You are on page 1of 61

(%!

"#$   )           


5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

  =>
          !   
-./ 0 1 2+ 342  %& :$  %& '   " () *+ . "
- %&+ ? -1 2+ @ 2 <=> 9:;+ ) 0   52 6 7 8
@- 2 <=> 9:;+ IF GH A BCB/ 1 DE / F 0 1 2+ 342
-E DO-L+ ?N   $  %J% C%/ 0 K () L M+ .1 2+
. E T) S IBL%  () L $ "/ S 0 1 R + 34R  %P Q 
' U  V W      X  Y 1 7Z  M+
 [    %_ ` aBF ' [M \ V+] 1C 0 C   ^
 :+ bc] E + ?a BF /N dN  E S+ ?a BF  e
7Z   "   X + .4f  L    0 C E
'   :+ ?0 C+  % ; g '  "  X  Y 1
.IF ij+ 0 1 [ /  [+ I 1 h>
$N fk g  ; 1F  l2 1* M4 ; F+   mk ) 9: '  L
%L .  n"   "   o * + !   o *
) L (!   S 9.k G)  M C 'CO +) ./E 0 1 2+ 342 
S i+H F * r+ .fk g  ; i+N  "   S 9." 
+ T"s 0 bt E B/*  'u   0 "   "  
.Q  E + %/ +  "s
mk ) ' (Z  n 0 j  '  %JA   (% c
. !   mk )+ N  0  

#<$
(%!"#$   )           


l/1* '+ l1j+ l + v V   74  + I4 + v %!
./N  ?'C 7 C wg  xN
?'C  S .4H+ C61 C y VB-"E v 74L :  
v ' 3 +  "   + C ) I; /  l ( I N lN Oc '
.; /E 7 C "s N z  + ?$ [L S l* F " IO+
:I   V M %L+
%|  + ?[C}F ) + ?w /* v 74L   g »
++ ?I ; ~R"+ ?I  o+6+ ?I  m."+ ?  ;+
k % .€ ?) )8 7 ] a + ?C61 046E [+ ?‚4jg
[:] Yƒ+ ?r / I ;+ ?$"W% 6N+ ?X " :+ ?k   ; %+
?0 „ N*+ 0 LN l / R+ ?0 "  lH++ F l*+4*+ ?†]
.(<)« I; / lN ‡ + ‚4H lg 9L   + ?I ˆ lN [%/ +
$1C+ ~CR l b"C a %G S k  U   L 9 %   +
$% -E $N [‡   + .[1  '+ D E [H wg C+ 2 ZE l
+ -H ?f1R*+ fG   ' 9." [L    A  C
5"- ' l" v Q‡   'N  %-‹ ' lj S Š Z1 7 8
S+ ?((?@A, /@ 6B 9 6CDE)) :V M 9+ l+ l v j

Ž= / ? C   M & ?H L 0 /% P S Œ )8 '] ~   ?‚ 1 E (<)
.7’>>/’/<< . *

5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

B--" ; ;B-* O:+ .(<)((?A, / 6B 9 6.FG3 /8)) :C +


B O: S+ ?  ' l/ A 9. CBC   A l) M $N 9 E
l1R*+ v 3 L   9k  “C6  E O: S $% E TH " 
. ZE 9  +W S
9 %  "  S +   ' YC! ”•C "+
S  ŠO H ?v 3 L ' 9./  M  $% E $N 'C 1  z}C
[C+  " l j  S M C  0 C ' }L f%L j
I  S  C — Ib‹L D–  : 6 + ?!   S l" [C '
'— 9:btN 9˜ M+ v 3 L ™   ' [L lN /6C+   X "
9."N i H ? ) 7 R\ l" t6) + v 3 L ! Q/  
.1 ")•%R + I; /  0 4+  "  : G S
:  .
'  "  N $/ % E $N i+ d RC ' [ f‡ + +1C
9:bƒ '  F; S  *•C  [:  ?F Y ' $% E
9 L   D– X /) dM C+  "  : G 9 S
:(Q ) @12 :+) 9k B/ N V C .9. /*+
$"WE  '/* ˜ ) ")xH   ) 0 Cš S G" "/ –g »
?“R/ + 7B! N 9 Z .H 9 * m" ' F; wg j+ M $!
%| %› a 1)] œ; 1  /1 C 'CO $N  u8 E  '  * ˜ %L

.X;  aBs .’< 3 N ? [k H 3 L ?Š Z1 žj ?Š Z1 (<)

#"!
(%!"#$   )           

 G F E DC B A { :Cš V *+ (74  9.)  +  +


 X W V{ :fC  V C+ [’ :ž  ]z KJ   I H
 u8 g .[’ :ž  ] z dcba`_^]\[ZY
@! +  J6 + } L "M4c ' b‹ C *+ ~c ' fC V K 
O:  *+ . :bƒ+   + “R/ + 7 + [%   I +
 % F› +  " + C s : GE Š * n + j "/ 0 M4c]
Q: n  " 0 ) E O£  ' V   ~ C O:+ ? u¢
.(<)« ~! 'WE 0 j '
v [: 9:+ 9:bƒ ' B-"   [:  C › “L+
l" v Q‡ D  'N T) ' l"" S lF  'N 7 8 + %L ?l j c+
?(( ( 9 I%3 J /8)) :9+ l+ l v j v V  V M :V M
.(’)((?M; E J K%3 L/ K%3 6%)) :V M ¤9: ' v V  C :  M
V C .[ :a 8 ] z U  T S R Q P O {:w /* v V C
: :b * S @RM
›f F+ f M y [%6H ?9.C.C '%H i428 lF+  O: »
[L+ m." [L :lg 9.C.C  [%6C+ ?  +  z ' ;+ 4N
7 M Q: n Š.C . +  z [L S 61 lg Š .C bc [L+ ?~C2

.’¥ ? "  +  ?9k B/ N (<)


V M .’<¦ 9M YC ?l%+  9/* ' [H 3 N ?lF  'N '" žj ?lF  'N (’)
.Ž’ ¥ ?<= YC ?V+] P ?lF  'N '" žj S ?žj Œ 1] l"

5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

.H /* › n R 1 ‡   I/ N ? /6 + b% r  S


0 M R ~R*+ ?H _ + 9:  V  ' ‚+ ~R* n + ?† %ƒ ›+
T )+ /1R   T ) $N §N*+ ?a "1 + [%/ !  C61
: € $N ~ "  S 7 M Q: n Š+ .i * + ~ "* S C61 IR
.L Q: –xH ?l%+ l* $N+ ?lL +  6 $N+ ?l"2 N+  )8
 I  Q:+  wg /R  ?9"* › n   I+/ wg I;+6
[%/ O:  L + ?v wg lN  )8 lF * ¨ I; 1 [%/ –g+ ?†]
.(<)« I ! N f %  + f 
l   VB-"E v 74L l)] LO @*   :   +
:Q V C ? )8 I; /  9+ l+ l v j
n % s +  "  "E IB.F §6"* 0 % '% C v LOH »
l V  }c H «† ] + 0 H ©› ' " C „+ ? )ª + " j .H
S V H ?l" t S a + ?v L– S  )8 I; /  :74  + I4
LST U ; O3 P Q R'B  97 N)) :IB/ 3 ' QM YC
.(’)« (¬> M ?ŠO  )((UG  3 W LXYZ[ \NN O K'B V8 .UG  3
l- +   4 ŠO LO B-" " $1- C ~1- —+
S  !   6 ƒ j 'u DO+ ?  "   fN ­g f
:®  V W 
¤ ; H¯  "       

.’’<¦¥ ?dN  P ? V4€ S ?@RM (<)


.<<=¥ ? "  %"*+ I; /  ?Q (’)

#"<
(%!"#$   )           

:  ]3
0 C  d1 *  D ›+ ?X+E o ‡ E ° '   ° d1"*
' ?%.+   C ƒ 9 E  )¢  ZE @) s   
0 Cš 9.G ' .   n } k  $% % $1 C y4c
l4L Ia N –O  + w /*+ l) 1 v I ‡ @2 .%G n  
QH 9G/ v 3 L Ia M  1* E %G/  F] V  ` ?lN T)] +
l v j v V  ' (1 %L ? y ‹ 6/N " ! + "   [L
'N v 1 ' l"" S ŠO  7 8 + ŠO YC! S 9+ l+
3^ 9 )) :9+ l+ l v j v V  V M :V M l" v Q‡ ; / 
z A { :bc^3 V L _ `3 7 (  L(1 ?7 ?G J a MC 9 XG1
.(<)(( d1 6 d1 V d1 e3 9. Ld1
C; /  /%J Y ‹ Š "  a  0 j * '%‡ ' a F M+
0  .E %"* S +;+ Qk  N› 9/  " V   " + C N  7 /
    V   \ lH (M ŠO + "O4    ]
 C : : I6 C; ! j  ²)  L Y . ] 0  .E %"*
[R IR ) j V 2] † C m -N+ m: " S f-  f | 
.(’) :bƒ+ Š t + Q% s + Q/ + Q_ %" C +

l   ' fH M '%H a F  h 3 N  [k H 3 N ?ŠO  '" žj ?ŠO  (<)
. ¥ /¬U ?ŠO  '" žj S ?žj Œ 1] l" V M .¬>= 9M YC ?F] '
? " + C N  7 / C; /  /%J Y ‹ Š "  a  ?0 j  + Q _ C  (’)
.:<Ž<</<’/’’³’> ?† C

5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

 ~ “L H/E C] I E 0 C›  S  ; (CF


¤f/ $"› ' §c 7 Q+ + Š  b•  O: [:+ ¤ a 6 S b•*
IB.F (Z  + .48 1R 7 /  W S   a Fg ´+
' ; " F   H 0 bt* Š X M+ 1M E @ ! N I;+B )+ 
; F+ 3 J  (1+ .)M 0 +4  9. %  a " S a j] $ R E
F   H 0 bt* [ S 3 J  ' (µ =) S   œ. 
N ­g mk ) 0.€ %L ?Qk   5/ z .s * * F; “¶  V*
¸. .s   V* n + ) 0 a  3 · ' (µh¦) 1 "N
.(<)*  œ. -  fL•* f‡ ¹ ‹L  L 04/
 o º   N $‹ 1  7 M ;] S b F   ; S+
$  %&  $  1 2 <¬>  Q " ']   
1 2 ¦= ' () * RN ‡  %&+ ?1 2 =¬ :;+ 1C·  %&
 %P (/c+ .;] N ¸;] + Q%/ $ ' 0 1 R d»+
Ž¦  s I 0 s ' ;      o %  1CJ 
1CJ   %J% Q " ']  S bt   mk " 0.€+ .M;
  o %   ; F+  VC — ?RN   %P  l" 
.(’)  "/ Q " ']  

