Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.first-global.us
India Research
Email: devinam@fglobal.com
Email: sriraghu@fglobal.com
US Sales:
Research Note issued by First Global Securities Ltd., India FG Markets, Inc. is a member of NASD/SIPC and is regulated by the Securities & Exchange Commission (SEC), US First Global (UK) Ltd. is a member of London Stock Exchange and is regulated by Financial Services Authority (FSA), UK
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Table of Contents
Particulars
n The Short Story... n Headlines n Guide to terms & Indices used
Page Nos.
1-2 3-7 8-9 10-11 12-15 12 13-15 16-19
l All these effects will be magnified for the MidCap universe n Conclusions n
Annexure A
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Terrell Biggs, Heavyweight Contender, in pre-fight conference: I have got the strategy to beat Mike Tyson Mike Tyson, Heavyweight Champion of the world: Everybody's got a strategy till they get hit
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
The future is already here: Interest costs have started creeping up (long-term rates are up nearly 200 bp from the bottom), capex cycles are starting in industries like steel & capital goods, earnings growth is slowing. Most important, Free Cash flow for the market aggregate, has already declined even in the YE March 2005 (FY05), as investment in working capital & capex went up. This to Most important, Free Cash flow us is the first red flag. FY06 earnings growth & RoE will for the market aggregate, has already show significant declines. declined even in the YE March 2005
(FY05), as investment in working capital & capex went up. This to us is the first red flag. FY06 earnings growth & RoE will show significant declines.
What concerns us most is the upcoming uptick in capital expenditures by Indian companies. This will be a double whammy hit on free cash and RoCE. Both will contract valuations quite significantly. Save for capital goods companies (a sector we like), increased capex is bad news for the market. Even for interest rates.
All these effects will be magnified for the Midcap universe. Given that large caps are still not very expensive relative to their history; correction is more likely via time (slow drift), rather than a sharp crash. Even so, the Sensex could head down to 7500-8000. MidCaps have a much worse outlook due to greater earnings cyclicality/ volatility & vulnerability to interest costs plus the higher (relative to Balance Sheet size) capital dilutionsnot to mention the way-above average valuation ratios the danger signs there are clear.
What concerns us most is the upcoming uptick in capital expenditures by Indian companies. This will be a double whammy hit on free cash and RoCE. Both will contract valuations quite significantly.
Most importantly, the key sign of bearishness we see is that the markets have become non-discriminating: just look at the demand for mid-cap paper, and crazily priced IPOs. We are seeing mid-caps routinely raising 50-100% of their capital employed in the GDR/FCCB market. Deals are being sold on the specious basis that because valuations MidCaps have a much worse are high, earnings dilutions will be low. Stuff and nonsense. outlook due to greater earnings Markets value high RoCEs. You hit that ratio, your cyclicality/ volatility & vulnerability to valuation gets hit. And stays hit. For a long, long interest costs plus the higher (relative to period of time. There's no escaping that. And we Balance Sheet size) capital fear the mid-caps are headed that way.
dilutionsnot to mention the way-above average valuation ratios the danger signs there are clear
Recommendation: Stick to the Large caps. Avoid, generally speaking, the mid-caps. It's as simple as that. Detailed strategy piece follows shortly.
Page 2
Note: If you're interested in any of the earlier FG reports mentioned in this piece, do email us for copies.
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Headlines
First, the good news
As everyone, from the Finance Minister downwards is fond of pointing out, the market P/E ratios not too highat least for the large caps (see Page no. 13)
l l
Sensex P/E (ttm) is only 23.1% above its 10-year average The P/E for the Manufacturing (Mfg) subset of First Global's own Large Cap & Junior Large Cap Index FG iTotal # is at the decade's average. Of course, the FG iMidcap # P/E is 52.8% over its decade's average, at 18.1x, as against 18.1x and 16.4x multiple for the Sensex and Nifty respectively.
# For details & composition of FG iTotal & FG iMidcap see pages 58 & 60.
Last 2-3 years have seen a benign cycle for the 3 drivers of P/E: Growth, Return on Equity & Cost of Capital (See Page 20)
l
Earnings growth accelerated: The NSE-50 index (Nifty) saw a 3-year Net Profit CAGR (FY02-FY05)# of 37.2%, against a 17.6% 10-year CAGR FG iMidcap Index saw a Net Profit CAGR of 103.3% for FY02-FY05, against a 10-year CAGR of 9.9% RoE jumped: from 13.1% in FY99 to nearly 24.8% for the Nifty in FY05 Cost of Capital fell as the 10-year government bond yields fell from 12.0% in FY98 to 5.4% in FY04(10-year Bond yields are up to around 7.5% now)
l l
# Throughout the report, FY05 stands for the year ending March 2005, or the closest financial year thereto
Page 3
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Most important, all the P/E drivers are taking a turn for the worse
FG iMidcap has had earnings declines in 5 out of the last 10 years. Nifty (excl. banking) has had negative or marginal earnings growth in 3, out of the last 10-years. The recent high growth appears to be a cyclical high. The earnings growth contribution has been the highest from commodity stocks and other cyclicals (contributing 89% of thetotal increase in profits), especially for the Midcap index. Even for FG iTotal , about 7-8 cyclical sectors (steel, oil, petrochem, capital goods etc) contributed over 80% of the earnings growth. Add banking, and the percentage goes to 90%. The FY2000 'high' P/E was because of the worldwide boom in TMT stocks. For manufacturing companies, that high was on cyclically low earnings; with high/ negative (due to losses) P/E for sectors like steel, textiles, commercial vehicles, computer hardware etc. The present 'not so high' P/E is on cyclically high earnings. The Top-10 stocks contributing 67.7% of the Nifty's earnings growth in FY06 have a heavy weighting of commodity cyclicals, like petrochemicals & steel.
Page 4
l l
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Earnings growth was driven by lower interest costs & depreciation which is reversing now (See Page 29)
l
For Nifty (excl. Bkg), PAT compounded at 37.2% for the last 3 years (FY02-FY05), as against a mere 24.0% for EBIDTA. For FG iMidcap, the divergence was even more: EBIDTA compounded at 19.4%PAT at 103.3%! That means that almost the entire Net Profit growth was driven by a decline in interest, depreciation & taxes (mainly lower interest expenses) Another way of looking at it: PAT went from 10% of EBIDTA in FY02 to 38.3% of EBIDTA in FY05 for the FG iMidcap. Thus, in spite of the cyclical tailwind, EBIDTA margins did not move significantly above averagesthe story was really of improved asset utilisation, and even more so, of lowered interest rates. The effect was much more visible in the Midcap stocks, which tend to be more highly leveraged than the large caps.
RoE expansion was driven by increasing Asset turnover & the expansion in the PAT/EBIDTA ratio
(See Page 39)
l
For the FG iMidcap Index, the expansion in PAT/EBIDTA contributed 72.5% of the RoE expansion, with Asset Turnover expansion contributing another 19.9%. The EBIDTA margin expansion contributed a mere 11.5%. Trends were similar for even the Large Cap indices. Now the capex cycle is starting again in capital-intensive industries, like steel. Interest rates have also begun to riseboth will have adverse impact on the return ratios. Add the impact of the huge fund-raisings by companies, especially in the Midcap universeand the RoE picture looks bleaker. Midcap companies have been routinely increasing Capital Employed by 50-100% through dilutionsnever a good idea, as history has shown
Page 5
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
For FG iMidcap Index, cyclical sectors with 46.8% weight in the index contributed more than 100% of the return expansion. The aggregate RoE expanded by 9 percent points from the bottom, whereas sectors like steel, mining etc. contributed 13.8 percent points of the rise. Now with the threat of the commodity cycle reversing (due, in no small part, due to the 'surprise' rally in the US Dollar - in which most commodities are quoted); these sectors are likely to see Returns slip from their highs driving down aggregate return ratios for the Indices
The most important indication: The pressure is already visible on the cashflows (See Page 45)
l
In FY05, Sensex companies showed a decline in Free Cash Flows of 7.8%, in spite of a NOPLAT growth of 46.5% - due to higher Working capital & capital investments. A similar trend was seen for the Nifty companies. (The Aggregates for the broader & Midcap Indices are not available, as not all Annual Reports have been released - but are likely to have worse numbers). In our view, cashflow strains normally precede pressures on the Income Statement.
All P/E drivers are taking a turn for the worse (See Pg 54)
l Earnings growth is likely to decline:
As the uptrend for cyclicals flattens out... or reverses The easy gains from fall in interest expenses disappear, as interest rates creep up
Turnover plus the capital dilutions will drive down Return on Capital/ return on Equity
l
Long-term interest rates are already up over 150 bp from the bottom & we expect to see further increases. Page 6
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
MidCaps have a much worse outlook due to greater earnings cyclicality/ volatility & vulnerability to interest costs plus the higher (relative to Balance Sheet size) capital dilutionsnot to mention the way-above average valuation ratios the danger signs there are clear.
