You are on page 1of 12

Bamboo Shoot in Our Blood

Fermenting Flavors and Identities in Northeast India

Dolly Kikon

This essay draws from my ethnographic fieldwork in Northeast India and examines how identities are mediated through
fermented food like bamboo shoot. These shoots come in different textures and forms: wet chunky pieces, sun-dried and stringy
threads, smoked and curly strands. Our relationship with fermented food, as this essay highlights, determine how we organize,
move, and order our lives, contributing to the creation of differences and alliances. At a time when we witness a global movement
on fermenting cultures and the microbial world, this essay locates small-scale nonindustrial fermentation practices among
communities across Northeast India. Exploring the significant role of food in shaping taste, practices, and politics on the ground, I
show how fermenting cultures shape citizenship practices and identities. By highlighting narratives and representations of
fermented food, this essay brings the extraordinarily varied and dense worlds of fermenting cultures and highlights the associative
relationship between fermented food and communities.

Bamboo shoot is part of my being. I cannot exist without it. (Zubeno, Wokha District, 2019)

Fermentation and eating fermented food are central to many Tracing the everyday fermentation practices and eating cultures
communities across Northeast India. From vegetables, beans, fish, reveals deeper meanings and significance about taste, ethnicity,
and rice, the cultures of consuming fermented food highlight the gender, and social relations. The importance of fermented food
diversity of food traditions here. While processes of fermentation across different cultures, according to Mintz, informs us how
continue to take place in small-scale nonindustrialized settings flavors and mastering the art of fermentation are integral to the
such as kitchens, the promotion of fermented food as a distinct social world of the fermenters and consumers of respective so-
marker of indigenous cuisine/tribal food from the region is done cieties. It is, as Mintz (2008) reflects, “a fabric of cultivation,
at another scale. Across high-dining restaurants in Delhi to pop- processing, kitchen lore, cuisine and folklore in which people
up food cafés in Goa and Mumbai, the magnitude of promoting learn from infancy about the foods they grow to like. Tastes are
fermented food from Northeast India across India is impressive. more commonly acquired in this way” (64). Highlighting non-
In this essay, I focus on fermented bamboo shoot to examine the industrialized forms of fermentation in Northeast India, this
associative relationship between fermented food and communi- essay examines how making and eating fermented food draws in
ties. Fermented bamboo shoot comes in different textures and debates about flavor and taste, but also about new practices of
forms—wet chunky pieces, sun-dried and stringy threads, smoked differences and alliances.
and curly strands. Simply put, fermented food is a technique of Our relationship with microbes determines how we organize,
preserving food to increase its shelf life (Yesudas 2018), yet its move, and order our lives, including values, knowledge, and
distinct aroma and taste sparks off sensory affects about taste. memories about communities. Known as tama in Nepali, khorisa
Paired with meat, fish, and vegetables across Northeast India, fer- in Assamese, lung seij in Khasi, and soidon in Meiteilon, the
mented food transforms communities, economies, and identities. knowledge and fermentation practices of bamboo shoot among
A rich body of research literature focuses on scientific ex- eastern Himalayan societies are layered and complex (see Tamuli
periments and tests conducted on nonindustrialized forms of 2017). In addition, communities are also named after fermented
fermentation among indigenous communities. Topics range from food. For instance, the Lotha Naga tribe of Nagaland also call
scientific processes of fermentation and microbial diversity (G. Das themselves Rhuchak Etsoi (fermented bamboo shoot eaters). As
et al. 2016; Tamang and Tamang 2009), nutritional and medicinal it turns out, the methods of preparing fermented bamboo shoot
values of indigenous practices of fermentation (A. Das and Deka are similar across communities, but nuances such as the types of
2012), and nontoxic processes of fermentation that communities wares or processes of fermenting and consuming are employed
should adopt (Nongdam and Leimapokpam 2014). In this essay, to create distinct accounts of community histories including
I examine seemingly ordinary practices and conversations about gender relations and social practices. These accounts offer us
fermentation and consumption. insights about indigenous skills and knowledge and invite us to

Dolly Kikon is Senior Lecturer in Development Studies in the Department of Social and Political Sciences of the University of Melbourne
(04, E 465, John Medley Building, Parkville, Victoria 3010, Australia [dolly.kikon@unimelb.edu.au]). This paper was submitted 6 VI 20,
accepted 18 III 21, and electronically published 21 IX 21.

Current Anthropology, volume 62, supplement 24, October 2021. q 2021 The Wenner-Gren Foundation for Anthropological Research. All rights reserved. Published by
The University of Chicago Press for The Wenner‐Gren Foundation for Anthropological Research. https://doi.org/10.1086/715830
Kikon Bamboo Shoot in Our Blood S377

