, we could not identify t14;18 on However, the biologic role of CD56 expression in our own
karyotypic analysis. Furthermore, VH region sequence case was unclear. An explanation of the significance of CD56
analysis showed a low to intermediate somatic mutation expression in B cell lymphoma should await the accumulation
without clear evidence of ongoing somatic mutation, although of cases in the future.
three clones each contained one point mutation. The R/S In summary, we have reported the first case of CD56
ratio of CDR2 and FW3 was 4, and 0.4, respectively. The expressing DLBL. The cell origin of this tumor was assumed
discrepancy of these R/S ratios indicated that tumor cell was to be antigen-selected post-germinal-center B cells. Although
associated with antigen stimulation.28 These VH sequence the biologic role and mechanism of CD56 expression has not
analyses suggested that cell origin of our case was a B cell at been well understood, the chromosomal abnormalities, 11q
a stage after antigen selection, such as memory B cells. From aberration, might be associated with its expression in this
the standpoint of surface marker and VH sequence analysis, case.
it is presumed that our case has different derivation from
MVL.
The mechanism of CD56 expression in B-NHL remains ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
to be understood. CD56 is known to be expressed in NK
cell lineage with a variety of degrees. Furthermore, some The authors would like to thank T. Umemiya and K. Azuma for
researchers have reported the expression of CD56 in their supportive technical assistance. The authors were
myeloid leukemia (e.g. in mixed lineage leukemia,16 and t8;21 supported by Grants-in-Aid from the Japanese Ministry of
leukemia).17 They suggested that these tumors may originate Education, Science and Culture (grant no. 09670176).
in progenitors at an immature stage that is common to both
the NK cell and the myeloid lineage. However, there have not
been any reports suggesting the presence of a common
REFERENCES
progenitor of the B cell and the NK cell lineage. According to
the cytogenetic study, various chromosomal abnormalities
1 Griffin JD, Hercend T, Beveridge R, Schlossman SF. Character-
were detected in our case. Of these, we could identify the 11q ization of an antigen expressed by human natural killer cells. J.
aberration. Although we were not able to assess this 11q Immunol. 1983; 130: 2947–2951.
758 T. Sekita et al.
2 Lanier LL, Le AM, Civin CI, Loken MR, Phillips JH. The rela- 18 Paulli M, Boveri E, Rosso R et al. CD56/neural cell adhesion
tionship of CD16 (Leu-11) and Leu-19 (NKH-1) antigen expres- molecule expression in primary extranodal Ki-1/CD301
sion of human peripheral blood NK cells and cytotoxic T lymphoma. Report of a pediatric case with simultaneous
lymphocytes. J. Immunol. 1986; 136: 4480–4486. cutaneous and bone localizations. Am. J. Dermatopathol. 1997;
3 MaClain DA, Edelman GM. A neural cell adhesion molecule 19: 384–390.
from human brain. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 1982; 79: 19 Pellat-Deceunynck C, Brille S, Puthier D et al. Adhesion
6380–6384. molecules on human myeloma cells: significant changes in
4 Cunningham BA, Hemperly JJ, Murray BA, Prediger EA, expression related to malignancy, tumor spreading, and
Brackenbury R, Edelman GM. Neural cell adhesion molecule: immortalization. Cancer Res. 1995; 55: 3647–3653.
Structure, immunoglobulin-like domains, cell surface modula- 20 Tatsumi T, Shimazaki C, Goto H et al. Expression of Adhesion
tion, and alternative RNA splicing. Science 1987; 236: 799– Molecules on Myeloma Cells. Jpn J. Cancer Res. 1996; 87:
806. 837–842.
5 Maness PF, Beggs HE, Klinz SG, Morse WR. Selective neural 21 Ng C-S, Lo STH, Chan JKC, Chan WC. CD561 putative natural
cell adhesion molecule signaling by Src family tyrosine kinases killer cell lymphomas: production of cytolytic effecters and
and tyrosine phosphatases. Perspectives Dev. Neurobiol. 1996; related proteins mediating tumor cell apoptosis? Hum. Pathol.
4: 169–181. 1997; 28: 1276–1282.
6 Baldwin TJ, Fazeli MS, Doherty P, Walsh FS. Elucidation of the 22 Hammer RD, Vnencak-Jones CL, Manning SS, Glick AD,
molecular actions of NCAM and structurally related cell Kinney MC. Microvillous lymphomas are B-cell neoplasms that
adhesion molecules. J. Cellular Biochem. 1996; 61: 502–513. frequently express CD56. Mod. Pathol. 1998; 11: 239–246.
7 Appel F, Holm J, Conscience JF et al. Identification of the border 23 Marks JD, Tristem M, Karpas A, Winter G. Oligonucleotide
between fibronectin type III homologous repeats 2 and 3 of the primers for polymerase chain reaction amplification of human
neural cell adhesion molecule L1 as a neurite outgrowth immunoglobulin variable genes and design of family-specific
promoting and signal transducing domain. J. Neurobiol. 1995; oligonucleotide probes. Eur. J. Immunol. 1991; 21: 985–991.
