Professional Documents
Culture Documents
26PNEFor - Web Munhoz MSP
26PNEFor - Web Munhoz MSP
net/publication/303976962
CITATIONS READS
4 32,298
1 author:
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Etiene Andrade Munhoz on 24 January 2018.
Virgínia Annett Polli, Mariane Beatriz Sordi, Mariah Luz Lisboa, Etiene de Andrade Munhoz*
and Alessandra Rodrigues de Camargo
Department of Dentistry, Health Science Centre, Federal University of Santa Catarina, 88040-900,
Florianópolis, Brazil
Abstract: The dental management of special needs patients creates doubt and anxiety among dentists. The theme is
underexplored throughout the undergraduate course and the dentists have not enough theoretical foundation to work on
this field. Special needs patients are those individuals who have permanent or transitory mental, physical, organic social
and / or behavioral impairments. Thus, the aim of this study was to assist dentists in the best dental management choice
for special needs patients. It was revised and more specifically detailed the management on dental base office, the
management under sedation and under general anesthesia, and home care treatments for patients with special needs,
with the aim of developing guidelines on management of dental patients with special health care needs to facilitate the
execution of dental treatment of these patients. From this literature review, we proposed a guideline to assist the dentist
in choosing the best therapeutic approach for the dental treatment of patients with special needs.
*
Address correspondence to this author at the Department of In order to conduct the proposed literature review, a
Dentistry, Health Science Centre, Federal University of Santa bibliographic research was performed in the database
Catarina, s/n, Delfino Conte Street, Trindade, Florianópolis, 88040-
900, Brazil; Tel: +55 (48) 3721-9520; E-mail: etiamfob@yahoo.com PubMed / Medline with the following descriptors: “Dent-
Author Contributions: All authors equally contributed to this paper istry/Special needs/Sedation”; “Dentistry/Special needs/
with conception and design of the study, literature review and General anesthesia”; “Dentistry/Special needs/Home
analysis, drafting and critical revision and editing, and final approval
of the final version. care”; “Special patients/Dental treatment”; “Risks/
Sedation/Dentistry”; “Domiciliary care/Dentistry”; and clinical examination. If possible, any dental, gingivo-
“Risks/General anesthesia/Dentistry”. The article search periodontal and soft tissue pathology must be
was restricted to the years 1999-2015. Systematic and noted. At least one panoramic X-ray must be taken
non-systematic reviews, studies on series of cases and as complementary exame. If necessary for the
research articles were considered to structure this diagnosis, additional periapical and/or occlusal X-
study. rays must be taken as well.
3.1. Management of the Patients with Special Needs 1. Violent movement constantly interrupting examination
2. Constant movements that hinder examination
For patients with neurological motor disorders, the
initial clinical assessment requires three steps: 3. Controllable movements that do not interfere with the procedure
4. Lack of movement
A. Evaluation of General Health: The first step starts
with a complete health questionnaire to be fulfilled
by the parents of the SNP. The medical history must After completing the three steps of the clinical assess-
explore physician reports, including any hospital ment, the most appropriate treatment plan for each
treatment, medications in use, health problems, patient must be drawn and classified by quadrants/
warning situations, alimentary habits and other sextants. Prioritization of therapeutic needs (preventive,
important medical information. conservative, surgical) must be performed as follows:
B. Evaluation of Oral Health: The evaluation of oral Preventive treatment, which includes systematic
health status starts considering prior treatments and scaling/cleaning and fluor application, also the
the reasons of consultation, before performing the placement of sealants;
Dental Management of Special Needs Patients Global Journal of Oral Science, 2016, Vol. 2, 35
The aid sustains the patient's head in order to shows the different types of medication that may be
stabilizes or support it (Figure 3); used in an outpatient setting by the dentist in order to
perform mild and / or moderate sedation for implement-
These techniques may be employed to short dental ing dental treatment. The table also presents the side
visits, in which preventive, restorative, and/or surgical effects of each sedative [12,14].
treatments - as described above - can be performed
before the attempted pharmacological restraint. The guideline developed by the Australian and New
Zealand College of Anesthesiologists [15], indicates the
Sedation obtained through oral medication - mild or risks involved in this technique, such as: depression of
moderate - may be an important and very useful option protective airway reflexes and loss of airway perme-
in dental treatment of SNP, since the sedatives are a ability; breath depression; depression of the cardiovas-
safe and effective way to contain the patient, with the cular system; drug interactions or adverse reactions,
advantage of being prescribed by the dentist for including anaphylaxis; unexpected high sensitivity to
outpatient use [12]. According to the American Dental drugs used for sedation and / or procedural analgesia
Association [13], sedation represents a minimal depre- that could result in inadvertent loss of consciousness,
ssion of levels of consciousness that keeps the pat- respiratory depression and / or cardiovascular depre-
ient's ability to maintain independently and continuous- ssion; individual variations in response to medicines
ly his airway, responding appropriately to physical used, particularly in the children, the elderly and those
stimulation or verbal communication. The loss of con- with pre-existing disease [15].
