Professional Documents
Culture Documents
© 2023 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
e134
approach causes the loss of solid den- two different lengths. The null hy- premolars were as follows: standard-
tin tissue and reduces the mechanical potheses were that neither the post ized mesiodistal and buccolingual
resistance of the tooth; consequently, type nor length would influence the root thickness, straight root, and type
the tooth is more vulnerable to frac- fracture resistance. I canal configuration. Premolars were
ture against occlusal forces.6 excluded from the study if they met
Both over-preparation of the any of the following criteria: presence
post space to reduce post and ca- Materials and Methods of internal root resorption, canal calci-
nal mismatch and inserting the post fication, fracture, Vertucci type other
too deeply into the canal jeopardize This study was approved by the Re- than type I, canal ramifications, root
the fracture resistance of the tooth.1,3 search Ethics Committee of Akdeniz concavities, root caries, or previous
Although the adhesive properties of University (no. 302). The protocol was endodontic treatment.
fiber posts allow them to be inserted accomplished in accordance with the The teeth were cleaned of peri-
less deeply into the canal than metal guidelines outlined in the Declara- odontal soft tissue, calculus, and
cast posts, it is impossible to apply tion of Helsinki. To determine the debris and were decoronated at the
the fiber post to the appropriate sample size, according to the pres- cementoenamel junction perpen-
length without removing the intact ent pilot study values containing 5 dicular to the longitudinal axis using
dentin tissue in cases of the sharp specimens for each of the four groups a diamond rotary cutting instrument
root curvature involving the entire (a total of 20), a power analysis was (DNA Dental) on a high-speed hand-
root.7 Further, in addition to polym- performed using the G*Power soft- piece (Super Torque 625, KaVo). All
erization shrinkage stress in the post ware (version 3.1, Heinrich-Heine- roots were cut to an equal length of
space where the configuration factor Universität Düsseldorf), with an ef- approximately 14 mm. The root sur-
(c-factor) is already high, conventional fect size of 0.84, a confidence level face of all specimens was cleaned with
posts present a single block structure of 0.05, and power of 95%. The ob- a periodontal scaler.
and decrease contact with the dentin tained minimum sample size for each Endodontic procedures were
walls, especially in non-round canals.8 group was 8. However, 4 specimens performed in all groups by one endo-
A bundle post system (Rebilda were added to account for loss in lab- dontist (D.Y.). A no. 15 K-file (Dentsply
Post GT, Voco) was developed to al- oratory tests. Thus, the total sample Malleifer) was used to determine the
low more tissue-protective clinical size for the present study was 48 working length, and 0.5 mm was re-
approaches for curved roots and (n = 12 per group). tracted after the tip was visible at the
extremely irregular canals. This sys- Forty-eight human mandibular root apex. The root canal instrumen-
tem consists of fine individual posts first premolars extracted for peri- tations were performed with nickel-
(0.3-mm diameter) and adapts to dif- odontal or orthodontic reasons titanium files (Protaper Next, Dentsply
ferent canal morphologies, according (without fractures) were selected. Sirona) in the sequence of X1, X2, and
to the manufacturer. A previous study The specimens were stored in 0.1% X3 files with the crown-down tech-
that investigated the stress distribu- thymol solution until needed for the nique, and canals were irrigated with
tion of a bundle post system via fi- in vitro procedures. Two periapical 5 mL 5.25% sodium hypochlorite. The
nite element analysis demonstrated radiographs were obtained for each canals were obturated with X3 gutta-
that the bundle post system caused specimen (at mesiodistal and bucco- percha points (Dentsply Sirona) and
higher stress in the root.9 However, lingual angles) to verify the absence a sealer (AH26, Dentsply Sirona). All
there is insufficient information in the of the second canal, internal root specimens were stored in 100% hu-
literature on the bundle post system. resorption, canal calcification, and midity for 1 week. After the storage
Thus, the present study compared fractures. External root surfaces were period, the teeth were randomly di-
the fracture strength of mandibular examined with optical magnification vided into four experimental groups
premolar teeth restored with fiber for the presence of root fracture. In- (n = 12 per group) according to post
posts and bundle posts inserted in clusion criteria of the mandibular first system and post length: Group C9
© 2023 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
e135
dual-cure adhesive core material (Re- Fig 1 Dimensions of post-core structures of specimens in (a) Group C9 (9-mm conven-
tional post); (b) Group C5 (5-mm conventional post); (c) Group B9 (9-mm bundle post); and
bilda DC, Voco) was inserted into the (d) Group B5 (5-mm bundle post).
canal. Conventional fiber posts and
bundle posts were placed into the ca-
nal with finger pressure according to core design. To stabilize the long axes formed on the specimens. The speci-
the specimens’ assigned study group. of the specimens during placement mens were exposed to 5,000 thermal
All specimens were polymerized via a in the self-curing acrylic resin, par- cycles in water baths of 5ºC to 55ºC
light unit (VALO Cordless LED Curing affin discs (Set Up Modelling Wax, with 20 seconds for each bath (Fig 2).
