Professional Documents
Culture Documents
White Craig Raine Analysis
White Craig Raine Analysis
A cabbage white:
A bluster at the edge of sight,
unbroken bronco,
its own mute rodeo,
like ectoplasm.
No lightning in spasms.
contains
flash photography.
Is now electricity:
New lambs
out on their limbs:
abrupt
little hiccoughs.
“A cabbage white”
The mention of a "cabbage white" likely refers to a butterfly. This sets the stage for a focus on nature and
simplicity.
“A bluster at the edge of sight, “
The term "bluster" suggests a gust of wind or a sudden, forceful movement. It's positioned at "the edge of
sight," hinting that this bluster might be on the periphery of perception, almost at the boundary of what
can be seen.
“unbroken bronco,”
The metaphor of the "unbroken bronco" conjures an image of a wild and untamed horse. The use of
"unbroken" emphasizes its untamed nature, suggesting a sense of unruliness or defiance.
“ its own mute rodeo,”
The idea of a "mute rodeo" introduces a contradiction. A rodeo is typically associated with noise, action,
and spectacle, but the use of "mute" suggests a lack of sound or perhaps a quiet, internal struggle. This
phrase implies an internal, personal challenge or conflict.
“ a battle without issue. “
The phrase "battle without issue" suggests a struggle or conflict that doesn't reach a resolution or
conclusion. It could imply an ongoing, perhaps internal, conflict that persists without a clear outcome or
winner.
The lines are talking about a butterfly. Picture it like a lively and energetic presence that you can see at
the corner of your eyes. The words "unbroken bronco" and "mute rodeo" compare the butterfly to a wild
and untamed creature, like a bucking bronco in a rodeo. This suggests that the butterfly is full of life and
energy, but it's also quiet or silent, like a rodeo without noise. The phrase "battle without issue" hints that
the butterfly faces challenges and struggles, but there may not be a clear resolution to those difficulties.
Overall, it paints a picture of a lively and untamed butterfly, facing the ups and downs of life.
Main Idea
The poem talks about different things in life, like nature, technology, and everyday objects. It uses the
idea of "whites" to show various feelings and experiences. The goal is to make readers think about the
many different aspects of life and emotions.
Themes
Different and Opposite Things: The poem talks about many different and opposite things, showing that
life has a lot of variety.
Being Delicate and Easily Hurt: The poem mentions baby animals and fragile things, highlighting how
life can be delicate and easily affected.
Nature and the World Around Us: Nature is an important topic in the poem, and it also touches on how
we might be harming the environment.
New Technology and Old Ways: The poem talks about new technology like bulbs and electricity,
alongside more traditional and natural things.
Life Being Short and Changing: The poem talks about moments that don't last long and emphasizes
how life is always changing.
Feeling Different Emotions: The poem suggests that people feel many different emotions, and happiness
can be expressed in various ways.
Strange and Everyday Things Together: The poem mixes strange or unreal things with everyday
objects, making it interesting and unusual.
Light and Darkness: The poem talks about light and dark things, both literally and in terms of feelings.
Creating a Specific Feeling: The poem tries to make you feel a certain way, often calm and thoughtful,
using descriptions like the twilight tone.
Rhyme: The poem doesn't follow a regular rhyme pattern. Some lines rhyme, but there's no consistent
scheme. This lack of pattern makes the poem feel modern and free-form.
Structure: The poem is structured informally, with each observation separated by an asterisk. It doesn't
have traditional stanzas, which gives it a casual and unconventional vibe. Each part is short, like a quick
snapshot of a moment or image.
Context: The poem talks about everyday things, especially those that are white. It mentions a butterfly,
toilet tissue, lambs, and a pigeon. The poem plays with the idea that ordinary things can have deeper
meanings, like "flash photography" or "indifferent happiness."
Message: The poem explores differences, like normal versus special moments. It uses the color white a
lot, suggesting ideas of purity or simplicity. Overall, it's about finding meaning in simple, everyday stuff.
Color Motif: The recurring motif of the color white is significant. White is associated with purity,
simplicity, and neutrality. The poem explores the different facets of white, from the delicate wings of a
butterfly to the everyday item of toilet tissue. This color choice may symbolize finding meaning or beauty
in ordinary and seemingly insignificant things.
Lack of Resolution: The poem doesn't provide a clear conclusion or resolution. The final lines talk about
"indifferent happiness" writing "different whites." This suggests a kind of happiness that's detached or
neutral. The phrase "different whites" highlights the various meanings and emotions connected to the
color white. The lack of resolution leaves room for interpretation, making the ending open-ended and
somewhat ambiguous.