threshold XG_Boost CAT_Boost

1 -584209397.8 -603365221
2 -549429716.1 -590414953
3 -515552505.5 -572135045 200000000
4 -485043211.5 -553060454
100000000
5 -460252605.7 -534864550
6 -436508919.9 -517318650 0
0 20
7 -413955778.7 -498957541 -100000000
8 -394523192.8 -480749793
-200000000
9 -376401708.2 -463581280
10 -359816779 -444885278 -300000000
11 -344710415.5 -427721200 -400000000
12 -329256350.6 -409891262
-500000000
13 -315332851.5 -393340414
14 -301951808.6 -377881960 -600000000
15 -290320134.8 -362979184 -700000000
16 -278555285.8 -348045500
17 -267561244.4 -333481116
18 -256664994 -320459270
19 -261487999.1 -306967744
20 -252373807.5 -295115782
21 -242823905.7 -283721989
22 -234428754.6 -272292242
23 -226265236.7 -261000570
24 -218229021.9 -250957001
25 -209664798.3 -240153704
26 -201350831.9 -233333910
27 -193650166.3 -224368809
28 -187182177.2 -214595779
29 -180501404.8 -205782335
30 -174109907.8 -197224439
31 -167007049.2 -188456648
32 -161158861.1 -180129042
33 -155025183.3 -171743152
34 -149512925.3 -163247199
35 -144091999.1 -155095168
36 -138254822.7 -146961791
37 -132446372.6 -139089087
38 -127359490.4 -131014307
39 -122806263.8 -123499296
40 -117428620.6 -115364189
41 -112535896.4 -107313568
42 -106780166.7 -99871125
43 -101148375.7 -92490070
44 -95705337.47 -86837645
45 -90020040.27 -80220412
46 -84702832.43 -72912965
47 -78845821.88 -65873994
48 -77662004.77 -57920319
49 -73358791.05 -51843028
50 -71736736.4 -44340576
51 -67046916.93 -40395841
52 -62454715.26 -37506609
53 -58145106.81 -32304900
54 -53417218.26 -26891203
55 -49684250.77 -50059359
56 -44514147.6 -48433710
57 -39643223.28 -43845438
58 -34952087.1 -40779266
59 -30320854.65 -35285646
60 -40034589.13 -30438175
61 -34811746.36 -25434469
62 -30982896.8 -21461811
63 -27138631.67 -17490988
64 -23873224.08 -14078798
65 -20787712.71 -12132018
66 -18590326.13 -10424495
67 -13930012.56 -6225935.92
68 -10637095.61 -2830680.16
69 -7620581.151 2000206.63
70 -4110106.65 4475630.29
71 -1024346.132 9143397.93
72 -10070491.69 13564113.7
73 -7358286.226 16376835.9
74 -5662723.783 21279041.5
75 -3122493.863 25199583.3
76 364185.27153 29086158.7
77 3640570.6373 33746394
78 5939312.0156 39506039.4
79 6791158.1153 46621298.7
80 9185757.8013 50128446.7
81 8683213.6606 55366393
82 10463387.58 60433032.6
83 12682846.617 69977568.7
84 15706333.394 81329107.1
85 16863020.454 48152463.6
86 20057445.142 52777514.7
87 23048834.226 59184026.6
88 27336573.533 68687008.4
89 31097662.209 79957678.3
90 33060393.707 92161860.5
91 36761724.24 105259378
92 43416269.03 57754743.2
93 55844340.819 68575044.4
94 19235021.649 90123741.4
95 12190137.929 21776179.7
 96 18095854.836 21491120.3
97 5013542.114 49577427.5
98 -816000 -459000
99 -306000
100
 Net_Benefit Comparison NON MOTOR
200000000

