Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Therapeutic Effect of Hydrogen and Its Mechanisms.2
Therapeutic Effect of Hydrogen and Its Mechanisms.2
Abstract
Hydrogen is a simple, colorless, and biologically active small molecule gas that can react with reactive oxygen species. Recent research suggests
that hydrogen possesses several biological effects, including antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, and anti-apoptotic effects, while exhibiting an
extremely high level of safety. Hydrogen application has shown promise in treating a range of acute and chronic diseases, both benign and
malignant. Importantly, an increasing number of clinical studies on hydrogen have demonstrated its efficacy and safety in treating various
diseases. This review highlights the beneficial effects of hydrogen in kidney diseases, summarizes potential mechanisms by which hydrogen
may act in these diseases, and proposes several promising avenues for future research.
Key words: acute kidney injury; anti-apoptosis; anti-inflammation; anti-oxidation; chronic kidney disease; end-stage renal disease; hydrogen;
therapeutic effect
doi: 10.4103/2045-9912.378880
How to cite this article: Cheng J, Shi M, Sun X, Lu H. Therapeutic effect of hydrogen and its mechanisms in kidney disease treatment. Med
Gas Res. 2024;14(2):48-53.
Funding: This work was supported by Foundation of Naval Medical University, No. 2019QH001, Foundation of Center of Hydrogen
Science, No. WF510105001, Shanghai Rising-Star Program, No. 20YF1458200, Foundation of Qingdao Special Food Research Institute, No.
66120002, Key Specialty Construction Project of Changning District of Shanghai, No. 20191005, and Health Service Key Project of Naval
Medical Center of PLA, No. 22M3201.
CsA-induced ROS, MDA, Keap1/Nrf2 HR-water Adult male Sprague- ≥ 0.6 ppm Lu et al.3
nephrotoxicity GSH, SOD Dawley rats
PD-related ROS (in vitro) FN, α-SMA, ROS-PTEN- IP-HR- Male C57B/L6 mice Lu et al.4
peritoneal fibrosis MMP1, AKT-mTOR solution (21–25 g)
E-cadherin,
vimentin
nYQp/IlQrHD3i3D0OdRyi7TvSFl4Cf3VC4/OAVpDDa8KKGKV0Ymy+78= on 11/24/2023
Sepsis-related AKI IL-6, TNF-α, Promote M2 Inhalation of Male C57B/L6 mice > 0.6 mM Yao et al.5
IL-4, IL-13, macrophage a HR solution (20–25 g)
IL-10, TGF-β, polarization
CD16, CD206
I/R-AKI α-SMA, Klotho, Klotho/ IP-HR-saline Male C57BL/6 mice 0.6 mM Chen et al.6
collagen-1 Beclin-1, Beclin-1, (8-wk-old)
LC3-II LC3-II/
autophapy
UUO α-SMA, TGF-β1/ HR-water Male Balb/c mice 0.6 MPa Xing et al.7
fibronection, SMAD/Sirt1 (25±3 g) dissolve in
E-cadherin, water for 2 h
Smad2, Sirt1,
TGF-β1
I/R-AKI IL-6, TNF-α Bcl-2, Bax, IP-HR- Sprague-Dawley rats 0.6 mM Li et al.8
Caspase3, Caspase9, solution (250–300 g)
Caspase8
AKI after OLT MDA, SOD Caspase3, Cyt-C Beclin-1, P53/DRAM/ Inject-HR- Male Sprague- 0.6 mM Du et al.9
LC3- Beclin-1, saline Dawley rats
II, P62, LC3-II/ (220±10 g)
LAMP2, autophapy
p-P53
Severe burn- MDA, SOD, IL-6, TNF-α, JNK, p-JNK, AKT, MARK/ IP-HR saline Male Sprague- > 0.6 mM Guo et al.10
induced early AKI CAT, GSH-Px IL-1β, IL- p-AKT, P38, p-P38 AKT/NF-κB Dawley rats
10, ICAM-1, (220–250 g)
NF-κB, ERK,
p-ERK
Severe AP-induced MDA, SOD IL-6, TNF-α, IκBa/NF-κB Inject -HR- Male Wistar rats > 0.6 mM Shi et al.11
early AKI IL-1β, IL-10, saline (200–250 g)
NF-κB, MPO,
IκBa
Renal injury in MDA, TAC, IκBa/NF-κB HR-water Male spontaneously > 0.8 mg/L Xin et al.12
spontaneously HT ROS, O2–, hypertensive rats;
