CHANGING TRADITIONS OF ECONOMIC PATTERNS RELATING TO THE
BUDDHIST NATIONALISM IN SRI LANKA FROM 19th CENTURY TO THE NEW MILLENNIUM. Jayaneththi, Ramesha, Department of History, University of Peradeniya, rameshadul@gmail.com, 0718720379
Introduction
Economy and Nationalism are fundamental factors in national states since the political stability is always depended on economic condition of the state. Therefore nationalism in new and developing state is a complex problem of increasing concern to both political scientists and economists. To the political scientists, nationalism appears on the one hand as an interrogative ideological force facilitating the establishment of a viable and cohesive nation-state: on the other hand, ethnic groupings, especially with considering geographical, linguistic and religious differences, generate the phenomenon of nationalism within the state. 1 To accelerate development processes, economic planning and policy buildings as well as industrialization, the government and ruling class have normally used economic nationalism. Economic nationalism is a term used to describe policies which emphasize domestic control of the economy, labour and capital formation. In colonial era, many anti-colonial movements used economic nationalistic ideas to develop the national economy. Therefore economic nationalistic ideas were widely spread in colonies parallel to their political and constitutional reforms demanding.
In Sri Lankan situation, anti-colonial activities against to British rules were consists with economic nationalistic ideas in combination with the Buddhist revival movements. Economy and Religion is a joined theme in every society either ancient or modern. In Sri Lanka, Buddhism has always combined with the State power, economic factors and dynamic social features. In the British period the economy and revival Buddhism was together with these economic nationalism ideas. After the Independence as national state, Sri Lankan regimes have practiced National
1 Harry G. Jonson 1968. A theoretical Model of Economic Nationalism in new and developing states in Harry G. Jonson (ed) Economic Nationalism in Old and New States, London, George Allen and Unwin Ltd., p.1.
2
economy to develop their economic policies. Especially after the 1956 regime change, the philosophical aspects and national aspects of Sinhala Buddhist community widely effected to the contemporary policy makers which belongs to democratic. In this paper, there is an attempt to examine about the combination of Buddhist nationalist ideas and national economy of Sri Lanka during the British period and post Independent era until the new millennium.
Methods
Main methodology of this research is the identification and analysis of historical sources. Data which belongs to Primary and Secondary sources were categorized and analyzed considering current theoretical and historical discourse. Especially data has been collected from Sri Lankan National Archives, libraries in University of Peradeniya and other places and web sites. Then the facts are discussed comparing with dynamic patterns of Buddhist economic nationalistic ideas of Sri Lanka.
Results
The British Period Post Independent Sri Lanka
Economic Nationalism and National State Building Processes (1796 - 2000)
Buddhist Nationalism and Phases of the Buddhist Revival Movement
Activators and Social Backgrounds Current Political Processes
Influences from Nationalist Ideas of Other National States Changes of the Ideological Factors in Politics and the Society Emerged Dynamic Patterns in Economic Policy Makings
3
Discussion
In the British period, the plantation era transformed the island's economy. The sharp economic changes in Sri Lankan society caused to emerge various social levels and groups. In Sinhalese society there was a highlighted capital class and middle class. The features of this class were configured by many economic and social factors. After 1833 the expansion of commercial plantations created a legion of new trades and occupations such as landowners, planters, transport agents, contractors and businessmen. Many Sinhalese converted their economic capitals with engaging these minor activities as well as major activities like plantation sector and rent systems. Therefore, wealth was the popular and more effective thing. Be a wealthy person or belonging to such a family was a crucial thing to earn social capital. Earning social capital mean earning the value of social relations and the role of cooperation and confidence to get collective or economic results. Many Sri Lankan communities who involving economic activities, understood about this value of social capital and they were eager to develop that status, engaging with many social welfare works. Some rich families like Goronise de Soyza family involved with social activities without concerning religious factor. They were Christian, but they help to some Buddhist activities in Moratuwa area.
The religious factor was a very dynamic cause to determine the states of classes. 2 And natives converted to various sects of Christianity to win Colonial masters hearts for earn economic as well as social capital without obstacles. In this situation, the highly Christianization among bourgeoisies and sharp reaction from Buddhist activators was an obvious trend which emerged as a colonial social formation. Many people converted to Christianity and had followed Western living style and education system. Because they had an eager to engage in the British administration system as Mudalirs and other minor officers.
