Consultant
Has expertise in a specific area, offers unbiased opinion and advice for a fee
Not an employee, but an independent contractor
REASONS FOR BECOMING CONSULTANTS (FWDIFSWUR)
1. Frustration with current job
2. Want a stimulating, dynamic, growing career
3. Dissatisfied with lack of challenges, opportunity or creativity in existing job
4. In between jobs and seeking new opportunities & careers
5. Foresee getting laid off & wish to establish themselves in a business to earn livelihood
6. Supplementary income
7. Retired with expertise & wisdom
8. With working experience & industry knowledge who want to combine family life with work at home
9. Understand gov’t operations and the contract process or built up contacts in gov’t, politics & industry over years
Consulting challenge quiz - one way to find out if one possesses the qualities required of a consultant
Skills - developed or acquired abilities
Talents - natural endowment; unique gift or special attribute
Attributes - inherent characteristics
TRADITIONAL AREAS OF EXPERTISE FOR CPA FIRMS (AAI > AAIM)
1. Auditing
2. Accounting system design and installation
3. Income tax work
Management consultancy
Rapidly growing area
Natural area of development of a public accountant
Extremely useful to business manager
Independent and objective advisory service
Recommend solutions to issues
Effect constructive change
Management advisory service
Function of providing professional advisory
Improve client’s use of capabilities and resources
TYPES OF ENCOUNTER
1. Consultations
Providing advice and information during a short time frame
Information provided is orally
Definitive: consultant is fully aware of the situation
Qualified to limitations: lack of first-hand observations or familiarity
2. Engagements
Analytical approach and process is applied in a study or project (FOPSFS)
o Ascertain facts and circumstances
o Identify objectives
o Define problem or opportunity for improvement
o Determine possible solutions
o Present findings and recommendations
o Implement solution
CPA’s purpose in engaging in MAS
Provide advice and technical assistance (not management decisions or positions that might impair objectivity)
ESSENTIAL QUALIFICATIONS (PAFT)
1. Technical competence 3. Analytical ability & experience in problem solving
2. Familiarity with client’s finance, control system and 4. Professional independence, objectivity & integrity
business problems
DEVELOPING TRENDS (TICS)
1. Specialization in different areas 3. Change in the management culture
2. Improvement of business education 4. Technical development
FUTURE PROSPECTS (MOMDB)
1. Management consulting will become even more specialized
2. Orientation will be towards being insight provider, creator and sharer of information
3. Management consultancy firms will tend to remain small or quite large
a. Small firm - narrow areas of specialization
b. Large firm - wide range of services to sustain high cost of operation
4. Dev’t of sophisticated marketing of services
5. Bright students’ career attraction will continue in management consulting
THE CONSULTING INDUSTRY (ICCOHO)
1. Information Technology (IT) 4. Operations management
2. Consulting and system integration 5. Human resources management
3. Corporate strategy 6. Outsourcing
MAIN TYPES OF CONSULTANT FIRMS (IAMI)
1. IT firms 3. Major consulting only firms
2. Accounting firms offering consultancy 4. Independents
CAREER STRUCTURE IN CONSULTING FIRMS (ACSBD)
1. Analysts
Most graduates would start
Gather information and processing it for the consulting team
Offered by large firms only
2. Consultants
Promoted analysts or those who have been in industry and have moved to consulting as a career change
Evaluation of the client business and make recommendations on its behalf
3. Senior consultants/Managers
Lead a consulting team and undertake a project on behalf of client
3-5 years of consulting experience
Ability to take responsibility of running small consulting projects
Deal with members of client team
4. Business development managers
Develop the firm’s products and build relationship with clients
Involved in large, complex consulting projects at strategic level
5-10 years of consulting experience
5. Directors/Partners (private)
Development of the organization as a whole and lead its strategic development
Overall responsibility for projects
10+ years of consulting experience
RATIONALE FOR USING MANAGEMENT CONSULTANTS (PAIT)
1. Independent viewpoint
See the true nature of the problems
Distinguish feasible and infeasible
Unbiased suggestion
2. Professional advisory
Possesses special knowledge, skill and variety of personal attributes
Introduce new ideas into the organization
Provide in-house training to keep staff informed
3. Temporary professional service
Less expensive (no tax deductions or fringe benefits)