100000000

0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
-100000000

-200000000

-300000000

-400000000

-500000000

-600000000

-700000000

XG_Boost CAT_Boost
120
threshold XGBoost Precision
1 0.033631 0.032714
2 0.035318 0.033326
3 0.037073 0.03426 1.2
4 0.038903 0.035259
5 0.040536 0.036238 1
6 0.042151 0.037236
7 0.043764 0.038249 0.8
8 0.045272 0.039339
9 0.046796 0.040442
0.6
10 0.048288 0.041642
11 0.04972 0.042915
0.4
12 0.051151 0.04423
13 0.052579 0.045413
14 0.054112 0.046639 0.2
15 0.055346 0.047995
16 0.056925 0.049351 0
0 20
17 0.058202 0.050641
18 0.059633 0.05187
19 0.060991 0.053304
20 0.06216 0.054576
21 0.063652 0.055989
22 0.065135 0.057334
23 0.066172 0.058628
24 0.067494 0.05989
25 0.06876 0.06123
26 0.070244 0.062503
27 0.071683 0.06366
28 0.073004 0.065208
29 0.074411 0.066678
30 0.075877 0.068168
31 0.077401 0.069509
32 0.078726 0.070875
33 0.080384 0.072383
34 0.081896 0.073837
35 0.083582 0.075541
36 0.085108 0.077208
37 0.086834 0.07882
38 0.08825 0.08036
39 0.090212 0.081976
40 0.091477 0.08395
41 0.093657 0.08628
42 0.095321 0.088359
43 0.097336 0.09007
44 0.099089 0.091596
45 0.100982 0.093213
46 0.102715 0.095325
47 0.105079 0.097411
48 0.107043 0.100185
49 0.109612 0.102444
50 0.111444 0.105257
51 0.11423 0.10891
52 0.11685 0.110618
53 0.119457 0.113137
54 0.121767 0.115155
55 0.123756 0.117774
56 0.127099 0.119983
57 0.130513 0.12273
58 0.133504 0.126182
59 0.136743 0.129874
60 0.139996 0.133367
61 0.144055 0.137346
62 0.147185 0.139715
63 0.15072 0.142803
64 0.152946 0.145017
65 0.155319 0.148055
66 0.157961 0.152145
67 0.164858 0.156272
68 0.168994 0.159378
69 0.173254 0.164125
70 0.178683 0.167905
71 0.184343 0.173812
72 0.188666 0.179016
73 0.193536 0.184298
74 0.202224 0.191292
75 0.207108 0.196387
76 0.217681 0.201409
77 0.229241 0.209955
78 0.23791 0.219185
79 0.247286 0.232301
80 0.257874 0.240074
81 0.271211 0.256192
82 0.276947 0.2672
83 0.291812 0.287431
84 0.304139 0.313305
85 0.309677 0.329146
86 0.330488 0.342067
87 0.348138 0.366609
88 0.374787 0.398305
89 0.400394 0.430809
90 0.421911 0.468944
91 0.443149 0.501887
92 0.48227 0.563981
93 0.548837 0.603448
94 0.608696 0.678082
95 0.694215 0.710744
 96 0.808511 0.757895
97 0.855072 0.924528
98 0.9375 0.962963
99 0.888889
100
 Precision Comparison NON MOTOR
.2

