You are on page 1of 16

history

New insights are provided into the architecture of Islamic bath-


houses of North Africa and the Middle East based on comparative
typological analyses of their space and proportion from five cities.

The architecture of Islamic public baths


of North Africa and the Middle East: an
analysis of their internal spatial configurations
Magda Sibley and Iain Jackson

The hammams (or Islamic bath-houses), commonly most houses did not have private bathrooms. Their
known as ‘Turkish baths’, are one of the key urban location within the city’s urban fabric is associated
facilities in Islamic cities. They evolved from the with not only the location of urban water
Roman and Byzantine public baths, as these were distribution networks, existing wells and springs but
assimilated when the Umayyad dynasty conquered also the proximity of both small and large mosques
Byzantine territories in the Middle East between ad within reasonable walking distance. Their size and
661 and 750. Early hammams were built in the eighth importance vary according to location, from small
century by the Umayyad rulers who established their structures in the heart of residential neighbourhoods
capital in Damascus. The most famous ones are to large buildings near major Friday mosques,
Qusayr Amra, in today’s north-eastern desert of theology teaching centres (madrassas), commercial
1
Jordan and Khirbat al Mafjar. The period following and crafts centres as well as caravanserais.
the rise of Islam witnessed a rapid development in the The Mediterranean hammam culture has played an
architecture of baths and the change from Roman to important role in supporting and transmitting a
Islamic bathing habits. Public Roman baths consisted rich, intangible heritage of culinary art, songs, poems
of very large establishments, the thermae, which as well as rituals of cleaning and beautifying the body.
comprised not only bathing facilities but also The hammam has been particularly important for
recreational ones such as libraries, gymnasiums, women as for centuries it was their only gathering
exercise grounds and gardens, tanning rooms, ball space in the city outside the home. The undressing
courts and concert halls. The balnea were the smaller room has social significance as a meeting place for the
privately or publicly owned Roman baths, located in arrangement of marriages and as a venue for the
2
greater number within the city. celebration of key life events such as pre-wedding
ceremonies, the birth of a child and the circumcision
Origins, rituals and traditions of a son. The undressing room is also where the latest
The hammams have evolved from the balnea tradition, neighbourhood news is exchanged and provides a
and consist of a large undressing hall and a sequence relaxing space for men where both business and
of three bathing rooms with increasing temperature political events are frequently discussed; as such,
and steam intensity. The cold plunge pool – an hammams have been the locus of social interaction
important feature of the Roman bath – disappeared for centuries, supporting a rich heritage and
in the Islamic hammam, where washing by pouring anchoring collective memories for many generations.
water over the body rather than immersing it in a The bathing ritual in the hammams of the
bath or a shared pool was an important religious Mediterranean region follows almost the same
3
requirement. sequence with slight variations. The body is never
In Islam, minor ablutions, Wudu, are required entirely exposed to the gaze of other bathers and is
before the act of praying and consist of washing parts traditionally wrapped in a fouta, a cotton towel. After
of the body (the face, the mouth, the nose, the ears, sweating in the hot room and then having their body
the arms and the feet). These are usually carried out scrubbed by a hammam attendant, the bathers wash
either at home or at the mosque. Major ablutions, their body facing the individual stone or marble
however, known as Ghusl, involve the purification of washing basin, scooping water with a brass bowl
the whole body, particularly after sexual intercourse commonly known as tassa and pouring water over the
and menstruation. Prior to the act of praying, which whole body. The bathers sit directly on the warm
takes place five times a day, the entire body is washed stone or marble floor or on wooden stools. However,
with running water before minor ablutions can be in the hammams of Morocco, hot and cold water are
performed. The ritual of body purification in Islam collected from hot and cold water fountain pools,
therefore contributed to the proliferation of public using wooden buckets, and these are then arranged
baths in the cities of the Islamic world at a time when on the floor, defining a private bathing area. The

