You are on page 1of 63

Structures Multiniveaux chapitre Structures Multiniveaux chapitre 33

Prof. Dan FLORICAU Prof. Dan FLORICAU Universit POLITEHNICA de Bucarest Universit POLITEHNICA de Bucarest

11

Besoins applicatifs Besoins applicatifs


Conversion dnergie en Forte Puissance: Exemple: Les applications Variation Vitesse Moyenne Tension

Secteur en Forte croissance Tensions de 2 10k Puissance de 300kW 10MW


Marine

Mtallurgie
Laminoir

Propulsion marine

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS - -D. Floricau 2008

22

Cellule de conversion de base 2N Cellule de conversion de base 2N


Properties: Properties: V ripple = E V ripple = E F ripple = Fd F ripple = Fd V max IGBT = E V max IGBT = E
I = E (1 ), max pour = 0.5 L Fd E I max = 4 L Fd
Semi-conducteur de puissance: Semi-conducteur de puissance: -gamme limite (<6.5 kV) -gamme limite (<6.5 kV) -performances rduites -performances rduites

E + iload

Besoins applicatifs: Besoins applicatifs: -augmentation de la puissance -augmentation de la puissance -augmentation de la tension -augmentation de la tension -augmentation des performances -augmentation des performances

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

33

Besoins applicatifs Besoins applicatifs


Pompage,

Wind energy

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

44

Semi-conducteurs de Puissance Semi-conducteurs de Puissance

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

55

Semi-conducteurs de Puissance Semi-conducteurs de Puissance


Calibre des interrupteurs de puissance

Surface silicium composants semi-conducteur

Augmentation paisseur Augmentation surface

paisseur
Augmentation tenue en tension (+) Diminution des performances (-)

Surface
Augmentation courant (+) Performances quivalentes (=)

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

66 44

Fractionnement ou associations Fractionnement ou associations


Pour adresser ces niveaux de tension / Puissance, deux solution sont possibles:
Fractionner les contraintes en tension Utiliser des associations de cellules ou convertisseurs

Intrts
Augmentation puissance Augmentation des performances Meilleure modularit Plus de degr de libert

Inconvnients
Rpartition des contraintes Autoriser lutilisation des degrs de libert

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

77 55

Association srie directe de composants Association srie directe de composants


Association srie:
Fractionner les contraintes en tension Utiliser des associations de cellules ou convertisseurs

Intrts
Augmentation de la tension Calibre interrupteurs plus petit Macro composants plus performants Augmentation Fd

Inconvnients
Rpartition des contraintes dynamiques Pas damlioration des formes dondes

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

88

Association srie directe de composants Association srie directe de composants


Cellule de conversion de base
E E/2 ? E/2 ?

Properties: Properties: V ripple = E V ripple = E F ripple = Fd F ripple = Fd V max IGBT = E/2 V max IGBT = E/2 ?? quilibrage
Rpartition des contraintes dynamique

E/2 iload O E E/2 Macro-composant A


E/2

uAO

10*iload

E/2

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

99

Association srie directe de composants Association srie directe de composants

Spectre de la tension de sortie 2 niveaux


Fs=50Hz Fd=1kHz

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

10 10

Association parallle de composants Association parallle de composants


Association parallle:
Augmentation du courant

Intrts
Augmentation du courant trait

Inconvnients
Pad damlioration des performances Pas damlioration des formes dondes

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

11 11

Association parallle de composants Association parallle de composants

Cellule de conversion de base

E/2

iload

Properties: Properties: V ripple = E V ripple = E F ripple = Fd F ripple = Fd V max IGBT = E V max IGBT = E

E/2

quilibrage
Macro-composant

Rpartition des contraintes dynamique

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

12 12

Structure 3L- SC4 (Stacked Cells, Bhagwat-1980) Structure 3L- SC4 (Stacked Cells, Bhagwat-1980)
Cellules de conversion superposes
Contraintes en tension sur les interrupteurs

V max IGBT V max IGBT


+ + E S2c O S1 S1c A S2 iload
E
ik

S1, S2c

uk

Properties: Properties: V ripple = E/2 V ripple = E/2 F ripple = Fd F ripple = Fd

ik
E/2

S1c+ S2
uk

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

13 13

S1c+S interrupteur 4 quadrants Structure 3L- SC (Stacked Cells) S1c+S22 interrupteur 4 quadrants ? Structure 3L- SC (Stacked Cells) ?
Cellules de conversion superposes
E/2 10*iload uAO

+ + E O

S1 S1c A S2

iload

E/2

S2c
iload>0, iload<0
Sr>0 Sr<0

+ Niveaux de tension: 0, E/2

S1 O S1c S2 S2c A

iload

+ + E O

S1 S1c A S2 S2c

iload
iload>0, iload<0 Niveaux de tension: -E/2, 0

+ E

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

14 13 14 13

Commande MLI Commande MLI


1
Dure de conduction

Duty cycle 1

T1

-1

vAO [u.r.]