consider the place of fermented food, as markers of differences prefer to invoke the seasons. Territorial boundaries fail to dampen
and belonging simultaneously. the heightened experiences of seasons in this part of the world.
Identities and cultures are constantly mediated through food “Spaces that elude national maps,” writes historian David Ludden
(Kikon 2017; Ray 2016). The senses of smell, touch, taste, sight, (2005:5), “have now mostly disappeared from intellectual life.”
and hearing create a hierarchy of values (Classen 2001). However, Situated along the eastern Himalayan range, the bamboo
these sensory values must be contextualized. What is considered shoot foraging season starts in the summer around June and
as stinky and associated as disgusting might be construed as stretches all the way to August/September. As the shoots appear
pleasant and bestowed with a taste of home and culture or even in the beautiful bamboo grooves, the monsoon clouds in this part
sacredness. Smell is deeply entangled with aesthetics and the of the world “bounce between the Patkai ranges and the eastern
pleasure of the senses, thereby creating an authoritative category Himalaya ranges” (Rahman 2020). Yet, the history of militari-
about what constitutes odor, stinky, and smelly (McHugh 2012). zation and violence in the region means life is precarious.
Smell matters when it comes to fermented food like bamboo Therefore, accounts of bamboo shoot fermenters and consumers
shoot. If the allures of eating and experiencing taste are about offer us new ways to think about taste, smell, and alliances. Just as
stimulating the sense of smell, fermented bamboo shoot invokes following Matsutake mushrooms, Anna Tsing (2015:4) reflects,
an emotional attachment to home and community. “guides us to possibilities of coexistence within environmental
Experiences of smell (tasty/disgusting) powerfully shape citi- disturbance,” to follow fermented bamboo shoot guides us to
zenship practices in India. At a time when we witness a global explore the possible alliances and fellowships in a militarized and
movement on fermented food and the microbial world, this essay extraction-intensive region (fig. 1).
locates small-scale nonindustrial fermentation practices among The monsoon rain across the Brahmaputra Valley can be hard
eastern Himalayan societies and their significant role in shaping and harsh. The raindrops are thick and sharp. On some days,
food cultures and politics in contemporary India. they feel like liquid whiplash on your skin. It literally hurts when
In the following sections of the essay, I highlight narratives and it pours in this part of the world. However, not everyone seeks
representations of fermented food from Northeast India. Much of shelter from the rain during the monsoons. During my field-
the fieldwork was done in 2018–2019 when I was tracing stories work, I would see Khasi women in the rain carrying wooden bas-
of indigenous cultures of preserving food and the emergence of kets stocked with tender bamboo shoots walking in the neighbor-
Naga cuisine in metropolitan India. However, I also draw from a hoods of Guwahati. Around Kharguli and Digholi Pukhuri, they
longer engagement with individuals, communities, and collectives would stop along houses and shops to sell their produce. Assamese
working on food-related issues in Northeast India, Nepal, and vendors would sell tender bamboo shoot in the Ganeshguri market
Bhutan. My interest in the issue emerged as part of my doctoral and Uzan Bazaar. Beside the bus stop in Manipuri Basti too, groups
fieldwork along the foothills of eastern Assam and Nagaland of Meitei women would sell new batches of fermented bamboo
between 2009 and 2011. Although my focus was on militarization, shoot in plastic packets along with vegetables and dry fish. There is a
extractive regimes (oil and coal), and social relations, I was acutely proliferation of fermented food like bamboo shoot in Guwahati.
aware that food played a central role in mitigating conflicts and Yet, on closer observation, the city also illuminates the different
maintaining social boundaries in the region (Kikon 2013). Over ways of preparing the item, a reflection of the ethnic communities
the last decade, I extended my work to metropolitan India where who sell it and eat it. In this sense, it is ethnic bodies that carry and
many indigenous migrants from Northeast India had traveled in sell bamboo shoot and keep the fermenting cultures alive.2
search of work and livelihood. There they often experienced rac- Encounters with fermented food are about flavors, interjected
ism and discrimination on the basis of their appearance and way of with intersubjective definitions and feelings about what consti-
life. Among other markers, the food they carried from home be- tutes the right taste.3 Understanding fermented food cultures was
came instrumental in their experiences of harassment by land-
lords and neighbors. At the same time, it was certain kinds of
fermented food such as bamboo shoot, soya beans, and dried
fish that created bonds of sociality among migrants. 2. Although some of the ethnic groups have exclusive demands for sep-
arate homelands, the lived experiences of fermenters and consumers highlight
The Taste of Place a connectivity. Feelings of alienation, injustice, militarization, and experiences
of being migrants and encounters with racism and violence are common
There are many ways to describe Northeast India: either as re- themes that come up. All these accounts give rise to the “Northeasterner”
mote and marginal to the Indian mainland or a region with experience in Indian cities like Delhi or Mumbai. Fermented food, as I will
extraordinary histories of trade, mobility, and communities.1 I discuss later in the essay, plays an important role in creating a sense of alliance
and fellowship.
3. I draw from Steven Shapin’s work on intersubjectivity and move away
1. See David Ludden’s essay (2005) on Northeast India and the pol- from the notional objectivity/subjectivity binary. For Shapin, the epistemic
itics of boundaries and political nature of maps. Also refer to Willem van “stick” of objectivity rests in an “unproblematic” plane of universalism, while
Schendel’s article (2002) to engage with the politics of spatialization, subjectivity is relegated as an individualized and private judgment. It is as
academic politics of scale, and new ways of thinking about regional areas though arguing about taste “beyond a certain point” (Shapin 2011:172) is
like Northeast India. pointless and rude. Other than creating disruption, subjectivity is devoid of
S378 Current Anthropology Volume 62, Supplement 24, October 2021

Figure 1. Northeastern India. Map created by Sarat Phukan.

not easy. The fermentation sites were mostly domestic spaces like Of course, there are various worldviews on fermentation.
kitchens, and it was women who were predominantly involved in Michael Pollan’s reflections capture how the invisible world of
preserving food. Care for the household and fermenting food fungi and bacteria shapes what constitutes protest and politics in
seem to be connected. Care, in the context of fermenting food, industrialized societies. For Pollan, fermenting one’s own food is
appeared to be caring for the development of the microbial both a process of becoming a creator of unique tastes and also a
process (Paxson 2013) and also the taste. The nature of caring for form of protest against homogenizing flavors of food experi-
fermenters includes deep knowledge about how to differentiate ences (Pollan 2012:xii). At the heart of this practice, Pollan
the fermented from the rotten, a knowledge that, according to reflects, is sharing food, living off the grid, resisting the idea of
Mintz (2008:56), “illuminates the power of culture and social becoming passive consumers, standing up to a corporate econ-
learning to shape perception.” He notes that one-third of food omy, and building a community of fermenters.
consumed by human societies has undergone some form of Contrary to this imagination, fermented food cultures in
fermentation, and this deserves recognition, as fermentation is Northeast India, often produced in nonindustrialized settings,
central in helping the process of evolution and nutrition in the are categorized as exotic and marginal to food cultures in India.
human diet. They do not inhabit the same artisanal space that Pollan attri-
butes to fermented practices in industrialized societies in the
West. These dominant stereotypes take away the powerful ac-
counts of fermented food cultures and their impact on the pro-
rationality. Here, I dwell on taste and odor (smelly food or sour taste) not as
duction of the embodied and intersubjective nature of knowledge
personal judgments that are private and arbitrary but as feelings that emerge
and politics. To make fermented bamboo shoot, one requires fresh,
from shared experiences of different ethnic groups. Everyday experiences of
fermented food cultures provide an opportunity to examine how taste, often
tender shoots. Here, elevation and ecology play a significant role.
subsumed within categories of subjective and private, powerfully shapes the Bamboo grows in the plains, along the elevated foothills, and in the
political and social worlds of citizens. Therefore, engaging with the “everyday mountains across the region. While one can eat fermented bamboo
life of science-making” (7) leads us to interrogate existing “problematic” shoot throughout the year, there is a season—June to October—to
frameworks about objectivity and subjectivity. harvest and preserve it. During this time, wild ferns, herbs, flowers,
Kikon Bamboo Shoot in Our Blood S379

and gourds are also available. This calls for a new imagination to
understand the edible ecological plant world in the eastern Hima-
layas (fig. 2).
Fermented food such as milk, rice, cereals, and vegetables are
consumed across India (Satish Kumar et al. 2013). Shops and
supermarkets across the country sell curd, cottage cheese, but-
termilk, pickles, or ingredient mixes to prepare idli, dosa, dhokla,
and jalebi. Thus, the perception of fermented food cultures from
the eastern Himalayan regions like Northeast India as inferior
and revolting are founded on class and caste hierarchies. But the
popularity of fermented food from the region is on the rise. For
example, akhuni (fermented soya beans), anishi (fermented yam
cakes), and ngari (fermented fish) have appeared on the menu of
ethnic restaurants and cafés across metropolitical cities in main-
land India. Across Northeast India too, cities like Guwahati, Di-
mapur, Shillong, and Itanagar serve bamboo shoot chutneys and
curries. Yet, accounts of fermenting bamboo shoot are hazy at best.
Excited to see a pile of tender bamboo shoots at Uzan Bazaar
in Guwahati, I asked about the stock. The vendors said, “From
the hills.” When I inquired, “Which hills?” given that Guwahati
shares its borders with a number of hill districts and states, the
vendor responded “Garo Hills.” He described how he had re-
fused a batch of bamboo shoots the previous week because they
were “old.” Plants are so integral to our dietary lives that we
often qualify their texture and quality of taste by attributing
temporal features assigned to humans. Even for bamboo shoot,
vendors and fermenters often employ terms like “young” and
“tender” to describe the taste and feature of the plant. The fresh
bamboo shoots in Guwahati during summer come from foragers
who enter the forest and harvest the young shoots from bamboo
Figure 3. Fresh bamboo shoot at Uzan Bazaar, Guwahati. Photo
grooves (fig. 3). credit: Dolly Kikon.
Bamboo shoot is a popular delicacy, but many households in
urban areas like Guwahati and Dimapur prefer to buy it from the
only one place in Shillong where we go to buy our fermented
store. Increasingly, the process of fermentation is no longer part
food. Khasis don’t usually make fermented foods at home; we
of an urban household’s daily routine. In a conversation about
prefer to buy them.”
fermentation, a Khasi friend from Shillong reminisced, “There is
The origins of the fermented food appear to symbolize the
distance of the urban consumers from the creators (Pollan 2012).
Thus, familiarity about fermented food does not mean a deeper
engagement with the processes. Such conversations denote how
fermentation and fermented food is seen as a revenue-generating
activity across communities. It also shows how urbanization and
markets in the region are shaping food practices.4 These expe-
riences can be witnessed among urban consumers in the West as
well.
The ability to buy processed meat, seafood, or meat packaged
in supermarkets “enable[s] us to eat meat without the killers or
the killing,” notes Pachirat (2011:3). Although many households
have stopped producing fermenting food, community culture

