Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Questions to be answered
What is wage?
What are the types of wages?
What are the theories of wages?
How the wages are determined?
What is minimum wage?
What is the effect of minimum wage?
What is the importance of minimum wage?
How minimum wage effects the Economic welfare of the labour?
What is the role of Union in fixation and raising the minimum wage?
Whether minimum wage has any relation with Economic justice of the labour?
What is the structure of minimum wages in India?
What is the situation in India regarding the enforcement of minimum wage criteria?
Contents
Introduction
Wages
Types of wages
Theories of Wages
Wages determination
Wage differentials
Structure of Minimum Wages
Fixation of Minimum Wages
Issues of Compliance
Enforcement and Implementation of Minimum Wages
Meaning of Wages
Wages are a payment for the services of labour, whether mental or
physical.
Though in ordinary language an office executive, a minister or a
teacher is said to receive a salary; a lawyer or a doctor a fee; and a
skilled or unskilled worker a wage,
yet in economics no such distinctions are made for different services
and
all of them are said to receive a wage.
In other words, wages include fees, commissions and salaries.
It is another thing that some may be receiving more in the form of
real wages and less in terms of money wages and vice versa.
We shall refer to this problem later on.
Types of Wages:
Time wages-
Wages may be paid weekly, fortnightly, or monthly and partly at the end of the year
in the form of bonus.
But the bonus may be a task wage if a work is finished within a specified period or
before that.
Sometimes, time wages are supplemented by wages earned by working extra time.
They are over-time wages.
Piece wages-
Wages are also paid in accordance with the amount of work done, say in a shoe
factory or a tailoring department as per one pair of shoes or pants manufactured.
If the rate per pair of shoes or for pants is Rs 50, a worker will be paid according to
the number of pairs of shoes or pants manufactured.
(ii) Money Wages and Real Wages:
Money wages or nominal wages relate to the amount of
money income received by workers for their services in
production.
Real wages include the various facilities, benefits and
comforts which workers receive in terms of goods and
services for their work.
These are in addition to the money wages of workers.
The Pay and Its Determinants
1.) EMPLOYER ABILITY TO PAY
2.) Productivity
3.) EMPLOYER WILLINGNESS TO PAY
4.) Comparable Wages
5.) Cost of Living
6.) Labor Supplies
Real wages depend upon the following factors-
a. Price Level
b. Money wages
c. Regularity of Work
d. Nature of Work
e. Future Prospects
f. Extra Benefits
g. Trade Expenses
h. Social Prestige
i. Form of Payment
j. Conditions of Work
Real wages depend upon the following factors.
a. Price Level:
The purchasing power of money depends upon the price level. When the price level
rises, the purchasing power of money gets reduced, thus adversely affecting the
real wages of workers. Every increase in the price level reduces the purchasing
power of money. This leads to a fall in the real wages of workers.
b. Money wages:
The size of the pay packet received by the worker is an important determinant of
his real wages. The greater the money wages, the greater will be the real wages,
other things remaining the same.
c. Regularity of Work :
A permanent job, even though it carries a smaller money income, is considered to
be better than a temporary job which may yield high reward in terms of money.
d. Nature of Work:
The nature of work also plays an important role in determining the level of real
wages. Some jobs are pleasant, while others are not.
Similarly, some occupations are enjoyable while others are disagreeable.
All these considerations have to be given weightage in determining real wages.
e. Future Prospects:
An occupation carrying the promise of better prospects of promotion in the future
is considered to be better than the one which does not do so, even though the
money wages offered by the latter may be high.
f. Extra Benefits:
In some occupations, employees receive in addition to their pay, some extra
benefits. For example, the manager of a firm gets in addition to his pay, a well-
furnished bungalow, free medical help etc. Such benefits increase the real wage of
a worker.
g. Trade Expenses:
This refers to the expenses one has to incur in the course of one’s occupation. These expenses are
high in some occupations while in others they may be moderate. These expenses should be deducted
from the money income in order to arrive at the real wage.
h. Social Prestige:
The real wages of employees engaged in prestigious occupations are high as compared to the real
wages of employees working in ordinary occupations.
i. Form of Payment:
Real wages are influenced by the form of payment. Generally, workers are paid money wages. But in
certain occupations, in addition to money wages, workers receive subsidized ration or free lunch, and
living quarters. All these facilities increase the real wages of workers.
j. Conditions of Work:
Conditions of work also affect real wages. In some cases, it is found that conditions of work are not
congenial and they adversely affect their health. In such cases, the real wages of workers are low.
