Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Sanette L.A. Ferreira (1999) Crime: A threat to tourism in South Africa,
Tourism Geographies, 1:3, 313-324, DOI: 10.1080/14616689908721324
To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/14616689908721324
Abstract
Tourism can play a significant role in overcoming the many socio-economic chal-
lenges South Africa faces, but only if the reality and perception of tourism safety
are addressed urgently and adequately as a strategic priority. Here, I analyse
the spatial pattern of crime against tourists in South Africa from 1993 to 1996.
'No-go' areas for tourists are identified and tourist perceptions of personal safety
are examined on a region by region basis. The analysis shows that, except for
the Gauteng region (the inland economic core region), most other cases of reported
crime against tourists are in the coastal areas of the country. Gauteng and
KwaZulu-Natal are perceived by foreign tourists to be the most 'unsafe' areas in
South Africa. Tourists from Australia, the Pacific, Asia and Scandinavia expressed
the greatest concern for their safety in South Africa. In spite of the current posi-
tive tourism marketing climate of 'post-apartheid' South Africa, there is increasing
concern that if the personal safety and security of tourists are not addressed in a
concerned and coordinated manner, tourism to South Africa will be adversely
affected.
Introduction
The world is changing and experiencing shifts in social values that affect
the way that individuals, businesses and governments behave. In light of
these changes, there has also been an increasing awareness that past
economic growth has seriously impacted the environment. This has
1993 1994
JB WV-
"Maputr
^ W a t e yaji^yen
h ._ \ _, JjSretfiQj
\ Jo/Bnti
^Mwana Bay 'HmH
1 . • T*
J bnteln J3«f jan&U/Tiqababa BldbmfontehKDurbaHi
Bloem
(1 my mr
3eaufort We •f^Wild Coast Sun
Tumtata ^JJfntataJP
/J^T^ichardsbaai
m A stown J3T*
1995 1996
[Swaziland
Irban
isikisiki
• • = 1 reported
case of serious crime
against tourists
1 II
\
60% : 36
50%
= 36 35" 36
- 37 = 38 : 30 32 32 33
II
40%
30%
20%
10%
33
—
—
31
-
30
—
30
— m
40
-
33
:
!
!
—
P
—1 4i -
0%
Jan'92 Aug'92 Jan'93 Aug'93 Jan'94 Aug'94 Jan'95 Aug'95 Jan'96 Aug'96
Figure 3 Ratings of personal safety, January 1992 to August 1996 (after Satour
1996: 29).
Evidence from around the world demonstrates that safety, tranquillity and
peace are necessary for the prosperity and sustainability of the tourism
industry. In South Africa, a certain level of tolerance with regard to
violence and unrest has existed, based on the assumption that these are
inherent features of a society undergoing far-reaching socio-political
change. This tolerance, however, has now been exceeded and most consider
the rising crime rate as largely symptomatic of socio-economic decline
(South African Police Services 1995: 95). The current economic problems
facing the country may constitute the single most important variable
responsible for crimes against tourists.
A major challenge facing South African society is to bring about a change
in values to encourage a philosophy that sees hard work and societal change
as virtues. According to Bloom (1996:102), the involvement of community-
based organizations in the promotion of sustainable tourism-related activi-
ties, for example the participation by the rural population in ecotourism
projects, could help to foster a feeling of pride and belonging and ultimately
help to reduce crime and violence. For all to share in the economic benefits
that tourism can bring, it is essential for South Africans to deal more res-
olutely with the problems of lawlessness and to turn the tide of crime to pro-
tect this important national resource. If important parts of the country are
dangerous, South Africa as a whole becomes a dangerous destination. It is a
priority of the greatest urgency that the government should control crime on
all fronts. Yet, international experience has shown that tourist safety cannot
simply be the responsibility of the police. Creative solutions, relying on the
cooperation of the business community, the hotel industry and the general
public, are also necessary. At the present time, in spite of the fact that South
Africa has received some negative publicity due to its high crime rate, South
Africa's foreign tourism market is continuing to grow at a positive rate.
Hopefully, events and conditions in the country will not deteriorate to an
extent that results in a long-term reversal in this trend.
References
Ambinder, E. 1992. Urban violence raises safety fears. Corporate Travel 9: 1-10.
Associated Press. 1993. Tourism falls prey to terrorism. Gainesville Sun, 6 May,
p. 13.
Bloom, Jonathan. 1996. A South African perspective on the effects of crime and
violence on the tourism industry. In Tourism, Crime and International Security
Issues, ed. A. Pizam and K. Mansfeld, pp. 91-105. New York: John Wiley.
