Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Assignment 3 - BAFI3192 - s3836577 Luong Quang Thoai
Assignment 3 - BAFI3192 - s3836577 Luong Quang Thoai
MANAGEMENT
ASSESSMENT 3
INDIVIDUAL RISK MANAGEMENT REPORT
LECTURER
KOK SENG KIONG
STUDENT’S NAME
LUONG QUANG THOAI
STUDENT ID
S3836577
TUTORIAL
THURSDAY 3PM
WORD COUNT
3030
I. Trading philosophy
since it is suitable in the context of numerous market changes, especially the economy during
determine stocks expected to perform well. Professional technology platforms such as Eikon
factors, market prospects, etc. Then, we can use the double moving average approach to
numerous loosely held paradigms based on the analysis of financial stock price and volume
data to understand past price movement and anticipate future prices (Trivedi et al). Hence,
Furthermore, hedging tools consideration is necessary to deal with future market volatilities.
Besides, strategies should be flexible to adapt to concurrent situations, such as adjusting stock
holdings and strategy depending on the market situation. The results of Charles Schwab's
Allocation". Investors only need some growth potential along with less volatility than the
overall market. However, I would prefer to buy both value and growth securities as long as I
Table 1: The latest P/E and P/B ratios of CVS Health in comparison with the market
medications, beauty products, and cosmetics. According to Table 1, both the company's P/E
and P/B ratios are lower than the market and industry median, which means the company is
presently undervalued. However, the company performed strongly in the first quarter of
2022, increasing the quarterly dividend by 10%, leading to a return of $722 million to
(MarketWatch 2022)
Overall, the CVS 1-month chart (from April 22 to May 9) shows a declining trend. However,
the pending merger with Aetna health insurer, another leading healthcare provider, will
promote bullish momentum. In May, the MACD line crossed the signal “from below to
Table 3:The latest P/E and P/B ratios of Intel in comparison with the market and
circuits, graphics, and microprocessors for computer system manufacturers and other
computing devices. Both P/E and P/B ratios are reported to be lower than the industry
median, proving the company is undervalued compared to its peers. However, EPS and ROE
2022).
Over one year, INTC has experienced a long downward trend because of the global
semiconductor chip shortage during Covid-19 (LI 2022). However, the computer hardware
market is expected to recover in 2022 (ReportLinker 2022). The intersection of MACD and
The company operates in the financial sector, which serves an extensive range of banking,
asset management, investing, and other financial products and services. BAC is one of the
largest financial institutions in the US. P/E ratios of BAC are still lower than the market and
industry average, which suggests the possibility of being undervalued; meanwhile, P/B ratios
are equal to the US banking industry median. All figures have a decreasing trend in Q1 2022.
(MarketWatch 2022).
Figure 3 illustrates an upward trend of BAC at the end of 2021 and a decline trend in the first
quarter of 2022. It can be seen that both MACD and signal lines crossed below during May,
Table 7:The latest P/E and P/B ratios of JP Morgan Chase in comparison with the
JP Morgan & Chase is a global leader in financial services and is one of the long-standing
banks in the world which offers financial services for individuals and businesses, asset
management, and investment banking. The P/E ratio is smaller than the industry median
whilst the P/B ratio is higher than the industry median. However, both of them are still lower
than the market that indicating the company is still undervalued. Both EPS and ROE declined
(MarketWatch 2022).
Like other stocks, JPM has also experienced a decreasing trend. The continuous intersection
Table 9:The latest P/E and P/B ratios of Apple in comparison with the market and industry
manufactures smartphones, tablets, and personal computers. Both P/E and P/B are much
higher than the market and the US technology median which means the company is
overvalued. EPS varied significantly while ROE kept rising over the period.
2022).
The price grew significantly at the end of 2021 but it fell slightly in the early 2022.