Š "  ¼WE ?½C Q " U4/ i2 •L ~ U4 S  L–] + ;] +; ? "1 (<)
.¦=¥ ?7< > ? " 0   CE /%J X; 
7 / ) 7 8 / F & ?9 E  Q " '] ~¾ S    ?Q  tE (’)
.< ¥ ? :<Ž’ ?T _ ;/ ? % F› + ) )8

#"f
(%!"#$   )           

   H/ V+ ¾ n  !   ° LWC ~1 +


O: 7¶  FC+ .  "   "    
    °•N Q  Š N  V P S $ /  
n B-"E    QR/C ON+ .$%/ %  " 
[  S @ R lN @ RE 9 + ²! ; Y ' a  . C
.Q/ s + 7 / 9/ 
:  d%
 l  'u ŠO ]  /  wg  !   
 dM C+ ?  " ; H]  "     
 d* ;  ! 9L d* %L Š fN ­g ] O:  C
.lC  " 
:g)Q h(
m."E H ?c bt-   bt  - V  +* -    fG)
S l Z  ´ ŠO :+ ?Qj  m."E ' 2 1*› CR : @ "E
. !  
:g)Q 1
     S "* Y1  ‡ E ;+!
. "  
0   52 6 7 8 ./ S I" Q.H ) E ;+! 
N/ %E N IF "C S  /C °4L+ BCB/ 1 DE / F+ )


5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

.C; / 
[ C N+ Œ ‹ Q  [ C ˜ Q.H ) B ;+! 
.:<Ž’ /<Ž’ Q/ s 7 / ' Q
:  )j*
:-. / 0'1 23 (<
  0 C !   ; F+  H/ + | : :0'1 23
.  " Z S ;| bt  
l v j %| l   VB-"E v 74L : :-. /
.“E nH; $N ™ ¿ l*+4 N 1/ E 9+ l+
:'( )* (’
~H  ) : ˜•N  "  Q " [  + T" 9    (HÀ
.( I ! S 1ƒ +  N  /6 + 9 
 E /  %G" S E /  a }c "s (HÀ M+
L 6E + 'Ccš d F ) 0 M4 'C *  ; IM) : ˜•N  "
l* F  o 1g+ . .H Á/C n /1R +  % F› K1 a "N+ bt* S
I -N 0 O ~¾  I; M Z a %-)g+ )z  I N - ]
.(<)(C 
 0 C/  ' f; T" 9 S $‹ 1 ' C/ 7M+
:   + ¿ '  | V  +*  "

.<Ž³<¬¥ ?T" a %+ 748 a % $N Q4g  G" '  "  ?d" (<)

#"i
(%!"#$   )           

.  " 0 N R‡› + † ] ' _ 


. 0 H ©› ' _ 
. @ RE H L $N z  ~¾ 
. Q " ~H  ~¾ 
. 0 O ~¾ 
. I; /   V ! 
 "  l - ; S Q lM Â/E O:+ ~_ '  
l ) d 74 S ? l)N S Ã / 9 E [/­ ~_ '  g » : V M Y
.«  "  N /6H ? l-Ä ' 3M+ ? X " d 7 J ) +
: ”š  4 '+
. Ik B 0 *  ' _ ³ <
. ‚+ + T" + 9 s 0 F  [¾ S V  › ³ ’
. X " d ~H  '  ³ ¬
. d% P S ] ®+  2+ IC E ³ Ž
. T" ' ‡ ³ ¦
. X " ' l-Ä N a  L› ³ h
. T" %"* S ; . F› ³ =
. 0 !  [%/N o % › ³ 
. [%/ S ¥4c8 ³
.Icš  V 1M8 ³ <>


5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

  C ƒ ~H C A  "  ®  “C/  7)  ""u+


: !
o 1g+ Å S ; d % E [   '   Q: :'( )*
.(<)Š  [6N  % F› +  /)› + / + + + % s l1) F
. [ n F : : - "  Qk F8 “C/  %"N
S 7Z E  "  X     " ; H ' ;H [L
. !  
:mn( 
lL*+ I; /  @1+ ?Icš + ) S 'W%  ) :  
:Cz s 9M 'N V M ? I+ 6 @1
 ¤£ ¢  ¡  ~}  | { z y  { :w /* v V M »
 µ ´ ³ ² ± ° ¯ ® ¬ « ª © ¨§ ¦ ¥
 ÉÈÇÆÅÄÃÂÁÀ¿¾½¼»º¹¸¶
f ‹ l) 1 3H ? [¬¦ : " ] z Ò Ñ Ð Ï ÎÍ  Ì Ë Ê
4
[‹» :l" v Q‡ @/L 'N ¸ V M %L ?'WE @M S lHOM ŠO  "
%L ? « Cg R ŠO  u8 +   ) :+ 'WE 1 @M S  )
V M %L   )   u8  ) ½/C zÂÁÀ { :Cš c S V M
.H dº –xH ] N d% C r g+ %! N ~R"C 'WE ; C » :“  Æ/N
'C " 'CO: $N w /*+ l) 1 v d» M+ ? «  )  f )  L ] N

.<Ž³<¬¥ ?T" a %+ 748 a % $N Q4g  G" '  "  ?d" (<)

#"$
(%!"#$   )           

 L K J I H { :l L lN L ' d‡  bƒ S  u8 + 3  °+


S+ ...[¦’ :  6 ]  z W V UT  SRQ  P O N M
v j 5" ' l" v Q‡ Š/]   ¸ YC ' $
o A pBq K`AC / 3N mr 9st K`)) :9+ l+ l
o A uAM K`AC / 3N V mr 9st K` Lo v 
A o v  v C / 3N mr wG (t K` L _ xN V
.(( _ xN V  A n( K`AC / 3N V mr wG (t K` L
:7 M /N X " [/JH
.X "  c 9:+  +  u8 [: :V+]
.9˜+; 9:+  +ªC › 'CO  u8 [: :Œ ‹
.a /  9: a›W.H
: % M a ] +
.~H " .H  ug 4N f)M ”+ ' : °
.f) ug ›+ f)M ”+ › ' :Œ ‹ +
' a 6C ' @M S v l/J-C  ) °  u8 +   ; E +
.(<) «Icš + ) S bc [L [j %˜+ ; 1
[Ç o ‡  ' aBF  "      V+ "* } /C
Q  S ;+   7 C 'C ]  "   'C  :+
."  +   lCA

.<³ = ¥ ?V+] aBs ?I; 8 + 9/ C›+  6"+ I; /   ; ‚  ?Cz s 9M 'N (<)

5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

wg  % "C 9˜ ˆ 9N 9 y'( z A, e^ct †/) "+


:$% M
.¸ ­8 “M E 3 j ³
.5  “M E 3 j ³
{ | e^ct a );3 :VX 3
ƒ › l)+ ; H¯  "   fN ­g f 'C +C a›W:+
:a›W: '+ l*  S . u "C; k /+ 'C; ' ; I !
' b1L ; È  Q ) @12 :+ :m) C V L T" r  (
:+ ‡E DK+ $N É 6 §N N Uc+ ?;  4   ‡E
 CH o M  ' 9.C+ I ! @   9."/C A 9:;+BC 'C 9˜ H
:m) C V C Q " †%
?‡ E " $4‹ V4c l)xH ?  ~k ! wg 1 )› (  ;+
' 0 K+ ?” 6  [F ' r / S  E  1 [L ' ; H ® Ê gaF
+ ; . ' [M ;+ () *+} ' 9.%G/ ?U4/ QË  + ‡E
‡E [L '%‡ ' ?D   ' (k E S)   +  e ' CBC ›
¬¦ ' i H 9˜ Š 9: % ' Œ ‹ “" S 9:+ ?®g +a F 'CO
l)g .I ! S "C; IG" ;  H l 6 | '* r  + 9." T ?"
I  ½C Â/E H l)] †E N / 9."  + [L g V   •E '
r ŠO 9." “6C r+ ?l" [‹ S 9: ' .6/C n C%/ E S
o ) Š ' M4 l T d1R N O:+ .I  "C l*G) I; /  ' '% C

#f!
(%!"#$   )           
.(<)"/  "L S C  + "/ I d () L
" ; H] 'C; ' I;  › ° L ŠO :[) H  H (3
?½C ;  › ' 1j †  fM + ÆCE  C %" :V H ?9.s /)
l*  /E QF4/ b•  ' I;  › •6N †   É ":  C  'u 4H
.(’) . % /C+ + ; E ' d1"C — "C
I;  › wg ; ŠO + ) )8 E 9z :+ :   7 : Ng (U
7M  :V H ? " . j+ ) )8 /1R 9.H S 'C a % '
0 CG" O: 7 ©  "+ . ) )8 /1R ' 0  H ... 'C a %
£ /F 2•L .Z )+ ?f1 ƒ T" 9 0 CG) • D– S ˜•
.(¬)3 J  I ‹  + "
 e^ct a );3 :X 2
  f1 WC 'C  + 'C  +C Q " a % ' ; 9:+
; H] $N+ %."N  RNC+ ?'C  + 'C ' +O DO+ ?; H¯  "
O: 3 j] ž‡  V ‹E C+H } /C+ . "  0›4 c N $N E
.“M E
:NG cA
† ] @1- *  C;]  9z M+ Q " [   9z :+

Jung, C.G. Psychology and Religion : West and East, p. ¬¬Ž.(<)


? T" N Q  ? Â/E N U4/ S  : Â/ ' Y1C  )8 ?  H ? [) H (’)
.<¦= ¥ ? :<Ž>’ ? <Ì ? 9  ; ? (C  ?  " (/2 »*
.Ž’ ¥ ? 7< = ?CE ˆ] 1  ?I:  ?'C D) H ; g ?Œ )8 T" 9 (¬)

5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

dM  N l j  )8 dRM $N+ I; /  $N C+H §NC+ .; H¯  "


COF ‹L c C2 ^) : V H ?Q »  CO: 'C ] «'C N+
 %1H . r [L o 1"C ? +] +/ dM  S * C2 ? +• /N+
"L –g ? lN j [L dRM ' N 4H ? i R* ›   "*  [/­ dM 
C61 0 "k  (/  ¨ ...   ' I N I; /   ¥©
lC 6* R N r] ' a % › wg+ . " I; /  $•* wg Ib1L ; •N
 » 0 ) CO: } /*  @­ C61  C;  V ! + . ( 'C ) dM  S c
.(<)(o " O: '
›+ ?[/ FBC+ ?dM  6C l)+ ? CO: 'C  C+H C %L
“  1/N C 'C g » : V H ? )8 .t 1C n I; /  ~
j _ lM2 ?  + ~ ) + ? d%s  †C –g ? D* 3 Z )› +
%M ƶ  l Rc 7 *+ . r] ‡  "E N z + I; /  wg V j 
l l%  OZ C m˜ O:+ ? ft N f.C 6* Q/M  r / I j lC 6* + I !
 2 3  I  N l 1* l 1xN ? 'C žC '%‹ O£+ . lC ¶+ [/ Fz
.(’) «Q »  CO: S f/» 9.FBN+  )
l ; M+ ?~R"E + dM  ' I/N O: C+H 0 +2  D ›+
9/ + dM  + ? y Q% " › O: a   "N+ ?T" a % ' b‹L
.(¬) .C