Beside this some Sinhala families associated with new Buddhist revival activity because they wanted to earn social capital and popularity among their petty societies. Petty bourgeoisies
2 Kumari, Jayawardena 2003. Nobodies to Somebody, Social Scientists' Association, Colombo, PP. 170- 177.
4
had a willing to develop their minor status in plantation sector and other economic activities such as trades and revenue. The leaders of this Buddhist revival clearly understood the strength of donations, wealth and the participation of this emerging economic families and small businessmen. This development of merchants capitalist activated and encouraged on ethnic and religious movements which were depend on funds and donations from the petty bourgeoisies. Those families who financed the religious revival were not mainly belonged to national bourgeoisies. National bourgeoisies had many opportunities to expand their independent business activities, rent systems, plantation ownerships and many others. Therefore they gave the priority to achieve the Government friendship without involving other anti-colonial movements. So they did not lead mass struggle for national political achievements or economic achievements like Indian nationalists.
Therefore petty bourgeois and other local level merchant community voluntarily involved to develop Buddhist revival movement. The link between Sinhala merchants and Buddhists leaders were strong from 1860s on ward. This multi activist's economic community in local level was the main financial donators of the Buddhist revival movements. Many low country families which belong to various castes had engaged with Temperance movement and Buddhist revival movement. With these involvements, many leaders of Buddhist revival movement raised their voice about the national economy or economic development of Sinhalese. Especially in this period trade was belong to non-Sinhalese people. The key areas like export- import economy, semi processing industries, wholesale and banking mainly controlled by Europeans and some Indians. Internal trade was dominated by local Muslims and Hindus. Therefore leaders undoubtedly encouraged native trade and other economic activities with advising to Sinhalese to deal with Sinhala (Swedesi) market and goods. Parallel to this social formation there were some obvious development in communication. It was called as the printing culture. Few leaders showed their enthusiastic ideas about this Sinhala Buddhist economic development through the newspapers and other pamphlets. In many writings of Anagarika Darmapala emphasize about necessity of Buddhist Sinhalese economic development for the national economy.
This Swedesi idea was not limited to Sri Lankan economic nationalism. Considering contemporary India, these Swadesi ideas had developed in Indian nationalist ideas with the
5
intervention of Gandi's activities in the era of Indian Nationalistic movement. Swadeshi Movement was a popular strategy for eradicating the British rule and for improving the economic conditions of the country. The concept of Swadeshi, as per Mahatma Gandhi, was to attain self-sufficiency which included employment of unemployed people by encouraging village industries and towards building a non-violent society. Thus, the main policies of the Swadeshi Movement included boycotting all types of British products and the restoration of all domestic products. 3
There were many other factors behind the growth of 'The new spirit in India'. It was widely accepted by everyone that Britain was the cause of the country`s poverty. The Swadeshi movement quickly gathered force in the country. Burning of British cloth in public places demonstrated the people`s determination not to rely on foreign products. The sale of English goods fell drastically, as Bombay Mills worked overtime to meet the demand for Swadeshi textiles. It became a matter of national and personal pride to wear coarse dhotis woven on local handlooms rather than fashionable Manchester cottons. Student volunteers further encouraged people to use Indian products. Popular enthusiasm was sustained by songs written by Rabindranath Tagore and others. Vande Mtaram by Bankim Chandra Chatterjee became the national anthem. Further, the Swadeshi movement gave tremendous inputs to Indian industries. Home grown salt, sugar, matches and other products had started to be manufactured on native soil. On a larger scale, the movement gave a stimulus to Prafulla Chandra Roys Bengal Chemical Works. This action encouraged Jamshedji Tata to open his famous steel plant in Bihar. At the same time, Indian labours took their first real steps towards organization. A series of strikes in Kolkata and other places demonstrated that the working class was growing weary of exploitation. Swadeshi Movement was described by Mahatma Gandhi as the soul of self-rule in the country. Not only India also in Japan, concepts of national economy was emerged with beginning the Meiji period 1868-1911. Sri Lankan economic nationalist ideas were influenced by emerging Japanese nationalism and Anagarika Darmapala paid his attention to Japanese developments. In
Meiji period Japan, nationalist ideology consisted of a blend of native and imported political philosophies, initially developed by the Meiji government to promote national unity and patriotism, first in defense against colonization by European powers, and later in a struggle to attain equality with the Great Powers. During the final days of the Tokugawa shogunate, the perceived threat of foreign encroachment, especially since the arrival of Commodore Matthew Perry and the signing of the Kanagawa Accord led to increased prominence to the development of nationalist ideologies. Some prominent daimyo promoted the concept of fukko (a return to the past), while others promoted osei (the Emperor's supreme authority). The terms were not mutually exclusive, merging into the sonno joi (Revere the Emperor, Expel the Barbarians) concept, which in turn was a major driving force in starting the Meiji Restoration. Government policies also laid the basis of later industrialist empires known as the zaibatsu. 4