history arq . vol 16 . no 2 . 2012 155


156 arq . vol 16 . no 2 . 2012 history

washing of private parts of the body takes place in between 2007 and 2009 in the cities of Ankara
semi-dark niches for a higher degree of privacy. The (Turkey), Damascus (Syria), Cairo (Egypt), Constantine
bathers move around spaces of different heat and (Algeria) and Fez (Morocco), focusing on five selected
steam intensity, but also of different levels of natural historic structures in each city.
light and privacy, in order to perform different body The first part of the paper presents the architecture
treatments. The scrubbing of the body takes place of hammams in five southern Mediterranean cities,
either on the floor or on the large heated marble highlighting the underlying logic in their spatial
table under the pierced dome or vault of the hot organisation and providing a new understanding of
room. The bathers might rest for a short while variations found across a wide but continuous
between the different stages of washing by sitting in geographic area. The second part of the paper focuses
the transition room, separating the undressing hall on analysing the way the total floor area of the twenty-
from the bathing spaces. seven hammam buildings investigated is distributed
Studies into the architecture of hammam between the different functional zones, with the aim
buildings in North Africa and the Middle East have of highlighting any patterns and overriding principles
remained few and far between. In the 1930s and ’40s, in their layout. Furthermore, investigations are
French architects carried out important research. carried out into the geometric composition of the
For example Michel Écochard and Claude Le Coeur spaces. The aim here is not to force particular
undertook extensive surveys of the hammams of geometric shapes onto the plan (especially as the
4
Damascus, and Edmond Pauty recorded the hammams were often built into tight urban plots,
5
hammams of Cairo. Henri Terrasse investigated therefore restricting the design to a small floor area),
6
some hammams in Fez, and Edmond Secret (a but to look for broad guiding principles that may have
French doctor in Fez) revealed the traditions linked been sought by the designers and builders at the time
to the hammam as well as some of the health these structures were erected. The third part analyses
7
benefits and risks of bathing in public hammams. the sections of the hammams and examines the
A more recent study by Martin Dow was conducted proportions of the different spaces. The aim here is to
8
on the hammams of Palestine. However, compare internal room proportions with particular
comparative studies of hammams across the emphasis on height:width ratios. The objective is not
southern Mediterranean countries are almost non- only to compare the scales of each hammam, but to
existent, and no investigations have been carried out consider whether certain proportions were
so far in revealing the silent rules embedded in their specifically pursued for certain rooms.
design, spatial composition and proportions. Five hammams were selected as primary focus case
The spatial configuration of hammams not only studies. All are historic structures still operating at
depends on the historical era when they were built the neighbourhood scale of the city: Hammam
but also on their geographical location around the Ammouneh, twelfth century (Damascus); Hammam
Mediterranean. Whereas the spatial organisation of Sengul, sixteenth century (Ankara); Hammam Bab al
the hammams of Morocco (reminiscent of the small Bahr, eighteenth century (Cairo); Hammam Seffarine,
9
Roman baths evident in Volubilis) has remained fourteenth century (Fez) and Hammam Suq al-Ghazal,
mostly unchanged throughout history, the spatial eighteenth century (Constantine). Each of the twenty-
organisation of those in Syria has undergone an seven buildings (located in the five cities listed above)
evolution over a period of many centuries. Such an has been visited, surveyed and extensively
evolution is clearly illustrated in the large sample of photographed, generating a substantial
hammams of Damascus investigated by Écochard and documentary record. In some hammams it was
10
Le Coeur in the 1940s. possible to observe, as well as to participate in, the
bathing process. In other cases, the hammam was no
Insights and approaches longer operational, or it was considered culturally
This paper provides a new insight into the insensitive to measure the space while in operation,
architecture of the Islamic bath-house in cities across so the hammam was studied outside opening hours.
North Africa and the Middle East area. Based on a Where possible, the hammam owners/managers have
sample of twenty-seven historic structures located in been interviewed and areas ‘out of bounds’ to the
five different cities, this paper sheds new light on the public, such as the furnace, have also been
building typology, highlighting its constant features documented and observed in action. In each case, a
as well as regional variations. The proportions and plan view and sectional drawing of the hammam have
geometric composition of the internal spaces are been drawn to scale and each distinct room within
investigated in order to reveal underlying principles the building photographed.
that have informed their layout and volumetric
composition. The results presented in this paper The architecture of hammams in the five case
stem from fieldwork conducted by the main author study cities
as part of a large research project into the hammams The vast majority of the hammams in the cities of
of the Mediterranean region, funded by the Lebanon, Palestine, Syria, Egypt and across the whole
European Commission Sixth Framework Programme of North Africa from Libya to Morocco, consist of
under the title hammam: Hammam, Aspects and single structures operating for men and women in
Multidisciplinary Methods of Analysis for the separate time slots. Their presence in the city tends to
Mediterranean Region (see www.hammams.org and be rather discreet as they are usually well embedded
www.hammams.info). Fieldwork was carried out in the urban fabric, sharing their walls with other

Sibley & Jackson  The architecture of Islamic public baths of North Africa and the Middle East
history arq . vol 16 . no 2 . 2012 157

1a

2a

1b

2b

1c

buildings and presenting an almost blank facade to


the street, but sometimes displaying a decorated
entrance. However, the hammams of Turkey present
an exception to this rule as almost all historic
hammams here consist of twin structures operating 2c
independently for men and women. The male
section has the strongest presence in the urban
fabric, usually displaying a more public entrance 1 Hammam roof b Sultan Inal, Cairo,
2 Central fountains in
architecture: a fifth 2006 hammam undressing
facade, whereas the female section is accessed from a facade of pierced c Sengul, roof of the
rooms
less public space and displays a more discreet domes and vaults twin structure, a Ammouneh,
a Ammouneh, Ankara, 2007 Damascus
entrance facade. In all countries of North Africa and Damascus, 2007 b Karacebey, Ankara
the Middle East, the hammam’s presence in the c al-Tanbali, Cairo

  The architecture of Islamic public baths of North Africa and the Middle East   Sibley & Jackson
158 arq . vol 16 . no 2 . 2012 history

urban fabric is most evident at roof level through the


unique architectural composition of pierced domes
and vaults, presenting the most interesting fifth
facade of all building types in the historic fabric of
cities in the Islamic world [1].
In all countries, without exception, a typical
hammam consists of three distinct sections: the first
section comprises the entrance and the undressing
hall, the second section consists of a series of bathing
spaces and the third section is defined by the furnace
area, usually located at the back of the hot room but
not accessible from it. The furnace area is not only
where the water is heated; it also acts as the heating
system for the bathing spaces. The smoke and heat
from the fireplace travels under the raised floor of the
bathing spaces before being extracted by chimneys
integrated into the walls of the building. This system
of underfloor heating is reminiscent of the Roman
hypocaust, and is found in the hammams of all
countries around the Mediterranean, though with
some variations. The hammams of Egypt present the
only exception to this rule, as the hypocaust system
seems to have been abandoned during the Fatimid
era in favour of a system of hot water pools releasing
11
heat and steam into the bathing spaces.
The act of washing in the hammam is marked by a
sequence of rituals that take place in a succession of
bathing spaces varying in their intensity of heat, 3a
humidity and natural light. The journey starts
outside the hammam, from a discreet street entrance
leading to the changing room via an intermediate
space that acts as a buffer zone between the public
street and the semi-public reception/undressing hall.
The changing room is usually the largest and most
decorated space with a central area, sometimes
demarcated by the presence of a central fountain as
is usually the case in Damascus, Cairo and Ankara [2].
The changing areas are traditionally open spaces
defined by raised platforms along the peripheral
walls of the reception hall and may include wooden
lockers used for storing belongings. The roof of the
undressing room consists, in most cases, of a large
3b
masonry dome. This is the case in the hammams of
Turkey, Lebanon, Syria and Palestine, sometimes the
3 Undressing rooms typical undressing remains of an
case in the hammams of Libya, Tunisia, Algeria and
(locally called room wooden roof atypical large
Morocco and almost never the case in the hammams maslakh) in with clerestory locally masonry dome
of Cairo which are characterised by a wooden roof hammams of Cairo called Shukhsheikha covering the
a Bab al Bahr: the b al Muayyad: the
undressing room
structure with clerestory openings [3a]. There is
however one exception, and that is Hammam al
Muayyad, a Mameluke structure in ruins, which still There is no doubt that the Ottoman influence has
displays today the remains of an unusually large played an important role in modifying, as well as
12
masonry dome over its changing room [3b]. unifying, the tradition of hammam buildings in the
When examining the organisation of the bathing many Mediterranean countries that fell under the
spaces in hammam buildings, two typical Ottoman rule – Morocco being an interesting
configurations can be found. The first one is a linear exception. As clearly illustrated in the work of
14
and sequential organisation (reminiscent of the early Écochard and Le Coeur, which traces the evolution
Umayyad hammams) where the bathing spaces are of the architecture of bathing spaces in the
organised along an axis. The second one is a central hammams of Damascus between the twelfth and the
organisation, reminiscent of Byzantine architecture, twentieth centuries, the internal configuration and
where the spaces are organised around a main the size of the bathing spaces of the hammams of
octagonal room with diagonal extensions leading to Damascus witnessed a slow evolution and a shift
15
a cruciform configuration. Both forms existed during the Ottoman period. Their work shows that
simultaneously in Damascus between the twelfth during the twelfth and thirteenth centuries the
13
and fourteenth centuries. warm room is the predominant bathing space. In the

