Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract : After interruption of a capacitive current For vacuum CB’s, the physical processes during the
sometimes Non Sustained Disruptive Discharges (NSDDs) capacitive switching duty have been studied by [5].
are observed when using vacuum circuit breakers. They found that the pre-ignition at contact closing and
According to network calculations, NSDDs generate the subsequent inrush current heavily eroded the
significant over-voltage on the terminal of the capacitor contacts leading to detached particles. These particles
bank to ground and across the circuit breaker (CB) cause late breakdowns which appear as NSDDs 1 .
terminals. In a full scale experiment at 12kV on an 8Mvar Breakdown frequencies of typically 3/1000 where found
capacitor bank artificial NSDDs are produced using a under the experimental conditions studied. The
Triggered Vacuum Gap. The over-voltage depends on the probability of breakdown depends on the dielectric
momentary voltage difference across the breaker and, conception or contact stroke of the vacuum interrupter.
hence, varies with the phase angle. The over-voltage on the So for the same voltage rating different designs lead to
terminal of the capacitor bank to ground varies from 1.5 to different probabilities of occurrence of NSDD. Fig. 1
4.2 pu, and to maximum 5.2 pu. across the CB terminals. shows the experimentally found relation between
The effectiveness of surge arrestors on the limitation of the dielectric conception, based on contact gap, and the
over-voltages is measured. The over-voltages are limited to probability of a NSDD during an operation. It shows
2.2 pu. on the terminals of the capacitor bank to ground that a minimum contact distance of 16 mm is necessary
and 3.2 pu. across the CB terminals. A single surge to reduce this probability below 1/500.
arrestor on the neutral point of the capacitor bank yields The overvoltage produced by a NSDD differs
the same level of protection and, therefore, is a cost notably from the overvoltage produced by a restrike. A
effective alternative. An application guide for switchgear restrike can generate an overvoltage of 3 pu. between
and arrestors is presented. the terminals of the capacitor bank, whereas a NSDD
causes a sudden voltage shift of the neutral capacitor
I. INTRODUCTION bank voltage, which leaves the voltage across the
capacitor unchanged, but creates an overvoltage
The capacitive current switching duty is characterised between 1.5 and 5 pu. on the terminal of capacitor bank
by frequent, day to day or hour by hour, switching of to ground and between 2.5 and 6 pu. across the CB
low to moderate currents in industrial or public terminals. Due to this high overvoltage a second NSDD
networks, and by a low rate of rise of recovery voltage. in the adjacent phases becomes more likely.
Modern circuit breakers (CB’s) which claim a long
mechanical but also electrical life without maintenance
seem to be best adapted to this switching duty [1,2,3].
Yet the behaviour of vacuum CB’s is rather different
from that of gas CB’s.
Today, the circuit breaker envisioned for capacitor
bank switching is either a vacuum or SF6 circuit breaker
or a vacuum or SF6 contactor. All these devices are
known for their long service life. The circuit breaker
offers a protection against short circuit currents with an
electrical life between 10.000 and 30.000 operations at
nominal current. Contactors offer an electrical life up to
1 million operations depending on load conditions. SF6
CB’s, in the past referred to as “restrike free” breakers,
are according to the new IEC62271-100 class C2 Fig.1 : Experimentally found dependence between probability of a
NSDD and nominal contact stroke of vacuum interrupter.
breakers with proven “very low restrike probability” [4].
Field experience indicates that the restrike probability 1
even for the electrically very stressed 36 kV networks is NSDD or non-sustained disruptive discharge [7] is a disruptive
discharge associated with current interruption that does not result in
lower than 1/50.000. the resumption of power frequency current or, in the case of capacitive
current interruption does not result in current in the main load circuit.
When two NSDDs occur simultaneously, the illustrated by Fig. 2, the voltage across the breaker
phenomenon turns into a restrike. Typically, a vacuum moves as a travelling wave through the line impedance
CB with a contact gap of about 16 mm has a probability towards the capacitor bank. The capacitor bank being a
of about 1/500 for producing a NSDD and belongs to
the class C2 with proven “very low restrike probability”.
Due to the rare occurrence and the random nature of
the phenomenon, the relation between NSDD and
overvoltage is not evident. Therefore in this paper this
question is addressed in section II using a numerical
network simulation. By this the worst case overvoltage
for different voltage levels is determined. Then in
section III an experiment designed to verify the
simulation results is shown. Here the NSDD is created
artificially, which permits to measure the influence of
phase angle and network parameters. A good
understanding of the origin of the overvoltage enables Fig. 3 : The voltage on all 3 capacitor bank terminals during current
interruption (at 0.1s) followed by a NSDD (at 0.13s) in R phase in a
the definition of protective measures adapted to the 12kV network.
switchgear and capacitor bank. In section IV protection
schemes based on surge arrestors are tested and
high frequency short circuit allows the wave to pass on
compared on their effectiveness. Finally in section V the
to the neutral point of the bank. At the neutral point the
results are discussed and an application guideline is
wave splits itself and continues its propagation in the
presented for the choice of switchgear and arrestor.
neighbouring phases towards the healthy CB poles.