. ¬>³’ ¥ ¥ ? /R  ; ? 0+bN ? I ! S ~M ? C+H (<)


.¬¦³¬Ž ¥ ¥ ? /R  ; ? 0+bN ? I ! S ~M ? C+H (’)
.¬’³¬<¥ ?T" a %+ 748 a % $N Q4g  G" '  "  ?d" (¬)

#f<
(%!"#$   )           

d‡  Ibc] 0 "  S [¼ ˜ ­  " 0   d RE +


%/ @  ¨+ [N ? \+ 0  ; ' 7C %H 'C ) +  1 
l aQ V+ " * ~N  S '* r n + ?%/ 0 /%s ' * n
T" 9/ C] /%s O.H ?@) s O£ 9  0N 'C N M4
?T" 9/ Q"L] ~1R  + 'C :l) " 3 L ." C (APA)
@  lH † ? ( Shafranske ) Q )   ?7< h 7  D–+
.(<); H¯  "  S 'C +;+ « ) †  s /E l"C;
  I4   - N $-Nt $‹ 1 ' ; 7 M M+
Robbins, ) I; /  + I4 $N 1F  2 1* M4 +F H  "

; H¯  "  9* I4 + ?(Francis and Edwards, ’>>
 I4 N ­8  š DOL+ ?(Lewis, Breslin and Dein, ’>>)
.(’)(Breslin and Lewis, ’>> ) 
 : GA 'C  + 'C M4 V   ; $/1 d%Í d" 7 M
 ; ’Ž + 1"F  ; ’ ." ? "  0›4 c +  "
 / ¿ () L+ «C; /  S (CF Š |  ; < + N
? "  : G+ 'C  $N ¸ ­g Ì 1* wg b6*   D* mk "

Shafranske, Religion and the clinical practice of Psychology, < h.(<)


; Mental Health, Religion & Culture Lewis, Christopher, & Breslin, Michael- (’)
Jan’>>, Vol. << Issue <, p ³’<, <¬.
Edwards, Bethan Francis, Leslie and, Robbins, Mandy-
; Jan’>>, Vol. << Issue <, p ¬³ , =.Mental Health, Religion & Culture
Mental Health, , Dein, SimonBreslin, Michael and., Lewis, Christopher Alan
; Jan’>>, Vol. << Issue <, p<³=, =.Religion & Culture


5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

.(<) "  V4 c : G+ 'C  $N 5 Ì 1* +


S   +; ' C; /  S (CF 0  ; 0  %L
«:<Ž<<?ž ) k  N› E 342   ] 0  .E %"*
+ LW* mk "N (Fc+ (:<Ž<< ?4 «:<Ž<< ?Q  tE
  ] 0  .E %"* S   lN 7 C ŠO ¸ ­8
[  S      N c Y N 7 M %L .(’)34R
] LW* J "N Uc+ (:<Ž’¦ ?Q  tE ) / s 34R Q 
.(¬)/ s 34R Q  [     ! ¸ ­8
? ZE : GA 'C  $N M4/ ‡ + I j " $1 C ~1 —+
+ ; H¯  "    + ?   .° '+
: G ' /N+ ? "  ' V  A 9./ ¼+ ?9 Z
› + 'C 9 / N  B C › 'CO ; H] d f M Q " V4 c›
0 Cš ' b C ;/ 9.G  C +   0 C ' K  G
›  - ' l + v 3 N f % : + fj T/C › Ib   +
.; .] 7 C 7 C+ ?Îz} S+ ? ) S  )8 I   ¾

.:<Ž’h ?dN  + Y ‹ + Œ ‹ V  ?Q4g  G" '  "  ?d" (<)
7 / C; /  /%J Y ‹ Š "  a   \ '%‡ ?4 «Q  tE «ž (’)
.:<Ž<< ?† C ? " + C N 
DE / F & ?/ s E N Q  [  S     ?Q  tE (¬)
.=¥ :<Ž’¦ ?<o ?<=7 ?48 0   + C N  7 / :; /

#ff
(%!"#$   )           

:7  
? "      (+ "* n 0   I" fG)
:+  ZE : GA 'C  [%6  o ‡ E Ik ; d  Y 1 •J H
. "  .°+  )8 Z ' %. @) F 
+; ' CG)  N Y 1 7 M :(:<Ž<<) x'*   (!
Uc+ .k  N› E O4*   ] 0  .E %"* S  
9/*   $/C l) ."+ ?    1* E k  N ."
.(<)@ R IRH d fH  !  C %L ?Ia  L  ] 0  .E
+; ' 1R*  N Y 1 7 M :(:<Ž<<) } Zt   (#
k  N› E O4*  N  + Ia  0  . %"* S  
?X;  “ ' fO%* 'C6+ k  ' "/ () * .I "E "CE N
'  " + ?7 / 9/  X  ' $  ?X  dN  $z 
'  L+ . [L ' O%* $4 V/A   ¾ X 
O4* 9˜ M '  §     O4* V  mk " 9:
 + I+4  ¸ ­8 ]  V; — N  + Ia  S 7 / 9/ 
.(’)  O4* 0 C  

?k  N› E O4*   ] 0  .E %"* S   +; ?„ «ž (<)
.:<Ž<< ?† C ? " + C N  7 / C; /  /%J Y ‹ Š "  a   \ '%‡
O4*  N  + Ia  0  . %"* S   +; ?Ï H 'N / ?Q  tE (’)
C N  7 / C; /  /%J Y ‹ Š "  a   \ '%‡ ?I "E "CE S k  N› E
.:<Ž<< ?† C ? " +

5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

 $N M4/  N Y 1 7 M :(:<Ž<<) /Y,   (<


O4*  Ia  0  .E a ;] + l*+4*+   
' O%* <>> ' "/ () *+ .† C "CA Qk  N› X;  “
y Y 1 + .† C i6N   ¾ X  ' $ 
0 % ~R)  1 c + ?a+E 9.H  1 c :Q: 0  1 c› '  %&
?  ' ! 9L  1 c + ?C.s Ia  S M4R + [%s +
[j * n mk " 9: '+ .I+4  m." ' R I6/ I+4   1 c +
  O4    $N C M N ­g l2 1* M4 ; F+ .g
.(<)   + C.s Ia  ” . S 9: + l*+4*+
É   M4  N Y 1 7 M :(:<Ž<=) ,N   ("
" () * .† C "CA / s 342   "  N QM4c]
0 C E “ Ð '+ / F 0 L ' f/ F f1 2 hŽŽ '  
:Q: H/E 7  ' 7 M /N S (/» f¶ $4 '+ ? 
7 -M+ .C / 7 / + ?1R  7 / + ?CG" 7 / + ?6 7 /
 L+ . "  + QM4c] É -  X  $  ; xN Y 1
$N k g ›; 0 – N J-Cg 2 1-* M4 ; F+ :mk " 9: '
$N+ QM4c] É -  ; /N 0 F; d» DOL+ - F
0 " d»  - "  ; /N 0 F; d» DOL+  F

+ l*+4*+     $N M4/ 4R   ; ?  %| ?4 (<)
Y ‹ Š "  a   \ '%‡ ?Qk  N› X;  “ O4*  Ia  0  .E a ;]
.:<Ž<< ?† C ? " + C N  7 / C; /  /%J

#fi
(%!"#$   )           

.(<) 
 L–] + ;] +;  N ‹ 1 ( M :(7< >) (Q   (f
3  l ‡ —  L+ .½C Q " U4/ i2 •L ~ U4 S
0 1 2 ' 1 2 <Ž '   " () *+ .~ U4 S 
?   žC ~ X  '. (12+ ?A I "E N N  L
?X E 0 F;   ' '— µ’=  ~1R  /N 0 c +
f& )N Ibc] "/  ‹ 1 (12+ .1 2 'C6 "/ ; ž1j+
%  (  ' 0 C Ia M l"%‡ [cC+) ~ f4g fF4
'  L+ .M; h> I   s I+ ?. /N    F <h
fk g V ; iN ƹ   "  ~   :mk " 9:
.(’)QF4/ m )} ' a . )› /N
  o º  Y 1 X; :(:<Ž<h) J Q,   (~
 z  1 2 <¬> ' "/ () *+ .Q " ']  
RN   %P + ? 1 2 =¬ ' () *+ 1CJ   %P :$  %&
 %P (/c .¸;] + Q%/ $ ' $  %P + 1 2 ¦= :;
Ž¦  F [L I+ ? F <’      o %  1CJ 
a . ) /N mk " 9:+ .1C· s / Š] RN   %P d¶ r+ ?M;

 L;   ?Q48  G"E '  "  N l M4+ QM4c] É   ?0 C+ (<)


.:<Ž<= ?48 ; / 'N %| 7 8 / F T" 9 9 M ?I 6" bƒ
Š "  ¼WE ?½C Q " U4/ i2 •L ~ U4 S  L–] + ;] +; ? "1 (’)
.¦<¥ ?7< > ? " 0   CE /%J X; 

5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

S bt   F++ $  %P  Q " ']  X M ´ 0 s


?RN   %P  l"  1CJ   %P  Q " '] 
.(<)Q " ']   ¸ ­8    $1C —
l M4+ ½C 7 B ›  N Y 1 7 M :(:<Ž<) €   (i
N  L 342 ' f1 2 ’¬Ž '   " () *+ . "  N
7 M . Ð  ; 0 ¶+ 0 C  '+ a ] N [H DE / Í
C2 ; g ' C; /  K1 S ½C 7 B › X  7 Z  N Y 1
 ; g ' C; /  K1 S 3 16  "  X + ?/C 6
 ; 2 1* M4 ; F+ ?mk " 9: () L+ .74  1 i+ H+ Q
.(’) "  ; /N+ ½C 7 B › $N fk g
” O 'C  V   N Y 1 7 M :(Shah, ’>>Ž) ‚ [   (
X E S $: E  QM4c] É   S °+ ½C   “M +
%/ S ŠB  ~:  k  ' "/ () *+ . CB  S "C bƒ+ "C
I A 0 ) 1 d» ´+ . . "N X E  $z  " <=³<¦ $N 
'+ . K1/ N   ~t +G S 9y ( a Nš + ?X E S $E
 L ” O 'C   mk " 9: '  L+ .9:;›+ d -E wg ; g `