.8

.6

.4

.2

0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120

XGBoost Precision
threshold XG_Boost CAT_Boost CAT_SGD_Mean CAT_SGD_Max CAT_SGD_Min
1 -584,209,398 -603,365,221 -605,514,137 -605,514,137 -603,365,221
2 -549,429,716 -590,414,953 -605,514,137 -605,514,137 -590,414,953
3 -515,552,506 -572,135,045 -605,514,137 -605,514,137 -572,135,045
4 -485,043,212 -553,060,454 -604,949,056 -605,514,137 -553,005,119
5 -460,252,606 -534,864,550 -602,746,499 -605,497,137 -534,752,554
6 -436,508,920 -517,318,650 -595,666,280 -604,482,029 -515,603,664
7 -413,955,779 -498,957,541 -587,282,120 -603,954,214 -496,533,670
8 -394,523,193 -480,749,793 -578,992,718 -602,869,052 -477,046,996
9 -376,401,708 -463,581,280 -569,502,789 -584,659,375 -442,612,754
10 -359,816,779 -444,885,278 -560,006,234 -578,697,458 -420,486,846
11 -344,710,416 -427,721,200 -549,026,780 -573,469,755 -400,168,250
12 -329,256,351 -409,891,262 -537,356,895 -566,764,576 -380,637,102
13 -315,332,852 -393,340,414 -525,005,092 -559,413,930 -360,625,755
14 -301,951,809 -377,881,960 -511,814,807 -553,325,668 -344,397,108
15 -290,320,135 -362,979,184 -497,822,043 -546,748,457 -328,640,805
16 -278,555,286 -348,045,500 -482,730,701 -540,122,179 -312,681,677
17 -267,561,244 -333,481,116 -468,285,915 -531,341,184 -294,989,855
18 -256,664,994 -320,459,270 -452,392,719 -522,673,800 -280,037,604
19 -261,487,999 -306,967,744 -435,079,664 -514,208,282 -264,986,837
20 -252,373,808 -295,115,782 -419,275,307 -504,634,465 -250,719,608
21 -242,823,906 -283,721,989 -402,720,663 -494,448,952 -237,671,276
22 -234,428,755 -272,292,242 -386,524,841 -484,548,125 -225,114,063
23 -226,265,237 -261,000,570 -370,561,595 -473,588,029 -211,180,605
24 -218,229,022 -250,957,001 -353,992,448 -462,890,605 -199,205,707
25 -209,664,798 -240,153,704 -337,940,755 -451,714,772 -186,253,239
26 -201,350,832 -233,333,910 -321,272,466 -440,007,396 -178,907,866
27 -193,650,166 -224,368,809 -304,057,336 -428,643,589 -169,538,806
28 -187,182,177 -214,595,779 -288,576,737 -415,440,877 -157,910,192
29 -180,501,405 -205,782,335 -272,779,065 -403,350,827 -147,786,231
30 -174,109,908 -197,224,439 -257,339,121 -392,051,272 -137,641,315
31 -167,007,049 -188,456,648 -240,880,521 -380,326,500 -128,628,200
32 -161,158,861 -180,129,042 -225,341,618 -368,424,239 -118,826,801
33 -155,025,183 -171,743,152 -211,594,557 -356,001,125 -109,067,695
34 -149,512,925 -163,247,199 -197,209,719 -343,817,477 -99,604,460
35 -144,091,999 -155,095,168 -183,271,111 -331,040,339 -91,488,790
36 -138,254,823 -146,961,791 -173,481,284 -318,102,206 -82,770,113
37 -132,446,373 -139,089,087 -162,004,298 -305,442,528 -73,348,691
38 -127,359,490 -131,014,307 -149,546,298 -291,724,925 -64,106,888
39 -122,806,264 -123,499,296 -138,330,862 -278,186,167 -55,650,796
40 -117,428,621 -115,364,189 -126,765,278 -264,590,313 -45,206,522
41 -112,535,896 -107,313,568 -115,331,161 -252,590,341 -38,438,079
42 -106,780,167 -99,871,125 -104,470,191 -238,925,777 -29,608,049
43 -101,148,376 -92,490,070 -93,564,269 -223,878,979 -19,936,694
44 -95,705,337 -86,837,645 -83,762,798 -209,719,643 -13,967,914
45 -90,020,040 -80,220,412 -74,536,067 -197,651,830 -7,173,508