With influenced of these countries, in Sri Lanka Anagarika Dharmapala has criticized Sinhalese capital class and he argued Tamils, Muslims and other Asian traders definitely invade native market and therefore Sinhalese should have an willing to develop and spread Sinhala market. Darmapala directly focused Sinhalese merchants backward ideas and attempts to depend on colonial economy. 5 And he clearly advised to develop national industries with empowering youths technical knowledge with using assistance of other developed countries like Japan, America, England, French and Italy. 6 He highly criticized British administration policy which discouraged Sinhalese economic and industrial development. Also he gave warnings about competition of other indigenous business class. 7 These economic nationalism ideas which
4 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meiji_Restoration 5 Guruge, Ananda (ed) 1991. Darmapala Lipi, (The Articles of Darmapala), Ministry of Cultural Affairs & Information, Colombo pp. 17-24. 6 Sinhala Baudyay, 1911-10-14, in Ananda Guruge(ed) 1991. Op.cit, P. 20 7 Sinhala Baudyay, 1909-10-30, in Ananda Guruge (ed) 1991. Op.cit, pp.125-130
7
combined with Buddhist revival movement spread as a new ideological factor among local Buddhist merchants. That influences has clearly appeared on the Independent process. Even after the independence this struggle to establish national economy and Industries in Sri Lanka was not disappeared. With emerging S.W.R.D. Bandaranayake's regime in 1956 these ideas of Sinhala Buddhist national economy had obviously increased. During the state building process the discourse of national economy was being getting important year by year. Especially after the collapse of UNP regimes nearly Independent, unauthorized Sinhala Buddhist activators and ideologists have got the practical power. Bandaranayake started to gather these ideologies before the Independence, with establishing Sinhala Maha Saba in 1935. He made many speeches to spread and lead Sinhala Buddhist nationalist ideas as his political policy. Therefore Sinhala Buddhist communities gathered around his party and they encouraged him to elect in 1956. Five Major Powers or Pancha Maha Balawega was his ideological force. That mean Sanga, Weda, Guru, Govi, Kamkaru or (Bikkhu, Aurvedic doctors, Teachers, Farmers and Labours. Especially United Bikkhus Front influenced the policy making process of Bandaranayake with their Ten Bills (Dasa Panatha). The six one is clearly express about National industries and important of Aurvedic medical sector. 8
After winning the election Bandarnayake introduced his polices as Middle and Neutralize way. Develop public sector was his main economic policy. Since his sudden death practically he couldnt activate this policies but his wife Mrs. Srimao Bandaranayake kept continue theses Sinhala Buddhist policies as well as Socialist ideas with regime of Samagi Peramuna in 1970. The regime of Samagi Peramuna expedited these policies during the short times. Therefore some short comings and consequences were emerged from the general public. Especially until 1977 the government helped native enterprises without considering their ethnicity. This trend was different after the regime changed in 1977. When the emerging Tamil National Movement with L.T.T.E., Buddhist Nationalism was expand with Sinhala Buddhist Ideas. Also Buddhist ideologist communities couldnt motivate much their business community regarding to the economic nationalism ideas, because of the Open Economic system. That caused
to increased business competition among investors without ethnic boundaries. Therefore, the sound of Buddhist economic nationalistic ideas were backward and the ideas about unity among Sinhalese against the terrorist movement and Westernized policy were forwarded. Some scholars such as S. J. Tambiah highly criticized Bikkhus involvement of this political and policy making processes as an ideological force. 9 But analysing this involvement with middle view it can be argued that many Bikkhus did not appreciate extremist way as L.T.T.E. and other Tamil nationalists have done. With Globalization and the Open economic process, Bikkhus tried to convert their Buddhist nationalism ideas which should suitable for current economic and social trends. Considering few Parliament acts it is obvious that some Buddhist societies have this balanced objectivise. By the act no. 62 in 1979, the Darmavijaya Foundation was established with many broad objectives. Encourage economic developments and social developments of Buddhists and appreciate Samm Ajiwa or Good employments. Specially has recommended high productivity and the protection of investments as well as value of the management of the living cost as suitable for the profit. 10
This society-wise nationalistic ideas were gathered by a political party called Jthika Heala Urumaya in new millennium. The Jthika Hela Urumaya was launched in 2004 by the lay-based; secular Sinhala Nationalist political party called Sihala Urumaya.. The party drew some support from the middle class conservatives and the Buddhist youth. It was a significant turning point in monks involvement in ethno-politics in Sri Lanka. 11 The party continues a Sinhala Nationalist posture in its politics and advocates spreading out the L.T.T.E. by force. It wants to maintain Sri Lanka's unitary constitution with meager devolution of power as a solution to the ethnic conflict. Except common social welfare policies, the JHU have shown their interesting about continues Buddhist economic ideologies and activities to protest some Government policies such as Privatization.