4. For instance, many Assamese households in urban areas of Guwahati


buy kahudi/panitenga and kharoli (fermented mustard seeds) from the
Figure 2. From left to right: Watercress, pumpkin, pennywort, market. In Dimapur as well, Naga consumers buy essential ferments like
bottle gourd, fish mint (top). Fiddlehead ferns, bamboo shoot, fermented bamboo shoot (wet/pulp/smoked) and anishi (fermented yam
pumpkin flowers (below). Photo credit: Dolly Kikon. leaves) or akhuni/axone (fermented soyabeans) from the market.
S380 Current Anthropology Volume 62, Supplement 24, October 2021

and pride remain strongly connected to these food items. Core iarity, and creating taste is grounded on touch (Classen 2005).
sets of values reiterating ethnic pride and heritage are also widely Yet, there are no standardized mechanisms of taste for com-
visible. For instance, in Nagaland, specific communities and fer- munities involved in fermenting bamboo shoot. Perhaps this is
mented foods are seen to be inseparable.5 Fermented food prac- the unique character of fermenting cultures and identities. From
tices in the region showcase food cultures as identity markers. crunchy and sour to soggy and soft, the accounts of eating
Although eating fermented food like bamboo shoot is becoming fermented food are never straightforward. Tangy, tasty, aro-
expressions of indigenous identities of/from the region across matic, delicious, mouthwatering. How do we remain faithful to a
India (Kikon 2015; Singh, Singh, and Sureja 2007), embracing standardized taste? From the moment the tender bamboo shoot
fermented food culture is centered on consumption: taste, feel- is chopped and sealed in assigned jars, the fermenter is vigilant,
ings, and the sensorial connections. touching, handling, smelling, and watching the preparation.
There are many ways to ferment bamboo shoot. To be precise, Sure, the element of uncertainty and chances of going moldy
any fresh bamboo shoot chopped and stored in a container fer- and bad are there. But it is here that the senses become observant
ments. But determining the taste as the fermentation sets in re- and monitor the process. Raymond Williams notes that taste is
quires years of practice and knowledge. My aim in this essay is to more than a physical sense. It is more than tasting with the
provide the accounts of bamboo shoot fermenters and consumers mouth, and is associated more closely to “touch or feel” (Williams
and explore how differences and alliances are produced. Some 2015:147). However, as taste became associated with the power of
ferment the bamboo shoot in dark and dry places, and others place the human faculty, explains Williams, the definition was reduced
stones on top of the jars to apply pressure during fermentation. to an abstraction with manners and rules of etiquette. This was the
There are also those who line the walls of the container with ba- beginning of discriminating and distinguishing the tasteful from
nana leaves. The fermenting process takes place in earthen pots, the tasteless.
cane baskets, glass jars, and plastic containers. Every community In other words, the meaning of taste moved away from the
asserts a distinct technique to ferment bamboo shoot, and none of human senses and became “a matter of acquiring certain habits
them is incorrect. However, there is an emphasis on “our way” as and rules” (Williams 2015:248). Unlike taste/tasteful,6 which is
the “best way.” Perhaps there is a belief that a particular kind of compromised and reduced to a sense of conformity to external
ethnic knowledge is superior and authentic. It was such assertions habits, Williams notes that the term “tasteless” continues to carry
that brought a performative element to my conversations with the “older and wider sense of touch and feel,” although in a moral
fermenters and consumers alike. The energy was difficult to ig- context more than anything else. Connecting with Williams’s
nore, and the excitement was altogether infectious. work on taste, I observed how feeling and touching was a central
“It depends on what you intend to do. Big piece, small pieces, process of fermenting food. When I listened to conversations
or pound them into pulp,” Zubeno said. A fermenter from about fermenting bamboo shoot, the accounts were ordinary and
Wokha, she described the chopping techniques for tender bam- simple. Yet, the elements of touch and taste—sour, sweetness,
boo shoot. The conversation was animated. She constantly ex- strong, mild—were always present. People also reacted strongly
panded and contracted her forefinger and thumb to demonstrate to how, why, and when to eat it. It was impossible to shake off the
the size of the pieces. In the middle of our conversation, her voice individualized feelings and stories. Feelings about preferences
trailed off. Appearing restless, she mumbled, “hah, ahummm,” a and fermented narratives also followed a territorial and ethnic
note of dissatisfaction, and got off from her chair hastily. “Wait,” specificity.
she told me and returned with an empty plastic bottle. She placed “I like fermented bamboo shoot from Assam. The ones from
the plastic bottle on her thigh and made gestures of chopping with Nagaland and Meghalaya are strong, way too strong for me,”
her right hand. The plastic bottle as an imaginary bamboo shoot Ashpriya said. It was her grandmother who fermented bamboo
created an additional air of excitement. Fermentation, Zubeno shoot in the household and made different kinds of pickles. Her
said, was part of her being: “We do not exist without it.” She had family also fried fermented bamboo shoot with mustard oil and
touched, tasted, and loved it since she was a child. garlic as a side dish on days when food was bland. In addition, it
was used as a balm for wasp stings and other insect bites. After
The Flavor of Bamboo Shoot her grandmother passed away, her mother and her younger sis-
ter fermented bamboo shoots. Until a few years back, they sent her
Touch is central to start the process of fermentation. The taste jars of fermented food from Sonari to Guwahati.
develops and grows as the hands and the tongue work together. In 2019, Ashpriya made her first batch of fermented bamboo
For fermented bamboo shoot, the distinction of value, famil- shoot. She said it was an emotional experience. She was thrilled
and documented the event on her mobile phone for her family.
She follows the values and rules about fermenting that her
5. For instance, the Lotha tribe are associated with fermented bamboo
grandmother taught her. She explained,
shoot and the Ao tribe are known for their anishi (fermented yam
cakes), while the Sümi tribe are regarded as the best akhuni (fermented
soya beans) makers, and the Rengma tribe are known for their fermented 6. Also Michael Taussig’s (2009) work refers to distasteful things in
mustard leaf items. the colonial and postcolonial vocabulary and mannerisms.
Kikon Bamboo Shoot in Our Blood S381