46 -84,702,832 -72,912,965 -66,962,478 -189,254,653 168,600
47 -78,845,822 -65,873,994 -57,745,186 -176,746,531 8,038,668
48 -77,662,005 -57,920,319 -48,244,039 -165,643,508 14,058,550
49 -73,358,791 -51,843,028 -38,094,213 -153,117,582 21,291,995
50 -71,736,736 -44,340,576 -29,573,655 -141,717,634 27,707,884
51 -67,046,917 -40,395,841 -20,584,134 -130,940,605 34,250,098
52 -62,454,715 -37,506,609 -15,079,576 -121,283,007 35,471,755
53 -58,145,107 -32,304,900 -5,745,637 -110,186,587 40,964,102
54 -53,417,218 -26,891,203 -447,753 -100,572,301 47,254,595
55 -49,684,251 -50,059,359 4,481,399 -89,411,111 8,257,321
56 -44,514,148 -48,433,710 12,431,923 -81,340,003 11,435,051
57 -39,643,223 -43,845,438 17,040,853 -71,174,207 15,246,391
58 -34,952,087 -40,779,266 -11,460,875 -63,487,341 15,298,360
59 -30,320,855 -35,285,646 -5,778,840 -54,350,651 19,994,779
60 -40,034,589 -30,438,175 -2,435,557 -47,989,844 23,753,003
61 -34,811,746 -25,434,469 3,733,070 -38,551,582 27,328,244
62 -30,982,897 -21,461,811 6,478,111 -57,348,733 31,137,267
63 -27,138,632 -17,490,988 10,614,553 -51,000,588 34,134,651
64 -23,873,224 -14,078,798 14,462,389 -44,730,920 37,717,656
65 -20,787,713 -12,132,018 18,666,606 -40,520,395 42,552,714
66 -18,590,326 -10,424,495 24,161,507 -34,200,738 42,162,678
67 -13,930,013 -6,225,936 28,324,805 -27,044,116 46,171,247
68 -10,637,096 -2,830,680 32,110,248 -21,572,399 47,912,952
69 -7,620,581 2,000,207 33,534,104 -16,073,779 50,957,884
70 -4,110,107 4,475,630 37,670,326 -11,361,639 54,323,702
71 -1,024,346 9,143,398 42,496,735 -5,127,086 58,692,509
72 -10,070,492 13,564,114 47,148,641 -898,186 62,970,145
73 -7,358,286 16,376,836 49,053,866 3,197,422 67,691,461
74 -5,662,724 21,279,041 51,425,996 9,336,613 71,243,048
75 -3,122,494 25,199,583 58,229,106 14,341,928 74,712,148
76 364,185 29,086,159 62,022,208 19,708,914 81,261,338
77 3,640,571 33,746,394 69,119,842 23,595,476 88,116,813
78 5,939,312 39,506,039 73,451,065 28,699,248 98,934,548
79 6,791,158 46,621,299 80,973,327 36,239,403 103,768,235
80 9,185,758 50,128,447 89,933,147 40,376,904 110,783,144
81 8,683,214 55,366,393 104,041,053 46,089,051 112,658,880
82 10,463,388 60,433,033 110,690,689 50,668,775 118,159,482
83 12,682,847 69,977,569 118,628,364 56,579,291 129,225,092
84 15,706,333 81,329,107 136,365,818 65,705,129 155,521,518
85 16,863,020 48,152,464 136,060,002 75,338,865 83,321,812
86 20,057,445 52,777,515 149,778,404 85,405,711 85,165,293
87 23,048,834 59,184,027 90,683,950 96,619,501 90,047,779
88 27,336,574 68,687,008 101,053,984 106,306,630 111,353,322
89 31,097,662 79,957,678 105,868,949 113,846,048 127,813,034
90 33,060,394 92,161,860 117,518,922 73,197,574 131,257,243
91 36,761,724 105,259,378 138,046,876 86,207,837 143,815,324
92 43,416,269 57,754,743 159,195,070 99,307,880 91,974,716
93 55,844,341 68,575,044 203,136,934 118,091,928 101,475,341
94 19,235,022 90,123,741 243,559,160 147,413,857 120,262,149
95 12,190,138 21,776,180 203,785,544 154,677,534 22,868,253
 96 18,095,855 21,491,120 23,276,881 145,152,845 29,372,082
97 5,013,542 49,577,428 45,416,310 283,830,146 26,899,517
98 -816,000 -459,000 -102,000 658,502,468 -102,000
99 -306,000
100
Max_value
658502468.21 Net_Benefi
800,000,000