II. ORIGIN OF OVERVOLTAGES These healthy poles are in fact open terminals for the
incoming wave causing it to reflect by doubling the
A. Numerical simulation voltage. After reflection the wave travels back to the
The simplified electrical circuit, Fig. 2, will be used failing CB pole. Here it creates a current zero passage
here to simulate the phenomena associated with a on which the breaker can interrupt. The frequency of
NSDD; the NSDD is simulated as a temporary loss of this current is typically of the order of 100 kHz for cable
dielectric strength in the vacuum interrupter of a connected capacitor banks. Fig. 3 shows the voltage
vacuum CB. swing on the bank terminals with respect to ground.
Note that
- For each of the three bank terminals the voltage
jumps to a new value, which means that the neutral
point of the bank attains also a different value.
- The voltage difference between terminals remains
unchanged. The capacitors themselves are not
stressed by the breakdown.
- The maximum terminal voltage to earth attains a
high value (see table I). This is a dc voltage, so all
parts of the installation are stressed during a long
period.
Fig. 2 : Electric circuit used to calculate overvoltage on capacitor
- The CB is stressed by the composed voltage of
bank during a NSDD. TVG see section III.
network voltage and capacitor bank terminal
The source side of the network is represented by: voltage.
- a generator with a driving voltage of U - The capacity of the bank itself is of no significance
- a short circuit impedance of value Ls for the phenomenon.
- a TRV network as defined by IEC for short circuit Table 1: Compilation of voltages associated with capacitor bank
conditions switching for nominal network voltages
- a capacitor Cp to account for parallel feeders Um US U C-bank UVCB BIL Power
The load side of the network is represented by: frequency
kVrms kVrms kV kV kV kVrms
- a 8Mvar capacitor bank with floating neutral
- single phase cables between CB and the bank. 12 10 47 55 75 28
The load and the source side of the network are 24 20 93 110 125 50
connected to each other by the CB. The CB is treated as 36 30 140 164 170 70
an ideal breaker with a NSDD some time after current
interruption. The moment of NSDD has been chosen in
B. Identification of zones at risk
order to create the worst possible case. The CB is
In table I the maximum possible overvoltage
allowed to recover immediately at the first occurring
produced by a NSDD is shown for three commonly
current zero. At a NSDD, on the R phase for the case
used classes of network voltages. For each voltage class creates a dc voltage on the capacitor bank terminal of
column 2 gives Us the nominal network voltage. 1.5 pu. Then 30 milliseconds after current interruption a
Column 3 gives the maximum overvoltage on the NSDD is generated in phase R at a maximum voltage
capacitor bank terminal to ground and column 4 the difference across the CB. At this moment the voltages
maximum overvoltage across the CB terminals. For on all C-bank terminals change suddenly and settle to a
reference the BIL and power frequency withstand new constant value. The highest overvoltage is found in
voltages of the equipment are given. For all three phase T. The instant of occurrence of the NSDD was
voltage classes both overvoltages exceed the peak value varied by firing the TVG at a predetermined moment to
of the power frequency withstand voltage. For the CB see the influence of the phase angle on the nature and
the overvoltage comes very close to the rated BIL the value of the over-voltage. The waveform of the
voltage for 36 kV class networks. overvoltage is a dc voltage and is the same for all tested
phase angles.
III. EXPERIMENTAL VERIFICATION
A. Test procedure
The objective was to create in a reproducible way
NSDD type breakdowns in a capacitive current
interruption test. This allowed to minimize the number
of tests to obtain the desired NSDD. NSDDs do not
occur frequently and are therefore difficult to reproduce.
A triggered vacuum gap (TVG) parallel to the R-phase
of the VCB is used to create an artificial NSDD in a
controllable way. A separate experiment confirmed that
the TVG was able to interrupt high frequency currents
of, for instance, 300A at 100kHz and 10 A at 900 kHz
at the first current zero. Hence, the duration of the
“artificial” NSDD is determined by the circuit topology
and only one half cycle of high frequency current will
pass through the TVG. Numerical modelling showed
that this will lead to the highest possible overvoltage.
Using the TVG provided a measurement window with
high frequency sampling centred at the time of
breakdown allowing precise measurements to be made.
Full scale tests are performed in a direct test circuit fed
by a generator 2000 MVA at 12 kV with short circuit Fig. 5a : Normal interruption of Fig. 5b : As Fig. 5a Surge arrestor
current limited at 14 kA. The capacitive load was a 8 capacitive current followed by in phase T limits the overvoltage.
Mvar capacitor bank; nominal current of 430 A. The NSDD in R phase after 30 ms.
detailed characteristics of the test circuit are given in For each phase (R, S, T). Red : Source side voltage on CB.
Green : Load side voltage on CB and capacitor bank terminal.
Fig. 4 and table II. Blue : Current through CB. Time scale: 1ms/div.
B. Test results
Fig. 5a shows an oscillogram of a normal
interruption with NSDD. The first phase to interrupt, R,