16
Then and now:
cinema as history in the light of
new media and new technologies
Laura Mulvey
peaking aficonado of Bran Cinema bt by no nes
‘expe Lam gong to ey to heya ths eapter by comer
tag oie comet ss hat [hope eat othe desion of
‘he Brian Canes reas has wl comune ane,
ore general perspective. Tam pricy interned i mye
‘ih the earn hisvokime are quests of sry: hehe
{oye Bra snce Cine Nanda soy of Brian Cnet
ell These escusins int, rae questions about "pola
ene and “enema” newbie interslte th oy
Thine aio en uenced, in ny rele ere y road
urls beeen the Brain and the Bash His experince of
the 1960s and 70s The sae he high pot of Cow Na Bat
the Brash erson ofa radial cinema (tuned apt
Aheconjnctre between cn a lt polis ape sm
Temporancusy i many diferent pare of the word ee ite,
then stretching. parteulary i i feist fri the Te
ike wo lca the cal apa of bh cinemas win
ier quesions «pola, cual and economic change hat
Ive tten place since that pred. Kgs sat vat ying
that iia o cmp Cems Noy an oustanding cont
orto wal cinema, wh de ater minor ow pea, exper
Ine Gremas my owe experience in my com. Home,
ther deren viulations rae common us that are oc
fp inerest de asa pater In these eres,
The similar pattern may he found tthe chose elms
exween Tet poles an the enema i the 16 and ene of“Tu Now Baty Cee
Jos, lsovientaon and dsilusion that followed, concentra
lowe all inthe SOx. gap, cher, i aesthetic ad pie
‘ntnaty developed shat esa tins edge toe wy dat
‘nema movement ‘ofthe 1990s conceved of hemsce
Steer that hey dio no yt Flt wo he ln, a
{il vd, moment before the eau From th pater, ice
So cna ine Thee eon er
‘hate changed ad are to do wih de experience of temporal
‘the problem of epoch ar someting sens bt ii to tee
‘fiz These ate aes that pertape can ontye ped By he
resent within the police kegacy of Tom doce 2d
{ice to find a way towards tvs iserprcion, Uae
Brin vero ofthe sory, the cinema of the Bran "rena
see’ drety rate the rela Between ed no
find ctr wha meaning hee cinema histones might hae
{or the present. To reterate the perepion of sup of
fon of eons, tht i sigan hee, That how
Ander; none the expeiencs af rel apiation, an he
Tomy tat characte the history ofthe sranegarde ron
(G/T de O/H? And how cathe contemporary es
ff Marian Cinema conte to mare general pul
Shout cinema and igor?
ist of al thei enema ofthe 196s, ot ony in Bin
ant al i eewhere,telong wo a moment of pte ops
nen Asana Xaver int ume, ha mpd, the ce
ton came to funciona signe peo aed yl o a
‘pian eeology. Not only di ths cheat the desi fae
tter word bt ea seemed flora mean fs
Asweall now, forthe modem tradon, the nema wate art
Ferm an ei specie io the twee entry that
‘oul prove he formal ue within whi ey ste of aes
esthetics could ind expr (As a precoror to he preset
Teplice been noticed how Eeguenty dhe rata 2
thes ofthe 19 ook ck to an tthe forma moment
[he cnemeonerin conjunetare a the 20 Thi ae
Sal he cue both er and Fanos) By the sco hal of
‘he overed centr, the nema could mediate between moder
ty paliferston of ager the pretence of the sole othe
Secale ani mornin somnntaent ora representation
Thro» pleads aesthetic xray, to deny image rane
oven) a athe And af ote, tf th gre te
Ena of selteorence an selfconscloes that mathe the
‘al nema of the prod
‘AsXinier as pointed ont, Gnepia, tre of enema a sich,
imate thee connecions Bele! Inthe ema meres th
ine adel pla change. So, a commento socal Wan
formation, cweatlor the pli anda commitment othe
‘Sheds place In embling that tranaormation, precious o he
Talo avant gate, work togetber in 190 rats. In
{ilarnonement te einen bal go be feo fom ie inane
Sn conseniona wappings in order to become sof nd ol
toh psa and sethee destin. One Is temped to spec
[ie uate cies’ prs ait ovine ansfonnave
eee ete eerrar oN?