600,000,000

400,000,000

200,000,000

-
0 20 40

-200,000,000

-400,000,000

-600,000,000

-800,000,000

XG_Boost CAT_Boost
 Net_Benefits_Comparison_Non Motor

40 60 80 100 120

Boost CAT_Boost CAT_SGD_Mean CAT_SGD_Max CAT_SGD_Min

threshold XGBoost CAT_BoostCAT_SGD_CAT_SGD_CAT_SGD_Min
1 0.033631 0.032714 0.032615 0.032615 0.032714
2 0.035318 0.033326 0.032615 0.032615 0.033326
3 0.037073 0.03426 0.032615 0.032615 0.03426
4 0.038903 0.035259 0.032641 0.032615 0.035262
5 0.040536 0.036238 0.032743 0.032616 0.036244
6 0.042151 0.037236 0.033075 0.032662 0.037284
7 0.043764 0.038249 0.033453 0.032687 0.038345
8 0.045272 0.039339 0.033811 0.032737 0.0395
9 0.046796 0.040442 0.034286 0.033532 0.041654
10 0.048288 0.041642 0.034749 0.033825 0.04306
11 0.04972 0.042915 0.035304 0.034085 0.044634
12 0.051151 0.04423 0.035914 0.034402 0.046161
13 0.052579 0.045413 0.036562 0.034756 0.047771
14 0.054112 0.046639 0.037333 0.035049 0.049227
15 0.055346 0.047995 0.038157 0.0354 0.050734
16 0.056925 0.049351 0.03901 0.035762 0.052283
17 0.058202 0.050641 0.03997 0.036199 0.054031
18 0.059633 0.05187 0.041023 0.036668 0.055582
19 0.060991 0.053304 0.042059 0.037137 0.057458
20 0.06216 0.054576 0.043098 0.03766 0.059302
21 0.063652 0.055989 0.044423 0.038268 0.061092
22 0.065135 0.057334 0.045737 0.038842 0.062809
23 0.066172 0.058628 0.047081 0.039481 0.064833
24 0.067494 0.05989 0.048501 0.040121 0.066763
25 0.06876 0.06123 0.050136 0.040875 0.068725
26 0.070244 0.062503 0.051849 0.041583 0.070523
27 0.071683 0.06366 0.053602 0.04235 0.072011
28 0.073004 0.065208 0.055257 0.043353 0.07417
29 0.074411 0.066678 0.056899 0.044309 0.076142
30 0.075877 0.068168 0.058719 0.045175 0.078327
31 0.077401 0.069509 0.060877 0.046114 0.07995
32 0.078726 0.070875 0.063065 0.047022 0.082061
33 0.080384 0.072383 0.065238 0.048022 0.084102
34 0.081896 0.073837 0.067537 0.049004 0.086613
35 0.083582 0.075541 0.06983 0.050258 0.088733
36 0.085108 0.077208 0.072347 0.051435 0.091243
37 0.086834 0.07882 0.074485 0.052777 0.094039
38 0.08825 0.08036 0.077091 0.054322 0.096595
39 0.090212 0.081976 0.079198 0.055861 0.098983
40 0.091477 0.08395 0.081666 0.057413 0.102356
41 0.093657 0.08628 0.084024 0.059032 0.106495
42 0.095321 0.088359 0.086619 0.060938 0.110026
43 0.097336 0.09007 0.08939 0.062608 0.113798
44 0.099089 0.091596 0.092089 0.064778 0.11637
45 0.100982 0.093213 0.094583 0.066376 0.119192
46 0.102715 0.095325 0.097426 0.068534 0.12286
47 0.105079 0.097411 0.100702 0.070723 0.127353
48 0.107043 0.100185 0.104055 0.072937 0.131881