May be hired on a project, seasonal, or new funding basis
4. Agent of change
Stimulate ideas in organization that might be resistant to change
TYPES OF MAS ENGAGEMENTS (NSPTIG)
1. Nature of the problem
a. Corrective
Situation in which conditions have worsened
Arises suddenly and demands urgent action
b. Progressive
Existing situation that can be improved
c. Opportunistic
Situation in which a future opportunity exists
Likely to lead to more risky and rewarding courses of action
2. Service delivery area
Functions or activities in which the problem exists
3. Phases of the analytic process
Engagement could involve one, more, or all of the phases (cannot be totally isolated)
a. Identifying objectives
b. Defining the problem
c. Finding out the facts
d. Developing the solution
e. Implementing the solution
4. Techniques and methodologies applied
Information systems planning and design
5. Industry/Nature of organization
Client, subject of an engagement
6. Geographical area
Location (single or multiple)
AREAS OF MS PRACTICE (MIIAT)
1. Management functions of analysis, planning, organizing and controlling
2. Introduction of new ideas, concepts and methods to management
3. Improvement of policies, procedures, systems, methods, and organizational relationships
4. Application and use of managerial accounting, control systems, data processing, and mathematical techniques and
methods
5. The conduct of special studies, preparation of recommendation
TYPES OF CONSULTANCY WORK (BIIMBO)
1. Business planning and development/Project feasibility studies
Project proposal: establish what the client wants and manage expectations about what can be achieved
Business planning/development: ambitions to grow and develop; great opportunity
Project feasibility study report: presents the process by the consultant and the outcome of investigation
2. Information systems consulting
Information needed: business’s external situation (competitive environment) and internal state
Management information system: collect and organize information and present to managers in usable form
3. Internal audit services
4. Management/Operations audit
Operational audit (management/performance audits): evaluate the effectiveness and efficiency of operations;
degree of operational efficiency, effectiveness, and economy
5. Business process improvement/Reengineering
Reengineering: complete redesign of a process on finding creative new ways to accomplish an objective
Organizational culture: mindset of employees, shared beliefs, values, goals
Change champion: recognizes the need for change and seeks to bring it about through own efforts
Well-defined process for change: timetable, well-articulated goals, and follow-up
6. Others such as (MMDPNDES)
a. Marketing research
Discover nature of competitive environment
Powerful approach to identify business opportunities
TYPES
o Primary Research - information collected for the specific project
Quantitative Research - statistical or numerical form (how much, often, many)
Qualitative Research - do not demand quantified answer (who, what, why)
o Secondary Research - information collected earlier (existing reports and articles)
b. Marketing strategy development
Approach to get the customer’s attention and get them to spend their money on products or services
c. Developing promotional campaign
Promotional campaign: inform customers about product, stimulate interest, and encourage purchase
d. Planning sales force activity
Sales team: primary promotional tool
One of the most important investment the firm will make (detailed and thoughtful offers real returns)
e. New product development
Often undertaken by interdisciplinary teams
Complex project that draws in most or all of the firm’s functions
f. Developing proposal for financial support
Infusion of capital
g. Staff recruitment
Human resource, identify skill and knowledge
h. Exporting and international market
Based on sound preliminary research and a thorough understanding of what to expect
MANAGEMENT CONSULTANCY SERVICES BY CPAS
1. Traditional services
a. Managerial accounting - planning and controlling business and decision making
b. Design and appraisal of accounting system
c. Financial management-related service
d. Project feasibility studies
2. Emerging consultancy services
a. Global risk management solution - managing the totality of risks and determination of critical risks
i. AREAS OF RISK MANAGEMENT SERVICES
1. Financial risk management
2. Strategic risk management
3. Operational and systems risk management
4. Compliance risk management
5. Internal audit services
b. Transaction services - mergers, acquisition, divestitures, joint ventures, spin-off and strategic alliance
c. Financial advisory services - financial, economic and strategic advice to companies with complex problems
