Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CP - AAP 2022 Providing A Primary Care Medical Home For Children With Cerebral Palsy
CP - AAP 2022 Providing A Primary Care Medical Home For Children With Cerebral Palsy
Cerebral palsy (CP) is the most common motor disorder of childhood, abstract
with prevalence estimates ranging from 1.5 to 4 in 1000 live births.
a
This clinical report seeks to provide primary care physicians with Nationwide Children's Hospital, The Ohio State University, Columbus,
Ohio; and bThe Children's Hospital at Montefiore, Albert Einstein
guidance to detect children with CP; collaborate with specialists in College of Medicine, Bronx, New York
treating the patient; manage associated medical, developmental, and
All authors reviewed the literature, drafted the manuscript,
behavioral problems; and provide general medical care to their patients critically edited the content, and approved the final manuscript as
with CP. submitted.
This document is copyrighted and is property of the American
Academy of Pediatrics and its Board of Directors. All authors have
filed conflict of interest statements with the American Academy of
Pediatrics. Any conflicts have been resolved through a process
Cerebral palsy (CP) is the most common motor disorder of childhood, approved by the Board of Directors. The American Academy of
Pediatrics has neither solicited nor accepted any commercial
with prevalence estimates ranging from 1.5 to 4 per 1000 live births.1,2 involvement in the development of the content of this publication.
In resource-abundant countries, the incidence among newborn infants Clinical reports from the American Academy of Pediatrics benefit
may be decreasing because of advances in perinatal care.3 from expertise and resources of liaisons and internal (AAP) and
external reviewers. However, clinical reports from the American
Academy of Pediatrics may not reflect the views of the liaisons or
All physicians who provide care for children must be familiar with the the organizations or government agencies that they represent.
definition, manifestations, and management of CP. This clinical report The guidance in this report does not indicate an exclusive course
updates previous guidance4 and specifically seeks to provide of treatment or serve as a standard of medical care. Variations,
taking into account individual circumstances, may be appropriate.
pediatricians, other physicians caring for children, and nonphysician
All clinical reports from the American Academy of Pediatrics
clinicians with guidance to detect CP in children; collaborate with automatically expire 5 years after publication unless reaffirmed,
specialists treating patients with CP; manage the medical, revised, or retired at or before that time.
developmental, and behavioral problems associated with CP; and DOI: https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2022-060055
provide general medical care to their patients with CP. Address correspondence to Garey Noritz, MD, FAAP, FACP. E-mail: garey.
noritz@nationwidechildrens.org
Definitions PEDIATRICS (ISSN Numbers: Print, 0031-4005; Online, 1098-4275).
As our understanding of CP has changed in recent years, it is helpful to Copyright © 2022 by the American Academy of Pediatrics
start with a common definition of the condition. The most current
consensus definition of 2006 states that “cerebral palsy describes a To cite: Noritz G, Davidson L, Steingass K, et al; AAP Council on
group of permanent disorders of the development of movement and Children With Disabilities, THE AMERICAN ACADEMY FOR
posture, causing activity limitation, that are attributed to non- CEREBRAL PALSY AND DEVELOPMENTAL MEDICINE. Providing a
Primary Care Medical Home for Children and Youth With
progressive disturbances that occurred in the developing fetal or infant Cerebral Palsy. Pediatrics. 2022;150(6):e2022060055
brain. The motor disorders of cerebral palsy are often accompanied by
PEDIATRICS Volume 150, number 6, December 2022:e2022060055 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS
Downloaded from http://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article-pdf/150/6/e2022060055/1407853/peds_2022060055.pdf
by Children's National Medical Center user
disturbances of sensation, perception, higher-order functions (running, It is important to describe the type of
cognition, communication, and jumping, etc) to significant disability, motor or movement disorder that is
behavior, by epilepsy, and by in which children are transported by present, because it can give clues as to
secondary musculoskeletal others in a wheelchair and are often the location of the brain disorder and
problems.”5 dependent on others for their care inform the types of treatment that
and activities of daily living. A could be offered. Abnormality in tone,
The term CP describes a group of common system for describing gross particularly spasticity, is most
disorders or what may be considered motor abilities in CP is the Gross common. Spasticity is “velocity-