Page 7
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
FG iMidcap Index
FG iMidcap has been used to show the trend of midcaps. FG iMidcap Index largely mirrors the CNX Midcap index, with the important distinction that it is split into the 26 sectoral indices. The composition of FG iMidcap is given in Appendix A. It currently has 150 companies. FG iMidcap (excluding banking) index is the FG iMidcap exclusive of banking companies. Manufacturing Index (FG iMidcap) consists of only manufacturing companies in FG iMidcap Index spanning 20 sectors. Service Index (FG iMidcap) contains only the service companies spanning 6 sectors. Service Index excluding banking index (FG iMidcap) is an extension of service sector index, which eliminates banking companies.
2. Averages referred to in the report, particularly for valuation ratios, are usually those calculated for the last 10-years (FY96-FY05), excluding the FY00 peak; though the averages including the peak values have also been given in the tables. 3. The Price based ratios for prior years are based on average prices for the last month of fiscal year. 4. Valuation ratios are historical, calculated for earnings of the fiscal year. Oct. 2005 valuation ratios are on ttm earnings/revenues, except P/BV, where FY05 book value has been used.
Page 8
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
5. The reason, for giving ratios & trends for various indices excluding banking & finance companies, in certain places, is that otherwise the ratios are somewhat distorted. For example, EBIDTA margins have a different meaning for the banking sector. 6. Everywhere in the report, the term Limited /Ltd. Companies refers to the subset of the Index for which the FY05 Annual Report/ Balance Sheet is available. For the Nifty, it is 49 out of 50 companies. For FG iTotal , it is 138 out of 151for FG iMidcap, it is 129, out of 150 companies. FY05 Annual reports were available for all Sensex companies. 7. All calculations are based on Reported Accounting Earnings, not Proforma/Adjusted earnings, in order to retain consistency. 8. Our data sources are Capitalline, Bloomberg and FG Estimates 9. We have calculated the valuation ratios in the following manner: 10. All ratios have been calculated for the same companies (the current index composition going back in time) rather than the actual index composition as on that date. P/E = Market Capitalisation/ Net Income to common stockholder P/S= Market Capitalisation / Net Revenues P/BV= Market Capitalisation/(Net Worth after excluding Preference Capital and Revaluation Reserve, if any) ROE= Net Income to common stockholder/ Net Worth after excluding Preference Capital and Revaluation Reserve, if any ROCE= [PAT + Interest Expense (1-t)] / Capital Employed (including short term debt)
The sectoral aggregates of these ratios have been computed by aggregating the items for all companies/ stocks in the numerator and denominator. For example, the P/E for the Sensex companies has been calculated by aggregating the Market capitalisation for all the Sensex stocks, and dividing by the Net Profits for all the Sensex stocks. Another possible way of calculating the same would taking a sum of (weight in the Index x P/E of the stock). The reason why this method was not used was due to distortions in historical ratios in years where several companies made losses. A sample calculation for the Sensex shows that there are significant differences in calculations under the 2 methods, though the expansion trend is similar: Calculation of P/E for Sensex companies
Aggregate Mkt Cap/Aggregate Profits Weights x P/E FY04 14.89 20.01 FY05 13.76 20.69 Oct 05 17.88 28.80
The second method would have resulted in higher P/Es, due higher weightage of companies like Infosys, which trade at a higher P/E, as against stocks in old economy sectors, like steel, oil, banks etc.
Page 9
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Note: USD exchange price at 44.61 as on Oct 11, 2005 The last price and market capitalisation are as on Oct 11, 2005
Page 10
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
14000 12000 Marcap (Rs. bn) 10000 8000 6000 4000 2000 0 FY96 FY97 FY98 FY99 FY01 FY02 Years Services (FG itotal) FG itotal excl. Bkg Nifty FY00 FY03 FY04 FY05 Oct05
Page 11
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
First, on P/E basis, the Indian markets currently look high, but certainly not extraordinarily so
P/E (ttm) is about 17.9x for Sensex, against an average of 14.1x for the 10-year period excluding FY00 P/E for Sensex, excluding Banking & Finance companies, is 18.2x, as against average of 14.7x for period excl FY00. For Nifty, the differential is less. Nifty, excl. Banking & Finance, P/E is 16.5x, against 14.4x for period excluding FY00. At first glance, the manufacturing sector P/Es dont appear too high 13.7x for Manufacturing (FG iTotal) against average of 13.7x for the period excluding FY00. The Manufacturing (FG iTotal) P/E grew from 8.3x in FY03 to 13.7x, whereas Nifty (excl bkg.) P/E grew from 10.4x in FY03 to 16.5x, revealing comparable growth rates. FG iTotal (net of Banking & Finance) P/E is 15.2x against average of 14.2x for the period excluding FY00.
Page 12
At first glance, the manufacturing sector P/Es dont appear too high 13.7x for Manufacturing (FG iTotal) against average of 13.7x for the period excluding FY00.
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
large caps
n
Taking a peek at the midcaps, these are now more expensive than the large caps and are trading way above their historical multiples. Last 2 years, P/E for FG iMidcap (excl bkg.) has been above its average of 11.9x... it is currently at an all time high of 18.1x The midcaps, these are now more - 52.8% above its historical average. expensive than the large caps and are trading way above their historical multiples... n The P/Es are 24.6x and 16.6x for the FG iMidcap Service and manufacturing sectors ... Last 2 years, P/E for FG iMidcap (excl respectively against averages of 7.9x and 12.3x. bkg.) has been above its average of 11.9x... it is currently at an all time high of 18.1x 52.8% above its historical average
Oct '05 Sensex Sensex excl. Bkg Nifty Nifty excl. Bkg Mfg (FG iTotal) Services (FG iTotal) Services (excl. Bkg) FG iTotal FG iTotal excl. Bkg 17.9 18.2 16.3 16.5 13.7 21.6 30.9 15.3 15.2 FG iMidcap P/E Mfg (FG iMidcap) Services (FG iMidcap) Services excl Bkg (FG iMidcap) FG iMidcap FG iMidcap excl. Bkg 16.6 24.6 31.0 18.0 18.1
FY03 FY00 9.4 9.9 9.7 10.4 8.3 9.3 17.8 8.5 9.2 24.1 26.5 26.2 29.7 18.2 34.7 78.5 23.5 27.5
Note: FY03 & FY00 have been chosen to approximate the lows & highs in these ratios respectively Page 13
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
36 31 P/E Ratio 26 21 16 11 6 FY96 FY97 FY98 FY99 FY00 FY01 Years FY02 FY03 FY04 FY05 Oct05
Note: Services excl. Bkg (FG iTotal) P/E for FY00 was 78.5x, as India participated in the worldwide tech boom
55 45 P/E Ratio 35 25 15 5 -5 FY96 FY97 FY98 FY99 FY00 FY01 Years FY02 FY03 FY04 FY05 Oct05
Mfg (FG iMidcap) Services excl Bkg (FG iMidcap) FG iMidcap excl. Bkg
Note: Manufacturing (FG iMidcap) P/E for FY02 was 187.8x, due to extraordinarily low aggregate earnings (several sectors like steel, industrial machinery & cement saw significant losses) Page 14
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
During the period that P/E has expanded, lets see what has happened to the drivers of P/E. All three drivers have moved in a direction conducive to P/E expansion, ie earnings growth has accelerated, returns have expanded & cost of capital has reduced. While the details come in a little later, the broad trend is captured in these headline numbers: All three drivers have moved
in a direction conducive to P/E expansion, ie earnings growth has accelerated, returns have expanded & cost of capital has reduced
Earnings growth accelerated: The NSE-50 index (Nifty) saw a 3-year Net Profit CAGR (FY02-FY05) of 37.2%, against a 17.6% 10-year CAGR, Sensex saw a 3-year Net profit CAGR of 30.7%, against a 22.2% 10-year CAGR, FG iMidcap Index saw a CAGR of 103.3% for FY02-FY05, against a 10-year CAGR of 9.9% RoE jumped: from 13.1% in FY99 to nearly 24.8% for the Nifty in FY05... and similar trends were noted in other indices Cost of Capital fell as the 10-year government bond yields fell from 12.0% in FY98 to 5.4% in FY0410-year bond yields are up to 7% plus now.