'%‡ N   ; ?Q " ']     o º  ?„ @" ?v 1 (<)
/ F & .9 E  Q " '] ~¾ S    : ˜ "+ Q  tE /  ;
.:<Ž’ ?T _ ;/ ( % F› + ) )8 7 / ) 48 ; / 'N %| 7 8
DE / F ?I 6" bƒ b F    ? "  N l M4+ ½C 7 B › ?Á¿ (’)
.:<Ž< ?a › ?[H

#f$
(%!"#$   )           
.(<)$: E  QM4c] É      WE
    N Y 1 7 M :(:<Ž’¦) } Zt   ($
f1 2 $/N ' "/ () *+ ./ s E N Q  [   
?I "E "CE N 48 / s N 'C V j+ I  L S  C
mk " 9:+ .$GH  bƒ cš “" + ?f4 L    G 9.)
bƒ 34R 0 F; §  '  $GH ! 34R 0 F; §  
S k g -›; 0 – i+H ; F++ .f-k g  ; T '+ ?$GH !
.(’)  $GH ! 34R Ï  (Q  [  ) Q%L   V/E
$/1     ; [%/N Y 1 7 M :(:<Ž’h) 5(*   (!ƒ
.C; / |  ; <+ N  ; ’Ž+ 1"F  ; ’ ." ? ;
. y4 c +  "  : G+ 'C  $N M4/ 0   O: S (;
Uc n  / J- " + . 0 M4/ 0    Ð T-C  (Z  +
: G+ 'C-  $N 1F  2 1-* M4 ; F+ LW* Y 1 .-N
 V4 -c : G+ 'C  $N @ - Ì 1* DOL+ ?  " 
.(¬) "
 V  CG) - N Y 1 7 M : (:<Ž’) } Zt   (!!

Ashiq Ali Shah, Education in the Moral Behaviour of Adolescents (<)


Self-Religiosity, Father’s Attitude and Religious, Psychology Developing Societies
’>>Ž; <h; <=.
& ./ s E N Q  [  S     .Ï H 'N / ?Q  tE (’)
.=¥ ?< ;/ ?<= P (48 0   + C N  7 / ) ; / DE / F
.:<Ž’h ?dN  + Y ‹ + Œ ‹ V  ?Q4g  G" '  "  ?d" (¬)

5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

Q  ¥ ) V4c ' ?9 E  Q " '] ~¾ S  


—+ .$% E a % 74L ' DOL+ ?C 1" "  +   '
" ) )8 T" S ¸ ­8   b•* :  ' lN Uc
.(<)$% E  l º + l*+4*
ROBBINS, FRANCIS AND )  3 y G „@(7   (!#
.I; /  + I4 $N Ì 1*›  N  ‹ 1 7 M : EDWARDS, ’>>)
.  ˆ N BC+ /2  S / s 342 ' f1 2 <¬<' "/ () *+
.I4  + Z6 + I; /  X  TC  4 9. ~12+
.(’)I; /  + I4   $N ¸ ­g Ì 1*  .€ mk " 9: () L+
LEWIS, BRESLIN AND DEIN, ) 9N I 7 yNc   (!<
 "  N I4 M4 V     N  ‹ 1 7 M : (’>>
V + ?Q  /F  Y\ :' )   \  %& /F  Y
 C  ' $‹ 1 .L ?@ L  + ?1R*  \ ) ^+ ?ŠbG"*
I4 X   Ð TC   1 D* (Z  . C+ ) RCN+
D* 9. (CF 'CO 0 KH ( "* %L ? "  X  DOL+
 ‹ 1 £ Uc n  / J " + .  ZE d% P 0 12 ' 0  

'N %| 7 8 / F & .9 E  Q " '] ~¾ S    ?Q  tE (<)
.:<Ž’ ?T _ ;/ ( % F› + ) )8 7 / ) 48 ; /
Edwards, Prayer, personality and Francis, Leslie and, Robbins, Mandy(’)
happiness: A study among undergraduate students in Wales. Bethan
; Jan’>>, Vol. << Issue <, p ¬³ , =.Mental Health, Religion & Culture

#~!
(%!"#$   )           
.(<); H¯  "  9; S I4  °] LW*
7 M : (BRESLIN AND LEWIS, ’>>) yNc  I 7   (!"
 ; ~C2 ' D–+ .  I4 1CJ   š  N  ‹ 1
% ¿ @ ] H/E+ ?I4 T) 9/N % C  S (CF n  1
 I4 b• N   (Fc+ .; H¯  "  I4 9
: ."  "  @ •N 
.j 0 L  S DOL ÌZ"C QC ŠO ²Z6 ³<
. 046E ' 1 )› j  0  A I4 ³’
.l8 [c* V4c '  9* I4 ³¬
.; H]  "  0 M R 9* I4 ³Ž
.(’); H] $N ž  [. * n Q  I+ m "* I4 ³¦
:7   +, wB
:QC A U¹ N  0   † /  V4c '
.1R* 0  ;+ CG) 0  ; $N 0   ( "* (<
9/  342+ 7 / 9/  342 $N 0   0 " ( "* (’
. )8 +  LO ' Q/ s

, Prayer and mental Dein, SimonBreslin, Michael and., Lewis, Christopher Alan(<)
health: An introduction to this special issue of Mental Health, Religion & Culture.
; Jan’>>, Vol. << Issue <, p<³=, =.Mental Health, Religion & Culture
Theoretical models of the nature of Lewis, Christopher, & Breslin, Michael(’)
; Jan’>>, Vol. << Mental Health, Religion & Cultureprayer and health: A review.
Issue <, p ³’<, <¬.


5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

     X  Z E TC E ( "* (¬


. "   0 ; 1/ +  u8  + ? "
 u¢ ¸ ­8 ] LW* 0   mk "  / ¿ () L (Ž
0› & ' b‹L  j c I N    +   I N l) L+
. " l j + Q " l" +    )8 I 
'  !   lg / *  d 0   9G/ mk ) ~ * (¦
. "   ¸ ­8   
:  G
mk ) lN (Fc + ?ŠG"  28 S l+ "* ´  V4c '
:QC %L  !   †+H ƒ j 'u N  0  
   o * $N fk g  ; 1F  Ì 1* M4 F * (<
.  n"   "   o * +  
 %& $N  "   S fk g  ; i+H F C (’
0 1 2+ 342 Ï  / s 0 1 2+ 342+ ./E 0 1 2+ 342
../E
 %& $N  "   S fk g  ; i+H F C (¬
../E 342 Ï  / s 342+ ./E 342
 %& $N  "   S fk g  ; i+H F C (Ž
../E 0 1 2 Ï  / s 0 1 2+ ./E 0 1 2
S 0 1 R + 34R $N  "   S i+H F * › (¦
. $  %P
#~<
(%!"#$   )           

' $ "/ ; H $N  "   S i+H F * › (h


.Q  E Y
' $ "/ ; H $N  "   S i+H F * › (=
. "s Y
' $ "/ ; H $N  "   S i+H F * › (
.%/ Y
:  (, 5AM
E S  C 'CO 0 1 R + 34R 9:   d% &
' () *   "+ .C; /  N/ %E S IF "C S Q/ s
: ° $  %&
0   52 6 7 8 ./ 0 1 2+ 342 :†q ,cA‡
34R  ÑN+ .IÍ     Cb_ /%J dN  )
.1 2+ f1 2 <=> o %P   «1 2 Ž 0 1 R + ?f1 2 <’’
; ÑN+ .IÍ BCB/ 1 DE / F 0 1 2+ 342 : ` ,cA‡
.1 2+ f1 2 <=> o %P   «1 2 ¬Ž 0 1 R + ?f1 2 <¬h 34R
.1 2+ f1 2 ¬Ž>   n"/ Q o %P  C O£+
:   
." †t  "  X E C 1 j S 0 ) N (/‡+ `
H/E DOL+ ?  0 " ²k c S +] 0  /E  V !
aBF ' [M  :+  Ò; ' aÓ N   ' !  


5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

X   .4
f  L    :+  •N aÓ . ) + ? +
.  I S lN /"H  " 
:'( )*  
C " 0F+ n + T" 9 S  y 0  ‡ E '  " 
n 0 C t ' ˜] ? " 0   (H O" $‹ 1 ' 7 % : +
0‹H . M o ‡   D– T/) DO+ ? )g [L .g ž%RC
~H  TC  '%‡ ("j M+ ? "  X   ‡ E TC E
.° ' f  'C6+   ~ _ 1 ." ;+ M+ ? "  +
l»* X E O: T)+?4 „ »*  E  /)› ")•%R X 
.  "  X  9 N U ! Bk H
 l1 ƒ S ½1 “•* + 0 »* ' I 1 TC E O: [L '+
 Q4g  *  "1 (  DO+ .N  TC  ' [)
lM Q4g  G" '  "  X E QC %H †/"+ . "
:QC  l" T1 )+ ?(:<Ž<=)  L l   S 0 C+
:  [ E N  t r%  ,8 
mn(   ,8 :†q 1t
%L ? "  T" 9 X  zN 9:  Y 1 dF 
; /* n CG" 2] + .C /* V  a š + 0 CG" ' f; ÁM )
.V P O: S @ )] : (Q V %L) U– Å  wg [j * M+ ? .g
~H  .H 9 C n  ! : ˜   "  (Q) /C Y

#~f
(%!"#$   )           

/1 + Q+ + ½C /1 Q:+  k ; /N /N V4c ' ; Q "
d “C/  O: Y 1 Â1* M+ .Q% s /1 + Q % F› /1 + Q "
 C ¨ ? ; /N]  %E Qk F8 “C/  S “2 [C/*
:Q: ; /N] O:+ .; /N] D* X M ."u k Fg 0  1 + ; "N ƒ j
:'% C+ ½C /1 (!)
. + bc  + cš 7  + l+ l1 L+ l k4+ v N  u8 ³
[H " + (†+ ) 0 1F  a ; '% C ŠO + ½C É   ³3
LO +  Ia M+ 0 Mj+ I%+ m+ I Lz+ 7 j+ I4j ' "C
.[F+ B v wg 3 o ) ' D– bƒ+ a  +
?l + YC! + b   L 6 7 / 9/* wg b6*+ H/E ³U
.6  /E + 7 / ¨6N 48 H ‹ %"*+
:'% C+ Q " /1 (#)
+ ® /)  B*g  .€g Š (Emotional security) ® /)› '] ³
.; N §¿ dM  %k4 [/H ;+;+ @ " Q2  0 1
7 .  V ! lN C+ (Self-concept) 0 O 7 . ³3
. . %"*  [%/ + .1+ 0 O [1 L ¸ ­g 0 –
'Ccš C )+ 0 O IM © ª   IG" lN C+ Vª   ³U
.[1 E  +
:'% C+ Q % F› /1 (<)
.l 9.1*+ 'CcÔ ; [1* ½/C+ Q % F› V 1 ³


