Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(7407/7408) Class:
Author:
Date:
Time: 203
Marks: 172
Comments:
Page 1
Colonel Frank Seely School
Q1.In the first diagram, PQ is a stretched string of length 0.34 m. When it is plucked, it vibrates
at a frequency of 440 Hz.
(a) (i) On the second diagram, draw the fundamental mode of vibration for the string.
(1)
(ii) State the wavelength of the standing wave produced when the string is
plucked.
...............................................................................................................
(1)
(iii) The same string is lightly touched at its midpoint and is plucked at the point X.
Draw the standing wave produced on the diagram below.
(1)
(b) The tension of the string is increased. State the effect this has on the fundamental
frequency of vibration of the string.
........................................................................................................................
(1)
(Total 4 marks)
Q2.(a) When an earthquake occurs longitudinal waves (P waves) and transverse waves (S
waves) are produced in the Earth’s crust. The P waves travel faster than the S
waves. A station, whose task is to detect and locate the position of earthquakes, is
at a distance d from the point where the earthquake originates (the epicentre).
The speed of P waves is 7.5 km s–1 and that of S waves is 5.0 km s–1 . For a
particular earthquake the station detects the P wave 1.5 s before the S wave.
(i) Write down expressions for the time it takes each wave to travel the distance d
from the epicentre to the station.
Page 2
Colonel Frank Seely School
Time for P waves ..................................................................................
(b) The earthquake can set up resonant vibrations in bridges causing them to collapse.
The diagram below shows one such bridge. The modes of vibration of the bridge are
similar to those of a stretched string.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(2)
(ii) The velocity of transverse waves along the bridge is 180 m s–1. Determine the
frequency of the vibrations produced by an earthquake that would cause the
central span of the bridge to resonate at its fundamental frequency (first
harmonic).
(3)
Page 3
Colonel Frank Seely School
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(2)
(Total 10 marks)
Q3.The drawing below shows a standing wave set up on a wire of length 0.87 m. The wire is
vibrated at a frequency of 120 Hz.
Q4.The equation for the speed, v, of a transverse wave along a stretched string is:
where T is the tension in the string and μ is the mass per unit length of the string.
(a) State the quantities that would need to be measured in order to calculate a single
value for the speed of the wave using the equation. Name a suitable measuring
instrument for each quantity.
........................................................................................................................
Page 4
Colonel Frank Seely School
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(4)
(b) The apparatus shown in the diagram below could be used to measure a value for v.
Explain how this apparatus may be used to calculate an accurate value of the speed
of the transverse wave along the string.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(4)
(c) With the signal generator in the diagram below set at 152 Hz, 10 loops fit the
vibrating length of the string exactly. The string is of length 2.0 m and the mass on
the end of it is 0.72 kg.
Mass = ....................................................
(5)
(Total 13 marks)
Page 5
Colonel Frank Seely School
Q5. Figure 1 shows a stretched string driven by a vibrator. The right-hand end of the
string is fixed to a wall. A stationary wave is produced on the string; the string vibrates in
two loops.
Figure 1
(a) State the physical conditions that are necessary for a stationary wave to form on the
string.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(3)
(b) Explain how you know that the wave on the string is transverse.
........................................................................................................................
(1)
(c) Compare the amplitude and phase of the oscillations of points A and B on the string.
Amplitude ........................................................................................................
Page 6
Colonel Frank Seely School
Phase ..............................................................................................................
(2)
(d) The length of the string is 1.2 m and the speed of the transverse wave on the string
is 6.2 m s . –1
Figure 2
(ii) Show on your diagram three points P, Q and R that oscillate in phase.
(2)
(Total 11 marks)
Page 7
Colonel Frank Seely School
Q6. State two factors that affect the fundamental frequency of a vibrating stretched string.
Factor 1 ...................................................................
Factor 2 ...................................................................
(Total 2 marks)
Q7. (a) State the conditions necessary for a stationary wave to be produced.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(3)
(b) The diagram shows a stationary wave on a stretched guitar string of length 0.62 m.
The speed of transverse waves along the string is 320 m s . Calculate the frequency –1
Page 8
Colonel Frank Seely School
Frequency ..........................................