Sibley & Jackson  The architecture of Islamic public baths of North Africa and the Middle East
history arq . vol 16 . no 2 . 2012 159

4a

5a

4b

5b

4c

5c

4d

4 The hammams 5 The hammams


of Fez of Damascus
a Makhfia a al Malik al Zaher
b Boussouifa b al Jose
c Moulay Idriss c al Bzouriye
d Abbad d Fethi 5d

  The architecture of Islamic public baths of North Africa and the Middle East   Sibley & Jackson
160 arq . vol 16 . no 2 . 2012 history

fifteenth century the hot room is expanded with


alcoves, and with the sixteenth-century Ottoman
domination of the Levant territories, the hammam
acquires much simpler forms with the hot room
becoming the dominant bathing space in both layout
and volume.
The case study hammams can be divided according
to the organisation of the bathing spaces. The
hammams of Fez (Morocco) [4], Damascus (Syria) [5],
and Constantine (Algeria) [6], all adopt a linear
organisation, whereas those of Cairo (Egypt) [7], and
Ankara (Turkey) [8], adopt an octagonal distribution
with a central hub. The hammams of Egypt [7] present
a unique and constant spatial configuration based on
a cruciform hot room with diagonal extensions
containing plunge pools. This organisation seems to
have remained the same since the Fatimid era (when 6a

the hypocaust system was abandoned) and is likely to


be linked to the type of heating system specific to the
Cairo hammams, which relies on the heat and steam
released from hot water plunge pools.
The linear organisation of the hammams of Fez is
apparent in all the layouts of the hammams
investigated, with the warm room (wasti) being the
largest bathing space with separate bays and
interesting architectural features, including in some
cases a central dome as is the case in Hammam
Makhfia [4a]. The linear organisation of the bathing
spaces is also evident in the way the three zones of
6b
cold, warm and hot spaces succeed each other and
bear similar Arabic names to those of the hammams
of Damascus. However, it is clear that the hammams
of Damascus are architecturally more sophisticated
than those in Fez, in terms of their spatial
composition, volumes and decorations [5].
Furthermore, whereas the hypocaust system stops in
the hot room in the hammams of Fez, the hammams
of Damascus have developed underfloor heating
based on a duct system, channelling the smoke and
heat from the furnace to both hot and warm rooms
and branching out to bathing bays in both rooms.
They also have a more sophisticated water
distribution system allowing bathers to mix cold and
hot water in individual stone or marble basins located
along the walls of both the warm and hot rooms.
Historical links between Damascus and Fez must
certainly have occurred via Andalusia during the
Umayyad dynasty which initially ruled from
Damascus and later on from Andalusia.
The central organisation of bathing spaces is
evident in the hammams of Cairo [7] and Ankara [8].
Those of both cities share a similar principle of
distribution of bathing spaces from a central hub.
6c
However, they have completely different heating
systems which seem to inform their proportions and
configuration. Whereas the hammams of Ankara rely
on an underfloor heating system, those in Cairo rely
on the heat released from the hot water plunge pools.
As mentioned earlier, all the hammams of Cairo (with 6 The hammams of 7 The hammams
one exception) are characterised by a wooden roof Constantine of Cairo
a Deggoudj a Bashtak
structure over their changing room, a feature that is b Belabjaoui b Inal
also found in some of the small Ottoman baths in c Suq al-Ghazal c al Malatili

Turkey but nowhere else in the southern


16
Mediterranean countries.

Sibley & Jackson  The architecture of Islamic public baths of North Africa and the Middle East
history arq . vol 16 . no 2 . 2012 161

7c

The Cairo hammams present a unique spatial


configuration of bathing spaces when compared
with hammams in the other four cities. The hot
room (locally known as beit al-harara, meaning ‘the
room of heat’) presents a central hub covered by a
pierced dome and marked by a central marble table
7a
with a hot water fountain. The cruciform hot room is
characterised by its three to four vaulted recesses or
iwans and raised plunge pool rooms, located as
diagonal extensions. Within each annexe of the hot
room, specific bathing functions take place, such as
scrubbing, massage and – uniquely to Cairo –
immersion in plunge pools. As noted, the hot room
and annexe spaces of Cairo differ from other
countries in their layout; whereas in the previous
examples we have seen how the hot room is
rectilinear, in Cairo the hot room acts as a ‘central
hub’ surrounded by the smaller annexe rooms and
plunge pools in a cruciform arrangement. Such
major difference in the spatial configuration of the
hammams of Cairo could be explained by the fact
that they rely on a different heating system. The
furnace and the hot water tanks are located on the
roof and not alongside the hot room as is the case in
all other Mediterranean countries. Using gravity, the
hot water is channelled in clay pipes from the hot
water tank (on the roof) and falls into the plunge
pools, releasing heat and steam. In some cases the
plunge pools also have their own annexes, creating a
complex arrangement of small interlinked zones.
The hammams of Constantine [6] seem to have a
hybrid configuration type combining both Ottoman
and Andalusian influences as is the case in the
17
hammams of Algiers. Like the hammams of Fez, the
hot water is collected by the bathers from the hot
water pool, named burma in both Fez and
7b
Constantine. The warm room is absent in the
hammams of Constantine, and the hot room is the
most important space, as is the case in the hammams
of Ankara in Turkey. Furthermore, the hammams of
Constantine display a large changing room with a

