Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Poetic Objects: Bachelardian Reverie, Reverberation and Repose in Claire Denis' 35 Shots of Rum
Poetic Objects: Bachelardian Reverie, Reverberation and Repose in Claire Denis' 35 Shots of Rum
Abstract:
This article draws on the interrelated concepts of reverie and repose in Gaston
Bachelard’s philosophy to approach Claire Denis’ poetic foregrounding of objects
in 35 Shots of Rum (35 Rhums, 2008). Connecting Bachelard’s work on time to his
later studies of the imagination, I demonstrate how the poetic time of reverie and
repose are essential to Bachelard’s thinking. Focusing on three especially charged
objects (trains, rice cookers and lanterns), I argue for reverie and repose as being
embedded into the rhythmic structure, affective organisation and form of Denis’
film. Contextualising Bachelard’s later thinking in relation to Eugène Minkowski, I
maintain that Denis’ objects reverberate (both formally and sensuously). In 35
Shots of Rum, Denis’ poetic objects and her evocation of different in-between states
parallels Bachelard’s own materialist thinking on the imagination, reverie and
repose.
7
Film-Philosophy 27 (2023)
8
Claire Denis’ 35 Shots of Rum
2 On the film’s relationship with Ozu see Williams (2009, pp. 48–50).
3 In Intuition of the instant, Bachelard (1932/2013, pp. 8–24) also takes issue with
Bergson’s theory of temporal continuity.
9
Film-Philosophy 27 (2023)
10
Claire Denis’ 35 Shots of Rum
5 According to the Tindersticks’ Stuart Staples, the film’s opening composition came to
him after seeing Denis’ footage of the train on its tracks whereby he “felt the rhythm”
(see Beugnet, 2014, p. 3).
6 While the point of view of the driver’s seat is later attached to one of Lionel’s colleagues,
Denis’ focus is on the train as a moving object in space here.
11
Film-Philosophy 27 (2023)
12
Claire Denis’ 35 Shots of Rum
13
Film-Philosophy 27 (2023)
7 As I have detailed elsewhere (2020, p. 354), the imagination does not have a fixed mode
in Bachelard’s work as its images depend upon the particular substances that are being
engaged or their imaginative admixtures.
8 The “poetic image is an emergence from language, it is always a little above the language
of signification” (Bachelard, 1958/1994, p. xxvii).
14
Claire Denis’ 35 Shots of Rum
Suddenly an image situates itself in the centre of our imagining being. It retains
us; it engages us. It infuses us with being […] A flower, a fruit, or a simple,
familiar object suddenly comes to solicit us to think of it, to dream near it
[….] [O]nce a poet has chosen his object, the object itself changes its being.
It is promoted to the poetic. (1960/1971, pp. 153–154, emphasis added)
15
Film-Philosophy 27 (2023)
repeated by her father in the film’s poignant closing shot). In the next cut,
Jo arrives home where Denis films her dropping her bag to the floor,
resting a baguette nearby and hiding her new purchase in her room in an
unbroken take. As with many of the film’s hallway scenes, the camera
stays fixed in place here as Jo moves in and out of the frame, turning light
switches on, loading but not yet starting the washing machine. Having
changed into loose-fitting clothing (a mode of dress that both father and
daughter adopt at home), she turns her attention to making dinner. When
Lionel announces his arrival home via the doorbell, she smiles (a gesture
that recalls her fleeting expression on the train). Returning to another
shot of the hallway, Denis shows father and daughter affectionately
greeting each other. Together with the kitchen, the hallway is one of the
main domestic sites through which Denis reveals the comfortable daily
rituals and rhythms of Lionel and Jo.9 Lionel confesses to smoking as Jo
brings him his slippers. The sounds of a pan, sizzling on the stove, softly
filter through the scene. Lionel sits to change his shoes while Jo leans her
back to the wall, arching her toes and watching on.
In extending Bachelard’s thinking on object-based reveries to Denis’
film, it is helpful to consider the influence of the French/Polish
philosopher Eugène Minkowski on Bachelard’s later work, especially
his sensuous concept of reverberation (retentir). First trained as a
psychiatrist, Minkowski shifted towards phenomenological philosophy
around the same time that Bachelard was making his own shift towards
studying the imagination. In his 1936 book, Towards a cosmology,
Minkowski maintains that “scientific knowledge is not the only nor the
privileged way of knowing things and the world” (Kockelmans & Kiesel,
1970, p. 236). For Minkowski, anticipating Bachelard’s own later
thinking, there are two modes of looking at the world: the scientific
and the poetic. The scientific look “wants to see facts in rigorous
objectivity and things in their ‘materiality’”; the poetic, by contrast, “does
not impose any barriers upon itself and lets its glance wander to infinity
to discover in each object an entire world” (1936/1970, p. 239, emphasis
added). Whereas the scientist “dissects, opposes, proceeds by means of
abstraction” (p. 246) (knowing the world via objective, empirical
measurements), the poet embodies a different mode of understanding.