My grandmother said that we should be quiet during the


chopping process.
No farting and no gossiping.
We should not be distracted like getting up in the
middle to do some other work.
And . . . we must quickly store it in the jar.
We must be fast.
Everything must be fast fast.
What appears as biological in nature such as farting or social
norms like gossiping are considered intertwined with sensory
cultures. Here, values associated with taste, pace, and mindful-
ness determine the quality of the fermented food. Therefore, just
like touching has a microbial connection, farting is perceived as
disrupting the air and the environment. Classen (2001) notes
that senses are shaped by culture and cannot be perceived as
biological alone. Therefore, observing social norms is deemed
important. For instance, Ashpriya remembers how her grand-
mother kept away naughty children while preparing fermented
bamboo shoot. The physical movement and agitated spirit of
children affected fermentation. She added,
Figure 4. Fermented bamboo shoot from the author’s collection.
When the fermentation is not right,
Photo credit: Dolly Kikon.
like it is not sour enough, or it becomes too sweet,
the fault lies with the maker and not the bamboo shoot.
The touch is wrong, we say. But with fermented bamboo shoot, I don’t remember
Taste is all about the touch. when I started eating it.
Is there a reason for this nature of knowledge? I wondered. Maybe as a baby, that’s all I can say.
Then I learned that Ashpriya followed her grandmother’s in- Food evokes powerful memories of the past. Recounting
structions. She kept her curious little daughter away from poignant memories of lives and places is often centered around
touching or playing with the bamboo shoot, and this helped her meals and food. In addition, family recipes are passed down
to focus and created a space for her to function without dis- across the generations and play a significant role in invoking a
traction. Consumers like Ashpriya considered the homemade community’s past connected to food and memory (Sutton 2001).
fermented bamboo shoot tastier, but others were quick to make Zubeno, the fermenter from Wokha, also describes how she fed
additional moral claims. They emphasized, for example, that fermented bamboo shoot to her child. She said, “He was around
having “clean thoughts” and “clean hands” was important, thereby two-and-a-half years old. I started feeding him as soon as he was
demonstrating an authority on how good taste is tied to a code of able to eat rice. Maybe my mother did the same with me. She
conduct of the maker (fig. 4). must have fed me fermented bamboo shoot very young.”
I also learned that certain ethnic households assigned specific
days of the week as fermented bamboo shoot day. During a
conversation with Augustin, a researcher from the Karbi ethnic
Gendering Fermentation
community, I learned that his household observed two days a Scientific literature on fermented food in Northeast India shows
week as bamboo shoot day. “Why twice a week?” I asked, and he how mothers feed infants fermented food as health food (Satish
replied, “It is associated with meat and fish. We add it to flavor Kumar et al. 2013). In addition, fermented food is also cele-
non-vegetarian dishes and eat it as curry too. So, I say twice a brated as a significant cultural symbol, yet fermenting is highly
week as a figure of speech. But what I mean is that fermented gendered. Women predominantly possess traditional knowl-
bamboo shoot is a regular feature of our diet.” Known as Hen-up edge and skills of fermentation across communities (Kikon
ahan, fermented bamboo shoot curry is an integral part of Karbi 2015; Singh, Singh, and Sureja 2007). For instance, women from
cuisine. Wondering how far one can trace the memory of taste, I the Apatani tribe of Arunachal Pradesh use banana leaves to line
asked Augustin about his earliest recollections of eating fermented the bamboo baskets before fermenting the bamboo shoot. It
bamboo shoot. He said: takes 6–8 days for fermentation. Among the Adi women,
No, I do not recollect eating fermented bamboo shoot. bamboo shoot is wrapped in banana leaves and placed under
I remember when I saw a potato for the first time. stones near streams and water bodies. It takes 3–4 months for
I asked my mother, “What is this?” fermentation. In Manipur, Meitei women chop and dry the
When I saw dal (lentils) for the first time, I asked my fresh bamboo shoots in the sun for 15–20 minutes and do not
mother, “What is this?” wash them, to retain the flavor and taste. Fermentation takes
S382 Current Anthropology Volume 62, Supplement 24, October 2021

place in clay pots and takes around 2–3 months. Khasi women during conversations with traditional fermenters transformed
in Meghalaya use glass jars and bamboo baskets to ferment the atmosphere. Among nonindustrial home-based fermenters
bamboo shoot, while women from the Barman community in there is a sense that traditional methods are inferior to scientific
Tripura prefer to cook fresh bamboo shoot and make a fish dish methods.8 Scientific papers on fermentation practices also give us
called Godhak (Singh, Singh, and Sureja 2007). a high-strung laboratory-driven knowledge. There is regimented
The gendering of fermentation is also visible in tales of food. order and the structure of the findings. There is a clear dem-
Some years ago, a friend narrated a Sümi Naga story about onstration of the laboratory tests conducted on the microbes and
akhuni (fermented soya beans). Once upon a time, a young the presence of lactic acid bacteria. A scientific finding about
woman often went to bed hungry because her cruel stepmother lactic acid in fermented bamboo shoots from Northeast India
deprived her of food. One day, she cooked a pot of soya beans in reports:
the fields and ate to her heart’s content. She left the leftovers This study showed that strains of LAB (Lactic Acid Bacteria)
wrapped in a leaf under a haystack. When she returned to the played important roles by their functional properties related to
field a few days later, the beans had become sticky and flavorful. acidifying capacity, degradation of antinutritive factors, tol-
From that day, she fermented soya beans and ate them. As days erance to bile-salt, wide enzymatic activities, and nonpro-
went by, her skin glowed and she became beautiful. She married ducers of biogenic amines. Understanding the biological and
well and became a wealthy woman. While this story resonates biochemical basis of indigenous knowledge of the ethnic people
with taste and flavor, it also draws our attention to the valuation of Northeast for production of nonperishable bamboo shoots
and history of fermented food among communities who practice by lactic acid fermentation has merit. (Tamang and Tamang
shifting cultivation. The reason food cultures of communities are 2009; emphasis added)
seldom incorporated in conversations about cuisine and taste is
because dominant frameworks about modern gastronomy and Although the article refers to the diverse fermenting cultures,
taste are connected to communities with a history of settled there are no conversations, observations, or interviews with the
agriculture. fermenters. The study highlights the nature of relationship be-
Given how seasons are key for shifting cultivation and the tween the world of traditional fermentation and the scientific
cycles of vegetables and plants, stories of fermentation among community, and institutional findings as superior in comparison
upland communities in Northeast India centrally emphasize to the rich fermenting cultures outside the laboratory. To many
time, precision, and a sustained sensory engagement. This also scientists, communities outside the laboratory are considered
means that the microbes at work in the fermenting jars set off a sites to extract samples. On the one hand, the characteristics and
series of social practices, taboos, and guidelines. These accounts identities of the lactic acid bacteria, such as their resilience to
come across as community histories and are considered local grow in brine and their ability to coagulate, are well laid down,
knowledge. For instance, when Zubeno, fermenter from Wokha, including the techniques and results. On the other hand, the
finished her performative account of chopping and fermenting practices of fermenters and consumers and how they care for
bamboo shoot, our conversation lingered on taste and time. She fermenting food, the deep cultural and social values, and their
stressed the “three-day rule.” According to her, fermentation knowledge of microbial ecology remain absent. The laboratory
sets in within 24 hours, but one has to wait for three days before life of fermented food highlights how the proof and evidence
opening the lid and tasting its flavor. about the truth of fermentation has to be dislodged from the
Who defines these timelines and procedures? What is the role experiential world and stored in a laboratory test tube. Social
of the researcher and the fermenter? My role as a researcher was anthropologists “might have no business probing the activities of
not to produce an ordered and standardized procedure of fer- science” (Latour and Woolgar 1986:19), but a deeper relation-
mentation. All communities with nonindustrialized fermenting ship between fermenting cultures and the scientific world needs
food cultures depend on the season and external conditions— to be iterated. After all, the referential point of taste and smell is a
rain, heat, cold, touch— to determine the taste. Yet this is not central characteristic of value addition and marketability (Besky
the case with the scientific papers documenting indigenous fer- 2021), including the origins of the modern commercial world of
menting processes in Northeast India. The scientific findings are nutritional value (Shapin 2011; see fig. 5).
dependent on laboratory tests and results to analyze the char- Studying the social construction of science, Bruno Latour and
acters of microbes under different atmospheric conditions. The Steve Woolgar (1986) suggest: “The elimination of alternative
personalities of the fermenters and their world are erased.
Some interviewees believed that fermented bamboo shoot
lacked taste due to the inconsistency and miscalculation of the
8. They internalize how their processes are not scientific and there-
maker/creator. My interlocuters often wondered if these pro-
fore keep these practices outside the realm of science. In my previous
cesses of fermentation were “unscientific.”7 The word “scientific” work on akhuni or fermented soya beans, similar moments surfaced, and
I asserted that such moments highlight the hierarchies of modernity.
They showcase our engagement with, and imagination of, modernity
7. The English word “unscientific” was used in conversations that where certain knowledge systems are relegated as simple and unscientific
were in Lotha, Nagamese, or Assamese. over others (see Kikon 2015).
Kikon Bamboo Shoot in Our Blood S383