Dure de conduction

T2

Sd1

Sr

Sd2

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

15 15

Analyse FFT de la tension de sortie pour 3L-SC Analyse FFT de la tension de sortie pour 3L-SC
Spectre de la tension de sortie 2N:
uAO E/2 10*iload

Fs=50Hz Fd=1kHz

Spectre de la tension de sortie 3N-SC:


E/2

iload

Fs=50Hz Fd=1kHz

Imax =

E/2 E = 4 L Fd 8 L Fd
16 16

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

Finalement 3L-SC6 Finalement 3L-SC6


La structure pourra donc tre la suivante:
S2 + S1 O + E S2c S1c A S3 S3c
Cellule 1: S1-S1c

Stratgie de commande:
Duty cycle 1

iload
-1 0 vAO [u.r.] 1

Dure de conduction

T1

tous les interrupteurs de la structure sont dimensionns pour E/2 3 cellules de commutation

Cellule 2: S2-S2c

2 3

Dure de conduction

T2

Cellule 3: S3-S3c

Dure de conduction

T3
17 17

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

Implantation de la commande Implantation de la commande


uAO

S2 + S1 O + E S2c S1c A S3 S3c iload


10*iload

iload>0, iload<0

Sr>0

Sr<0

S2 + S1 O S1c S2c S3 S3c A iload

S2 + S1 S1c A S3 S3c iload

iload>0, iload<0

O + E S2c

Niveaux de tension: 0, E/2

+ E

Niveaux de tension: -E/2, 0 18 18

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

Squences de commutation Squences de commutation


VDC/2 Sd1 O+ P 0 0 S1 Tsw/2 Tsw O+

Sd2 N O-

S2 + S1 O + E S2c S1c A S3 S3c iload

Sr

Sr -VDC/2 0 S1 S1c S2 S2c S3 S3c Tsw/2

O-

Tsw

S1c S2 S2c

Output Voltage (vA0) -E/2 0 E/2

Switching State N O O+ P
-

Switch Sequence S1 0 0 0 1 S1c 1 1 1 0 S2 0 0 1 1 S2c 1 1 0 0 S3 0 1 1 1 S3c 1 0 0 0

S3 S3c VAO 0 (a) VDC/2

0 VAO (b)

VDC/2

Voltage levels: 0; E/2

Voltage levels: -E/2; 0

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

19 19

Calculus of total losses in power devices Calculus of total losses in power devices
The total losses (PX): The conduction losses (PcondX):

PX = PcondX + PswX

(1) (2)

PcondX = PcondT + PcondD


condT condT PcondT = vCE 0 I avg + rdT I rms

where: vCE0, rdT, vD0 and rdD parameters of the transistors and diodes
(3)

condD PcondD = v D 0 I avg

+ rdD

condD 2 I rms

(4)

The switching losses (PswX):

v swX swX 2 PswX = f sw sw AswX sw + BswX I avg +C swX I rms vdef

(5)

where, AswX, BswX, CswX and vdef constants taken from the IGBTs characteristics, sw ratio between the switching interval and the switching period for semiconductor device
Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 20 20

Total losses in power devices Total losses in power devices


S2 + S1 O + E S2c S1c A S3 S3c iload

The following hypotheses were considered to calculate the losses in power devices: the the the the load is linear; load current is sinusoidal; current and voltage ripples are neglected; dead times of the IGBT modules are neglected.

f T1(x ) = M sin x, x [0, ]


I conT1 = avg
I conT1 = rms

1 2

2 I sin(x ) f T1 (x ) dx =

I 2 M [( ) cos + sin ] 4
M 4 1 1 + cos + cos(2 ) 2 3 3

T1

1 2

2 I sin (x ) f T1 (x ) dx = I

)2

I swT1 = avg

1 2

2 I sin (x )dx =

I 2 (1 + cos()) 2
1 sin (2) + 2 2

IswT1 = rms

1 2

2I sin (x ) dx = I

)2

Simulated distribution of losses in 3L-SC converter featuring Eupec IGBTs (VDC= 3000V, Irms=200A, fs=1000Hz, Eupec FF200R33KF2C): (a) PF=-1, M=0.05, (b) PF=1, M=0.95