(3)
(Total 6 marks)
Q8. (a) Explain how a stationary wave is produced when a stretched string is plucked.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(3)
(b) (i) On Figure 1, draw the fundamental mode of vibration of a stretched string.
Label any nodes with a letter N and any antinodes with a letter A.
Figure 1
(2)
(ii) On Figure 2, draw the fourth harmonic (third overtone) for the stretched string.
Label any nodes with a letter N and any antinodes with a letter A.
Figure 2
(2)
Page 9
Colonel Frank Seely School
f=
(i) What would need to be done to the length of the string in order to double the
frequency?
...............................................................................................................
(1)
(ii) What would need to be done to the tension of the string in order to double the
frequency?
...............................................................................................................
(2)
(Total 10 marks)
Q9. Figure 1 shows a violin string. One way to produce a musical note is to pull the centre
of the string to one side and then release it quickly.
Figure 1
(a) Draw on Figure 1 the fundamental standing wave that will appear on the string
when the note is sounding.
(1)
(b) (i) Sketch on Figure 2 the standing wave that corresponds to a frequency of
Page 10
Colonel Frank Seely School
three times that of the fundamental.
Figure 2
(ii) State the name given to points on the standing wave where there is no
vibration of the string.
...............................................................................................................
(2)
(c) Children often learn to play the violin on a small instrument with shorter strings.
These shorter strings have to produce the same fundamental frequencies as those
on the full-size instrument. State two ways in which this can be achieved.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(2)
(Total 5 marks)
Q10. The figure below shows a graph of displacement against time for two waves A and
B. These waves meet in phase and add to form a resultant wave.
Page 11
Colonel Frank Seely School
........................................................................................................................
(1)
(2)
(Total 3 marks)
Q11. The figure below shows the appearance of a stationary wave on a stretched string at
one instant in time. In the position shown each part of the string has its maximum
displacement. The arrow at W shows the direction in which the point W is about to move.
Page 12
Colonel Frank Seely School
(a) (i) Mark clearly on the diagram the directions in which points X, Y and Z are about to
move.
(ii) State the conditions necessary for a stationary wave to be produced on the
string.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(4)
(b) In the figure above, the frequency of vibration is 120 Hz. Calculate the frequency of
the fundamental vibration for this string.
B Particles between adjacent nodes are out of phase with each other.
Page 13
Colonel Frank Seely School
(Total 1 mark)
(a) amplitude
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(b) phase
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(Total 5 marks)
Q14.The graph shows the variation of displacement of the particles with distance along a
stationary transverse wave at time t = 0 when the displacement of the particles is greatest.
The period of the vibrations causing the wave is 0.040 s.
Page 14
Colonel Frank Seely School
(i) draw the appearance of the wave at t = 0.010 s, labelling this graph B,
(ii) draw the appearance of the wave at t = 0.020 s, labelling this graph C,
(b) (i) Describe the motion of the particle at V, giving its frequency and amplitude.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(ii) State the amplitude of the particle at W and its phase relations with the particle
at V and the particle at Z.
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(6)
(Total 9 marks)
Q16.
frequency of vibration = 50 Hz
The diagram above shows a stationary wave on a stretched string at a time t = 0. Which
one of the diagrams, A to D, correctly shows the position of the string at a time t = 0.010
s?
D
(Total 1 mark)
Q17.A uniform wire fixed at both ends is vibrating in its fundamental mode. Which one of the
Page 16
Colonel Frank Seely School
following statements is not correct for all the vibrating particles?
Q18.Stationary waves are set up on a length of rope fixed at both ends. Which one of the
following statements is true?
A Between adjacent nodes, particles of the rope vibrate in phase with each other.
D Particles of the rope at adjacent antinodes always move in the same direction.
(Total 1 mark)
Q19.Which line, A to D, in the table gives a correct difference between a progressive wave and
a stationary wave?
(Total 1 mark)
Page 17
Colonel Frank Seely School
Q20.A stationary wave is formed by two identical waves of frequency 300 Hz travelling in
opposite directions along the same line. If the distance between adjacent nodes is 0.60 m,
what is the speed of each wave?