  The architecture of Islamic public baths of North Africa and the Middle East   Sibley & Jackson
162 arq . vol 16 . no 2 . 2012 history

9a

8a

9b

9c

8b

8 The hammams of 9 Organisational


Ankara diagrams illustrating
a Sengul the various hammam
b Karacebey plan configurations
in the five cities
9d
a Seffarine, Fez
b Suq al-Ghazal,
Constantine
c al-Tanbali, Cairo
d Bab al Bahr, Cairo
e Ammouneh,
Damascus
f Sengul, Ankara

9e

9f

mezzanine level, similar to those found in the Interpretation of floor area distribution
changing rooms of the hammams of Ankara. Each room/space within the hammam has been
The diagrams in Figure 9 show a simplification of measured and the areas calculated, as shown in Tables
the spatial arrangement of the hammams 1 to 5. The hammams have been arranged according to
investigated in this paper. (These diagrams are based their geographic location, which enables the
on the spatial representation used by Martin Dow in hammams from each city to be compared. The
18
his analyses of the Islamic baths of Palestine.) The analysis of the total floor areas of all the twenty-seven
diagrams do not show floor areas or volumes, but hammams reveals some interesting results. The
illustrate the variations in the spatial sequence of the hammams of Ankara are the largest with a total floor
various hammam spaces in the five different cities. area for men and women sections ranging between

Sibley & Jackson  The architecture of Islamic public baths of North Africa and the Middle East
history arq . vol 16 . no 2 . 2012 163

Hammam Entrance Changing room Cold room Warm room Hot room Furnace Total

Belabjaoui 8.07 58.73 8.18 -- 46.75 10.89 132.62

Bougouffa 3.31 30.48 -- 11.33 22.56 5.83 73.51

Deggoudj 5.1 43 -- 10.18 22.3 11.25 91.83

Suq-al-Ghazal 1.72 84.57 26.85 -- 79.49 78.76 271.39

Table 1 Floor areas of the different spaces in the hammams of Constantine, Algeria (m2)

Hammam Entrance Changing room Cold room Warm room Hot room Furnace Total

Seffarine (male) 23.37 14.26 15.84 21.68 12.1 25.5 112.75

Seffarine (female) 12 18.15 23.8 42.2 38.9 25.5 160.55

Seffarine (total) 35.37 32.41 39.64 63.88 51 51 273.3

Abbad 6.4 37.28 36.85 32.7 23.61 17.96 154.8

Boussouifa 8.1 15.46 12.47 23.63 27.14 19.17 105.97

Makhfia 12.65 55.28 30 68.46 48.84 22.33 237.56

Moulay Idriss 7.99 48.16 21.16 31.2 30 25.8 164.31

Table 2 Floor areas of the different spaces in the hammams of Fez, Morocco (m2)

Hammam Entrance Changing room Cold room Warm room Hot room Furnace Total

al Jose 20.61 102.53 23.66 27.43 20.54 18.91 213.68

al Malik al Zaher 0.79 106.5 19.84 28.93 46.01 52.37 254.44

al Bzouriye 10.73 122.82 12.19 39.39 73.77 22.95 281.85

Fethi n/a 144.49 48.24 48.68 101.01 n/a 342.42

Omari 1.4 54.4 9.54 24.14 29.04 60 178.52

Silsleh 0.29 77.36 9.79 19.76 40.26 22.56 170.02

Ammouneh 1.74 58.25 n/a 16.8 35.82 10.82 123.43

Table 3 Floor areas of the different spaces in the hammams of Damascus, Syria (m2)

Hammam Entrance Changing room Warm room Hot room Furnace Total

Inal 8.87 136.27 9.66 118.1 n/a 272.9

al Nahhasin Qalawun 9.38 80 15.37 105 n/a 209.75

Sukkariya 11.3 107.86 15.04 81.14 n/a 215.34

Muayyad Shaykh 4.52 244.02 16.07 81.42 n/a 346.06

Darb al-Ahmar 5.88 125.3 20.66 75.37 n/a 227.21

Bashtak 27.6 215.95 29.32 113.89 n/a 386.76

al-Dud 22.45 174.1 49 252.39 n/a 497.94

al-Tanbali 8.2 104.67 14.7 130.65 n/a 258.22

Bab al Bahr 5.01 81.33 23.32 72.44 n/a 182.1

Table 4 Floor areas of the different spaces in the hammams of Cairo, Egypt (m2)

Hammam Entrance Changing room Warm room Hot room Furnace Total

Sengul (male) 16.86 108 34 99.52 30 288.38

Sengul (female) 8.7 119.1 27 76.76 30 261.56

Sengul (total) 25.56 227.1 61 176.28 60 549.94

Enebay 1.26 162.74 72 80.87 33.58 350.45

Karacebey (a) 6.3 244 15.18 126.95 37.5 429.93

Karacebey (b) 8.58 184.4 19.4 169 37.5 418.88

Karacebey (total) 14.88 428.4 34.58 295.95 77 850.81

2
Table 5 Floor areas of the different spaces in the hammams of Ankara, Turkey (m )

  The architecture of Islamic public baths of North Africa and the Middle East   Sibley & Jackson
164 arq . vol 16 . no 2 . 2012 history

100% 100%
90% 90%
80% 80%

70% 70%

60% 60%

50% 50%

40% 40%
30%
30%
20%
20%
10%
10%
0%
0% Inal al Sukkariya Muayyad Darb Bashtak al-Dud al-Tanbali Bab al
Belabjaoui Bougouffa Deggoudj Suq-al-Ghazal Nahhasin Shaykh al-Ahmar Bahr
Qalawun
10a 10d