Figure 5. From left to right: Fermented bamboo shoot juice and fermented bamboo shoot chunks from the author’s collection. Image
credit: Dolly Kikon.

interpretations of scientific data and the rendering of these connected to the earth and the environment and other forms of
alternatives as less plausible is a central characteristic of scientific life around us” (xix).9
activity. Consequently, the practising scientist is likely to be as
much involved with the task of producing order and plausible The Smell of Community
accounts out of a mass of disordered observation as is the outside
observer” (36). Fermentation directs our attention toward identities, commu-
Fermentation is a living process. The fermenter or the “out- nities, and elements of social change. Smell is central here.
side observer” are spread across thousands of households and Migrants from Northeast India experience racism and disgust in
geographies. Sight, touch, and tongue are indicators to assess the Indian cities and hostels through everyday activities of eating
activities of the living organisms, and so are seasons and to- “smelly” food (Kikon 2017). As much as fermentation is a nat-
pographies—not merely visible to the eyes as color and bubbly ural process, the microbial activities also transform community
objects, but alive to the taste buds as an encounter of texture and perception on citizenship and rights. Particularly in India, the
flavor. The makers and consumers are constantly interpreting sensorial politics of disgust is deeply founded on producing mean-
and establishing a living ecology of fermented culture. Every ings about purity and cleanliness (Staples 2014). As a result, policing
fermentation process is a transformative relationship. the boundaries of smell and food becomes a matter of governance
An interviewee once said that sometimes her ferments turned and order. The food cultures of certain communities as dis-
“sour,” so she threw them away. “Aren’t all fermented bamboo gusting in India signals the role of disgust in reiterating hierar-
shoot sour?” I inquired. “It is a different kind of sourness,” she chies and violations (Miller 1998).
responded. Fermenters develop what Susan Lepselter (2016:29) For instance, in 2013 the city police in India’s capital, New
refers to as a “meta-awareness,” where knowledge of the taste Delhi, came out with the famous guidelines for migrants from
becomes an embodied feeling on the tongue, nostrils, and eyes, Northeast India to refrain from cooking “smelly food like Bam-
and is incorporated into the pores of the fingers. boo shoot and akhuni (fermented soya beans).” A series of pro-
Reflecting about the character of fermentation, American tests and allegations about discrimination and racism appeared in
food activist and fermenter Sandor Katz describes each batch of public sites and digital forums (Hueiyen Lanpao Editorial Team
fermented food as unique and different. The invisible life forces 2013).
that ferment our food, notes Katz, give an element of en- In the mid-1990s, for students from Northeast India in Delhi
chantment and magic to the entire process. Dwelling on mi- deep anxieties over cooking fermented food prevailed. Many of
crobial processes, he highlights how transformation, decom- us improvised ways of cooking fermented food. For example, we
position, death, and fermentation are aligned on the same plane.
Referring to microbes in our environment as “communities,”
Katz (2012) underlines how our quest to join fermenting cultures 9. Also see the video by Ann Husaini and Emily Lobsenz for the New
is a way of seeking connections with food and a way of life. York Times Op-Doc, available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?vpYue
Fermenting cultures show us how there is a “hunger to be more 5osieODk.
S384 Current Anthropology Volume 62, Supplement 24, October 2021

soaked akhuni (fermented soya beans) in hot water for 3–


5 minutes and covered it with a lid. We then made a paste and
added fresh tomatoes, chilies, ginger, and salt. For fermented
bamboo shoot, we added them in the curry a few minutes before
we turned off the cooking gas. The lid remained intact on the pot
and we closed the windows and doors to make sure our neigh-
bors were not bothered by the smell. Sometimes we lit incense
sticks. Such moments highlight how food creates boundaries and
meanings of disgust. The politics of taste and odors produces the
smell of a community. Fermenting food practices connects us to
a meaningful life and the environment around us (Katz 2012). In
the light of eating fermented food in New Delhi, one can add that
the process to find a meaningful life also means deriving pleasure
and cherishing a shared sense of eating smelly food.10 As fine
dining restaurants in India add Northeast cuisine to “celebrate”
diversity, fermented food is erased or tuned down to “suit local
taste” (Dutta 2019; fig. 6).
Here, lived experiences create a regional solidarity and alliance
(Hazarika 2017). Specifically, consuming fermented food and
ethnic politics grounded on territoriality give rise to distinct
forms of “gastropolitics” (DeSoucey 2017). Experiences of ca-
maraderie and bonding created by consuming fermented food
among migrants from the northeast in urban India break down Figure 6. Fermented, sun-dried, smoked, and curled bamboo
boundaries, especially when people are away from home. Yet shoot from the author’s collection. Image credit: Dolly Kikon.
they also tend to establish a hierarchy of food cultures of certain
communities while erasing other fermenting cultures in public
perception. Therefore, the smell of a community derived from new values and solidarities. It is alive and breathing with new
eating fermented food offers us new analytical frameworks to meanings to infuse new political smells.
understand social relationships and alliances. This means un-
settling existing ethnic characteristics and creating solidarities to Transethnicity: A Culinary Identity
value an ecological world where microbial biodiversity is cele-
brated and is part of community life. Fermented food like bamboo shoot operates as a distinct marker
Accounts of migrants from Northeast India highlight how of ethnic identification from the outside (etic), and also as a
fermented food helps them to remember family and loved ones collective glue (emic) where a shared regional understanding
back home (Kikon 2018; McDuie-Ra 2012). Once a migrant in about food culture functions as a connection. Celebration of
New Delhi described that his clothes and shoes smelled of taste and flavors creates a sense of community solidarity that
fermented food whenever he returned from home and unpacked cuts across ethnic markers that I refer to as transethnicity. If
his suitcase. Just as migrants remember home, it also creates new fermented food like bamboo shoot is consumed across ethnic
communities and civilities. For instance, during hostile border lines, the notion of transethnicity encourages us to consider
disputes along the Assam-Nagaland border, when Ahom and food cultures as a significant theoretical framework to study new
Naga elders meet for reconciliation meetings and eat together, forms of communities and political entanglements. Translating
they praise the food and invoke a shared past and community practices and forms of knowledge as a field of inquiry under-
camaraderie (Kikon 2019). Fermented food cultures represent lying the everyday experiences of eating fermented food is key.
Transethnicity offers deeper engagement that generates how
lived experiences of “smelly” food shape citizenship practices
10. However, fermentation has become a trend in places like Mumbai, and politics of solidarity. In addition, it shows how fermented
Goa, and Pune. These fermenting communities from metropolitan Indian food ethnographies contribute toward new embodied practices.
cities are mobile and wealthy and follow global trends. Kombucha is a fine It is key to interpret and analyze the “unruliness of smell”
example (Ray Chaudhuri 2017). The “community of microbes” (Katz 2012)
(Pachirat 2011:3) attributed to fermented food and to address
is the only thing that connects the cool Indian hipster fermenters and ethnic
how smelly food produces distinct values and a contingent
groups from Northeast India. As health-conscious hipsters, they connect
with their global networks in countries like Switzerland to procure the
alliance of “us.”
Symbiotic Culture of Bacteria and Yeast or SCOBY, known as the “mother” Northeasterner or the Northeast has become a regional
(Ray Chaudhuri 2017) to start the process of fermentation. Kombucha identity based on geographical location in India. When it comes
smells as well. Yet the connection of fermenting cultures in Northeast India to lived experiences about what it really means to be a North-
reiterates a politics of difference and disgust. easterner or to come from the Northeast, a strong distinguishing
Kikon Bamboo Shoot in Our Blood S385