Light, Ultradent). The core design of all Cavex) were used (Fig 2). After resin To measure fracture resistance, the
specimens was structured with stan- polymerization, a light-bodied polyvi- specimens were tested with a univer-
dardized dimensions using the core- nyl siloxane impression material (Elite sal testing machine (Shimadzu). Each
matrix: 5-mm total height with 1 mm HD+, Zhermack) was injected into the specimen was aligned at a 45-degree
of composite resin that covers 3 mm acrylic resin root chamber, and roots angle relative to the long axis of the
of post height (Fig 1). All specimens were inserted manually. tooth (Fig 2). The static compressive
were polymerized for 40 seconds. After the polymerization pro- load (500 N) with a cross-head speed
To simulate a periodontal liga- cess, the specimens were stored in of 0.5 mm/minute was exerted on the
ment, the roots were wrapped in deionized water (37°C) for 3 days. To facial surface of the buccal cusp until
aluminum foil and embedded in self- simulate temperature changes and fracture occurred. The fracture resis-
curing acrylic resin (Meliodent, Kulzer) masticatory force in the oral cav- tance was measured in Newtons. After
immediately after post insertion and ity, thermocycling loading was per- mechanical tests, the failure mode was
© 2023 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
e136
a b c
d e
Fig 2 (a) Placement of the bundle post. (b) A core matrix was used to standardize the dimensions. (c) Paraffin discs were used to stabilize the
axes. (d) Samples underwent a thermocycling process. (e) After thermocycling, the specimens were loaded to measure fracture resistance.
© 2023 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
e137
Table 1 The Fracture Resistance of Bundle and Conventional Fiber Posts at Different Lengths
Study group Mean (SD) Median Minimum Maximum
Group C9 391.39 (± 76.96) a
380.7 270.9 518.6
Group C5 408.49 (± 97.13) a 442.2 233.4 520.8
Group B9 384.79 (± 103.85) a 333 261.1 535.4
Group B5 435.55 (± 162.03) a
464.05 241.9 700.5
Group C9 = 9-mm conventional post; Group C5 = 5-mm conventional post; Group B9 = 9-mm bundle post; Group B5 = 5-mm bundle post.
All values are presented in Newtons.
aSame superscript letters were not significantly different (two-way ANOVA; P > .05).
conventional post. Because the bun- and did not increase the root frac- tion in both study groups. In order
dle post system comprises fine indi- ture strength. In a previous study to directly evaluate the effect of the
vidual posts, it acts as a customized evaluating the monoblock struc- novel bundle post and to standard-
post and creates a more uniform struc- ture, it was reported that creating ize the remaining dentin tissue, post
ture in the canal due to the distribution a monoblock in the canal improved cavities were prepared for the teeth
of the entire post space. Depending fracture resistance.12 On the contrary, with the same cervical diameter in
on its properties, it is expected that another previous study evaluating the all groups. Otherwise, the remain-
by forming a monoblock structure in effect of the morphologic structure ing dentin would differ among study
the root, the intense strain areas will of the fiber post showed that form- groups, and the fracture resistance
decrease, and the fracture will not oc- congruence does not affect fracture would be positively affected in the
cur at a specified high-stressed point.11 strength,13 which is congruent with bundle post group.