d. Project finance and privatization - related to partnership between public and private sectors in delivering
infrastructure and services or privatization and project finance
e. Valuation services - guide clients through complex business transaction
f. Business recovery services - implementation, rationalization and recovery programs
g. Dispute analysis and investigation - environmental analysis, real estate damage, investigative services
h. Computer risk management - implementation and use of technology
i. Application software selection and implementation - assist clients in prioritizing their needs, identifying the
right software and tailoring it to meet their requirement
DETERMINING THE SCOPE OF THE SERVICE
1. Responsibility to establish scope of services
2. Independence - not make management decisions
3. Competence - professional quality; technical qualifications and ability to supervise and evaluate
4. Requirement for specialization
5. Identification and resolution of client’s basic problems
6. Referrals
7. Code of Professional Ethics
TYPES OF CLIENTS SERVED (CIPUIU)
1. Contact clients
First approaches the consultant
2. Intermediate clients
Members of the organization who become involved
Work with the consultant and provide information (sit in meetings and influence the project)
May be actual recipients of the final report
3. Primary clients
Identified the problem and most immediately affected
Willing to pay to have the issue resolved
4. Unwitting clients
Members of the organization who will be affected but are unaware
No direct or formal control
5. Indirect clients
Members of the organization who will be affected and are aware
Consultant is unaware they will be impacted
Feel positive or negative about the consultant’s intervention
6. Ultimate clients
Total community that will be affected
Universe whose interests the consultant must take account
GROUPS OF CLIENTS THAT CPAS CAN PROVIDE MAS (PGNPO)
1. Privately-owned business firms - merchandising, manufacturing, banking, transportation, etc.
2. Governmental agencies and organization - BIR, SEC, Bureau of Customs, DOH, etc.
3. Not-for-profit nongovernment organization - hospitals, research institutions, charitable institutions, etc.
4. Professional association - lawyers, doctors, etc.
5. Others
OUTPUT OF A CONSULTING EXERCISE (FISING)
1. Provision of information
Information = valuable = cost
2. Provision of specialist expertise
Application of technical knowledge and ability to use specialist analysis techniques
3. Provision of a new perspective
Managers are not decision making automata (use 'cognitive maps', 'mindsets', or 'dominant logics')
Offer conceptual frameworks and support
4. Provision of support for internal arguments
Disagreements arise; conflicts of opinion take a variety of form
5. Provision of support in gaining a critical resource
Attract resources to survive
Great value in structuring proposal and advising on how it might be delivered
6. Facilitating organizational change
Change: natural response to internal dynamics of organizational growth
Change usually meets resistance (possibilities and uncertainties)
Call for change: primary goal of the consulting exercise (change management)
PROFESSIONAL ATTRIBUTES OF MANAGEMENT CONSULTANTS (Prof. J. Owen Cherrington) (TIC)
1. Technical skills
Education requirement: depends on area of specialization
o Technical training
Length of education - bachelor’s degree
Type of education - technical and general degree
o Common core requirement
Communications
Mathematics and statistics
Computer data processing
2. Interpersonal skills (IIOUJCAPPRPA)
Personal attributes that make an individual amiable and effective
a. Intelligence/Capacity for logical thinking and reasoning
Mental organization to relate facts in a logical fashion and reason inductively and deductively
b. Integrity
Moral and ethical soundness, fairness, equity, honest, dependability
c. Objectivity
Unbiased, independent
d. Understanding of people
Anticipate human reactions, maintain friendly relations and mutual confidence, and respect rights
e. Judgment
Ability and reasoning power to arrive at a wise decision
f. Courage
Strength of mind and character to encounter disagreement with firmness of spirit and determination
g. Ambition
Desire and motivation to earn full recognition
h. Psychological maturity
View situations in perspective and take action on a controlled basis
i. Physiological equilibrium
High-energy level
j. Relationship-building skills (analysis of the business and people)
An ability to build rapport and trust with the client
o Rapport: people communicate with ease and work together effectively
o Trust and commitment to each other
An ability to question effectively
o Questioning: one of the fundamental communication skills
o Way to get information, build rapport, and control direction of conversation