OONO-, SOD, male Wistar-Kyoto
GPx, catalase, rats (8-wk-old)
GST, NADPH
oxidase
Rhabdomyolysis ROS, MDA, TNF-α, IL-6 IP-HR-saline Male Wistar rats 0.6 nM Gu et al.13
induced AKI SOD, GSH-Px, (180–200 g)
8-OH-dG
Ferric NTA- HO-1, HO-2, IL-6, MCP-1, JAK/STAT/ HR-water Male Wistar rats > 0.8 mg/L Li et al.14
induced MDA, OONO-, NF-κB PCNA (200–230 g)
nephrotoxicity catalase,
NADPH oxidase,
xanthine oxidase
Renal injury MDA, SOD ED1 Apoptotic tubular Interstitial IP-HR-saline Male Sprague- 0.4 MPa Xu et al.15
induced by UUO cells were fibrotic area Dawley rats dissolve in
determined by (180–200 g) saline for 4 h
TUNEL-positive
staining
T2DM and MS ROS, MDA HR-water Male stroke-prone 0.3-0.4 ppm Katakura et
spontaneously al.16
hypertensive rats
(5-wk-old)
Renal cold I/R MDA, 8-OH-dG, ED1, IFN-γ, Apoptotic tubular Kidney Inbred male Lewis 1.61 mg/L Abe et al.17
injury in kidney iNOS, HO-1 IL-6, TNF-α, cells were grafts were (LEW) rats
transplantation CCL2, IL-1β determined by preserved (250–350 g)
TUNEL-positive in HRUW
staining solution
Gentamicin- Na+-K+- HR-water Male Sprague- 1.2±0.1 mg/L Matsushita
induced ATPase Dawley rats et al.18
nephrotoxicity (284±23 g)
Cisplatin-induced Na+-K+- HR-water Male Sprague- 1.2±0.1 mg/L Kitamuta et
nephrotoxicity ATPase Dawley rats al.19
(284±4 g)
Renal I/R injury MDA, 8-OH-dG, IL-6, TNF-α, Apoptotic tubular IP-HR-saline Male Sprague- > 0.6 nM Wang et
SOD, CAT IL-1β, MPO cells were Dawley rats al.20
determined by (200–220 g)
TUNEL-positive
staining
Renal I/R injury 8-OH-dG Inject-HR- Male Wistar rats 640 µM Shingu et
saline (250–300 g) al.21
Note: 8-OH-dG: 8-Hydroxy-2'-deoxyguanosine; AKI: acute kidney injury; AKT: AKT serine/threonine kinase 1; AP: acute pancreatitis; ATPase: adenosine triphosphatase; CAT: catalase; CCL2: chemokine
(C-C motif) ligand 2; CsA: cyclosporine A; Cyt-C: cytochrome-C; DRAM: DNA damage regulated autophagy modulator; ED1: ectodysplasin A; ERK: extracellular signal-regulated kinase; FN: fibronectin 1;
GSH: glutathione; GSH-Px: glutathione peroxidase; GST: glutathione S-transferase; HO: hemeoxygenase; HR: hydrogen-rich; HRUW: Hydrogen-Rich University of Wisconsin; HT: hypertension; ICAM-1:
intercellular adhesion molecule 1; IL: interleukin; IP: prostacyclin; I/R: ischemia/reperfusion; IκBa: NF-κB inhibitor alpha; JAK: Janus kinase; LAMP2: lysosomal associated membrane protein 2; LC3-II:
microtubule associated protein 1 light chain 3-II; MARK: microtubule-affinity regulating kinase; MDA: malondialdehyde; MMP1: matrix metallopeptidase 1; MPO: myeloperoxidase; MS: metabolic syndrome;
mTOR: mechanistic target of rapamycin kinase; NF-κB: nuclear factor kappa-B; NADPH: nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate; NTA: nitrilotriacetate; O2–: superoxide anion; OLT: orthotropic liver
transplantation; OONO-: peroxynitrite; p-ERK: phosphorylated ERK; p-P53: phosphorylated p53; PCNA: proliferating cell nuclear antigen; PD: peritoneal dialysis; PTEN:phosphatase and tensin homolog;
ROS: reactive oxygen species; Sirt1: sirtuin 1; SOD: superoxide dismutase; STAT: signal transducer and activator of transcription; T2DM: type 2 diabetes mellitus; TAC: total antioxidant capacity; TGF-β:
transforming growth factor-β; TNF-α: tumour necrosis factor-α; TUNEL: terminal deoxynucleotide transferase-mediated dUTP nick end labeling; UUO: unilateral ureteral obstruction; α-SMA: alpha-smooth
muscle actin.