The intersection of MACD and signal line is observed as the same as the JPM's trend, hence
JPM is expected to reach 17% returns sooner than forecasted because rising-rate rates provide
a boost. While guiding about 2022 expenses remained constant at approximately $77 billion,
Federal Reserve combats inflation rate by raising interest rate expectations and may issue a
The US's inflation rate increased dramatically from 2.6% to 8.5% over one year (Figure 6). A
high level of inflation rate wears down the purchasing power of future cash flow over time,
fueling volatilities in the market then adversely influences investment level and depresses
economic growth (Mamo 2012). When monetary policy is tightened to manage high inflation
rates, financial institutions would take advantage related to interest rates (Gaggar 2022).
Figure 6: Monthly inflation rate in the United States from April 2021 to April 2022
(Statista 2022).
Figure 7: Annualized growth of real GDP in the United States from 2012 to 2022, by
quarter
GDP growth rate in the US fell steeply in Q3 2020 and recovered remarkably in the next
quarter of 2020. However, until early 2022, GDP growth fell at a 1.4% pace in the nation due
to a widening trade deficit (Cox 2022). In spite of the disappointing records, stock and bond
yields continue to rise with technology stock in the lead (Cambon 2022).
Before buying decisions, I had taken a look at historical data and fundamental data to choose
companies that are currently undervalued. I am just a beginner in the stock market, despite
being a moderate investor, I have spent 26% of my portfolio's weight on INTC stock which is
the most volatile one (beta > 1), and the rest of 74% weight on F, BAC, JPM and CVS that is
less fluctuated (beta <1). I assigned 18% of the weight for each bank which is higher than
14% of F, since banking securities will benefit from the high inflation rate in the US.
Creating a value-weight portfolio will be safer since large capital stock displays less
volatility.
Table 11: Weighting of initial portfolio and Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM)
calculation.
The US government 10 years treasury bond yield (risk-free rate) is at 1.51% in 2021 (Statista
2022). The 10-year expected return on the US market is 16.58% (Thune 2022). The trading
duration is from 25/4 to 8/5 hence there are overall 10 effective trading days excluding
weekends.
4. Unsystematic risk
Unsystematic risk is specific to each enterprise or sector and can be alleviated through
portfolio diversification.
Technology industry: competitive risk is a common risk that we frequently see in the
technology industry. Samsung and Huawei race to launch new affordable smartphones but
Apple has no announcement of new foldable smartphones. Apple has always created a unique
difference in its products and prioritized the core value of the product over new features and
utilities. This has contributed to the reduction of competitive risks. On the other hand, the
access to exploit and install malware chips (Lifars 2022). Its users' data can be stolen since
due to its importance. Moderna is a prime example of this. Specifically, at the time when the
Covid-19 pandemic became more serious again, Moderna had several protests about the
effectiveness of the vaccine ( Trefis Team 2021). If MRK’s antiviral studies are effective, this
impact might be seen, and vice versa. Moving to CVS, its new policies and restrictions on
activities have become barriers to CVS. For example, employees' salaries and CVS business
expenses negatively impacted its price moving on 4th August 2021 (Baccardax 2021).
Banking: Entering the banking sector, emerging financial technologies are often disrupted
and this has become the challenge that JPM and BAC need to face. In particular, the
consumer banking segment contributes notably to the main revenue source of those two
finance that does not depend on central financial intermediaries like brokers, exchanges, or
banks to provide financial services, or traditional financial instruments, which instead use
smart contracts on the blockchain. This offers a danger to incumbents in traditional banking,
since Defi raised $80b in 18 months, owing to unhappiness with the current system,
including:
As a result, the traditional banks will not soon be replaced by Defi in the problem associated
5. Systematic risk
Systematic risk refers to an undiversifiable risk that the whole market has to deal with like
2022). Beta is an index that represents systematic risks in the CAPM theory (Kirill, Carlota,
and Neus 2016). In my initial portfolio, technology stocks are the most volatile (beta > 1)
while healthcare and banking sectors have less volatility. The weighted beta (1.033) indicates
The Covid-19 outbreak: many countries imposed strict lockdowns which resulted in an
interrupted supply chain. The highest volatility was recorded during Covid-19, despite stocks
in high-income countries being vulnerable, they still bound back stronger than in low-income
Russia, many businesses announced a partial or full halt to operating in Russia (Francis
2022). Apple has halted its exports, McDonald, Starbucks, PepsiCo and Coca-cola shuttered
all their locations in Russia which put downward pressure on stock market prices.