An ability to communicate ideas succinctly and precisely
o Offer something the business cannot offer itself
o Use technical knowledge to create value for the business (no jargon)
o Consultant talks the same language as the client
An ability to negotiate objectives and outcomes
o Outcomes must be defined and agreed by consultant and client
o Clear expectations of the result and both parties’ responsibilities in achieving them
An ability to convince through verbal, written and visual mediums
o Use ideas to encourage people to follow them
o Communicated in a way that convinces people they are good and are worth implementing
o Conviction = manner is appropriate to the audience
An ability to use information to make a case for a particular course of action
o Ideas must be backed up with information (facts and interpretation of facts)
o Know when and how to use a particular information
An ability to develop selling strategies
o Formal selling approach: communicate what the consultant can offer and be used to build long-
term relationship
An ability to work effectively as a member of a team
o Advocate individual interests and compromise individual concerns for the interest of the group
An ability to listen effectively
o Active listening
An ability to demonstrate leadership
o Leadership: focus and direct individuals that brings the organization benefits; most valuable
commodity
o Not an inherent and fixed property of an individual (situational)
k. Project management skills (deliver negotiated outcomes)
An ability to define objectives and outcomes
o Objective: state what the project is going to achieve (SMART)
An ability to develop formal plans
o Plan: course of action to achieve objectives
o Defining tasks, identifying who will be responsible, and financial implications of activities
An ability to sequence and prioritize tasks
o Coordinate tasks within the shape of overall project (timetabling)
o Prioritization: undertaken by individuals and between individuals
o Shorter time and lower cost
An ability to manage the financial resources that are to be invested in the consulting project
o Keeping track of expenditure; managed budgets
An ability to recognize the human expertise necessary to deliver the project
o Understand how members can specialize their roles
o Differentiation activities = specialize contribution
An ability to manage personal time
o Productive use of time, avoid last-minute panics, less stress
l. Analysis skills
An ability to identify what information is available in a particular situation
o Problem definition and questioning skills
An ability to identify what information is needed in a particular situation
o Distinguish information from that which is a distraction
o Nature of the decisions, significance to project, and type of information available
An ability to process that information to identify the important relationships within it
o Draw conclusions
An ability to draw meaning from that information and use it to support decision-making
o Identify impact of conclusions
o Private aspect: detached and reflective consideration of what the information means and what is
the best option
o Public aspect: using information to make the case for a course of action, advocate options, convince
others of the correctness of course, and meet objections
o Intuitive side of analysis: supplemented by the use of formal techniques that help decision-making
An ability to recognize the business's profile of strengths, weaknesses and capabilities
o Conceptual framework: guide
An ability to recognize the opportunities and challenges the environment offers the business
o Business environment: shifting kaleidoscope of possibilities
An ability to assess the business's financial situation
o Financial performance: fundamental measure of business’s success
o Understand performance in marketplace, risks, and resources
o Forma ratio method: easiest and most rewarding method of financial analysis
An ability to evaluate the business's markets and how they are developing
o Market: total demand for a good or service
o Analysis of trends
An ability to assess the business's internal conditions
o Flexible and responsive to new possibilities (capacity to grow)
o Resources to innovate: human skills and productive capacity
An ability to analyze the way in which decision-making occurs within the business
o Know who is involved and the roles they play
3. Consulting process skills (PISPI)
Ability to understand
a. Problem definition phase
Begins with the recognition of symptom and ends with the complete description of the problem
b. Identification of alternative solutions
Fact-finding and analysis phase
c. Selection of the most desirable alternative
Solution development phase
Developing a detailed plan of the action (rationale, schedule, resources)