a phenotype. It is considered a dependent” hypertonia that increases
Motor Functional Classification
phenotype because there are different with greater speed of passive joint
System (GMFCS);9 see Fig 1. The
brain disturbances that can result range of motion. Spasticity is usually
GMFCS is easy for patients and
in a common clinical picture of associated with damage to white
families to comprehend and is fairly
motor disability. These include matter tracts. Dystonia is both a tone
stable over time, especially after the
intrauterine and perinatal infections, disorder and a movement disorder in
age of 2 years;10,11 future gross motor
intraventricular hemorrhage, hypoxic- which involuntary sustained or
ischemic encephalopathy, stroke, function can be predicted from
current functioning with some, but intermittent muscle contractions cause
cerebral malformations, genetic twisting and repetitive movements,
disorders, and several others. In the not perfect, certainty. Families have
indicated a desire to understand their abnormal postures, or both. Dystonia
past, CP was assumed to be often coexists with spasticity and can
attributable to an injury to the brain child’s motor function using the
be associated with abnormalities in
in the birth process, but it is now GMFCS as well as a desire to revisit it
the basal ganglia (Table 1).15 Less
known that <10% of cases are over time.12 The Manual Ability
common movement patterns include
related to perinatal asphyxia.6 Most Classification System is a systematic
ataxia (abnormal, uncoordinated
children with low Apgar scores do not way to describe how individuals with
movements), athetosis (continuous,
develop CP, and most children with CP use their hands together to
involuntary writhing movements),
CP had high Apgar scores.7 As many manage daily activities such as eating,
chorea (brief, irregular contractions
as 30% of patients likely have a dressing, and playing.13 The
that are not repetitive or rhythmic but
genetic etiology for their CP.8 Communication Functional
appear to flow from 1 muscle to the
Classification System (CFCS) describes
next), or some combination of these.
These etiologies are permanent and communication abilities.14
nonprogressive, in that the brain When these are present, referral to a
specialist can be helpful for diagnosis
disturbance is not ongoing or “Topography” refers to the parts of
worsening; however, the physical and management. An individual
the body affected by CP. The brain
manifestations of movement and patient’s tone may evolve over time.
may be affected unilaterally or
posture problems can change over For instance, many children with CP
bilaterally, leading either to unilateral
time. CP is not considered static in are hypotonic in infancy and early
or bilateral symptoms. Purely
that sense. For example, changes in childhood, especially in the trunk, with
unilateral brain abnormalities are not
gait, pain, or posture may be related spasticity and dystonia emerging later.
very common, although patients may
to the underlying CP as a result of Management of spasticity and dystonia
have bilateral abnormalities with is discussed later in the paper.
worsening contractures, poorly clinical findings notably more
controlled tone, or progressive An Integrated Approach
pronounced on one side than the
subluxation or dislocation of a hip,
other. “Hemiplegic CP” indicates Although CP is a motor disorder
etc. However, symptoms ought not
predominantly unilateral involvement. caused by a disturbance in the brain,
to be assumed to be related to CP
Bilateral symptoms may be described difficulties in other areas of the
without proper investigation into
as “quadriplegia” if all 4 limbs are nervous system and nonneurologic
other causes.
affected, “diplegia” if the legs are comorbidities may exist. Common
Clinicians and researchers have predominantly affected, or “triplegia” problems include epilepsy, cognitive
attempted to use a common language if there is relative sparing of 1 arm. and communication issues,
to describe various attributes of Topography alone does not predict respiratory symptoms, gastrointestinal
patients with CP; many of these terms function; some children with and urinary problems, and pain.
will be used throughout this report. quadriplegia may be able to ambulate These will be discussed in detail in
In terms of motor abilities, children and some with diplegia may not. this clinical report. In addition to
with CP exhibit a wide range of Motor function is graded using the providing general medical care,
characteristics, from mild deficits in GMFCS as described above. 1 responsibility of the primary care
physician (PCP) is to integrate and providing families with resources and with community partners, including
orchestrate care across multiple organ support to help the child or early intervention programs, school
systems and multiple specialists adolescent thrive. This can be systems, insurance companies, and
(the “medical neighborhood”) while accomplished through collaboration others.