sciousness levels is produced by pharmacological or
non-pharmacological method, or a combination of both In order to minimize or avoid these risks, the dentist
[8,13]. must have a basic service support emergency kit,
composed of Ambu (manual ventilator), stethoscope
The sedation procedure can be performed using an
and sphygmomanometer, oxygen cylinder, Guedel
evolutionary scale for choice of drug, namely: benzo-
cannula, insulin syringe, scalpel, oximetry, epinephrine,
diazepines, nitrous oxide, antihistamines and hypnotics
antihistamines, Captopril 12.5 mg, Hydrochlorithiazide
(barbiturics and non-barbiturics). It is also possible to
25 mg, Dimenhydrinate 50 mg and Pyridoxine Hydro-
prescribe opioids for ambulatorial use, although with
chloride 10 mg, physiological saline, children's aspirin,
some more caution. For deep sedation, the drugs used
Isosorbide Dinitrate 5mg and sachet of carbohydrate or
are propofol and the neuroleptics, but these medica-
glucose 50%. The dentist also must have the course of
tions should be used in a hospital setting [14]. Table 3
Dental Management of Special Needs Patients Global Journal of Oral Science, 2016, Vol. 2, 37
Table 3: Medications, Indications, Contraindications and Side Effects of Different Drugs Used for Mild, Moderate and
Deep Sedation in the Dental Treatment
Basic Life Support (BLS), so that in any situation, the that causes loss of consciousness where the individual
professional knows how to handle emergency situa- does not respond to painful stimuli and losses the abi-
tions that endanger the life and physical and / or mental lity to maintain ventilatory and neuromuscular function
integrity of the patient [16]. independently. Mandatorily, this approach should be
performed in a hospital setting, with the assistance of
Due to severe health impairments and the less the anesthesiologist [13].
cooperative level of some patients with the dental
treatment, procedures under general anesthesia are In dentistry there is not a determining classification
very useful in some clinical situations [17] The ADA that helps the dentist in the choice of general anes-
(2009) considers general anesthesia as a procedure thesia. Thus, the SNP risk analysis indicated for gene-
38 Global Journal of Oral Science, 2016, Vol. 2 Polli et al.
ral anesthesia must be directed to the American Society tages and disadvantages of this anesthesic modality in
of Anesthesiologists (ASA), based on the physical dentistry [22].
condition of each patient [18]: ASA I - Patients without
organical, physiological, biochemical and / or psychol- Different than other therapies, home care aims to
ogical alterations. There are no systemic changes; ASA target the dental approach for those bedridden indi-
II - Patients with mild or moderate systemic disease viduals or unable to get around their homes [23].The
caused by pathophysiological phenomenon or by the purpose of home care is to provide differentiated dental
condition to be treated surgically; ASA III - Patients with service, offering specific care by a qualified profess-
very intense organical changes or pathological dis- ional, including the participation of relatives or guard-
orders of any cause, even if it is not possible to define ians. The procedures performed in the home setting
the degree of the organical incapacity; ASA IV – Pat- aim at removing odontogenic infection, in addition to
ients with severe general disorders, endangering their performing preventive procedures such as hygiene
lives, not able to be corrected by surgery; ASA V - instructions to the patient, carers and guardians [24].
Moribund patient, with few chances to survive, they
Although the home dental care might be a challenge
undergo surgery as a last resort; and ASA VI - Patient
for the dentist - due to space limitations, inadequate
with declared cerebral death [18].
posture, insufficient lighting, reduced access to imaging
According to the World Health Organization (WHO), exams, less control over unforeseen events, emergen-
approximately 8% of people with disabilities present cies and lack of biosecurity –it is an extremely import-
indication of dental treatment under general anes- ant activity for the care of the SNP [5].
thesia. In a dental context, systemic health condition
There are four main types of home care, according
should be evaluated together with the anesthesiology
to the physical and cognitive status of the patient: 1)
team and the costs and benefits of the therapeutic ap-
Required emergency treatment: aims to treat pain or
proach discussed between both teams and family [19].