Page 15
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
The easy sense of comfort vanishes once one goes beyond the P/E into other valuation ratios. On P/BV & P/Sales, markets are much higher than their historical averages
The easy sense of comfort vanishes once one goes beyond the P/ E into other valuation ratios. On P/BV & P/Sales, markets are much higher than their historical averages
Note: FY03 & FY00 have been chosen to approximate the lows & highs in these ratios respectively Page 16
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Thus P/S ratios have broadly doubled (or more) from the bottom for the large cap indices. Though these appear lower than the FY00 peak, thats solely because of TMT companies, which have not reached their FY00 peaks. Sensex P/S is 3.0x, against a low of 1.3x & average (excl. FY00) P/S ratios have broadly of 1.8x. Manufacturing (FG iTotal ) P/S is already at doubled (or more) from the bottom peak levels (excl. FY96 when it was 1.4). This is in for the large cap indices. Though contrast to the P/E for this sub-index, which remains these appear lower than the FY00 around historical averages.
peak, thats solely because of TMT companies, which have not reached their FY00 peaks
In the midcap space, the P/S for FG iMidcap has witnessed a massive growth from FY03, roughly swelling four times from the low of 0.33. The current P/S of 1.3 is also double the average (excl. FY00) of 0.6. It was also backed by Market capitalisation rise of 600% since FY03.
The P/S for FG iMidcap has witnessed a massive growth from FY03, roughly swelling four times from the low of 0.33. The current P/S of 1.3 is also double the average of 0.6
Note: Services excl. Bkg (FG iTotal) P/S for FY00 was 12.5x Page 17
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Note: Services excl. Bkg (FG iMidcap) P/S for FY00 was 7.4x
Note: FY05 and Oct. 2005 ratios are for limited companies whose annual reports are released. Oct '05 P/ BV has also been calculated based on the Book Value as in the FY05 Annual Report as mid-year Balance Sheet numbers are not available.
Page 18 Note: FY03 & FY00 have been chosen to approximate the lows & highs in these ratios respectively Page 18
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
With P/BV at or close to their peak and about doubling from the bottom, even for the large caps; the question is how much of the return expansion and growth story is already in the price. Taking a closer look at midcaps, manufacturing has led the growth story from forefront; its P/BV is more than double compared to the 10 year average.
Note: Services excl. Bkg (FG iTotal) P/BV for FY00 was 11.1x
Mfg (FG iMidcap) Services excl Bkg (FG iMidcap) FG iMidcap excl. Bkg
Page 19
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
The Drivers of the P/E have all moved in an expansionary direction over the last few years
l The Cost of Capital has fallen
n
Cost of capital has fallen at the same time that returns were expanding. The risk-free 10-year bond rate has fallen from around 12.0% in FY98 and FY99 to 11.4% in FY00 and FY01; 6.9% in FY03 to 5.4% in FY04, before rising by a percent point to 6.3% in FY05 and 7.15% presently. Assuming a 7% risk premium, the average cost of equity dropped from 18.4% in FY00 and FY01 to 13.3% in March 05. The interest cost dropping had a two-fold effect one, the cost of capital declined. Two, the Net Profit was boosted due to lower interest costs. The differential between RoE and Cost of Equity went from a negative 2.3% to a positive 10-11% as returns expanded at the same time. That has had an explosive impact on valuations.
Cost of capital has fallen at the same time that returns were expanding. The risk-free 10-year bond rate has fallen from around 12.0% in FY98 and FY99 to 11.4% in FY00 and FY01; 6.9% in FY03 to 5.4% in FY04, before rising by a percent point to 6.3% in FY05 and 7.15% presently.
Average
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
RoE has moved up from a low of 14.0% in FY99 and 15-16% for 3 years thereafter to 19.1% in FY04 (Sensex excl. Banking & Finance). RoE has further moved up to 22.8% for FY05. For Nifty, excl. Banking & Finance, expansion in RoE has been from 13.1% in FY00 to 20.9% in FY04 (24.8% for Ltd. Companies in FY05) For FG iTotal companies (excl Bkg.), RoE touched a bottom of 12.0% in FY99, but has grown to 21.0% in FY04 (22.9% for Ltd. Companies in FY05) For FG iMidcap (excl bkg.), after consistent declines during FY96-02, RoE has expanded from 2.4% in FY02 to 8.5% in FY04 (16.9% for Ltd. Companies in FY05)
For Nifty, excl. Banking & Finance, expansion in RoE has been from 13.1% in FY00 to 20.9% in FY04 For FG iTotal companies (excl Bkg.), RoE touched a bottom of 12.0% in FY99, but has grown to 21.0% in FY04 (22.9% for Ltd. Companies in FY05)
Note: FY05 numbers are only for Limited companies for which FY05 Annual Reports are available Page 21
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
RoE
Mfg (FG iMidcap) Services excl Bkg (FG iMidcap) FG iMidcap excl. Bkg
Note: FY05 numbers are only for Limited companies for which FY05 Annual Reports are available
growth 17.5%) against FG iMidcap (3 year CAGR growth of 16.2%), whereas the earnings growth has seen a steep rise in midcaps (3 year CAGR growth of 103.3%), against FG iTotal earnings growth of 37.5% (3 year CAGR growth).
The major contributor to such extraordinary growth has been declining interest rates, slightly helped by lower depreciation, as a percentage of sales indicating better capacity utilisation.
The major contributor to such extraordinary growth has been declining interest rates, slightly helped by lower depreciation, as a percentage of sales indicating better capacity utilisation.
Page 22
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Page 23
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Note: Manufacturing (FG iMidcap) earnings growth for FY03 was 1288.6%, as it was coming off the extraordinarily low base of FY02, when several cyclical sectors (Steel, Capital Goods etc.) saw losses Page 24
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Growth rate of earning has also accelerated oflate, Manufacturing sectors saw earnings growth of 78.6% in FY03, 26.1% in FY04 and 30.4% in FY05, against FG iTotal (excl Bkg) earnings growth was 59.7%, 24.9% and 30.3% for those years as against Nifty earnings growth was 44.6%, 26.3% and 39.0% for those years.
# The lower 3-year CAGR for this segment is mainly due to banking companies
All looks good. There have been good fundamental underpinnings to the bull run so wheres the dark lining to this silver cloud? Its roots lie in the very good news that we have been celebrating. Remember the equation: P/E = 1-g/r k-g Where g = growth in earnings r = return on incremental equity capital k = cost of equity The drivers here are not one-time or historical values, but what the future trends are. And here, the analysis of the past itself indicates that the seeds of disquiet have already been sown.
Wheres the dark lining to this silver cloud? Its roots lie in the very good news that we have been celebrating
Page 25
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
If one analyses the tables & graphs in the previous section, The interesting thing is that Mfg. (FG iTotal) and even FG iTotal (excl Bkg) have seen earnings declines in 3 out of the previous 10 years. Nifty (excl. Banking & Finance) has seen earnings declines in 2 years and only 3% growth in another year; vs. a CAGR of 37.2% in the last three years. In midcaps (FG iMidcap excl. bkg), the earnings growth The interesting thing is that Mfg. (FG has been negative in 5 of 10 years; only during last 3 years, has growth been seen. The iTotal) and even FG iTotal (excl Bkg) growth has been phenomenal with 103.3% have seen earnings declines in 3 out of the and 270.2% (3 year CAGR growth) in FG previous 10 years. Nifty (excl. Banking & iMidcap and manufacturing (FG Finance) has seen earnings declines in 2 iMidcap) sectors respectively. years and only 3% growth in another year; vs. Thus, there is clearly a cyclical component to the growth. 3 years of very high earnings growth, particularly for manufacturing, means that the current period represents a cyclical high. This is also evident from the improvement in Working Capital ratios, which shows that conditions have lately been conducive for most cyclical industries.
a CAGR of 37.2% in the last three years... ... In midcaps (FG iMidcap excl. bkg), the earnings growth has been negative in 5 of 10 years; only during last 3 years, has growth been seen.
Another way to look at it is that the high P/Es in around FY2000 for manufacturing sectors were on cyclically low earnings unlike now. During FY00 & FY01 that period negative/ high P/E sectors were: Steel, CV, textiles, Pharma, Computer Hardware, FMCG, Food. Therefore P/E was high then around cyclical low in earnings unlike now.
Another way to look at it is that the high P/Es in around FY2000 for manufacturing sectors were on cyclically low earnings unlike now.
Of course, the major reason for the yo-yo days of 2000 was the worldwide Tech boom, in which the Indian TMT stocks participated gleefully. This time round, P/E is high for services sectors: Retail Sector, Construction Sector, Hotel Sector, Telecom Sector, and Banking/Finance Sector. Of course, some of which may be secular stories. Even media & software, while below the peak are still high compared to last 3 years.
