Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PERSPECTIVES ON INFORMATION
TECHNOLOGY AND SOCIETY
Technological Determinism
Social Constructivism
2
Related but Distinct
Technological Social
Determinism Constructivism
Positivism / Subjectivism /
Empiricism Post - Modernism
3
Does society determine technologies, or do
technologies determine society?
4
But Seriously…
6
Examples of Determinism
Lynn White “The history of the use of the horse in
battle is divided into three periods: first,
The invention of the stirrup that of the charioteer; second, that of
the mounted warrior who clings to his
led to Feudalism. steed by pressure of the knees; and
See: White, L. Medieval Technology and third, that of the rider equipped with
Social Change. Oxford: Clarendon stirrups.”
Press, 1962.
7
More Examples of Determinism
The automobile created suburbia.
See: McShane, C. Down the Asphalt Path: The Automobile and the American City. New York,
NY: Columbia University Press. 1995.
8
Consequences of Technological Determinism
9
Critiques of Tech Determinism
“Technologies do no doubt, as Richard Sclove (1995) puts it,
'constitute part of a society's core political infrastructure', just
as do laws regulating behavior and taxation, but I think it's
worth making the point that they are not likely to be any more
predictable in their effects than those.”
12
Understanding the Social Construction of
Technology
13
Main arguments of SCOT
14
Interpretive Flexibility
15
Main arguments of SCOT (continued)
Stabilization
Over time, negotiations lead to
convergence.
Closure
Closure is a social process in which
the technological artifact reaches a
final, consensual form.
16