5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

[ /   I Š (Social interaction)


Q % F› [   ³3
. % F› 0 1 "E V  ¨ S 'Ccš d
Ò;] ! H * £ C+ (Social skills)  % F› 0  .E ³U
N ­8 Z6 0 %  + 3;] + M  + M 1 L  % F› 0  .E '
.7 J ) + ~H N 'Ccš d [ /  ' ; '¼ n
:'% C+ Q% s /1 (")
C; / )1 0 2 6" a ;  I lN C+ Q% s Ì 6" ³
.d% P + [%/ + VB-"E S
H ¾ n _ )1 'C %  Æ/N  — ½/*+ )1 M  ³3
.)1 M  ' Ò;] ! 
l-N 9 .C+ l1 C ¸ J-Cg (Body concept) Q% F 7 . ³U
.l j+ l 4  GH ¿ N+
 t c(7  ,8 : ` 1t
 TC  ' f; Y 1 dR  N  ; /N] a ‡ 
` ... . ) H N  % F›  " TC E + Z6 TC +  "
?/N]  "  ; /N ' /N [ (I 1) f"N 'C6 ƒ j ´
n 9: % f"%  ?; /N] O: ' /N [ Qk F8 “C/  ;+
0  1/ (/‡+ ` .X E O: ; g ' w+] E S :L– ~1
* M+ ... $%¿  †/ (%%j j c ) 1  S .C /*+
.%¿ 0 ) 1 › ' 6 Y 1
:QC  $%¿ 0 .F * 9: () L+
#~i
(%!"#$   )           

V 2  9." b‹  Y ?D– '  ; "1 ;   c (<)


‹— bƒ 0 N J  a Rg ®  N+ ?$j E [ S @1  X E
.! 9 .F 
. . ) I 1/ V 2 b* (’)
.0  1/ Æ/1 C " + C t ƒ  [C/* (¬)
Æ/N [C ¾ + ?L– — ‹L 1 0  1 + ; "N H ‡g (Ž)
?$j E 0 N J  S o "   % 1 wg N ­8 0  1/
N ƒE N %¿ 0 N J › + R%" 0 N J › ' 3+y +
. % F›
?ÆtN+ @ + / [‹ ·›    0 b1/  ; /1  (¦)
. .£  +  + [H+ @­ [‹ ' 0 b1/ N ." ‡ / › +
: t +, I;c)'t 7 M
.H+ ?$j E N J  C  0 C2 Y 1 7Z 
/1  M+ ?i428  H E 7 wg   H E ' N J › U *
I; CBN l" † /  + ?Y1 C › l)  1   Š; !  _ Y 1
"N [L  ¥ E FH ?0  c   wg [* Y\ 0  _ ;
S f ¼ ~H   _ 0 F; (h) ?0 F; ( wg I + F; ' ‚+  *
?@F E "1 fR ~H  bƒ  Z (<) %"N ?@F E "1  
.1  ; "1 1 " N žj T/ +


5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

q  t   :` ` 1t


 X E +] I  Y 1  N  0 a F8  aÓ "N
 ; /N ' /N [ I 1 'C6 dM N f"N > ' f)   "
0 ) 1 j wg H ‡8 N ?X E ." “• C n /N]  "
' f1 2 <’> ' )  "  I  O: ~1R* ´ M+ .Z6
;  o % F› + T" 9 Q% M '  % F› 7 / L 342
0 1+ i Qk 8 [  S .Z  ) 1  ¬ 9." Y 1
T"s + '  Y '  ]   "/ £ 6 "/ O:+ ?X E
Qk1E @CJ  : E O: S ~1R  ' y + ?Q%/  E+
IM + ?$j E  l ‡++ l%.H  ' ~  + X %
/N+ . "  '  ZE 0 C E $N B%   . ) ; "1
. Y 1 F .g  6E "/  X E ' +] I  ~1R*
.z4 k 8 04 
´ H ?X E V 2 ' $%¿ 0 j  fG) :X E   c
 %_  N+ ?X E ; /N ' /N [L ' ; "N  e ; ; /1 
.lg Q% "* ŠO  "  /1N Ì 1*› C  ; "1 ' f"N 6
.§H f"N h>  % 6 X % k ." I  (Fc DON+
 A ˆ *1 z p :7  1t
3 ! 7Z  + .0 1‹ + i 04 / 3 \ Y 1 7 M Y
:QC  i

#~$
(%!"#$   )           

l 1M 9  µ> $%| i * 1 ) "N [ d‡++ :$%¿ ij ³


.$%¿ i * ' µ<>> wg µ > $N  ; "1 d» 1 ) (j+ M+
; "1 $N Ì 1*› [ / 3 \ D–+ :Qc  i *› ij ³
DOL+ ? F d ; /N] Ì 1* DOL+ ? y Q% "* n ; /N] +
I  S ; "1 ( M+ ?X %  F d "N [L Ì 1*
.  Ì 1* 0 F;  X % k ."
:X E 0 1 U Z ›   iR Y 1 7Z  +
() L /N [+ ?>, Q  H Î 1)+L  CRN 0 1‹ ³
Q% s + ?>,ŽŽ Q % F› + ?>,h Q " + ?>,¦ ½C :QC %L
. >,=
H ‡g >,=> : $kBs $N Ì 1*› [ /  H :" kBJ  ³
; "1 + ?>,’  % "F ; /+ ?>,’ + N ³  b1 [ / wg
.>,== F+B ; "1+ >,¬ C;
4 $* S L–  . ~12+ :X %  k ; /N] 0 1 ³
.(<) (~E S X E G))IF 0 1 04 /  /N] ; /N] (+
  wQjB z p8
7 M+ ?lZ ) ´ ?l+ S +] 0 ) 1 j H ‡xN X E ; g /N
7 M %L ?./E 0 1 2+ 342  l1R N $ "s ' ./E IO* 

 L;   ?Q48  G"E '  "  N l M4+ QM4c] É   ?0 C+ (<)


.:<Ž<= ?48 ; / 'N %| 7 8 / F T" 9 9 M ?I 6" bƒ
 
5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

 X E ~1R N $ "s ' BCB/ 1 DE / F IO*  '  %&
./ s 0 1 2+ 342 '  %&
wg Œ ‹ Q  [ C ˜ ' I  V4c $ "/  ~1R  ´+
dCz * ´ Y .(<):<Ž’ /:<Ž’ Q/ s 7 / ' Q [ C N
<=> ." ) 1  ¬Ž> d» ´+ ?  n"  ) 1  Ž>> N M
/ F 0 1 2+ 342 "/ ) 1  <=>+ ?./E 0 1 2+ 342 "/
.BCB/ 1 DE
?%/  .s Q: + 0 bt   e  ) 1  [L Š ¾+
 ' !  + ?T"s + ?%/ + ? "s + ?Q  E+
:; Ñ 1  "  X  0  1 0 bt E O: /N ”•C+ .
7 Z  N $Z E $‹ 1  R N [  % (¼+ .I 1 h>
.(’)(SPSS) k 8 s /E m )N

X E Ö "N 9.  52 6 7 8 ./  $%k   [CBF 7C  Y 1 ; C (<)
DE / F 0 1 2+ 342  l1R* /N  DOL+ ?./E 0 1 2+ 342  l1R* /N +
52 6 7 8 ./ & C¾ K: ' 9;+ I; 1A 0a F   O:  L+ .BCB/ 1
.) 0  
7 / N T" 9 9 N a 8 –  74  1 ‚4 † /  L Y 1 6C (’)
.k g . s /+   0 ) N V c;xN l  48 ; / 'N %| 7 8 / Í  % F›

#i!
(%!"#$   )           

%D'B   hˆ M K‰
:  (, =ˆ *E :VX 3
:  ‹ y(Š  Q(   (!
:(<) 9M V+s wg G" V4c ' . H/ 'u+
(<) 9M V+s
o %P 1 " 0 1 2 1 " 342 o "
"/
<=> µ’ Ž µ=’ <’’ 52 6 7 8 ./
<=> µ’> ¬Ž µ> <¬h BCB/ 1 DE / F
¬Ž> µ’Ž ’ µ=h ’¦ o %P

<’’ (tN ./E 342 "  (<) 9M V+s ' ž C+


' µ’ 1 "N 1 2 Ž (tN 0 1 R " %"N ? µ=’ 1 "N f1 2
(tN BCB/ 1 DE / F 342 "+ ../E 0 1 2+ 342 "
1 "N 1 2 ¬Ž 0 1 R ; (tN %"N ?µ> 1 "N f1 2 <¬h
ÑN T"s bt  S+ .  n" $N ;/ S 3   ž C+ µ’>
; ÑN %"N ?µ=h 1 "N ’¦ / s + ./E n" S 34R ;
' %G/ 1 t  T/C O:+ ?µ’Ž 1 "N 1 2 ’ 0 1 R
. LO ' 9: $ "/

:  Œ( }  cMt (#
:(’) 9M V+s wg G" V4c ' . H/ 'u+
 
5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

(’) 9M V+s


µ 0 1 2 µ 342 µ 0 1 2 µ 342 o "
/ F / F ./ ./ Q ; 7
³ ³ <’,¦ <= ’,< < Ž,< ¦ V+]
’, < , <’ ¬¦,Ž <= <’,¬ <¦ Œ ‹
¬,’ <¬ ’,’ ¬ ³ ³ Ž, h Y ‹
ŽŽ,’ <¦ ’,’ ¬ h’,¦ ¬> ’Ž,h ¬> dN 
¦, ’ ¦,  ³ ³ <’,¬ <¦ T _
³ ³ <’,¦ <= ³ ³ ’,¦ ¬ X; 
¦, ’ <=,= ’Ž ³ ³ ’,¦ ¬ dN 
’, < ¬,’ ¦’ ³ ³ ¬h, Ž¦ ' ‹
µ<>> ¬Ž µ<>> <¬h µ<>> Ž µ<>> <’’ o %P
S ./E 342 " BL* (’) 9M V+s wg G" ' ž C+
%"N ?µh<,¦ :  /%& 1 "N (¬h, ) ' ‹ + (’Ž,h) dN  $C E
(¬,’) ' ‹ + (<=,=) dN  $C E S 0BL* / s 342 " S
.$ "/ S 1 ) •N ' ‹ E QG+ µ¦¦, :  /%& 1 "N
Œ ‹ $C E S BL* ./E 0 1 2  () L 0 1 R " S %"N
0 1 2 " S+ .µ =, :  /%& 1 "N (h’,¦) dN  + (¬¦,Ž)
/%& 1 "N (ŽŽ,’) dN  + (¬,’) Y ‹ $C E S BL* / s
 dN  E V  0 1 R "  4C+ ?µ’,Ž : 
./E n"  0 C E  dCz   $1 C+ .$  %P S 1 ) 
?' ‹ E S 34R  %& S 1- )   L+ ?3   / s +
 0 W O: [L+ .dN  E S 1 )   L 0 1 R  %"N