factor is food. Identifying the cuisines of communities across the Fermented food across the Himalayan region goes beyond the
region, Hoihnu Hauzel notes, “The importance of bamboo shoot territorially defined state spaces and boundaries and intersects
can hardly be exaggerated in the Northeastern diet” (Hauzel through reciprocal exchanges, food practices, and resource re-
2014:3–4). While scholars have highlighted questions of ethnicity, gime (Kikon 2015:331). Out of these processes, a notion of
identity, and diversity as a regional category (Ngaihte and shared identity—a regional identity as Northeastern/Himalayan—
Hanghal 2017), food writers like Hauzel are drawn toward the also comes into existence.12 However, across the Indian sub-
transformative elements of taste that give rise to a sensory re- continent, fermented bamboo shoot as an appetizing food is
gional identity. “To eat food from the Northeastern states, one missing. This is peculiar because India is the second largest
earlier went to the state house restaurants or Dilli Haat. Today, bamboo-producing country after China, and irrespective of the
one would go to Humayanpur instead,” writes Chaudhuri (n.d.). nutritional benefits and market potential of fermented bamboo
Others follow a territorialized framework of writing about North- shoot in India, the market for bamboo shoot remains absent. The
east Indian food where dishes are bounded with the respective states reason is that the “pungent taste and strong odour” of the food is
and ethnic groups (Chopra 2014). unappealing to the Indian consumer (Nongdam and Leimapok
Ethnicity is an important theoretical lens to study significant pam 2014:10).
cultural practices and notions of race (Hutchinson and Smith These accounts of fermented food create polarizing experi-
1996), nationalism (Smith 1992), and authenticity and taste (Ray ences of what is considered palatable and repugnant. Kire, a Naga
2016). In the culinary world, ethnicity is an all-encompassing writer, describes the lives of ethnic migrants from Northeast
category that ranges from a national identity connected with India as intertwined with fermented food cultures:
food (Indian, Pakistani, Chinese, Vietnamese) to a racialized A pungent, sweet, aroma wafted through the ventilator of a
category like non-Western dishes outside the French and Italian dingy rented room in a residential Delhi locality. “Baiya Nigu
cuisine as opposed to Japanese, Chinese, or Vietnamese dishes is cooking his Naga dish again,” exclaimed five year old Rahul
(Ray 2016). Transethnicity as a culinary identity recognizes food knowledgeably, sniffing the air and wrinkling his upturned
practices and community connections at particular junctures little nose in distaste. His chubby feet furiously peddled the
of history. In Northeast India, ethnicity provides a theoretical electric blue tricycle, its shrill bell ringing throughout the entire
framework to analyze conflict and violence (Hausing 2009), de- stretch of corridor as if to ward away any lingering traces of the
mands for homelands, natural resources (Karlsson 2011), and offensive smell . . . . He (Nigu) had been warned by the
autonomy (Barbora 2002). In addition, exclusive community landlord not to cook his strong-smelling traditional dishes.
claims (Hausing 2009) and assertions (Hausing 2020; Vande- This warning had been initiated by complaints from the other
kerckhove and Suykens 2008) are examined as ethnic in nature. tenants who had reported a strange odour emitting from his
However, these ethnic communities portrayed as communi- room. They all proclaimed the smell to be most foul and
ties at war with one another also seek reconciliation and live as simply unbearable. “It’s only fermented soya beans and some
neighbors. bamboo shoot” he had stammered when faced with his
In the last two decades, there has been heightened focus on grumpy landlord. (Kire 2015:52–53)
ethnic conflicts and nationalism that is based on exclusive his-
tories and “unique cultures” across Northeast India (Kikon It was flavors, disgust, and taste about fermented food that
2015). Ethnic model villages and food festivals have become a drew me to explore transethnicity. The development of rela-
common theme across the region (Kikon 2005; Wettstein 2016). tionship and alliances among community members cutting
In ethnic food festivals, each community displays their food to across ethnic lines, and at times interethnic hostilities, are formed
mark their distinct culture and tradition. Yet, on a closer look, as a result of shared food cultures and celebrating flavors. Here,
products like fermented bamboo shoot or rice beer are available the capacity to embrace fermented food like bamboo shoot unifies
across the different food stalls.11 Such examples demonstrate a opposition groups and creates new alliances. Otherwise marked
transethnic culinary moment. The future of food and innova- as distinct cultural traits of specific communities, fermented food
tion (Metcalfe 2019), race and labor relations (Holmes 2013),
fair trade and justice (Besky 2013), and ethics of branding food
(Probyn 2016) are important intellectual works framed through 12. With the exception of Nepali cuisine, the Himalayan region as a
food cultures and consumption practices. culinary topography remains absent in the West. A number of Indian
In this regard, fermented food cultures from Northeast India restaurants in Melbourne showcase their culinary affinity with Pakistani
draw our attention to new alliances. Emerging culinary practices or even Chinese and European cuisine. However, one is yet to come across
one that displays affinity to Bhutanese or Northeast Indian cuisine. The
offer a new lens to understand transethnic solidarities. This also
confinement of a Himalayan regional identity as a geography of migration,
means acknowledging gastronomical communities as political
tourism, and an impending region facing drastic climatic devastation means
communities (Anderson 1991; Chatterjee 2004: Kikon 2017). the reproduction of a region using taken-for-granted categories and frame-
works. Here, food remains invisible and escapes any form of analysis. Ex-
11. The connection between identity and food is also important in the perts, consultants, and corporations benefit directly from distancing a region
hills of North Bengal where Darjeeling tea is connected to Gorkha identity like the Northeast and the Himalayan region as a remote and exotic geog-
and a driving force for political demands (Besky 2013). raphy, thereby reinforcing hierarchies of power and knowledge.
S386 Current Anthropology Volume 62, Supplement 24, October 2021