Value at Risk measures the possibilities of loss in financial portfolios over a specified period
of time with a specified probability (Liu and Wu 2008). According to Table 12, I am 99%
confident that my portfolio will lose more than $41,751.8, making up 4.6% of my initial
portfolio. 1% opportunity of losing more than $41,751.8 can occur if a systematic risk
happens such as war or a pandemic outbreak that adversely affects the stock market.
Figure 9: Histogram of portfolio's daily return frequency in three years from 9/5/2019
to 9/5/2022.
The chart shows a right-skewed distribution, the total positive return day is approximately 3
times compared to the total negative return day throughout 3 years, which means my initial
7. Hedging
a. Future contract:
Regarding the information analyzed above, the US stock market tendency was going down during the
serious breakout Covid-19’s period. Hence, I would expect that the market price volatility could also
decrease and I also took advantage of buying future contracts to limit financial risks. Since the
securities in my initial portfolio all belong to the S&P 500 index, I decided to buy the E-Mini S&P500
Future Continuous Contract on the first day of the trading session (25th April 2022).
Table 12: Future trading data
With the contract size of 50, the contract’s number might be calculated throughout the formula of
option hedge ratio, showing the risk’ magnitude posed by a hedging instrument movement.
After finishing the calculation of the option hedge ratio, there were 4 contracts that I would sell on
25th April 2022 to limit the financial risk due to my expectation of decreasing market trend on 9th
May 2022.
Figure 10: E-mini S&P 500 Future Contract Continuous Contract on 9th May 2022
Based on Figure 10, the market price went down to $4,015.50 as I expected. Consequently, I,
fortunately, got a profit from the futures contract of $55,450 (Table 13).
b. Option contract:
From Appendix 1, in my hedging transaction, the final decision was to sell 4 put option
contracts, equivalent to 400 AAPL shares. More notably, each contract would have a price of
$5.8 and the strike price would be $160 as my AAPL holding was 792 shares. Additionally,
our final trading day is on 9th May 2022, so the expiration date of buying 4 put option
According to the calculation shown in Table 15, the net return on 9th May 2022 in those two
cases was at a loss. However, it might be seen that I should choose the case of using the put
option and selling 400 AAPL shares at $160 because the net return of that case is greater than
the other case on 9th May 2022. If I still exercise the put option, the advantage that I might
receive:
Option profit = (160-152.06) x 400 = $2382
To sum up, on 9th May 2022, I decided to choose the first case to create the option profit of
$2382.
III. Reflection
a. Risk appetite: is the level of risk that investors are willing to accept in
4 out of my 5 chosen stocks (JPM, BAC, INTC and CVS) are from companies
with outperforming financial performance in the past few years and are
60% of stock weight in my portfolio that has lower volatility than the market
(JPM, BAC, and CVS) since the banking and healthcare industry can endure
short-term investment.
returns and their risks which were convinced by covariance with market
volatility (CFA Journal 2018). Moreover, CAPM assumes that all investors
have the same expectations & plan in a specified period and there is no
transaction fee involved when investing. The model always gives a positive
average return on the market (CFA Journal 2018). Besides, the market return
of systematic risks (Wobst et al 2020). The actual return is quite different from
the expected return calculated by using the CAPM method (table 13)
(expected return of $6770 and the actual loss of $44,828 on 9 May). Some
stocks might perform worse than the model's expectation, unsystematic risks
and business fundamental shocks were not included in the CAPM calculation.
c.