[gal mpiraton. Annette Bicheton' noes the convergence
ence the inca, pla raaion and modern
tet dey ted wih (he ina wat corm
These links ete cinemas ranformatve potent and poli
{at pit are esp marked bya tlelogieal ew of Mory
hd aeacice sowie ot oni with exo cbt wih allocala pois movements olay ean
five a moving no tre then lo ed tower in
pion of -History Ale seflerting this por of hr
teak, Susan Blcons has relocated the cola of co
‘ian foe the specie hint f the sci coves a
‘at rom on” by a amir Many of phase the decline of he
‘dustin! workingles (prt Ford), pltalzabon, neotbe
hth afc he ony hen
idrsses the probe fap in hed or a hewtook Nw
pce eget natn, gaming
‘ate 105 ae eal san he wa
“Shape has but completely pase aay” He emphasize the i=
‘ual cones conldton, ad wiser dfn, of ne
toric defeat af bone and deli general- Ont cul fo
erhae the “postmoderrejeedon Of hnry ding the 1950.
Iharked and expres te beak ete heed adhe 0
‘iswreton nt rae ofthe loge
‘ir the sequen on eter an ated or pol level?
1 impel ode the eat nan Hy om
Pest pun chang ding he st cae sng,
perms ads micas ding
‘Changed The hina the emblem of went cen ser
‘old ataly aged By te ine of ts undedth Dirty
any olds mechanic echnlogy hal been overtaken by Be,
"Seernic ad digi echnolglen bic ve a igh pricw ks
sing prove Beste theft peop il go athe cinema
Ila numbers and dubs wil corte 1 8030, mo of
them ake ily to he inode tthe cinema election,
iteram lesion, sought spear te 1,08 om de,
Soh apeiing ante 7, Ad alone ier goin eon
By the 1205 sigil o llected She proction o magen
sswellathedifdon. Soy asthe dea ced 18 oneal
‘ri alongad, step wth, lhe res enone above
{ior them gan to acquire Is on don etmeen the hen
‘tell reonsng a projection andthe now” af a complex
‘aston to be ecologic and proliferating media Hf hee
‘anh ik leet a ramework or ctor fr conemporsry
‘ula sapiation, cs loge pet to yw conde beter
uly descendent night ner lamenort or mecphor win
Iehich the potie of toil om ant dont might be
Tht oF imagined. The nema nis present configuration,
Saning longed memory ath ne aig eapact
Saigo cdr vara for ncqotming tov te ide
“San tack Mors continues he paragraph half quoted above
in gach wy ao get that aeampe to meqotte aces the
Ate ae indeed, of plead imporance inthe prevent cow
Junctue Haw pricey thie ask might be anderahen Hs
Imeresing, ‘To look backyard fom etd hori lol
nigh steko be ingly notalge to Marto the other
nd, nowalge for historical eealgy e posmodeih AS
Buck ore putsie‘lee ad ork ou wa how thc rable inorder ore
Sha hp any gcd
ery Ar age tte ay aang ie
trom the century There retro tnough orks meapho
Neves working through the rubble of Fistor” revenge
Areas of significance’ both of which pnt finn toward a
{nttectal and pita rection fr now, bt one ch invoice
‘king hickmut the formar looking ltrs of moder
This would neal invove moving Beyond the Keo ie
nllcance of "Histor. wh the connotations of faed progres
‘ivi evoked by Skin DuclAors, and abo lxjond te ans
Soa ct fps dena Wi hn perpen
“Throwghowt the cis collected Into ths book, dere i a
securing seahebe and political aie! the way that the Now
Iwan Cinema ofthe He hs fesse the hee of na
[Nina As ita Nagi sayin her nroictn: It om pa
‘eto aera nt te new fle mana 9 rong Mar
‘link with rain ins of the pasta that hey share 3 num
Uber features and tendencies” Kea Xaver, an Bens sd
Teta Nagi again, inher chapter Took closely andrea a
‘Bie hei nk "They note th tte, i 9 ns oD
fenblemate Gnome Now subj. paricary the st he
poverty sriken Novas of Bra) Ad Ue ows (he sans of
Fo} tmspite of weir mportane collecive empha onthe diet
‘herent warnete about the return to dest there
‘but an hommage tthe carer cinema of social constiowsness.