However, in the present study, it the results of the present study. In Prefabricated round fiber
was observed that the bundle post the present study, the results may be posts, which have a structure that
in the canal formed a monoblock affected by the post space prepara- is mismatched to the canal space,
© 2023 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
e138
create a leverage effect and make the post distributes the stress to the ligament.25,26 Further, the periodon-
teeth more susceptible to fracture. limited area.19,20 tal ligament simulation is effective in
However, fiber posts decrease frac- The specimens of the present the failure mode. A previous study
ture resistance, as they require canal study presented no ferrule or crown showed that more catastrophic frac-
space preparation to adapt prop- prosthesis. The use of a crown pros- tures were observed in models with-
erly.14 In a previous study examining thesis has been suggested in order to out the periodontal ligament.27
tooth deformation caused by differ- adequately replicate the clinical con- The main limitation of this study
ent procedures, it was reported that ditions when evaluating fracture resis- is the inability of an in vitro investi-
the most deforming procedure was tance.21 However, the presence of a gation to adequately replicate oral
the parallel-sided post preparation.15 crown prosthesis and ferrule design conditions. A static load and no fer-
The deviations generally occur in the affect the fracture resistance more rule design symbolize worst-case
natural course of the canal during than the post-related factors. It has scenarios, not adequately represent-
post space preparation of the teeth been reported that the crown pros- ing the oral cavity and the best treat-
with very curved roots.16 The post thesis creates a ferrule effect on the ment option.21–24 As is the nature of
type evaluated in the present study tooth and covers the effect of other in vitro fracture-strength studies, the
allows post-core treatment without factors.22–24 In order to evaluate the results of the present study are appli-
deforming the canal. effect of post-related factors more cable to clinical use with the scope of
The present study showed that clearly, crown prosthesis and ferrule only short-term to medium-term ag-
there was no significant difference design were excluded from the pres- ing, while the long-term behavior re-
in fracture strength according to ent study’s methodology, as reported mains unknown. Further in vitro stud-
the post lengths. Thus, the second in previous studies.23 In addition, ex- ies that focus on different mechanical
hypothesis was accepted. This re- cluding the crown prosthesis enabled properties are needed to understand
sult is in congruence with previous a loading point to be created on the this bundle post system, and clinical
studies that evaluated the effect of core structure, preventing the tip of studies are needed to understand the
post length.17,18 Although the pres- the universal testing machine from long-term results of this material.
ent study showed that post length dislodging.
did not affect fracture strength, the According to the results of the
shorter fiber post (which was, at mini- present study, in all groups, restor- Conclusions
mum, the same length as the clinical able fractures were more common
crown height) that was luted to the than nonrestorable catastrophic frac- Within the limitation of the present
root canal with adhesive results in tures. This might be related to the study, the results demonstrate that
less removed dentin, which is direct- fiber post that reinforces the cervical root restoration with the bundle
ly related to the tooth survival rate.16 area and distributes the occlusal forc- post did not reduce the mechanical
Contrary to the results of the present es all along the root. In the present resistance of the tooth compared to
study, previous studies showed that study, the periodontal ligament was the conventional round fiber post.
shorter fiber posts negatively affect simulated in order to better repre- Post length did not affect fracture
fracture resistance.13,19,20 These stud- sent the anatomical structure of the strength.
ies indicated that fiber posts with an tooth. This representation ensured
elastic modulus similar to dentin act the movement of the specimen dur-
as a hydraulic system when subjected ing fracture formation against force, Acknowledgments
to compressive forces. Therefore, the just like a natural tooth within a peri-
longer fiber post absorbs more force odontal ligament. Thus, more realis- This study was supported by the Akdeniz
rather than transmitting it to the root tic results were obtained using this University Scientific Research Projects Coor-
dination Unit (grant no. TDH-2017-2791). The
dentin, which positively affects the more biomimetic model compared
authors declare no conflicts of interest.
fracture resistance, while the short to the model without the periodontal
© 2023 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
e139
10. Scotti N, Borga FAC, Alovisi M, Rota 19. Lin J, Matinlinna JP, Shinya A, Botelho
References
R, Pasqualini D, Berutti E. Is fracture MG, Zheng Z. Effect of fiber post length
resistance of endodontically treated and abutment height on fracture resis-
1. Bhuva B, Giovarruscio M, Rahim N, Bitter
mandibular molars restored with indi- tance of endodontically treated premo-
K, Mannocci F. The restoration of root
rect onlay composite restorations influ- lars prepared for zirconia crowns. Odon-
filled teeth: A review of the clinical lit-
enced by fibre post insertion? J Dent tology 2018;106:215–222.
erature. Int Endod J 2021;54:509–535.
2012;40:814–820. 20. Junqueira RB, de Carvalho RF, Marinho
2. Santos TDSA, Abu Hasna A, Abreu RT, et
11. Martins MD, Junqueira RB, de Carvalho CC, Valera MC, Carvalho CAT. Influence
al. Fracture resistance and stress distribu-
RF, Lacerda MFLS, Faé DS, Lemos CAA. of glass fibre post length and remaining
tion of weakened teeth reinforced with a
Is a fiber post better than a metal post dentine thickness on the fracture resis-
bundled glass fiber-reinforced resin post.
for the restoration of endodontically tance of root filled teeth. Int Endod J
Clin Oral Investig 2022;26:1725–1735.
treated teeth? A systematic review and 2017;50:569–577.
3. Soares CJ, Pereira JC, Valdivia AD, Novais
meta-analysis. J Dent 2021;112:103750. 21. Tan PL, Aquilino SA, Gratton DG, et al.