diseases that severely influence the general health of
Among the contraindications of the technique is the the patient. In these cases, the treatment is performed
independently of the patient's collaboration; 2) Nece-
old age, decompensated systemic diseases, physical
ssary treatment - Severe: aims to preserve oral and
limitations that may interfere with physiological func-
general health of the patient, the latter being able and /
tions, specific syndromes with psychological and ana-
or aware of receiving dental treatment; 3) Necessary
tomical abnormalities, pediatric patients with congenital
treatment - Moderate: the patient may have restrictions
heart disease and / or physical disabilities, mental
to cooperate and may require prior medication (sedat-
illness or cognitive disorder, and other complex medical
ives) to the dental care, in this case it is evaluated the
conditions [20]. Absolute contraindications are also
benefit of the treatment in relation to the stress that the
mentioned, so the professional should be aware of febr-
patient might have; and 4) No need for treatment: in
ile conditions, colds, respiratory infections or decom-
this case, the patient may be in a persistent vegetative
pensated heart failure that compromise the general
state, or may have a good oral function, not presenting
anesthesia execution [21]. Table 4 shows the advan-
oral diseases [25].
Advantages Disadvantages
The cooperation of the patient The unconsciousness of the individual during the procedure
is not absolutely essential (it is considered advantage and disadvantage at the same time)
The patient is unconscious during treatment The patient's protective reflexes are depressed
The therapy does not cause pain Vital signs are depressed
The drugs used cause anterograde amnesia It requires advanced training for administration of general anesthesia (medical team)
--- The need for a professional team (not just the dentist) for conducting the proposed treatment
--- Must necessarily be performed in a hospital environment, including post-operative monitoring
Complications in the trans-surgical and post-operative are more common in procedures
---
performed under general anesthetic induction
Dental Management of Special Needs Patients Global Journal of Oral Science, 2016, Vol. 2, 39
3.2. Decision-Making About Treatment Modality – patient, and the advantages and disadvantages of
Behavior Scales using each of them (Table 3) [12,14]. The outpatient
sedation technique should only be performed by quali-
The indications described below were based on our fied professionals. All support for any complications
clinical experience, the amended Frankl scale (Table 1) must be available and ready for use at the dental ap-
[9] and the scale developed by Houpt and co-workers pointment. Regarding the assessment of the underlying
(Table 2) [10]. This should not be used systematically disease, it is suggested this technique for patients ASA
for the convenience of the dental team, but rather should I and ASA II.
be seen as the last resource for protocol treatment.
The proposed protocols were classified in three main - General Anesthesia: We advocated that general
groups: anesthesia must be considered for patients classified in
categories 1 and 2 (Tables 1 and 2) [9,10]. The use of
- Conditions Techniques and / or Physical the technique requires the participation of a multidisci-
Support: Patients in categories 3 and 4 (Tables 1 and plinary team in a hospital setting. The hospital routine
2) [9,10] who are cooperative with dental treatment but, must be respected. The cooperation of the patient is
eventually, do not show clear signs of interacting verb- not required in this modality. Regarding the assess-
ally with the dentist. Many patients are collaborative ment of the underlying disease, it is suggested this
even though they are not able to carry out interactive technique for patients ASA I to ASA IV.
communication with the dentist because their special
conditions; 3.3. Guidelines of Service
Figure 4: Sedation sequence. Materials used: Midazolam, distilled water, disposable syringe, 2 ml of gooseberry juice. Mixture
of the macerated sedative with the distilled water, and addition of 2 ml of the gooseberry juice. Sedative administration.
40 Global Journal of Oral Science, 2016, Vol. 2 Polli et al.
Step 1 - Initial Assessment of the Patient: Comple- ive, restorative and surgical treatment can be per-
tion of a health questionnaire, including medical history, formed and concluded in different approaches.
physician reports, hospital treatments, medications in
use, health problems, alimentary habits and behavior. Step 6 - Documentation: All the procedures should
Patients included in category 2 (Tables 1 and 2) are be documented, reporting the sedative drugs and the
potential for intervention. local anesthetics administered, as well as the doses
and the pre / postoperative medications. The description
Step 2 - Preoperative Evaluation: Medical assess- of the dental procedure performed is also part of this
ment by the team which manage the patient; request of description.
laboratory exams about the clinical state; verbal and
written instructions to the patient and / or guardian Step 7 - Patient Discharge: It is necessary that the
about the pre, intra and postoperative procedures; patient is capable to walk with minimal assistance.
informed consent form of the patient and / or guardian; Postoperative pain and bleeding should be minimal or
dietary restrictions of 4 hours without ingesting solids absent. The patient should be accompanied by a res-
and liquids; evaluation of the patient's vital signs (blood ponsible person who will receive verbally and written
pressure and respiratory rate). postoperative orientations [12].