Following table 15, I give a decision of exercising the option to sell 400 AAPL shares at a
market price of $160. The net portfolio return of AAPL stocks with using option is -
$1,175.2.
Regarding the above-calculated result in Table 13, the net return of five initial securities by
Under the above data calculations, my portfolio increased to $10,598.11 after using hedging
transactions. This increase in profit was mainly due to the fact that the portfolio received a
profit of $55,450 in the future trading and the price movement tendency for the options also
decreased as expected. Also, if I face a loss in using hedging for my portfolio, I personally
feel that spending on those trades is worth it. To explain more specifically, if I get back the
calculated VaR result above, the loss I might get is up to $41,751.80. To continue to receive a
significant amount of profit in the next period, it is very essential to carefully analyze the
After calculating and evaluating the above two hedging transactions' methods and examining
the effect that my portfolio is affected, my final decision is to choose the option contract for
According to Trigeorgis & Reur (2016), the option contract has partially eliminated the
symmetric reward between those two upsides and downsides while purchasing an option, and
the inherent risk also does not exist. The reason for this has to do with the freedom of
investors to buy and sell shares. Specifically, they might trade their asset at any agreed-upon
price instead of being forced. Consequently, based on options having conditions, it is easier
for investors to make decisions to reduce risk as much as possible or they might receive a
periodic amount of profit for them. Whereas the financial risks in portfolios are covered by
future contracts, investors often use options to hedge price movements in securities. This
corresponds to investors’ concerns about risks during the trading session. Options might be
more effective to use since changes can not directly affect future hedges that depend on the
To conclude, options still have their strength and effectiveness on transferred risks. Because
References
Baccardax, M 2021, ‘CVS Stock Slides As COVID Cost Concerns Cloud Earnings Beat,
<https://www.thestreet.com/investing/cvs-health-stock-jumps-as-retail-rebound-drives-
earnings-beat>.
Baker S, Bloom N, Davis SJ, Kost K, Sammon M, Viratyosin T (2020), ‘The unprecedented
stock market reaction to COVID-19’, Rev Asset Pricing Study, 10(4), pp.742–758, doi:
10.1093/rapstu/raaa008
Bhavana (18 May 2022) 'Systematic Risk', cleartax, accessed 21 May 2022,
<https://cleartax.in/g/terms/systematic-risk>.
Brooks, B 2021, Don’t fear ‘DeFi: It could be less risky than traditional finance, FORTUNE,
regulation-decentralized-finance/>.
Cambon CS (28 April 2022) 'U.S. GDP Falls 1.4% as Economy Shrinks for First Time Since
<https://www.wsj.com/articles/us-economy-gdp-growth-q1-11651108351>.
CFA Journal 2018, 9 THE LIMITATIONS OF CAPITAL ASSETS PRICING MODELS -
CFAJournal, viewed 20 May, 2022, <https://www.cfajournal.org/limitations-capm/>.
Cox J (28 April 2022) 'U.S. GDP fell at a 1.4% pace to start the year as pandemic recovery
growth.html>.
CVS (2022) CVS Health reports strong first quarter results, CVS Health, accessed 21 May
2022, <https://www.cvshealth.com/news-and-insights/press-releases/cvs-health-reports-
results-2022-q1>.
Francis S (17 March 2022) 'Russia’s War on Ukraine: An Economic Explainer for U.S.
<https://www.kiplinger.com/investing/604415/russias-war-on-ukraine-an-economic-
explainer-for-us-investors>.
Gaggar A (25 February 2022) 'Could Some Sectors Benefit from Inflation?', CommonWealth,
<https://blog.commonwealth.com/independent-market-observer/could-some-sectors-benefit-
from-inflation>.
systematic risk and effect of the financial crisis on US tourism industry: Panel data research',
10.1108/IJCHM-03-2016-0173.
