Case Report

Team Name: Lgs Opf Team L

Head Delegate: Zara Rehan

Contact Information: +92 319 4100406

Crime Scene
Do Not Enter!
Murderers: Chamali (Unintentional) and Dr. Tabbasum Mehmood

Victims cause of Death: Broken Glass Pieces and dangerous Chemicals spilled
on the ground. Another reason could have been a push by someone which
caused Abdul to fall onto the broken glass pieces and chemical.

Timeline Of Murder:

1. Chamali Was Stealing Chemicals

2. Abdul Aziz Caught him and the chemicals were broken somehow
during this process
3. Chemical spread on the floor
4. Abdul Aziz was pushed
5. Abdul Aziz Fell on the broken glass causing a cut on his jugular vein
and chemicals leading to disfiguration of his face and body.

Background Of Murder:
We believe that the murder was unintentionally caused by two people that are
Chamali and Dr. Tabbasum Mehmood.

Chamali who belonged to a poor family got a job of a Space Janitor in a

spaceship at the age of 27, out of necessity. Driven by determination, he worked
his way up through the ranks, steadily advancing within the space crew.

However, at the age of 32, his brother Sarim was diagnosed with brain cancer. His
desperation for funds caused him to try to steal the chemicals from the lab as
advised by his brother, however, during this act he was caught by Abdul Aziz.
Chamali was well raised and thus, was not used to stealing and therefore, when
he was caught might have dropped a beaker containing a harmful chemical on
the ground.

This might have happened because he panicked and was only stealing to afford his
brothers operation.
Abdul Aziz who caught Chamali during this act punished him by dismissing him
from his job and he was not seen after that therefore, he did not directly commit the
murder but the chemicals that he dropped were the cause of murder of Abdul Aziz,
which can be predicted by the broken glass beaker on the ground and also a burnt
paper and some corrosion marks on the floor, showing a chemical outbreak on the
floor.

The corrosive and dangerous chemical seeped its way into the tiles which is
also imminent from the burn marks on the paper and corroded floor tiles.

Chamali was fired because of his actions and the same day another event happened
which led to Abdul Aziz’s death.

Burnt Paper

Broken Beaker\ Flask

After this event Chamali was told to leave the room, but however, was not
fired immediately (as stated by him during the interrogation).

However, we think that he did not further murder Abdul Aziz to hide his act
because even while stealing he panicked and thus, killing someone would not
have been something a hardworking person like him would do.
Although he was desperate, he only wanted money and knew that he could not
murder Abdul Aziz to hide his mistake.
His claim of working in the electrical was not true, since no one would work after
such an incident due to the guilt, pressure and tension on them.

Second Part Leading to the Death Of Abdul Aziz:

After Chamali left the lab we suspect that another person entered the room
while Abdul Aziz was examining the fallen chemical and the beaker.

This person was either Dr. Tabbasum Mehmood or Dr. Shanawaz sharif.

The person was NOT Shanawaz since he had a decent post and said that he had
left his coat in the lab since that is a rule of the chemistry lab (as stated in the
interrogation).
Furthermore, Shanawaz had a very good portfolio and could have gotten a job
elsewhere if he had problem with this specific firm or with Abdul copying his
work.

Furthermore, he was in an age where people tend to become sensible and thus, he
would have never done such a thing. Besides, he mentioned that relations between
him and Abdul had become better before he was killed.

We believe that the person who hammered the last nail into the coffin was Dr.
Tabbasum Mehmood.

She had confessed her feelings for Abdul 3 weeks before his death and did not
receive a favorable response, which thus, later on became a reason for dispute
amongst both of them and led to the death of Abdul Aziz after Chamali left
the room and Abdul Aziz was left alone with Dr. Tabbasum Mehmood.

We believe that Dr. Tabbasum Mehmood entered the lab while Abdul was
examining the fallen chemical.

Tabbasum had a built-up anger for Abdul due to the unfavorable response by him
after her confession and also the fact that Abdul wanted to expose her frauds. This
led to tension in the chemistry lab causing Dr. Tabbasum Mehmood to have a fight
with Abdul. Abdul struggled which can be shown by the messed-up apparatus on
the shelves. Proof Can be seen Below:

Dr Tabbasum pushed Abdul Aziz who then fell onto the shards and the corrosive
chemical.

This theory can also be proved by the fact that Tabbasum’s diary was found on the
slab.

Dr Tabbasum pushed Abdul Aziz causing him to fall on the broken glass
beaker shards, which inflicted a cut on his jugular vein and also on places
marked in the picture below:
Proof Of Glass Shard hitting Aziz’s jugular vein can be seen in this photo in the
following area:

The Following event also shows as to why there weren’t any fingerprints on
the murder object which in this case was the glass shard and the fallen
chemical.
Main Clues that Lead to the following case report:

1. Broken glass shards near dead body

2. Chemical reaction indication by corrosion of tiles and burnt paper
3. Tests showed corrosive chemical that had burnt Abdul’s Body
4. Diary Of Tabbasum on the shelf
5. Some Apparatus and research materials were arranged properly on the
counters, but some of the apparatus was not in the normal manner perhaps
showing a fight took place.
6. Burnt documents indicated an explosion or maybe an exothermic reaction.
Documents belonged to Dr Tabbasum.