rom ahi penpecte, the "reworking. of national allegory
(Savers tem) might rprenent mone evar a ep
ing the rasp cna work hog he ube Th
‘snot conta an nea, nosaige etm to wpa
Than as ove Nd 9 SHOHY
hopes. But cond acknowledge the prblens posed by hire
{acura ed ocnglae dns euler, pal i the preg
‘coe rma pola and economic change
woe te cu a aon apy ed
Prominin keeping th he real ay fH, become ae
Fain in which contemporary demas ean be reovked and ee
‘mein de Brat Cn ttn Wale Sls 1998) ep
Keeping with er eracng. of Clauer Rochas "Aeshede of
rac ars psn ok ply snd hep
Seamer nd of wil ronan nd yet
sone te age ha ce ht Ca Nn
pontmodernty wed tation to proce a seare of mule
St aening ofthe here andthe diachronic thewe rele
‘Guttoudy perbape tentate resmertbed by 4 crema that
rol Hike suse hag sce bythe eel tres hat
Time change.
erkape ny approach alee By Be ek of aioe across
the get den tan, The ey inteeting aed ein,
tem arta era ny aie at dep
Image into the alley and the arworld. "Theres no dalogue
wth the radial rantgue ofthe Se and the so came,
Term to dramatize th es The Brita vance the Os
tnt Ms ranged eros gallery and perfomance wor, er uchthin the eds modernist athe, to fein reorkig
‘aerate, co experimental doce. The jour Afi
‘brought dierent rand of ivdependent nd experi eth
togethers Ad in Keng Nth te adel iemaona pt
tion af the tie, the coer of ec was take re late
Koch's Osi da mate sonia sein Gur (Aoi
Non, 160 Uinetly though intereing work coved
‘bedoneon's more indi bl tough the 10, he move
ment fellin the fice of to, quite connect cent
Tn 1979 Manguee Thatcher became re Mines, ein
confident acral Comer Gonement that ey ely
xt of the ning hat had kept the ts eae ane, Ot
‘he her hand n 198 fourth T cael cme on thea
4 poke bie wo encoenge expeinental work» Channel Font
‘Seemed fore at lest open at ey pate for aa
‘era retention seach er anne’ Bt the ne
Dimi fered by eleven vas ako emblemate of the decline
‘tn format and alter exhbaon spces paps
‘combination of these Beto that conte daly
the Heh atic cineams experience of caer ‘The pala
‘Font parla omni, nen ough se of Aeon sd
dbovictaion tht foes around the spec plane that it
Firs woman Prine Miniter cel tok dani the wok
‘hist ad moat curing teteon ovement, A of eu
‘uorienaion asthe economies pie np gaa:
on seemed ob js wo gto grasp
Tat 1 concide by rtuming Wo the question of nema in
be present climate of eit etna an perl conte
Inion to the Wifi of egotatag aco the oes die
Praca theo cal sapect of the nes jen
legeter ere: Fit of al. the Birth of the cinema slowed he
‘orld e seni ll he deal of oeshanial moement, i
‘imseent socal ad seed mln, Ofer Be
wal sein Now so witha seme of woe the acme
‘hema eto ofthe Went century offers, tao mich 3
toe ya sein the word te presen uta lescope ta he
pase” Now ane th te simple our oii baton ea
Sop an tha about the comple of min ages wi he
‘ae pce for reflection on tne tht hs angen lee the
{il phlogeph Rather than the voy eden ccd
vith projected cinema fen dace by ein 2 more “pen
Tie cinema, in Rnmmond Bllours prise, should emerge
‘Grea can become 4 mater allegory forthe ontemporary
ec to bxng the “rabble of history ip clove and "eset the
Teas of agicane” at i cao prone a sory
tprecente tne chine’ wih we do. The clos
"Ines ye thre evidently a Maye bt ti neil eo
‘fie moment but abo, and pes more crcl offers a
‘ore alata imginae, means fr retectng on me ll BP
I iights none acon ina bileren cco enn,
‘Blows flection on ow te were clare a pin
fn how ges let inthe sabenem of hoy. tm se
Comat of thought abo tempore, dee gape andl contin
‘cute Brain tenance’ nema ow election
Siri ee rar an
Toy son, ne Aer