28: 297–312. 24 Ramasamy I, Brisco M, Morley A. Improved PCR method for
8 Van Camp B, Durie BGM, Spier C et al. Plasma cells in multiple detecting monoclonal immunoglobulin heavy chain rearrange-
myeloma express a natural killer cell-associated antigen. Cd56 ment in B cell neoplasms. J. Clin. Pathol. 1992; 45: 770–775.
(Nkh-1; Leu-19). Blood 1990; 76: 377–382. 25 Tamaru J, Hummel M, Zemlin M, Kalvelage B, Stein H.
9 Figarella-Branger DF, Durbec PL, Rougon GN. Differential Hodgkin’s disease with a B-cell phenotype often shows a VDJ
spectrum of expression of neural cell adhesion molecule rearrangement and somatic mutations in the VH genes. Blood
isoforms and L1 adhesion molecules on human neuroecto- 1994; 84: 708–715.
dermal tumors. Cancer Res. 1990; 50: 6364–6370. 26 Hummel M, Tamaru J, Kalvelage B, Stein H. Mantle cell
10 Moolenaar CECK, Muller EJ, Schol DJ et al. Expression of (previously centrocytic) lymphomas express VH genes with no
neural cell adhesion molecule-related sialoglycoprotein in small or very little somatic mutations like the physiologic cells of the
cell lung cancer and neuroblastoma cell lines H69 and CHP- follicle mantle. Blood 1994; 84: 403–407.
212. Cancer Res. 1990; 50: 1102–1106. 27 Osborne BM, Mackay B, Butler JJ, Ordonez NG. Large cell
11 Mechtersheimer G, Staudter M, Moller P. Expression of the lymphoma with microvillous projections: an ultrastructural study.
natural killer cell-associated antigens CD56 and CD57 in Am. J. Clin. Pathol. 1983; 79: 443–450.
human neural and striated muscle cells and in their tumors. 28 Tamaru J, Hummel M, Marafioti T et al. Burkitt’s lymphomas
Cancer Res. 1991; 51: 1300–1307. express VH genes with a moderate number of antigen-selected
12 Van Riet I, De Waele M, Remels L, Lacor P, Schots R, Van somatic mutations. Am. J. Pathol. 1995; 147: 1398–1407.
Camp B. Expression of cytoadhesion molecules (CD56, CD54, 29 Offit K, Chaganti RSK. Chromosomal aberrations in non-
CD18 and CD29) by myeloma plasma cells. Br. J. Haematol. Hodgkin’s lymphoma: Biologic and clinical correlations.
1991; 79: 421–427. Hematol. Oncol. Clin. North Am. 1991; 5: 853–869.
13 Kern WF, Spier CM, Hanneman EH, Miller TP, Matzner M, 30 Offit K, Parsa NZ, Gaidano G et al. 6q deletions define distinct
Grogan TM. Neural cell adhesion molecule-positive peripheral clinicopathologic subsets of non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma. Blood
T-cell lymphoma: A rare variant with a propensity for unusual 1993; 82: 2157–2162.
sites of involvement. Blood 1992; 79: 2432–2437. 31 Gaidano G, Hauptschein RS, Parsa NZ et al. Deletions
14 Nakamura S, Suchi T, Koshikawa T et al. Clinicopathologic involving two distinct regions of 6q in B-cell non-Hodgkin’s
study of CD56 (NCAM) -positive angiocentric lymphoma lymphoma. Blood 1992; 80: 1781–1787.
occurring in sites other than the upper and lower respiratory 32 Harada H, Kawano M, Huang N et al. Phenotypic difference of
tract. Am. J. Surg. Pathol 1995; 19: 284–296. normal plasma cells from mature myeloma cells. Blood 1993; 8:
15 DiGiuseppe JA, Louie DC, Williams JE et al. Blastic natural 2658–2663.
killer cell leukemia/lymphoma: A clinicopathologic study. Am. J. 33 Leo R, Boeker M, Peest D et al. Multiparameter analysis of
Surg. Pathol. 1997; 21: 1223–1230. normal and malignant human plasma cells: CD381, CD561,
16 Suzuki R, Yamamoto K, Seto M et al. CD71 and CD561 CD541, cIg1 is the common phenotype of myeloma cells. Ann.
myeloid/natural killer cell precursor acute leukemia: a distinct Hematol. 1992; 6: 132–139.
hematolymphoid disease entity. Blood 1997; 90: 2417– 34 Borowitz MJ, Guenther KL, Shults KE, Stelzer GT. Immunophe-
2428. notyping of acute leukemia by flow cytometric analysis.
17 Baer MR, Stewart CC, Lawrence D et al. Expression of the Hematopathology 1993; 5: 534–540.
neural cell adhesion molecule CD56 is associated with short 35 Maurer D, Felzmann T, Knapp W. A single laser flow cytometry
remission duration and survival in acute myeloid leukemia with method to evaluate the binding of three antibodies. J. Immunol.
t(8; 21) (q22; q22). Blood 1997; 90: 1643–1648. Meth 1990; 135: 43–47.