Page 26
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
MANUFACTURING SECTORS Steel Sector Oil Sector Petrochemicals Industry Oil Refineries Sector CV & PV Sector Metals Sector Shipping Sector Industrial Machinery Sector Cement Sector Auto Ancillary Sector 2W Sector Fertilizer Sector Chemicals Sector Textile Sector Paints Industry Oil Exploration Computer Hardware Sector Equipment Sector FMCG Sector Pharmaceuticals Sector Power Sector Food Sector Consumer Durable Cyclical Cyclical Cyclical Cyclical Cyclical Cyclical Cyclical Cyclical Cyclical Cyclical Cyclical Cyclical Cyclical Cyclical Cyclical Cyclical Cyclical Cyclical Non-Cyclical Non-Cyclical Non-Cyclical Non-Cyclical Non-Cyclical 141423 88456 53789 27696 26240 26064 16663 16661 10085 5836 4459 4371 2176 1665 1415 649 -1417 -1915 5663 5136 4824 1891
Standalone Aggregates
Industry Nature
Contribution Cumulative Contribution to Cumulative to FG iTotal contribution service(FG contribution profit growth iTotal) growth
8.9% 3.7% 0.5% 0.3% 0.2% 0.2% 0.1% -2.7% 88.7% 11.3% 1.8% 100.0% 90.5% 97.6% 101.3% 101.9% 102.1% 102.4% 102.6% 102.7% 100.0% 78.9% 32.7% 4.8% 2.5% 2.0% 1.7% 0.8% -23.4% 78.9% 111.7% 116.4% 118.9% 120.9% 122.7% 123.4% 100.0%
Banking Sector Software Sector Finance and Investment Sector Construction Sector Hotel Sector Media Sector Retail Sector Telecom Sector Mfg (FG iTotal) Services (FG iTotal) Services (excl. Bkg) FG iTotal FG iTotal excl. Bkg Sensex Sensex excl. Bkg Nifty Nifty excl. Bkg
Considering the increase in profits in FG iTotalTM during FY02-05, the cyclicals have emerged as the clear winners with a contribution of 85.5% to earnings growth. Yet, another way of looking at cyclicals is from viewpoint of manufacturing (FG Page iTotalTM) growth, where they comprise 97.7% of earnings growth.27 The top 7 sectors have contributed a whopping 82.2% of earnings growth, with steel leading the pack at 28.5%. Oil, oil refineries and petrochemicals together form 34.2% of earnings growth, followed by commercial & passenger vehicles, metals and banking (all are cyclicals sectors to varying degrees, including banking, which played a commendable role by contributing 8.9% to earnings growth).
Page 27
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
SERVICE SECTORS
Standalone Aggregates
Industry Nature
PAT Growth Contribution Cumulative Contribution to Cumulative (Rs mn) to FG iMidcap contribution services (FG contribution profit growth iMidcap) growth
1372 821 378 240 -344 -555 57002 1911 883 58913 57885 2.3% 1.4% 0.6% 0.4% -0.6% -0.9% 99.1% 100.5% 101.1% 101.5% 100.9% 100.0% 71.8% 42.9% 19.8% 12.6% -18.0% -29.0% 71.8% 114.7% 134.5% 147.0% 129.0% 100.0%
Banking Sector Retail Sector Construction Sector Hotel Sector Finance & Investment Sector Software Sector Mfg (FG iMidcap) Services (FG iMidcap) Services excl Bkg (FG iMidcap) FG iMidcap FG iMidcap excl. Bkg
Similarly, the profit growth in midcaps has also been led by cyclicals (forming 88.8% of earnings growth, a tad higher than that for the largecaps). The twist in the story was that the Top 7 sectors (accounting for 87.3% of earnings growth) driving the largecaps and the midcaps are completely different, with the exception of steel (steel once again led the pack in midcaps by contributing 47.8% to earnings growth). Mining, industrial machinery, chemicals, fertilizers, auto ancillary and power sectors have come into the limelight (power being the only noncyclical sector). Page 28
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Earnings growth was driven by lower interest & depreciationwhich is reversing now
The lower interest rates have helped not only on the Cost of capital front, but also boosted Net Profit growth through lower interest costs, for both large caps and midcaps. In fact, in spite of the cyclical tailwind, EBIDTA margins did not move significantly above averagesthe story was really of improved asset utilisation and even more so, of lowered interest rates. The effect was much more visible in the midcap stocks, which tend to be more highly leveraged than the large caps. Depreciation and Tax costs, as percentage of sales, have remained at around the same levels. Interest costs have declined over the years. The interest expenses, as percentage of sales, have been 1.7%, 1.0% and 0.8% in FY05 for Sensex (excl Bkg), Nifty (excl Bkg) and FG iTotal (excl Bkg) respectively, against FY02 ratios of 3.2%, 2.8% and 3.1% in Sensex (excl Bkg), Nifty (excl Bkg) and FG iTotal (excl Bkg) respectively. The contrast is even sharper vis--vis the interest expenses in FY97 (see Table below). Clearly declining interest rates have been the major force, driving PAT higher. 3 year CAGR (FY02-FY05) PAT growth has been 30.7%, 37.2% and 37.5% for Sensex (excl Bkg), Nifty (excl Bkg) and FG iTotal (excl Bkg) respectively against at CAGR EBIDTA growth of 23.7%, 24.0% and 21.8% in 3 year CAGR (FY02-FY05) PAT growth has been Sensex (excl Bkg), Nifty (excl Bkg) and 30.7%, 37.2% and 37.5% for Sensex (excl Bkg), Nifty FG iTotal (excl Bkg) respectivelythus (excl Bkg) and FG iTotal (excl Bkg) respectively Net profit growth has compounded at a against at CAGR EBIDTA growth of 23.7%, 24.0% and rate roughly 10 percent points higher than 21.8% in Sensex (excl Bkg), Nifty (excl Bkg) and FG the EBIDTA growth for Nifty & FG iTotal (excl Bkg) respectivelythus Net profit growth iTotal companies has compounded at a rate roughly 10 percent points higher than the EBIDTA growth for Nifty & FG For FG iMidcap, the divergence was iTotal companies... even more: EBIDTA compounded at 19.4%PAT at 103.3%! That means ... For FG iMidcap, the divergence was even more: that the extraordinary compounding of EBIDTA compounded at 19.4%PAT at 103.3%! Net Profits was because of proportionately lower interest, depreciation & tax charges (mainly lower interest costs) Page 29
In spite of the cyclical tailwind, EBIDTA margins did not move significantly above averagesthe story was really of improved asset utilisation and even more so, of lowered interest rates. The effect was much more visible in the midcap stocks, which tend to be more highly leveraged than the large caps.
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
Decline in interest rates has proved more fruitful in midcaps, as from 8.6% of turnover in FY02, interest expenses declined to 4.6% of turnover in FY05. Interest cost decline has led to higher PAT growth - 3 year CAGR PAT growth for FG iMidcap excl bkg was 103.3%, as against 19.4% for EBIDTA.Another way to look at it: Net Profits Decline in interest rates has proved more went up from 10% of EBIDTA in FY02 to fruitful in midcaps, as from 8.6% of turnover in FY02, 38.3% of EBIDTA in FY05 for the FG interest expenses declined to 4.6% of turnover in FY05. Interest cost decline has led to higher PAT growth... iMidcap Index. This has been the single most important component of the Earnings ... Net Profits went up from 10% of EBIDTA in FY02 to Growth & RoE expansion. Basically, the 38.3% of EBIDTA in FY05 for the FG iMidcap Index. positive impact of operating & financial This has been the single most important component of the Earnings Growth & RoE expansion... leverage kicked in, as a cyclical upturn coincided with lowered interest costs.
FG iMidcap (excl bkg) 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 51.2% 39.3% -0.5% 38.0% 33.7% 33.3% 33.7% 9.2% 23.8%
Page 30
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
The margin expansion has all been below the EBIDTA line
The lower interest rates have also helped Net Profit Margins. EBIDTA Margin expansion has been very little, especially beyond the large cap companies represented by the Sensex & Nifty. The FG iMidcap EBIDTA margins remain at 10-year averages. For the FG iMidcap Index, EBIDTA margins are actually below the decade's averages. The entire margin expansion has come below the EBIDTA line.
18.3% 18.3% FG iMidcap 18.6% 40.3% 14.7% 22.2% 18.2% 15.9% 48.9% 18.5% 22.4% 16.2%
Whatever EBIDTA margin expansion is there has also come in manufacturing that too, mainly in cyclical sectors like Steel, Shipping, Autos, Oil exploration. Interestingly, services margins have contracted
Whatever EBIDTA margin expansion is there has also come in manufacturing that too, mainly in cyclical sectors like Steel, Shipping, Autos, Oil exploration. Interestingly, services margins have contracted mainly due to pressure on Infotech and construction companies' margins.