100% 100%

90%
80% 80%

70%
60%
60%

50%
40%
40%

20% 30%

20%
0%
10%
Seffarine Seffarine Seffarine Abbad Boussouifa Makhfia Moulay
(total) (m) (f) Idriss 0%
Sengul Sengul Sengul Enebay Karacebey Karacebey Karacebey
(total) (m) (f) (a) (b) (total)
10b 10e

Key
100%
Furnace 10 Distribution of floor a Constantine,

90% areas by type of Algeria
Hot Room
80% space within the b Fez, Morocco

Warm Room hammams of the c Damascus, Syria

70%
case study cities d Cairo, Egypt

Cold Room
60% e Ankara, Turkey

Changing
50%
Entrance
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
al Jose al Malik al Bzourive Fethi Omari Silsleh Ammouneh
al Zaher
10c

260 and over 400 square metres (see Table 5). The exceed that of the hot room, which constitutes the
hammams of Cairo and Damascus seem to be closer in main bathing space in all the hammams of
their range of total floor areas to those in Ankara (see Constantine. The importance of the hot room, and
Tables 3 and 4). The hammams of Constantine and Fez the disappearance of the warm room, is reminiscent
tend to be smaller (Tables 1 and 2). Figure [10] of the Ottoman hammams and is a feature also found
illustrates how the total floor area of each hammam is only in the Ottoman hammams of Damascus.
distributed between the different spaces and is Compared with the hammams of Constantine, the
expressed as a percentage of the gross floor area. This hammams of Fez present much smaller entrance
enables a comparison of floor area distribution spaces and changing rooms. Furthermore, the warm
between the large hammams in prime city locations room (and not the hot room) is the largest bathing
and the smaller local neighbourhood ones. In the city space and occupies a central position between the
of Constantine in Algeria, the hammams adopt broad cold and the hot rooms. Despite slight variations, the
similarities between each room area, with warm room (in all the investigated hammams of Fez),
approximately 50% of the hammam devoted to always occupies a similar proportion of the total
entrance and changing areas, with the exception of floor area in each hammam [10b]. Their overall floor
Suq al-Ghazal, which has only 30% of its gross floor area as single structures varies between 100 and 160
area dedicated to these functions [10a]. However, if the square metres with the Makhfia hammam being an
large furnace area of Suq al-Ghazal (which also houses exception to the rule, having a total floor area
a wood workshop) is discounted from this calculation, exceeding 200 square metres.
the hammam has a similar proportion of the floor The pre-Ottoman hammams of Damascus present a
area devoted to the changing space (around 45%). The different condition to those of both Fez and
floor area of the changing room seems to always Constantine. Like the hammams of Fez, the three

Sibley & Jackson  The architecture of Islamic public baths of North Africa and the Middle East
history arq . vol 16 . no 2 . 2012 165

Hammam Hot room Gross floor Hot room as a smaller buffer before the hot rooms which
2
(central ‘hub’) area (m ) ‘hub’ as % occupy the second largest area in these cases. The
2
area (m ) of gross area
plan of hammams Sengul and Karacabey (in Ankara)
al-Tanbali 19.8 258.22 7.67
are arranged almost symmetrically, with the furnace
Bab al Bahr 23.4 182.1 12.85 located at the centre, and the male and female zones
Inal 26.7 272.9 9.78 on either side. In terms of the interior, the two main
al Nahhasin Qalawun 23.2 209.75 11.06 spaces are the changing area and the hot rooms each
occupying approximately 40% and 30% respectively
Sukkariya 18.9 215.34 8.78
of the total floor area of the hammam. The hot
Muayyad Shaykh 31.2 346.06 9.01
rooms contain smaller annexes in a similar fashion
Darb al-Ahmar 22 227.21 9.68 to the Cairo hammams, however here the plan is
Bashtak 28.4 386.76 7.34 restricted to the square rather than the more
al-Dud 42.5 497.94 8.53 fragmented arrangements of Cairo.
The floor area calculations and analyses reveal that
Table 6 Floor area of the hot room ‘hub’ area of the Cairo hammams the hammams located geographically close to each
other and within the same city, adopt similar floor
area proportions. There are, of course, variations and
space sequence of cold, warm and hot rooms is exceptions in each city representing the complex
maintained, but the division of these spaces is more urban sites that these structures occupy as well as
akin to those found in Constantine with a large specific needs, such as the population figures and
changing area and then a series of smaller bathing density of the immediate context. The location of the
rooms beyond. As a percentage of the whole, the hammam alongside other more civic and important
warm rooms are generally consistent across all the buildings, such as mosques, is also an important
hammams. The entrance spaces, apart from in Al factor determining its size. If each floor area is
Joze hammam in Damascus, are comparatively small, adjusted by plus or minus 10% then we see very
with the plans showing an almost direct entry into similar proportions in each city and broad
the changing space. It is common in other cities such similarities across the entire sample range. Despite
as Cairo, Constantine and Fez for the entrance space each hammam adopting very different plans and
to be designed in an ‘L’ formation to ensure privacy room shapes, the percentage area of each room
in the changing area; however, in Damascus and relative to the whole is very similar across all
Ankara, this transition space between the street and countries. The major exception to that conclusion is
the changing room is not always adopted. Fez, which has much smaller changing areas (an
As shown in figure [10d], the Cairo hammams have average of 18% of the total floor area compared with
a considerable proportion of room area devoted to 46% in the hammams of other countries) [10]. This
the changing room and hot room, with only a small could be due to the geographic position of Morocco,
transition room between them in the form of a which is the furthest distance from the Ottoman
warm room used as a winter undressing room as centres and has strong similarities with the
19
well. The central hub area of the Cairo hot rooms has Andalusian hammams in Spain.
also been measured, revealing a significant result.
Table 6 shows that regardless of the gross area of the Proportions and geometric configurations of spaces
hammam, the floor area of the hub area remains The results in Table 7 show considerable variation in
almost consistent throughout all the hammams of the height:width ratio of the hot rooms. This is
Cairo with slight variations. The larger hammams mainly due to the two variations of the central hub
will have additional annexes and plunge pools to space with annexes, and the alternative, a linear
accommodate larger visitor numbers; however, singular hot room. At Suq al-Ghazal we also find a
unlike their changing area, which varies very low ceiling relative to the overall width of the
dramatically from 80 square metres to 240 square hot room. It is in the proportions of the changing
metres (see Table 4), their hot room is not enlarged room that hammams share some similarities. The
proportionally. One reason for this could be the two Cairo hammams have very similar proportions
nature of the heating system adopted in these along with Ammouneh in Damascus, despite the
hammams, and the necessity to maintain a level of Damascus hammam having a rectilinear single-space
heat and steam based on the plunge pool heating hot room.
system as smaller rooms are easier to heat and keep As previously stated, the objective here is not to
warm. It could also be to aid privacy and enable impose ‘golden ratios’ or perfect geometries on the
families to have an entire annexe for themselves. hammam layouts, rather to consider principles and
Table 6 shows that the hot room areas vary between general notions relating to practical requirements
19.8 square metres and 31.2 square metres (with the such as the heating system and spatial hierarchies.
exception of al-Dud), a relatively small area range Each plan and section of the main case studies has
when compared with the differing sizes of the been analysed. The drawings shown here represent
changing rooms for example. only the most overt geometrical matches found in
In Ankara the results of the floor areas analyses this study. This type of research into hammam
show how the furnace areas are remarkably similar. typology has not been executed before and these
The changing areas also have similar floor areas, with results are tentative approaches at deciphering the
most around the 50% level [10e]. The warm rooms act complex arrangement of the hammam type.