like bamboo shoot defies exclusive territorial boundaries. It goes and microbial engagement. Finally, fermentation helps us to
against the assertions of ethnic claims for exclusive accounts. For think about new relationships and alliances. Proposing trans-
example, the preparation styles of fermented bamboo shoot ethnicity, I dwelled on the emergence of political identity
among communities are not drastically different, yet members based on sensory experiences to elucidate new networks of
from different ethnic groups are quick to comment that their solidarity and imaginations. This is where we see the rise of a
method is genuine or more authentic. A lady from the Lotha “Northeast India” cuisine—tangy, spicy, aromatic, all blending
Naga community told me, “The Aos also make fermented bam- to create the smell of a community. The purpose of thinking
boo shoot, but we are the ones who started making this first, so about transethnicity is not to simply discredit the political and
our product tastes better” (emphasis added). cultural assertions that ethnic communities seek to defend and
There is something about putting identity and food together protect. Rather, it is to propose how fermented food cultures
that can quickly become an assertion to claim one’s superiority. invoke a sense of belonging, ethics of responsibility, and a moral
In contrast, ethnic restaurants offering “Northeastern cuisine” obligation toward communities transcending rigid ethnic classi-
in cities like Delhi, Mumbai, and Chennai, or migrants forging fications. The representation of fermented food as part of the
alliances and networks over fermented food, tell us something Northeast cuisine, and thereby as part of the Northeast Identity,
new. Perceived through the lens of food cultures, ethnicity ap- cannot be perceived with casualness. Eating is not only a form of
pears as a porous framework where members from different ingestion but a practice where consumers should acknowledge
ethnic groups transcend to experience a shared sense of com- the cultivators, producers, makers, and packers, including the
munity and fellowship. This shared sense of eating and longing rhythms, songs, sorrows, and stories of how the food arrived on
for fermented bamboo shoot exemplifies transethnicity, going our plate.
beyond exclusive kinship, blood ties, or cultural beliefs (Carsten
2019, 2004), and perhaps also a way of looking beyond racial,
territorial, and social identity (Hollingsworth 1997; McDuie-Ra
2016). Therefore, adopting transethnicity means understanding Acknowledgments
how food alters our sense of political identity and meanings
I am grateful to my colleagues at the North East Social Research
about community. As economic development and mobility across
Centre (Guwahati), the University of Melbourne, and the Australia
Northeast India produce a regional cuisine called Northeastern
India Institute for their support. Thanks to the organizers of the
cuisine, fermented food like bamboo shoot helps us locate new
2019 Wenner-Gren symposium 160 “Cultures of Fermentation”
forms of solidarities and political cultures.
for the generous invitation. I presented an earlier version of this
essay at the workshop and received generous comments from my
Conclusion fellow participants. Thank you, Heather Paxson, Salla Sariola,
Björn Reichhardt, Christina Warinner, Daniel Münster, Danilyn
Fermenting cultures involve a diversity of practices, processes,
Rutherford, Eben Kirksey, Eva Rosenstock, Jamie Lorimer, Jessica
and networks. Focusing on nonindustrialized practices of fer-
Hendy, Katie Amato, Mark Aldenderfer, Matthaüs Rest, Megan
mentation, this essay traced the social and cultural terrain of
Tracy, Oliver Craig, Roberta Raffaetà, and Shinya Shoda. A special
fermentation—an uncharted marginal practice—that is often
thanks to Laurie Obbink for taking care of the participants and
set aside as a domestic practice. The facet of fermentation as
overseeing the logistics of the wonderful event. I am also thankful
highlighted in this essay is not about acquiring the right taste but
to the three anonymous reviewers and the comments from the
understanding how taste and touch are constituted within a
editors. To Joel Rodrigues, for an enriching fellowship and af-
cultural and political memory of fermenting cultures. Not merely
fection. To Willem van Schendel for encouraging me to explore
procedural, the process of fermentation takes place across var-
the concept of transethnicity. I hope this is the beginning of a long
ious sites—kitchens, courtyards, and living rooms—and the
conversation. To the amazing interlocutors of fermented bamboo
action transforms relationships and our senses. I also examined
shoot from Northeast India, your knowledge and laughter gave
how the flavor of bamboo shoot underlines the importance of
me the strength to complete this essay. Elum montso ka!
connecting fermented food with memories of families and
communities. The ethnographic accounts revealed the connec-
tions between human societies and food and the relation be-
tween food and memory.
The impact of fermented food in creating solidarities and
References Cited
networks is significant. For migrants from Northeast India, eating
shapes a shared experience of belonging and connects them to Anderson, Benedict. 1991. Imagined communities: reflections on the origin and
spread of nationalism. Revised edition. London: Verso.
the fermenter/family/community back home. In fermenting bam- Barbora, Sanjay. 2002. Ethnic politics and land use: genesis of conflicts in
boo shoot, I juxtaposed narratives of scientific laboratory tests India’s North-East. Economic and Political Weekly 37(13):1285–1292.
to showcase how scientific work eliminates the social world Besky, Sarah. 2013. The Darjeeling distinction: labor and justice on fair trade
tea plantations in India. Berkeley: University of California Press.
of fermenters and erases local knowledge. I argued that fer- ———. 2021. Teawords: experiments with quality in Indian tea production.
menting cultures offer a world of connection, care, palatability, American Anthropologist 123(1). https://doi.org/10.1111/aman.13508.
Kikon Bamboo Shoot in Our Blood S387