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

21 21

Structure 3L-NPC (Neutral Point Clamped) Structure 3L-NPC (Neutral Point Clamped)
Principe de la structure: Association srie directe Ajout 2 diodes clamp pour fixer la tension aux bornes des interrupteurs S1 et S2c lors de la conduction de S2 et S1c Fractionner la tension dentre

S1

+ Du O Dd S2 A

Duty cycle 1 2 1
Cellule 1: S1-S1c

iload R L
-1

Dure de conduction

T1

+ E S2c S1c

1 vAO [u.r.]
Cellule 2: S2-S2c

Dure de conduction

T2

(Nabae, 1981) (Nabae, 1981)


Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 22 22

3L-NPC: configuration possible 3L-NPC: configuration possible

S1 + Du O Dd + E S2c S1c S2 A iload

S1 et S2 = ON S1c et S2c = OFF

VAO = E/2

Properties: Properties: V ripple = E/2 V ripple = E/2 F ripple = Fd F ripple = Fd V max IGBT = E/2 V max IGBT = E/2

S1 + Du O Dd + E S2c S1c S2 A iload

S1 et S2 = OFF S1c et S2c = ON

S1 + Du O Dd + E S2c S1c S2 A iload

S1 et S2c = OFF S1c et S2 = ON

VAO = -E/2

VAO = 0

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

23 23

Le zro volt par les diodes: 2 cas possible Le zro volt par les diodes: 2 cas possible

S1 + Du O Dd + E S2c S1c
S1 + Du O Dd + E S2c S1c E + S2c S1c S2 A iload O Dd Du S2 A iload

S2 A

iload

iload>0
S1 + -

iload<0

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

24 24

Structure = 2 cellules de base + Cells) Cellule 3L-NPC = 2 SC (Stacked diodes Structure 3L- cellules de base + 22diodes clamp Cellule 3L-NPC 3L- SC (Stacked Cells) clamp
Cellule 3L-NPC
E/2
S1 + Du O Dd + E S2c S1c S2 A iload

uAO

10*iload

E/2

Sr>0

S1 + Du O Dd + E S2c S1c S2 A

S1 + Du O Dd + E S2c S1c S2 A

Sr<0

iload>0, iload<0 Niveaux de tension: 0, E/2

iload

iload

iload>0, iload<0 Niveaux de tension: -E/2, 0 25 13 25 13

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

Commande MLI Commande MLI


Dure de conduction

Duty cycle 1

T1

-1

vAO [u.r.]

Dure de conduction

T2

Sd1

Sr

Sd2

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

26 26

Analyse FFT de la tension de sortie pour 3L-NPC Analyse FFT de la tension de sortie pour 3L-NPC
Spectre de la tension de sortie 2N:
uAO E/2 10*iload

Fs=50Hz Fd=1kHz

Spectre de la tension de sortie 3N-NPC:


E/2

iload

Fs=50Hz Fd=1kHz

Imax =

E/2 E = 4 L Fd 8 L Fd
27 27

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

Squences de commutation Squences de commutation

S1 + Du O Dd + E S2c S1c S2 A
-1 0 Duty cycle 1

VDC/2 Sr

0
Sd1 O P O

Sd2 N O

iload

Sr -VDC/2

vAO [u.r.]

0 0 S1 S1c Ts

0 S1 S1c S2 S2c VAO 0 VDC/2 (b)

Ts/2

Ts

Output Voltage (vAO) -VDC/2 0 VDC/2

S2

Switching State N O P

Switch Sequence S1 0 0 1 S1c 1 1 0 S2 0 1 1 S2c 1 0 0

S2c VAO 0 (a)

VDC/2

Voltage levels: 0; E/2

Voltage levels: -E/2; 0

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

28 28

Total losses in power devices Total losses in power devices


S1 + Du O Dd + E S2c S1c
f T1(x ) = M sin x, x [0, ]
I conT1 = avg
I conT1 = rms

S2 A

iload

The following hypotheses were considered to calculate the losses in power devices: the the the the load is linear; load current is sinusoidal; current and voltage ripples are neglected; dead times of the IGBT modules are neglected.