involve oxygen free radicals, inflammation, apoptosis, adhe- duced, indicating that HRUW treatment reduced the level of
sion factors between endothelial cells, and calcium overload, reactive oxygen species. Additionally, this study showed that
the exact mechanism of renal injury is still unclear.26 Recent HRUW treatment inhibited the expression of inducible nitric
studies have demonstrated that H2 can protect renal tissue oxide synthase, which is responsible for producing nitric ox-
from I/R-induced oxidative damage, primarily due to the anti- ide. The reaction of nitric oxide with superoxide anion radical
inflammatory and anti-apoptotic effects of H2 and selective (O2–) forms another highly active peroxynitrite ion (ONOO-),
reduction of cytotoxic reactive oxygen species, particularly which causes oxidation/nitration modification of biomolecules
-OH and ONOO-.8,20 Furthermore, it has been reported that and regulates physiological and pathophysiological processes.
H2 can also mitigate I/R damage to other organs such as the Several studies have shown that inhibiting inducible nitric ox-
heart,27,28 lungs,29 liver,30 and intestines.31-33 ide synthase can reduce I/R injury,34-36 indicating that inducible
nitric oxide synthase plays an important role in this process.
Application of hydrogen in renal transplantation
Renal transplantation remains the most effective treatment for Application of hydrogen in hemodialysis and peritoneal
end-stage renal disease (ESRD). However, kidney I/R injury dialysis
is an inevitable consequence of renal transplantation, and the The number of ESRD patients worldwide is increasing an-
duration of cold ischemia time is a potential risk factor for the nually. In China, the prevalence of CKD is as high as 10.8%,
survival of donor kidney transplantation. In a study conducted and 1% of CKD patients will develop ESRD.37 Hemodialysis
by Japanese scholar Abe et al.,17 a H2 dissolving device from (HD) and peritoneal dialysis (PD) are the main alternative
Miz Company was used to electrolyze circulating water be- therapies for ESRD, with renal transplantation being the most
tween a water tank and an electrolyzer. H2 was produced con- ideal treatment option. However, due to the scarcity of kidney
tinuously, which allowed the concentration of H2 in the water resources and patient physical and economic conditions, HD
to reach 1.61 mg/L at 20°C. They then prepared hydrogen-rich and PD remain the most common treatment methods. Both of
University of Wisconsin organ protection solution (HRUW) these dialysis methods use a large amount of dialysate during
by immersing 50 mL centrifuge tubes containing University of the process, which allows H2 to enter the body as a carrier.