Many medical centers have a prevalence demonstrate a racial understand and address these
multidisciplinary team available to disparity.18 CP is more commonly disparities, and changes in social
evaluate and treat children with CP. diagnosed among children identified and economic policies at the societal
These can be difficult to access for as non-Hispanic Black than non- level are needed to reduce them.3
families in rural areas or those with Hispanic white or Hispanic. Because
transportation difficulties. Those with race assignment is a social rather Barriers to Care
such barriers may depend more than a biological construct, race and The care of children with CP can be
heavily on their local resources, racism as social determinants of extremely complex and costly, both for
medical home, and pediatrician for health cannot be discounted among the family21 and medical providers.
urgent or acute care challenges. For the factors to which these Children and families may be eligible
patients receiving care across disparities may be attributable. for a range of services that are, in
multiple physicians or health systems, Systemic societal inequities, as well reality, difficult to access.22 These
it can be important to delineate as those within the medical system, services include home nursing services
responsibilities across the care teams can confer deleterious lived and durable medical equipment, such
and to facilitate needed care (such as experiences for women from as wheelchairs, transportation, respite
hip surveillance) while minimizing historically minoritized groups care, and others. Families may have
duplication. This collaboration can be before and during pregnancy. trouble navigating the complicated
accomplished through the use of a Differential exposures to risk and systems tasked to provide these
patient- or family-centered care plan. protective factors likely contribute services, especially if they have
This arrangement is likely to be to the observed disparities in having language barriers or low health
different for different patients and a child with CP.19 Efforts to combat literacy. Where available, social
dependent on local resources. racism and eliminate barriers to workers and care coordinators can be
culturally sensitive prenatal, helpful, but families are often left to
Disparities
perinatal, and later pediatric care manage care on their own.
Preterm birth plays a significant may help to improve outcomes for Medicolegal partnerships may be
contributory role in the risk of CP, all children with CP. available to assist families in
as nearly half of people with CP maintaining their legal rights to health
were born prematurely.3 Social Aside from race, CP is also known care, education, and public benefits.
factors, as well as the possibility of to be more prevalent in children
underlying genetic variations and who come from families with lower Payment for physician services is
gene-environment interactions, have socioeconomic status. The often inadequate in comparison with
all been posited as determinative knowledge of these disparities may the amount of work performed by the
variables in the etiology of preterm prompt physicians to identify medical home to provide expert,
birth.16,17 Although the complexity implicit biases and barriers to coordinated care for children. The
of the precise antecedents and screening, identification, treatment, breadth of the pediatrician’s care, as
perinatal contributors to the and familial support for children illustrated in this clinical report, is
causal pathway for preterm birth with CP whose lives are impacted by difficult to sustain solely through
are incompletely understood, social determinants of health.20 payment for intermittent office
population-level studies of CP Further research is needed to better visits.23 Because visits with patients
TABLE 3 Elements of the History or Examination That May be Seen in Children With CP
Perinatal History Developmental History Examination Findings
Prematurity Early rolling Increased or decreased muscle tone
Low birth weight Thumb in fist after 7 m Scissoring of the legs
Neonatal encephalopathy Inability to sit by 9 m Asymmetric strength or reflexes
Neonatal seizures Milestones attained “out of order” (able to pull to stand Opisthotonus
before able to sit)
Neonatal stroke or other asymmetric creeping or crawling Persistent primitive reflexes
known brain abnormality
Congenital infection Inability to walk by 18 m Combination of ankle clonus, brisk deep
tendon reflexes and persistent Babinski after 18 m
Chorioamnionitis Persistent toe walking
Neonatal meningitis
Known hypoxic event
The presence of these elements does not mean that CP is definitely present, and their absence does not mean that CP can be excluded.
Extinction (“crying it out”) Parents put the child to bed and ignore until morning (but monitor for concerns for safety or illness).
Graduated extinction Parents put the child to bed and ignore crying and tantrums for a predetermined period of time before briefly
(“sleep training”) checking on and reassuring the child. The time between checks is gradually increased. The time between
checks should be determined based on the child’s temperament and the parents’ tolerance for crying.
Fading of parental presence Parents put the child to bed and gradually fade their proximity to and interactions with the child during sleep-onset
every few nights. For example, the parent can transition from lying next to the child to sitting in a chair next to
the bed and progressively move the chair further from the bed every few nights until they are no longer in the
room.
Scheduled awakenings After establishing the baseline timing and number of night awakenings, parents wake the child up 15–30 min before
the typical awakening and follow their typical response to spontaneous awakenings. The scheduled awakenings are
then gradually faded out by increasing the time between them.
Positive routines Parents develop a consistent bedtime routine of calm activities to establish a behavioral chain leading up to sleep
onset and promote appropriate sleep associations. Use of a transitional object such as a blanket or stuffed
animal can help promote appropriate sleep associations.
Bedtime pass Parents provide the child with 1 or 2 tokens (the bedtime “pass”) that can be turned in for 1 request or contact
with a parent after bedtime. If the child does not use the bedtime pass, he or she can turn it in for a positive
reinforcer in the morning
Bedtime fading The designated bedtime is temporarily delayed until it coincides with the child's usual onset of sleep. The bedtime
is then gradually moved earlier. If the child fails to fall asleep as expected, he or she is taken out of bed briefly
before put to bed again.