Page 31
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Sensex Sensex excl. Bkg Nifty Nifty excl. Bkg Mfg (FG iTotal) Services (FG iTotal) Services (excl. Bkg) FG iTotal FG iTotal excl. Bkg Mfg (FG iMidcap) Services (FG iMidcap) Services excl Bkg (FG iMidcap) FG iMidcap FG iMidcap excl. Bkg
16.1% 16.6% 13.0% 12.9% 9.8% 13.7% 17.4% 10.4% 10.2% 6.4% 7.9% 7.3% 6.6% 6.5%
14.7% 15.4% 11.6% 11.5% 9.4% 16.0% 15.9% 10.4% 9.8% 3.4% 10.9% 6.9% 4.9% 3.7%
11.5% 12.8% 8.4% 8.7% 6.0% 12.1% 18.6% 7.2% 6.9% 3.7% 8.0% 11.5% 4.5% 4.3%
12.7% 13.6% 10.0% 10.2% 7.4% 13.3% 17.4% 8.4% 8.0% 4.0% 9.7% 11.3% 5.0% 4.6%
PAT margin
Decline in interest rates have been fruitful for midcaps, aiding PAT margin to almost double from the bottom.
Page 32
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
However, whats key is that cyclical sectors have been huge contributors to the RoE expansion. For example, for FG iTotal:
Steel Oil Auto: CVs & PVs Ind. M/C Cement Auto Ancillaries Auto: 2W Metals Shipping Textiles Fertilizers Total (these sectors) Total (All sectors)
3.7% 15.7% 2.5% 7.1% 2.5% 1.7% 2.4% 3.9% 0.8% 0.6% 0.6% 41.4% 100.0%
42.9% 24.1% 21.8% 17.2% 18.2% 28.0% 26.3% 16.9% 22.8% 8.6% 13.1%
58.8% 23.9% 24.3% 19.6% 21.1% 29.0% 23.8% 20.2% 30.4% 7.7% 15.9%
-17.1% 11.6% -4.3% 11.0% 6.6% 13.2% 16.4% 11.2% 7.7% -5.7% 4.1%
8.4% 18.3% 11.7% 14.9% 13.7% 19.7% 23.6% 14.4% 15.7% 4.6% 9.5%
60.0% 12.5% 26.1% 6.3% 11.6% 14.8% 9.9% 5.7% 15.1% 14.3% 8.9%
34.5% 5.8% 10.1% 2.4% 4.5% 8.3% 2.7% 2.5% 7.1% 4.0% 3.5%
2.2% 2.0% 0.6% 0.4% 0.3% 0.2% 0.2% 0.2% 0.1% 0.1% 0.0% 6.5%
1.3% 0.9% 0.2% 0.2% 0.1% 0.1% 0.1% 0.1% 0.1% 0.0% 0.0% 3.1% 4.7%
21.0%
22.9%
12.0%
16.4%
9.1%
4.7%
9.1%
Note: FY05 numbers are only for Limited companies for which FY05 Annual Reports are available
Page 33
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Steel Sector
5.5% 1.8% 1.1% 1.0% 0.6% 0.6% 0.4% 0.3% 0.2% 0.1% 0.0% 0.0% 11.7%
0.9% 0.6% 0.5% 0.2% -0.1% 0.1% -0.1% 0.1% 0.1% 0.0% -0.1% -1.7% 0.6% -0.6%
Industrial Machinary Sector 9.4% 14.4% 19.9% -4.6% 7.8% 19.0% 6.6% Auto Ancillary Sector Computer Hardware Sector Cement Sector Fertilizer Sector Mining Sector Textile Sector Petrochemicals Sector Metals Sector Tyres Sector Equipment Sector Total (these sectors) Total (All sectors) 8.9% 26.5% 24.6% 14.3% 20.4% 12.2% 6.1% 1.3% 26.6% 12.3% -51.7% 8.5% 78.2% 18.1% 4.8% 0.4% 4.9% -13.0% 2.0% 13.4% -1.5% 19.9% 11.6% -1.9% 8.5% 5.5% 1.8%
3.3% 13.6% 14.1% -4.8% 11.6% 18.4% 2.0% 3.6% 18.0% 63.8% 6.4% 5.8% 10.3% 8.8% 4.9%
2.9% 17.3% 15.6% 10.7% 13.8% 6.6% 3.6% 1.3% 21.0% 24.8% 16.7% 20.7% 4.3% 0.3% 1.7% 10.9% 8.3% 8.0% 14.7% 2.9% -3.8%
2.7% -71.2% -8.2% -71.2% -7.7% 0.0% -63.5% 46.8% 100.0% 8.5% 16.9% 2.4% 9.1% 6.1% -0.6%
6.1%
Note: FY05 numbers are only for Limited companies for which FY05 Annual Reports are available
Quite clearly the big gains in returns have come from sectors, which are deeply cyclical from Steel to Oil to Shipping to Capital Goods. While some gains may be somewhat permanent eg. through the export orientation of auto ancillaries, or a permanent improvement in working While some gains may be somewhat capital through better inventory and debtor control.; higher permanent eg. through the export commodity prices & a good demand cycle have been big orientation of auto ancillaries, or a contributors too. permanent improvement in working capital through better inventory and n For FG iMidcap Index, cyclical sectors with 46.8% weight in the index contributed more than 100% of debtor control.; higher commodity prices & a good demand cycle have been big the return expansion. The aggregate RoE expanded contributors too. by 6 percent points from the bottom, whereas sectors like steel, mining etc. contributed 11.7 percent points of the rise. Even for FG iTotal , cyclical sectors with a 41.4% weightage contributed 3.1 percent points, of the 4.7 percent point return For FG iMidcap Index, cyclical expansion. sectors with 46.8% weight in the index contributed more than 100% of the return n Now with the threat of the commodity cycle expansion. The aggregate RoE expanded by reversing (due, in no small part, due to the surprise 6 percent points from the bottom, whereas rally in the US Dollar in which most commodities sectors like steel, mining etc. contributed are quoted); these sectors are likely to see Returns 11.7 percent points of the rise. slip from their highs driving down aggregate return ratios for the Indices
Page 34
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
n
www.first-global.us
Also anecdotal evidence suggests that taking up of slack capacity also contributed to the return expansion. In Cement, for instance, companies are still using up capacities set up 5-7 years ago. For Manufacturing (FG iTotal) Companies Sales/ Net Fixed Assets has gone up from 1.94 in FY98 to 2.9 in FY04. Sensex (excl. Banking & Finance) Fixed Asset Taking up of slack capacity also turnover went up from 1.51x in FY99 to 2.08 in contributed to the return expansion. In FY04. For Nifty (excl. Banking & Finance) Sales/ Cement, for instance, companies are still Fixed Assets went up from 1.7 in FY98 to 2.6 in using up capacities set up 5-7 years ago. FY04. More details on this in our next section. The biggest gainers in this area were also cyclicals Companies Sales/ Net Fixed Assets has Fixed Asset turnover for steel companies in FY05 gone up from 1.94 in FY98 to 2.9 in FY04. was 1.5-2x as against 0.7-0.8x 6-7 years ago. For the Industrial Machinery sector, the ratio has almost tripled. The expansion has to do with stock price escalation, better commodity prices and increased capacity utilisation.
The biggest gainers in this area were also cyclicals Fixed Asset turnover for steel companies in FY05 was 1.5-2x as against 0.70.8x 6-7 years ago. For the Industrial Machinery sector, the ratio has almost tripled
Page 35
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
24%
19% RoCE
14%
9%
4% FY96 FY97 FY98 FY99 FY00 FY01 Years FY02 FY03 FY04 FY05
Note: FY05 numbers are only for Limited companies for which FY05 Annual Reports are available
Note: FY05 numbers are only for Limited companies for which FY05 Annual Reports are available Page 36
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Bearing in mind the 10-year trend in RoCE, last two years have seen steep growth. FY05 witnessed 3.4%, 2.6% and 10.4% ROCE growth in Nifty (excl bkg.), sensex (excl bkg.) and FG iTotal (excl bkg.) respectively. FY05 has seen good bottomline growth, coupled with minute fall in leverage, percolating down to robust RoCE growth.