1 2

2 I sin(x ) f T1 (x ) dx =

I 2 M [( ) cos + sin ] 4
M 4 1 1 + cos + cos(2 ) 2 3 3

T1

1 2

2 I sin (x ) f T1 (x ) dx = I

)2

I swT1 = avg

1 2

2 I sin (x )dx =

I 2 (1 + cos()) 2
1 sin (2) + 2 2

IswT1 = rms

1 2

2I sin (x ) dx = I

)2

Simulated distribution of losses in 3L-NPC converter featuring Eupec IGBTs (VDC= 3000V, Irms=200A, fs=1000Hz, Eupec FF200R33KF2C): (a) PF=-1, M=0.05, (b) PF=1, M=0.95

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

29 29

Structure multicellulaire imbrique

(Flying Capacitor)

Principe de la structure:
Cellule de base

2L

+ E

iload

Association srie directe Ajout dune source flottante intermdiaire Fractionner la tension dentre par combinaison

+
2L
+ E iload

+ E/2

iload
On ajoute simplement une source intermdiaire pour fixer le potentiel aux bornes des interrupteurs de la structure

Cellule de base

Cellule 3 niveaux de tension


(Meynard 1991)

3L

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

30 30

Combinaisons possibles (en Hacheur) :

Identifications des cellules de commutation Identifications des cellules de commutation

Vs = E
S1 + E C1 + E/2 C2 S2
S1 S2 + E/2 S1 S2 + E/2

Vs = E/2
iload

iload

+ E

iload

+ E

S1c

S2c

S1c

S2c

S1c

S2c

S1

S2 + E/2

S1

S2 + E/2

3 niveaux de tension [0, E/2, E] 2 possibilits pour faire du E/2

+ E

iload

+ E

iload

S1c

S2c

S1c

S2c

Vs = E/2 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

Vs = 0 31 31

Combinaisons possibles (en onduleur point milieu) :

Vs = E/2
E/2 + + E/2 S1c S2c C1 S1 + E/2 C2 S2

Vs = 0
E/2 + + E/2 S1 + E/2 S2

iload

E/2 + + E/2

S1 + E/2

S2

iload

iload

S1c

S2c

S1c

S2c

E/2 +

S1 +

S2

iload

E/2 + + E/2

S1 + E/2

S2

iload

3 niveaux de tension [-E/2, 0, E/2] 2 possibilits pour faire du 0

+ E/2 S1c

E/2

S2c

S1c

S2c

Vs = 0

Vs = -E/2

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

32 32

Exemple ralisation industrielle Exemple de de ralisation industrielle


Locomotive T13 utilisant un convertisseur multicellulaire 3kV

Solution Alstom:

Conversion 4 niveaux Structure Flying Capacitor

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

33 33

Ralisation de la source flottante

Ralisation par une source idale:

Ralisation par un condensateur flottant:

+ E

+ E/2

iload

S1 + E C1 + E/2 C2

S2

iload

3~

S1c

S2c

Structure TROP coteuse et complexe

Les porteuses sont dcales de 180 (cas idal)

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

34 34

Stratgie MLI

(doublement de la frquence en sortie)

E/2
E/2 + O + E/2 S1c S2c C1 S1 + E/2 C2 A S2

Sd2 O2 P O1

Sd1 O2 P

E/2

Sd2

Sd1

iload

Sr 0

0 Sr O 4 N O3 Tsw/2 N O4 Tsw

-E/2 S1

Tsw/2

Tsw

-E/2 S1 S1c S2 S2c

Properties: Properties: V ripple = E/2 V ripple = E/2 F ripple = Fd/2 F ripple = Fd/2 V max IGBT = E/2 V max IGBT = E/2

S1c S2 S2c VAO 0 (a) E/2

0 VAO (b)

E/2

I max =

E/2 E = 4 L 2 Fd 16 L Fd

Voltage levels: 0; E/2

Voltage levels: -E/2; 0

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

35 35

Bilan sur le control de la tension flottante


Les courants la frquence de dcoupage participent de faon prpondrante sur lquilibrage naturel Si les sources flottantes sont dsquilibres, il existe des harmoniques la frquence de dcoupage sur la tension de sortie Trois solutions:
S1
S1 + E C1 + E/2 C2 S2
S1 S2 + E/2 C1 C2 Rf Lf Cf

S2 + E/2

+ E

iload
C2

iload

+ E

iload

C1

S1c
S1c S2c
S1c S2c
Control actif

S2c

Jajoute une filtre auxiliaire Je fait rien (-) quilibrage naturel LENT (-) Si pas de charge, pas dquilibrage (-) Si charge fortement inductive (machine) peu dharmonique Fd, donc quilibrage Trs Lent (+) ne ncessite rien dautre Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 (+) quilibrage naturel RAPIDE (+) Si pas de charge, quilibrage naturel quand mme (+) Si charge fortement inductive (machine), pas de problme (-) ncessite lajout dune filtre (par phase) Je mets en place un contrle actif (+) quilibrage contrle en boucle ferme RAPIDE (-) Si pas de charge, pas dquilibrage (-) La dynamique peut dpendre du niveau de courrant en sortie 36 36