Theories of Wages:
(i) The Subsistence Theory of Wages
(ii) The Standard of Living Theory of Wages
(iii) The Wage Fund Theory
(iv) The Residual Claimant Theory
(v) The Marginal Productivity Theory of Wages
The Modern Theory of Wages
The wage rate, like any price, is determined by the demand for and
supply of labour.
it is a point where the cost of employing labour (the wage rate) equals
the marginal revenue product of the labour to the employer.
For full equilibrium, it is essential that marginal revenue product of
labour should equal its marginal cost (marginal wage) and the average
revenue product be equal to the average cost of labour (average wage).
AW = MW
... and MRP = MW
ARP = AW
... MRP = MW = AW = ARP
Union and Wages – Collective Bargaining
The main function of a trade union is to raise wages and to
improve the working conditions of its members.
It replaces individual bargaining by collective bargaining and
makes the rates of wages uniform for the same category of
workers over the entire industry.
Under perfectly competitive labour market, wages in a
particular industry are fixed by the forces of demand and
supply.
But unions can raise wages in the short-run by reducing the
supply of labour.
This is illustrated in Panels (A) and (B) of Figure 6.
Panel (A) shows the equilibrium wages rate OW being determined by
the equality of demand and supply of labour OE at point a.
in Panel (B), at a given wage rate OW or WS the firm employs Oe units
of this labour.
If the workers employed in this industry form a union, they cannot
affect the demand for labour in the short-run.
They may demand a wage rate above the equilibrium rate OW but it will
tend to reduce the number of workers employed.
Suppose the union asks for OW1 wage rate.
This will tend to make the supply curve of labour perfectly
elastic so that it now becomes W1S1 in place of SS in Panel
(A).
The new equilibrium position is established at n where the
demand curve D intersects the supply curve W1S1 and the
number of workers employed in the industry is reduced
from OE to OE1
The given wage rate for the firm being W1S1 it will also
employ less workers than before, Oe1 < Oe as shown in
Figure 6 (B).
If the union wishes to maintain the increased wage
rate,
it will have to reduce the supply of labour, It may
do so in a variety of ways:
by encouraging the unemployed to seek jobs in
other industries;
by raising the membership fee for new entrants;
by raising the apprenticeship period and
by encouraging restrictions on immigration, etc.
Above all, the reduction in supply will depend upon the
elasticity of demand for labour. If the demand for labour is
quite inelastic, then the reduction in supply would be small.
But this is not likely to be the normal situation in the case of
an industry.
If somehow the union is able to shift the MRP curve (demand
curve for labour) upward to the right, the wage rate would
be raised substantially and the employment would also
expand. But to raise the demand for labour is not an easy job
for the unions. This is possible over the long-run when
technological changes raise the demand for the industry’s
product.
The union can then demand a wage increase, the rise being
negotiated by collective bargaining.
(ii) The demand for the commodity which the group helps to produce is
inelastic; or
(iii) The wage-bill of this group forms a very small proportion of the
total wage-bill of the concern so that a rise in their wages does not
substantially affect the total cost of production of the commodity; and
(iv) lastly, if the other cooperate factors are squeezable, that is, the
wages of the other group of workers are reducible or the raw material
suppliers are forced to accept low prices, etc.
The union will be successful if any of these conditions is
fulfilled. This is only possible in the short-run.