Carsten, Janet. 2004. After kinship. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. McDuie-Ra, Duncan. 2012. Northeast migrants in Delhi: race, refuge and re-
———. 2019. Blood work: life and laboratories in Penang. Durham, NC: Duke tail. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
University Press. ———. 2016. Adjacent identities in Northeast India. Asian Ethnicity 17(3):400–
Chatterjee, Partha. 2004. The politics of the governed: reflection on popular 413.
politics in most of the world. New York: Columbia University Press. McHugh, James. 2012. Sandalwood and carrion: smell in Indian religion and
Chaudhuri, Sharmistha. n.d. Humayunpur: a getaway to the Northeast. Outlook culture. New York: Oxford University Press.
Traveller. Metcalfe, Robyn. 2019. Food routes: growing bananas in Iceland and other
Chopra, Ashish. 2014. Your guide to northeast India food. Condé Nast Trav- tales from the logistics of eating. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
eller, November. Miller, William Ian. 1998. The anatomy of disgust. Cambridge, MA: Harvard
Classen, Constance. 2001. The senses. In Encyclopedia of European social his- University Press.
tory: from 1350 to 2000, vol. 4. Peter N. Stearns, ed. Pp. 355–364. Detroit: Mintz, Sidney W. 2008. Fermented beans and Western taste. In The world of soy.
Scribner’s. Christine M. Du Bois, Tan Chee-Beng, and Sidney W. Mintz, eds. Pp. 56–73.
———, ed. 2005. The book of touch. London: Routledge. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
Das, A. J., and S. C. Deka. 2012. Fermented foods and beverages of the north- Ngaihte, S. Thianlalmuan, and Ninglun Hanghal. 2017. The question of India’s
east India. International Food Research Journal 19(2):377–392. North-East identity and solidarity. Asian Ethnicity 18(1):38–53.
Das, Gitishree, Jayanta Kumar Patra, Sameer K. Singdevsachan, Sushanto Nongdam, P., and Tikendra Leimapokpam. 2014. The nutritional facts of
Gouda, and Shin Han-Seung. 2016. Diversity of traditional and fermented bamboo shoots and their usage as important traditional foods of Northeast
foods of the seven sister states of India and their nutritional and nutra- India. International Scholarly Research Notices 2014:1–17.
ceutical potential: a review. Frontiers in Life Science 9(4):292–312. Pachirat, Timothy. 2011. Every twelve seconds: industrialized slaughter and the
DeSoucey, Michaela. 2017. Contested tastes: foie gras and the politics of food. politics of sight. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Paxson, Heather. 2013. The life of cheese: crafting food and value in America.
Dutta, Indrani. 2019. The North East flavour trail. The Hindu, July 26. https:// Berkeley: University of California Press.
www.thehindu.com/life-and-style/food/indian-hotels-celebrating-traditional Pollan, Michael. 2012. Foreword. In The art of fermentation: an in-depth
-spices-and-meats-from-the-seven-sisters/article28721095.ece. exploration of essential concepts and processes from around the world. By
Hausing, Kham Khan Suan. 2009. Hills-Valley divide as a site of conflict: Sandor Ellix Katz. Pp. xi–xiv. White River Junction, VT: Chelsea Green.
emerging dialogic space in Manipur. In Beyond counter-insurgency: breaking Probyn, Elspeth. 2016. Eating the ocean. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
the impasse in Northeast India. Sanjib Baruah, ed. Pp. 263–289. New Delhi: Rahman, Mirza Zulfikar. 2020. The many names of rain in the eastern Hi-
Oxford University Press. malayas. India Climate Dialogue. November 21. https://indiaclimatedialogue
———. 2020. Failure to envision a power-sharing arrangement with Non- .net/2020/11/21/the-many-names-of-rain-in-eastern-himalayas/.
Bodos makes BTR a weak “shared-rule” model of autonomy. Indian Express, Ray, Krishnendu. 2016. The ethnic restaurateur. London: Bloomsbury.
February 7. https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/bodo-accord Ray Chaudhuri, Zinna. 2017. Hipsters in India are obsessed with a 2000-year-
-assam-peace-6254940/. old fermented health drink from China. Scroll.in, May 12. https://scroll.in
Hauzel, Hoihnu. 2014. The essential North-East cookbook. Delhi: Penguin /magazine/836534/hipsters-in-india-are-obsessed-with-a-2000-year-old-fer
Books India. mented-health-drink-from-china.
Hazarika, Sanjoy. 2017. Discrimination, being North-Eastern and “Indian- Satish Kumar, R., P. Kanmani, N. Yuvaraj, K. A. Paari, V. Pattukumar, and V.
ness.” Hindustan Times, August 11. https://www.hindustantimes.com/analysis Arul. 2013. Traditional Indian fermented foods: a rich source of lactic acid
/discrimination-being-north-eastern-and-indian-ness/story-s8Y33kar75WFkH bacteria. International Journal of Food Sciences and Nutrition 64(4):415–428.
4CdGkV8H.html. Shapin, Steven. 2011. The sciences of subjectivity. Social Studies of Science
Hollingsworth, Leslie Doty. 1997. Effect of transracial/transethnic adoption 42(2):170–184.
on children’s racial and ethnic identity and self-esteem: a meta-analytic Singh, Anamika, Ranjay K. Singh, and Amish K. Sureja. 2007. Cultural sig-
review. Marriage and Family Review 25(1–2):99–130. nificance and diversities of ethnic foods of Northeast India. Indian Journal
Holmes, Seth M. 2013. Fresh fruit, broken bodies: migrant farmworkers in the of Traditional Knowledge 6(1):79–94.
United States. Berkeley: University of California Press. Smith, Anthony D. 1992. Ethnicity and nationalism. International Studies in
Hueiyen Lanpao Editorial Team. 2013. Zero tolerance policy. E-Pao.Net, Sociology and Social Anthropology 60:1–4.
March. http://e-pao.net/epSubPageExtractor.asp?srcpnews_section.editorial Staples, James. 2014. Civilizing tastes: from caste to class in South Indian
.editorial_2013.Zero-Tolerance_Policy_HL_20130311. foodways. In Food consumption in global perspective: essays in the anthro-
Hutchinson, John, and Anthony D. Smith, eds. 1996. Ethnicity. Oxford: Oxford pology of food in honour of Jack Goody. Jakob A. Klein and Anne Murcott,
University Press. eds. Pp. 65–86. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Karlsson, Bengt G. 2011. Unruly hills: a political ecology of India’s Northeast. Sutton, David. 2001. Remembrance of repasts: an anthropology of food and
New York: Berghahn. memory. Oxford: Berg.
Katz, Sandor Ellix. 2012. The art of fermentation: an in-depth exploration of Tamang, Buddhiman, and Jyoti P. Tamang. 2009. Lactic acid bacteria isolated
essential concepts and processes from around the world. Kindle version. White from Indigenous fermented bamboo products of Arunachal Pradesh in
River Junction, VT: Chelsea Green. India and their functionality. Food Biotechnology 23(2):133–147.
Kikon, Dolly. 2005. Engaging Naga nationalism: can democracy function in Tamuli, Phatik. 2017. Fermented foods and beverages. Jaipur, India: Aavishkar.
militarised societies? Economic and Political Weekly 40(26):2833–2837. Taussig, Michael. 2009. What colour is sacred? Chicago: University of Chicago
———. 2013. Tasty transgressions: food and social boundaries in the foothills Press.
of Northeast India. Anthropology News 54(1–2):15–16. Tsing, Anna. 2015. The mushroom at the end of the world: on the possibility of
———. 2015. Fermenting modernity: putting Akhuni on the nation’s table in life in capitalist ruins. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
India. South Asia: Journal of South Asia Studies 38(2):320–335. https://doi Vandekerckhove, Nel, and Bert Suykens. 2008. “The liberation of Bodoland”:
.org/10.1080/00856401.2015.1031936. tea, forestry and tribal entrapment in Western Assam. South Asia: Journal
———. 2017. Jackfruit seeds from Jharkhand: being Adivasi in Assam. of South Asia Studies 31(3):450–471.
Contributions to Indian Sociology 51(3):313–337. van Schendel, Willem. 2002. Geographies of knowing, geographies of igno-
———. 2018. Dreams and desserts: Indigenous migration, service, and mo- rance: jumping scales in Southeast Asia. Environment and Planning D:
bility in India. International Journal of Communication 12:4143–4157. Society and Space 20(6):647–668.
———. 2019. Living with oil and coal: resource politics and militarization in Wettstein, Marion. 2016. How ethnic identity becomes real: the enactment of
Northeast India. Seattle: University of Washington Press. identity roles and the material manifestation of shifting identities among
Kire, Avinuo. 2015. The power to forgive and other stories. Delhi: Zubaan. the Nagas. Asian Ethnicity 17(3):384–399.
Latour, Bruno, and Steve Woolgar. 1986. Laboratory life: the construction of Williams, Raymond. 2015. Keywords: a vocabulary of culture and society.
scientific facts. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Lepselter, Susan. 2016. The resonance of unseen things: poetics, power, captivity, Yesudas, B. Salome. 2018. Bamboo shoots: plants of nutrition and employment.
and UFOs in the American uncanny. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. Down to Earth, December 2018. https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/food
Ludden, David. 2005. Where is Assam? Himāl Southasia, November 15, pp. 24– /why-colistin-should-be-banned-in-food-animal-production-sector-in-india
29. https://www.himalmag.com/where-is-assam/. -65519.

You might also like