#i<
(%!"#$   )           
.  n %&  T) J 
:(¬) 9M V+s wg G" V4c ' . H/ 'u+ :(Š (<
(¬) 9M V+s
µ 0 1 2 µ 342 µ 0 1 2 µ 342 o "
/ F / F ./ ./  "s
=,< ¬¬ ,¬ <¬¦ ’=, ¦ ¬h, Ž¦ Š; /
’, < - - - - <,h ’ Œ LN
- - >,= < h< << ’’,< ’= ½u
- - - - - - h,h  Œ; 
- - - - - - Ž,< ¦ ® j
- - - - - - <<,¦ <Ž Š; 6*
- - - - - - =,Ž Š
- - - - - - >, < Œ tH
- - - - - - <,h ’ Š Cg
- - - - - - >, < ® t"
- - - - - - <,h ’ ¸ 
- - - - - - >, < Œ B-"*
- - - - - - >, < ŠbJ)
- - - - ¦,h < >, < ½R H
- - - - ¦,h < <,h ’ Š 
- - - - - - >, < ® t"N
%<>> ¬Ž %<>> <¬h %<>> < %<>> <’’ o %&
1 t  6C $C; /   (¬) 9M V+s wg G" ' ž C+
1 )+ ./E 342 ' ¬h, 1 ) ‹ Y ?  n" S Q%G/
 
5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

0 1 2 ' ’=, 1 ) '‹ 0 1 R " S+ ?/ s 342 ' ,¬


1 ) Q: 1 t O: ' O ŠO + ./ s 0 1 2 ' =,< 1 )+ ./E
I  + .µh< 1 "N ./E 0 1 2 1 ƒ ' Y 0 "% 0 1 R
0 1 2 " S   ?  n" S 3   T) · : G*  "J  /
.':bƒ  0 "% 0 1 R 1 ) (t2 Y ./E
:(Ž) 9M V+s wg G" V4c ' . H/ 'u+ :NA Ž' ("
(Ž) 9M V+s
µ 0 1 2 µ 342 µ 0 1 2 µ 342 o "
/ F / F ./ ./ K
’¬,¦  <Ž < ’,< < <,h ’ < ³<=
=>,h ’Ž <¬,’ < h>,Ž ’ <Ž, < ’’³’>
¦, ’ <Ž,= ’> ,¬ Ž <h,Ž ’> ’¦³’¬
³ ³ ¦,< = ’ ,¬ <Ž h=,’ ’ ‹L•H’h
<>> ¬Ž <>> <¬h <>> Ž <>> <’’ o %&
K S $ "/ S 34R 1 ƒ  (Ž) 9M V+s wg G" ' ž C
342 + µh=,’ ./E 342  1 " (tN Y ‹L•H’h C%/
C%/ K S } 1 " () H 0 1 R " S %"N .µ¦,< / s
/ s 0 1 2 + µh>,Ž ./E 0 1 2 "  (tN Y ’’³’>
C%/ 0 K S 3 *+ T) J-* T/* @- " + 7 M] O:+ .µ=>,h
.  0 "/
wg G" V4c ' l H/ 'u+ :-. / 9 0'  (f
:(¦) 9M V+s

#if
(%!"#$   )           
(¦) 9M V+s
µ 0 1 2 µ 342 µ 0 1 2 µ 342 o "
/ F / F ./ ./ !  

¦¦, < ¦ ,h < ³ ³ ’,¦ ¬ aBF ' [M

¬’,¬ << ¬>, Ž’ <>,Ž ¦ ¦,= = ¦³<


³ ³ Ž,Ž h ³ ³ <,Ž ¦ <>³h
³ ³ <,¦ ’ ’,< < ¬,¬ Ž <¦³<<
³ ³ >, < ³ ³ <,h ’ ’>³<h
¬ < ³ ³ ³ ³ < < ’¦³’<
³ ³ ³ ³ ’,< < < < ’ ³’h
, ¬ ’, Ž ¦,Ž Ž< =h,’ ¬ 4
f  L 

<>> ¬Ž <¬h <>> Ž <>> <’’ o %P

$N !   S b1 0+   (¦) 9M V+s wg G" ' ž C


() L Y ?/ s 0 1 2+ 342 "/N )  ./E 0 1 2+ 342 "
(µ=h,’) 4 f  L    S ./E 342  } 1 "
%"N .(µ¦,Ž) 4f  L    S ./E 0 1 2  DOL+
S } 1 " () L Y T/ () L / s 0 1 2+ 342 " S
/ s 342  1 " () L Y ?aBF ' [M  V+] E
+ @ " + 7 M] O:+ .(µ¦¦, ) / s 0 1 2 + ?(¦ ,h¦)
 S $Z E ' 9: ./E 0 1 2+ 342   /12 () L
j c) †+ Æ/N j  1 c " Ib1L FN "%.C O:  ›g ?
. "       ½1E (Œ ‹ †

 
5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

ˆ M ^ (   G QME :X 2


o * $N fk g  ; 1F  Ì 1* M4 F * :bq ' (!
n"   "   o * +     
. 
 bN Ì 1* [ / 7 Z  ´ † O: j  1 c›+
.l ›;+ Ì 1*›   (h) 9M V+s $1C+ . . ›; + M4/ H/E

(h) 9M V+s


)* cM  'B  / 0'1   'B I7 ?MV  QB V A^
'(
>, ’ Ì 1*› %M
>,>>< k 8 › %M
fk g  ; ›

V+] † j ~¾ (h) 9M V+s S G" V4c ' ž C
     o * $N 1F E 2 1*› M4/ 0F+ Y
0 1 2+ 342 '   n"   "   o * +
" › %M () L+ ?BCB/ 1 DE / F+ 52 6 7 8 ./
 S I;  ! [‹¼ J " O:+ .›   %M Q:+ >,>><
 v u t{ :w /* v V M H ?% E T"   ' 
.[’ :a 8 ] z ¢ ¡  ~ } |{ z y x w

#ii
(%!"#$   )           

' 3  S  @:OC Š» :Cš O: b * S b‹L 'N V M


.lL D– ' Q6C  H ?[+ ÑCz+ Ɂ+ ?i )+ D ' ?† 
›+ .(<) «lH 1ƒ + b_ @2+ %! +  u8 .H [ „ fC :+
ŠO ?w /*+ l) 1 v 74L : lZ*+  u8 9k ; 9: '  D
  "  0 4 .G*+ + ‚6"*+ 3  'K%R* lN
J " d † O: J ) ~ *+ .l  ~1R*+ l*+4  7z4E + lGH 
fj c+ ? .‡ ~1 n N  0   9G/ £ Uc n  /
 o %  ¸ ­8 ] 0L n + (:<Ž<h ?v 1 )  ; J )
.  "  Q " ']   
 "   S fk g  ; i+H F C :‘ ` ' (#
342 Ï  / s 0 1 2+ 342+ ./E 0 1 2+ 342  %& $N
../E 0 1 2+
n  !   Q ] †t ' ~  lN M † O:+
M+ . "      ! ¸ ­8 ] LW*
%L S b1 i  $1*   0 " ²k c † " " ~1
E S %G/ 9. 1 ƒ  L Y ./E 0 1 2+ 342 $N !
() L / s 0 1 2+ 342 %"N ?f4 L    :+ ]
j  1 c›+ .aBF ' [M  :+ Ò;] E S %G/ 9. 1 ƒ
. . ›;+ i+   (0)  1 c 7 Z  ´ †

.<<’¥ ?T _ aBs ?9G/  b * ?b‹L 'N (<)


 
5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

(=) 9M V+s


I7 '( )* cM ’ ˆ *18 V “G cp  QME
 Š Q  aY (, t Q  aY (,
› (0) %M  ©› § E ;/ n"
Š /E  
>,>>< ’, Ž <,  =,’¬ <=> ./E "
<,Ž< <=> / s "
Œ ‹ † j ~¾ (=) 9M V+s wg G" V4c ' ž C
 "   S ./E 0 1 2+ 342 "  § E Y
%L ?<,Ž< : / s 0 1 2+ 342 "  § E %"N =,’¬ :
342 Ï  k g ›; 0 – i+H ; F+ 0.€ (0)  1 c %M 
. "   S ./E 0 1 2+
 H/E (/ n  !   : ~¾ LW* J " O:+
342 ] ? "         o *
  S / s 0 1 2+ 342 ' 9.k G) b‹N  M C ./E 0 1 2+
f M 9.C  "   o *  D– T/) + ?!
mk ) 9G/ lN (Fc  d ~ * J " O:+ ./ s S 9.k G"N
(  l  ŠO )  u8 o *› ¸ ­8 ] S ?N  0  
. "   o * 
 S fk g  ; i+H F C l)  ²"C+ :g ` ' (<
../E 342 Ï  / s 342+ ./E 342  %& $N  " 

#i$
(%!"#$   )           
. . ›;+ i+   (0)  1 c 7 Z  ´ † j  1 c›+
() 9M V+s
I7 '( )* cM ’ ˆ *18 V “G cp  QME
 Š aY (, t aY (,
› (0) %M  ©› § E ;/ n"
Š /E  
>,>>< ’,¦< ’,¬< =,<Ž <’’ ./E "
<,¬h <¬h / s "
Y ‹ † j ~¾ () 9M V+s wg G" V4c ' ž C
=,<Ž :  "   S ./E 342 "  § E Y
(0)  1 c %M  %L ?<,¬h : / s 342 "  § E %"N
 S ./E 342 Ï  k g ›; 0 – i+H ; F+ 0.€
. " 
o *  H/E (/ n  !   : ~¾ LW* J " O:+
./E 342 ] ? "        
V+J "/F H?!   S / s 342 ' 9.k G) b‹N  M C
%"N 4
f  L   G µ=h,’ 1 ) ./E 342  )F  (¦) 9M
 o *  D– T/) + .µ’, Q: / s 342 " S ™ !
 d ~ * J " O:+ ./ s S 9.k G"N f M 9.C  " 
 u8 o *› ¸ ­8 ] S ?N  0   mk ) 9G/ lN (Fc
 "   o *  (  l  ŠO ) 9 E ;
.lC

5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

 S fk g  ; i+H F C l)  ²"C+ :57  ' ("