  The architecture of Islamic public baths of North Africa and the Middle East   Sibley & Jackson
166 arq . vol 16 . no 2 . 2012 history

Hammam City Hot room Hot room Hot room iwan Changing room
(width:height) plan shape (width:height) (width:height)

Bab al Bahr Cairo 1:1.1 ‘central hub’ 1:1.5 1:1.37

al-Tanbali Cairo 1:1.3 ‘central hub’ 1:0.8 1:1.35

Ammouneh Damascus 1:1.8 rectilinear -- 1:1.37

Seffarine Fez 1:1.47 rectilinear -- 1:1.1

Suq al-Ghazal Constantine 1:0.46 rectilinear 1:1.62 1:1.02

Sengul Ankara 1.44 ‘central hub’ 1:2 1:1.13

Table 7 Width:height ratios of the hot room and the undressing room of the six primary hammam case studies in the five cities

Figure [11b] shows a section of Bab al Bahr without that makes up the octagon of the hot room [12b].
the original dome of the hot room which has Each new square helped to inform the dimension of
collapsed, the focus being the hot room area and the subsequent squares that were added and it seemed
adjacent iwan. In the hot room the width:ceiling that they ‘lined up’ with the structure of the
height ratio is 1:1.1 at the base of the collapsed dome, hammam. There are, of course, many other factors at
whereas in the iwan the width:height ratio is 1:1.5. play in the design of any building beyond the
The plans of Bab al Bahr, while initially appearing arrangement of shapes; however, it seems that a
not to follow a clear geometry, reveal several loose geometric proportioning system was deployed
interlocking squares. The hammam can be divided in the layout of this particular hammam.
into two main sections: changing and bathing [12a, Generally the hot room ceiling-height dimension
b]. The extremities of each section form a square plan is greater than the width of the room. The hot room
that is further subdivided into smaller areas and adopts narrow proportions while maximising the
rooms. The changing room has a height:width ratio area in contact with the furnace. The above ratios
of 1:1, if the clerestory window lantern is discounted. illustrate how the volume is reduced to aid the
With the lantern it is a ratio of 1:1.37. The sectional heating of the room (entirely reliant here on the heat
drawings [11a, b] also reveal the influence of the and steam released by the water in the plunge pool)
square in the volume composition of this hammam. as well as to enable a greater density of steam. At Bab
The square, octagon and eight-pointed star al Bahr, we see that the main hot room proportions
(created by two superimposed squares, one rotated are 1:1.3 (taking into consideration the height of the
45 degrees relative to the other) are frequently collapsed dome), the height being considerably less
deployed within Islamic art, architecture, than some of the cases studies in other countries.
calligraphy and ceramics. The shapes in the hot The iwans are considerably smaller than all the
room area were created using the 45 degree chamfer spaces found in the hammams of other countries,
again enabling them to be heated more effectively
and to higher temperatures. The steam produced
also acts as a screen to maintain privacy in these
smaller areas.
In Bab al Bahr the changing room width:height
proportions are 1:1.37. This creates an impressive
entrance space illuminated from the clerestory
windows [3a, 11b]. However, if the main ceiling
height is considered below the clerestory, the
width:height proportions are close to 1:1, making
11a the room a near perfect square. The longitudinal
section and plan reveals how Bab al Bahr is composed

11 Patterns in the
sections of Hammam
Bab al Bahr, Cairo
a Section of the
undressing room
b Section showing
the four squares that
largely dictate the
volumes of all of the
hammam key areas
(note that the
collapsed dome of
the hot room is not
represented in this
11b section)

Sibley & Jackson  The architecture of Islamic public baths of North Africa and the Middle East
history arq . vol 16 . no 2 . 2012 167

12 Organisational
patterns in the plan
of Hammam Bab al
Bahr, Cairo
a Floor plan with
superimposed
squares
b Plan with
superimposed
rotated squares