A 180 m s−1
B 250 m s−1+
C 360 m s−1
D 500 m s−1
(Total 1 mark)
When a detector is moved gradually along XY, its reading alternates between maxima and
minima. Which one of the following statements is not correct?
Q22. In testing a particular type of guitar string, a string is stretched and vibrated for a long
period of time using a mechanical vibrator as shown in Figure 1. The right-hand end of
the string is fixed. A stationary wave is produced on the string; the string vibrates in two
loops.
Figure 1
Page 18
Colonel Frank Seely School
(a) State the conditions that are necessary for a stationary wave to form on the string.
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
(3)
(b) Explain how you know that the wave on the string is transverse.
......................................................................................................................
(1)
(c) Compare the amplitude and phase of the oscillations of points A and B on the string.
Amplitude ....................................................................................................
Phase ..........................................................................................................
(2)
(d) The length of the string is 1.2 m and the speed of the transverse wave on the string
is
6.2 m s . –1
Page 19
Colonel Frank Seely School
(e) (i) The frequency of the vibrator is tripled.
Sketch the new shape of the stationary wave on Figure 2.
Figure 2
(ii) Show on your diagram three points P, Q and R that oscillate in phase.
(2)
(Total 11 marks)
Q23. Figure 1 represents a stationary wave formed on a steel string fixed at P and Q
when it is plucked at its centre.
Figure 1
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
(3)
(b) (i) The stationary wave in Figure 1 has a frequency of 150 Hz. The string PQ has
a length of 1.2 m.
Page 20
Colonel Frank Seely School
Calculate the wave speed of the waves forming the stationary wave.
Answer ........................... m s –1
(2)
(ii) On Figure 2, draw the stationary wave that would be formed on the string at
the same tension if it was made to vibrate at a frequency of 450 Hz.
Figure 2
(2)
(Total 7 marks)
Q24. Figure 1 shows a side view of a string on a guitar. The string cannot move at either
of the two bridges when it is vibrating. When vibrating in its fundamental mode the
frequency of the sound produced is 108 Hz.
(a) (i) On Figure 1, sketch the stationary wave produced when the string is vibrating
in its fundamental mode.
Figure 1
(1)
Page 21
Colonel Frank Seely School
answer = ........................................... m
(2)
answer = ...................................... m s –1
(2)
(b) While tuning the guitar, the guitarist produces an overtone that has a node 0.16 m
from bridge A.
(i) On Figure 2, sketch the stationary wave produced and label all nodes that are
present.
Figure 2
(2)
Page 22
Colonel Frank Seely School
answer = ...................................... Hz
(1)
(c) The guitarist needs to raise the fundamental frequency of vibration of this string.
State one way in which this can be achieved.
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
(1)
(Total 9 marks)
Q25. (a) (i) A piano string has a tension of 681 N. It vibrates with a fundamental
frequency (first harmonic) of 92.5 Hz and has a mass per unit length of 1.87 ×
10 kg m .
–2 –1
.............................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................
(ii) The figure below shows a string stretched between fixed ends.
Draw onto the figure the first overtone (second harmonic) mode of vibration.
Page 23
Colonel Frank Seely School
(1)
(iii) State how you could make a string on a stringed instrument vibrate in this
mode of vibration.
.............................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................
(2)
(b) Describe how you would investigate the variation of the fundamental frequency (first
harmonic) of a string with its length.
State which variable(s) you would need to control and how you would do so.
You may wish to assist your account by drawing a diagram.
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
Page 24
Colonel Frank Seely School
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
(4)
(Total 10 marks)
Q26. (a) State two differences between stationary waves and progressive waves.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(2)
(b) A violin string has a length of 327 mm and produces a note of frequency 440 Hz.
Calculate the frequency of the note produced when the same string is shortened or
“stopped” to a length of 219 mm and the tension remains constant.
frequency ................................................. Hz
(2)
(Total 4 marks)
Page 25
Colonel Frank Seely School
Q27. The figure below shows a continuous progressive wave on a rope. There is a knot in
the rope.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(2)
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(3)
(c) A continuous wave of the same amplitude and frequency moves along the rope from
the right and passes through the first wave. The knot becomes motionless.