QQelements sur le dimensionnement

S1 + E C1 + E/2 C2

S2

iload
Rf Lf Cf

Filtrage
Le facteur 4 sur londulation de courrant nous permet soit de diviser londulation par 4 ( mme inductance que le 2 niveaux) OU diviser linductance par 4 pour la mme ondulation

S1c

S2c

Charge auxiliaire IGBT


Calibre en tension E/2 Calibre en courrant Is Frquence Fd

Condensateur Flottant
Tension E/2
C= Is 2 p Fd Vc max

Frquence de rsonance Fd

f =

1 L f C f

= 2 f d

Slectivit

z=

Rf 2

Cf Lf

< 0.1

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

37 37

Structure 3L-ANPC (Brckner, 2001)


1 Duty cycle Duty cycle Duty cycle

2
0

2 1=3

2
0 1 -1 (c)

3 1
0

S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c S2 A iload R L

-1 (a)

vAO [u.r.]

-1 (b)

1 vAO [u.r.]

vAO [u.r.]

MLI 1 Properties: Properties: V ripple = E/2 V ripple = E/2 ripple = Fd FFripple = Fd V max IGBT = E/2 V max IGBT = E/2

MLI 2 Properties: Properties: V ripple = E/2 V ripple = E/2 ripple = Fd FFripple = Fd V max IGBT = E/2 V max IGBT = E/2

MLI 3 Properties: Properties: V ripple = E/2 V ripple = E/2 ripple = Fd/2 FFripple = Fd/2 V max IGBT = E/2 V max IGBT = E/2

MLI 1 MLI 2

I max =

E/2 E = 4 L Fd 8 L Fd

MLI 3

I max =

E/2 E = 4 L 2 Fd 16 L Fd
38 38

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

3L-ANPC: Stratgie MLI 1


E/2

S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c


Duty cycle 1

carrier H O+ P O+

carrier L N

Sr*

S2 A

iload R L
(a)
S2 S2c S3 0 0 S1 S1c

V* -E/2

O-

O-

Tsw/2

Tsw

0 S1 S1c S2 S2c S3 S3c

Tsw/2

Tsw

S3c VAO 0 E/2

0 VAO (b)

E/2

-1

(b)

vAO [u.r.]

(a)
Voltage levels: 0; E/2

Voltage levels: -E/2; 0

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

39 39

MLI 1: combinaisons possibles


S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c S2 A iload R L

E/2

uAO 10*iload

S1 + S1c O S3 + E S2 A iload R L S3c S2c

-E/2

Sr>0
S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c E S2 A iload R L + + S1c O S3 S3c S2c S1 S2 A iload R L

Sr<0
Properties: Properties: V ripple = E/2 V ripple = E/2 ripple = Fd FFripple = Fd V max IGBT = E/2 V max IGBT = E/2
E S1 + S1c O S3 + S3c S2c S2 A iload R L E + S3 S3c S2c + S1c O S1 S2 A iload R L

uAO=E/2

uAO=0

uAO=0

uAO=-E/2 40 40

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

MLI 1: Implmentation PSIM

S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c S2 A iload R L

3L-ANPC: MLI 1
Simulated results for the 3L-ANPC PWM-1 (VDC/2=1500V, R=5, L=10mH, M=0.8, fs=1000Hz) Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 41 41

Total losses in power devices Total losses in power devices


3L-ANPC: MLI 1
S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c S2 A iload R L
The following hypotheses were considered to calculate the losses in power devices: the the the the load is linear; load current is sinusoidal; current and voltage ripples are neglected; dead times of the IGBT modules are neglected.

f T1 (x ) = M sin x, x [0, ]
I conT1 = avg 1 2

2 I sin(x ) f T1 (x ) dx =

I 2 M [( ) cos + sin ] 4
M 4 1 1 + cos + cos(2 ) 2 3 3

T1

I conT1 = rms

1 2

2 I sin (x ) f T1 (x ) dx = I

)2

IswT1 = rms

1 2

2I sin (x ) dx = I

)2

1 sin (2) + 2 2

1 I swT1 = avg 2

I 2 (1 + cos()) 2 I sin (x )dx = 2

Simulated distribution of losses in 3L-ANPC PWM-1 converter featuring Eupec IGBTs (VDC= 3000V, Irms=200A, fs=1000Hz, Eupec FF200R33KF2C): (a) PF=-1, M=0.05, (b) PF=1, M=0.95

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

42 42

3L-ANPC: Stratgie MLI 2


1 Duty cycle

S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c


+ S1c S2 O S3 + E S3c S2c E/2 A

2
S2 A

2
0 1

iload R L

Sr<0

1=3
-1 vAO [u.r.]