d. Presentation
e. Implementation Phase
Putting the detailed plan into operation
Least difficult to do
High degree of logistic complexity
COMMON BARRIERS TO EFFECTIVE COMMUNICATION (KIIRI)
Diagnostic ability: understand the circumstances surrounding the communication situation and its pitfalls
1. Know-it-all-attitude and/or prejudice of some personnel of the client
2. Inability to understand technical language
3. Inadequate background or knowledge
4. Resistance to change
5. Information overload
MAS PRACTICE STANDARDS (PCDCUPSC)
1. Personal characteristics
Integrity: ensures findings and recommendations are free of intentional distortions or misstatements
Objectivity: avoid bias and maintain impartial attitude
Independent in mental attitude: undertake engagements in which practitioner can maintain
Avoid assuming the role of management
2. Competence
Technical qualifications of practitioners (professional quality)
Ability to supervise personnel, evaluate quality of work, and accept responsibility to client
Competence: identify and define needs using analytical approach and process, and knowledge of technical
subject matter under consideration
Education (required for admission of profession) and experience (acquired by personal participation)
3. Due care
What the practitioner does and how he does it
Diligence and appropriate attention in carrying out the assignment
Systematic critical review
4. Client benefit
Problem definition, identification of objectives, and benefits
Inform client if there is a change in anticipated benefits and costs
5. Understanding with client
Inform client of objectives, scope, approach, role of all personnel, manner in which results are to be
communicated, timetable, and fee
Preliminary discussion: develop sufficient information for formulating objectives and scope
Done in formal contract, letter of understanding, or file memorandum
New arrangement if there is change in significant aspect of engagement
6. Planning, supervision, and control
Planning: translation of objectives into activities and events within a targeted time schedule (engagement plan)
Supervision: exercise judgment to the amount of supervision by competent personnel
Control: measurement of progress in meeting plan and objectives, documentations
7. Sufficient relevant data
Type and amount of data required, source and reliability of data
8. Communication of results
Findings, recommendations, accomplishments, and major assumptions must be conveyed to client
Limitations, reservations, or other qualifications
Oral or written reports (no written report = file memorandum)
Interim communications
Summarize findings, work accomplished in relation to plan and tentative recommendations
Final report
Made upon completion of engagement
Ensure results and recommendations are communicated
Responsive to objectives and scope
ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS (IOPCP)
1. Integrity - straightforward, honest, fair dealing
2. Objectivity - no bias, conflict of interest, or undue influence
3. Professional competence and due care - act diligently and in accordance with standards, sound judgment, make
clients aware of limitations
Attainment of professional competence: requires high standard of general education followed by specific
education, training, and examination
Maintenance of professional competence: requires continuing awareness and understanding of technical
developments
Diligence: act in accordance with the requirements of an assignment
4. Confidentiality - not disclose information
5. Professional behavior - comply with laws and avoid actions that discredit profession
ETHICAL CONFLICTS (CCBPM)
1. Conflict of interest - personal interest improperly influence judgment
2. Confidentiality breaches - sensitive client information is disclosed without proper authorization
3. Bias - decisions influenced by personal preferences
4. Pressure from clients - act unethically
5. Misrepresentation - false or misleading information
REASONS FOR BECOMING CONSULTANT FWDIFSWUR
TRADITIONAL AREAS AAI > AAIM
TYPES OF ENCOUNTER CE
ESSENTIAL QUALIFICATION PAFT
DEVELOPING TRENDS TICS
FUTURE PROSPECTS MOMDB
CONSULTING INDUSTRY ICCOHO
MAIN TYPES OF CONSULTANT FIRMS IAMI
CAREER STRUCTURE IN CONSULTING FIRMS ACSBD
RATIONALE FOR USING MANAGEMENT CONSULTANTS PAIT
TYPES OF MAS ENGAGEMENT NSPTIG
NATURE OF THE PROBLEM CPO
AREAS OF MS PRACTICE MIIAT
TYPES OF CONSULTANCY WORK BIIMBO
OTHER CONSULTANCY WORK MMDPNDES
TYPES OF CLIENTS SERVED CIPUIU
GROUPS OF CLIENTS THAT CPAS CAN PROVIDE MAS PGNPO
OUTPUT OF A CONSULTING EXERCISE FISING
PROFESSIONAL ATTRIBUTES OF MANAGEMENT CONSULTANTS TIC
INTERPERSONAL SKILLS IIOUJCAPPRPA
CONSULTING PROCESS SKILLS PISPI
COMMON BARRIERS TO EFFECTIVE COMMUNICATION KIIRI
MAS PRACTICE STANDARDS IOPCP
ETHICAL CONFLICTS CCBPM