As he puts it, the poet “communicates with the whole universe […] the
atmosphere which reverberates around […] is for [them] everything”
(p. 246).
9 Filmed at a distance with a static camera, Denis’ filming of the hallway doubles and
inverts the railway tracks.
16
Claire Denis’ 35 Shots of Rum
17
Film-Philosophy 27 (2023)
18
Claire Denis’ 35 Shots of Rum
Figure 1: 35 Shots of Rum – The rice cooker, chromatic sympathy and reverberation
11 Deleuze (1985/2005, p. 16) cites Ozu’s prolonged shot of the vase in Late Spring as a
still life and an example of the time-image: “Ozu’s still lives endure, have a duration,
over ten seconds of the vase […]”.
19
Film-Philosophy 27 (2023)
Figure 2: 35 Shots of Rum – Reverberation, the red rice cooker and the passing of time
marked shift in tone. The rice has been cooked and eaten; Jo and Lionel’s
time together in their modest apartment has come to an end. Denis holds
on the pair embracing before making a hard cut to moving vehicles and to
Lionel and Jo on the road to Germany.
The final appearance of the rice cookers in 35 Shots of Rum occurs after
the film’s titular drinking game, where Lionel consumes the fabled
number of rum shots on the occasion of Jo’s marriage (presumably to
Noé). Neatly closing the film, Denis loops back to and echoes the film’s
beginning. More specifically, she returns to Jo’s gift, still wrapped in its
red plastic bag from the store. In the film’s final shot, the camera holds on
the kitchen bench and on Lionel, unwrapping Jo’s small pink-and-white
rice cooker and placing it next to the larger, red model. Knowing, only
now, that Jo had made her own thoughtful purchase for the house, he
reaches out to adjust the lid of Jo’s cooker, setting it back into place – a
gentle action, reminiscent of the gesture of adjusting clothing or tendrils
of hair. Before the film cuts to black, Denis lingers on the two rice cookers
side by side (one large, one small), calling up the intimate doublings of
father and daughter that have recurred throughout the film.
As Bachelard alerts us, an “inanimate object [can] open itself to the
greatest of dreams”, leading us to “reverberate to the object drama” that is
imagined by the poet (1960/1971, p. 164). As with the apple that centres
the poet’s cosmos or Ozu’s Late Spring, Denis’ rice cookers overflow their
own material bounds. As object-based reveries, they become Denis’
means of affectively organising and poetically centring the film. More than
20
Claire Denis’ 35 Shots of Rum
just structuring and bookending the film, then, rice cookers reverberate
across it (beyond the discrete scenes in which they feature), bringing the
closeness of Lionel and Jo together with the passing of time. To recall and
slightly alter Bachelard’s words, we might say that the simple object of a
rice cooker “represents the [film’s] world” (1960/1971, p. 153). In 35
Shots of Rum, the rice cookers embody a temporality and a tenderness that
exist well beyond this object’s domestic function.
21
Film-Philosophy 27 (2023)
A profile shot of Lionel at work in the driver’s seat gives way to the
unexpected image of a horse’s hooves, moving across the stones of the
tracks. In this fleeting, fantastical image (a recreation of Goethe’s poem
“Der Erlkönig” by Denis), the sonic rocking of the train combines with
Lionel’s rocking, imagined image of himself and his Jo, riding a horse.
Shot with a freeform, hand-held camera, the sequence is stylistically
distinct from Lionel’s driving or the film’s objective shots of the world.
According to Bachelard, in reverie, a “universe can be born from an
isolated image” (1960/1971, p. 175). Through an image which “has just
charmed” the awakened dreamer, the dreamer inhabits a “unity of reverie,
a unity of world” (p. 175). As Lionel and Jo ride through the wind, the
camera whips about, moving abruptly from Lionel’s hands on the bridle
to shots of the horse’s ears and its whipping mane. Denis then suddenly
cuts back to a suburban train station, returning the film’s focus to the
tracks.
