Drives / Interference Control
—Valtage
Disturbance
Powar Engineering &
POWER ENGINEERING POWERQUALITY GROUNDING
ENGINEERING CALCULATORS »
WHAT IS SEPARATELY AND NON-SEPARATELY DERIVED
SYSTEM?
A separately derived system is an electrical system in which the service
phase (hot) and neutral conductors has no electrical connection to another
source of energy. Another source of energy can be a utility, generator, PV
or wind energy source. Grounded conductors (Neutral) of the two sources
are NOT solidly connected. Note that interconnection of equipment
grounding and bonding conductors are permitted.
A non-separately derived system is an electrical system in which the
service phase (hot) conductors typically have no electrical connection to
another source of energy, however the neutrals are solidly connected.
Interconnection of equipment grounding and bonding conductors are
permitted, Note that when two sources are meant to operate in parallel (like
co-generation plant) the phase conductors are interconnected along with
solidly connected neutral.Separately Derived System
Separately derived system will have two or more sources with phase and
neutral conductors totally separate from one another. Neutral of each source
can be individually grounded solidly to a common ground bus, however
neutral is not interconnected. Neutrals may also be grounded through an
impedance (HRG ete.) per NEC 250.28 (b).
One example of separately derived system is a transformer that is situated
between two systems that couple energy magnetically. Secondary side phase
and neutral conductors have no electrical connection to primary conductors.
Secondary side of an autotransformer however cannot be a separately
derived system as there is one conductor that is common to primary and
secondary. Another example of a separately derived system is a generator
who’s neutral is not electrically connected to the utility service neutral. The
same concept can be extended to a PV, wind or microgrid energy source.
Grounding rules for separately derived systems are given in NEC 250.30.TRANSFORMER 2
New Separates
cc Derived Source
ui
Existing
Somes 4
NI
GROUND
NEUTRAL-GROUND NEW _NEUTRAL-GROUND
BOND BOND
Figure 1: Isolation transformer used to ereate separately derived system
National Electrical Code [NEC] article 100
defines separately derived system as ‘A premises
wiring system whose power is derived from a
source of electrical energy or equipment other
than a service. Such systems have no direct
electrical connection, including solidly connected
grounded circuit conductor (Neutral) to supply
conductors originating in another system’. Note
that the term ‘service’ means electric utility
power.
Referring to figure 1, we can see that the existing service neutral is ‘not
carried over and a ‘new neutral is derived at the secondary of isolation
transformer. The cireuit on the secondary side of this transformer can be
called separately derived. Generator with 3-pole ATS and no
interconnected neutral is also separately derived system as shown below.UTILITY SOURCE GEN SOURCE
SP ATS
Figure 2: Separately derived generator source with no neutral
Generator used with 4-pole automatic transfer switch [ATS] as shown in
figure 3 is also separately derived. When 4-pole ATS transfer from utility
source, three phases + neutral are switched to generator and the load now
has a ‘new neutral’ that is referenced to ground at the generator instead of
neutral that is grounded at the utility source.
UTILITY SOURCE GEN SOURCE
Figure 8: Separately derived generator source with 4P ATS
Referring to figure 3, source neutral (Xo) is connected to ground grid using
main bonding jumper [MBJ] while Neutral disconnect link [NDL] is used to
isolate neutral bus from the source.
Note that interconnection of grounding (earth wire) or bonding conductors
between service and the alternate source is allowed and does not
compromise integrity of separately derived system.Read: Single point
grounding in power
systems
Advantages of separately
derived system
Having separately derived
system by means of an
isolation transformer as
shown in figure 1 has the
benefit of reducing common
mode noise and thus
improve power quality.
Figure 4: This generator neutral is bonded to ground at the generator + COmmon mode noise on the
neutral-ground conductor
will not propagate to the load, however differential noise (phase-neutral)
will not be blocked. To provide noise free connection to sensitive electronic
loads, a combination of isolation transformer and isolated ground receptacle
can be considered to provide additional ground noise elimination.Figure 5: Power generator can be separately or non-separately derived system depending on neutral connection
Having a separately derived system simplifies ground fault sensing unlike
the complicated ground fault detection schemes of non-separately derived
systems with interconnected neutral.