But competition is not perfect and labour is paid much below the
marginal revenue product.
A trade union can raise wages up to the marginal revenue product level
by collective bargaining.
A rise in the wage rate which equals the marginal revenue product of
labour would neither affect employment nor output adversely.
Assuming that the employers are not united a powerful trade union can
force the industry to pay wages equal to the marginal revenue product. In
such a situation, it is difficult to import even the ‘Black-legs’.
In the case of a monopolist buyer of the services of labour, the
workers will be paid less than their marginal revenue product
and even the number of workers employed will be much
smaller than the under perfectly competitive labour market.
But if the union tries to push up the wage rate above OW2 employment will fall.
If the union follows the ‘closed shop’ policy and does not bother about increasing
the level of employment, it can at best raise the wage rate to OW1.
It means that the trade union has a monopoly in the selling of the services of
labour and aims at destroying monopolist exploitation by asking for OW1 wage rate.
Basi V.D. Tot Basi V.D. Tot Basi V.D. Tot Basi V.D. Tot Basi V.D. Tot
c A. al c A. al c A. al c A. al c A. al
Min Mi Min Mi Min Mi Min Mi Min Mi
Wa n Wa n Wa n Wa n Wa n
ge Wa ge Wa ge Wa ge Wa ge Wa
ge ge ge ge ge
B 303 36 339 335 38 343 364 43 407 407 47 454 364 21 385
C 300 36 336 307 36 343 334 38 372 364 43 407 334 19 353
Industrial A 523 61 584
Worker B 437 50 487 0
(employees C 350 40 390 0
employed in
loading and
unloading in
1)goods
sheda,
parcel
offices of
railways; 2)
other
goodssheds,
godowns,
warehouses;
3) docks and
ports
Industrial For 350 40 359 437 50 487 523 61 584 610 71 681
Workers work
employed in above
Gypsum groun
Mines, d
Barytes For 437 50 487 523 61 584 610 71 681 683 78 761
Mines, work
Mauxite below
Mines, groun
Manganese d
Mines, China
Clay Mines,
Kyanite
Mines,
Copper
Mines, Clay
Mines,
Magnesite
Mines,
White Clay
Category Daily Daily VDA Total Daily Minimum Wages
Basic
1. Excavation & removal of over burden with Wage
50 m lead/1.5 meters lift
( In Rupees Per ( In Rupees Per ( In Rupees Per ( In Rupees Per ( In Rupees Per
Day ) Day ) Day ) Day ) Day )
Agricultu A 333 38 371 364 43 407 395 46 441 438 50 488 395 23 418
re
B 303 36 339 335 38 343 364 43 407 407 47 454 364 21 385
Mines,
Mauxite
Mines,
Mangane
se Mines,
China
Clay
Mines,
Kyanite For 437 50 487 523 61 584 610 71 681 683 78 761
Mines, wor
Copper k
Mines, belo
Clay w
Mines, grou
Magnesit nd
e Mines,
White
Clay
Mines,
Stone
Mines,
Steatite
Mines,
Ochre
Mines,
Asbestos
Mines,
Fire Clay
Mines,
Stone Breaking or Stone Crushing for the stone Daily Basic Daily VDA Total Daily Minimum Wages
Chromite
Mines,
Quartzite
Mines,
Quartz
Mines,
Silica
Mines,
Graphite
Mines,
Felspar
Mines,
size Wage
Laterite
Mines,
Dolomite
Mines,
Red Oxide
Mines,
Wolfram
Mines,
Iron Ore
Mines,
Granite
Mines,
Rock
Phosphat
e Mines,
Hematite
Mines,
Marble
and
Calcite
Mines,
Uranium
Mines,
Mica
Mines,
Lignite
Mines,
Gravel
Mines,
Slate
Mines,
Magnetit
e Mine
B 437 50 487
C 350 40 390
C 494 57 551
C 579 66 645
Construct A 523 61 584 579 66 645 637 73 710 639 79 718 637 36 673
ion or