49 0.109612 0.102444 0.10771 0.075336 0.136746
50 0.111444 0.105257 0.110544 0.077578 0.140762
51 0.11423 0.10891 0.114922 0.080186 0.148382
52 0.11685 0.110618 0.119767 0.082572 0.152646
53 0.119457 0.113137 0.124754 0.085387 0.157493
54 0.121767 0.115155 0.128851 0.088151 0.163221
55 0.123756 0.117774 0.133553 0.090809 0.167351
56 0.127099 0.119983 0.139241 0.093464 0.171978
57 0.130513 0.12273 0.144763 0.096944 0.177043
58 0.133504 0.126182 0.150532 0.100822 0.182306
59 0.136743 0.129874 0.155891 0.10452 0.188616
60 0.139996 0.133367 0.161547 0.10825 0.194035
61 0.144055 0.137346 0.167743 0.112648 0.199384
62 0.147185 0.139715 0.173697 0.116239 0.204098
63 0.15072 0.142803 0.177784 0.119645 0.209947
64 0.152946 0.145017 0.181064 0.123237 0.215807
65 0.155319 0.148055 0.187806 0.12663 0.223469
66 0.157961 0.152145 0.195318 0.131894 0.226923
67 0.164858 0.156272 0.2026 0.138349 0.240458
68 0.168994 0.159378 0.209176 0.141965 0.242838
69 0.173254 0.164125 0.217868 0.145074 0.250549
70 0.178683 0.167905 0.223894 0.150818 0.256553
71 0.184343 0.173812 0.231458 0.157437 0.265866
72 0.188666 0.179016 0.240087 0.163918 0.274908
73 0.193536 0.184298 0.246567 0.169648 0.285
74 0.202224 0.191292 0.253623 0.177273 0.292494
75 0.207108 0.196387 0.266958 0.182964 0.299387
76 0.217681 0.201409 0.275478 0.189957 0.313514
77 0.229241 0.209955 0.29009 0.195505 0.327354
78 0.23791 0.219185 0.299492 0.20202 0.354237
79 0.247286 0.232301 0.315254 0.214805 0.363977
80 0.257874 0.240074 0.333333 0.222909 0.377399
81 0.271211 0.256192 0.363077 0.237815 0.379902
82 0.276947 0.2672 0.375221 0.247756 0.389972
83 0.291812 0.287431 0.390342 0.258703 0.411765
84 0.304139 0.313305 0.423077 0.278997 0.456693
85 0.309677 0.329146 0.422096 0.29797 0.450893
86 0.330488 0.342067 0.447811 0.318436 0.455026
87 0.348138 0.366609 0.472222 0.344 0.468208
88 0.374787 0.398305 0.497653 0.36246 0.521127
89 0.400394 0.430809 0.508287 0.376218 0.554622
90 0.421911 0.468944 0.535032 0.411905 0.561224
91 0.443149 0.501887 0.574627 0.452663 0.58427
92 0.48227 0.563981 0.626168 0.509225 0.701493
93 0.548837 0.603448 0.681319 0.550661 0.721311
94 0.608696 0.678082 0.722222 0.609626 0.754386
95 0.694215 0.710744 0.779661 0.620915 0.8125
 96 0.808511 0.757895 0.844444 0.709402 0.896552
97 0.855072 0.924528 0.931034 0.833333 0.888889
98 0.9375 0.962963 0.833333 0.926829 0.833333
99 0.888889
100
 Precision_Comparison_Non_motor
1.2

0.8

0.6

0.4

0.2

0
0 20 40 60 80

XGBoost CAT_Boost CAT_SGD_Mean CAT_SGD_Max CAT_S

_Non_motor

80 100 120

CAT_SGD_Max CAT_SGD_Min