You are on page 1of 17

The Rule of Law

and the Military


Defense Institute of International Legal Studies
Newport, RI
2 Wherever Law Ends –
Tyranny Begins
John Locke
3
Types of Law

• Moral
• Divine
• Natural
• Positive
4
What is the Rule of Law ?

Government decisions are


rooted in the consent of the governed.
5
What is the Rule of Law ?

Taken through authoritative


institutions or structures designed
to prevent tyranny.
6
What is the Rule of Law ?

Which protect
fundamental human rights
7
What is the Rule of Law ?

Subject to the appraisal


of an independent judiciary.
8 Evolution of the Rule of Law

• Universalist
Empires
• Nation States
• International Law
• International
Organizations
9 Milestones
• United Nations
• War Crimes Tribunals
– Nuremberg
– Tokyo
• Universal Declaration
of Human Rights
• War Crimes Tribunals
– Yugoslavia
– Rwanda
10 Government Institutions

• Legislative
• Executive
• Courts
• Criminal Justice
11
Why Resistance

• Legal Traditions
• Customs
• Development
• Nationalism
• Leaders
12 Military Commander’s
Dilemma

Autonomy Accountability

Efficiency
Standard Procedure
Expediency

Mission Goals Legitimacy

National Goals
13 The Rule of Law in a
Democracy

• Constitution
• Statutes
• Judicial System
• Citizens Are Aware of Their Rights
• Police Who Respect the Rights of Citizens
• Lawyers Who Can Assist Citizens in the
Defense of Their Rights in Court.
• Impartial Judges
14 The Rule of Law in
Post-Conflict Societies
• Unique Challenges caused by
- Social, economic, political turmoil
- Non-democratic rule
- Destructive conflicts

• International community impact on:


- Unique populations
- Resources
- Locations
- Traditions
15 Benefits for a Democracy

• Civilian Control of the


Military

• Liberty Based in Law

• Military Decisions Founded


in Law - Not Personal
Interest
16
Benefits for the Military

• Uniformity in Treatment of the Citizen


Soldiers
• Clear Guidance
• Confidence of Civilian
Government
• Enhanced Military Morale
The Rule of Law
and the Military
Defense Institute of International Legal Studies
Newport, RI

You might also like