Sr>0

S1

S1 + S1c
iload R L

S2 O E/2 A

Properties: Properties: V ripple = E/2 V ripple = E/2 ripple = Fd FFripple = Fd V max IGBT = E/2 V max IGBT = E/2

iload R L

S3 + E S3c S2c

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

43 43

MLI 2: Combinaisons possibles

Sr>0
E/2 Sr O+ P 0 Sd1 O+

Sr<0
0 Sd2 N OSr -E/2 O-

S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c S2 E/2 A iload R L


0 S1 S1c S2 S2c S3 S3c VAO 0 (a)

S1
Ts

0 S1 S1c S2 S2c S3 S3c

Ts

+ S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c S2 E/2 A iload R L

E/2

0 VAO (b)

E/2

Voltage levels: 0; E/2

Voltage levels: -E/2; 0

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

44 44

MLI 2: Combinaisons possibles


S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c S2 E/2 A iload R L

E/2

uAO 10*iload

S1 + S1c O S3 + E S2 E/2 A iload R L S3c S2c

-E/2

uAO=E/2
S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c A iload R L S2

uAO=0
S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c A iload R L
E + -

uAO=0
S2
+ S1c O S3 S3c S2c A iload R L
E + S3 S3c

uAO=-E/2
S1 + S1c O A iload R L S2c S2

S1

S2

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

45 45

MLI 2: Implmentation PSIM

S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c S2 A iload R L

3L-ANPC: MLI 2
Simulated results for the 3L-ANPC PWM-2(VDC/2=1500V, R=5, L=10mH, M=0.8, fs=1000Hz) Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 46 46

Total losses in power devices Total losses in power devices


3L-ANPC: MLI 2
S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c S2 A iload R L
The following hypotheses were considered to calculate the losses in power devices: the the the the load is linear; load current is sinusoidal; current and voltage ripples are neglected; dead times of the IGBT modules are neglected.

f T1 (x ) = M sin x, x [0, ]
I conT1 = avg 1 2

2 I sin(x ) f T1 (x ) dx =

I 2 M [( ) cos + sin ] 4
M 4 1 1 + cos + cos(2 ) 2 3 3

T1

I conT1 = rms

1 2

2 I sin (x ) f T1 (x ) dx = I

)2

IswT1 = rms

1 2

2I sin (x ) dx = I

)2

1 sin (2) + 2 2

1 I swT1 = avg 2

I 2 (1 + cos()) 2 I sin (x )dx = 2

Simulated distribution of losses in 3L-ANPC PWM-2 converter featuring Eupec IGBTs (VDC= 3000V, Irms=200A, fs=1000Hz, Eupec FF200R33KF2C): (a) PF=-1, M=0.05, (b) PF=1, M=0.95

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

47 47

3L-ANPC: Stratgie MLI 3

(Prof. D. FLORICAU, 2008)

S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c S2 A iload R L


S1 + S1c S2 E/2 S3 + E S3c S2c A iload R L

Duty cycle

2 1

Sr<0
-1 0

Sr>0
1

vAO [u.r.]

S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c S2 A iload R L

Properties: Properties: V ripple = E/2 V ripple = E/2 ripple = 2Fd FFripple = 2Fd V max IGBT = E/2 V max IGBT = E/2

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

48 48

MLI 3: Combinaisons possibles

Sr>0
E/2 Sr O1+ Sd1 P O2+ Sd2 P O1+

Sr<0
E/2 Sd1 Sd2

S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c S2 A iload R L

0 Sr

O 1N

O 2N

O 1-

S1 + S1c S3 + E S3c S2c S2 E/2 A iload R L

-E/2 0 S1 S1c S2 S2c S3 S3c vAO 0 (a) E/2 Ts

-E/2 0 S1 S1c S2 S2c S3 S3c 0 vAO (b) E/2 Ts

Voltage levels: 0; E/2

Voltage levels: -E/2; 0

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

49 49

MLI 3: Spectre de la tension de sortie Spectre de la tension de sortie 2N: Fs=50Hz Fd=1kHz
E/2 uAO 10*iload

Spectre de la tension de sortie 3N-ANPC PWM 3:


-E/2

Fs=50Hz 2Fd=1000Hz Fd=500Hz

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

50 50

MLI 3: Implmentation PSIM

S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c S2 A iload R L

3L-ANPC: MLI 3
Simulated results for the 3L-ANPC PWM-3 (VDC/2=1500V, R=5, L=10mH, M=0.8, fs=500Hz) Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 51 51

Total losses in power devices Total losses in power devices


3L-ANPC: MLI 3
S1 + S1c O S3 + E S3c S2c S2 A iload R L
The following hypotheses were considered to calculate the losses in power devices: the the the the load is linear; load current is sinusoidal; current and voltage ripples are neglected; dead times of the IGBT modules are neglected.

f T1 (x ) = M sin x, x [0, ]
I conT1 = avg 1 2

2 I sin(x ) f T1 (x ) dx =

I 2 M [( ) cos + sin ] 4
M 4 1 1 + cos + cos(2 ) 2 3 3

T1

I conT1 = rms

1 2

2 I sin (x ) f T1 (x ) dx = I

)2

IswT1 = rms

1 2

2I sin (x ) dx = I

)2

1 sin (2) + 2 2

1 I swT1 = avg 2

I 2 (1 + cos()) 2 I sin (x )dx = 2

Simulated distribution of losses in 3L-ANPC PWM-3 converter featuring Eupec IGBTs (VDC= 3000V, Irms=200A, fs=500Hz, Eupec FF200R33KF2C): (a) PF=-1, M=0.05, (b) PF=1, M=0.95

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

52 52

Squences de commutation pour 3L-ANPC


MLI 1
Output Voltage (vA0) -VDC/2 0 VDC/2 Switching State N OO+ P Switch Sequence S1 0 0 0 1 S1c 0 0 1 0 S2 0 0 1 1 S2c 1 1 0 0 S3 0 1 0 0 S3c 1 0 0 0

MLI 2
Output Voltage (vA0) -VDC/2 0 VDC/2 Switching State N O O+ P
-

Fin Chapitre 4

Switch Sequence S1 0 0 0 1 S1c 0 0 1 0 S2 0 0 1 1 S2c 1 1 0 0 S3 0 1 0 0 S3c 1 0 0 0

MLI 3
The three PWM strategies differ by the type and by the number of zero switching states. The zero switching states can be used to distribute losses more evenly among the semiconductors. The intention is not to save total converter losses, but to distribute them equally. The commutations to or from the zero states determine the distribution of the switching losses. All commutations take place between one active switch and one diode. Even if more than two devices turn on or off, only one active switch and one diode experience essential switching losses. The distribution of conduction losses during the zero states can be controlled by the selection of the upper or lower ANPC path. The conduction losses in the states P and N cannot be influenced.
Output Voltage (vA0) -VDC/2 Switching State N O10 O2O1+ O2+ VDC/2 P Switch Sequence S1 0 0 0 0 1 1 S1c 1 0 1 1 0 0 S2 0 0 1 1 0 1 S2c 1 1 0 0 1 0 S3 0 1 0 0 1 1 S3c 1 0 1 0 0 0

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

53 53

5L-SMC Commutation Cell (Gateau, 2001)

3L-SC (1980)
VDC

+ + O A

iload

+ -

iload O A

VDC
iload

+ -

3L-FC (1991)

+ VDC

5L-Stacked Multilevel Converter (Gateau, 2001)


54 54

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

5L-ANPC Commutation Cell (Barbosa, 2005) 5L-ANPC Commutation Cell (Barbosa, 2005)

+ -

ANPC-3L (2001)
Fig. 13
VDC

iload O + A

+ -

iload

iload O + A

FC-3L (1992)
Fig. 14

+ VDC

VDC
Fig. 15

5L-Barbosa Topology (2005) (5L-ANPC)


55 55

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

PWM Strategy for 5L-ANPC PWM Strategy for 5L-ANPC


VDC/2 carrier 2 carrier 1

VDC/2 V* P1

carrier 2 P1 P2

carrier 1 P1 P2

VDC/4

VDC/4
O
+

S3 + S3c O S4 + VDC S4c S2c S1c S2 S1 A iload

V* P 1 0 S1 0

O P1 Tsw/2

P1 Tsw

0 0 S1 S1c S2 S2c S3, 4 S3c, 4c VAO VDC/4 0 VDC/4 Tsw/2 Tsw

R L

S1c S2 S2c S3, 4

Fig. 16

S3c, 4c VAO

Higher levels: 0, +VDC/4, +VDC/2 Higher levels: 0, +VDC/4, +VDC/2

0 (a)

