3. DIFFERENT CONTEXTS, DIFFERENT BIG BUSINESSES 4. DIFFERENT SECTORS, DIFFERENT STRATEGIES AND STRUCTURES Characteristics of BB: A.Chandler Jr. 1. US modern multi-unit business replaced small traditional enterprise, when administrative coordination permitted better profits than the coordination by market mechanism; 2. A managerial hierarchy was created for this multi-unit business enterprise; 3. Multi-unit business enterprise appeared for the first time in history in a time when the volume of economic activities reached a level that made administrative coordination more efficient than market coordination; 4. Multi-unit business enterprise grew in size and diversity and as its managers became more professional, the management of the enterprise became separated from its ownership; 5. As the large enterprises grew and dominated major sectors of the economy they altered the basic structure of these sectors and of the economy as a whole.
KEY: SCALE AND SCOPE, MULTIDIVISIONAL STRUCTURE, PROFESSIONAL
HIERARCHY NOT LINKED TO OWNERSHIP, INTERNATIONALIZATION definitions Before 1914, more than 1,000 employeees (Kocka and Horn 1979)
Around 1950s 10,000 employees and share capital of 5
million sterling pounds in Uk, FR, GER (Cassis 1997)
A consequence of previous revolutions in demand
(growth of population and purchasing power) and supply (technological revolutions increasing productivity and lowering production and transportation costs). ORIGINS AND EVOLUTION Preindustrial big companies: not professionally managed?
During first industrial revolution 1830s-18890s: new
Second industrial revolution 1880s-1914: still railroad
companies, but also steel, chemicals, electricity, oil, motor cars, rubber, machinery and consumer durables (food, drink, tobacco). Economies of scale and scope. Sharp differences between countries. Family firms endure or become big corporations. Different contexts, different typologies of BIG BUSINESS 1900s- 1940s USA
GERMANY
JAPAN USA: STATE PROTECTION BUT ALSO
ANTIMONOPOLY LEGISLATION,
CARTEL-FREE POLICIES (EXCEPT 1930S),
FREEMARKET,
PROPERTY RIGHTS PROTECTION,
PATENTS AND BRANDING A VENUE FOR INVESTMENT IN R&D&i,
CONSUMER GOODS FOR BIG DOMESTIC MARKET.
MORE VERTICAL AND HORIZONTAL INTEGRATION IN SPECIFIC
INDUSTRIES AND SERVICES
AND AFTER 1970S INCREASED DIVERSIFICATION
GERMANY:
STATE PROTECTION,
CARTELS,
BANKS,
HEAVY INDUSTRY,
DUMPING IN FOREIGN TRADE,
TECHNICAL EDUCATION ENSHRINED,
KINGDOM OF MITTELSTAND FIRMS
JAPAN:
STATE PROTECTION,
EARLY IMPORTED KNOW HOW FROM LEADERS
NETWORK BASED BIG BUSINESSES:
UNTIL 1945 ZAIBATSU,
AFTER 1950S KEIRETSU (BUSINESS GROUPS WITH STRONG
TRADING COMPANIES AND INDUSTRIAL COMPANIES WITH A MAJOR BANK AND THE STATE TO SUPPORT BOTH).
INITIAL GREAT DIVERSIFICATION
PROGRESSIVELY SPECIALIZATION
LABOUR RELATIONS
STABILITY IN LINKS TO SUPPLIERS
RELUCTANCE TO INWARD FDI
Sectors: different structures and strategies BANKS: NATIONAL PROVINCIAL BANK OF ENGLAND, CREDIT MOBILIER, BANQUE DE PARIS ET DES PAYS BAS, BARING BROTHERS, FIVE ROTHSCHILD HOUSES (London, Paris, Frankfurt, Vienna, Naples), DEUTSCHE BANK, JPMORGAN, BARCLAYS, BANK OF AMERICA, CHASE MANHATTAN BANK
IRON AND STEEL INDUSTRIES: US STEEL, BETHLEHEM STEEL
CAR MANUFACTURING: FORD, GENERAL MOTORS, PEUGEOT, RENAULT, FIAT,
HISPANO-SUIZA, TOYOTA
CHEMICAL INDUSTRIES: IG FARBEN, DUPONT
ENERGY: GENERAL ELECTRIC, STANDARD OIL, WESTINGHOUSE
MACHINERY: HARVESTER, SINGER
FOOD, BEVERAGES, TOBACCO: UNILEVER, UNITED FRUIT COMPANY, IMPERIAL TOBACCO MINERALS: RIOTINTO, ANACONDA, ALCOA, PECHINEY