A B C
D E F
G H I
Figure 5: Materials used for general anesthesia. A) Surgical center. B) Anesthesia and monitoring device. C) Portable
compressor for micro motor. D) Photopolymerizer. E) Ultrasound. F, G and H) Dental instruments. I) Sterile gauze.
A B C
D E F
G H I
Figure 6: Dental procedures performed in hospital. A and B) Approximated and extended view of the prepared patient to
receive dental care. C) Prevention procedure using ultrasound. D) Patient receiving local anesthesia for local tissue ischemia. E,
F and G) Endodontic procedures. H, I) Restorative procedures.
Step 5 – Dental Treatment: The use of general ment. Preventive, restorative and surgical treatment
anesthesia is indicated for cases of more complex can be performed and concluded in a single appoint-
dental problems, which involve extensive dental treat- ment.
42 Global Journal of Oral Science, 2016, Vol. 2 Polli et al.
Step 6 - Documentation: The whole procedure tory, physician reports, hospital treatments, medica-
must be documented, reporting the name of the admin- tions in use, health problems, alimentary habits and
istered inducing drugs and anesthetics (local and gene- level of cooperation. Patients included in categories 3
ral), the doses and the pre and postoperative medi- and 4 (Tables 1 and 2) are potential for intervention.
cations.
Step 2 - Preoperative Evaluation: Medical assess-
Step 7 - Recovery Room: Postoperative care relat- ment by the team which manage the patient; request of
ed to the type of the dental procedure performed. Drug laboratory exams linked to the clinical state; verbal and
prescription must be maintained as used in the operat- written instructions to the patient and / or guardian
ing room. The patient care is responsability of the hos- about the pre, intra and postoperative procedures;
pital nursing team. informed consent form of the patient and / or guardian;
dietary restrictions according to the underlying disease.
Step 8 - Hospital Liberation: For dental procedures
without complications, patient will be released between Step 3 - Professionals and Equipment: It is re-
1-2 days. Anesthetic liberation is liability of the res- quested two dentists. The necessary equipments are
ponsible anesthesiologist. presented in Table 5.
A B
C D
Figure 7: Illustrative sequence of home care. A) House layout to receive the dental team. B) Portable equipment before
installing. C) Dental assistance. D) Portable equipment installed and ready for use (equipment consists of portable compressor,
outputs for micro motor, multifunction syringe and aspirator).
Dental Management of Special Needs Patients Global Journal of Oral Science, 2016, Vol. 2, 43
Step 5 – Dental Treatment: The most favorable matter, we consider that the use of proposed on the
cases are those in which the dental needs are small amended Frankl scale [9] and scale developed by
and easily resolved with short appointments. Prevent- Houpt and co-workers [10], can be useful tool to
ive, restorative and surgical treatment can be perform- analyze behavior as a basis for dental treatment [11].
ed and concluded in different approaches.
The main aim of this study was to perform a litera-
Step 6 - Documentation: Every procedure should ture review targeted at dentists who are unfamiliar with
be documented, reporting each drug used (ie. admin- this area, in order to learn about different management
istered local anesthetics and pre / postoperative medi- techniques considered for dental care of patients with
cations). special needs. As to facilitate the access and the
understanding of the subject addressed, the goal was
to elaborate guidelines of dental care for different tech-
4. DISCUSSION
niques based on the available literature. The theoretical
basis necessary to develop this literature review was a
In the scientific literature there are no studies that
address the use of different techniques directed to the challenge for the small amount of published works on
the subject.
management of special needs patients, from outpatient
clinic approach - with the help of conditioning and
As a starting point, we tried to facilitate the identifi-
physical support techniques – to general anesthesia,
cation of primary signals to be recognized on each pat-
placing them at an increasing scale choice.
ient, so that the dentist might choose the best thera-
peutic approach. For the preparation of the protocols
This scarcity exists by the magnitude of the subject
presented in this work, we based our review on manu-
involved. The area of special needs patients has as
als of the American Dental Association [13], Australian
object of study heterogeneous subgroups of patients,
whose classification ranges from oncological, infec- and New Zealand College of Anaesthetists [15] and on
our clinical experience, which were reinforced with
tious, psychiatric, chronic, systemic diseases to genetic
images of cases performed by the authors. The seda-
disorders in adults and children. Thus, in order to focus
tion and general anesthesia guidelines proposed by
this subject, it is necessary initially to define the study
subgroup to which it is addressed. this study differ from the above protocols once they
present a more dynamic and practical profile, with
Behavioral management, physical constraint and simplified topics.