12a

12b

of two large volumes (the changing and hot rooms) dome aperture [14]. In the hot room area we see
which lead to several smaller rooms. The smaller another variation on the hot room theme; there is a
rooms are less formally arranged and without the large hot room with three smaller annexe spaces.
same concern for geometrical proportions. In However, rather than operating as separate rooms as
Hammam al-Tanbali the planning strategy is less in Cairo, the annexes are more like niches, offering
clear and neat defined geometries are not as evident. some degree of privacy while remaining within the
However, the sectional drawing marks a clear divide one singular volume.
between the entrance/changing area and the bathing In Hammam Seffarine [15], the sectional drawing
spaces. The changing area has a flat roof with demonstrates the even distribution of space
clerestory lanterns, whereas the hot room, unlike throughout the hammam, unlike the other
Bab al Bahr, is still domed and at a smaller scale than examples where changing and bathing are split into
the changing room. two large volumes. The changing room is still the
In Hammam Ammouneh [13a, b] the plan is largest component and grandest space within the
broadly divided into two square areas. The bath is hammam; however, in the bathing spaces there is a
split into areas for changing and washing, with a more even distribution of space between the cold,
central spine containing the toilets and circulation. warm and hot rooms. The changing room is also
However, unlike the Cairo examples, the changing more ornately decorated than the other hammams,
area has a domed roof structure rather than a flat perhaps seeking significance through applied
roof with clerestory lanterns. Also, in contrast to the ornament, rather than through a large volume.
Cairo hammams, Ammouneh does not have a Sengul in Ankara [16a-c] also adopts a central hub
centralised hot room with peripheral annexes – it hot room arrangement, like the hammams of Cairo,
only has one annexe off the hot room. Rather, the but relies entirely on the underfloor heating system.
progression through the hammam terminates with Sengul is also a double hammam, with distinct
the hot room that is positioned adjacent to the bathing structures adjacent to each other and
furnace, with the small annexe room further sharing the same furnace. The hammam is almost
enveloping the furnace room. symmetrical in plan with each entrance at opposite
Suq al-Ghazal [14] is the exception to these cases, ends of the building. The visitor travels towards the
with a low ceiling height relative to the width of the hot rooms that are located centrally, but share the
hot room. However, within this hot room there are same furnace. The dual aspect of this hammam
three niches with ratios of 1:1.62, which is more akin means that both male and female bathers can use
to the proportions found in the other hammams. In the facilities at the same time and the division of
the changing area the overall height to the point of space is equal, which would suggest the hammam is
the dome and overall width gives a ratio of almost used by both sexes in equal measure. However, the
1:1. In addition there is another square proportion male section is slightly larger than the female section
established by the positioning of the columns and in terms of floor areas of all of the spaces. The

  The architecture of Islamic public baths of North Africa and the Middle East   Sibley & Jackson
168 arq . vol 16 . no 2 . 2012 history

13 Organisational
patterns in the plan
and section of
Hammam
Ammouneh,
Damascus
a Section showing
the hot room and
undressing room
proportions
b Plan with
superimposed
squares over the
bathing and
changing areas

14 Section through
Hammam Suq
al-Ghazal in
Constantine
showing the hot
13a
room and
undressing room
proportions

15 Section through
Hammam Seffarine
in Fez showing the
hot room and
undressing room
proportions

16 Section through
Hammam Sengul in
Ankara showing the
square proportions
of the undressing
room
a Layout of Sengul’s
twin structure
b Sectional drawing
through the male
undressing room
c Male undressing
room

13b

14

sectional drawing is cut through the male changing Conclusion


room [16b, c]. The shaded square illustrates how this The analyses of the architecture of hammam
portion of the hammam is governed by a square buildings across a wide geographical area, the spatial
geometry that extends to the roofscape. This configuration of their internal spaces along with
proportion can only be experienced through the their floor areas and proportions, have revealed
abstract device of the sectional drawing, however the interesting research results, indicating a common
designers must have felt this was an appropriate vernacular know-how across the region.
method for establishing the proportions of the The results obtained through this research suggest
changing area. that within each city of each country, the hammams

Sibley & Jackson  The architecture of Islamic public baths of North Africa and the Middle East
history arq . vol 16 . no 2 . 2012 169

16a
15a

16b
15b

adopt similar design intentions and internal


arrangements, based on the percentage area each
building devotes to specific functions in the bathing
process. The internal arrangement of spaces is
governed by a ‘vernacular’ or overriding principle
specific to that location, independent of the gross
size of the hammam and its position within the city.
The principle is not a fixed or rigid device, but
intimates a theme upon which variations are made.
In all cities the changing room occupies almost
half of the total floor area of the whole hammam,
reflecting its important role as a gathering space for
social interaction; this importance is reminiscent of
the Roman baths. The hot and the warm room seem
to vary in their importance depending on the era in
which the hammams were constructed and their
geographical location. It is clear that the warm room
is the main bathing space in all the hammams of Fez,
whereas the hot room is the main bathing space in
the Ottoman hammams of Damascus and Ankara.
The succession of the three thermal zones (cold,
warm and hot) is more apparent in the hammams of 16c

Fez in Morocco, which are closer in their typology to


the small Roman baths, whereas this succession shapes and patterns in the plan and cross-sections of
seems to disappear in some of the hammams in the some of the hammams. In certain cases there is no
other countries where the hot room becomes the discernible pattern, yet in other cases, such as Bab al
dominant bathing space. Variations in the Bahr, the presence of the squares in plan and section
underfloor heating system (a hypocaust in Fez, indicate an overt concern for proportion and
Constantine and Ankara, and an underfloor duct geometrical relationships.
system in Damascus) have some implications in the It is clear that the climatic region where the
way the bathing spaces are configured. hammams are located, as well as the type of heating
The hammams of Cairo present a clear exception system adopted, play an important role not only in
to all the hammams investigated in the region. Their the configuration and proportions of the spaces, but
hot room is characterised by a cruciform also in the composition and proportions of domes
organisation with smaller raised hot water plunge and vaults covering the bathing spaces. These forms
pool rooms, releasing heat and steam to the other respond better than any other to the stratification of
spaces. The size of the hot room seems to vary very heat and steam creating comfortable internal
little in relation to the overall size of the hammam. environments. The research discussed in this paper
Larger hammams tend to have larger changing areas will continue with further studies into geometry and
and an increased number of plunge pools. division of spaces within the typology of a much
In terms of proportions, this research has observed larger sample with the aim to reveal the silent rules
that there appears to be some concern for geometric embedded in these important vernacular buildings.