Separately derived systems will have very little circulating current within
the switchboard whereas non-separately derived systems with
interconnected neutral invariably results in circulating neutral/ground
current within the switchboard and in the grounding grid adjacent to
switchboard and the service transformer. See figure 8.
Disadvantages of separately derived system
To keep the neutral separate, four pole switching will have to be used.
Four pole ATS (4P ATS) and four pole circuit breakers (4P CB) are very
expensive.
Switchgear with 4P ATS or 4P CB will have larger foot print.
Switching neutral in 4P ATS or 4P CB can lead to voltage sensing issues
in UPS and other sensitive electronics loads. Some users prefer AT'S with
overlapping neutral for this reason though the benefits are questionable.Four pole ATS with overlapping
neutrals parallel two neutrals which
may create momentary current flow
that may activate ground fault
protection if both sources are live.
Parallel operation of separately derived
sources with interconnected neutral is
| not possible. If there is no
interconnected neutral, then parallel
operation can be performed.
figure 6; Pad mount transformer secondary
Non-Separately Derived System
Non-separately derived system will have two or more sources with neutral
of each source solidly connected to each other.
Example of non-separately derived system is a generator with three phase
and grounded neutral (3P-LN) connected to a 3P-LN utility through a 3P
ATS and common neutral bus. Key idea to remember here is that non-
separately derived systems have shared neutral.
Read: Multi point grounding in power systemsUTILITY SOURCE GEN SOURCE
NEUTRAL,
SP ATS
Figure 7: Non-separately derived generator with shared neutral and 3P_ ATS
Advantages of non-separately derived system
+ Parallel operation of two or more sources with interconnected neutral is
possible.
+ Three pole circuit breaker (3P CB) or three pole ATS (3P ATS) can be
used which are less expensive, more commonly available and takes less
floor space.
Disadvantages of non-separately derived system
Both service and generator neutrals are connected in the switchboard. By
interconnecting the neutrals that are grounded separately at two locations
we have created parallel path for normal neutral return current. Current
will also take parallel path during ground fault wherein fault current
would split between the two neutral-ground connections and will make
traditional zero sequence or residual ground fault sensing ineffective.UTILITY, SOURCE GEN SOURCE
ON OFF
figure 8: Non-separately derived systems ereate circulating neutral-ground current
Circulating neutral current and inability to perform ground fault sensing
using zero sequence OT or residually connected CT is the reason
complicated differential ground schemes are necessary for non-separately
derived systems. When ground and neutral currents are accurately
measured and accounted for in differential ground fault scheme, non-
separately derived system offers as much performance or more as separately
derived system. Only exception to this is the power quality benefits by using
an isolation transformer to derive a separately derived system.
Read: CT shorting block
Summai
Separately derived system does not share neutral between service and the
alternate source. When sources are switched, all three phases plus neutral
are switched using a 4P ATS or 4P CB making the installation expensive
and occupying more floor space. Secondary side of an isolation transformer
is also a separately derived system. Separately derived source obtained by
means of an isolation transformer provide some power quality benefits.
Separately derived systems do not result in circulating neutral or ground
current and ground fault sensing using well understood zero sequence orresidual scheme is possible. Parallel operation of two sources with common
shared neutral is not possible.
Non-separately derived systems share neutral between the service and the
alternate source. When sources are switched, only three phases are
switched using a 3P ATS or 3P CB, while the neutrals are bolted together
simplifying the installation. Non-separately derived system does result in
circulating neutral or ground current and ground fault sensing using well
understood zero sequence or residual scheme is not possible. Complex
differential ground fault sensing schemes has to be implemented to obtain
reliable ground fault detection when two or more sour’
are
interconnected. Parallel operation of two sources with shared neutral is
possible.
Read: Neutral CT with electronic trip units
‘To invent, you need a good imagination and a pile of junk."-Thomas A. Edison About Us | Disclaimer | Contact Us