sedation techniques are more described in pediatric
Furthermore, the guideline presented here com-
dentistry specialty [19]. However, they do not take into
consideration many of the anatomical and neurological prises additional information, such as references to the
medication used for sedation, in addition to risks and
changes that occur in patients with neuro-psychomotor
directions on their use. Maybe this could be the differ-
disturbances that might difficult the use of such tech-
ential of this study since, when compared to other
niques. It is based on this prerogative that profe-
protocols, it was observed that not all authors cite this
ssionals end up basing their behavior on the clinical
particular content or gather the information of the three
experience acquired throughout their lives. In this
44 Global Journal of Oral Science, 2016, Vol. 2 Polli et al.
afore mentioned assistance options [5,8,13,15,17,19, used by dentists that are not familiar with this area on
20,26,27]. the professional clinical routine.
lutionary guideline destined to a better therapy – seda- [12] Coke JM, Edwards MD. Minimal and moderate oral sedation
in the adult special needs patient. Dent Clin N Am. 2009; 53:
tion, general anesthesia or home care - for dental treat- 221-230.
ment of special needs patients with neuro psychomotor http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cden.2008.12.005
disorders. This was the first time in the literature that a [13] American Dental Association (ADA) guidelines for the use of
sedation and general anesthesia by dentists. 2009; 1-12.
scientific work discussed and compared the different
[14] Saraghi M, Badner VM, Golden LR, Hersh EV. Propofol: an
therapeutic modalities involved in the dental treatment overview of its risks and benefits. Compend Contin Educ
of special needs patients. We hope this guide could be Dent. 2013; 34(4): 252-8.
Dental Management of Special Needs Patients Global Journal of Oral Science, 2016, Vol. 2, 45
[15] Australian and New Zealand College of Anaesthetists. Association of Hospital Dentists the Academy of Dentistry for
Guidelines on Sedation and/or Analgesia for Diagnostic and the Handicapped and the American Society for Geriatric
Interventional Medical, Dental or Surgical Procedures. PS09. Dentistry. 2009; 29: 17-20.
2014. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1754-4505.2008.00057.x
[16] Haas D. Management of Medical Emergencies in the Dental [23] Miller CE. Preventing dental disease for people with special
Office: Conditions in Each Country, the Extent of Treatment needs: the need for practical preventive protocols for use in
by the Dentist AnesthProg. 2006; 53(1): 20-24. community settings. Special Care Dent. 2003; 23(5): 165-
[17] Wang YC, Lin IH, Huang CH, Fan SZ. Dental anesthesia for 167.
patients with special needs. Acta Anaesthesiol Taiwan 2012; http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1754-4505.2003.tb00305.x
50(3): 122-5.
[24] Fiske J, Griffiths J, Jamieson R, Manger D. Guidelines for
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.aat.2012.08.009 oral health care for long-stay patients and residents. Gerod-
[18] Zambouri A. Preoperative evaluation and preparation for ontology 2000; 17(1): 55-64.
anesthesia and surgery. Hippokratia 2007; 11(1): 13-21. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1741-2358.2000.00055.x
[19] Townsend JA, Martin A, Hagan JL, Needleman H. The user [25] Nederfors T, Paulsson G, Fridlund B. Ability to estimate oral
of local anesthesia during dental rehabilitations: a survey of health status and treatment need in elderly receiving home
AAPD members. Pediatr Dent. 2013; 35: 422-425. nursing--a comparison between a dental hygienist and a
[20] Messihea Z. Risks of general anesthesia for the special dentist. Swed Dent J. 2000; 24(3): 105-16.
needs dental patient. Special care in dentistry : official [26] Glassman P, Subar P. Planning dental treatment for people
publication of the American Association of Hospital Dentists, with special needs. Dent Clin N Am. 2009; 53(2): 195-205.
the Academy of Dentistry for the Handicapped, and the
American Society for Geriatric Dentistry. 2008; 29 (1): 21-25; http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cden.2008.12.010
quiz 67-68. [27] Chen X, Clark JJJ, Naorungroj S. Oral health in nursing home
[21] Bennett JD, Kramer KJ, Bosack RC. How safe is deep residents with different cognitive statuses. Gerodontology
sedation or general anesthesia while providing dental care? J 2013; 30(1): 49-60.
Am Dent Assoc. 2015; 146(9): 705-8. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1741-2358.2012.00644.x
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.adaj.2015.04.005 [28] American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry. Guideline on
[22] Dougherty N. The dental patient with special needs: a review Management of Dental Patients with Special Health Care
of indications for treatment under general anesthesia. Needs. student.ahc.umn.edu. 2012; 34(5): 160-165.
Special care in dentistry official publication of the American