VR, Meneses MS. Influence of resin cement
12. Elnaghy A, Elsaka S. Fracture resistance In vitro fracture resistance of endodonti-
and post configuration on bond strength to
of simulated immature roots using cally treated central incisors with vary-
root dentine. Int Endod J 2012;45:136–145.
Biodentine and fiber post compared ing ferrule heights and configurations. J
4. Bitter K, Falcon L, Prates Soares A, Sturm
with different canal-filling materials un- Prosthet Dent 2005;93:331–336.
R, von Stein-Lausnitz M, Sterzenbach G.
der aging conditions. Clin Oral Invest 22. Zhou L, Wang Q. Comparison of fracture
Effect of application mode on bond
2020;24:1333–1338. resistance between cast posts and fiber
strength of adhesively luted glass-fiber
13. Büttel L, Krastl G, Lorch H, Naumann M, posts: A meta-analysis of literature. J En-
bundles inside the root canal. J Adhes
Zitsmann NU, Weiger R. Influence of post dod 2013;39:11–15.
Dent 2019;21:517–524.
fit and on post length on resistance frac- 23. Al-Omiri MK, Mahmoud AA, Rayyan MR,
5. Pereira RD, Brito-Júnior M, Leoni GB,
ture. Int Endod J 2009;42:47–53. Abu-Hammad O. Fracture resistance
Estrela C, de Sousa-Neto MD. Evaluation
14. Barbosa Kasuya AV, Favarão IN, of teeth restored with post-retained
of bond strength in single-cone fillings of
Machado AC, Rezende Spini PH, Soares restorations: An overview. J Endod
canals with different cross‐sections. Int
PV, Fonseca RB. Development of a fiber- 2010;36:1439–1449.
Endod J 2017;50:177–183.
reinforced material for fiber posts: Evalu- 24. Naumann M, Metzdorf G, Fokkinga W, et
6. Alharbi FA, Nathanson D, Morgano SM,
ation of stress distribution, fracture load, al. Influence of test parameters on in vitro
Baba NZ. Fracture resistance and failure
and failure mode of restored roots. J fracture resistance of post-endodontic
mode of fatigued endodontically treated
Prosthet Dent 2020;123:829–838. restorations: A structured review. J Oral
teeth restored with fiber‐reinforced resin
15. Lang H, Korkmaz Y, Schneider K, Raab Rehabil 2009;36:299–312.
posts and metallic posts in vitro. Dent
WH. Impact of endodontic treatments 25. Sary SB, Samah MS, Walid AAZ. Effect
Traumatol 2014;30:317–325.
on the rigidity of the root. J Dent Res of restoration technique on resistance
7. Sturm R, Prates Soares A, Sterzenbach G,
2006;85:364–368. to fracture of endodontically treated
Bitter K. Interface analysis after fatigue
16. Ha WN, Chaves GS, Decurcio D, Estrela anterior teeth with flared root canals. J
loading of adhesively luted bundled fiber
C, Peters OA, Rossi-Fedele G. Remaining Biomed Res 2019;33:131.
posts to human root canal dentin. J Mech
dentinal thickness after simulated post 26. Soares CJ, Pizi EC, Fonseca RB, Martins
Behav Biomed Mater 2012;119:104385.
space preparation and the fit of prefab- LR. Influence of root embedment mate-
8. Spicciarelli V, Marruganti C, Di Matteo
ricated posts to root canal preparation rial and periodontal ligament simulation
C, et al. Influence of single post, oval,
shapes. J Am Dent Assoc 2021;152: on fracture resistance tests. Braz Oral Res
and multi-post restorative techniques
1020–1032. 2005;19:11–16.
and amount of residual tooth substance
17. Franco EB, Lins do Valle A, Pompéia 27. Silva CF, Cabral LC, Navarro de Oliveira
on fracture strength of endodontically
Fraga de Almeida AL, Rubo JH, Pereira M, et al. The influence of customization
treated maxillary premolars. J Oral Sci
JR. Fracture resistance of endodontically of glass fiber posts on fracture strength
2020;63:70–74.
treated teeth restored with glass fiber and failure pattern: A systematic review
9. Yanık D, Turker N. Stress distribution of
posts of different lengths. J Prosthet and meta-analysis of preclinical ex-vivo
a novel bundle fiber post with curved
Dent 2014;111:30–34. studies. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater
roots and oval canals. J Esthet Restor
18. Schmitter M, Rammelsberg P, Lenz J, 2021;118:104433.
Dent 2021;34:550–556.
Scheuber S, Schweizerhof K, Rues S.
Teeth restored using fiber-reinforced
posts: in vitro fracture tests and fi-
nite element analysis. Acta Biomater
2010;6:3747–3754.
© 2023 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY.
NO PART MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.