LI W (20 April 2022) 'Global Semiconductor Shortage Likely to Ease Significantly in H2
<https://www.counterpointresearch.com/semiconductor-shortage-likely-ease-h2-2022/>.
Lifars (13 January 2022) 'Vulnerability Threatens Intel That Leads To Affect Its Users',
that-leads-to-affect-its-users/>.
Liu M and Wu FF (2008) 'Chapter 12 - Analytical Methods for Energy Diversity & Security',
https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-056887-4.00012-3.
Mamo, TF 2012, 'Economic Growth and Inflation A panel data analysis', pp. 1-44, viewed 23
<https://www.marketwatch.com/investing/stock/intc/charts?mod=mw_quote_tab>.
ReportLinker (21 March 2022) 'Computer Hardware Global Market Report 2022',
<https://www.globenewswire.com/news-release/2022/03/21/2406913/0/en/Computer-
Hardware-Global-Market-Report-2022.html>.
<https://www.techtarget.com/searchsecurity/definition/What-is-risk-appetite>.
Simply Wall st (2022) Apple, (chart), Simply Wall st, accessed 21 May 2022,
<https://simplywall.st/stocks/us/tech/nasdaq-aapl/apple>.
Simply Wall st (2022) Bank of America, (chart), Simply Wall st, accessed 21 May 2022,
<https://simplywall.st/stocks/us/banks/nyse-bac/bank-of-america#valuation>.
Simply Wall st (2022) CVS Health, (chart), Simply Wall st, accessed 21 May 2022,
<https://simplywall.st/stocks/us/healthcare/nyse-cvs/cvs-health#valuation>.
Simply Wall st (2022) Intel, (chart), Simply Wall st, accessed 21 May 2022,
<https://simplywall.st/stocks/us/semiconductors/nasdaq-intc/intel#valuation>.
Simply Wall st (2022) JPMorgan Chase, (chart), Simply Wall st, accessed 21 May 2022,
<https://simplywall.st/stocks/us/banks/nyse-jpm/jpmorgan-chase#valuation>.
Son H (23 May 2022) 'JPMorgan expects to reach 17% returns sooner than planned as rising
<https://www.cnbc.com/2022/05/23/jpmorgan-backtracks-on-key-target-says-it-can-reach-
17percent-returns-this-year.html>.
Statista (2022) Monthly 12-month inflation rate in the United States from April 2021 to April
<https://www.statista.com/statistics/273418/unadjusted-monthly-inflation-rate-in-the-us/>.
Statista (2022) Yield on 10-year Treasury bond in the United States from 1987 to 2021, (bar
10y-us-treasury-bond/>.
Thune K (22 April 2022) 'What Is The Average Return Of The Stock Market?', Seeking
market-return>.
Trefis Team, ‘What Drove Moderna Stock From $100 To Near $500’, Forbes, 20th August,
drove-moderna-stock-from-100-to-near-500/?sh=5152ff156042>.
Trigeorgis, L & Reuer, J.J 2016, ‘Real options theory in strategic management’, Strategic
Management Journal, vol. 38, no. 1, pp. 42-63, viewed 24th May 2022,
<https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/smj.2593>.
Trivedi, Roy S, Kyal and H A (2020) Effective Trading in Financial Markets Using Technical
Analysis. Trivedi, Smita Roy.; Kyal, Ashish H., Milton : Taylor & Francis Group, doi:
ISBN : 9781000205091.
Wobst, J, Gramlich, A, Röttger, P & Spee, K 2020, “Which is the ‘right’choice of the market
portfolio of the CAPM?”, Management, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 25-29.
Yahoo Finance (2022) S&P 500 (^GSPC), Yahoo Finance, accessed 21 May 2022,
<https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/%5EGSPC/history?
period1=1650672000&period2=1651968000&interval=1d&filter=history&frequency=1d&in
cludeAdjustedClose=true>.
Appendix:
Appendix 1: AAPL options on 25th April 2022