Wisconsin solution (ViaSpan; DuPont, Wilmington, DE, USA) As the smallest molecule in nature, H2 has the characteristics
into MiZ hydrogen-saturated water for 48 hours. It was found of strong penetration and rapid diffusion and can enter the
that after 24 hours of refrigeration, there was no significant blood and body through free diffusion. In recent years, more
difference in the survival rate between the UW group and and more studies have focused on H2-containing dialysate. It
the HRUW group. However, HRUW treatment significantly has been found that HR dialysate (with an average H2 con-
improved renal function, reduced renal tubular damage, and centration of 50 ppb) can effectively reduce oxidative stress
inhibited the development of renal tubular cell apoptosis and levels in the dialyzer, improve the nutritional status of dialysis
interstitial fibrosis. The possible mechanism for this is that H2 patients, and reduce the incidence of cardiovascular disease.38,39
protects cells by reducing oxidative damage to DNA, lipids, H2-containing dialysate does not reduce biocompatibility or
and proteins. Compared with UW preservation solution, the increase the risk of infection, making it a possible clinical
level of malondialdehyde in renal tissue was significantly re- application for HR dialysate.40,41
50 Medical Gas Research ¦ June ¦ Volume 14 ¦ Issue 2
Cheng et al. / Med Gas Res www.medgasres.com
Patients with HD who have elevated levels of oxidative burns.10 HR water supplementation has also been confirmed
stress are more likely to have severe cardiovascular disease. to be effective in treating interstitial cystitis/painful bladder
The contact between blood and the dialysis membrane in- syndrome, with the results indicating significant improvement
creases the level of oxidative stress during HD. Japanese in bladder pain scores in 11% of patients.49 However, further
scholar Nakayama and his team developed a new HD system research with an extended observation period and a larger
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/mgar by BhDMf5ePHKav1zEoum1tQfN4a+kJLhEZgbsIHo4XMi0hCywCX1AW
that delivers HR dialysate (with a H2 concentration range of number of clinical cases are necessary. In addition, H2 has
30–80 ppb) through water electrolysis. After more than three demonstrated advantages in interfering with various chronic
years of observation, the study shows that HR HD can reduce diseases related to kidney diseases, such as diabetes, arterio-
the incidence of end-point events, such as all-cause mortal- sclerosis, hypertension, and others that significantly threaten
nYQp/IlQrHD3i3D0OdRyi7TvSFl4Cf3VC4/OAVpDDa8KKGKV0Ymy+78= on 11/24/2023
ity and non-fatal cardiovascular and cerebrovascular events human health. An intervention study in 2008 demonstrated the
(such as heart disease, stroke, and limb amputation caused by effect of drinking HR water on patients with type 2 diabetes.
peripheral artery disease) compared to conventional HD pa- The results showed a decrease in the levels of oxidized low-
tients, improving the prognosis of long-term HD patients.40,41 density lipoprotein and free fatty acid in serum, while the level
As an alternative therapy for ESRD patients, PD has the ad- of plasma adiponectin and extracellular superoxide dismutase
vantage of better protecting residual renal function and stabiliz- increased in patients who consumed HR water daily. Among
ing hemodynamics. However, the long-term use of peritoneal the six patients with impaired glucose tolerance, four patients
dialysate can lead to peritoneal fibrosis and peritoneal failure, recovered their normal glucose tolerance test by consuming
resulting in the discontinuation of PD. Scholar Nakayama and HR water, indicating its potential in preventing type 2 diabetes
his team40,41 produced H2 in peritoneal dialysate by electrolyz- and insulin resistance.50 Furthermore, a double-blind, random-
ing water. The H2-containing peritoneal dialysate can improve ized, placebo-controlled trial by domestic scholars showed that
apoptosis, proliferation, and fibrosis of peritoneal surface cells. the intake of HR water reduced plasma low-density lipoprotein
Animal experiments have shown that H2-containing peritoneal cholesterol levels in patients with metabolic syndrome. H2
dialysate has a certain protective effect on mesothelial cells activates the A1-dependent efflux of ATP-binding transporter
and the integrity of the peritoneum.40,41 H2 has also been used and enhances the anti-atherosclerotic function of high-density
in clinical cases. Encapsulated peritoneal sclerosis (EPS), the lipoprotein.51 These findings suggest that H2 has the potential
most serious and life-threatening complication of PD, has a to prevent atherosclerosis.
high mortality rate. Recent reports show that the mortality rate
of EPS is 14–84%. Extensive peritoneal fibrosis in patients SUMMARY AND PERSPECTIVE
with EPS can lead to malnutrition and intestinal obstruction. H2 medicine is rapidly advancing and has unique advantages
Inflammation, angiogenesis, and fibrosis of the peritoneum compared to hydrogen sulfide and other cytotoxic antioxi-
are the key factors, while peritoneal fibrosis and adhesion are dants. H2 is safe and has strong diffusion ability, making it an
the core elements.42,43 Although drug interventions (such as attractive treatment method. Recent studies have shown that
tamoxifen, steroids, and new immunosuppressive agents) can H2 has anti-oxidant, anti-inflammatory, and anti-apoptotic
delay the progression of EPS, the effect is still poor, and the effects, making it an effective treatment for a variety of dis-
side effects are significant.44 Adverse reactions such as isch- eases. Despite numerous studies confirming the preventive
emic stroke and pulmonary embolism are related to tamoxifen, and therapeutic effects of H2, the specific mechanisms of H2
and opportunistic infections are related to corticosteroids. on human diseases remain unclear, especially in the field of
In contrast, H2 has been tested in deep water diving, and no urinary system research. However, the safety and accessibil-
toxicity has been found even at high concentrations. This case ity of H2 offer excellent opportunities for extensive research
study shows that the delivery of H2 through HD and peritoneal in this area. Overall, H2 shows great potential as a promising
lavage, in addition to giving oral prednisolone treatment, can new treatment for various urinary system diseases.