Just as science cannot fully account for the child’s curious look at a star
in Minkowski, objective spatial coordinates cannot map the imagination
in Bachelard. Similarly, for Denis, the systemic operations of the world
(including a map of the RER network) are not the same as a train-based
reverie.12 In re-locating the film’s setting from suburban Paris to the
natural world, Denis employs a series of charmed images to stage another
pivotal sequence in 35 Shots of Rum. To figure the intimate bonds of Lionel
and Jo, their separation and the fleetingness of time itself, she employs
another charged poetic object: the child’s lantern.
In Lübeck, Lionel and Jo brush autumn leaves away from the gravesite
of Jo’s mother. Resting on a nearby bench, they share a hot drink. After the
film cuts to an overhead shot of leaves in the trees, the sound of the wind
picks up, rushing through the scene. An extended shot of beach grass
follows, moved by gusting winds. Re-orienting the film’s previous sense of
scale and location, the view of a sombre toned beach and overcast sky is
seen, framed through the small window of Lionel and Jo’s campervan. By
the seaside in their campervan, Lionel and Jo huddle together against the
winds. Here, Denis once again underscores Lionel and Jo’s synchronicity
through small-scale, intimate and domestic imagery. Inside the van, Jo
washes the dishes, pausing to hand Lionel an opener as he pulls a beer
from the van’s fridge. In the Lübeck scenes, Denis embeds Lionel and Jo’s
togetherness into a larger, environmental sense of diffusion (wind gusts,
falling leaves, the lapping of the sea).
12 The objective and the poetic are not an either/or equation. Via Bachelard and
Minkowski, what I am suggesting is that both systems inform 35 Shots of Rum.
22
Claire Denis’ 35 Shots of Rum
23
Film-Philosophy 27 (2023)
24
Claire Denis’ 35 Shots of Rum
sounds of the coastal wind and the children’s song. Cutting to another set
of children toting rounded lanterns and another lantern parade, Denis’
film begins to take on an increasingly bittersweet tone. The children’s
singing has cut out, replaced by the touching yet elegiac “Lanterns”.
As the children move forward in blue-tinted light (inhabiting the in-
between of twilight and nightfall), they swing flickering lanterns. Their
lanterns glow red, amber and gold, creating the glimmering effect of
bouncing brightly-coloured orbs.
In The poetics of space and The poetics of reverie, Bachelard describes how
the imagination can transform objects and their surroundings, endowing
them with associations or affective qualities that exceed their objective
size, shape and dimension. Through their dimension-changing possibi-
lities, intimately imagined images (a nest, a child’s lantern) can bring
about wondrous, even world-expanding moments. Through intensity in
the “intimate domain”, Bachelard writes, we often experience an
“intensity of being” (1958/1994, p. 193). For Bachelard, intensity is
very much a temporal concept. It is premised upon change and transition:
the “intensity of a being evolving” (p. 193).
Inspired by Bachelard’s writing, Kristupas Sabolius suggests that a
moment of reverberation can not only alter our perception of things but
change our own internal, rhythmical settings. A “single and immediate
image can touch the whole world” through its evocations of an “echoing
25
Film-Philosophy 27 (2023)
26
Claire Denis’ 35 Shots of Rum
breaks down on the way to the concert; René’s suicide, stopping Lionel’s
train on its tracks; the sounds of a coffee pot bubbling over Lionel and Jo’s
seaside holiday, bringing with it the morning of Jo’s wedding day. If
reverie and repose encourage wellbeing, as Bachelard (1960/1971, p. 182)
proposes, then 35 Shots of Rum repeatedly cuts its own peacefulness short.
By repeating the stop-start motions of reverie itself, Denis’ film powerfully,
poetically reverberates – recalling those moments in which we find
ourselves jolted out of pleasant daydreams.
ORCID
Saige Walton https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5213-2484
REFERENCES
Bachelard, G. (1960/1971). The poetics of reverie: Childhood, language and the cosmos
(D. Russell, Trans.). Beacon Press.
Bachelard, G. (1958/1994). The poetics of space: The classical look at how we experience
intimate places (M. Jolas, Trans.). Beacon Press.
Bachelard, G. (1936/2000). The dialectic of duration (M. Jones, Trans.). Clinamen Press.
Bachelard, G. (1943/2011). Air and dreams: An essay on the imagination of movement
(E. Farrell & F. Farrell, Trans.). Dallas Institute Publications.
Bachelard, G. (1948/2011). Earth and reveries of repose: An essay on images of interiority
(M. Jones, Trans.). Dallas Institute Publications.