Explain how this could happen.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
Page 26
Colonel Frank Seely School
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(3)
(Total 8 marks)
Q28. When a note is played on a violin, the sound it produces consists of the fundamental
and many overtones.
Figure 1 shows the shape of the string for a stationary wave that corresponds to one of
these overtones. The positions of maximum and zero displacement for one overtone are
shown. Points A and B are fixed. Points X, Y and Z are points on the string.
Figure 1
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................
(2)
X and Y .................................................................................................
X and Z .................................................................................................
(2)
Page 27
Colonel Frank Seely School
(i) Show that the speed of a progressive wave on this string is about 125 ms . –1
(2)
(ii) Calculate the time taken for the string at point Z to move from maximum
displacement back to zero displacement.
answer = ................................... s
(3)
(c) The violinist presses on the string at C to shorten the part of the string that vibrates.
Figure 2 shows the string between C and B vibrating in its fundamental mode. The
length of the whole string is 320 mm and the distance between C and B is 240 mm.
Figure 2
(i) State the name given to the point on the wave midway between C and B.
...............................................................................................................
(1)
answer = ................................... m
(2)
(iii) Calculate the frequency of this fundamental mode. The speed of the
Page 28
Colonel Frank Seely School
progressive wave remains at 125 ms .–1
answer = .................................Hz
(1)
(Total 13 marks)
Q29.Sound waves cross a boundary between two media X and Y. The frequency of the waves
in X is 400 Hz. The speed of the waves in X is 330 m s-1 and the speed of the waves in Y
is 1320 m s-1. What are the correct frequency and wavelength in Y?
B The two waves producing the stationary wave must always be 180° out of
phase.
C The separation of the nodes for the second harmonic is double the
separation of nodes for the first harmonic.
(Total 1 mark)
Q30.Figure 1 and Figure 2 show a version of Quincke’s tube, which is used to demonstrate
interference of sound waves.
Figure 1 Figure 2
Page 29
Colonel Frank Seely School
A loudspeaker at X produces sound waves of one frequency. The sound waves enter the
tube and the sound energy is divided equally before travelling along the fixed and
movable tubes. The two waves superpose and are detected by a microphone at Y.
(a) The movable tube is adjusted so that d1 = d2 and the waves travel the same distance
from X to Y, as shown in Figure 1. As the movable tube is slowly pulled out as
shown in Figure 2, the sound detected at Y gets quieter and then louder.
Explain the variation in the loudness of the sound at Y as the movable tube is slowly
pulled out.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(4)
Calculate the minimum distance moved by the movable tube for the sound detected
at Y to be at its quietest.
Page 30
Colonel Frank Seely School
State and explain the measurements you would make to obtain a reliable value for
the speed of sound using Quincke’s tube and a sound source of known frequency.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(4)
(Total 11 marks)
Page 31
Colonel Frank Seely School
(ii) 0.68 m
B1
(1)
Page 32
Colonel Frank Seely School
idea of a resonant length
eg length of string is a whole number of half wavelengths of the wave
v = fλ
C1
2.8 Hz
A1
(3)
clear link and conclusion shown between the new natural frequency of
the spans
and the max frequency of the earthquake
examples:
c = fλ or substituted values
C1
Page 33
Colonel Frank Seely School
A1
(3)
or
The drawing shows third harmonic (second overtone)
M1
so 120 = 3 × f0 so f0 = 40 Hz
do not allow just 120 / 3
A1
[5]
(b) frequency read from signal generator when standing wave produced / use of
strobe etc.
B1
measure λ using several loops or full length of string
B1
node → node / each loop = λ / 2
B1
use of c = fλ
B1
(4)
Page 34
Colonel Frank Seely School
c = 60.8 (m s ) e.c.f. from λ
–1
C1
T = 7.06 (N)
C1
μ = 1.9(1) × 10 (kg m ) c.a.o.
–3 –1
A1
m = 2 × μ value (= 3.8 × 10 kg or equivalent unit) e.c.f. s.f.p. applied only at
–3
this answer
B1
(5)
[13]
B1
B1
B1
3
B1
1
B1
B1
2
(d) λ = 1.2
Page 35
Colonel Frank Seely School
B1
M1
f = 6.2/1.2 = 5.2 Hz
A1
3
B1
1
B1
1
[11]
M6. Two of
B1
B1
Tension
Length
Temperature
[2]
B1
Page 36
Colonel Frank Seely School
incident wave and reflected wave/wave reflected through
180 /waves travelling in opposite directions
O
B1
same frequency/wavelength
B1
in same medium.