Sensex Sensex excl. Bkg Nifty Nifty excl. Bkg Mfg (FG iTotal) Services (FG iTotal) Services (excl. Bkg) FG iTotal FG iTotal excl. Bkg
CNX Midcap RoCE Mfg (FG iMidcap) Services (FG iMidcap) Services excl Bkg (FG iMidcap) FG iMidcap FG iMidcap excl. Bkg 8.1% 27.4% 8.5% 12.3% 8.1% 10.4% 22.5% 9.6% 13.0% 10.4% 2.4% -4.9% 1.1% 0.7% 2.3% 1.1% -4.7% 18.7% 0.0% 1.7% 9.9% 5.8% 15.2% 9.0% 10.3% 1.4 0.8 0.4 1.3 1.3 1.2 0.7 0.4 1.1 1.1 -0.2 -0.1 0.0 -0.2 -0.2
Note: For comparative reasons, FY04 numbers have been included only for companies where FY05 Annual reports are available. Parallel to RoE growth, cyclicals have triggered growth in RoCE as well. At the outset sectors like steel, auto and auto ancillaries seem to be the biggest contributors, followed by all other cyclical sectors. In midcap space again, cyclicals are having their say with Mining and computer hardware leading the expansion.
Page 37
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Steel Oil Ind. M/C Auto Ancillaries Metals Auto: CVs & PVs Auto: 2W Fertilizers Textiles Shipping Cement
20.2% 16.9% 14.3% 21.3% 14.0% 18.1% 20.7% 10.8% 7.0% 14.3% 12.7%
0.92% 1.29% 0.33% 0.18% 0.16% 0.40% 0.16% 0.03% 0.04% 0.07% 0.15% 3.71% 6.01%
0.41% 0.54% 0.12% 0.10% 0.09% 0.18% 0.03% 0.01% 0.01% 0.03% 0.06% 1.56% 3.24%
18.3% 13.9% 19.4% 13.6% 6.0% 19.3% 14.6% 5.8% 0.9% 5.9% 6.8% 9.1% 6.0% 10.8% 10.4%
Note: FY05 numbers are only for Limited companies for which FY05 Annual Reports are available
Industrial Machinary Sector Auto Ancillary Sector Textile Sector Cement Sector Steel Sector Mining Sector Fertilizer Sector Equipment Sector Petrochemicals Sector Tyres Sector Metals Sector Computer Hardware Sector
12.2% 16.8% 7.9% 3.1% 5.9% 9.9% 9.8% -16.7% 10.9% 8.6% 14.0% 22.4%
2.4% 10.8% 6.1% 1.4% -4.0% 6.1% 3.6% -16.7% 6.7% 8.6% 12.3% -9.2%
8.5% 13.6% 8.0% 5.1% 3.4% 17.2% 9.6% 1.8% 9.8% 11.7% 14.1% 13.1%
0.91% 0.54% 0.10% 0.08% 0.37% 0.14% 0.21% 0.00% 0.12% 0.00% 0.02% 0.41% 2.90% 1.39%
0.34% 0.28% 0.00% -0.10% 0.09% -0.26% 0.01% -0.50% 0.03% -0.05% 0.00% 0.12% -0.03% -0.80%
Note: FY05 numbers are only for Limited companies for which FY05 Annual Reports are available Page 38
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
What has driven the RoE expansion? PAT/EBIDTA & Asset Turnover
If one looks at the drivers of return ratios:
In this context, if one looks at the following tables, one thing is clear the 2 components driving the return expansion have been Asset Turnover & PAT/EBIDTA. The EBIDTA margin expansion has already tapered off. This means that the two major underlying factors driving the return expansion have been better capacity utilisation (manifested in both higher asset turnover The 2 components driving the return & lower depreciation growth) & lower interest costs. For the Nifty, for instance, the asset Turnover in FY04 & FY05 was 1.34 and 1.56 respectively, against average of 1.18. The PAT/EBIDTA ratio in FY04 & FY05 was 54.5% and 57.6% respectively against average of 47.6%. For the FG iMidcap Index, (excl. banking), the expansion in PAT/EBIDTA contributed 72.5% of the RoE expansion from FY02 to FY05, with Asset Turnover expansion contributing another 19.9%. The EBIDTA margin expansion contributed a mere 11.5%. For the Nifty too, the PAT/EBIDTA & Asset Turnover, in that order, have contributed almost the entire expansion.
Page 39
expansion have been Asset Turnover & PAT/ EBIDTA. The EBIDTA margin expansion has already tapered off. This means that the two major underlying factors driving the return expansion have been better capacity utilisation (manifested in both higher asset turnover & lower depreciation growth) & lower interest costs.
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Table 18: RoE change and change contributors (change over FY02 to FY05)
Sensex, Nifty and FG iTotal Indices Contribution to RoE change (% of total) FG Mfg Services Services iTotal Sensex (FG (FG (excl. FG excl. excl. Nifty iTotal) iTotal) Bkg) iTotal Bkg Sensex Bkg EBIDTA/Sales Sales/Net Assets Services FG Nifty Services excl Bkg iMidcap excl. Mfg (FG (FG (FG FG excl. Bkg iMidcap) iMidcap) iMidcap) iMidcap Bkg 14.3% 16.4% 95.4 % 231.8% -0.1% 11.5% 19.9% Midcap Indices
31.6% -1455.3% 208.6% -18.0% 26.3% -3.5% 26.3% 4.1% 27.5% 52.1% -315.6% 35.7% 43.3% 54.4% 58.4% 77.6% 40.9% 57.4%
EBIDTA/Net Assets 83.7% -1642.5% 244.3% 25.3% 80.6% 54.8% 103.9% 45.0% 84.9%
30.7% 120.5% 108.6% 17.9% -12.0% -18.0% -5.3% -8.5% 9.4% 87.5%
Net Assets/Networth -61.5% 192.8% -102.9% -42.2% -56.1% -42.8% -53.8% -33.9% -45.5% -7.0% PAT/EBIDTA 77.7% 1549.7% -41.4% 116.9% 75.4% 87.9% 49.9% 88.9% 60.6% 76.3%
RoE
100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
RoE change (FY02 - FY05) in percent points (contribution from various components)
FG Mfg Services Services iTotal Sensex (FG (FG (excl. FG excl. excl. iTotal) iTotal) Bkg) iTotal Bkg Sensex Bkg Nifty EBIDTA/Sales Sales/Net Assets 2.6% 41.9% -14.9% -1.5% -5.7% -2.9% -1.4% 2.0% -0.4% 2.3% 0.5% Services FG Nifty Services excl Bkg iMidcap excl. Mfg (FG (FG (FG FG excl. Bkg iMidcap) iMidcap) iMidcap) iMidcap Bkg 2.7% 3.5% -11.3% -10.6% -2.3% 43.2% 0.0% 2.5%
12.0% 24.7%
-5.8%
2.1%
9.4%
7.7%
2.8%
6.9%
11.1% -30.1% -30.1% -24.1% -18.7% -27.7% -24.4% -20.3% 2.4% 16.8% 17.0% 11.7% 8.9% 15.7% 15.1% 34.5%
RoE
10.8%
0.3%
-1.3%
7.8%
9.3%
6.5%
7.0%
-2.9%
-0.5%
11.9% 14.5%
Please note that FY05 figures are not comparable to prior year numbers for FG iTotal & FG iMidcap, as these have been calculated only for companies where FY05 Annual Reports are available (called Limited Companies elsewhere in report)
Page 40
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Page 41
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Page 42
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Page 43
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Page 44
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
comes through in its cashflows, rather than a bland analysis of the Income Statement. This is also the place where problems and turning points show up, long before they do elsewhere in the financial statements. The same holds for market aggregates. And this is where the strain is already beginning to show.
In FY05, Sensex (excl. Banking) companies showed a decline in Free CashFlows of 7.8%, in spite of a NOPLAT growth of 46.5% - due to higher Working capital & capital investments. A similar trend was seen for the Nifty companies. Thus the peaking of the Asset Turnover cycle is clearly over working capital investments bottomed out in FY04, and are now creeping
upcapacity slack has also been used up & investments are picking up. The FY05 Aggregates for the Midcap Indices are not available, as not all Annual Reports have been released but are likely to have worse numbers.
In FY05, Sensex (excl. Banking) companies showed a decline in Free CashFlows of 7.8%, in spite of a NOPLAT growth of 46.5% - due to higher Working capital & capital investments. A similar trend was seen for the Nifty companies.