0 1 2 Ï  / s 0 1 2+ ./E 0 1 2  %& $N  " 
../E
. . ›;+ i+   (0)  1 c 7 Z  ´ † j  1 c›+
( ) 9M V+s
'( )* cM ’ ˆ *18 V “G cp  QME
 Š Q  (, t Q  (, I7
› (0) %M  ©› § E ;/ n"
Š /E  
>,>>< ¬,Ž¦ <,=< =,>< Ž "
./E
<,<< ¬Ž "
/ s
dN  † j ~¾ ( ) 9M V+s wg G" V4c ' ž C
=,>< :  "   S ./E 0 1 2 "  § E Y
(0)  1 c %M  %L ?<,<< : / s 0 1 2 "  § E %"N
S ./E 0 1 2 Ï  k g /* ›; 0 – i+H ; F+ 0.€
. "  
o *  H/E (/ n  !   : ~¾ LW* J " O:+
./E 0 1 2 ] ? "        
V+J "/F H?!   S / s 0 1 2 ' ' bG) b‹N 'C
%"N 4
f  L  'G µ¦,Ž 1 ) ./E 0 1 2  )F  (¦) 9M

#!
(%!"#$   )           
o *  D– T/) + .µ, Q: / s 0 1 2 " S 0 GH !
d ~ * J " O:+ ./ s S ' G"N f M '.C  "  
 u8 o *› ¸ ­8 ] S ?N  0   mk ) 9G/ lN (Fc 
 "   o *  (  l  ŠO ) % E 
. .C
  S i+H F * › l)  ²"C :y ” ' (f
.$  %P S 0 1 R + 34R $N  "
. . ›;+ i+   (0)  1 c 7 Z  ´ † j  1 c›+
(<>) 9M V+s
'( )* cM ’ ˆ *18 V “G cp  QME
 Š  t Œ(, ’ Q j  aYj I7
› (0) %M  ©› § E ;/   n"
Š /E
>,’¬ >,<¬ >,> Ž,’¦ ’¦ 34R "
Ž,>h ’ 0 1 R "
T _ † j ~¾ (<>) 9M V+s wg G" V4c ' ž C
%"N Ž,’¦ :  "   S 34R "  § E Y
%L ?fF Ib1L FN N   Q:+ ?Ž,>h : 0 1 R "  § E
34R $N k g ›; 0 – i+H ; F+ 7 0.€ (0)  1 c %M 
. "   S $  %P S 0 1 R +
† ¹ + o *  ¥ E T"s  ; F+ 7 LW* J " O:+
.lC  "  

5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

 S i+H F * › :l)  ²"C ŠO + :  ' (~


.Q  E Y ' $ "/ ; H $N  " 
. . ›;+ i+   ()  1 c 7 Z  ´ † j  1 c›+
(<<) 9M V+s
› () %M §  o %& 0 F; 'C 1  
0 /NE  /NE C!
>,¦Ž< ¦,¬< ¬,Ž¦ ’Ž,<’ = 0  %P $N
>,h¦ ’<¦,> ¬¬’ [c ;
0  %P
’¬ ,’< ¬¬ o %P

I7 '( )* cM ’ ˆ *18 V “G cp  QME
}  cMt g1 9  Š  t Œ(,
› () %M §  o %& 0 F; 'C 1  
0 /NE 0 /NE C!
>,¦Ž< ¦,¬< ¬,Ž¦ ’Ž,<’ = 0  %P $N
>,h¦ ’<¦,> ¬¬’ [c ;
0  %P
’¬ ,’< ¬¬ o %P

X;  † j ~¾ (<<) 9M V+s wg G" V4c ' ž C


S .€ %L ?fk g  ; '* r+ ?¦,¬< () L ()  1 c %M  Y
n" S i+H ; F+ 7 ½/C — >,¦Ž< Q: › + V+s
. 

#<
(%!"#$   )           
+ o *  Q  %  ; F+ 7 LW* J " O:+
.  n"   "   † ¹
  S i+H F * › l)  ²"C+ :57  ' (i
. "s Y ' $ "/ ; H $N  "
. . ›;+ i+   ()  1 c 7 Z  ´ † j  1 c›+

(<’) 9M V+s


'( )* cM ’ ˆ *18 V “G cp  QME
(Š g1 9  Š  t Œ(, I7
› () %M §  o %& 0 F; 'C 1  
0 /NE  /NE C!
>,<’< ¬,¬ ’,’¬ ¬¬,ŽŽ <¦ 0  %P $N
>,hh ’<>,< ¬’Ž [c ;
0  %P
’Ž¬,h¬ ¬¬ o %P

dN  † j ~¾ (<’) 9M V+s wg G" V4c ' ž C


.€ %L ?fk g  ; '* r+ ?¬,¬ () L ()  1 c %M  Y
n" S i+H ; F+ 7 ½/C — >,<’< Q: › + V+s S
. 
† ¹ + o *   "J  ; F+ 7 LW* J " O:+
.  n"   "  


5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

  S i+H F * › l)  ²"C+ :9 ` ' (


.%/ Y ' $ "/ ; H $N  "
i+   ()  1 c 7 Z  ´ † j  1 c›+
. . ›;+
(<¬) 9M V+s
'( )* cM ’ ˆ *18 V “G cp  QME
A g1 9  Š  t Œ(, I7
› () %M §  o %& 0 F; 'C 1  
0 /NE  /NE C!
>,¬’< <h,¦< ,=Ž ’ ,’’ ¬ 0  %P $N
>,¦ < ,< ¬¬h [c ;
0  %P
’’=,Ž< ¬¬ o %P

dN  † j ~¾ (<¬) 9M V+s wg G" V4c ' ž C


.€ %L fk g  ; '* r+ <h,¦< () L ()  1 c %M  Y
n" S i+H ; F+ 7 ½/C — >,¬’< Q: › + V+s S
. 
† ¹ + o *  %/  ; F+ 7 LW* J " O:+
.  n"   "  

#f
(%!"#$   )           

:  ;cB
7C mk ) ' lN (Fc +   O: S l‡ ´  V4c '
:  0 j  Y 1
S 0   + $   4 f  L   \ 7 % :› (!
9  Q " ' b‹L  ! Oy ¸ ­8 ¯ ® / 9/  0 W
 DOL+ N  0   Æ/N mk ) S 0.€ %L ?Q%/ 9.¾+
.  O: ' Œ ‹ + V+] $‡ mk ) S .€
 "  ' V   wg V j  3 1 9: '  (#
.l: )+  +] V ‹ › +   \ 7 % :› V4c ' ~ C
T/"C   a BF ' fb1L fM  G 'CO 34R (<
› 'CO 9.k G"N )  9.C  "    fN ­g D–
.    ' b  B-" ›g  G
  o *    ! ¸ ­8 ] ("
.Q  E + %/ +  "s + T"s [ /N • C ›  "
9£42  !   dHN 0 %/E + $%/E 7 % : I+‡ (f
l E ?fH ‡g  C Y\ Q  E  2g U c  L  ¨ ' 1 2+
. " 9. j+ 9.¾  ¸ ­g  '
 ' ! % ¸ ­8 ] wg 0 .] + a Nš 1 ) ( (~
Y\ ? " 9. j  o * + Q%/ 9:;›+ 9.¾  
.k E 0   S     Cb_ + N 9.M !g  j


5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

   ¾ +; 0 %/+ Q%/ ¥ I+‡ (i


/F E  ¥! N 9:bLO*+ ?0 1 R + 34R  !  *g
 F] L•*+ .+ D* ' 9.F¶ /N G  "C › ¨ %k 
.Š+c] F¯ 1 E C ) k  + !  1* E
[1  a  wg Š; y + ~H E :+ v %\ ´

#i
(%!"#$   )           

5p A@

7 5p t :V3
?48 1 E :V 1)  ?a BF ) ^ ?m >Q x); ?[ ºg 'N %| ?Š Z1 (<
.7< <
•Y “ 1–C w •Y, ’ C q  ,q  ?9G/ 1 ; /g ? "1 (’
:I:  ? " 0   CE /%J X;  Š "  ¼WE ?‹N }'(
.7< >
N  @  :† C ?Œ 1] 'C j ) %| :~¾ ?mrM 9( x); ?ŠO  (¬
.:<Ž> ?w+] /1R ?a BF 4 ?m_ V+ ¸/
C N  7 / C; /  /%J Y ‹ Š "  a  ? ;cM  } M” NM (Ž
.:<Ž<</<’/’’-’> ?† C ? " +
cn(t 9 '( )* 7 ?M^Y, }^YEq Uc ? % ?0 C+ (¦
; / 'N %| 7 8 / F T" 9 9 M ?I 6" bƒ  L;   ?}Y 
.:<Ž<= ?† C ?48
z A, Y  z A, I7 }Y 8 cn( 9 '( )* ?9: Ng 'N Ï j ?d" (h
.:<Ž’h ?Š 1" y  ; :I "E ?y'(
1t rYB   q t A(B ’ -. /  ?„ «ž (=
? " + C N  7 / C; /  /%J Y ‹ Š "  a   \ '%‡ ?ˆ M7V
.:<Ž<< ?† C
.:<Ž<Ž ?V4y  W :I:  ?'( )*  / ?V » ?9k B/ N (
.7< = ? CE ˆ] 1  ? I:  ?‘  y'( 6, ? 'C D) H (
} M L St 7 •Y ’  : S 9, g)QN /  ?  H ? [) H (<>
. :<Ž>’ ?<Ì ? 9  ; ? (C  ?  " (/2 »* ? y'( 7


5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

/1R ?6" +  1R 9/  ; :IF ?0 &   ?/ bY— ’ ? ?@RM (<<
.:<Ž>h ?I6 ) ‹
 ?a BF ?u   6 NV c( u   ˜ M' ?Cz s 9M 'N (<’
.:<Ž< ?w+] /1R ?z 1 R  B-) 1  :E
/1R ?dCz  + 6" 12  ; :† C ?a BF ) ^ ?6n / D'B ?b‹L 'N (<¬
.:<Ž’> ?) ‹
@  :† C ?Œ 1] 'C j ) %| :~¾ ??p  97 9( x); ?lF  'N (<Ž
.:<Ž> ?‹ ‹ /1R ?a BF ?m_ V+ ¸/ N 
bƒ b F    ?'( )* 7 ?M^Y, ‹N  „MV ?9: Ng 'N  ?Á¿ (<¦
.:<Ž< ?a › ?[H DE / F ?I 6"
?0 / J 6"  ; :I:  ?'( )* A(B u  ?9: Ng V %L ?Q (<h
.7’>>>
 M & ?G C AM‡ ’ ‘  9q wv -.  ?9 F ?‚ 1 E (<=
.7’>>/’/<< . * Ž= / ? C 
 7 M.  uz   A(B ’ -. /  ?Ï H 'N / ?Q  tE (<
/%J Y ‹ Š "  a   \ '%‡ ?u c(t (Nt ’ ˆ M7V 1t rYB
.:<Ž<< ?† C ? " + C N  7 / C; / 
1t 7 }  K*)M ’ -. / 0'1 23 ?Ï H 'N / ?Q  tE (<
?< ;/ ?<= P ?48 0   + C N  7 / ) ; / DE / F & . Š
.:<Ž’¦
& ?6t  }'( 9q w‰ ’ -. / 23 ?Ï H 'N / ?Q  tE (’>
. :<Ž’ ?T _ ;/ ? % F› + ) )8 7 / ) 7 8 / F