  The architecture of Islamic public baths of North Africa and the Middle East   Sibley & Jackson
170 arq . vol 16 . no 2 . 2012 history

Notes Sylvie Denoix, Jean-Charles Fadli for their technical assistance in


1. K. A. C. Creswell, A Short Account of Depaule and Michel Tuchscherer the production of photos and plans
Early Muslim Architecture, revised (Cairo: Institut Français of Cairo hammams.
and supplemented by James W. d’Archéologie Orientale – IFAO,
Allan (Aldershot: Scolar Press, 1999), pp. 97–98. Biographies
1989), pp. 105–17, 186–92. 12. Fodil Fadli and Magda Sibley, ‘The Magda Sibley is an architect and
2. Inge Nielsen, Thermae et Balnea: The Historic Hammams of Cairo, Senior Lecturer in architecture at the
Architecture and Cultural History of Safeguarding a Vanishing University of Manchester. Her
Roman Public Baths (France: Heritage’, in Journal of Architectural research examines the
Lavoisier, 1995). Conservation, 14.3 (2008), 59–80. transformations of world heritage
3. Islamicstudies.info ‘Taharah: 13. Sibley, ‘The Pre-Ottoman Public Islamic cities in North Africa and the
Purification’, see Baths’. Middle East with particular emphasis
<http://www.islamicstudies.info/ 14. Écochard and Le Cœur, Les Bains on how two vernacular building types
prayers/purification/purification. de Damas. – the courtyard house and the public
php?id=4> [accessed 5 April 2012]. 15. Sibley, ‘The Pre-Ottoman Public bath or hammam –act as urban
4. Michel Écochard and Claude Le Baths’. catalysts in the twenty-first century.
Cœur, Les Bains de Damas, vols 1 and 16. Elif Sehitoglu, The Historic She has been awarded various
2 (Beyrouth: Imprimerie Hammams of Bursa (Istanbul: Tarih research grants from the Arts and
Catholique, 1943). VakfiYurt Publications, 2008). Humanities Research Council in the
5. Edmond Pauty, Les Hammams du 17. Nabila Seffadj, Les bains d’Alger UK (ahrc) to investigate the public
Caire (Le Caire: Imprimerie de durant la période ottomane (XVIe– baths in the World Heritage cities of
L’Institut Français d’Archéologie XIXe siècles) the mena region. Her work has gained
Orientale – IFAO, 1933). (Paris: PU Paris-Sorbonne, 2008). an international dimension with her
6. Henri Terrasse, ‘Trois Bains 18. Dow, The Islamic Baths of Palestine. partnership in the European
Mérinides du Maroc’, in Mélanges 19. Carlos Vilchez Vilchez, Arab Baths consortium for the hammam project
offerts à William Marcais par l’Institut (Granada: Los Libros de la Estrella, and recently with her involvement in
d’Études Islamiques de l’Université de 2004). the EU funded project Euro-Med
Paris (Paris: Éditions G. -P. Heritage 4 Hammamed project. She is
Maisonneuve, 1950), pp. 311–20. Illustration credits currently completing a book on the
7. Edmond Secret, ‘Les Hammams de arq gratefully acknowledges: historic public baths of North Africa
Fès’, in Bulletin de l’Institut d’Hygiène Magda Sibley, all images and the Middle East and their survival
du Maroc, Nouvelle Série, 2 (1942), into the twenty-first century.
61–77, reprinted in Edmond Acknowledgements
Secret, Les Sept Printemps de Fès This research was funded by the Dr Iain Jackson is a lecturer and
(Tours: Impression Aps., 1990), pp. European Commission 6th architect at the Liverpool School of
57–67. Framework Programme Specific Architecture. He is interested in
8. Martin Dow, The Islamic Baths of Targeted Research Projects (strep), ‘transnational architecture’, and, in
Palestine (Oxford: Oxford fp6-2003-inco-mpc-2 (517704), particular, the architecture of British
University Press, 1996). Duration: 2005 – 2008. Scientific and architects working in tropical
9. Alaa Habashi, ‘Restoration for Site financial co-ordinator: Oikodrom – climates. He is currently writing a
Presentation: The Ruins of the The Vienna Institute for Urban monograph on the work of Maxwell
Idrissid Bath in Volubilis, Sustainability. Fry and Jane Drew, with particular
Morocco’, in The Proceedings of the Many thanks are due to Dr Heidi focus on their work in India, Ghana
Conference on Conservation in Dumreicher at Oikodrom for and Nigeria.
Changing Societies: Heritage and coordinating the hammam project.
Development (Leuven: Katholike We are also grateful to the following Authors’ addresses
Universiteit, Raymond Lemaire research partners: Prof. Dalila El Dr Magda Sibley
International Centre for Kerdany at mimar Consultancy in Manchester Architecture Research
Conservation, 2006), pp. 267–76. Cairo, Kamal Reftani at ader fes in Centre (marc)
10. Écochard and Le Cœur, Les Bains de Morocco, Dr Sarab Atassi at ifead in The University of Manchester
Damas; Magda Sibley, ‘The Pre- Damascus, Dr Samira Debbache at School of Environment and
Ottoman Public Baths of the Constantine School of Development
Damascus and their Survival into Architecture in Algeria and Prof. Humanities Bridgeford Street
the Twenty-first Century: An Emine Saltik at the School of Oxford Road
Analytical Survey’, in Journal of Architecture, the Middle Eastern Manchester
Architectural and Planning Research, Technical University in Ankara. m13 9pl
24.4 (2007), 271–88; Mounir Keyyal, Thanks are also due to the owners, uk
al Hammamt al Dimashkiya managers and staff working in the magda.sibley@manchester.ac.uk
(Damascus: Ibn Khaldun, 1986). case study hammams who have been
11. Abu al-Futuh, Muhammad Sayf so helpful in facilitating the Dr Iain Jackson
al-Nasr, ‘Les hammams dans les fieldwork. Liverpool School of Architecture
Quartiers de Khan al-Khalili et The illustrations were produced as University of Liverpool
Bayn al-Qaásrayn des Fatimides part of the EU funded hammam Abercromby Square
à la fin de l’Époque Mamelouke’, project and in the context of an ahrc Liverpool
in Le Khan al-Khalili et Ses Environs: funded project titled The Surviving l69 7zp
Un Centre Commercial et Artisanal au Islamic Baths of North Africa. We are uk
Caire du XIIIe au XXe siècle, ed. by grateful to Adham Bakry and Fodil iain.jackson@liv.ac.uk

Sibley & Jackson  The architecture of Islamic public baths of North Africa and the Middle East

You might also like