Page 45
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
After expanding every year from FY02, the FCF from operations declined in FY05 with higher capex (YoY growth of 33.7%) & higher investment in Working Capital (shift from decrease in working capital in FY04, followed by an After expanding every year from FY02, increase). This was in spite of a Net Operating the FCF from operations declined in FY05 Profit less Adjusted Taxes (NOPLAT) growth with higher capex (YoY growth of 33.7%) & of 46.5% This indicates that the easier gains are already in. Asset turnover is likely to decline from hereon. The Working Capital increase showed up in Capital-intensive sectors like Oil, Steel and Capital goods.
higher investment in Working Capital (shift from decrease in working capital in FY04, followed by an increase). This was in spite of a Net Operating Profit less Adjusted Taxes (NOPLAT) growth of 46.5%
Page 46
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Operating profit has grown at 3 year CAGR of 27.7% against 23.9% for NOPLAT, indicating a higher growth in operating profit (due to increase in tax and tax provisions). There was a swing in trend with a higher NOPLAT growth in FY05 (53.1% growth in NOPLAT against 39.0% in operating profit) Increase in working capital as percentage of operating profit has grown in FY05 to 18.3%, against average of 12-13% during FY02-FY03. Capex has risen by 27.1% in FY05, but is still below the FY02 peak.
Page 47
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Cyclicals have seen high inflows into capex (37.1% of operating profit), but this is lower than the FY02 peak. Increase in working capital and capex expenditure have led to lower operating cash flow and lower free cash flow in FY05. (Free cash flow declining for the first time after FY00). However, trends may be modified as the balance Annual reports come in.
Page 48
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Unlike cyclicals there is no divergence among operating profit and NOPLAT, the tax and tax provisions FY04 witnessed a decrease in working capital, followed by an increase in FY05. Overall, cashflows have begun to decline in FY05, due to higher investment in Fixed Assets & Working Capital. Operating cash flows and free cash flows has been at historical lows, standing at 104.9% and 98.3% as percentage of operating profit.
-89.7% 1988.8%
Page 49
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
The trend of growth in NOPLAT and operating profit reveals that NOPLAT has risen at a higher rate. This shows tax and tax provisions coming into play. The increase in working capital and capex in FY05 over FY04 has led to lower free cash flow from operations. (Free cash flow, as percentage of operating profit, was 57.8% in FY05 against 68.1% in FY02)
Page 50
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
The divergence between operating profit and NOPLAT is more underlined than largecaps, with tax and tax provisions growing more than proportionately. The capex plans in value terms for FY05 are more than that of FY02, FY05 capex plans stood at 47.5% Higher capex and working capital expenditure resulted in lower operating and free cash flows in FY05 (Free cash flow as percentage of operating profit is 50.7% which has been the lowest excluding FY97-98)
n n
Page 51
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Manufacturing especially cyclical sectors have witnessed a major change in tax and tax provisions crystallising into discrepancies between operating profit and NOPLAT Increase in working capital has resulted in lower operating cash flow, standing at a historical low of 86.3% as percentage of operating profit. More outflows into capex has dictated lower free cash flows.
Page 52
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Similar to services sector in FG iTotal, there has been no divergence between operating profit and NOPLAT. The ratio of NOPLAT to operating profit has been the same roughly around 130.0% throughout the stint. FY05 saw an increase in working capital and increase in Capex leading to decrease in free cash flow.
-99.0% 2531.9% 85844 12.3% 13536 47.6% 6746 1067 77988 18.4% 89835 4.6% 10060 -25.7% 6606 12 86368 10.7%
Page 53
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Now for the future trends in Earnings growth (g), Return on Incremental Net Worth (r) & Cost of Equity (k)
Of course, all these values are supposed to be not one-time, but sustainable values.
As the uptrend for cyclicals reverses, or even flattens out, the cyclical part of the earnings growth will disappear.
Net Profit growth for the Nifty is slowing down from 26.3% and 39.1% in FY04 and FY05 respectively to 13.5% in FY06, as per consensus estimates. However, these consensus estimates dont take into account the losses likely in oil marketing companies. Factor these in and growth rates slip to single digits. Net Profit growth for the Nifty is slowing The contribution in profits is also skewed towards a few stocks out of which about half are cyclicals, in areas like petrochemicals, steel etc. The Top10 stocks are expected to contribute 68% of Nifty's profit growth. Of these, only cyclicals like Oil, Petrochemicals & Steel contribute about half. Add banking, and just 6 stocks
The easy gains from fall in interest expenses disappear, as interest rates creep up
down from 26.3% and 39.1% in FY04 and FY05 respectively to 13.5% in FY06, as per consensus estimates. However, these consensus estimates dont take into account the losses likely in oil marketing companies. Factor these in and growth rates slip to single digits.
Page 54
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
from cyclical sectors will contribute about half of the total profit growth for the NSE-50 (Nifty). The secular growth stories like Infosys & TCS have a much lower contribution to profits. All these points towards threat to earnings growth in the coming years. Just 6 stocks from cyclical sectors
will contribute about half of the total profit growth for the NSE-50 (Nifty). The secular growth stories like Infosys & TCS have a much lower contribution to profits. All these points towards threat to earnings growth in the coming years.
The same reasons that will drive down earnings growth plus the peaking of the improvement in asset Turnover plus the capital dilutions will drive down Return on Capital/ Return on Equity. Now the capex cycle is starting again in capital-intensive industries, like steel. Interest rates have also begun to riseboth will have adverse impact on the return ratios.
Page 55
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
n
www.first-global.us
Add the impact of the huge fund-raisings by companies, especially in the Midcap universeand the RoE picture looks bleaker. Midcap companies have been routinely increasing Capital Employed by 50-100% through dilutionsnever a good idea, as history has shown. We expect the RoE trends to dip southwards FY06 onwards. Add the impact of the huge fundraisings by companies, especially in the Midcap universeand the RoE picture looks bleaker... ... We expect the RoE trends to dip southwards FY06 onwards.
Long-term risk-free rates have been inching up from 5.4% in March 04 to 6.3% in March 05 to about 7.5% now. With the soaring fiscal deficit, these are likely to rise further if not immediately, then in another 6-8 months. For details of our interest rate view, please refer to First Globals report Where are interest rates headed...and why it should concern you, dated 26th September 2005.
universe
This is the segment with the higher concentration of cyclicals, greater financial leverage and proportionately higher capital dilutions. Therefore, the returns & earnings growth contraction will be more pronounced here.
This is the segment with the higher concentration of cyclicals, greater financial leverage and proportionately higher capital dilutions.
Plus, the Midcaps are also trading far above their historical P/E & P/S ranges, and are now more expensive than the large capsall signs are flashing Red.
The Midcaps are also trading far above their historical P/E & P/S ranges, and are now more expensive than the large capsall signs are flashing Red.
Page 56
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Conclusions
n n
Overweight Large Caps, relative to the Midcaps All the P/E drivers; viz., earnings growth, Return on equity & Cost of capital are taking a turn for the worse, making P/E expansion very tough. However, given that large caps are still not very expensive relative to their history; correction is more likely via time (slow drift), rather than a sharp crash. Even so, the sensex could be easily headed towards 7500-8000. MidCaps have a much worse outlook due to greater earnings cyclicality/ volatility & vulnerability to interest costs plus the higher (relative to Balance Sheet size) capital dilutionsnot to mention the way-above average valuation ratios the danger signs there are clear. As for the sectoral views & weighting, await our forthcoming piece.
MidCaps have a much worse outlook due to greater earnings cyclicality/ volatility & vulnerability to interest costs plus the higher (relative to Balance Sheet size) capital dilutionsnot to mention the wayabove average valuation ratios the danger signs there are clear.