Courtesy of K Steingass, American Academy of Pediatrics, PREP DBPeds Self-Assessment.
“yellow” (probably do it) commonly used by patients with CP be reweighed at each visit to
intervention.87 have been associated with decreased improve accuracy. It may be
feeding and nutrition because of impossible to accurately measure
NUTRITION, GROWTH, AND their unpleasant taste, suppression height in patients with scoliosis and
GASTROINTESTINAL PROBLEMS of appetite, sedation, reduced contractures.242 Alternative
Feeding problems and adequate gastrointestinal tract motility, and measures using knee height, arm
nutrition are often a major challenge alterations of vitamin metabolism. span, or tibial and ulnar length have
Examples include anticonvulsants, been developed to determine an
for children and adolescents with
muscle relaxants, pain medications, equivalent height for patients with
CP,4 particularly in children with a
and psychiatric medications.243 severe CP.242,245,246 Some experts
greater degree of motor
recommend measurement of body
impairment.239,240 Feeding Because of the complexity, composition by skin fold measures,
difficulties may result from significance, and prevalence of bioelectric impedance analysis, or
coordination problems at the oral and gastrointestinal issues in children dual energy x-ray absorptiometry
pharyngeal levels that result in with CP, the PCP and family may (DXA) as useful in determining fat
dysphagia, excessive time needed for consider building a multidisciplinary versus lean body mass242,244 and
feeding, gastrointestinal tract motility team, including a nutritionist, nutritional status, but these measures
problems, vomiting, risk for aspiration, pediatric gastroenterologist, may not be easily available or
dental issues, and maladaptive pediatric otolaryngologist, speech practical in the PCP’s office. An
behavioral responses to feeding.241 and feeding pathologist, and emerging tool for evaluating growth
Inadequate nutrition leads to poor occupational therapist to assist with is the mid-arm circumference, which
growth, poor brain function, optimizing care.241,244 can be used in conjunction with other
decreased potential for cognitive measures and has been studied in
ability, poor social interaction, Growth and Nutrition Assessments
youth with CP.247,248
decreased immune capacity with Assessing growth and nutritional
increased risk of infections, and status in children with CP is As with all children, monitoring
decreased ability to heal.241 difficult. Weight may be difficult to growth parameters over time using
measure if the patient is unable to growth curves is important. Growth
Suboptimal nutrition can lead to transfer onto a scale. In these cases, charts for children with CP stratified
nutritional deficiencies in children the patient may be held by a parent by GMFCS level have been
with cerebral palsy, including iron, or weighed in a wheelchair, with the constructed249 using observational
vitamin D, phosphorus, and weight of the parent or chair data from a large cohort of children
calcium.242 Medications that are subtracted. The parent or chair can from California. The authors showed a
and determine if Ca
Treatment and Fragility Fractures
and Calcium
FIGURE 4
AACPDM bone care pathway. Reproduced with permission from: Fehlings D, Switzer L, Stevenson R, Gaebler-Spira D, Dalziel B, Ozel S. AACPDM Osteoporosis
Care Pathways. American Academy of Cerebral Palsy and Developmental Medicine. Published September 2016. Accessed 19 Aug 20 from https://www.
aacpdm.org/publications/care-pathways/osteoporosis-in-cerebral-palsy.431 Note: AACPDM Care Pathways are clinical practice guidelines for the health care
of individuals with childhood-onset disabilities. Their main goal is to develop recommendations that allow users to understand the evidence on a topic and
apply it to clinical practice. The Osteoporosis Care Pathway was developed from the best available evidence at the time of its development, and the informa-
tion contained could change or be updated with emerging or new evidence. Please be sure to visit the website https://www.aacpdm.org/publications/
care-pathways/osteoporosis-in-cerebral-palsy for updates.
other tools such as quantitative tool has not been established. 298 (on the basis of a DXA scan
computerized tomography or Available guidelines 295,299 do not alone) without fracture with a
ultrasonography) as a screening support treating low bone mass bisphosphonate.
FIGURE 7
Six core elements of transition. Reproduced with permission from: White PH, Cooley WC, Transitions Clinical Report Authortin Group, American Academy of
Pediatrics, American Academy of Family Physicians, American College of Physicians. Supporting the Health Care Transition From Adolescence to Adulthood
in the Medical Home. Pediatrics. 2018;142(5):e20182587.