improve EPS. Therefore, H2 is expected to become a new
alternative drug therapy for EPS.45
Author contributions
Study design: HL and XS; paper drafting: JC and MS. All the authors
Application of hydrogen in other kidney diseases
approved the final version of the manuscript.
Cisplatin is a highly effective chemotherapeutic drug that Conflicts of interest
has a broad anti-cancer spectrum and a strong synergistic The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest that could be
effect with a variety of other anti-tumor drugs. However, the perceived as prejudicing the impartiality of the research reported.
efficacy of cisplatin is dose-dependent, and its significant Editor note: Xuejun Sun is an Editorial Board member of Medical
Gas Research. He was blinded from reviewing or making decisions
risk of nephrotoxicity often hinders the use of higher doses, on the manuscript. The article was subject to the journal’s standard
thereby limiting its anti-tumor effect. Accumulation of reac- procedures, with peer review handled independently of this Editorial
tive oxygen species at high concentrations plays a crucial role Board member and his research group.
in cisplatin-induced nephrotoxicity.46 Studies have shown Data availability statement
No additional data are available.
that inhalation of H2 and oral intake of HR water can reduce Open access statement
cisplatin-induced nephrotoxicity without affecting its anti- This is an open access journal, and articles are distributed under
tumor activity.47 Furthermore, H2 has shown to be effective the terms of the Creative Commons AttributionNonCommercial-
in reducing kidney injury caused by other factors such as ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and
build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit
nephrotoxicity caused by nitrogenous ferric acetate,14 unilateral is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.
ureteral obstruction,15 septic shock,48 acute pancreatitis,11 and
Medical Gas Research ¦ June ¦ Volume 14 ¦ Issue 2 51
Cheng et al. / Med Gas Res www.medgasres.com
Transplantation. 2012;94:14-21.
18. Matsushita T, Kusakabe Y, Kitamura A, Okada S, Murase K. Pro-
References tective effect of hydrogen-rich water against gentamicin-induced
1. Ohsawa I, Ishikawa M, Takahashi K, et al. Hydrogen acts as a nephrotoxicity in rats using blood oxygenation level-dependent
therapeutic antioxidant by selectively reducing cytotoxic oxygen MR imaging. Magn Reson Med Sci. 2011;10:169-176.
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/mgar by BhDMf5ePHKav1zEoum1tQfN4a+kJLhEZgbsIHo4XMi0hCywCX1AW
radicals. Nat Med. 2007;13:688-694. 19. Kitamura A, Kobayashi S, Matsushita T, Fujinawa H, Murase K.
2. Huang CS, Kawamura T, Toyoda Y, Nakao A. Recent advances in Experimental verification of protective effect of hydrogen-rich wa-
hydrogen research as a therapeutic medical gas. Free Radic Res. ter against cisplatin-induced nephrotoxicity in rats using dynamic
2010;44:971-982.
nYQp/IlQrHD3i3D0OdRyi7TvSFl4Cf3VC4/OAVpDDa8KKGKV0Ymy+78= on 11/24/2023
35. Watanabe M, Kamimura N, Iuchi K, et al. Protective effect of 44. Danford CJ, Lin SC, Smith MP, Wolf JL. Encapsulating peritoneal
hydrogen gas inhalation on muscular damage using a mouse sclerosis. World J Gastroenterol. 2018;24:3101-3111.