Clark, L. 1988. Planning for tourism in far North Queensland: a local govern-
ment response. In Frontiers of Australian Tourism: The Search for New
Perspectives in Policy Development and Research, ed. W. Faulkner and
M. Fagence, pp. 77-88. Canberra, ACT: Bureau of Tourism Research.
Place: Crime as a threat to tourism 323
Croall, J. 1995. Preserve or Destroy. London: Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation.
Crystal, S. 1993. Welcome to downtown USA. Meetings and Conventions 28:
42-59.
de Villiers, D. 1995. Unpublished speech by the Minister of Environmental Affairs
and Tourism at the Workshop on the Security of Tourists, 7 November, Pretoria.
Financial Mail. 1994. Crime, cold comfort. Financial Mail 134: 47.
Glanz, L. 1995. Crime in South Africa: what police statistics tell us. HSRC Bulletin,
October/November, pp. 18-21.
Khamisi, J. 1995. Kenya is fading as a tourist destination. Weekend Argus, 30 April.
Mansfeld, Y. 1993. Turbulent security environment and the variable propensity to
travel: the case of Israel, 1948-1989. TESG, Journal of Economic and Social
Geography 84: 132-43.
Maslow, A. 1954. Motivation and Personality. New York: Harper.
Ministry for Administration and Tourism. 1992. White Paper on Tourism, Republic
of South Africa. Pretoria: RSA Government Printer.
Murphy, Peter E. 1985. Tourism: A Community Approach. London: Methuen.
New York Times. 1993. Brutal murder in 'sunshine state'. New York Times, 16
September, p. A10.
New York Times. 1995. Fearful of tourism decline, Florida offers assurances on
safety. New York Times, 15 September, p. A14.
Pizarm, Abraham. 1982. Tourism and crime, is there a relationship? Journal of
Travel Research 20: 7-10.
Pizam, Abraham and Mansfeld, Yoel. 1996. Introduction. In Tourism, Crime and
International Security Issues, ed. A. Pizam and Y. Mansfeld, pp. 1-10. New
York: John Wiley.
Rohter, Larry. 1995. Fearful of tourism decline, Florida offers assurances on safety.
New York Times, 15 September, p. A14.
Satour (South African Tourism Board). 1993. A Survey of South Africa's Inter-
national Tourism Market, Summer 1993. Pretoria: RSA Government Printer.
Satour (South African Tourism Board). 1995. A Survey of South Africa's
International Tourism Market, Summer 1995. Pretoria: RSA Government
Printer.
Satour (South African Tourism Board). 1996. Foreign Visitor Statistics, December
1996. Pretoria: RSA Government Printer.
South African Police Services. 1995. Annual Report of the Commissioner of the
South African Police. Pretoria: RSA Government Printer.
Schiebler, Susan A., Crotts, John C. and Hollinger, Richard C. 1996. Florida
tourists' vulnerability to crime. In Tourism, Crime and International Security
Issues, ed. A. Pizam and Y. Mansfeld, pp. 37-50. New York: John Wiley.
Sherman, L.W., Gartin, P.R. and Beuger, M.E. 1989. Hot spots of predatory crime:
routine activities and the criminology of place. Criminology 27: 27-55.
Theobold, W.F. 1994. Global Tourism - The Next Decade. Oxford: Butterworth-
Heinemann.
World Commission on Environment and Development. 1987. Our Common Future.
Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Biographical note
Le tourisme peut êre un facteur-dé pour surmonter les nombreux défis socio-
économiques auxquels fait face l'Afrique du Sud, à condition que la réalité et la
perception de sécurité touristique soient considérées de façon urgente et suffisante
comme une priorité stratégique. Cet article se concentre sur l'Afrique du Sud et
analyse le schéma spatial de la criminalité contre les touristes (1993-1996), définit
les zones "no-go" (zones à éviter) pour les touristes, analyse région par région la
perception qu'ont les touristes de la sécurité personnelle, et démontre l'associa-
tion vitale entre tourisme et sécurité. L'analyse spatiale montre que, excepté pour
la région du Gauteng (coeur économique intérieur), la plupart des cas rapportés
de crime contre les touristes a lieu dans les régions côtières du pays. Le Gauteng
et le Kwazulu-Natal sont considérés par les touristes étrangers comme étant les
régions d'Afrique du Sud de plus forte insécurité. Les touristes d'Australasie,
d'Extrème-Orient et de Scandinavic ont les pires perceptions de la sécurité en
Afrique du Sud. Malgré le climat positif actuel de marketing touristique régnant
dans une Afrique du Sud "post-apartheid", il y a une inquiétude croissante,
renforcée par les recherches entreprises parmi les touristes, que si la sûreté et la
sécurité personnelles des touristes ne sont pas prises en compte de manière concertée
et coordonnée, le tourisme en Afrique du Sud en soit affecté très négativement.