B1
(b) f = c/λ
C1
λ = 1.24
C1
f = 258 Hz
A1
B1
B1
B1
3
Page 37
Colonel Frank Seely School
(b) (i) one loop
M1
A1
2
B1
B1
2
B1
1
C1
A1
2
[10]
M9. (a) single loop/half of sine wave shown between fixed points
B1
1
B1
(ii) node
Page 38
Colonel Frank Seely School
B1
2
B1
B1
2
[5]
M10. (a) 4 mm
B1
1
C1
9 or 9:1
A1
2
[3]
B1
X and Y up
B1
Page 39
Colonel Frank Seely School
same frequency/wavelength not ‘it has same frequency’
moving in opposite directions,
reflected at end of string,
same/similar amplitude
integer no of ½ wavelengths between walls
B2
4
C1
40 Hz
A1
2
[6]
M12.C
[1]
M13.
phase: progressive wave, adjacent points vibrate with different phase (1)
stationary wave, between nodes all particles vibrate in phase
[or there are only two phases] (1)
[5]
Page 40
Colonel Frank Seely School
(iii) A, N (1)
(3)
= 25 Hz or s–1 (1)
(ii) 10 mm (1)
W, V phase difference π [or antiphase or 180°] (1)
W, Z in phase (1)
(6)
[9]
M15.C
[1]
M16.C
[1]
M17.B
[1]
Page 41
Colonel Frank Seely School
M18.A
[1]
M19.A
[1]
M20.C
[1]
M21.C
[1]
M22. (a) reflection implied/2 waves in opposite directions/fixed end (not ends) (1)
Page 42
Colonel Frank Seely School
(d) λ = 1.2 (1)
M23. (a) (progressive waves travel from centre) to ends and reflect (1)
two (progressive) waves travel in opposite directions along the string (1)
(ii) diagram to show three ‘loops’ (1) and of equal length and
good shape (1) (or loop of one third length (1))
4
[7]
Page 43
Colonel Frank Seely School
M24. (a) (i) one ‘loop’ (accept single line only, accept single dashed line)
+ middle node between the decimal point and the centre of the
‘m’ in ‘0.64 m’
Page 44
Colonel Frank Seely School
C1
A1
3
B1
1
pluck or bow B1 2
B1
B1
B1
B1
Page 45
Colonel Frank Seely School
in progressive waves, all points have the same amplitude (in turn),
in stationary waves, they do not
B1
B1
B1
stationary waves have nodes and antinodes but progressive waves do not
B1
C1
657/660 (Hz)
A1
2
[4]
Page 46
Colonel Frank Seely School
M27. (a) the maximum displacement (of the wave or medium)
candidate who correctly describes the motion of a knot 180 degrees out ofphase
with the one shown can gain maximum two marks(ie knot initially moving upwards)
3
knot is at a node
(allow goes up and down / side to side / etc, repeatedly, continuously, etc)
(ii) X and Y: antiphase / 180 (degrees out of phase) / п (radians out of phase)
(b) (i) v = fλ
(ii) ¼ cycle
T = 1 / 780 OR = 1.28 × 10 –3
0.25 × 1.28 × 10 –3
= 3.2 × 10 (s)
–4
(ii) 2 x 0.240
(iii) (f = v/λ = 124.8 or 125 / 0.48 ) = 260 (Hz) ecf from cii
1
[13]
M29.D
Page 48
Colonel Frank Seely School
[1]
M30.(a) Initially the path difference is zero/the two waves are in phase when they meet/the
(resultant) displacement is a maximum ✓
Alternative:
Constructive interference occurs when the path difference is
a whole number of wavelengths and the waves are in phase
1
As the movable tube is pulled out, the path difference increases and the two
waves are no longer in phase, so the displacement and loudness decrease ✓
Destructive interference occurs when the path difference is
an odd number of half wavelengths and the waves are in
antiphase
1
When the path difference is one half wavelength, the two are in antiphase and
sound is at its quietest. ✓
Initially the path difference is zero and the sound is loud
1
As the path difference continues to increase, the two waves become more in
phase and the sound gets louder again. ✓
As the pipe is pulled out the path difference gradually
increases, changing the phase relationship and hence the
loudness of the sound
1
Page 49
Colonel Frank Seely School
Path difference = 2 (d – d ) = 2 (distance moved by movable tube)
2 1
Measure distance moved by movable tube for each successive minima and
maxima✓
Start with d1 = d2
Measure distance moved by movable tube for first minimum.