9 S. J. Tambiah 1992. Buddhism Betrayed? Religious politics and Violence in Sri Lanka, Chicago, The University press. PP 104-113 10 Sri Lankan Government Act, No. 62, 1979, "The Darmavijaya Foundation" 11 http://bathspa.academia.edu/MahindaDeegalle/Papers/999784/Politics_of_the_Jathika_Hela_Urumaya_Monks_Bu ddhism_and_Ethnicity_in_Contemporary_Sri_Lanka , PP. 83-103
9
Conclusion As a result of these changes, since Independence, many traders and entrepreneurs have conducted their business with global approach and there is not any significant diversity or discriminations depend on ethnicity, as many minorities have argued. Buddhist nationality is only an ideological factor which effected to some regimes. But after the introducing of the Open economy and with the Globalization this religious based economic nationalist ideas were practically despairing. Considering the popularity of these ideas in the Buddhist society, Buddhist business class and merchants still involve to donate and develop the religious based activities to continually collect their social capital. Therefore it can be argued that after introducing the open economy system and the global market, Sri Lankan religious based economic nationalism has changed their mood on practical involvements. The reflection of these ideas is remained in social activities and the ethical system of expending the profit of Buddhist economic class. References 1. Bandara, Navarathne (2007).Brithanya Yatah vijitha ugaye Lankawe jathika Wayaparaya, (In English - The National Movement during British Colonial Era), Fast Pub. Ltd., Colombo. 2. Banduthilake, Malalgoda (1999). S.W.R.D. Bandaranayake, Deepani Publishing Ltd., Nugegoda. 3. Bhagavan, P. (1987). Political Economy of Sri Lanka, Navrang Oriental Booksellers & Publishers, New Delhi. 4. Burnell, Peter (1986). Economic Nationalism in the Third World, Harvester Press, Sussex. 5. Guruge, Ananda W.P. (1991). Darmapala Lipi, (The Articles of Darmapala), Ministry of Cultural Affairs & Information, Colombo.
10
6. Guruge, Ananda W. P. (1991). Return to Righteousness: a collection of speeches, essays and letters of the Anagarika Dharmapala, Ministry of Cultural Affairs & Information, Colombo. 7. Jennings, Ivor (1948). The Economy of Ceylon, O. U. P., Indian Branch. 8. Jayawardena, Kumari (1999). Ethnic and Class conflicts in Sri Lanka : some aspects of Sinhala Buddhist consciousness over the past 100 years , Sanjiva Books, Colombo 7. 9. Jayawardhane, Kumari (2003). Nobodies to Somebodies, Social Scientists' Association, Colombo. 10. Jhonson, H.G. (1968). Economic Nationalism Old and New State, George Allen and Unwin Ltd. 11. Micheael, Robert (1979). Collective Identities, Nationalism and Protest in Modern Sri Lanka, Marga Institute, Colombo. 12. Micheael, Robert (1979). Problems of Collective Identity in a Multi Ethnic Society, Marga Institute,Colombo. 13. Perera, N.M. (1971). The Economy of Ceylon- Trends and Prospects, Ministry of Finance, Colombo. 14. Tambiah, S. J. (1992). Buddhism Betrayed? Religious politics and Violence in Sri Lanka, The University press, Chicago. 15. Thiagarajah, A. (1966). The Economic Development of Ceylon with Special References to Industrialization, Sri Sanmuanatha Press, Jaffna. 16. http://bathspa.academia.edu/MahindaDeegalle/Papers/999784/Politics_of_the_Jathika_H ela_Urumaya_Monks_Buddhism_and_Ethnicity_in_Contemporary_Sri_Lanka