You are on page 1of 2

Before Purchasing Magnetic Stirrer, We need to look other aspects .

The Purpose of magnetic Stirrer for us is mixing as well as aeration in Lab Trials. The Considerations on other equipments is listed below. 1. Magnetic Stirrer : Of course, it will be good ahead of all mixing equipments, but still owns some hurdles to us. Mainly, Price. The Indian Brands are available at reasonable price but weight/dimension/visual appeals are the issues. Compact sizes with low weight are available with Top-Suppliers at a hefty price. Apart from pricing, few other issues are that it will be too fast in start up. The Shear in culture is likely, due to this. However, speed regulator can help. Settling of sludge in this case is double. Means, due to continuous mixing the solids won t settle down. So, I doubt showing the color reduction, due to suspension of solids. Throwing of magnets towards the sidewalls of the flasks, also other issue. Despite of these, we can consider this, when doing lab trials at Bigger Companies. 2. Aqarium pump / fish tank aerator: This method is better than periodic shaking. To agitate the water, you can simple place an air stone inside the tank to send air bubbles to the top. The bubbles from airstone simply provide a current in the water. The actual oxygen is absorbed from the surface of the water as it moves across the top of the tank and not from the bubbles themselves. Briefly, it produces agitation of the sample which breaks up the surface tension of the water, allows for oxygen exchange at air-water interface. When looking the cheap price (few hundred only) & ease of carrying domestically, ideally this can be preferred. Only thing, we should have high capacity aerators for efficient current & oxygen uptake. But, when going to Bigger Companies with superior lab set up, it may look odd there. But, domestically for small or medium size companies this can be preferred. 3. Over Head Stirrer: Stirrer is top-mounted, supported by clamp & has a motorized unit. The Key benefits will be a good mixing, even for high viscous solution and getting a radial flow. But, the setup is time consuming, more space requirement makes it to not to consider, even before looking the pricing.

4. Shakers: Useful for mixing small volumes of liquid, like our case. Laboratory shakers tend to agitate the solutions either in forward & backward motion / orbital motion which creates a vortex effect within the solution. The swirling action achieved with an orbital shaker is perfect for gentle mixing or aeration. Even though Handy Shakers available in markets compare to price& weight with magnetic stirrer, it is ruled out. 5. Spinner Flasks/Stirrer Bottles / Baffled Flasks: Specifically designed for efficient mixing in suspension cell culture Like in biological tank, for Lab scale experiments these are preferred .But seeing the cost implication, these are not considered.

Overall, we can consider using Aquarium pumps/Fish tank aerators for Small/Medium Segment Companies. For Heavy Segment Companies, We can Consider Multipoint magnetic stirrer.

You might also like