1
Page 50
Colonel Frank Seely School
E3.(a) The majority of candidates were able to calculate the speed of the transverse wave,
correctly calculating the wavelength and multiplying their value by the frequency.
(b) Candidates going on to use their value of speed were usually successful. However
those candidates trying to argue in terms of fundamental and third harmonic (or
second overtone) were often unconvincing and rarely gained credit for their
answers.
E4.(a) The majority of candidates were able to suggest what quantities needed to be measured in
order to calculate the speed of the waves however many of these failed to give suitable
measuring instruments with which to make the measurements.
Surprising few candidates suggested using a newton meter in order to measure the
tension in the string.
(b) This was often too loosely answered with insufficient detail of how multiple loops
should be used in order to measure an accurate value for the wavelength. Again
many candidates failed to explain that the calibrated signal generator would give a
value for the frequency of the wave.
(c) This was often the part most successfully answered by candidates. Although many
gave a value for the wavelength of 0.20 m, with error carried forward this still gave
access to the remaining four marks. Only the strongest candidates tended to
multiply the value for μ by the 2 m that gave the total mass of the string.
(a) Many ‘physical’ conditions were encountered in scripts, most of them spurious and
incorrect. Candidates seemed unable to distinguish between a standing and a
travelling wave. Responses here indicated that an understanding of reflection, or
two waves in motion, or the need for appropriate boundary conditions, or even the
requirement for constraints on frequency were rare.
(b) General misunderstandings carried through to this part also where statements
intended to show an understanding of why the wave was stationary were poor and
unfocussed.
Page 51
Colonel Frank Seely School
(c) A sizeable minority were unable to compare the amplitude of A and B correctly.
Comments such as ‘A and B are not quite in phase’ indicated further
misunderstandings of exactly what the wave is doing.
(d) The calculation was carried out well even by those who could not translate the
diagram into a correct wavelength (2.4 m and 0.6 m were both popular distractors).
(e) (i) Many candidates were able to draw a correct new shape for the stationary
wave. Those who failed usually drew three ‘loops’ rather than six.
(ii) The crucial point in the question was that the three points had to oscillate in
phase. Those candidates who identified nodal displacements points penalised
themselves accordingly.
E6. There were many correct answers to this question. Incorrect responses were usually
couched in terms of the amplitude of the wire and the frequency of the signal.
E7. Part (a) was generally not answered well; in part because the conditions were not
known, but also as result of poor writing skills.
Failure to realise that the wavelength was twice the length of the guitar string was a very
common error in part (b). Of the candidates who did get the calculation right, many lost a
mark for quoting too many significant figures in the final answer.
E8. (a) Most candidates had some idea of the formation of a standing wave. They were
unclear about where reflection occurred or failed to mention the superposition of the
two waves. Some candidates thought that the two waves were always 180° out of
phase.
Page 52
Colonel Frank Seely School
(ii) This was not done quite as well as some candidates misidentified the fourth
harmonic and some failed to label all of the nodes.
(ii) A large number of candidates correctly stated that the tension should be
quadrupled. A few simply stated that it should be increased and some others
thought it should be doubled. Both of these responses gained partial credit.
E9. (a) Almost all candidates were able to draw the pattern of the fundamental standing
wave on a stretched string.
(b) (i) The drawn standing wave patterns for a frequency three times higher were
good.
(ii) The use of the word ‘node’ as a descriptor for the point of no displacement
was recognised well, only a handful were wrong.