VDC/4

Fig. 17

(b)
56 56

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

PWM Strategy for 5L-ANPC PWM Strategy for 5L-ANPC


0
V* -VDC/4 carrier 4 carrier 3

carrier 4

carrier 3

N1 O-

N1 O-

N1
-VDC/4 V*

N2 N1 0 N1 Tsw/2

N2 N1 Tsw

S3 + S3c O S4 + VDC S4c S2c S1c S2 S1 A iload R L


-VDC/2 0 S1 S1c S2 S2c S3, 4 S3c, 4c 0 Tsw/2 Tsw

-VDC/2 S1 S1c S2 S2c S3, 4 S3c, 4c 0


-VDC/4

Lower levels: 0, -VDC/4, -VDC/2 Lower levels: 0, -VDC/4, -VDC/2

VDC/4

-VDC/4

VAO (c)

VAO

VDC/4

Fig. 18

(d)

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

57 57

Simulation results for 5L-ANPC Simulation results for 5L-ANPC

S3 + S3c O S4 + VDC S4c S2c S1c S2 S1 A iload R L

VDC=800V, ss=500Hz, R=1, L=1mH, M=0.9 VDC=800V, FF=500Hz, R=1, L=1mH, M=0.9

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

58 58

3L-SNPC Commutation Cell (Floricau, 2007)


It is made of 6 switches (3 commutation cells: S1-S1c , S2-S2c and S3-S3c) disposed on three sides and two clamp diodes (Du, Dd) ; Each switch is capable to support a voltage equal to VDC/2. The commutation cells are controlled with duty cycles 1, 2 and 3:
S2 A iload S1c S3 S2c
-1 1

S1 + Du O Dd + VDC S3c

Duty cycle
1

Duty cycle

2 1
0 1

3
0.5 -1 0

2 1 vAO [u.r.]
1

vAO [u.r.]

(a) PWM1

(b) PWM2 59 59

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

Sinusoidal PWM-1 Strategy for 3L-SNPC


VDC/2 V
*

carrier H O+
P

0
O+
N

carrier L
+ -

S1 + Du S2 iload>0 A Dd S1c iload<0 S3c S2c VDC S3 + -

S1 Du O Dd

iload<0

iload>0

S2 A S1c S3 S2c

V
Tsw

O-

O-

O + -

0 0 S1 S1c S2 S2c S3 S3c VAO 0 (a) VDC/2


Voltage levels: 0; VDC/2

Tsw/2

-VDC/2

Tsw/2

Tsw

VDC

S1 S1c S2 S2c S3 S3c 0 VAO (b) Voltage levels: -VDC/2; 0 VDC/2


+ VDC

O state
S1 + Du O Dd S2 A S3

(a)

S3c

P state
S1 + Du O Dd S1c S3 S2 A iload>0

S1c

S3c

iload<0 S 2c

iload>0

+ VDC S3c iload<0 S 2c

N state

(b)

O- state

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

60 60

Sinusoidal PWM-2 Strategy for 3L-SNPC


VDC/2 V* 0 O1+ carrier 2 P O2+ carrier 1 P O1+
VDC/2 carrier 2 carrier 1
+ S1 + Du S2 iload>0 A S1c iload<0 S3c S2c S3 + VDC O Dd S1c iload<0 S3c
+

S1 Du S2

0 V* O1

O2 N

O1 N

iload>0 A S3 S2c

O + -

Dd

-VDC/2 S1 S1c S2 S2c S3 S3c VAO 0

Tsw/2

Tsw

-VDC/2 S1 S1c S2 S2c S3 S3c 0 VAO

Tsw/2

Tsw

VDC

O1 state

(a)

O2 state
S1 iload>0 S2 A

S1 + Du O + Dd S2 iload>0 A S3 + VDC + -

Du O Dd S1c

S1c

S3

VDC/2

VDC/2 (b)
Voltage levels: -VDC/2; 0

VDC

S3c

iload<0 S 2c

O1- state

(b)

S3c

iload<0 S 2c

O2- state

(a)

Voltage levels: 0; VDC/2

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

61 61

Experimental results for 3L-SNPC converter

3L-SNPC Structure

S1 + Du O Dd S1c S2

3L-SNPC

A iload S3 S2c R L

RL Load
R=16.7 L=6mH

+ VDC S3c

FPGA Card
Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

100V/div, 5A/div, 4ms/div

62 62

Merci pour votre attention

FIN

Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008 Cours SOCS D. Floricau 2008

63 63

You might also like