Page 57
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Annexure A
FG iTotal Composition
FG iTotal Index MANUFACTURING SECTORS Fertilizer Sector Power Sector Metals Sector RCF Tata Power Co. Hindalco Inds. Monsanto India CESC Natl. Aluminium GNFC Reliance Energy Neyveli Lignite Natl. Fertilizer NTPC Hind.Zinc Hind.Copper Industrial Machinary Sector Equipment Sector Shipping Sector Larsen & Toubro GTL Ship. Corp. (I) BHEL Himachal Futuris GE Shipping Co Sterlite Inds. Finolex Cables Essar Shipping Bharat Electron Sterlite Optical Varun Ship. Co. Siemens ABB Cummins India Engineers India Alfa Laval (I) Bharat EarthMove Jindal Saw 2W Sector Auto Ancillary Sector Oil Sector Bajaj Auto MICO ONGC Hero Honda Motor Bharat Forge Indian Oil LML Sundaram Clayton Essar Oil Kinetic Motor Co Sundram Fasten. TVS Motor Co. SKF India Motherson Sumi Steel Sector TISCO Essar Steel SAIL Jindal Steel CV & PV Sector Tata Motors Maruti Udyog M&M Ashok Leyland
Page 58
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
Oil Refineries Sector BPCL HPCL Mangalore Ref. Kochi Refineries
www.first-global.us
Petrochemicals Industry Chemicals SectorPharmaceuticals Sector Reliance Inds. Tata Chemicals Ranbaxy Labs. IPCL ICI (India) Sun Pharma. Shasun Chemicals Cipla Dr Reddy's Labs. Glaxosmithkline Nicholas Piramal Lupin Matrix Labs. Novartis India Pfizer Aurobindo Pharma Wyeth Wockhardt Cadila Health Computer Hardware SectorPaints Industry Textile Sector Consumer Durable HCL Infosystems Asian Paints Arvind Mills Videocon Intl. Moser Baer (I) Goodlass Nerolac Raymond MIRC Electronics Tata Infotech Berger Paints Bombay Dyeing BPL Himatsing. Seide Nahar Spinning Indo Rama Text. FMCG Sector Food Sector Cement Sector GAS Sector ITC Nestle India Grasim Inds. GAIL (India) Hind. Lever Tata Tea Guj. Ambuja Cem Dabur India Britannia Inds. ACC Nirma Madras Cement Colgate Palmoliv Marico
Retail Sector Titan Inds. Trent Pantaloon Retail Banking Sector St Bk of India ICICI Bank HDFC Bank Bank of Baroda UTI Bank Bank of India Oriental Bank Corporation Bank J & K Bank ING Vysya Bank Pun. Natl. Bank
FG iTotal Index SERVICE SECTORS Construction Sector Hotel Sector Gammon India Indian Hotels Hind.Construct. EIH IVRCL Infrastruc Hotel Leela Ven. Nag. Constructn. Finance and Investment Sector Media Sector HDFC Zee Telefilms IDBI TV 18 India Reliance Capital Balaji Telefilms LIC Housing Fin
Telecom Sector Bharti Tele-Vent MTNL VSNL Software Sector Infosys Tech. Wipro Satyam Computer CMC Tata Elxsi SSI Pentamedia Graph Flextronics Polaris Software HCL Technologies TCS
Page 59
Page 59
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
FG iMidcap Composition
FG iMidcap MANUFACTURING SECTORS Power Sector Mining Sector CESC Sesa Goa Guj. Inds. Power Guj. Mineral Dev
Fertilizer Sector Chambal Fert. GSFC Nag. Fert & Chem Coromandel Fert. Deepak Fert. Indo Gulf Fert. Godavari Fert. Steel Sector Essar Steel Ispat Inds. Bhushan Steel Jindal Stainless Mah. Seamless Uttam Galva
Industrial Machinary Sector Bharat EarthMove Crompton Greaves Thermax Lak. Mach. Works Honeywell Auto HEG BOC India KSB Pumps Elgi Equipment Auto Ancillary Sector Sundram Fasten. Amtek Auto Exide Inds. Motherson Sumi SKF India Rico Auto Inds Automotive Axles PRICOL Wheels India India Nipp.Elec. Omax Autos Munjal Showa Ucal Fuel Sys. Rane Engine Val. Fag Bearings
Oil Exploration Sector Aban Loyd Chiles Hind.Oil Explor. S E Asia Marine
Chemicals Sector Pidilite Inds. Guj. Alkalies BASF India Godrej Indus. Aarti Inds. Clariant (India) Colour-Chem Rallis India Hind.Organ.Chem. GHCL Hikal
Page 60
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
Computer Hardware Sector CMC Tata Elxsi Zensar Technolgs Paints Sector Goodlass Nerolac Berger Paints ICI (India)
Petrochemicals Sector Pharamceuticals Sector Jubilant Organ. Glenmark Pharma Finolex Inds Torrent Pharma. T N Petro Prod. Orchid Chemicals Ipca Labs. FDC Alembic Merck Unichem Labs. J B Chem & Pharm Morepen Labs. Strides Arcolab Textile Sector Sugar Sector Bombay Dyeing Balrampur Chini Mahavir Spinning Bajaj Hindustan SRF Bannari Amman Himatsing. Seide Abhishek Inds. Vardhman Spg. Century Enka Nahar Spinning Garden Silk Mill Nahar Exports Alok Inds.
Plastic Sector Supreme Inds. Sintex Inds. Jain Irrigation Polyplex Corpn
Cement Sector Birla Corp. Shree Cement India Cements Dalmia Cement Ramco Inds. Everest Inds. Prism Cement
FG iMidcap SERVICE SECTORS Construction Sector Gammon India Hind.Construct. ITD Cem IVRCL Infrastruc Hotel Sector Asian Hotels Oriental Hotels Retail Sector Pantaloon Retail Titan Inds. Trent Banking Sector Allahabad Bank IndusInd Bank Federal Bank Karnataka Bank Karur Vysya Bank Dena Bank Bank of Rajasth. Bank of Punjab South Ind.Bank City Union Bank Finance & Investment Sector Tata Invest.Corp Sundaram Finance Tata Finance PNB Gilts Software Sector Infotech Enterpr GTL Geometric Soft. Rolta India Mastek Aftek Infosys Sonata Software VisualSoft Tech. Hexaware Page SSI
61
Page 61
FIRST GLOBAL
India Research
www.first-global.us
FG Markets, Inc.
90 John Street, Suite 703, New York, NY 10038
The information and opinions in this report were prepared by First Global. Information contained herein is based on data obtained from recognized statistical services, issuer reports or communications, or other sources, believed to be reliable. However, such information has not been verified by us, and we do not make any representations as to its accuracy or completeness. Any statements nonfactual in nature constitute only current opinions, which are subject to change. First Global does not undertake to advise you of changes in its opinion or information. First Global and others associated with it may make markets or specialize in, have positions in and effect transactions in securities of companies mentioned and may also perform or seek to perform investment banking services for those companies. Whilst all reasonable care has been taken to ensure the facts stated and the opinions given are fair, neither First Global (UK) Limited nor FG Markets, Inc. nor any of their affiliates shall be in any way responsible for its contents, nor do they accept any liability for any loss or damage (including without limitation loss of profit) which may arise directly or indirectly from use of or reliance on such information. First Global (or one of its affiliates or subsidiaries) or their officers, directors, analysts, employees, agents, independent contractors, or consultants may have positions in securities or commodities referred to herein and may, as principal or agent, buy and sell such securities or commodities. An employee, analyst, officer, agent, independent contractor, a director, or a consultant of First Global, its affiliates, or its subsidiaries may serve as a director for companies mentioned in this report. First Global and its affiliates may, to the extent permitted under applicable law, have acted upon or used the information prior to or immediately following its publication, provided that we could not reasonably expect any such action to have a material effect on the price. This memorandum is based on information available to the public. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. This memorandum is not an offer to buy or sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy or sell the securities mentioned. The investments discussed or recommended in this report may not be suitable for all investors. Investors must make their own investment decisions based on their specific investment objectives and financial position and using such independent advisors as they believe necessary. Where an investment is denominated in a currency other than the investor's currency, changes in rates of exchange may have an adverse effect on the value, price of, or income derived from the investment. There may be instances when fundamental, technical, and quantitative opinions may not be in concert. Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance. Income from investments may fluctuate. The price or value of the investments to which this report relates, either directly or indirectly, may fall or rise against the interest of investors. There are risks inherent in international investments, which may make such investments unsuitable for certain clients. These include, for example, economic, political, currency exchange rate fluctuations, and limited availability of information on international securities. The value of investments and the income from them may vary and you may realize less than the sum invested. Part of the capital invested may be used to pay that income. In the case of higher volatility investments, these may be subject to sudden and large falls in value and you may realize a large loss equal to the amount invested. Some investments are not readily realizable and investors may have difficulty in selling or realizing the investment or obtaining reliable information on the value or risks associated with the investment. Where a security is denominated in a currency other than sterling (for UK investors) or dollar (for US investors), changes in exchange rates may have an adverse effect on the value of the security and the income thereon. The tax treatment of some of the investments mentioned above may change with future legislation. The investment or investment service may not be suitable for all recipients of this publication and any doubts regarding this should be addressed to your broker. While First Global has prepared this report, First Global (UK) Ltd. and FG Markets, Inc. is distributing the report in the UK & US and accept responsibility for its contents. Any person receiving this report and wishing to effect transactions in any security discussed herein should do so only with a representative of First Global (UK) Ltd. or FG Markets, Inc. First Global (UK) Limited is regulated by FSA and is a Member firm of the London Stock Exchange. FG Markets, Inc. is regulated by SEC and is a member of National Association of Security Dealers (NASD) and Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC). FG Markets, Inc., its affiliates, and its subsidiaries make no representation that the companies which issue securities which are the subject of their research reports are in compliance with certain informational reporting requirements imposed by the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Sales of securities covered by this report may be made only in those jurisdictions where the security is qualified for sale. Additional information on recommended securities is available on request. This report may not be resold or redistributed without the prior written consent of First Global.
Page 62