(c) Again, many were able to translate their knowledge of the factors influencing the
frequency of the string to this slightly unusual case of the miniature violin. They
fluently and concisely described appropriate changes to the mass per unit length of
the string (increase) and to the tension (decrease). Some, however, lost marks
because they simply stated the factors rather than the direction in which they
needed to change. The question clearly implied a requirement for this and this was
recognised by the vast majority of candidates.
E10. Many candidates were able to complete the task of adding together two amplitudes
Page 53
Colonel Frank Seely School
from the graph. For the minority, 2 mm rather than 4 mm was a very common error. Graph
labels provided a substantial number of unit errors in this question.
Few of the candidates were comfortable with the calculation of intensity ratio from the
graph. Examiners saw many examples of 3:1 (the amplitude ratio), usually with no
explanation for the origin of the ratio. In other cases the ratio was calculated the wrong
way around (1:3 or 1:9) or candidates worked on the basis of an inverse-square law
calculation.
E11. (a) (i) Almost half the candidates revealed that they could not describe the
motion of a stretched string exhibiting a stationary (standing) wave.
(ii) However, the written description of the necessary conditions for the string to
demonstrate the motion was better with many candidates giving a
comprehensive list (two correct conditions were required as a minimum for full
marks).
(b) Correct calculations of the frequency of the fundamental were surprisingly rare.
There is widespread confusion about the wavelength conditions for the stationary
wave. Common incorrect answers included 80Hz (where the candidate thinks the
string is 3λ long) and 360Hz (candidate multiplies rather than divides by 3).
Examiners were surprised to find that a significant minority understood the physics
and implied that they intended to divide 120 by 3, but commonly obtained an answer
of 60 Hz for the result.
E13.It was evident that the depth of knowledge necessary to answer this question was not
available to the majority of candidates. Even the energy transfer section in part (c) was the
source of wrong or vague or inadequate answers.
E14.In part (a) there was much confusion with progressive waves and only the better
candidates showed B correctly.
Page 54
Colonel Frank Seely School
In part (b)(i) few candidates said that the particle at V performed simple harmonic motion.
Credit was given if it was stated that the particle was instantaneously at rest. In part (b)(ii)
most candidates knew the meaning of amplitude but the question about phase often
defeated weaker candidates. with more confusion with progressive waves
E23. A large number of candidates struggled with part (a). This was mainly due to a lack
of understanding of the fact that two waves must be travelling in opposite directions in
order for a standing wave to form. They seemed to be describing one wave reflecting back
and forth. Those who understood how the stationary wave formed and added further detail
went on to score two or three marks fairly easily.
Some candidates in part (b) (i) did not multiply by two and only scored one mark out of the
two available.
A majority gained two marks in part (b) (ii). A few candidates knew what to do but their
sketch lacked acceptable accuracy, for example, the ‘loops’ were not of similar length.
Only a quarter of candidates got the wavelength wrong.
E24. In part (a) (i), about 60% of candidates drew one ‘loop’ and picked up the mark.
However, we were fairly lenient on the shape of the ‘loop’ and students need to practice
drawing these shapes.
Part (a) (ii) was expected to be a little easier than it was. 42% scored no marks on this
despite the benefit of an error carried forward from an incorrect part (a) (i). Many did not
realise the wavelength was found from the length of the string and knowledge of the
shape of the fundamental. Some candidates used λ = v/f with v = speed of light. In
contrast, most candidates found part (a) (iii) a very easy calculation.
The majority of candidates got four antinodes in part (b) (i), but then nearly half of those
lost the second mark by either not sketching the curve carefully enough or, more
commonly, forgetting to label the antinodes.
In part (c), the vast majority correctly suggested tightening or shortening the string. A few
thought that plucking harder would increase the pitch and some suggested increasing the
length, using a thinner string, increasing the wave speed, or even ‘play faster’.
Page 55
Colonel Frank Seely School
E25. Most candidates did the calculation well. Those that did not usually did not correctly
rearrange the equation. Once again, those who set out calculations well tend to be more
successful than who are untidy or who miss out steps. Candidate’s drawings of the
oscillation tended to be correct. A few got it wrong because they could not identify the
correct oscillation but more lost the mark because their loops were obviously far from
equal in size. Candidates should be advised to take care with their answers. Measuring
the sixes of loops would not be inappropriate. Few candidates answered part (a) (iii) well.