Bachelard, G. (1932/2013). Intuition of the instant (E. Rizo-Patron, Trans.). Northwestern
University Press.
Beugnet, M. (2014). ‘To let the image sing’: Conversations with Dickon Hinchliffe and
Stuart Staples. In M. Vecchio (Ed.), The Films of Claire Denis: Intimacy on the Border
(pp. 3–11). I. B. Tauris & Co.
Bíró, Y. (2009). A subtle story: 35 shots of rum. Film Quarterly, 63(2), 38–43. https://doi.
org/10.1525/fq.2009.63.2.38
Chimisso, C. (2000). Introduction. In G. Bachelard, The dialectic of duration (M. Jones,
Trans.) (pp. 1–13). Clinamen Press.
Davis, R. (2009, March 10). Interview: Claire Denis on 35 shots of rum. Daily Plastic. http://
www.dailyplastic.com/2009/03/interview-claire-denis-on-35-shots-of-rum/
Deleuze, G. (1985/2005). Cinema 2: The time-image (H. Tomlinson & R. Galeta, Trans.).
Continuum.
Galt, R. (2014). Claire Denis and the world cinema of refusal. Substance, 43(1),
96–108.
Kearney, R. (1991). Poetics of imagining: Modern to post-modern. Edinburgh University
Press.
Kockelmans, J. J., & Kiesel, T. J. (1970). Eugène Minkowski. In J. J. Kockelmans &
T. J. Kiesel (Eds.), Phenomenology and the natural sciences: Essays and translations
(pp. 235–237). Northwestern University Press.
Lee, K. (2009, April 2). Spectacularly intimate: An interview with Claire Denis. MUBI
Notebook. https://mubi.com/notebook/posts/spectacularly-intimate-an-interview-with-
claire-denis
27
Film-Philosophy 27 (2023)
Lim, D. (2009, September 4). Finding rhythms within rhythms in Parisians’ lives. The
New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/06/movies/06lim.html
Martin, A. (2006). Ticket to ride: Claire Denis and the cinema of the body. Screening the
Past, 20. https://www.screeningthepast.com/issue-20-first-release/ticket-to-ride-claire-
denis-and-the-cinema-of-the-body/
Mazis, G. (2016). Merleau-Ponty and the face of the world: Silence, ethics, imagination and
poetic ontology. SUNY Press.
Mazis, G. (2017). Bachelard’s poetic ontology. In E. Rizo-Patron, E. S. Casey, & J. M. Wirth
(Eds.), Adventures in phenomenology: Gaston Bachelard (pp. 127–140). State University of
New York Press.
Minkowski, E. (1936/1970). Prose and poetry (astronomy and cosmology)
(J. J. Kockelmans, Trans.). In J. J Kockelmans & T. J. Kiesel (Eds.), Phenomenology and
the natural sciences: Essays and translations (pp. 239–248). Northwestern University
Press.
Moran, S. (2009, July 3). 35 shots of rum: Interview with Claire Denis. Electric
Sheep Magazine. http://www.electricsheepmagazine.co.uk/2009/07/03/35-shots-of-
rum-interview-with-claire-denis/
Préclaire, M. (2017). Bachelard’s open solitude (E. Rizo-Patron, Trans.) In E. Rizo-Patron,
E. S. Casey, & J. M. Wirth (Eds.), Adventures in phenomenology: Gaston Bachelard
(pp. 259–269). State University of New York Press.
Sabolius, K. (2012). Reaching imaginary places: Resonance and reverberation. Altre
Modernità, 105–117. https://doi.org/10.13130/2035-7680/2409
Soudaigne, C. (2008). 35 Shots of Rum press kit, 65th Venice International Film Festival,
AFI Research Collection Archives, Melbourne, Australia.
Walton, S. (2020). Sleeping away the factory, healing with time: Gaston Bachelard, the
poetic imagination and Testről és lélekről/On body and soul (2017). Paragraph, 43(3),
348–363. https://doi.org/10.3366/para.2020.0345
Wheatley, C. (2009). Steady she goes. Sight & Sound, 19(8), 40–43, 45.
Williams, J. (2009). Romancing the father in Claire Denis’s 35 shots of rum. Film Quarterly,
63(2), 44–50. https://doi.org/10.1525/FQ.2009.63.2.44
Wright, L. (2017). Retentir: A poetics of the railway station. Scrutiny2, 21(3), 37–56.
https://doi.org/10.1080/18125441.2016.1190397
28