#$
(%!"#$   )           
:Q(pq 5p t :  2
<) Jung, C.G. Psychology and Religion : West and East, Second
Edition, London: Routedge & Kegan Paul, < <.
’) Shafranske, Religion and the clinical practice of Psychology,
Washington, D.C.: American Psychological Association, < h.
¬) Ashiq Ali Shah, Education in the Moral Behaviour of Adolescents
Self-Religiosity, Father’s Attitude and Religious, Psychology
Developing Societies ’>>Ž.
Ž) Breslin, Michael & Lewis, Christopher, Theoretical models of the nature
of prayer and health: A review. Mental Health, Religion & Culture; Jan’>>,
Vol. << Issue <, p ³’<, <¬.
¦) Lewis, Christopher Alan, Breslin, Michael and.Dein, Simon, Prayer and
mental health: An introduction to this special issue of Mental Health,
Religion & Culture. Mental Health, Religion & Culture; Jan’>>, Vol. <<
Issue <.
h) ) Robbins, Mandy, Francis, Leslie and Edwards, Prayer, personality and
happiness: A study among undergraduate students in Wales. Bethan, Mental
Health, Religion & Culture; Jan’>>, Vol. << Issue <.

 
5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

  w)
:'( )*  
61 9™ J 67
 .¥ X 
:1 R nc / @ R Qc
??? l* LN+ v „+ 9 74 
b1/  N L 6E S D)+ /*  6 [CBF D 7M  ;+ aQ [L [1M+ ›f +
wg  ) 1  DCC $N .Q%/ Y1 7 A  1 › O: V4c ' ÉG) .F+ '
Qc D" 3 RE + ?  I ! S "  +* n [k E Æ/N V  DC  / 
@ \ › Z6 ÉG) .F+ ~R" ' I 1 [ N J › : ?1 R nc /@ R
. C  lH †  + ® ‹ : 
(  C; mk "  %L ?K2 c c+ j 0 N Fg É ": ( H ?'K%2
Š :  "%.C %H 9› N  ) c ; F+ 7 4) O ?  – \ H. 
CÍ o ‡ E Oc•*  9.E ?D1 "C › M+ D1 "C M Š •  f–g • E H ?1ƒ]
› É F ?M; j mk ) ' Y1  C ¨ iN É2 Ø V ­ % }/* + %k4
V+ @ \ @·  V+  [N ." Š 7  4f C 2 f M+ Q* ›+ N Fg +; I 1 Š É *
.D" }/C  ij @ t S Q.H É2 c  ;* IH
[c ; (b) žj 4/N I 8 ' ‹L D" fN R T ?1 R nc @ R Qc
+RE   0  _ ' fZ D f%k4 () *  d ~ C ŠO  _ S dNE
.I 1 [L 7 
.F ' l ON   fbc v É BF+ ?~1R  ' V K % ) 1 › 9 (ƒH –g
.) 1 › O: K1/* V %L8 + /*+
) 0   52 6 7 8 ./ : _ 57 M AM Š (!
BCB/ 1 DE / F

#$!
(%!"#$   )           

dN  Y ‹ Œ ‹ V+] :š  }  cMt (#
' ‹ dN  X;  T _
...................................... :(LO*) c  "F Š; / :(Š (<
}L•H ’h ’¦ ³’¬ ’’ ³’> < ³ <= :A ("
:-. / 9 \n'1  (f
aBF <¦ ³ << a BF <> ³h a BF ¦ ³ <  + aBF ' [M
4
f  L  aBF ’ ³ ’h aBF ’¦ ³ ’< aBF ’> ³ <h

~H +› ~H +› ~H +› ~H + ~H + ~H + I 1/ 7


fR fb‹L f)  f)  fb‹L f ¼
S o M  7/ fb‹L Ì  <
[F+ B v ' fH c Qj /E
T" N ‹ ½"C l) '€ ’
9.H ' @ƒ ¸ @C ¬
‡ C 'C %  Æ/N X  Ž
Š;   [6N
I%/ a ;  f%k ; ¥ ¦
DO j ® (* %L
Œ•N .H 0/ 0  N 0 h
d" 
”M S f)  D6 ½N "C =
'Ccš d [ /  
n ” C + ' )1 nM  
£ V4c8 7  ¥
l/" (+  f" (C %L
U! Æ/N D– ® @1  ¨

 
5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23
¸  ‹C › Qk Mj <>
n 0  %s S V /H +N 7 M <<
.H É 
fF f% F D  ½)   <’
v %! + f " +
0 +"    ¥ <¬
"C 0 ‡ ¿ +
Æ/N wg  H ½)   <Ž
O: S ‚ J" %.E 0 
I !
 dR  › Œ•N fb‹L / <¦
® 'Ccš 1 ) (
IF )N I M @ L  V+  <h
0•s 6 ® (‡ %L <=
l  a  + I4 N v wg
) /E
fZ ("L   f)  ¼ <
c
S 9: * n V %] N 7 M <
.g 9G) n 0  %s ‚ ˆ
nj  GH ¿ N f%k ; 9 : ’>
% s
'E [ — v N Œ ug    ’<
½C 7 B › N  j C
O: S X " ™ G  / ’’
b‹N ½ [H I !

#$<
(%!"#$   )           
› O ?QM  ' Vz "* › ’¬
9./ Š; F+ S Qk4z @ƒC
' o ) Š  — @ › ’Ž
‡ C R6)] o )
/C6 7  @ L S fb‹L M ’¦
  ” 1F +  2g U c
' fL•   L › ?@ t S ’h
~1 n 0› ! S ¨ Q )
.H ‚ J" ®
Š;A  L  [H ?@ t S ’=
'Ccš N Ì4 c› @ ›+
f; .& @R * n '.E @ › ’
fC F
v L– %" ‚ *› N / ’
[.  + %  + ž1  N
5ƒ I ‹  [.  ' ¬>
É* › C ƒ X " a ‡g ¬<
9." ; / N› [H] H
Qj 9 F Š v %\ ¬’
3 / ' V c+
: v  Œ 1  S d‡ ¬¬
® % [L  @M
' Q:  H Œ;+ * f)  ¬Ž
žC  ½"u › Y\ a 
£
S fb‹L   'Ccš d ¬¦
lH YC! 'u o ‡  @ )
 
5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23
S Qk4z ' b‹L  i * ¬h
[M]  I + ‡ C 1/
S  M "C ' Cª fb‹L ½EWC ¬=
[F+ B v /
X "  IH f)  Œ;+ * ¬
  [L S ½) 1M C
0 2 6" S f1 ƒ É  ¬
 % F›
9G/ S É  4 fb‹L T%¾ Ž>
‡ C 3 /]
0 C o %  Š " d* f)  Ž<
 
[1 E ' Æ ƒ  c ½N "C Ž’
lH 3 ƒ ²Z ½)   Ž¬
S / 9G/ [1M '
' f "  L  ½GtC ŽŽ
Q% F S @ @1 N 'Ccš
f G| @* ½) (% –g Ž¦
Q B + l" “L• H f
D–
' ‹L [k   @ t S ) Žh
9k 6  ΠL
'Ccš o "Mg S N /j F Ž=
QCN

Ù L Ù M  (  ½) ½EWC Ž
   '

#$f
(%!"#$   )           
' ® v l% M A f ¼ †  ) Ž
I ! O: S  M
Ib‹L 0  H S Ì 18 N 0/ ¦>
”  '
S / @ƒ 1  @"· ¦<
›g  1 ›+  ) ) 9˜]
9. 
n COƒ] ' ‹L ›g V+  ¦’
0 C  +  : Š ¾
:; H 9G/ I ' ) ¦¬
"C [k E 9/*   j
7 % : Š  Œb/C › ¦Ž
0  % F›  f%k ; ¥ ¦¦
½% n
‡ C 3 /]  — @"· ¦h
 L  6c 'Ccš 7 
9y CZ 
 j+ o %  ŠC  ‚6"* ¦=
"s
%2 ½ X " l C  ½C › ¦
3 j  Œ L ' '  ½)
 (H/* –g ‚ *› N / ¦
CF [z + ~Cj
n V %] Æ/1N ®Ú S 7 M h>
ŒN .F VON @R *
~H E v +

 
5(* 6% 78 97 : ;..3 '( )* +, -. / 0'1 23

,c›ct G
)'* c›ct
’¬ ..................................................................................   ²Z
’Ž> ............................................................................................... 

’Ž< ...................................................................................   6

’ŽŽ ......................................................................................   °

’Žh ....................................................................................   :

’Žh ...................................................................................... Y1 m."

’Žh ..................................................................................... Y1 ;+

’Ž= .............................................................................   0 R

’Ž .................................................................................... ŠG"  28

’¦> ................................................................ 'C ' T" a % “M 

’¦¦ ............................................................................... N  0  

’h’ ................................................................. N  0    ~/*

’h¬ ...................................................................................   †+H

’hŽ .........................................................................   0 "+ d% &

’hŽ ...................................................................................   X 

?1  '( )*  


’h¦ ................................................... ŠG"  28 ; g :w+] E
’h= ....................................................... X E ; "N ; g :) ‹ E
’h ................................................. +] ) E   :‹ ‹ E
’h ...................................... X % k 8 0 a F8 :/N  E
’=> ........................................................................   ~1R* 0 a Fg

#$i
(%!"#$   )           

%D'B   hˆ M K‰
’=’ .............................................................   (, =ˆ *E :VX 3

’=’ ............................................   ½/ T"s + 1 " + ;/ (<


’=’ ..................................................   n"/ Q  E (’
’=Ž .................................................................................  "s (¬

’=¦ ........................................................................... C%/ K (Ž


’=¦ ...................................................   ' !   (¦
’== .......................................... ˆ M ^ (   G QME :X 2
’== ......................................................................... V+] † (<
’= Œ ‹ † (’
..........................................................................

’= ........................................................................ Y ‹ † (¬

’< dN  † (Ž
.........................................................................

’’ ...................................................................... T _ † (¦

’¬ ...................................................................... X;  † (h


’Ž ........................................................................ dN  † (=

’¦ ......................................................................... ' ‹ † (

’h ...............................................................................   ;cB


’ dF E
............................................................................................

’ < ...................................................................................   ~

’ = .............................................................................. 0  ‡ E X.H

 

You might also like