Stopping was mentioned and allowed even when the candidates did not indicate that this
should be done lightly.
Part (b) was extremely badly done. There were some diagrams that showed more or less
appropriate experimental apparatus but more that showed unfamiliarity with any sensible
experiment. Candidates tended not to know the names of apparatus such as oscillators or
signal generators. Very few mentioned that the length of the vibrating string should be
measured using a metre rule or suitable alternative. Those that mentioned that a graph
should be drawn almost always failed to suggest an appropriate graph that would yield a
straight line. When describing experiments, candidates should be aware of the need to
state the measurements that should be made; the measuring equipment used; which
variables to control and how; how to display the results in a straight line graph.
E26. In part (a), many students could not make a distinction between progressive and
stationary waves, instead making generalised, unspecific and often inaccurate
descriptions of aspects of waves. For example, some thought that all stationary waves
were transverse. References to phase and amplitude were rare and confused.
Part (b) was done more effectively by many. Those that failed to gain credit tended to
invert the ratios. Students could get the correct numerical answer using the general wave
equation but this approach was not credited.
E27. Many students had learned the correct definition in part (a) but some gave a
description, for example ‘the greatest height of the wave from the middle’. This did not
gain marks.
Surprisingly in answer to part (b), many students referred to the equilibrium position as the
‘node’ and maximum amplitude as the ‘antinode’ on a progressive wave. Many use
fractions of a cycle to describe the position of the knot but some use angles or fractions of
a wavelength which are not appropriate. The biggest loss of marks occurred in the first
Page 56
Colonel Frank Seely School
mark where a large number thought that the knot would be travelling upwards initially.
Part (c) was a fairly easy question with students only needing to state that the ‘knot is at a
node on a stationary wave which is caused by superposition’ to get three marks. Most
students managed to get two of the marking points. Many did not understand how a node
is formed, believing it is the sum of a peak and a trough only, or that the whole rope is
stationary, or that the rope is only stationary at a node when cancellation occurs between
waves that are 180° out of phase. The two waves that form a stationary wave are not
always 180° out of phase in order to cancel at the nodes. Nodes are where the wave
always cancels but the phase difference between the waves repeatedly varies from zero
to 2π. Cancellation everywhere on the stationary wave only occurs when the waves are in
antiphase but cancellation always happens at the nodes because the displacements of
the waves are always equal and opposite at those points (or displacements are both zero
when in phase and in antiphase). This is a complex situation but there are many
simulations available on the internet that help to get these ideas across.
E28. Part (a)(i) was almost universally misinterpreted due to a similar question appearing
on a previous paper. Many students interpreted the question as ‘describe the motion over
the next cycle’. Those who did this often failed to point out that there was a continuing
oscillation taking place. Part (a)(ii) was very poorly answered which was a surprise. A
common answer was ‘out of phase’ for X and Y which is not equivalent to ‘antiphase’.
Phase was often given in terms of number of wavelengths, e.g. ½λ. There was little
understanding of the difference between phase difference along a progressive wave and a
stationary wave. Many had measured the fraction of a wavelength between the points and
converted this into an angle as you would for a progressive wave. It is suggested that
phase difference along a stationary wave be demonstrated by referring to the many
simulations available.
Part (b)(i) presented few problems for students. In part (b)(ii) many students did 1/780 and
obtained the time for one complete cycle but did not recognise that they needed to divide
by 4 to get the time for ¼ of a cycle. A significant number thought that the time between
maximum displacement and reaching the equilibrium position was half a cycle. Some
divided 780 by 4 which makes the answer 8 times greater than it should be.
For part (c)(i) most students got ‘antinode’ but a significant number put ‘node’/ ‘amplitude’/
‘max displacement’ / ‘stationary wave’ / ‘equilibrium’ / ‘maxima’. Part (c)(ii) presented few
problems for students. In part (c)(iii) quite a few students left this blank because they were
unable to answer the previous question. However, many of those who scored the mark did
so by using an incorrect answer to (c)(ii). Students should be encouraged not to give up;
the final part of a question is not necessarily the hardest.
Page 57