hindlimb ischemia-reperfusion injury model. Plast Reconstr Surg. 45. Terawaki H, Nakano H, Zhu WJ, Nakayama M. Successful treat-
2017;140:1195-1206. ment of encapsulating peritoneal sclerosis by hemodialysis and
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/mgar by BhDMf5ePHKav1zEoum1tQfN4a+kJLhEZgbsIHo4XMi0hCywCX1AW
36. Saito M, Chen-Yoshikawa TF, Takahashi M, et al. Protective ef- peritoneal lavage using dialysate containing dissolved hydrogen.
fects of a hydrogen-rich solution during cold ischemia in rat lung Perit Dial Int. 2015;35:107-112.
transplantation. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2020;159:2110-2118. 46. Qin X, Meghana K, Sowjanya NL, et al. Embelin attenuates cis-
37. Shi Y, Rehman H, Wright GL, Zhong Z. Inhibition of inducible platin-induced nephrotoxicity: Involving inhibition of oxidative
nYQp/IlQrHD3i3D0OdRyi7TvSFl4Cf3VC4/OAVpDDa8KKGKV0Ymy+78= on 11/24/2023
nitric oxide synthase prevents graft injury after transplantation of stress and inflammation in addition with activation of Nrf-2/Ho-1
livers from rats after cardiac death. Liver Transpl. 2010;16:1267- pathway. Biofactors. 2019;45:471-478.
1277. 47. Nakashima-Kamimura N, Mori T, Ohsawa I, Asoh S, Ohta S.
38. Terawaki H, Zhu WJ, Matsuyama Y, et al. Effect of a hydrogen Molecular hydrogen alleviates nephrotoxicity induced by an anti-
(H2)-enriched solution on the albumin redox of hemodialysis pa- cancer drug cisplatin without compromising anti-tumor activity in
tients. Hemodialysis international International Symposium on mice. Cancer Chemother Pharmacol. 2009;64:753-761.
Home Hemodialysis. 2014;18:459-466. 48. Liu W, Dong XS, Sun YQ, Liu Z. A novel fluid resuscitation proto-
39. Maeda K, Yoshizaki S, Iida T, et al. Improvement of the fraction col: provide more protection on acute kidney injury during septic
of human mercaptalbumin on hemodialysis treatment using hy- shock in rats. Int J Clin Exp Med. 2014;7:919-926.
drogen-dissolved hemodialysis fluid: a prospective observational 49. Matsumoto S, Ueda T, Kakizaki H. Effect of supplementation with
study. Ren Replace Ther. 2016;2:42. hydrogen-rich water in patients with interstitial cystitis/painful
40. Nakayama M, Itami N, Suzuki H, et al. Novel haemodialysis (HD) bladder syndrome. Urology. 2013;81:226-230.
treatment employing molecular hydrogen (H(2))-enriched dialysis 50. Kajiyama S, Hasegawa G, Asano M, et al. Supplementation of
solution improves prognosis of chronic dialysis patients: A pro- hydrogen-rich water improves lipid and glucose metabolism in pa-
spective observational study. Sci Rep. 2018;8:254. tients with type 2 diabetes or impaired glucose tolerance. Nutr Res.
41. Nakayama M, Zhu WJ, Watanabe K, et al. Dissolved molecular hy- 2008;28:137-143.
drogen (H(2)) in Peritoneal Dialysis (PD) solutions preserves me- 51. Song G, Lin Q, Zhao H, et al. Hydrogen activates ATP-binding
sothelial cells and peritoneal membrane integrity. BMC Nephrol. cassette transporter A1-dependent efflux ex vivo and improves
2017;18:327. high-density lipoprotein function in patients with hypercholes-
42. Vidal E, Edefonti A, Puteo F, et al. Encapsulating peritoneal scle- terolemia: a double-blinded, randomized, and placebo-controlled
rosis in paediatric peritoneal dialysis patients: the experience of Trial. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2015;100:2724-2733.
the Italian Registry of Pediatric Chronic Dialysis. Nephrol Dial
Transplant. 2013;28:1603-1609. Date of submission: December 12, 2021
43. Jagirdar RM, Bozikas A, Zarogiannis SG, Bartosova M, Schmitt Date of decision: January 24, 2022
CP, Liakopoulos V. Encapsulating peritoneal sclerosis: pathophysi- Date of acceptance: February 25, 2023
ology and current treatment options. Int J Mol Sci. 2019;20:5765. Date of web publication: June 19, 2023